Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2025-12-10
Completed:
2026-02-12
Words:
14,186
Chapters:
5/5
Kudos:
108
Hits:
0

Bloodletting (New Orleans)

Chapter 4: IV. Fishing / The Lady of Shallot

Summary:

Will gets an idea.

Notes:

I have so many ideas, and I want to write, but I have had a migraine every other day or so. Have you ever heard of trepanation? You know it's bad when you understand why the ancients drilled holes in their skull. I wonder if some ancient person had a migraine and decided, yup, it's time... no, it wouldn't help with anything, but talk to anyone with migraines, and you'll know we've all had this urge.

 

Shout out to my friend reading this! I just introduced her to his blessed website.

Here is a humorous poem I composed about my migraine:

They say trepanation
Is good for the soul---
Did I say soul?
I mean my skull.

Or maybe the guillotine
would be worth a try,
At least it would
Be fast-acting
and eliminate
the symptoms.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

She loos'd the chain, and down she lay;
The broad stream bore her far away,
    The Lady of Shalott.

From "The Lady of Shallot" by Alfred, Lord Tennyson, Part IV, lines 24-26

IV. Fishing / The Lady of Shallot

It was something like early autumn. It was crisp now but not cold. Nature was creeping towards its yearly death. In the midst of this death, there was beauty, as there always was, as there always had been and would be. Humanity at large gawked at the beauty of these dead things in nature and then refused to accept the accusation of morbidity. It was a fool’s thing to do. 

Some Red Maples had already relented and turned a vibrant scarlet, and they were eye-catching among some of the still verdant and more indecisive trees. 

He didn’t know about this setting intellectually, but he knew it intuitively. He knew enough to exist here without wondering how he came to be here, in the waders he’d had for ages, in this isolated stream he knew so well and that had been so faithful to him, supplying trout in abundance over the years along with respite from the cacophony in his mind.

It just so happened that he was here again when the conditions were perfect for fishing, and he wasn't here alone.

“Did you know they used to tie suspected witches up and throw them in the water. If they sank, they were innocent. If they floated, they were a witch.”

Will was pulled from his reverie by her words. They seemed to come from nowhere and float and bob around his head as his handmade lure did in the water. He didn't remember coming here, and he didn't remember coming here with her in particular. For some reason, he knew this situation wasn't possible. He experienced a potent case of tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon when he tried to recall why this wasn't possible, but he felt relaxed at the moment, comforted by the scenery.

So, he brushed off the uneasiness.

“I have heard of that; they called it something like ‘swimming a witch'. What brings that to mind? The water?”

“I was thinking about how I had an ancestor in the Salem Witch trials—but they didn't drown them there. They hung them.”

“And crushed them, so I've been told.” Will wasn't sure where this conversation was going, but he thought he might as well be an active participant in it. “What was her name?”

He looked at her, but she didn't look back. She looked at the water and at the lure in anticipation of a trout coming along and finding it interesting. She seemed in reverie of her own, for a time, but he didn't repeat his words. It was quiet out here. She'd heard him; she was just taking her time on her answer.

“Abigail Hobbs.”

That did sound vaguely familiar when it came to the information he'd managed to intake on those trials over the years. He couldn't remember ever actively searching for any information about them, but it was the kind of infamous event that pervaded American culture hundreds of years later, so one could not avoid hearing about it. 

He nearly asked her if her father knew that’d been the name of an ancestor of theirs, or if it was a coincidence, but she’d surely heard enough about her father. He’d brought her here to forget that.

Forget that, how? You’re practically teaching her to hunt again. A blasphemous voice in his mind reminded him. Why would she want to be here?

Will settled on saying, “Wow, that’s, uh, quite the trivia.”

He felt like an idiot saying it.

“You’re wondering if my parents knew?”

She could see right through him, couldn’t she? 

She was perceptive. She’d had to be. She’d had to learn how to predict the inner workings of a madman, map out his patterns, and know what actions and words led to what outcomes. She’d learned how to appease him for so long.

