Chapter Text
The rain is letting up but Thorin still feels it on his face, standing at the doorstep and ringing the bell yet again. Waiting there dwarfed by the house, Thorin is struck by how old it is, more than a century, sagging into its foundations as if it wants to become simply another hump in the landscape. There’s a massive slate lintel over the front door that makes him think of a dolmen; the association isn’t a pleasant one. He cranes his neck to look above, trying to spot the problem with the chimney, but the angle’s all wrong. The wall seems to slope outwards, as if it were cantilevered; it’s only perspective, though. It has to be. Thorin rings the bell again. He leans in close to the door, listening for the sound, but it doesn’t come. Disconnected, of course. He spends a good minute knocking on the front door, rainwater dripping down the back of his neck because he forgot to pull his hood up when he first stepped out and now it’s wet anyway, so what’s the point?
Just as he’s ready to go back to the truck and wait out the rain, Thorin hears running footsteps. There’s a brief silence, and then the door he’s had his ear pressed to is cautiously opened. The man standing in the doorway is a good deal shorter, and younger, than he expected. He takes a step back, so as not to seem too threatening; he can hear Balin’s voice in his head, reminding him, “First impressions for one’s employer are important, after all.” Even if said employer is probably a pampered city boy who’s likely torn up the wallpaper.
Bilbo, for his part, stares up at Thorin while reminding himself that it’s impolite to stare, and definitely impolite to gape open-mouthed. He’s just surprised: it’s the first time anyone’s come to call since he moved out here. Bywater is so far off the main roads, and hidden in the hills, and it’s not as if he told anyone where he was going when he left. So this strange man standing broad-shouldered and damp on his front doorstep is more than a little bit of a shock. “Can I help you?” he asks. “Are you lost?”
“This is Bywater, isn’t it?” Thorin asks.
“Yes, it is.”
“Thorin Oakenshield, then. Here to fix your roof.”
“Oh. Oh! Yes, of course, I’m so sorry.” Bilbo laughs and shakes his head, and takes a step back. “Won’t you come in out of the rain?” he asks.
Thorin glances back at his truck, his tools. He isn’t getting paid to socialise. “Just for a minute,” he says. “I should get to work.”
“In the rain?” Bilbo asks.
“You’re new here,” Thorin says; he doesn’t even need to make it a question. “It’s always raining, on and off. You get used to it.” Thorin doesn’t add that he’s been here just over four months and is still not used to it.
“Even so . . .” Bilbo says. “I insist.”
The man looks so hesitant, fretting there in the doorway, that Thorin sighs and steps inside. “We can get the contract out of the way, at least.”
“Yes, of course. And tea? I’ll make tea. Just leave your boots in the hall, if you wouldn’t mind. The kitchen’s ahead there, on the right.” Bilbo disappears down a darkened hallway. Thorin bends to unlace his boots and looks around for a place to hang his dripping parka. Once his eyes adjust to the dim light, he spots a neat row of hooks over a long bench that lines the entryway, holding a succession of potted plants. The wallpaper, he’s more than pleased to see, is a Morris original: Acorn, and still in relatively good shape. There’s a corner just along the doorframe that could use a bit of restoration, but though he knows the patterns, papers and textiles aren’t his area of expertise. He’s already thinking ahead to who he could call, from his old school company. Slow down, he tells himself; You don’t even know this project will hold up. You don’t even know the man’s name.
His host is bent down in front of the range when Thorin enters the kitchen, and he gets the distinct impression that the man had been swearing not a second before. “Something wrong?” he asks, glancing around, taking in his surroundings: a bowl of fruit on the counter, a stack of unopened letters, kettle and cast-iron pan ready on the stove. The flagstone floors are worn smooth beneath his feet; the windows are dirty. There’s still an oddness about this house that he can’t place, this man is still a stranger, and yet he’s practically aching to put his hands to work on this house, to look and look until he gets his fill of good design. Get it together, Oakenshield. This isn’t a school project, it’s just a job like any other.
“Ah, no, I just— Just a moment, sorry.” Bilbo rummages in the top drawer of one of the built-in kitchen cabinets. Thorin, following his movements, takes in the details of the intricate moulding, all done by hand. “Have to re-light the pilot,” Bilbo explains, holding up a long box of matches. “It was being so cooperative this morning, too.”
“You checked your furnace?” Thorin asks.
“No, I didn’t think that had, er, anything to do with this?”
Thorin shrugs. “It could. Old houses, old boilers. I can take a look. I mean, if you like.”
“Tea first,” Bilbo says, as he clicks the gas on and the burner lights. “I’m afraid,” he says, speaking to the kettle, “that I’m going to end up asking an awful lot of you. I really only meant to repair the roof, but now that you’re here, well.” He turns and smiles at Thorin. “It is a very old house.”
