Actions

Work Header

Raven

Chapter 11: Chapter 11

Summary:

Saruman!

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Saruman the White was a very tall, very severe wizard. His eyes brushed over Bilbo without much interest before resting on Thorin. His lips curled up minutely.

‘Well well, if it isn’t the Dwarf who couldn’t keep his hands off other people’s belongings,’ he sneered. Bilbo instantly disliked him. He was just about to give the wizard a piece of his mind, when another person stepped forward from the shadows.

‘Bilbo Baggins?’

He saw a scruffy looking old Man, with long grey hair and beard, dressed in a grey cloak.

‘Excuse me, have we met?’

‘Ah, not in many years. Not since you were a small child even. But you are your mother’s son.’

Bilbo frowned.

‘Do you mind, Gandalf,’ snapped Saruman. ‘My issue is with Thorin, not with this halfling.’

‘Hobbit,’ said Thorin firmly. Both wizards looked at him in mild surprise, Bilbo smiled.

‘Not important,’ said Saruman with a dismissive gesture. ‘Now, I assume you want me to turn you back to your normal form?’

Thorin nodded.

‘Tell me, why would I do that? Tell me why you think you don’t deserve what you have?’

Thorin didn’t say anything. Bilbo stared at him, frowning. Why wasn’t he speaking? Saruman smiled an arrogant, unkind smile.

‘Maybe you think you do deserve it. Isn’t that right?’

Thorin swallowed. Slowly he nodded.

‘Thorin!’ Bilbo couldn’t keep quiet anymore. ‘That’s nonsense, nobody deserves this!’ He looked at the White Wizard. ‘I know what he did and that he deserved some punishment, but over eighty years of this? Can you honestly say he deserves that?’

‘He chose his path himself, and suffered the consequences.’

‘What do you know of his path?’ shouted Bilbo indignantly. ‘You have no idea ...’

‘We all choose our paths,’ said another voice suddenly. The Lady Galadriel glided into the room. She came to stand next to Saruman, looking at Bilbo. ‘You chose your path, master Baggins. It did not involve stealing, did it?’

‘Well, no, but ...’

‘Yet you were an outcast yourself, just like your friend.’

‘It’s not the same,’ Bilbo objected. ‘I had my parents when I was young. And nobody called me an abomination.’ Bilbo’s voice faltered when he said the word.

‘Bilbo’s youth was different from Thorin’s,’ said Gandalf. ‘Bilbo was not rejected by his parents, even if they did not understand the significance.’

Both Saruman and Galadriel threw the Grey Wizard a warning glance.

‘Oh, I think it has gone on long enough, don’t you agree?’ said Gandalf. ‘Clearly Aulë and Yavanna’s plan has come to nothing, seeing as neither of them knows, nor do their people. It’s all rather pointless. We can at least explain.’

‘But is it our place to explain?’ asked Galadriel, her gaze was soft when she saw Bilbo and Thorin’s bewildered faces.

‘I think it is, since we are the only ones living on Arda who know about it. And since it hardly seems a coincidence they found each other, and have now managed to find all three of us in the same place at the same time.’

‘We are not here to discuss this, we are here because this thieving Dwarf thinks his punishment should be over.’ Saruman sounded irritated.

‘Exactly!’ cried Bilbo, fed up with all the mystery. ‘Just turn him back and we’ll not bother you anymore.’

Saruman looked at the hobbit with a smirk.

‘It’s not that simple, Master Hobbit,’ he said. ‘As long as Thorin really thinks he should not be a Dwarf again, I can’t turn him back, even if I wanted to.’

Bilbo looked at Thorin. His friend did not meet his eyes.

‘Thorin?’ he said softly, touching his arm. ‘What is this?’

‘You are such a gentle soul,’ said Galadriel. ‘Thorin is not like you.’

Bilbo turned around swiftly.

‘And what is that supposed to mean?’ he said rudely. ‘I’m tough enough, and of course he’s not like me, he’s a Dwarf. But he can be gentle too.’ Thorin’s wing around his shoulders, Thorin handing him tea, Thorin reading to him under the stars, Thorin with little birds on his arm and joy in his eyes.

Galadriel smiled at him, and so did Gandalf.

‘Why do you not want to be a Dwarf again?’ asked the Queen softly. Thorin straightened his back.

‘I have never been much good as a Dwarf,’ he said.

‘And have you been good as what you are now?’

‘No.’ Thorin hesitated. ‘Not until recently.’

‘Not until ...?’

‘Not until I met Bilbo,’ said Thorin with a clear voice.

Saruman’s mouth twitched.

‘So,’ he said slowly. ‘Having Master Baggins for a friend makes some sort of difference?’

Thorin nodded.

‘Bilbo seems to think you should be a Dwarf again,’ said Gandalf. ‘Apparently he thinks you have been punished enough.’

