Work Text:
Will’s pretty sure that everyone in his life is going to tell him that sailing to Europe on his own to hunt down Hannibal is a bad idea, so he does the adult thing and simply doesn’t tell anyone that he’s doing it.
For some, this is easy. Alana, for example, is occupied with her recovery. She does check up on Will, but with a lot of energy devoted to rehabilitation and coming to terms that her longtime mentor and friend is the Chesapeake Ripper, she doesn’t quite see the holes in the mask he presents to her.
For others, this is a little less easy. Jack is far too busy trying to simultaneously recover physically from the fight with Hannibal and reputation-wise in the eyes of the FBI, but he’s not so busy to forget to have Will tailed. And Will’s pretty sure that tail will call immediately if Will, for example, boards an airplane or buys a boat ticket.
Fortunately for Will, the agent assigned to tail him is pretty bad at their job. He sees them on his trail in the first five minutes and has a plan to fool them within the next five.
He tells everyone that he’s using his recovery to focus on finally finishing his repairs to the Nola. It’s good, solid work, after all, and it takes his mind off things. And since he’s been tinkering with the Nola for a while, it only takes a short bit of dedicated time to finish putting everything in place.
For his first boat trip, he deliberately only stays out a few days. He makes sure his tail sees him buying supplies, but only enough for a short trip. He makes sure he puts a hold on his mail, but only for a few days. When he sails back in and there isn’t an FBI car waiting for him, he takes the test run as successful.
He starts taking more trips. Then he starts buying more supplies. Then he starts staying out longer, and longer, and longer.
When he finally makes it a full two weeks without his tail panicking or calling in anything, he makes his move. By then, he has enough supplies stockpiled to make the crossing and he’s fully comfortable in how the Nola sails. The only abnormal thing he does is buy some more bait than usual, but he knows his tail won’t find that strange because Will has also been going fishing on land and he could theoretically just be stocking up.
After that, all he has to do is pack his things, lock up his house, and cast off.
As the harbor disappears behind him, Will does have a moment of doubt. There’s been no word about Hannibal in weeks, after all. No one knows where he fled; the last confirmed sighting was security footage of Hannibal and a woman Will’s pretty sure is Bedelia boarding a flight to Italy, but they could have gone anywhere once they landed. For all Will knows, Hannibal could be in Asia or South America by now, and he could be heading on a dangerous transatlantic trip for absolutely nothing.
But then his scar twinges. It’s healed remarkably well. The doctors confirmed that Hannibal sliced him open with surgical precision – just enough to tear and bleed, not enough to kill.
And just like that, the doubt vanishes. Will knows Hannibal now: all of him, not just the pristine image of an excellent therapist and upstanding member of society and lover of opera. If Hannibal has left Italy, Will’s sure he can find him.
Besides, if Hannibal had wanted to prevent Will from finding him in the future, he would have made sure the blow was a killing one. He knows Hannibal well enough to know that much.
So Will takes a deep breath, turning his steering wheel away from his normal fishing haunts and towards Europe.
Towards Hannibal.
Will starts fishing on his second day of sailing. Mostly this is so that he can conserve his food supplies for days when the weather is too rough to fish or the fish simply aren’t biting, but also because it gives him something to do that isn’t brooding over Hannibal. He has to actually focus on baiting the line, casting it out, and paying attention to the line, as well as focusing on making sure the Nola is still sailing smoothly.
His attention and focus pays off. It doesn’t take long until his bucket is full of nicely sized fish. Not enough to fill up his freezer, but certainly enough for dinner for the next few days.
He switches to his lures then. When he’d still been early in recovery, he’d been too weak to tinker with boat parts and engines, but his physical therapist had still recommended activities to keep his mind and hands occupied. Will had ignored their suggestions of Connect 4 and catching a ball and instead fallen back to making lures. It had been almost meditative, winding wires around colorful pieces of feathers or shiny bits of metal, and he’d only caught himself on the hook once or twice.
It is one of these lures that he selects now. It’s a pretty thing: blood red thread wound round the hook, blood red feathers splayed around the middle, bone white stone fragments decorating the top. Will had made it while thinking about lying on the floor of Hannibal’s kitchen as his blood pooled around him, feeling like Hannibal had cut him to the bone with words in addition to gutting him in the heart when he’d killed Abigail. He had not, of course, told his therapist this, instead making up some lie about sunsets and new beginnings.