“I’ll see to the roof,” Thorin says. “But I do general repairs, too, so, you know, if you have other work . . .” He lets his voice trail off. He’s still trying to figure out how not to be uncomfortable about asking for work. Somehow it always feels like begging; it leaves a sour taste in his mouth.
“Are you not with the roofing company?”
“I work with a construction company,” Thorin hedges. “Sometimes other companies pass their calls along to us, if they’re focusing on other projects at the moment.”
“I see.” Bilbo takes two tea cups and saucers out of the glassed-in china cabinet and sets them out on the counter. “Oh, sorry, sorry, I didn’t even introduce myself. Where on earth are my manners? Bilbo Baggins. It’s a pleasure,” he says, holding his hand out. Barely a month up here and he’s slipping out of social graces already. His mother would be appalled. It’s rather thrilling, actually.
“Thorin Oakenshield.” They shake hands, firm grips, one warm and callused, the other cold and smooth.
“Yes, I didn’t think your name had changed,” Bilbo quips. Thorin gives him a blank look. “Please, make yourself comfortable,” Bilbo says, falling back into childhood manners. There was a time when he was the perfect host; perhaps this is a chance to regain that qualification. He sets the tea to steep and then joins Thorin, who has wondered over to the nook and is looking out at the back fields and the sunken garden. “What do you think?” he asks.
“Best house I’ve seen in ages,” Thorin says. And then, because he can’t quit while he’s ahead, “What the hell are you doing here, though?” The rain beats gently against the window as each of them stare at the other in stunned silence. “I mean—” Thorin starts out, working through the various ways he might be able to back out of this conversation.
“I really don’t know,” Bilbo admits.
“No, never mind, it’s none of my business.”
“It’s fine. You’re the first one who’s asked me that. I thought you deserved a proper answer.” Bilbo smiles, and slides onto a bench to pour tea. “Come on, sit down. Do they pay you by the hour?”
“You pay me by the hour,” Thorin answers.
“Oh, right, of course. Well then, might as well enjoy it, yes?”
So they sit and drink tea, and if Bilbo doesn’t want to admit that he’s ridiculously, unexpectedly glad for company of any kind, then Thorin is equally reluctant to say this is the first time he’s had a moment to breathe since moving up here. If he isn’t careful, he’s going to fall asleep right on this table. A very nice table, oak with leaf detail carved up its legs. He fingers the joining surreptitiously, noting how smooth everything is, and how tightly it’s still holding together despite the years. It’s the sort of thing he used to make, or dream of making. His throat goes tight and he takes a sip of his tea.
The room has fallen quiet, neither knowing what to say. Bilbo studies Thorin, while Thorin studies his table. Wonders what sort of thoughts run through the head of a man like that, someone who drives a truck with a rusted-out door panel, who has brought smells of cigarette smoke and coffee into Bilbo’s tidy kitchen. Well, he thinks, not that he’s one to talk at the moment, covered in dust from the attic. He’d been trying to uncover some more of the furniture, looking for something to drag down into the front drawing room to set before the window, a place to sit—theoretically—while composing a drawing room play. If he were ever to write anything that might actually make money, that is. Can’t rely on the Baggins family name forever.
“I’ll go up to the roof now,” Thorin announces, pushing his chair back, and Bilbo blinks a couple of times to re-focus. “Where’s the leak?”
“Above the attic,” Bilbo says.
“Yes, I figured that much,” Thorin replies, aiming for patience but falling short. “Where, exactly? You have found it, right? Or is it the whole roof?”
“No, sorry, right,” Bilbo says, completely unhelpful. “I can show you, from the attic. I haven’t exactly been up on the roof to have a look around.”
Thorin huffs a laugh and brings his cup over the sink. He’s about to start washing up when a gentle hand on his wrist stops him. “Leave it,” Bilbo says, “leave it. I’ll do it later. I’m paying you to fix my roof, not do my dishes. I can actually do that.” And he leads Thorin further into the house, down another dim hallway—do none of the lights in this house work?—and up two flights of stairs, and then to a narrow door at the end of the hallway. Though the ceilings on the first floor were impressively high, they’ve been getting lower as they climb. Here on the third level, Thorin’s head nearly brushes the ceiling. He has to duck as they go up into the eaves. Bilbo finds the dangling chain for the attic light and pulls, casting a yellow glow across the long cluttered space. The attic, unexpectedly, runs the full width of the south side of the house; Thorin had been expecting just a bit of storage space, not this maze of dropcloth-covered furniture and God knows what else. Bilbo leads him across the narrow bit of open floor, skirting a battered luggage set, and they come to stand under an oilskin tarp that’s dripping steadily into a nearly-filled bucket.
