Actions

Work Header

If There Were Water

Summary:

Bilbo Baggins might be in over his head. He’s purchased an old stone house atop a hill overlooking a city he doesn’t know, and plans to live quietly, largely ignoring the rest of the world. But it’s early April, the rainy season, and the roof leaks, and there's something strange about Bywater House that he can't quite figure out.

Thorin Oakenshield is in his fourth month of trying to reconcile his own grief with his failures at anything remotely resembling a competent single parent, living out of a shoebox flat with Fíli (seven, sullen, and stubborn as hell) and Kíli (five, resilient but cracking), working crap jobs and hating everything including himself.

Under the cover of rainy afternoons and sleepless nights, roof repairs and building restoration, Bilbo and Thorin try to figure out how one navigates isolation, and how one breaks out of it. Every step they manage to take forward finds them dragged back again; every question asked has too many answers, or too few. This is a story about living in a world where everyone is on their own, always, and how things go on.

[for ewebean & noneedforsuspicion, and the 2014 Hobbit Big Bang]

Notes:

This was written for The Hobbit Big Bang (hobbitstory on LJ), in collaboration with 2 marvelous artists: ewebean and noneedforsuspicion.

Art by ewebean: here
Art by noneedforsuspicion: here

This was my first time doing a Big Bang challenge, and though the timing could have been better, the overall experience was really great. To be a part of such positive, collaborative energies in this fandom, and to have so many artists and writers working alongside (please check out their works--I've seen very exciting things so far) was such a good experience. I wrote this story faster than I've written anything else in a while, and I'm not sure how that turned out. I guess we'll see how you think it turned out, though, right?

Other links:
8tracks
the ITWW fic tag on my tumblr
Bywater house
a fantastic photoset/edit by bilboo (perkynurples on Ao3)
a lovely edit by little-miss-carrot
and Thorin looking properly disheveled, thanks to harmleikur

----------

Chapter Text

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

“All over the whole round earth . . . people are drawn inward within their little shells of rooms . . . and none can care, beyond that room; and none can be cared for, by any beyond that room; and it is small wonder they are drawn together so cowardly close . . . and wonder only that an age that has borne its children and must lose and has lost them, and lost life, can bear further living; but so it is.”

—James Agee, Let Us Now Praise Famous Men (1941)

 

 

CHAPTER ONE

 

It’s raining again, the kind of late April rain that can pour down all day without interruption, so steady as to wash the world away. There is rain drumming against the windows, overflowing the gutters, flooding the sunken garden at the back of the house—nothing but water. Outside, barely visible through the fog, the landscape has dimmed into greens and blues. There is a chill in the house at odds with the soft golden light in the study. Somewhere, the roof is leaking, water droplets falling evenly to pool and gather on the floorboards. As the rain wears on the house creaks and settles, all crooked walls and windows that don’t quite shut, doors drafty in the winter and swollen in the summer and shifting restlessly in between.

            Bilbo Baggins, twenty-six, pseudonymous author and social recluse and generally unremarkable heir to the Baggins family fortune—greater in name than in number, now, not that anyone will believe it—might be in over his head. The first step to facing one’s problems is to acknowledge them; everyone knows this. Bilbo sighs, and leaves his study to fetch a bucket from the kitchen, walking through the house in search of the leak and resolutely thinking of anything but.

            The house is a crumbling old Arts & Crafts Style from the turn of the twentieth century, two stories and an attic but built partially into the slope of the hill so that the ground floor is on two separate levels and the dormer windows don’t match up, a newer and slightly haphazard addition of a sunroom off the west side. It has two parlours plus two studies, four bedrooms, and something the realtor tried to market cheerfully as a “breakfast nook,” at which point Bilbo had been so ready to be rid of her that he simply wrote out a check. For such a large, rambling house set on five acres of land, atop a hill overlooking the city, it was a remarkably affordable offer. And the nook, as Bilbo has taken to calling it despite his best efforts, is actually one of his favourite spots—a long bay window arching over the back lawn. He has tea there, most mornings, and reads the paper, and asks himself what on earth he is doing, fooling himself at playing This Old House while leafing through a book of William Morris’s wallpaper patterns and wishing he had someone around to show him how this was supposed to work.

