Chapter Text
❉
Perhaps he had underestimated him. Or perhaps accurately estimated him. Hannibal had recognized the potential, but it seems he may not be so embryonic.
Will Graham was exquisite, both in his capacity for violence and his propensity for mercy. The man viewed the world in such a specific way, making assessments on everything his eyes landed on, on everyone. Hannibal had no doubt about that.
Yet, when a person is judged lacking, his hand is still stayed. A man brimming with intellect, with vision, but cursed with caution and fear. Perhaps he was more virtuous than Hannibal had estimated, more patient too.
Hannibal was also a patient man, and a strategic one, but his hunger had sharp edges to it, his instinct a blade. He couldn’t be as patient as Will was. As a mortal he had no urgency, no true need, but perhaps that made him more exciting.
The idea that Will could be unpredictable. That he could explode into a righteous anger, that he could decide something was below him. That he was formidable and discerning.
He’d only seen it twice, but Hannibal was sure the man possessed a font of experience. In the quiet of his office, his mind attempts to conjure images of this, trying to sate his voracious curiosity.
He imagines the first time, mind straining to conjure the image of a younger man. To Hannibal, it felt almost impossible to imagine Will as such, and found focusing on the violence was easier.
Will bathed in a spray of ruby red, a baptism of blood, inviting him into a new world. A world not many mortals have seen. It crystallizes before him, brilliant colour overwhelming his minds eye. He finds himself slowly filling in details—an eyelash, a freckle, a wrinkle—building a larger and larger monument to Will in his mind. A statue in his honour, a painting, a composition, it couldn't quite be defined.
The space around him was quiet. The air still, as if pausing to pay proper respect to the thought. The only movement came from his breath leaving him, deliberately long and slow, dispelling the dust in his moonlit office. He watches the particles dance and fall with soft reverence, almost caressing the air. It seemed even the air around him was falling victim to the sentimentality in his chest.
He feels the heat of arousal begin to pool in his gut, joining a sea of warm affection. It was far from comfortable, this unnatural fever and these overwhelming feelings, filling him to the brim with energy. Untransformed, untouched, the potential was stringing his muscles taut with tension with no way to dissipate it. Certainly not as he sat in the dark of his office. He wonders if the image he’d conjured was accurate.
It was one of a dozen questions that came to mind at the thought of Will Graham. He was inundated with these curiosities, large and small.
In the mornings when the light was low, he would find his mind wandering to Will. How would he drink his coffee? What were his morning rituals? Would he languish or would he be regimented?
In the evenings, he’d return to an empty home. A tomb, in truth. Did Will enjoy music? Would he enjoy the darkness Hannibal kept?
The questions, left unanswered, made him feel particularly tender. That soft space between his ribs, that loneliness, raw like a bruise being pressed. Would he ever know the answers?
Was Will lonely like him?
Hannibal knew that answer. Will carried the seriousness of a much older man and he was so settled in his loneliness it was almost stitched into the fibre of him. He wore it like a scar. It had hurt once, maybe, but not any longer. And despite the numbness of feeling, it was there to stay, something that Will couldn’t rid himself of.
Will would suit the supernatural, Hannibal decided. He seemed half there, with his mind and disposition, he would settle into it easily. However, as hard as Hannibal ruminates in the quiet, he’s unable to conjure the image of it.
As doubt sneaks through the cracks and chews at the inside of his skull, it wishes in dulcet tones that things could’ve been different.
That there was a world where Will was on more even footing, where what they shared was not mired with so many complications. That Will would accept what Hannibal must do.
A becoming was a violent thing. It couldn’t be soft words and warm touches. It couldn’t happen in the quiet of the night under careful watch. It couldn’t be a lovers embrace.
It was violence and destruction and blood and pain.
Would they survive it?
Hannibal realizes then, that his regard for Will was strong enough to pursue it despite the risk. Will would be better for it and if he could forgive Hannibal, then that was an additional boon.
He brought his glass to his lips, tipping a generous sip of Pinot Noir into his mouth. Each movement of the glass sent the earthiness to his nose. This batch had been oak-aged, a long process that left notes of vanilla hiding in the lurch, buried under the ripe mud and smoke.