“Hmm,” Thorin says, staring up at Bilbo’s shoddy repair work. He scans the room, notes the placement of the central beams. “Need to see it from the outside,” he says, one hand on a ceiling joist, “but I think I can tell where the problem is. Might have to order the slate. Unless you have any on hand?”
Bilbo just laughs. “I only moved in last month. For all I know, there’s an entire quarry in the cellar, though I doubt it. Actually, I doubt if there is a cellar. Haven’t found one yet.”
“Do you, er, do you at least have a ladder?” Thorin asks, because he’s been stupid and hasn’t brought one. Still, the corner of roof over the house’s south side is low enough to the rise of the hill that he thinks he could probably climb up.
“Yes, it’s in the shed. I can get it for you.”
“I’ll get it. It’s my job.” Thorin pauses, like he wants to say something else, only he has no idea what that might be. So he gives Bilbo a nod and heads back downstairs. The halls seem somehow slanted, even though he’s sure they’re not, and when he turns left to find the staircase to the ground level he ends up facing a spare bedroom instead. Everything is so dark, between the rich colours of the wallpaper and the lack of proper lighting. Thorin doesn’t even want to think about redoing the electrical wiring on this house, though; the designers of the Arts & Crafts movement may have had elegant aesthetics, but any electrical engineering done in Bywater is probably an after-thought, part of some ill-conceived renovation project by a former owner. He wonders if Bilbo’s having electricians in. It really isn’t his expertise, but surely if he got Fíli to take out a few books from his school’s library, Thorin could learn. More tasks to do meant more money; work, work, work, goes the chant at the back of his mind. Secondary school libraries have books on electrical engineering, right?
The shed is rotting to bits, slanting over sideways against the stone wall that lines a portion of the garden. Thorin opens the door slowly, afraid that it’s going to fall apart. He pulls a torch out of the pocket of his parka and clicks it on, scanning the cobwebbed interior. A rusted push-reel lawnmower, tin paint cans, gardening tools, and a wooden ladder lying across the shed floor that has definitely seen better days. Still, it will do well enough for getting him up onto the roof. He pockets his torch again and drags the ladder out, kicks the shed door shut behind him, remembering a second too late to be gentle with it. The building sways, but doesn’t fall.
While Thorin is up on the roof, Bilbo continues his puttering about the attic. He empties the bucket into the second floor bath and then replaces it and takes down the tarp. The sky is lighter now, as if the sun’s trying to break through, and he can just make out a patch of thin cloud through a gap in the slate tiles. There’s an old rolltop desk tucked away in the corner that he’s been meaning to take a look at, and now seems as good a time as any. Picking his way through the clutter, Bilbo keeps an ear attuned to the slow, careful footfalls coming from the roof above him. They come to a halt just behind Bilbo. A shower of dust falls onto his head.
“All right up there?” he calls out.
“Found the break,” Thorin calls back, his voice muffled by wood and stone. “Old slate, breaks easily. Can patch it up for you but I’ll have to order more.”
“Sure, sure, that’s fine,” Bilbo calls back. Thorin walks around over his head a bit more, and then Bilbo hears scraping, hammering, enough noise to figure that Thorin knows what he’s doing. So Bilbo gets back to his pursuit of the desk. The rolltop itself is locked, but just last week Bilbo found a ring of keys that had fallen—or was hidden, perhaps for a reason—behind a row of books on one of the parlour shelves and he’s eager to try it out. The lock is tarnished brass, delicately shaped, and Bilbo finds the corresponding key, small and warm in his hand. This is the first thing in the house that has been obviously locked away, and he wants to know why. The desk caught his eye the very first time he came up into the attic, even amid a face-full of cobwebs and a lingering uncertainty about his decision to purchase the house. Slotted into the corner there across the room, it seemed to be waiting for him. Holding his breath, Bilbo turns the key in the lock and lifts the lid. There’s a brief scuffle and some protracted muttering from the roof but Bilbo is too distracted by the allure of a secret.
Thorin, outside on the roof, misses his step and slides halfway down, catches himself with an arm flung out to grab the rough-hewn stone of the chimney. The slate is slick with rain, and the treads of his boots are worn out; cursing himself for his carelessness, Thorin picks his way back up to the place where the slate tiles have cracked. He’s never fallen off a roof before, and now isn’t the time to start. He sets about pulling up the broken tiles, making enough of a gap that he can actually see down into the attic, through the moss-covered wood. The broken pieces he piles neatly by his side in a feat of balance—they’ll be useful for matching the colour when he goes to order new ones, and for patching any future gaps. From his kneeling position, the angle is just right to catch a glimpse of Bilbo’s dusty head bent down over a desk. This is the first job Thorin’s ever worked where the client hung around the same room as him. Although, he supposes, technically it’s not the same room. Still, the company, however distant and preoccupied it may be, is almost nice. Almost.