Those red feathers gleam in the sun as Will raises his rod. When he casts his line, the lure reminds him of blood arcing from an arterial spray as it soars towards the water.
Unlike when he had used bait, his lure at first gets nothing. Not even a nibble. Will tries switching to a different side of the boat, just in case the fish have moved, but he still gets nothing. It’s not terribly surprising; sometimes a lure that looks appealing to a human eye simply doesn’t catch the eye of the fish, and that’s just what happens when one makes handmade lures. After a few more casts, Will resigns himself to the red lure being a failure and starts to reel it in.
That’s when his whole line locks up.
At first, Will thinks his line has gotten snagged. He jerks his rod this way and that, trying to untangle it from whatever it’s gotten snarled in, but there’s no give at all. He peers under the boat, but he can’t see anything on the Nola it could have gotten caught in. He sends out a bit more line, hoping that will release the tangle, but to his surprise, the line goes flying outwards.
Instinct kicks in. He yanks his rod up so that the hook comes out and sinks into whatever fish has decided to make a meal of his lure. He’s rewarded by powerful tugging on his line, a sure sign that he’s hooked something.
And by the feel of the tug against his finger, a big something.
On one hand, it’s a good sign that Will’s lure is not, in fact, a complete and utter failure. On the other hand, if fishing has taught Will anything, it’s that hooking a fish and actually landing a fish are two different things, and one only celebrates the latter.
With a fish so large, Will doesn’t bother to engage in a battle of strength. There’s no sense in risking his line being snapped or exhausting himself for one fish. Instead, he starts to release and reel, release and reel, release and reel, letting the fish tire itself out from swimming back and forth. With every release, he gives a little less; with every reel, he pulls in a little more. It’s the most delicate of dances, but Will dances it with everything he has – and after so much time dancing with the FBI and crazy killers and Hannibal Goddamn Lecter, he has a lot.
His dancing is therefore rewarded when he realizes he’s getting near the end of his line. Even better, the resistance of the fish – while still strong – has lessened, meaning it’s probably tired out enough that Will can haul it aboard without too much effort. He spares a glance down at his feet to make sure he has his big net ready for the catch –
And a human hand clamps onto the side of the Nola.
Will shouts in surprise and stumbles back. His rod goes with him, which means that the fish hooked on his line gets pulled further up.
Except it’s not a fish.
Or, well. Not just a fish.
A human torso and a fish tail comes sliding over the side and onto the deck of Will’s boat. The fish tail is a deep, blood-red, with spine tipped fins at the end and gleaming silver veins running down the length. It’s like no fish tail Will has ever seen and it’s also the most beautiful fish tail Will has ever seen.
The human torso, on the other hand, is far more familiar to Will. And not just because it’s human.
Because of the head attached to the human torso.
“Hannibal?” Will asks incredulously.
Hannibal – because it is indeed Hannibal Goddamn Lecter – smiles politely. His smile is a little offset by the hook in his cheek, but the tiny part of Will that isn’t frozen in shock notes that Hannibal’s smile is, in fact, genuine, if a little sheepish, which is not an emotion Will had ever thought might be associated with Hannibal Goddamn Lecter.
“Hello, Will,” Hannibal says around a mouthful of Will’s hook. “It appears that even though I know you well enough to see the hook, I am still unable to resist your lures.”
“I’m a good fisherman,” Will replies instinctively. And then, when the rest of his brain catches up: “What the hell, Hannibal?”
Getting the hook out of Hannibal is actually quite easy, mostly because Hannibal has the common sense to be still where a fish would struggle and flop around. Will – who is far more used to the latter – has the hook out in seconds with a pair of pliers.
Of course, this does mean that Will is left awkwardly holding the bloody hook and lure in his hand and Hannibal is left with a mouth that is now hook free, which means Hannibal immediately starts talking.
“My thanks, Will,” Hannibal says, and he has the audacity to sound sincere.
“Next time you swallow my lure, you’re getting it out yourself,” Will says, for lack of anything else to say.
Hannibal smiles at that, which is when Will remembers the really unfortunate part of interacting with Hannibal. Namely, that to him threats are not only utterly ineffective, but in fact quite alluring.