He allowed his mind to drift away, ripe cherry flooded his palate, the tartness a perfect distraction, flushing away the bitter sadness that his thoughts had brought forth. Flushing away the tenderness he felt. Ignoring that each what if seemed to chew further into him. What would happen when there was nothing left?
He allowed the flavour to consume him, cataloguing the notes rather than all the ways this all could go wrong.
It was beautiful, that was undeniable. Not quite to his taste, but the vision of raw, potent, brutality had it’s own sort of appeal. Those feral instincts buried so deeply, lurking in the shadows of our prefrontal cortex. An animal thing. Scratching and pounding on locked doors, begging for a breath of fresh air, to be released and to run free.
Hannibal could understand the desire to rip and tear. He could even understand the urge to desecrate, not that he ever would. It was messy, which could be delightful, but was ultimately foolish. More blood was simply more evidence. Messy, messy, messy. Not conducive for a successful hobby. Or a subtle one.
The scene in front of him was nothing short of beautifully foolish.
The gas station they found themselves at was unremarkable. He’d never been here, yet he’s sure he could’ve imagined it perfectly. A way-stop off the highway to shelter and fuel and loiter, covered in a thin film of dirt that could never be wiped away. The clerk sat alone in his modern-day lighthouse, protected behind a foggy plastic barrier, eyes glazed over despite the hubbub.
The parking lot had emptied out as the full strength of the FBI had slowly filed in, what had been somber travellers was now replaced by flashing lights and curious eyes.
Hannibal was one of many who’d been summoned, although it had been Will who’d called in the quiet of the night. He hadn’t said many words, but his voice had been soberly resolute.
Jack’s calling me out. I want you there.
No questions really, no request. Just a few words said plainly, as if the weight wasn’t enormous. As if demanding Hannibal’s time was his right. As if desiring his company wasn’t a revelation.
Hannibal had made some noises of agreement, nothing he can remember now, and started his drive.
The words had ricocheted around his skull. He has no memory of the journey, only I want you. I want you. I want you.
Each repetition had Hannibal picturing different ways Will could’ve said those same words.
A lovers whisper, heads pushed together sharing a pillow.
Across a dining table, hair combed, suit pressed, and warm eyes.
Hunched over a corpse in the forest amongst the dirt, blood-stained.
He may not get these things, but he at least had the memory of those words to do with as he pleased. He had the subtle southern twang that extended vowels and clipped consonants. He had the sound of his steady breaths and surety. He had Will’s intent, his desire. If he stretched his imagination, he even had the image of Will’s lips forming each syllable slowly, deliberately.
It would live with him forevermore, regardless of what happened. Regardless of what Will felt for him after all this business. After he became.
Even now, staring at the messy red smudges on old pavement, his mind echoed with the distant call of I want you I want you I wa—
“Uncharacteristically quiet today, Dr. Lecter.”
Hannibal turns his head, finding Jack beside him, watching his face curiously. He hadn’t even noticed his arrival nor his proximity.
He blinked once, then twice, wetting his eyes and grounding himself in the moment. He could not afford to be adrift.
“I find I don’t have a taste for gore any longer,” he says, voice pitched quiet for his false confession.
Jack nods, but only after a moment. Only after looking at Hannibal in a strange way, as if he was a mystery to be solved. The look sticks with Hannibal, even as the man seemingly moves on.
“An animal would’ve dragged their prey away to feed,” Will remarks, still staring at the corpse.
“Mostly everything was accounted for, so no eating,” Jimmy argues.
“A rabid animal will attack indiscriminately with no appetite for its prey,” Hannibal says after a moment. He remains unsettled both by his distraction and the vague familiarity. This vulgar show of brutality, this ferocity, it was something he'd seen before.
“And the same wound patterns were found in livestock?” someone asks, Hannibal isn’t quite sure who. He considers the information and finds it odd. What reason did they have to attack livestock?
Should this be who he believes, animals would not sate the hunger. Animals were functionally pointless.