Bilbo lets his breath out in a single push, clearing what little dust there is off the flat surface of the desk. There’s a row of narrow shelving, and three drawers. The first holds a letter opener and a stack of correspondence, heavy paper and wax seals and flowing cursive, exactly the sort of thing you would expect in this kind of desk. Bilbo goes to pick up the bundle of letters and they crumble away beneath his fingertips, attic heat and moisture having joined the decaying work of old age. If he comes back with gloves, Bilbo thinks, and perhaps a better light, he might be able to salvage something, so he eases the drawer shut and moves onto the next one. Only bits of string and a couple of marbles, a dried-out fountain pen. The last drawer sticks when Bilbo tugs on its handle, and he nearly overbalances before pulling it free. At first he thinks it’s empty. Then a gleam of light, let through by a passing cloud, catches on something in the back of the drawer. Bilbo reaches a hand in, gropes around blindly, and feels cool metal, smooth and round. It’s a ring, a plain golden band. There’s nothing else. Bilbo turns it over in his hands a few times, shifting his footing to see it in a better light. It’s simple enough, but intriguing: To whom did it belong, and how did it end up in a desk drawer? Bilbo reminds himself, yet again, to look into the history of his house. For the time being, and for lack of any better place of safe-keeping, he slides the ring onto a finger. It looks a little foolish, with his rumpled cotton shirt and his old jeans, the ones that are slightly too tight and have a hole in the left knee. It also looks a little like he’s married, and Bilbo quickly moves it from his ring-finger to the middle, which turns out to be a better fit anyway.
For the better part of the morning they stay like that, Thorin walking around up on the roof, testing for loose tiles and noting that Bywater’s corroded copper gutters are long overdue for at least a good cleaning, if not outright replacement, while Bilbo putters about the attic, uncovering a collection of yellowing portraits in ornate frames and a series of cloth-bound books he sets aside for later perusal, perhaps over tea. Tea: the moment he thinks it, Bilbo is fantastically hungry. He doesn’t wear a watch these days, and has to go down into the study to check the time. It’s half past two. “Thorin?” he calls out, climbing back up into the attic. “Are you all right up there?”
“Fine,” Thorin calls back.
“I’m starving, aren’t you? Come inside and have something to eat.”
“I’m looking at your rear chimney right now.”
“It can wait. I’ll be in the kitchen.”
Thorin, braced in a low crouch on the east side of the house, just below the jut of the chimney, shakes his head. He’s done as much as he can to patch the roof—certainly better than a tarp and a bucket—but he wants to figure out what exactly is wrong with the chimney, apart from some structural faults in the stone. There isn’t time to be loafing about on lunch break; he’s not getting paid to eat lunch, no matter how lenient his employer seems to be, which is precisely why he never bothers packing any. A flask of bitter coffee and half a pack of cigarettes are waiting in his truck, but he kind of doubts that’s what Bilbo had in mind when he said, “Come inside.” If the man hadn’t already insisted on making him tea—really excellent tea, frankly, and he doesn’t even like tea—Thorin would suspect he joking. But the offer is clearly a serious one, serious enough that when another ten minutes have passed and Thorin is sifting through the back of his truck for materials to build a brace for the chimney Bilbo comes out and taps him on the shoulder.
“Come in and eat,” he says. “Won’t you?”
Thorin studies Bilbo, this man, his employer, who lives on his own in a house far too large for any one person let alone a person as small as he is, a good head and more shorter than Thorin, in a fine but rumpled button-down that probably cost more than Thorin’s made in the past month. He wants, badly, to dislike him, or at least to resent him. To look into those blue-green eyes and scowl, as he usually does, and turn away and go about his business. There are a great deal of people in this world, and he, typically, hates almost all of them. So it can’t be Bilbo that’s giving him pause, which means it must be the house: Bywater, a relic of the last century, a space that breathes dusty echoes of Thorin’s former life, all of his aspirations gathered together into a twisting groundplan of dimly lit rooms and unevenly pitched rooftops. There is something about it that he hasn’t yet figured out, something tugging at the corners of his consciousness, saying, I’m here, I’m here, if you would only look. Look hard and look twice. “Yeah, all right,” Thorin says, and pushes himself out of the truck, dusts off his pants. All right; I’ll look, just for a little while longer.