            There are at least two problems with that plan: he’s moved up here to leave behind everyone he knew, and he doesn’t even really like people anyway, so he’s not about go out and find some new ones now that he’s finally found solitude. He’s perfectly comfortable where he is. Even if the attic is flooding. It’s a small flood, Bilbo tells himself; And besides, you did say you had to wash the floors. Straightening up, bucket squarely positioned under the worst of the leaks, Bilbo stretches his arms over his head and looks around. The house wasn’t advertised as furnished and yet the longer he stays here—going on four weeks, now—the more furniture he finds, tucked away under threadbare sheets in the attic, more furniture than that small space should be able to hold. And then there are nights when it’s three in the morning and he’s fallen asleep at his desk only to wake up and find everything just a little bit shifted. A chair slightly to the left of its last position. Books on a shelf he remembers leaving empty. No matter how hard he tries, he can’t recall moving the long desk into the front parlour, or how he managed to get the legs to fit through that doorway.

            In retrospect, he should probably have been a bit more concerned about that.

            Everything in the attic manages to be covered in dust, no matter how much time Bilbo spends cleaning. He runs his hand over the lump of a chair draped in faded red and cream paisley sheets on his way back downstairs, thinking about how it would look in the sitting room. The roof repairs have just moved to the top of his to-do list, though. And no matter how many home improvement magazines he has read or any number of memories of shop class in secondary school, that is not something he’s qualified to do himself. That alone wouldn’t normally stop him; it is an awfully high roof, though. He doesn’t particularly want to break his neck, even if the sunken garden would make an uncannily good cemetery.

            This kind of morbidity is new to him.  It’s a taste in the back of his mouth, coopery and bright and a little bit sour. He files it away for later inspection. Right now, it’s later than he meant to stay awake yet again. With the roof leak temporarily under control—by a very loose definition—he double-checks that the front door is locked, shuts the light off in the study, and crawls into his bed without bothering to change into pajamas. The rain beats against the wide window off the foot of the bed. Bilbo watches the droplets streak past against the dim blur of distant city lights until he falls asleep.

            In the morning, it’s still raining, same as it has been for the past three days. Bilbo wakes at seven o’clock and rolls over to smother himself in pillows, groaning. An hour or so later he gets out of bed. The floorboards are cold underfoot, as if it weren’t spring. The bedroom window sits atop a small rise of hill, and even though he knows he’ll get wet, Bilbo can’t quite resist opening the window and sticking his head out. The wind and water hit him almost immediately, soaking through the thin knit of his sweater. The big oak on the front lawn lost a branch overnight—he sees it lying halfway across the front walkway. More maintenance, Bilbo thinks, and steps back inside, shuts the door. After a shower and breakfast—in the nook—he checks on the leaking roof. A bit of work with tape and a square of oilskin makes a funnel, directing the flow more accurately into the bucket.

            Well, he had wanted spring, and spring in this part of the country apparently means rain. The catch on the attic’s skylight is broken—another new addition, he can see clearly now in the dim morning light—and it’s blown open, a gap an inch or two wide letting in the rain. There’s a ladder in the shed out in the garden. Rather than go down two flights of stairs and into the rain, Bilbo drags a low wooden bench over, balances a chair on top of it, and clambers up, straining with his arms over his head to reach the window’s catch. He gets a face full of rain anyway for his efforts but manages to tug the window shut, and some rooting around in the old seaman’s chest in the attic’s far corner turns up a spool of wire so he can tie the fasteners together. It’s not exactly his neatest work, but it will do.

            The thing about living out here is that Bilbo is learning that for all his skills in the garden, his cultivated ability to avoid people he doesn’t really like, and the fact that he has, on occasion, written a fairly decent book, he has never had to fend for himself before. He has always gotten by. After “getting by” the deaths of not only one but both of his parents, “getting by” the feeling of his family home grown too large and yet not holding enough space for him inside its walls, or the carefully concerned greetings of neighbours and distant relations, Bilbo realised he wasn’t actually doing anything with his life. Nothing at all. And it’s not that there was anything inherently wrong with that, but once the last of the well-wishers went away and his pantry emptied out of casseroles and cakes, once the season started to change and his latest manuscript was sent back by his editor with more red pen than he’d ever seen before, he decided—in a way, it was decided for him, but he hasn’t made that particular connection yet—that he needed to get away.