“I thought I already did when I left the United States,” Hannibal comments. “Have the FBI updated my bounty yet?”
“How should I know?”
Hannibal raises an eyebrow. “Dear Uncle Jack isn’t keeping you informed?”
“I’m keeping myself as informed as I want to be,” Will snaps. “Which in this case was not at all.”
“Indeed? Then you are so far from your usual fishing grounds because . . . ?”
“How could you possibly know – Oh my god,” Will realizes. “Did you stalk me as a merman?”
“Certainly not,” Hannibal says, and Will has five seconds to feel relief before Hannibal continues, “Stalking would require an intent to kill. I never intended to kill you, Will.”
For a long moment, Will looks at his bloody lure and contemplates shoving it down Hannibal’s throat. He’s pretty sure he’ll never be able to use it again, for one thing. And it might actually be enough to shut Hannibal up.
But then he looks at the spines on the ends of Hannibal’s fins – the wickedly sharp looking spines, which Will gets the feeling can pierce human flesh just as well as fish flesh. He sighs.
“Technically, it can be the intent to injure, harass, or intimidate in addition to kill,” Will says. “I’m pretty sure letting my brain cook itself counts as injury.”
Hannibal has the gall to look remorseful at that. “I do regret that, Will. Truly I do. But I – ”
“No, nope, and no,” Will interrupts, because it’s fun to see Hannibal’s eye twitch when Will is rude and Will has to get his fun somewhere where Hannibal Goddamn Lecter is concerned. “I am not here to listen to your carefully crafted excuses. Answer the question, Hannibal. Did you or did you not stalk me as a merman?”
Hannibal flicks his tail. Will doesn’t get the impression that it’s a nervous tick; the movement is smooth and elegant and controlled, like everything Hannibal does is. He wonders if it is the equivalent to a human crossing their legs.
“That term is terribly inaccurate,” Hannibal says.
“We already established that stalking includes intent to injure, Hannibal, and I was definitely injured, so – ”
“Not the stalking.”
“Then?”
Hannibal flicks his tail again. This time, it’s a sharp movement. Will would almost call it disdainful. “‘Merman,’” he says, and his tone is so full of disdain that Will is surprised it doesn’t start dripping out of his mouth.
“ . . . Okay, then what do you want me to call you?” Will asks in exasperation.
Immediately, Hannibal’s entire demeanor changes. He straightens up, his eyes brighten, and his tail resumes its elegant sprawl against the deck. Will knows that emotion without even needing to guess: eagerness.
“‘Merman’ is the term humans use,” Hannibal says, sounding like the word is a badly cooked meal that he dearly wants to spit out. “We do not bother with such silly delineations. We are mer; that is our name. Or, if you would like to be formal, we are the children of Mother Ocean.”
Will squints. “Okay, I remember Father Time and Mother Earth. Never heard of Mother Ocean.”
“You wouldn’t have. Humans have long ago forgotten that they are not alone in this world. Your tales are Mother Earth are fragmented and wildly inaccurate now, but, like all tales, they contain a grain of truth. As we mer are the children of Mother Ocean, you humans are the children of Mother Earth.”
It sounds compelling. Then again, Hannibal’s made a life out of sounding compelling, and the last time Will listened to Hannibal when he sounded compelling, he ended up in jail with severe encephalitis.
Will crosses his arms. Skeptically, he says, “And, what, Time Lords are the children of Father Time?”
“Father Time is who we all answer to,” Hannibal says patiently, even though Will knows damn well Hannibal can tell Will is being sarcastic. “We of Mother Ocean might live longer than you of Mother Earth, and those of Mother Sky longer still, but in the end, we all answer to Father Time.”
“What the – who the hell are the children of Mother Sky?”
Hannibal shrugs elegantly. “I could not tell you their true name; we have always guarded such truths fiercely. And our word for them would not mean anything to you.”
“Hannibal.”
“You humans called them angels.”
Will has not entered a church in decades. It’s been even longer since he’s attended a mass or read the words of the Bible. And yet, his first impulse is immediate and complete rejection – a bone deep urge to shout blasphemy. The idea that angels, with their wings and halos and harps, could be anything as mundane as simply another race misunderstood by humanity is almost too impossible to believe, too cliché to accept.
