Chapter Text
Bilbo licked his lips. Okay. Time to stop acting like the youngest Gamgee whenever he saw a pretty lass and actually say something. Hemming and hawing and just staring at Thorin would never amount to anything.
The others had been kind enough to give them some privacy, and rude enough to be very obvious about why they needed it (Bilbo wasn’t really upset with them though, but as far as he was concerned; Dwalin’s little talk was the kick in the arse that he’d needed, no more help and meaningful looks necessary thank you very much).
“So we both did and said some things that we shouldn’t have,” Bilbo began, looking across the room to where Thorin was leaning against the wall.
“No,” Thorin said, and Bilbo immediately bristled.
“What do you mean ‘no’. You were-“
“I mean that you didn’t do anything wrong.”
“Oh.” Bilbo blinked. Well this was somewhat of a change of heart. And now he felt even more guilty for jumping to conclusions. “You did hear what Dwalin said, didn’t you? I have to say that I do understand the points he made. You’re a king, I should have-“
“No I should have,” Thorin said with a deep sigh. “Already the first time I asked you to marry me I should have talked to you about what that would entail. But I didn’t.”
“I could have asked,” Bilbo said tentatively. To be entirely honest he hadn’t really thought about what Thorin being King would mean for himself beyond that first bout of worrying that Thorin would need to find a Queen and have little princes and princesses.
When it had been clear that was not the case… well, obviously he should not have been so quick to breathe a sigh of relief and call the whole thing settled.
Dwalin definitly had a point in that Thorin wasn’t a farmer. (Though the idea of Thorin in shirt with dirt stains, plain trousers and bare feet was certainly a lovely one.) “I should have asked,” Bilbo amended, because he should have. He hadn't forgotten about Thorin being a king, he'd just... ignored certain aspects of it.
“It’s my failing,” Thorin said with an expression of most profound regret. “I failed you.”
Bilbo sighed and sank down on the floor. Wrapping his arms around his knees he said: “Not more than I failed you I would say. I didn’t know that the stone meant so much to you. I thought it was just, I don’t know, a stone. Then again I guess a glory box is just a chest, so-“ Bilbo bit his lip. “Do you want it now?”
It was still in his pocket, digging rather uncomfortably into his thigh. And less literally, into his guilty conscience. He shouldn’t be the one to have it.
Thorin looked torn. “Keep it for now,” he said eventually. “I think that is best. There is something …” The Dwarf shook his head. “I am truly sorry for what happened on the battlements. What I said - I never intended for it to sound as if-” Thorin swallowed and looked away. “As it doubtlessly did to you. I hope you will allow me to make-”
“Thorin,” Bilbo said softly. “As I said we both did and said some things we shouldn’t have. I was completely furious with you. But I’m not anymore.”
What Dwalin had said and some time to think it over had very efficiently put an end to that. He was a little upset still, but compared to before it was hardly worth mentioning.
“I don’t think that you really wanted to throw me-“ Bilbo’s eyes widened as Thorin flinched as if in pain. “-from the battlements,” the Hobbit finished a bit lamely. “Thorin.”
“That you ever had cause to think so, even for a moment-“ Thorin bent his head, and to Bilbo’s continued surprise; sank down onto his knees. “I- there are not words that will sufficiently express my regret.”
“Thorin, please stand up,” Bilbo said, then he realised that it was a little silly to ask Thorin to do so while sitting down on the floor himself, even if he had only sat down because he was tired of standing.
The Hobbit awkwardly got to his feet and padded over to the dejected looking Dwarf, gently touching his shoulder. “Come on then, stand up. We can’t have a discussion with both of us on the floor. There is a limit, and it is drawn at one.”
When Thorin just looked up at him with the saddest blue eyes he’d ever seen, Bilbo gently cupped his face. “I’m not saying that you weren’t being a colossal idiot, I’m saying that we both were. I’ve got just as much to apologise for.”
“No,” Thorin protested. “You didn’t-“
“We’re not arguing about who is the biggest idiot,” Bilbo said firmly. “I’m nipping that one in the bud.”
Thorin looked confused. “Nipping? What bud?”
“The argument. We’re not going to argue about that.” He should probably have learnt by now that plant-related metaphors were sadly wasted on Dwarfs.
“I think we’ve argued plenty during the last few days without getting into a competition about who’s the biggest moron," Bilbo continued. "As far as I’m concerned, we’ve both won already.” Bilbo nudged Thorin’s shoulder again. “Come now, stand up. Let’s pretend we’re two mature and sensible people. I think we gave it a good go before coming here, well most of the time, so it can’t be that tricky.”
-
When Thorin had allowed himself to picture their return to Erebor, the death of the Dragon, and their triumphant reclaiming of their home, it had not at all involved…. well, anything that had happened during the last few days.
Dwalin was entirely correct. There was much he needed to apologize for. The memory of Bilbo flinching away from him… that would surely haunt him to the rest of his days. It kept getting worse each time he thought about it.
Thorin stayed on his knees, looking up at his- at Bilbo. “Will you allow me to make amends? Any punishment you-”
“I’m not going to punish you!” Bilbo exclaimed, looking aghast at the very idea. He took a half-step back and Thorin almost reached for him, asked him not to leave, but he remembered that he hadn’t the right.
“I made you think- Bilbo there is nothing in this world I love more than I love you. I- what I said-“
“Is Kíli right?” Bilbo asked. “You don’t want the Arkenstone now, is that because there really is something like the Dragon-sickness still lingering?”
“There is something… not right,” Thorin said hesitantly, because he had spent almost an entire night lying awake thinking about the Arkenstone. At the time it had seemed perfectly reasonable. On hindsight.... “Call it Dragon-sickness or not. Though I do not claim that as an excuse for my actions.”