            So he left his childhood home in the care of his cousin, the only family member he can actually stand, and he packed his bags, boxed up his books, stuffed it all into the tiny trunk and backseat of his father’s 1962 Triumph Herald 948 Coupe and drove off. At first he thought he’d do some kind of writer-in-residence thing: find a big old house, out in the country, maybe a castle, and pay room and board, wander the gardens and talk to the groundskeeper, that sort of thing. So when his editor phoned with an offer to take a look at an old stone cottage—“Plenty of charm,” he’d said, “I think it’s just the place for you,” insisting on calling it a cottage when it could easily fit a family of six—Bilbo accepted his directions and changed his course, heading north instead of out to the coast. He’d never been to this part of the country before. Moors and flatlands, bog country, water running through everything, and then up into the hills. Driving through the city at the base of the hills, Bilbo wondered if this was really going to be a place he could come to like. And when he wound his way out past the city limits and up to the house, it wasn’t his editor who was waiting for him, but a realtor. The old man had taken his request for “residency” in earnest, it seemed, and Bilbo found himself with a somewhat nervous young woman in a dark skirt-suit who wanted to show him this “gorgeous old place, loads of character.” “Yes, I’ve heard,” Bilbo replied, and kind of wanted to tell her he wasn’t interested, but then . . . the house really was impressive, even if its groundplan and layout were a bit odd. And he felt bad about turning her away.

            What Bilbo Baggins doesn’t know is this: the house he’s moved into has a name, has a history dating back more than a century, and has been empty for nearly forty years—for good reason, most would say. The city’s residents don’t like to look at Bywater, brooding up there in the hills. It’s too old-fashioned, too uneven, too large, full of too many memories and with plenty of space for them to grow. When word started to spread that someone was buying it, everyone hoped it would be razed to the ground. The realtor who showed Bilbo the property nearly quit her job the morning of, rather than set foot inside. No one knows the real story—or if they do, they’re not sharing—but in that way that all old houses are talked about under the breath, only in passing, everyone agrees: Bywater is haunted.

            It’s not that anyone died a tragic death swooning from its slanted roofline, or was gruesomely murdered in either of its two wide parlours. And the house itself, though it definitely needs work, is normal enough, if you excuse the oddities of its placement on the landscape: swathes of heather running right up to the ivy-covered walls, unassuming front door, long driveway—even though the driveway is little more than a dirt track, and Bilbo’s car struggles to keep its wheels. There shouldn’t, logically, be anything wrong with Bywater at all. It’s just an old house. But that’s precisely the trouble: it’s an old house, a house that has seen history, a house that has stood exactly the same while the city changed and the world changed and its inhabitants grew old, up on the hill. Waiting. Watching. Accumulating time like water, until the very floorboards and joists swell with the weight of a hundred years. A house like that, once it fills up, leaves no space for anything else.

            What Bilbo Baggins does know is that he needs to phone a local roofing company—needs to actually talk to someone—so he can get someone out to fix his roof, provided that the rain will let up for even half an hour. He’s not optimistic about that, but the contractor he speaks to on the other end says they may as well make arrangements. “Weather changes quickly, this part of the country,” the man says, and Bilbo rolls his eyes, looking out at the flood that is his back lawn.

            “Well, apart from the roof,” he says, “there are a couple of other things I may need fixed. I wonder if you could help me?”

            “Such as?”

            “The back steps sag, for one thing, and I think the sunroom beams are rotting through.”

            “Anything else?” the man asks. He sounds bored. Bilbo briefly contemplates phoning another company. He knows how young he sounds over the phone, how inexperienced; it’s part of the reason he writes under a pseudonym. Once people meet him in person, it’s even harder to get them to take him seriously, short and slight as he is, with rather unfortunately large ears. “Hello?” the contractor asks, and Bilbo snaps back to attention.     

            “Oh, right. Yes, the, er, the back chimney’s sort of falling to bits. I don’t know if that would be your area or—”

            “You’d want a stone mason,” the man says. “I can put a note in, see if we have a fellow. Where’d you say you were located?”

            “22 West Farthing Way.”

            The man on the other end of the line is quiet.

            “It’s, ah, the old cottage on top of the hill?” Bilbo adds, trying to clarify.