Then Will looks again at Hannibal’s long shimmering blood-red tail, which is undeniably something Will would have also thought impossible even an hour again, and swallows down that urge.
As he swallows, a headache blossoms in his temple. Will rubs at it, half grateful to experience something as normal as a Hannibal-induced headache, half irritated that he has to bite down the automatic fear that it’s a sign of his encephalitis returning.
“Will? Are you feeling ill?”
“It’s nothing an aspirin won’t fix,” Will mutters. “Or ten.”
Hannibal makes a face. “Such quantities are not good for you, Will. If there’s anything I could do to assist instead . . .?”
“Wellllll,” Will says. “There might be something.”
Hannibal brightens. He leans forward, tail twitching the same way Will’s dogs’ do when Will waves a big stick. “Name it.”
Will lowers his hand from his forehead. He leans forward, mirroring Hannibal, and smiles as bright as he can. In his most cheerful voice, he says, “You can get the hell off my boat, Hannibal.”
It’s like taking away a toy from a puppy. Hannibal’s entire body slumps. His face goes from eager anticipation to utter devastation so fast that Will’s almost impressed. Or, at least, he would be, if he wasn’t pretty sure that the utter devastation is mostly just a ploy to get Will to feel sympathy for him.
“If that would make you feel better, I, of course, will oblige,” Hannibal says, and somehow he manages to imbue each and every syllable with tragedy like he’s performing in a Shakespearian play. “But . . . if I might beg a short respite before I depart?”
Will should not ask for more details. Will also should not even begin to entertain the request. And Will absolutely, completely should not agree.
Will says, “Do I even want to know why?”
That sheepish expression returns. Hannibal lifts a hand and presses it to his cheek, which – while no longer a waterfall of blood – is still sluggishly bleeding.
“Salt water stings all wounds, regardless of whether they are on a human or mer,” Hannibal explains. “I heal swiftly, but not that swiftly. I would ask for a short respite until I return home.”
Will should say no. Will should go and get his gun. Or he should roll up his sleeves and heave Hannibal overboard himself. After all, an open wound to the cheek can’t be more painful than a gut wound to the chest.
Will says, “Fine. But this had better make us even.”
“Even Steven,” Hannibal replies.
It’s so not the type of response Will expected that Will blinks stupidly at Hannibal for a few minutes. Then he realizes he’s staring stupidly and clears his throat. “Good,” Will says, and stomps off to go inside and get out some of his energy on the actual fish he’s caught.
Will makes sure that he beheads, descales, skins, guts, and filets every single fish he’s caught before he allows himself a break. It does mean that his hands will likely stink of raw fish for hours, but he considers that price worth it – both for the fact that he can now safely store the fish filets away and because surely, in that amount of time, Hannibal will have long since gotten bored and left.
As he wipes down his board and blade, he imagines it in his mind: Hannibal grasping the side of his boat, heaving himself up and over, swimming away until that blood-red tail is nothing but a flicker beneath the waves. A part of Will regrets not being able to see such a sight.
The bigger part of Will wants to add a stab wound to Hannibal’s gut to match Will’s own.
“You’ve already got his cheek,” Will tells himself, rinsing his hands. “Even Steven. Leave it at that.”
He grabs a beer and steps outside, ready to enjoy the warm sun and cool breeze and –
And Hannibal is still there. Blood-red tail and all.
“Why are you still here?” Will demands, and this time he doesn’t care that he’s definitely being rude. If Hannibal wanted him dead, he could have dragged Will overboard and drowned him, so clearly, being rude is not something Hannibal considers worthy of a death sentence right now.
Hannibal gives him a serene smile. “Perhaps I find myself desiring some conversation,” he says breezily, as though they’re still facing each other in his office and not on Will’s boat.
“Go talk to a fish, then.”
“My lesser brethren of the waters are capable of speech, but I must admit, their eloquence is . . . limited. As are their topics of conversation.”
“What, you get bored if someone can’t talk about the opera to you?”
“Fish do not attend the opera,” Hannibal says, as if it’s obvious. “They would not be able to appreciate the beauty of an Atlantis performance.”
There are several things Will could comment on in that sentence. He goes for the easiest one. “Atlantis is real?” he asks.
Hannibal smiles mysteriously. “Not in the way humans speak of it. But yes.”