The kitchen windows look out onto the slope of hills, fog hugging the mountainsides and lying low in the valley. Under a fine mist, everything is grey-green, grasses and hedgerows and fields all blending together, the city just a blur on the horizon line. Thorin washes up in the kitchen sink while Bilbo pours them each a glass of lemonade and carries more food than is strictly necessary over to the table in the nook. Plates of cold chicken and cheeses, a basket of bread that looks homemade, tomatoes and greens and olives heaped in a bowl. “I’d offer you wine,” Bilbo is saying, as Thorin tries not to gape, “but I worry that you’d fall off my roof.”
“Right,” Thorin says, “no,” and swallows, feeling a tightening in his stomach that has nothing to do with the fact that he’s almost already fallen off the roof.
“I’d also invited you into the dining room proper, but I’m afraid it’s a bit unfinished.”
“Uh, no, it’s fine,” Thorin says. “This is fine.” He slides into a seat on the bench, pale sunlight warm on his back through the windows.
Bilbo smiles at him. “Here, then, pass your plate,” he says, and proceeds to serve Thorin nearly a week’s worth of food. Thorin just stares at it for a second, blinking, before he accepts it. “Thanks for all your help,” Bilbo is saying, cutting his chicken into neat strips. Thorin shakes his head, and tears his gaze away from the feast to look his employer in the eye.
“This is . . . You didn’t have to do this.”
Bilbo waves his words away. “To be honest, I’m not used to eating alone. So you can just think of it as doing me a favour.”
A favour. Right. Thorin makes himself drink a full glass of water before he starts to eat. The last thing he needs right now is to make himself sick by eating too much, too quickly. The food is delicious, easily the best meal he’s had since coming up here. Tomatoes have never been his favourites but these are juicy and sweet, golden yellow, tangy against the richness of the cheese.
“So, what’s the plan, Thorin?” Bilbo asks. “How do things look up there?”
This, at least, is a conversation in which Thorin can hold his own. He’s talked to countless clients over the years, even if he’s never enjoyed it the way some of the others from his school did. This is just another job. “Like I said, we’ll need to order the slate. It looks local, so it shouldn’t be too hard to find. I’ll build a brace for the chimney, but I think it needs more comprehensive structural work to really be sound,” Thorin says, hedging, once again, trying to make himself an opening for the future. And then, because it’s the first thing he’s been genuinely curious about in weeks, he can’t help asking, “You know the history of this house?”
“No. When I said I didn’t know what I was doing here, I meant that in many ways. I didn’t come up here intending to buy a house, and now that I have . . .” Bilbo sweeps his hands out, and shrugs. “I’m looking into it. There has to be someone around here who knows. It would be fantastic to see it the way it was meant to be, however many years ago.”
“Probably close to a century, if not a little more.”
“Really? How can you tell?”
“It’s a—” Thorin breaks off; this is usually where he’d leave the conversation to strictly business. But with a stomach full of chicken and bread, and the softness of the bench cushion against his weary back, his defenses are down. “Studied this style of architecture in school,” he says, rubbing his neck, his sore shoulder. “If it’s not one of Gimson’s cottages, it’s very close. He was working around the turn of the century.”
“Gimson,” Bilbo repeats. “I’ll look into him. That’s wonderful, I had no idea you were familiar with all this.”
“I mean, it’s probably not Gimson, this far north. But similar.”
“A starting point, at least.”
“If you’re looking to restore the house,” Thorin starts, tentatively.
“Yes, definitely,” Bilbo says. “Well, I came up here to do some writing, to be honest, but I think I need a good distraction. This company you work for, would they be willing to let you take this on as a larger project? I know I initially asked about just the roof and the chimney, but considering that this does seem to be in your area of expertise, the opportunity does present itself, don’t you think?”
“It’s not a problem,” Thorin says quickly. “I’ll do it.”
“Oh, that’s great. Do I need to fill out a contract, or—”
“We can just work it out between us,” Thorin says, which is definitely not the way that things are done, but why not cut out the middle-man? Even if Durin & Sons has been good to him in the past, it’s no guarantee that will continue. Bilbo has his head cocked to one side, as if he’s considering, or possibly suspicious. Thorin backtracks hastily. “If you want to save paperwork, I mean. It’s fine, if you’d rather not.” The last thing he needs is for anyone to file a report about him.
“No, no,” Bilbo says, his smile returned, “that would be a lot simpler. And that is what I came out here for: simplicity. Or, something like that.” Bilbo laughs a little, and stabs his fork neatly through a tomato. “What are your usual wages? I’m sorry to ask, it’s very rude, I’m sure, but I really have no idea.”