            “Yeah,” the man says, after a long pause. “I know it. Listen,” he starts to say, and then clears his throat. “Maybe you’d better—”

            “Oh, damn it,” Bilbo cuts in; “The back door’s just blown open. I have to go, sorry. So when the weather clears, I’ll expect your man. Yes? Wonderful, thanks very much.” Bilbo hangs up—corded phone, who even still uses those?—and skids around the kitchen counter to wrench the back door shut again. There is a pool of water on the floor already, leaf bits and debris scattered on the threshold. Once he has a few kitchen towels pressed up against the bottom of the door and has mopped up the mud and sticks, he realises the construction company never actually confirmed that they would send someone. He could call them back. Or he could just wait and see what happens when the rain stops—whenever that might be—which is, on the whole, a better and less awkward option. Feeling unusually accomplished for someone who hasn’t really done anything, Bilbo makes himself a cup of tea. From the sunroom, whose name has yet to apply, he watches the wildflower garden sway in the wind, staunch blues and purples against such grey skies.

            He has a whole list of work that needs doing on the house. The wallpaper in one of the upstairs bedrrooms is peeling, a combination of years of moisture and sealed windows. The range in the kitchen is temperamental and requires its pilot light to be re-lit nearly every week; it goes out at the slightest draft. The back door, apparently, doesn’t latch properly, which accounts for the draft. The floors in general could use refurbishing; there are deep gouges in the wood that Bilbo can’t account for, and blackened corners on every level, as if the house had been on fire at some point, but only enough to char a bit. The plumbing could stand to be re-done, so that it doesn’t take fifteen minutes of running water to get the bath warmed. And then there are heaps of cosmetic things, fixtures that need replacing, cabinets updating; someone, presumably the last owner, thought chroming the second-floor bath was a grand idea. Bilbo’s closed the door on that space, can’t even stand to look at it. A house like this has to be treasured, rebuilt piece by piece, with the proper attention to its history. He has plenty of catalogues and guides to period interiors, but even though the house is old enough to merit outside documentation of its history, his own efforts have consistently turned up nothing. So Bywater is, in many ways, a chance for Bilbo to re-invent himself.

            The rain does let up eventually, fading out towards the evening. From the window in his bedroom Bilbo can look out over the city, the low-lying valley shrouded in fog while up on the hill Bywater stands exposed. On nights like this, when the moon breaks through the clouds and lights up the yard, plants swollen fat with water, eaves still dripping, Bilbo likes to pretend he is on an island, his own outpost above the flood, drawn inwards unto itself—a closed world.

 

It’s five-thirty in the morning and he can’t sleep. The springs of the pull-out sofa in his frankly awful one-bedroom flat are digging into his back and every time he rolls over he risks upsetting the cut length of PVC piping supporting the mattress and falling to the floor. The sun won’t be up for another hour and a half but he may as well get up—a good night’s sleep has been a lost cause for so long now it’s becoming routine. Of course, there’s not much one can do at five-thirty in the morning, at least while trying not to wake the two boys presumably fast asleep just on the other side of the thin wall. A shower’s out, that’s for sure; Thorin has found, though, that if he muffles the coffee percolator with a kitchen towel, he can brew a pot relatively quietly. So he makes coffee and turns on his computer, browsing local classified ads and hating every second of it.

            At thirty-four, Thorin Oakenshield kind of thought he’d have his life figured out by now. A stable job, a decent house, weekends off, trip now and then to the islands to do some hiking. And up until last year—four months ago, really—that had been true. Oakenshield’s was a small company, a hand-made furniture start-up he began running in his last years of school out of their woodworking shop, but over the years and with the help of a couple of friends, it had grown into a respectable business. Not by his father’s standards, but then, Thorin mostly tries not to think about that. He had done well enough. Gathered a loyal clientele, sold all his pieces at asking price because of the detailed workmanship, had a favourable write-up or two in home improvement magazines and interior design catalogues. A fine update of the Arts and Crafts style, they all called him; an heir to Morris and Voysey in the modern age. Worth the trip out to the coast. He still has those reviews, cut out and pasted into a photo album somewhere by his younger sister, Dís. He can recall, quite distinctly, being hugely embarrassed at the time. He never thanked her properly.

            This is why he shouldn’t wake up so early: too much time for introspection. Dís has been dead for four months and his life is no longer his own now, and that’s all there is to it. Her sons Fíli, age seven, and Kíli, age five, are his responsibility, even if he would do anything rather than let them hear him thinking of them that way. As a burden. Sleeping peacefully, if a little cramped, side by side on the double bed in a bedroom barely wide enough to fit it, the boys are probably the only thing in Thorin’s life right now that he actually likes. He’d been living three hundred kilometers or so to the southeast, out along the coastline, an old dairy barn converted into a furniture shop with the hayloft as his office and flat. Dís had told him it was “unbearably hip” and brought him fresh flowers every time she visited, seeming to take special delight in watching her older brother trim their stems and place them in an old cut-glass bottle beside the sink. Even when she was sick, she still made the trip down to see him, the boys running out of the car practically before it stopped and tackling him to the ground. Thorin taught them—city kids that they were—how to climb trees, how to fish, how to make flint arrowheads and shoot a bow, how to plane a piece of wood. Every third word out of their mouths had been “Uncle” and they had to be dragged bodily away from him at the end of their stay.