But in the end, it was a false belief that appeasing a man like that would sate him. It was like feeding a wild animal. Knowing it will be fed, an animal will continually come back in hopes of food. Eventually, will come back wanting food when you don’t have it, and you will be the food. 

He felt he might as well ask, then, “Did they?”

“Not when they named me. My mom got into making family trees later on. They found out then.”

“That’s quite the coincidence then.”

“Yeah.”

For some reason she just doesn’t sound convinced. She never sounds terribly convinced about anything. Never very enthused. Almost like she doesn’t really want to be here at all. That same voice in his head added. You’re the wild animal now, idiot. Stop kidding yourself.

He distracted himself from these thoughts by simply looking in front of him, where his lure bobbed, waiting for trout to come.

“Hey, Will?” She looked at him now. He had a moment of irrational fear that she could, for some reason, read his thoughts. As if that were a rational thing to be afraid of. “If you had to, which would you rather do: sink or float?”

“Well,” Will thought for a moment, glad to see her be the one to pose a question. 

It was a tough one, too.

At one time in his life, it would have been an easy question. He would have rather drowned, and drowned innocent at that. How terrible could such a death be? But now, he knew what it was like to drown, to be stifled by water cold and deep. Maybe it would be better to burn aboveground, to burn like Joan of Arc, in infamy, than to be concealed by the depths of the ocean, than to have his body eaten by the scavengers of the sea—if his executioners happened to be English, they might hang him, too. If his neck broke it would be a quick death. If it didn’t, he’d dance the dance of the hanged man. He doubted anyone would be nice enough to weigh him down…

“So, I’m tied up and thrown in the water. If I sink, I’m dead; if I float, I’m burnt or hung. That’s a pretty tough decision. Is there any chance that if I float, I can get away from the executioner?"

“Not in this scenario.”

“Is my executioner any good?”

His question was only half serious.

“How am I supposed to know?”

“You were the one who posed the question.”

“Right. Well. Let’s say your executioner is about as good as any at the time.”

“You know what, then, maybe I would be hung,” Will shrugged. He had, at least partially, experienced one of these outcomes, and he’d prefer not to drown again. But hanging—it was so public. He was starting to doubt his answer.

 An intrusive thought then—what he’d nearly done to Hannibal when he was in prison, falsely accused. He’d played the hangman back then, or at least hired the hangman; but Hannibal had escaped that fate—as Hannibal was wont to do, and so did Will. Then there’d been Frederick, who was never one to escape his fate, and who had been burnt literally and figuratively by Will’s own personal vindictive kindling. 

“Do you think drowning would be that terrible?” She paused, backtracking her statement a bit. “I mean, more terrible than burning or hanging?”

Will scoffed at the question. “I don’t think—I know it would be terrible.” 

It was getting awfully chilly outside for it to be early fall. It was, right? How did he know it was? 

It was probably just the wind picking up. It was why goosebumps were rising on his skin.

“Are you cold, Abigail?”

“Now that you mention it…” She nodded. It was a yes, essentially. 

“Alright, then, uh,” He looked at his line. Nothing promising, yet. In fact, now that he thought about it, the stream seemed unnaturally devoid of fish, of wildlife in general. Certainly, there were some bugs present, there were midges and mayflies aplenty, but that was it. He couldn't recall having yet heard a bird chirping or an animal skittering through the woods.

How long had they been out here? It had been some time, surely. 

He looked behind him at the general direction of where he had parked. His car had seemed only a short distance away when he’d parked, but now the stream seemed like a great gulf from here to here. 

Maybe this was all futile.

Will sighed and began to reel his line back in.

“We can be done for the day, if you want.”

“Yeah, that’s not a bad idea.”

It shouldn’t be getting colder out. I know it can’t be past noon. 

He knew it couldn’t be a storm coming. No leaves turned over on the trees. The sky was clear but for a few cumulus clouds that floated above. Even with the clouds the sky appeared a screen, a canvas, blank and wanting. 

He didn’t think he ever would have thought of the sky as a canvas until…until he met Hannibal.