‘He doesn’t know me.’

Bilbo’s mouth dropped open.

‘Now that’s just ridiculous! Of course I know you.’ But he had to admit that there was some truth in it. There was still so much he didn’t know about Thorin. Did it really matter?

‘Do you think you know him well enough to say that he will be good as a Dwarf now?’ asked Gandalf.

Bilbo pondered on this for a moment.

‘Yes,’ he said then. Thorin would probably never be an easy person, but that was alright, it didn’t mean he was a bad one. And Bilbo would help him make the best choices he could. Saruman stared at the hobbit, obviously thinking. Then he smiled cunningly.

‘I have a proposition,’ he said. ‘Since you believe in Thorin, you will responsible.’

Bilbo frowned, Thorin’s head had come up, looking at the White Wizard.

‘I can turn Thorin back into a Dwarf based on your belief that he deserves to be. But the moment he commits another transgression, stealing or hurting people, you will be the one turned into a bird. Do you agree to this?’

‘Yes,’ said Bilbo immediately.

‘No!’ exclaimed Thorin at the same time.

‘What’s this? You don’t even trust your friend’s belief in you? You don’t trust yourself to keep to the right path, even if he does?’ Saruman asked.

‘He would, he always believes the best of others.’

‘Does he?’ asked Galadriel’s soft voice.

‘Yes,’ said Thorin. ‘Because he’s the kindest, purest soul I have ever met. He never condemned me even though he saw first-hand some of the things I have done. He is willing to be my friend even though I am who I am. And I will not run even the slightest risk that he will ever have to be like this, like I am now. So I absolutely refuse to be changed back.’

Bilbo turned to Thorin, grabbing his arms.

‘Thorin, this is ridiculous. I know it will be alright...’

‘No! You don’t know that. I have never been good, I don’t even know how to. I’ve always been a thief and a bully.’ He pulled his arms free from Bilbo’s grip, took his hand and turned around. ‘We are leaving now.’

‘Stop.’ Two voices rang out at the same time. Gandalf and Galadriel looked at each other with a faint smile, then they turned to face Saruman. The White Wizard’s eyes narrowed, Galadriel’s eyebrow turned up and Gandalf’s brow wrinkled. After this silent communication Saruman sighed.

‘Very well,’ he said. ‘I suppose you are right.’ And to Thorin: ‘Stay still.’

Bilbo saw Thorin’s eyes grow huge as he staggered backwards, winged arm raised as if to ward off an attack.

‘Don’t,’ he said.

‘Step away from him, master Baggins,’ said Saruman, ignoring Thorin. But Thorin clasped Bilbo’s hand in his.

‘Don’t,’ he said again. ‘I don’t want it.’

Bilbo squeezed his hand, then pulled himself free.

‘It will be alright,’ he said, stepping away.

Thorin stood frozen, fear in his eyes, while Saruman began to chant strange words, making intricate movements with his hands. Thorin raised his wings and hid behind them, something he hadn’t done in weeks. Bilbo watched as his friend’s form seemed to shimmer. Slowly the black feathers withered, arms and legs grew thicker, beak retracting. But the blue eyes stayed the same, and the fear was still there when the transformation was complete and he lowered his arms in resignation.

Bilbo stared at the Dwarf in front of him, clad in the same ragged trousers, now quite tight, his broad chest dusted with swirls of black hair instead of feathers. He had thick muscular arms, long dark hair, a short beard and a rather pointy nose.

‘Look at you,’ Bilbo whispered. Thorin was absolutely beautiful and Bilbo couldn’t take his eyes off him. A soft cough reminded him where he was. A deep blush crept up his cheeks. Gandalf and Galadriel were observing him with fond amusement on their faces, while Saruman just looked vaguely irritated.

‘Well, if that was all,’ the wizard said.

Bilbo swallowed. Thorin looked very lost.

‘Thank you,’ Bilbo said absentmindedly, taking the few steps that separated him from Thorin and pulling him into a hug that felt different now. No more soft feathers and wings, but hard muscle and strong arms. Bilbo found he liked this just as much, even though the air was nearly crushed out of his lungs when Thorin hugged back.

Then he felt a light touch on his shoulder.

‘Come with me,’ said Gandalf. ‘You can rest and have something to eat. And I want to talk to you.’

Notes:

Oh...and there’s Dwarf!Thorin. Ah, so handsome!

And, since I can't resist Thorin, have some pictures of how I imagine he would have looked immediately after having been turned back:

https://i2.wp.com/collarcitybrownstone.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/Pinterest-3.jpg?resize=500%2C371 (only no Balin of course, no silver threads yet, and umm, no shirt :-) )

http://thearkenstone-ck.tumblr.com/post/83721291671/thorin-oakenshield