            These days, he’s lucky if they say ten words to him put together, or go three days without breaking anything. He came up here when Dís died, thinking he’d take them back to the barn with him. Thinking that they would find a way to carry on together. But one look at Fíli’s bright, defiant eyes and Kíli’s tear-streaked face and he couldn’t find it in himself to drag them away from everything they knew, not when they’d just lost so much. Except their fancy private school tuition and house mortgage combined were more than Thorin could afford, particularly since he’d all but quit his job as Oakenshield’s head carpenter and Dis’s ex-husband’s family were proving irrational and impossible to negotiate with. Frustrated with the whole affair and needing to leave, desperately, before he punched someone, Thorin all but threw the deed to the house at them. He may have also shouted rude words—again, something he tries not to think about, as he had Kíli in his arms at the time, and Fíli at his heels, and whatever other shortcomings he might have as a parental sort of influential figure, he’d like to think they won’t grow up to be quite so angry all the time. The present forecast isn’t looking good, he has to admit; and those shortcomings are rapidly turning into failures. At least the boys are still in school, even if he doesn’t know how he’s going to pay for it when the next term starts.

            Holding his lit cigarette out of the one window in the main room, Thorin lets himself close his eyes and have a moment—just a brief one—of hating everything, including himself. Uphold the family name? Find a way to carry on together? Who the hell are you kidding? You can’t even find a goddamn job.

            Everything he’s applied for in the past few days has come to nothing. Either he’s overqualified, or the hours would conflict with him making even the barest effort at looking after the boys, and he’s been forcing them to spend far too much time on their own as it is. Fíli takes his younger brother to school in the mornings, walks him home in the afternoons, sometimes gets dinner ready, helps Kíli with his homework and his shower and reads him a story before bed, all while Thorin is out pouring concrete or waxing corporate office floors or any number of menial labour jobs he can’t stand, night shifts and dirty work, the kinds of jobs no one actually wants to do. Sometimes he fills in on the local fire crew, returning to the ropes he’d learned back during school when he’d volunteered at the fire and ambulance station. But even when Thorin’s working six jobs, a different one every day of the week, coming home with a sore back and rough hands, a headache from gritting his teeth all day, it still doesn’t pay the bills. He needs something steady, something nine-to-five. Ideally, something nine-to-four. He’s spent the last months as a glorified handyman, showing up at construction yards and hoping they’ll take him on for a day’s pay, usually cash in an envelope at the end of the shift. Once in a while he’s been able to catch a longer gig installing flooring or doing landscaping and then the company will cut him a check at the end of the week, but he feels like he’s sixteen again and working crap jobs just to get a bit of extra money, so he could go drinking with his mates or buy parts for the motorbike he was rebuilding. It’s not a career, it’s not what he trained for; he’s throwing away all his skills as a craftsman. There’s no artistry, no room for expression. Concrete blocks, neat squares of lawn. He hates it.

            Stubbing out his cigarette, Thorin goes back to his computer. The city’s not large enough to have its own theatre, gallery, or any sort of place he could showcase his work, even if he had any of his tools up here with him. He thought briefly of applying for a position with the boys’ schools, as a woodworking instructor, but his relationship with Fíli and Kíli is strained enough as it is, without the added strangeness of him teaching them and their classmates. They need some time apart from him. There’s a new local classified and odd-job ad listing that catches his eye, though, offering surprisingly good pay for repairing a roof and a chimney on an old house outside of town. The construction company that posted the ad is one Thorin’s worked with before, even if the job is likely one for a union man or an inside contractor. He scribbles down their number and the details, and then clears his computer before putting it away to start making the boys breakfast. Doesn’t want them to know exactly how many jobs he’s working these days, or how many more he’s searching for.