He could very well remember his actions while out on the battlements. Nothing had forced him to say those hurtful things.
Bilbo couldn’t be expected to know much, if anything about politics, or how the Arkenstone had been in his family’s care for centuries, about how you couldn’t trust anyone who came to negotiations with weapons all but drawn to not repeat that tactic over and over again.
He should have talked to his Ho- to Bilbo about such things, but to be entirely honest, he hadn’t wanted Bilbo to second-guess his decision to marry him.
Being wedded to a King was indeed nothing like being the spouse of a farmer. A frown briefly touched Thorin’s brow at the idea of Bilbo marrying someone else, but he forced it away. He hadn’t the right. Bilbo had not even acknowledged Thorin’s declaration of love just then. Perhaps, it was too late.
The small hand still gently touching his face might just be Bilbo being kind.
As he had told Fíli that night before Bilbo first ventured into Erebor, it was too late for far too many things. Azog should have died at the gates of Moria. And now an army of Orcs were marching against them. The raven had not said who their leader was, but Thorin knew it would be the pale Orc as he knew his own name.
“And are you feeling… not right, still?” Bilbo asked, brushing his thumb over Thorin’s face and Thorin closed his eyes for a brief moment. If Bilbo decided to end their relationship, would he ever feel right again? But that wasn't what had been asked.
There was still a yearning to hold the Arkenstone in his hand, to gaze upon it and marvel at its beauty. Then the image of Bilbo flinching away from him presented itself in Thorin’s mind and he shuddered.
“I don’t know,” he said hoarsely. “I truly don’t know. But I would rather throw myself down from Erebor’s walls then to cause you a moment more of hurt.”
Bilbo sighed. “I’m not the innocent you paint me to be. Again, you were not the only one being a colossal idiot.”
“It was not your fault.”
“Beg to differ.” The corner of Bilbo’s mouth quirked slightly. “Kíli is perhaps the one who been most level-head these last few days. He’s a sweet boy, but I’m fairly sure that that is a good indication that something is amiss. Eggs…” The Hobbit shook his head. “But really now, please get up from the floor. My knees ache just looking at you.”
Thorin slowly rose to his feet. The fact that Bilbo kept one hand on him, now pressed against his arm instead of his cheek cheered the Dwarf somewhat.
What he wanted was to gather Bilbo up in his arms, but… if Bilbo would flinch away then Thorin’s heart would surely break, and he would only have himself to blame.
“Much better,” Bilbo said with a small smile. “Thank you. Now, as two mature and responsible people, I think we should agree that we both have done and said things that we should not have.”
“But-“
“Thorin, Dwalin is right. I was just as much of an idiot as you were. And we both had reasons to act like we did-”
“But-“
“Not necessarily good reasons, mind, but it’s not like we almost came to blows regarding what how much milk to put in tea - never let it be said that Bracegirdles-“
“Bilbo,” Thorin interrupted.
“Yes?”
Thorin’s jaws worked, but the right words refused to come out. “I don’t know what to say to make this better. I don’t know what to say to make you forgive me.”
-
Bilbo sighed. “I’m starting to suspect that you’re not listening to me again. This wasn’t your fault. I’m not saying that I agree with the whole concept that not giving away gold is better than ending up in a war, but I think I understand part of it. It’s like if I gave Lobelia a spoon each time she came around, against the promise that she’d leave afterwards. She’d likely set up camp in the garden to have a shorter distance to travel between each visit. And that girl can wield an umbrella just as well as any Man can wield a sword.”
“You really need to tell me about this Lobelia,” Thorin said with an uncharacteristic hesitation, but at least he was trying to lighten the mood somewhat and Bilbo smiled up at him. “And the entire story about the eggs, even though I think the latter will make me want to put my nephew in house arrest for the next decade or so.”
“Well, your plan was to shut us all inside this mountain,” Bilbo teased, but he but his tongue when Thorin’s face grew serious once more. Right, not the time for jokes yet. The idea that an army of Orcs were heading for them, and that the Elves and Men outside Erebor’s gates were not exactly friendly either… well, there wasn’t really anything Bilbo could do about it. Right now it didn’t even seem that important, because the still miserable look in Thorin’s eyes might be something he could actually fix.
“My mother once threw a copper pot at my father,” Bilbo said conversationally. “She didn’t mean to, but he still ended up with a decently sized lump on the side of his head and had to stay in bed for a week. Though mother always claimed that he was well enough after the first couple of days and only milked it for sympathy.”
Thorin looked endearingly confused.
“It’s not okay for people who love each other to hurt each other,” Bilbo said quietly, and Thorin looked away. “But sometimes it happens, and the only thing you can do is to try and figure out how to not do it again. The next time I’m about to do something stupid because I don’t know better, tell me why it’s stupid instead of forbidding me to do it, and we’ll talk about it.”
Thorin opened his mouth and Bilbo reached up to press a finger too it. “If you tell me that I didn’t do anything wrong again, I’m going to take that as permission to use the Arkenstone as a paper weight.”
“How do you accidentally throw a copper pot at someone?” Thorin asked, his slightly chapped lips and his soft-rough beard brushing against Bilbo’s fingers in a pleasing tickle, and the Hobbit had to take a moment to give himself a stern talking to. Especially when the image of Thorin as a farmer made a second appearance. Only now he wasn’t wearing a shirt at all.
“Apparently she was aiming for a spider.” Bilbo shook his head. “Imagine what she would have thrown had she been able to see the ones in Mirkwood. She’d gone back to the Misty Mountains to recruit a Stone Giant.”
It was a relief to see the hint of a smile on Thorin’s lips. Come what may, Bilbo would make his best to not let it disappear entirely.
