Chapter Text
Before Bilbo could finish drying his face, there was a knock at his door. He frowned into the washcloth. Thorin's knock was louder, and Kili's more enthusiastic. Perhaps it was Balin.
He walked to the door, steeling himself for another lecture, and opened it to find...
"Gloin?" he said, perplexed. As angry and hurtful as Gloin had been, Bilbo couldn't find it in himself to really be afraid of the dwarf, so if Gloin wasn't there to kill him or yell at him more, he didn't know what was going on.
"Master Baggins," Gloin said. His voice was quiet and his eyes downcast. "I come to seek your pardon for the things I said in anger. I was wrong."
Gloin was (usually) a decent dwarf, one with a fierce love of his kin and a sensible head on his shoulders, less inclined to grumble than some, but not overly cheerful like others. Next to his son, who Bilbo suspected would someday prove to be the stuff legends are made of, it was easy to forget Gloin's worth. But when he forced his head up to meet Bilbo's eyes with a steady gaze, Bilbo was reminded that Gloin was a worthy soul himself.
Still, that didn't mean Bilbo forgave him.
"I..." he started to say, and then remembered that brittle look in Thorin's eyes. "I..."
"I accept your apology," he said, and pretended that he did not see the knowing look on Gloin's face.
***
No more than an hour later his door slammed open. Bilbo did not even bother to turn around; if it was not in fact Thorin he would have to ask whatever monster had found him to give him but a moment to eat his hat.
"I must apologize if you took my words as harsh," Thorin said behind him. Bilbo could not hold back a small sigh. Even his apology held blame. But perhaps this was the way of kings; Bilbo supposed it was difficult to believe that you held divine favor and could yet be in the wrong against mere hobbits.
"I accepted Gloin's apology," Bilbo said wearily. He walked from his little bookshelf to the table and rearranged his washcloth on the basin.
"Oh?" Thorin sounded genuinely surprised. "That... that is good of you." He paused. "I think that you should leave."
Had he ever considered this possibility before, Bilbo would have expected the words to hit him like a blade, slicing through him and ripping him in half. But when Thorin spoke, Bilbo found himself simply nodding, as though he had been expecting it all the while.
"Oh," he said, staring into the empty basin. "I... I see."
Heavy footsteps started toward him and stopped when he could feel the edge of Thorin's heat bleeding into him. "No, you do not see," Thorin said, sounding frustrated, "because you will not turn around."
His words startled a choked laugh out of Bilbo; he slapped a hand to his face and shook his head.
"Very well," Bilbo said, and slowly turned.
Thorin stood there with a misery on his face Bilbo hadn't seen before - something quiet and hopeless that had given up on desperation. There were always new sorrows, it seemed. Thorin's face was pale and tired, and his hands were draped in strings of gold.
"What..." Bilbo started to ask, and then just managed to avoid flinching as Thorin surged forward. He stopped just in front of Bilbo and carefully took Bilbo's hands, the heat of Thorin's skin contrasting with the strands of cool gold that overlapped his wrists.
"It is not as you think," Thorin said, low and earnest and cracking at the end. "It is no banishment I would inflict on you. I wish you to go with all the honor of a prince, with as many jewels as you will take, and know that I will never allow your name to be forgotten when our battles are made into song."
The stone of the mountain was cold under Bilbo's feet, though normally he did not notice it.
"But then... why..." He wanted to pull back, to punish Thorin in even some small petty way. But the thought of never again feeling that forge-hot skin scraping roughly against his own turned Bilbo to stone, though the battle-terror of a dragon had not been able to do so.
For a moment Thorin was silent and merely looked at Bilbo. He did not plead or cajole or apologize with his eyes, as he had been wont to do. Those piercing blue eyes did not seem sharp just then; they were soft and melancholy. Before now Bilbo had not known that Thorin knew how to be sad without being fierce.
"Because you are not happy here, my halfling," Thorin finally said. His grip loosened around Bilbo's hands. "You miss your sun and stars and eastern winds. You long to grow plants in a little garden. You desire a life of peace. If you wished for caverns or secret little rivers or a voice in the fate of men I would have granted you all you asked, but these things you wish for I have no power to give you."
Bilbo felt as though all the air had been wrenched from his lungs, but he forced out his words in spite of it.
"What you say is true, but you cannot promise me that I will find all the flowers in the Shire more lovely than... than..." Bilbo stalled, suddenly aware that he was about to stumble across a line they had always stayed within. This was how it was between them; a maze of unspoken lines and heartbreaking impossibilities.
Thorin lifted one big hand and drew it down Bilbo's face, grazing his cheek with calluses.
"You see?" Thorin almost whispered. The both of them had always been so careful to remain within the lines, though Bilbo was never sure what they were afraid of. Perhaps it was the unknown consequences to Durin's line, or to themselves. Perhaps they were simply afraid of each other.
"I... I want to stay with you," he said, his voice high and feeble even to his own ears.
Thorin managed a small, rueful smile.
"And I am grateful for it, but I am not the sort of dwarf with whom you might live on love alone. You think that I lack all self-awareness but I tell you I know that I am stubborn, and difficult, and even when my time is free my mind often is not." He let Bilbo's hands drop and stepped back. Bilbo fought the urge to wrap his arms about his own waist for some small false comfort.
"Good of you to decide for both of us, and spare me the trouble," Bilbo managed, biting his lips to stave away the hot tears that threatened to rush forward.
Thorin gave him that awful faint smile again.
"It had to be done by one of us, and you are twice as loyal as you are tall, halfling. I have always been the selfish one; you shall walk away remembering me as I am, I hope. If you do that, you shall not mourn me overmuch."
Bilbo had to look away. He pursed his lips and gave his head a small shake, willing his tears to wait just a moment or two longer.
"You see," Thorin said very gently, his voice fading away already as Bilbo heard him walk toward the door, "I have betrayed you, and yet you are too worn to fight me. You are a creature of sunlight, halfling. You were never made to walk in the darkness of the mountain, not even with me beside you as your guide."
If I could learn to love you, I could learn to love the mountain, Bilbo thought, but Thorin had already walked out and shut the door.