Thorin has a quick inner debate: the chance to lie, and ask more, is so desperately tempting, and normally he wouldn’t even hesitate. He would have, once; would never even have considered it. But his honesty had been one of the first things to go after Dís’s death. And yet the words won’t come, not to Bilbo, looking up at him bright-eyed from across the table. Thorin clears his throat. “Minimum,” he says, honestly.
“Right,” Bilbo says. “And that is . . . ?”
It takes Thorin a second to realise what Bilbo asking, and what it means. What sort of family Bilbo must be from, not to know what minimum wage is, never to have worked a low-paying job. To have come up here and purchased a house on a whim, apparently, and afford it and repairs and still not hold down a job, because whatever writing Bilbo has planned, Thorin doubts it’s the kind that pays the bills. “Six pounds thirty-one,” he says, and tries to keep the sudden flare of anger out of his voice. It’s not Bilbo’s fault he’s well-off, and it’s precisely that wealth that’s going to be putting food on Thorin’s table, and he should really learn to stop being so surprised by how unfair the world is.
“Oh,” Bilbo says, and swallows dryly. “Oh, that’s—that’s less than I was expecting.”
They finish their food in silence, the mood turned tense. There’s at least enough food left to feed three. Thorin tries, once again, to help clear up, but Bilbo waves him outside with a distracted air so Thorin goes back to his truck. He kind of wants a cigarette, to clear his head, but it seems a waste after such a nice meal. The rain starts up again, soft and cool, and Thorin pulls his parka hood up over the hardhat and climbs back up onto the roof. It’s not that he’s ashamed, exactly, of the kind of life he’s living. But when he gave up his honesty he clung stubbornly to his pride, and he hasn’t yet figured out how to react to people learning exactly how precarious his finances are, particularly when those people are as kind as Bilbo seems to be. It’s easier if they’re rude: they sneer, he sneers right back, everyone’s equally disgusted. But this is a much more difficult situation to navigate. Thorin thinks, balancing on one knee as he tacks a cross-brace onto the scaffolding he’s building, that he could have handled that better.
Bilbo stays out of sight for the rest of the afternoon. By the time Thorin has the chimney suitably braced and his tools gathered up, it’s nearly four-thirty in the afternoon. His watch battery died last week and he hasn’t had the chance to replace it yet; that is his excuse. Seeing the time on the truck’s dashboard clock still makes him swear. Fíli will be done with rugby practice in five minutes, give or take, and he and Kíli will be back home in twenty. “Er, Bilbo?” Thorin calls out, poking his head into the entryway. “I have to go.”
“Is everything all right?” Bilbo asks, emerging from the drawing room, a battered book in his hands.
“Yeah, fine, I just— I lost track of the time. Have somewhere to be.”
“Can you come back tomorrow?”
“Uh, sure, but I need to go now, so . . .” Needed to go half an hour ago, really.
“Of course,” Bilbo says. “You can come and go as you please, Thorin. It’s only me here, and I’m usually at home. Let me just get you your pay.” He disappears into the kitchen and comes back with a large paper bag and an envelope.
“What’s that?” Thorin asks.
“Pay,” Bilbo says, and ushers him towards the door. “See you tomorrow, Thorin!”
Thorin is torn between curiosity—what on earth is in such a large bag?—and urgency, and manages a quick, “Right, yeah, thanks,” before ducking out. The front path up to his truck is slippery but he takes it at a run, throws himself into the truck and speeds off down the lane, sending sheep skittering out of the way. He doesn’t look back to see Bilbo standing on the rise of the lawn, waving him off. It’s half an hour’s drive, nearly, back into the city. By the time he pulls into the back lot of the flat, the boys are surely home. He climbs the stairs up to the building's third level, steeling himself for what’s likely to be a cold reception, trying to figure out what the hell they’re going to do about dinner.
Fíli and Kíli are at the kitchen table doing schoolwork when Thorin walks in. They look up, but don’t say a word. Fíli’s keys are hanging on the hook by the door, as if Thorin needed a reminder that he has let his nephews become latchkey kids. This is not the life their mother wanted for them, he knows; he knows, and everyone can stop telling him about it. “How was practice?” Thorin asks. After the first week of saying so every night, he’s given up apologising for being late. Asking about rugby league seems like the next best thing.
Fíli shrugs. Kíli pushes aside his exercise book and twists in his chair to look at Thorin. “Fíli punched a boy in the face,” he says, and Thorin has to stare at him for a second before figuring out that it’s pride that made Kíli talk, not the chance to tell tales. The kid is actually smiling about it. Thorin switches on the hall light and looks Fíli over, top to bottom. There’s a slight bruise spreading over his right cheek.
“I told you not to say anything!” Fíli says, rounding on his younger brother, who shrinks back a little. “It’s not a big deal.”
“What happened, Fíli?” Thorin asks. He sets the bag from Bilbo on the counter and waits.