“ . . . Right,” Will says. “Well, I’m certainly not going to talk about opera to you – human or Atlantean.”
“You are still more eloquent than a fish.”
“High praise, I’m flattered,” Will mutters. He squints at Hannibal. “Why haven’t you changed back yet? I know you can, I’ve seen you with legs before.”
Because between the sun and the wind, Hannibal looks pretty damn dry now. Not dried out in a dangerous way, but every mermaid story Will’s ever heard about merpeople who can switch back and forth usually says that if a merperson gets wet, bam, they get a tail, and if they get dry, bam, legs.
“I fear I am still a little bit too wet for that,” Hannibal says.
“Oh, so that part of the myth is real?”
Hannibal hums. “In a way. Water can assist us; lack of water can work against us. But we are not slaves to our bodies or instincts. I can transform whenever I wish. It simply takes more effort if one is not at the desired level of moisture.” He pauses, and then adds, “You needn’t worry. I will not turn into a helpless creature without control or muscle mass if I regain my legs. I make sure to keep both of my forms in excellent shape.”
“I suppose murder is a good exercise,” Will says before he can stop himself.
Unfortunately, that just makes Hannibal smile more. “Indeed.”
His tone makes it clear that he is no hurry to return to the ocean. If anything, Will’s instincts tell him that with each passing minute, Hannibal resolves more and more firmly to stay aboard Will’s ship. Probably because he wants to talk Will’s ear off with lengthy metaphors. Or maybe to try and kill him again.
Neither of those things are what Will wants, so Will glances down. There’s a spare bucket on the deck, freshly filled with water. Will had intended it to house whatever big catch he reeled in; although he’s definitely done fishing for the day, it can certainly serve a different purpose.
He picks it up, carries it over to Hannibal – and empties all of it over that beautiful blood-red tail.
To his credit, Hannibal does not flinch at being suddenly drenched in freezing cold salt water. He doesn’t even blink.
He does, however, say, “I see I still need to earn your forgiveness.”
If anything, that just unsettles Will even more. He takes a few steps back, careful to make sure he is out of reach of those sharp looking spines on Hannibal’s fins. With the bucket in front of him like a shield, he says, “No need. We already agreed; we’re even.”
“If you say so, Will,” Hannibal says.
And then, without so much as a good-bye, Hannibal grasps the side of the Nola and heaves himself back overboard, his tail slipping beneath the waves without even a single splash to betray him.
Curiosity gets the better of Will. He drops the bucket and rushes to the edge, leaning over to peer at the water. But there’s no sign of Hannibal – not a flicker of human arms, not a gleam of a blood-red tail. If Will didn’t know for sure that he was cured of his encephalitis and healed of his gut wound, he’d be tempted to put the whole thing down to his hallucinations returning.
Then again, there is a giant puddle on his deck in the shape of a mer. Will sighs and resigns himself to spending a good while mopping up the deck.
But first he goes and nudges the Nola’s speed up. Just in case Hannibal is tempted to come back.
That night, Will falls asleep, as he always does, to the gentle rocking of the waves and the soft sounds of water lapping against the hull.
However, he does not wake, as he always does, to the bright light of the sun or the waves against his boat. Instead, he is jolted out of sleep by what he can only describe as a racket.
To be fair, it’s not a jarring racket. It’s nowhere near the level of repairing a boat engine or the MRI machine Will had crawled into – for no reason at all, thanks to Dr. Sutcliffe and Hannibal burying his diagnosis. It’s more like a song just off in the distance, at a pitch just barely at what a human could hear, as if Will was camped at the edges of a city hosting a music festival. If anyone else had heard the sounds, they would probably have said it was soothing, like a lullaby.
But Will isn’t anyone, and to him, the eerie music has the unmistakable edge of a lure. The music wants him to do something.
Will’s never been good at doing what he’s been told, though, so instead of following the eerie music, he instead gets up, grabs some ear plugs, puts his pillow over his head, and goes back to bed.
It takes him a long time to fall back asleep, and when he does, he dreams of sea foam and deep blue waves and a melody older than time.