His feet were cold. He could feel his socks soaking the water up, slushing around in the boots he wore inside his waders. His waders…He was wearing them and so how could his feet be wet? Where was his mind today? 

Even so, his feet were wet. Not damp, but sickeningly, gangrene-level wet. 

The water was rising. It was rising rapidly, and for what reason he didn’t know. He began to feel as if he were on a foreign planet. There was the assumption inside of him that he knew this setting like the back of his hand, and still it kept surprising him. Maybe he had been fooled. Maybe he didn’t know anything at all. 

He looked at Abigail. The water was up to her waist now.

“I don’t know what’s going on, but I think we need to go now.”

He meant that as in right this instant, but she didn’t seem to understand. She was back in a reverie. She was locking eyes with a ghost, with the still air in front of her. Will was afraid that if he looked too long at where she pointed her gaze, he would also see what she was seeing. He didn’t want to.

The water was chest level.

“Come on.”

He took hold of her wrist, knowing no other way to get her to move besides picking her up. She felt full of lead, head to toe.

“Something else about my ancestor—”

“This isn’t the time. You can tell me on the way home.”

He couldn’t move her. How was it that he couldn’t move her?

“She was innocent—they all were, of course, but she survived by accusing others. You know, they’d only kill you if you wouldn’t admit you were a witch.”

The water was on her chin now. She seemed unbothered by it.

She didn’t want to be here in the first place, so why won’t she move? 

Just before she went under, he attempted to lean down and lift her, but no, she was still dead weight. His vision was blurred as he went under, or, rather, the water went over, and he saw her blurred image—and his nostrils were burning and full of water, and he tasted salt though he knew intellectually this was fresh water they were in.

Will felt the ground drop out from under him and woke by a hypnic jerk.

 

Hannibal was lying with his head on his hand, watching Will like a cat when he awoke. Will awoke and immediately descended into a fit of coughing, spluttering and gasping for air. When Will realized he was not submerged in a nightmare stream and that blessed oxygen surrounded him, he began to calm down. Hannibal sat up in the bed they were in and grabbed a handkerchief from the bedside drawer. It was clean, folded, and made of some expensive fabric.

“You haven’t had a nightmare in some time,” Hannibal observed, as he began to wipe the perspiration from Will’s brow.

At one time, Will would have been indignant at someone doing such a thing, as if he couldn’t do it himself. Now, it didn’t bother him. He wouldn’t openly admit that, though. He wouldn’t admit quite how grounding Hannibal’s touch was to him, whether the hand on his shoulder or the one dabbing at his gross sweat.

Will said nothing as Hannibal wiped at his sweat. He only continued to catch his breath. That damned taste of the salty ocean, how could it still be present? He had the idea to get up and brush his teeth, but that would do nothing because the origin of the taste was his mind and not his senses. 

“Do you think, perhaps,” Hannibal began, “Recent events might have brought it on?”

“I would suppose that, but the dream had nothing to do with recent events.” That was his own opinion, but Will had some idea of what Hannibal was going to say, so he addressed it before the other man even could, “And yes, I guess it could be the stress from that whole experience, even if the dream itself didn’t have much to do with the vampire situation—I assume you  were going to mention something about that.”

“It’s a reasonable connection to make.”

“Correlation doesn’t equal causation.”

“I am aware. Why don’t you tell me about the nightmare?”

As Will recounted his nightmare to Hannibal, the former psychiatrist listened intently—he listened intently as Will told him what had begun as a visit to his own version of a mind palace (his mind-stream?) ended in his sudden and startled awakening. 

“...There is one thing I got from the dream—an idea. It’s a bit vague now, but…But I think it would be possible to pull off.”

Hannibal, of course, knew exactly what this meant, and he smirked genuinely at the Monster he’d helped cultivate. “An idea?”

Notes:

Whether or not I still have a head, the Carmilla thing will happen at some point; I just might be carrying around my head like St. Denis by then.

Thanks for reading! Let me know what you think :) Also what do y'all think Will's idea is? >:)

Is that how you do the evil emoticon? I don't know I tried.