“It’s not like you can tell me not to punch people,” Fíli says, glaring, though his gaze is focused on his maths and not his uncle. “You’ve done it.”
Rather than admit that Fíli’s right, Thorin just asks, “Do you want to tell me why you punched him?”
“He deserved it.” Fíli scrunches up his paper and shoves it towards the wall. Kíli is nodding, not helping.
“Kíli, give us a minute,” Thorin says, pressing his fingers to the bridge of his nose.
“But I—”
“Now, Kíli. Go . . . water your plant or something.” Thorin leans back against the counter and rubs a hand across his face. He’s damp and aching, wants a hot shower and some sleep. Kíli hesitates, but his older brother gives him a gentle push towards the hall. He’s been trying to grow a seedling in a little plastic pot, a school project that seems like an exercise in futility to Thorin, but it keeps the kid happy. Or, close enough. “What happened?” Thorin asks Fíli again, when they’re alone.
“He was being an arse.”
“That’s not enough of a reason. Did he hit you first?”
“He was making fun of Kíli,” Fíli says, not answering. “I told him to stop, and he didn’t, so I hit him. Then he stopped.”
“Fíli,” Thorin says, and tries to figure out how to scold the boy for doing exactly what he would have done.
“It’s not fair!” Fíli shouts, turning in his chair to gesture angrily. “I never did anything to him but he’s always shoving me around and I swear I never hit him before but he—”
“Fíli, it’s all right.”
“. . . What?”
“I’m not angry. Not with you. You stuck up for your brother.” Fíli is staring at Thorin like he can’t quite believe what’s happening. Thorin just sighs, and adds, “Try not to hit him again, yeah?”
“Yeah, all right,” Fíli says, after a minute. He deflates right before Thorin’s eyes.
“Are you hurt?”
“I’m fine,” Fíli says. Thorin raises an eyebrow. Fíli rubs his nose—his knuckles are split, Thorin notices. “It’s not a big deal, honest.”
“Let me see your hand.” Thorin takes his nephew’s hand, turns it over, presses gingerly along the bones. Fíli tenses and inhales sharply. Well, fuck, Thorin thinks, and brings his free hand up to rest on Fíli’s head. “Nothing’s broken,” he says. “And your face? Did you ice it?”
Fíli shakes his head. “Coach wanted me to, but I just . . . I just wanted to get Kíli home.”
Thorin goes to the freezer and takes out an icepack, wraps it in a towel. Rugby, even youth league, is a contact sport; this isn’t the first time Fíli’s come back to the apartment with bruises. It is the first time, though, that those bruises weren’t received on the pitch. Thorin sits down next to Fíli at the kitchen table and, after glancing at the boy for confirmation, leans in and holds the icepack gently to the side of Fíli’s face.
Fíli winces at the cold and bites his lip. “You’re really not angry? Mum would’ve been furious.”
It always catches Thorin unawares when either of the boys mentions Dís. It’s never with any frequency, always in passing, and he doesn’t know whether it’s their way of gradually acknowledging the way things are now, or some kind of mental slip. “She would’ve been,” he says. “But she’d understand, too. Someone gives you a hard time once, you tell them to stop. They do it again, you tell one of your teachers, or your coach. They do it a third time, you hit ‘em. They hit you first, you hit back, twice as hard. That’s how we grew up, your mum and . . . and I.” He almost mentions Frerin, but that’s a whole other center of grief he’s not ready to discuss, certainly not with the boys who didn’t even know him and who have known more than enough death already.
“I don’t think he’ll bother me again,” Fíli says, and can’t quite contain his smugness. “His nose was bleeding. A lot.”
Thorin refrains, admirably, from offering any congratulations. “If he gives you any more trouble, I want you to tell me,” he says.
“Why? What’re you going to do? I can handle it.”
“You can, yeah. But I still want to know.”
“Fine.”
“Good.”
They sit at the kitchen table in silence for exactly two minutes before Kíli comes back and leans against the wall, as if they can’t see him. “Get in here, you,” Thorin says. Kíli comes and leans against the table—they only have two chairs—and grins. “All right?” Thorin asks. Kíli nods, brightly. “This boy says anything to you again, you tell me.”
“I can fight him, too!”
“No!” Thorin says, and doesn’t mean to shout but kind of does it anyway. Under his cold hand, Fíli flinches. “Damn it,” Thorin breathes, and wants to knock his head against the wall. “I don’t want you to get hurt, Kíli, that’s all.” Or sent to the headmaster’s office, or find himself in enough trouble that the school actually sends someone over to talk to Thorin. The possibilities are endless and all bad.