The misfiring of instinct was a serious thing. To Hannibal, it seemed only possible in times of true desperation. An animal chewing it’s own leg to escape a trap, a mother eating her child, a pack descending upon itself.
Hannibal pondered this, mind set adrift again, pulled in by an errant ocean current.
Another predicament, as his life seems to be overwhelmed by.
He saw it first in pictures. Blurry around the edges, a hurried shot, but clear enough to catch something in motion. It was artful in its candour, but not what he needed in that moment. He needed detail, he needed every possible pixel to sate his curiosity.
He sat in his office, in the desk he’d picked specifically for comfort, feeling restless. The blue light of his iPad reflected on his face, cutting through the darkening room, and what was usually ignored now disturbed his eyes. He could feel the strain building and a low pounding growing behind his eyes.
He’d been fine not 30 minutes ago. He was fine no longer. It was akin to an allergy, a physiological reaction to the news that stared back at him.
CHESAPEAKE RIPPER RIPS AGAIN!
Not to mention how gauche the alliteration alone was, it felt so cheap. It was wrong, of course, because he’d put that persona on ice years ago, but it was also ugly. Which was possibly worse.
Garishly laid out with large graphics and bold fonts. It was purely sensationalist.
As he stared, he realized he knew that woman. Hannibal was certain she was one of his experimental fledglings. Occasionally, he’d turned a few patients that he’d professionally turned away, simply curious as to how their mental instability would translate.
She—Georgia—had disappeared. He knew she’d been feral, but now she looked truly awful. Not at all how he remembered the young girl who he’d treated for her paranoia. Perhaps a trick of editing, but she looked truly grey.
The killer, whoever they might be, had quite a queer sort of humour. She’d been posed in a very specific way, the image came to him immediately.
A rendition by John Waterhouse of a classic tale, a young Pandora melancholically posed, opening the box gifted to her, damning humans to all sorrows unknown.
A sorrowful painting and perhaps a poignant tableau. Not unlike the inspiration he may have taken, but even so, the message was unfamiliar. Who was this killer trying to advise.. or reprimand?
Why had they stolen Hannibal’s modus operandi? And why have they allowed themself to be dubbed Ripper?
He must have stared for hours, waiting for it all to make sense, for the message to be understood, but he was left angry instead.
The tableau lacked any depth. Any inspiration. Any true artistry.
All Hannibal could feel at the sight was anger. A flat wall of rage as this killer took his liberties with one of Hannibal’s experiments. He wasn’t sure if it was the killer’s or his own.
He could feel the discontent churning in his gut. A sort of feeling that burned bright red, scalding and damaging. He felt it fill the vessel of his body, molten fingers reaching from his stomach to all his extremities, clawing away at any rationality. Even his toes were hot with it, wriggling in his shoes and demanding impatiently. Every fibre of his body called for some sort of action, some sort of attack, but in this case he was unsure what was to be done.
The indignity of his name being assigned to any killer to grace Baltimore’s streets. Ms. Lounds may have written the article, but the FBI had confirmed the assumption, had agreed readily.
His fingers twitched impotently as he swiped at the screen. The article closed away, pulling his eyes away from the device at last. He was no longer enjoying himself.
He was no longer amused, he was no longer intrigued. Instead he was disturbed to his core.
There were a few avenues he could pursue.
A case of stolen identity was easily resolved should he find this killer. He could teach them his actual technique. Show them his artistry first hand. He could keep them on the edge of life, skating that beautiful line where Hannibal lived, and show him how the Ripper got his name.
But in the interim perhaps he could make himself known.
It was reckless, but the longer Hannibal sat considering his options, the less it felt like a choice.
He must do this. He was the apex predator, he was not to be ridiculed.
“Have you tried rabbit before, Jack?”
The man drags his gaze to Hannibal, head first, then eyes, reluctant to part with his meal. Hannibal smiles warmly at the man’s hunger. It was truly rewarding to feed a grateful audience, there was no greater pleasure.
“I have, but I can’t say it looked like this,” Jack commented, eyes pulled back to the meat, ornately placed on a bed of green. Hannibal had only just placed it in front of him and retreated to his own seat across the table.