            Breakfast is leftover porridge from earlier in the week, bread that’s slightly stale but all right for toasting—no toaster, just straight on a griddle on the stove—and honey, a gift from Thorin’s eccentric and somewhat frightening neighbour back on the coast. He keeps bees and harvests the honey himself. They used to trade: Thorin would carve increasingly detailed wooden bowls and plates in exchange for more honey than he could possibly eat. Even though he hasn’t been keeping up his end of the deal, and didn’t tell anyone his new address, the shipment of honey arrived on his doorstep his first week in the flat and has continued like clockwork since. The boys tear through it at a pace Thorin never could. He keeps meaning to send something in return, at least a thank-you note, but has no idea what to say.

            Fíli slumps into the kitchen in his school pants and an undershirt, dragging a hand through unruly curls. He doesn’t even look at Thorin, just sits at their narrow table and yawns. Thorin’s only recently managed to stop sighing every time this happens. He serves up a bowl of porridge and a plate of toast, and goes to wake Kíli. The younger boy’s still asleep, curled into a ball with his back to the wall and one hand stretched out to the indent where his brother had been lying. Thorin sits down on the edge of the mattress gently. It sags beneath his weight as he leans over to put a hand to Kíli’s shoulder.

            “Morning, Kíli,” he says. “Time to get up.”

            “Mmmf.” Kíli uncurls and opens his eyes. “Where’s Fíli?”

            “Having breakfast. Come on, up.” Thorin stands and looks around the room—one desk, a wardrobe, narrow curtained window.

            Kíli rolls out of bed and trots into the kitchen still in his pajamas. Sits at the table, bare feet swinging, munching on toast. This is the only hour of the day—before either of them are fully awake—that Thorin feels like they could be a family, just the three of them. Not half an hour later, when both boys are dressed in carefully pressed grey slacks (shorts for Kíli, who hasn’t graduated to full pants) and navy blazers, pale blue button downs and striped ties, holding school satchels and paper lunch sacks, Thorin will look at them and see only a divide.

            They walk to school most days, hand in hand out of the housing estate and into the old part of the city. Kíli’s still in primary school, and Fíli’s a year younger than the usual cutoff for his school, but both are smart enough—and Dís was connected, and charming, enough—that they’ve advanced a year. Across the road from Fíli’s old stone school is a smaller brick building, newer, built to prepare younger students to enter the co-educational secondary school. Thorin, who went to state schools like his siblings, like their parents, scoffed at the idea when Dís first told him she was enrolling the boys at the academy. Questioned the cost, argued—quite accurately—that Kíli would never keep his navy blazer clean or his tie straight, scowled at the idea that the education they’d grown up with hadn’t been good enough. “I just want what’s best for them,” Dís said, her tone of voice making it final. Thorin knew his younger sister, her stubbornness and her grit, and he stopped teasing the boys about their uniforms long enough to consider that maybe she was right.

            After the boys leave, Thorin cleans up the kitchen, straightens up the flat. Goes into their room to make their bed, only to find that Fíli has done it already, the corners of the bedsheets tucked in with his mother’s precision. Their room is almost spartanly clean; you would never guess two boys under age 10 live here. Fili might kick over an end-table twice a week, but any cracks are always mended, the fallen lamp always righted. A lingering neatness instilled by Dís combined with Thorin’s own need to make the place not seem like such a crap-heap means that everything is always put away. Organisation means more floor space, more floor space translates into the appearance of a bigger room. It’s a lesson Thorin learned quickly, after moving here. He never kept the barn this neat, scrap wood and plans and personal belongings strewn about the hayloft, half a week’s wardrobe hanging off of various pegs on the main floor. Right about now, he’s wishing he took better care of his clothes; what he has left now are pants wearing thin in the knees, shirts stained with plaster and paint. Laundry is expensive, and new clothes even more so, and what money there is for hygiene goes towards the boys, always. So when Thorin finally gets his shower and trims his beard—a concession to job hunting—it’s a two-day old outfit of dusty canvas workpants and an oil-stained shirt that he puts on. Just before he steps out the door, a hooded parka and his hard hat in his hands, he pauses with his hand on the doorknob and takes a deep breath. Says, as he says every morning, “Get it together, Oakenshield.”

            It’s a quarter to eight by the time he’s heading down to the train station, heavy workboots splashing through puddles from last night’s rain. The construction company is just south of the city center, and while they don’t have any open calls posted along with the roofing job, he figures he can at least go and badger them into letting him join a crew for the next week or so.

            Thorin draws himself up to his full 192cm, squares his shoulders, and enters the company’s main office. “Can I help you?” the young kid working the front desk asks. Thorin knows he’s heard the kid’s name before, something with an O, but it escapes him now.

