Actions

Work Header

If There Were Water

Chapter 6: epilogue

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It’s Thursday, the first of May; they are standing under a May-tree in full bloom. They bury the book—Bywater House, A History, by Bilbo Baggins, all the words he does not remember writing—in the sunken garden. As Bilbo helps Thorin dig, the gold ring slips off his finger, tumbles into the hole. Thorin goes to pick it up. “Don’t!” Bilbo shouts, and when Thorin pauses, and gives him a curious look, he only says, “Leave it there. I think . . . it was never meant for me.”

            “You’re sure?” Thorin asks.

            “Yes,” Bilbo says, “I’m sure,” even though he isn’t, and fills in the hole. A single white blossom falls from the tree and lands in his hair. Thorin lifts a hand to brush it aside; something makes him pocket the blossom, instead of letting it fall to the ground. Later on he’ll find it, still fresh as the day it fell, and rub the petals between his fingers, and remember.

            It takes them a while to sort out the mess, all the unasked and unanswered questions, Thorin’s blood on the kitchen floor and ash in the attic, trickling down into the upstairs study. Thorin never does read the book. Seeing the story written out, black lines on white paper, would have made things too real in his mind. He’d rather remember it in Bilbo’s voice, hushed, cautious, telling them all under the barest sliver of a waxing moon: how Bywater was built, so long ago, and how the history it holds grew and grew until the house was fairly overflowing with it, until the house was so full of memories that there was no place—no room—for anything else. And the house . . . turned. The words on the page, though they were typed with Bilbo’s own fingers, are too jumbled to make out, scratched through and blotted, too many letters on the page. Previous generations of owners tried to burn the house down, and when the flames didn’t take they doused the house with water, and when the windows didn’t break under the force of hoses they left the house behind and there it stood, for forty years. Waiting. Taking its time.

            Thorin doesn’t believe the story. Bilbo says he doesn’t either. And yet neither of them knows what to think, and none of that means anything for the fact that here they are, with a house no longer closed against them but open, the windows and doors flung wide open to the late morning air.

             Bywater is changed now. Neither of them can say how but both feel it, in the air they breathe, in the firmness of the floors, in the sudden brightness that has overtaken the house. There is light—everywhere. And everything has found its place. After the rain stopped yesterday they went back into the house and found only stillness. As if great emptiness opened up inside. “I can’t fill it all on my own, you know,” Bilbo tells Thorin, and reaches out his hand. It could be theirs, this emptiness, this space, these rooms. Theirs to fill, and theirs to connect—only connect.

            But Thorin doesn’t take his hand. “I don’t think it should be filled,” he says, and his eyes are hard as he looks back at Bilbo. They are so far apart.

            Thorin takes the boys back to the flat, though they plead with him to stay, though Bilbo stands in the doorway where the lilacs bloom and watches them go until they’re out of sight, over the hills and down into the glen. Bilbo stands in the doorway for a long, long time. This isn’t the ending they were meant to have, either of them, and he knows it. But how to fix it? Thorin is gone, and he took the boys with him, so now Bilbo is here, alone, again. On his own in this big, empty house. He shivers, and steps back inside. Bywater sighs around him, a whispering sound, like turning pages in an old book. Bilbo’s memories of the night and the early morning are blank; try as he might, he can’t remember anything, beyond going into the study Wednesday night when he couldn’t sleep, and sitting at the typewriter. Then, leaving the study, and meaning to go into the kitchen, where he heard Thorin making coffee—Thorin, who he’d been expecting to come running to the noise of the typewriter keys. And then he was outside, standing in the rain. That’s it. There isn’t any more. His mind is as blank and empty as the attic, and he has no more idea about one than the other.

            These are his options: go after them, or wait for them to return, or do nothing. “What should I do?” Bilbo wonders aloud. The house doesn’t answer. It really is empty now.

            The silence in the Land Cruiser is deafening, a roar in Thorin’s ears as he guides them out of the highlands and down towards the city. He thought he’d figured it out, that feeling that he was missing something, that there was something he couldn’t see—he thought he’d left it behind. But here it is again. Is this the right choice? Was it a choice, at all? Here, in the cramped space of this truck, is everything he cares about. How could he make them stay, after everything that happened?

            And yet Fíli  is asking, “Why are we leaving?” and Kíli says, “Yeah, I wanted to stay.”

            What answer can he give? What answer is there? The choices we make, and the places we choose, and the words we say: all of these things, in the end, amount to nothing. All you can do—all you can ever do—is move forward, with all that you have.

            “Uncle?”

            “It’s not our home,” Thorin says, finally. “It never was.”

            “It could be,” Kíli says. “If we went back.”

            They don’t turn around. The city feels dirtier, their flat darker, everything somehow smaller than it was before. Thorin helps the boys get cleaned up—washes the soot out of their hair, cleans a scrape on Kíli’s knee—and then takes a long shower of his own as they sleep in the next room. They are, all of them, shaken, and tired, a little less certain of the world today than yesterday, aching with hunger for more than they can say. The water is hot and smells faintly of sulfur as Thorin tips his head back into the spray. His leg is healed, no trace of burns, not even any lingering pain. It’s as if the past few days never happened. Perhaps they never did. Perhaps he’ll wake up tomorrow and it will be April again, and raining.

Notes:

----------

I set out to write a ghost story, a story about a haunted house, after spending a year teaching uni first-years mystery fiction. I don't think I achieved that. The question of how exactly to classify this remains unanswered, for me. The point was never the haunting, or the ghosts. The epigraph is immensely important to me, and that's really what drove all of this. And just like Agee ends with hope, there is hope here, too, if you're looking for it. I think there is.

Let me know your thoughts? In comments below, or over on tumblr at stick-around-town.

And please be sure to check out the artists for this fic, and their works! Links are in the opening notes. Leave them your thoughts, too; they're really great.