They’d instituted a standing date, for lack of a better word. Dinner and a chat, a check-in more than anything. Jack was in the business of caring, perhaps more than Hannibal would consider convenient, but it was admittedly endearing. Hannibal had come to enjoy the man's company, to consider him a friend, even.
Hannibal bows his head modestly in thanks, something which Jack huffs at, amused and endeared he’d guess.
“This particular rabbit was rather difficult to catch, I’m told,” Hannibal muses with a lip quirked. A carousel of images flash through his mind, of the hunt, the catch, the harvest, the prep. Not quite quick enough. “But perseverance means little to the right predator,” he remarks, punctuating the story with a laugh, short and almost bitter on his tongue.
His eyes are on Jack, drinking in the man’s reactions. Performance was a unique kind of sustenance, a unique thirst to be quenched for Hannibal. The art of being seen, even if what is shown is a gleaming facade, is a sort of vulnerability that was rewarded with adulation. The sparkle in Jack’s eyes made this meal worthwhile, despite his own inability to consume it.
Jack chuckles, a boisterous sound that bubbles up and out.
Hannibal hums, finally bringing a forkful of meat to his mouth. His lips wrap around the three tines slowly, aroma hitting his nose first, then flavour his tongue. The seasonings coat his palate, thyme and smokiness the most evident, but as he chews down the muscle the true flavour begins to bloom. The blood, the tissue, the meatiness.
He closes eyes briefly as he chews.
“That seems to be the theme for the evening,” Jack muses, eyes finally on his.
Hannibal tilts his head in question, swallowing down his food, and urging Jack to explain.
“The ripper. We’ve been looking for a while, but there’s been some new developments in the case. Will— he was able to figure out a connection.”
Hannibal hums again, looking to his plate as he spears another piece of meat. He can feel Jack’s eyes on him as he thinks. The man keeps talking.
“There’d never been a pattern, that was the problem. There was never a discernible motive.” Jack’s voice had taken a tone of lamentation, frustration easy to pick from each word. In many ways, that was a comfort. The man was comfortable enough to keep Hannibal looped in.
“No thread to follow,” Hannibal adds, nodding appropriately in commiseration.
Jack hums again, mouth busy chewing more meat. Hannibal waits, patient, chewing his own bite. The moment extends briefly, not longer than normal, but Jack’s eye contact felt distantly unnerving. It was brief by any measure, yet Hannibal feels tension settle in his shoulders. The anticipation.
Jack swallows, finally, moving to wash down the food with a long pull of wine. “Not anymore,” he says. “We have something, I can’t quite disclose it, but it might be good.”
Hannibal feels his lips pull, a small smile taking form. The meat in his mouth loses its flavour. He doesn’t believe himself threatened, but a thread of something pulls at him.
He swallows the meat, tongue leaden as he jokes, “then I suppose this meal is a celebration.”
Jack pauses a moment, eyes flickering around Hannibal, before smiling and raising a glass.
“Do you have any regrets?”
There’s an energy in him, something sharp and soaked in anger. Or maybe not quite anger. Urgency, maybe. The way he asks the question, the way the words are spat out, feels like condemnation.
“With every choice lies the possibility of regret,” Hannibal hums, maintaining his joviality. “However, if I choose an action, there is always a reason and I like to stand with my convictions.”
Will laughs, a bitter and derisive sound that cuts off just as quick. “Does that mean you’re incapable of changing your opinion?”
Hannibal doesn’t answer immediately, allowing the silence to stretch. It was rude. He was rude. Always seemed to be, yet Hannibal finds he’s excited to break the silence. “I like to honour my decisions, even in hindsight. To honour who I was then and what he wanted.”
Will doesn't laugh again, but Hannibal can see it's a close thing. Hannibal isn't technically being mocked.
Not overtly at least.
“One could say you’re dancing away from accountability with all of that justification.” The tilt of his head implies that he would say that, that he is saying that.
Hannibal's lips pull into a small not-smile, amused despite himself. He takes a moment to adjust his posture and recross his legs, reclaiming the reigns of the conversation as he steeples his hands on his lap.