            “I want to talk to the foreman,” Thorin says. “Is he in the back?”

            “Well, yes, but you can’t—”

            “Right,” Thorin says, and pushes past him.

            “He’s busy!” the kid calls out after him, in vain. “Oh, bother . . .” Thorin ignores him and walks right up to the foreman’s door, knocks twice.

            “What is it?” the man calls out. He sounds aggravated. Wonderful. Thorin pushes the door open and the foreman looks up from a set of blueprints. He’s an older man, gone completely grey and starting to put on weight, but he knows his work and he’s a fair boss. Has never tried to get out of paying Thorin, like some others have. “You again,” the foreman says.

            “I need work,” Thorin says, and closes the door behind him. “You know I’m at least twice as good as anyone you’ve got out there.”

            The boss stares him down.

            “It’s true,” Thorin insists.

            “You know that and I know that,” the boss concedes. “But those men out there have contracts—union contracts, mind you”—he waves a hand out the window overlooking the loading docks—“and if I give you their jobs, I get the board on my arse.”

            “You don’t have to pay me as much as you pay them.”         

            “Lad, you don’t want to be saying that. Your work is top-quality. Don’t sell yourself short, especially not if you need the money.” The man is gracious enough to leave off the pointed addition that Thorin does, in fact, desperately need the money. Thorin grits his teeth.

            “There must be something,” he says. “Anything.” Opts for aiming just short of intimidation: draws his brows together, brings down the corners of his mouth, lays his hands flat on the desk and leans in. He’s found that intimidation doesn’t work with this man, and is, grudgingly, impressed by it, so in return he’s a little more forth-coming, a little more open. But not all the way. The alternative would be, of course, pleading. He’s still a long way off from doing that. When he was younger, just after his mother died, he took care of his siblings with less than he has now; if it comes to it, he’ll just tighten his belt and manage. But to be able to buy Fíli new rugby cleats, or Kíli the next book in that series about the dragon that he loves, that would mean an awful lot. “Anything,” he repeats.

            The boss studies Thorin and then sighs, still not the least bit intimidated. He flips through the memo pad on his desk where he records calls from various contractors looking to hire out projects. His eyes settle on a page; Thorin catches the date of the call, noting that it was just this morning, from the local roofing contractor: the posting he saw online. It’s a bit unusual for the roofers to hire out jobs, Thorin knows, and wonders why they’ve called Durin & Sons. The boss leans back in his chair and scratches his chin. “You seem like a logical man, Oakenshield,” he says. Thorin, confused, says nothing. “Like a man who doesn’t scare easily.”

            “Yeah,” Thorin says, slowly.

            The boss sighs. “All right, lad. There’s a house out West Farthing Way, up in the hills. You ever been out there?”

            “No. I’m new to the area, so . . .”

            “Sure, sure,” the boss nods. “Heard anything about it, though?”

            “No,” Thorin says, beginning to get annoyed. “D’you have a job for me or not?”

            “A fellow out there needs his roof fixed. Chimney, too, and possibly a couple of other things. It should be a one-man job, but it may take some time. If I put these union lunkheads on it, they’ll take even more time, and cost the company twice as much for half the work. To be honest, I thought of you when the call first came in, but . . . Well. Are you up for it?”

            “Yes. Can I start today?”        

            The boss looks unhappy but he says yes, and gets the paperwork started. “It’s not my place to ask,” he says, looking down at his papers instead of at Thorin, “but if you’re in some sort of trouble, there are—”

            “I’m not,” Thorin says quickly, before the man can continue. They’ve been down this road before. “I just need the money.”

            “Fair enough.” The boss hands a folder to Thorin and says, “22 West Farthing Way. Place is called Bywater. Should be easy enough to find. If you run into trouble . . . any trouble, just give us a ring, all right?”

            “Right,” Thorin says, but knows he won’t. The first sign of disinterest from him and four other men will be clamouring for his job. It’s only a roof and a chimney; how hard can it be?

            With the boys already set for the day, between school and Fíli’s youth rugby league practice afterwards—Kíli hangs around and pesters the coaches, or the players on the bench, who grudgingly put up with him because he’s their #2 winger’s younger brother—Thorin has eight hours open ahead of him. At the company’s usual hourly wages, that’s enough to buy nearly a whole week’s worth of dinners. He resists smirking at the front desk kid on his way out but is pleased to have proved him wrong. When he gets outside the rain’s started up again and it’s a wet walk to the train station, back to the flat to pick up his truck.