“I said I would handle it,” Fíli says. “And I will.” He looks at Thorin, his gaze for an instant so much like Frerin’s that Thorin is certain he’s seeing his brother. This has always been one of his problems with Fíli: he doesn’t know how to talk to this boy who looks so much like someone he so desperately wants not to be dead. It never changes anything, and yet he goes on wanting. Sometimes Thorin cracks the door open while the boys are asleep and just watches, two heads, the younger dark, the older fair. It’s the reverse of him and Frerin. But his family has always gone in cycles. This time around, the pattern just got confused.
“I can hold the ice,” Kíli says, and Thorin motions him over, lets the boy take the towel and the chair. He goes to the counter, opens up the paper bag. Bilbo’s paper bag. His mind is on dinner, running through a catalogue of the contents of their cupboards and refrigerator—two tins of beans, half a box of crackers, curry powder, milk, four eggs, some slightly stale bread—and trying to figure out what he’s going to scrape together, taking things out of the bag automatically. It only registers when he’s lifting out a container of pulled chicken that Bilbo has sent him back with a pile of food, and an envelope far too fat to contain only minimum wages.
Thorin’s still standing there, dumbfounded, when Fíli asks, hesitant, “Is that . . . dinner?”
“Yeah,” Thorin says, and clears his throat. “Fíli, can you set the table? I’ll just be a minute.” He checks to make sure he’s emptied the bag, folds it neatly, and then steps outside with it tucked under his arm. Leaning back against the bland hallway wall, Thorin closes his eyes and breathes out to a count of ten. He wants a cigarette. He wants to phone Bilbo and ask him what the hell he thinks he’s doing, tell him that the Oakenshields aren’t some charity case, that he can fuck off and take his tomatoes with him. But he doesn’t have Bilbo’s number—and since when did he start calling strangers by their given names in his head, anyway?—and no matter how much he hates it, how it hurts his pride, he can’t deny that the boys deserve better food than what he’s been managing. They need better food. He does, too. He hasn’t said anything, not that there’s anyone around to tell, but one of the reasons he keeps his beard shorter these days is that it’s started to wear thin and patchy. He woke up one morning to dark hair on his pillow and took the scissors to his chin over the bathroom sink. Protein, iron, vitamins. He swallows his pride, no matter how bitter the taste, and goes back inside.
Fíli and Kíli have laid out the food on the counter, two plates at the table and one atop the stove, where Thorin usually leans. They’re looking at him wide-eyed, obviously wanting to ask him what’s happened, but keep shooting glances at the bounty before them, too. “Go on,” Thorin says, and if his voice is hoarse they don’t mention it. Just load their plates up with things they haven’t eaten in weeks: green beans, fresh bread, cheese. Thorin knows he should tell them to eat slowly, to remember to chew or they’ll make themselves sick, but to say as much would be to admit it, out loud, that he’s failed to provide for them. So he says nothing, and takes a bite of cheese, just a small one, savouring it against his tongue.
“Where did you get this?” Fíli asks, when he’s eaten a drumstick and a wing and at least six of the small, ripe tomatoes. That’s the other thing with Fíli: he’s old enough to ask precisely the kinds of questions Thorin never wants to answer. Kíli is content to munch on what looks to be an entire chicken breast, cutlery forgotten in favour of his fingers. Content to eat whatever you put in front of him, really, whether it’s strictly edible or not.
“Started a new job today,” Thorin says, and leaves the rest for Fíli to connect on his own. Before another question can come up, he says, “So, rugby. When’s your match?”
Fíli shoots him a look that says he knows what Thorin’s doing, by avoiding the question, but only says, “Friday next. Why?”
“Thought I might come.”
“You never come.”
“I want to go!” Kíli says. “I only ever get to watch practice, it isn’t fair.”
“It’s the same thing,” Fíli says.
“No, it’s not.”
“Is, too.”
“No!”
“You don’t know anything, Kí, so shut it. Life’s not fair!”
“Knock it off, you two,” Thorin says, and hopes that Kíli doesn’t start crying. “Finish your dinner, and then get cleaned up and into bed.” So he’s never claimed to be the best at parenting; so he forgets, sometimes, how much he and Frerin used to bicker at each other when they were young. Fíli frowns, the goodwill from just a moment ago forgotten. He chews his dinner sullenly and sulks off into the shower when he’s finished. Kíli pokes a finger into the container of blueberry crumble and licks it clean, lingers and pouts in Thorin’s direction for a while before disappearing into the bedroom. Thorin knocks his head back against the cupboards, twice, three times, and then sets about putting the leftover food away and cleaning up the kitchen. “Trying is only half the battle,” Dis used to say, when they were younger and Thorin wasn’t speaking to their father; “The other half is following through.”