“What is it that you’re feeling regretful of, Will?”
He expects to wait out a response, he expects irritation. Instead, Will smiles a predatory smile—small and assured—and leans back in his own chair.
“I regret not putting my foot down, not taking action,” he says, voice pitched low and serious. Hannibal watches quietly for a moment, eyes fixed on his mouth, on his pinched brows, on his tense fingers.
“From my perspective, you very much have been a man of action, there is hardly a situation I can recall where you’ve been cowed,” Hannibal commented, eyebrow raised. His head tilts in question, his mind flashing to the bodies Will has dropped. Rather productive he’s been, Hannibal thinks.
Will’s brows flutter and he adjusts again, settling his shoulders against the plush of the chair.
Silence surrounds them again, not quite charged, and not quite still. It seemed to be a ledge they often found themselves on. Each moment they shared seemed to hold this same weight, this bouldering pressure that reduced Hannibal's view to the man in front of him, attention held desperately hostage, leaving him unable to escape even into his own mind.
It was rather intimate, that silence, not quite tender or tenuous. It felt absolute for lack of a better word. It was a truth of their intimacy, the assumption that they were beyond any idle utterings, beyond the need to explain. That they could share this usually brittle thing, reinforced only by their shared regard.
In this moment, it's not quite right.
Will's body attempts to project languid energy yet he is more restless than Hannibal had ever seen him. It was rather unsettling, in truth.
Hannibal might've believed him truly uncaring, if not for the glint in his eyes. The distant interest is so carefully concealed, or carelessly open. Hannibal would never be sure of anything about Will Graham, not his thoughts and certainly not his intentions.
So, instead, Will was the image of discordance. A physical manifestation of the complicated web of synapses that came together to form Will Graham. Hannibal, not for the first time, wished he could cut into him. The phantom sensation manifests instantly, his mind turning it over.
Fingers tearing into the soft give of his dura, he imagines it would be akin to the sun cracking open, the answers he desperately sought bursting forth.
He'd reach in, pads slowly mapping tissue, a conscious swipe, ridges of his skin catching on every neuron, learning and cataloguing. With enough time, perhaps he could learn Will's flesh like Braille, perhaps he could brush his hippocampus—CA1, CA2, CA3—and come away with knowledge of Will's life, an exploration, an understanding, something that the living man refuses to give.
His melancholia grew. At the desire, at its futility, at everything and nothing at all. Who was he to fantasize when his plans involved the destruction of Will’s life?
Perhaps, in several centuries, Will could come to understand, but perhaps that was his own childish hope springing forth. He himself has no tenderness for the men that cursed his soul and made him so.
His ennui surrounded him like a fog. He could no longer see past it, vision reduced simply to this day and the next. To this step then the next. To function and necessity, to survival.
On one side of his narrow view was Will, bright and full of life. On the other was an unidentified, unmitigated, expanse of darkness. There was nothing to grasp on to, nothing to take note of.
There was nothing on the other side, truly nothing. Will was his only path.
“Have you spoken to Jack?”
“I often speak to Jack,” he answers simply, mind slow to catch his meaning. Will doesn't speak for a moment.
“We're closing in on the ripper, he's reckless,” Will scoffs. His voice is tinged with something Hannibal can’t quite place. He knows the FBI has been rabid in their desire to capture his alter ego, but he hadn’t known of Will’s involvement.
“And how have these developments come about?”
“He has a pattern, as mundane as it sounds, something increasingly obvious once I noticed it.”
Will seems satisfied after this assertion, body tension draining, smugness settling into every line of his face. Hannibal notices then, that they have traded dispositions.
His body had tightened so thoroughly that he’s sure Will would notice. Will would likely mistake it for interest.
Not for the first time, a feeling lances through him. He’s not sure how best to name it, but his mind races to recount the past weeks. It’s not easy, to isolate time, to pick apart the hours that fuse together in his memory, the days are akin to blinks, the weeks a sneeze.
What was time to an immortal being? To someone who had seen war — start to finish, insult to killing blow. Someone who has seen society collapse unto itself?