            The road out of the city proper is a long, winding track, twisting over the highlands. It seems like it should take longer to break out into the hills but Thorin finds himself leaving civilisation behind almost before he realises it, coming up over a rise to look out on rocky fields dotted with damp sheep. “Who the fuck lives out here on this stupid hill?” he mutters, wrenching the steering wheel around a hairpin bend. He has a couple of close calls with dazed sheep in the middle of the road, as if they didn’t have acres of hills to roam; he is driving faster than he should, admittedly, but time is money and his clock doesn’t start until he arrives at the house. At Bywater. “And what kind of arsehole names their house?” The road signs are small, hard to read, if they exist at all. One turn leads him to a dead end and a cluster of stinging nettle that’s overgrown the road; another takes him to a ruined farm cottage. While that is at least interesting, and its roof does need restoring, it’s not what he’s looking for. At last, the sign for West Farthing Way—a narrow piece of wood with an arrow, and small, neat letters painted below—shows itself against a farmer’s stile and Thorin pushes his rusting truck up the hill, tires slipping in mud. The Land Cruiser is a piece of shit, even if one with potential; when Fíli phoned, end of December, his voice tight with worry, to say that Dís was looking really ill and he didn’t know what to do, Thorin just threw his bags into one of the junkers they kept in the barn for hauling furniture and took off. His own car had been out of petrol; stupid, so stupid; how many times, growing up, did his father tell him to fill the tank the moment it got below half? He hasn’t had even a spare weekend to drive down and pick it up since he got here; all his time is spent working, if you can call the crap odd-jobs he finds “work,” or looking for work, or banging his head against a wall trying to figure out how to get the boys to talk to him.

            Because they haven’t talked, to anyone, about it. Have hardly said a word about family since the funeral, when some old distant relative wanted Fíli to give a eulogy and Thorin nearly broke the man’s nose. There was no way in hell he was going to make his nephew stand up there beside his dead mother’s coffin and talk to a crowd of people who’d hardly had anything to do with them since Dís married young and got herself pregnant. That was how they worded it, “got herself,” as if one person was all it took. It was a horrible scandal, of course, because way back when the Oakenshield name used to mean something, apparently, and taking off into the highlands after a man with no money to his name was about as improper as you could get. No matter that Dís’s husband quickly established himself as the head coach of the area’s premiere rugby league and within two years had made enough to buy them a spacious home. Thorin got the sense that their marriage wasn’t precisely a happy one—he hates himself for never properly asking Dís, but how does one ask their younger sister whether or not she really loves her husband and the father of her children? Still, it was a bit of a moot point, as not even six months after Kíli was born the man died in a car crash on his way home from a match. Probably out on these same hills that Thorin is lost in right now.

            He catches a glimpse of Bywater from down in the valley, coming up the approach. The grey stone and dark slate roof blend in with the hillside; more than half the house is shrouded by the landscape until he comes around the final turn in the dirt track and then suddenly it is towering over him, two chimneys and a wavering, peaked roofline. It’s bigger than he thought, and much older. It is also, he recongises in an instant, one of Ernest Gimson’s cottages, or at least someone who studied under him. The lines of the house are unmistakable, even if it is out of Gimson’s usual southeastern territory. He aches to get his hands on it, to be inside its walls, finally something aesthetic after months of working industrial gigs and pouring concrete for Brutalist corporate suites. Perhaps the owner is restoring it; perhaps there are original Arts & Crafts details preserved inside, wallpaper and finishes and mouldings. Or, more likely, given the state of his luck these days, the owner is some horribly pretentious middle-class tosser who wants to gut the place and turn it into a hotel. Thorin lets himself be upset about the hypothetical destruction of history for precisely as long as it takes him to navigate the winding drive and come to a stop at the rear of the house. Then he reminds himself of his situation, of just how precarious it is. It’s money, it’s a job, and you can’t afford to complain. You also can’t afford to fuck it up, so hold your tongue. And yet, and yet . . . there is a feeling, somewhere in his bones, about all of this that he can’t really call excitement. Can’t say what it is, and that inability unnerves him. He never used to be so unsure of himself.

            Shrugging on his parka but leaving the hard hat with his tools in the truck, Thorin walks around the narrow footpath to ring the bell at the front door.