The most he can grasp is the emotion, but even that was elusive in turns. These past months, Hannibal realizes, come easily. They taste like a freshly decanted cab. Bright. Almost painfully so. Something puerile, begging attention, but pungent with promise.
He finds himself able to chase the threads, to call to mind Will's eyes carelessly finding his own, to find these still moments, to count the seconds.
He thinks suddenly of Randall Tier. Another experiment—
another…
The realization is sharp. It comes to him fully formed, no gaps, no questions. In one moment, it's clear.
There is no more room for doubt as words and expressions begin to fill in the gaps. Little moments that he’d discarded quickly enough and explained away. He could clearly see the meaning now.
Hoisted by his own petard, Hannibal thinks ruefully.
Despite this, he smiles at Will, the edges sharper now, with the burden of this knowledge. The man’s disposition begins to make sense. It all seems to now.
He'd almost been caught wrong-footed. Almost. But he is still a creature of unimaginable potential, certainly not something Will Graham is prepared for.
Certainly not something Will Graham would expect.
He hears it again, those cursed words.
I want you, I want you, I want you.
He has almost grown to dislike them in the span of a day. Not the words themselves, but the way to meaning has been warped by his boundless mind.
I want you. I want you.
Those subtle changes meant everything and nothing all the same.
He blinks back to this moment and finds Will’s eyes on him, watching as he seems always to do. So careful and purposeful he seemed to be, but to what end, Hannibal couldn't help but wonder.
What was Will’s end goal?
They track each other silently, both content in their observation. in their rapport, or the pretence of it. A sinking feeling begins to grip him, something familiar, something battle-worn, something lingering.
Hannibal had spent the entirety of his lives cognisant of it.
The first life was that of an isolated boy-child with limbs sprouting faster than could be corralled, left gangly by hunger. He’d been labelled an oddity, a curiosity, neither precious or neglected. It had been a mystery then, something to ponder, a soreness akin to a bruise. Both by his prodding and his still tender heart.
The second is that of the boy—still a boy, perhaps always a boy—no longer a child, left with a power with no hope of subduing. A power that was flint in his chest's hearth, a pilot light turned forest fire, a hunger that now had the capacity to destroy. He knew despite his denial that it had only changed forms—it has always been there, it has always been known—perhaps evolved. Perhaps it would have always reached this height, this insurmountable, unavoidable need. Perhaps not. In this second life, this life that has stretched longer than anything holy, he knows it as a boon. This otherness he once cursed in the silent night, he knows it as his own.
He knows that he is his hunger, he is this creature.
But, suddenly, it manifests. This feeling. A creeping sensation dancing down his spine, coating his skin slowly. Trickling like a stream to consuming like a torrential pouring. This feeling reattaches itself to Hannibal without warning. Here in the space he’d made for himself. He looked around the walls, the toy box he’d happily decorated, the trimmings and colours and paintings, and found that this life offered no comfort.
He was not meant to be here, not alone, not like he thought.
His eyes skim down, landing finally on one Will Graham.
When he writes the invitations it’s with the finality of a knife. His fountain-tip strikes the page with large swooping motions leaving behind stark black ink that looked like gashes. His eyes see only red.
It was worse than he thought, it seemed. Another body has dropped, another familiar face. Randall Tier, found strung up in the very museum where he worked. Never mind that it would be foolish for Hannibal to do so, never mind that he cared for his experiments, was curious. It has been named Ripper and with this, any subtlety has been lost.
The ink is slow to dry. Little wells of obsidian linger on the page, begging to be smudged, begging for his finger to swipe and disturb. Begging him to push until the flesh of the paper gave away, until his fingers could grab hold of the meat underneath.
If he could feed on the flesh, then perhaps the violence would have meaning. If the words distort, perhaps he would have another choice. If the letter is ruined, perhaps it could be different.
His mind skips again, away from this day and towards a dream like reality where all is well. Where Will Graham has not placed a target on his back regardless of Hannibal’s feelings on the matter.
That is not the case, he reminds himself. All is as it is, and if he is fortuitous, it will be as he has written soon enough.