Needless to say, Will is pretty cranky the next morning. He hits the snooze on his alarm five times, and each time, he feels more and more exhausted. His mood is not at all helped by the fact that his sleep-deprived state means that he falls over when putting his pants on and spills coffee on himself during breakfast. Fortunately, it’s not like there’s anyone else who can see him, out here in the wide ocean on the Nola, so Will doesn’t bother to get changed; he just refills his coffee and heads out to the deck to see if the sun and the wind can lift his mood.
And the warm sun and the gentle wind probably would have done it – if Will had registered them before he registered the blood-red tail on his deck.
Will glares. “What are you doing here?”
“I’m here to resume our conversation,” Hannibal says casually, as though he isn’t at the center of a brand new giant puddle on Will’s deck.
“Was that what we were having?” Will sips at his coffee. “I was under the impression that you were getting a hook taken out of your mouth and I was getting my lure back.”
“Can that not be the start of a fruitful conversation?”
“Not for most people, no.”
Hannibal smiles. “Then it is a good thing that I am not ‘most people.’”
Will sighs and gives up, because clearly Hannibal has decided not to take the obvious hint. It’s not exactly surprising – after all, knowing the exact social mores gives one all the opportunities to break them – but it is kind of annoying, because what Will really wants to do is just drink coffee and eat breakfast in silence. And he’s pretty sure Hannibal won’t be amendable to letting that happen.
Sure enough, Will barely gets five seconds to drink more coffee before Hannibal ventures, “I must admit relief that you no longer rely upon that terrible aftershave, but I am not sure that coffee is a wise choice of replacement.”
“Stop smelling me, Hannibal.”
“I didn’t need to smell it. I can see it.”
“Well, then turn off your eyes off it offends your delicate mer-sensibilities,” Will says. “And your nose too while you’re at it.”
“I’m afraid that isn’t possible. If anything, my senses are heightened in this form.”
Will squints. Aside from the obvious change of the giant tail, Hannibal doesn’t look that much different in mer form than from when Will knew him as a human. He has gills on his neck and webbing between his fingers, but his face looks about the same. About the only obvious difference on the upper half of his body is a glittering gem at his throat, blood-red like his tail.
“What’s with the ruby in your neck?” Will asks.
Hannibal’s tail goes still on the deck. His gaze sharpens; his muscles tense. His entire body becomes an expression of intent, like a lion seconds before pouncing.
“Or you can just not tell me,” Will says casually, trying to hide the adrenaline spike behind another sip of coffee. “Since it apparently bothers you.”
The observation works more than the offered out. Hannibal’s expression goes from wary to downright insulted.
“I am not bothered,” Hannibal says, in the same tone a child might declare that they were not, in fact, a baby. “I am . . . merely thinking how best to describe my Song to you.”
Will raises an eyebrow. “Your what now?”
“This,” Hannibal says, gesturing at the ruby in his throat, “is my Song. It is a gift from Mother Ocean; the source of my power.” He pauses, and then adds, “Your kind used to hunt us for it.”
Will rolls his eyes. “I’m not going to kill you and steal your precious Song,” he says in exasperation. “I’ve got enough problems without adding how to dispose of a mer corpse to them.”
“Oh, that would be the easy part,” Hannibal corrects him, since Hannibal cannot resist both giving out more information and correcting people. “Mer dissolve into sea foam upon our death. It is how we return to Mother Ocean, the same way your kind decomposes when you return to Mother Earth. It would be fairly easy to wash my remains off the deck.”
“That is not – I am still not going to steal your Song, Hannibal.”
“A wise decision. As your kind eventually discovered, our Songs die with us. It would only last a precious few seconds in your hand before it dissolved as well.”
“Good to know,” Will says sarcastically. “Let me guess: the next thing you’re going to tell me is what kind of power your Song is the source of.”
“I’m glad you asked,” Hannibal says. He does so with a straight face and sincere tone, because he’s the most annoying creature in existence. “Once, there were many Songs: the Song of water, for example, to command the waves and the tide; the Song of earthquakes, to command the shaking of the earth; the Song of volcanoes, to command the explosion of fire; and so many more. Alas, the war and your kind’s hunts have whittled us down. Now there are very few Songs left.”
“Uh huh,” Will says, because he isn’t stupid. “I notice you never mentioned what your Song was.”
Hannibal gives him a sly smile. “Why, haven’t you guessed?”
“What part of yesterday and today have given you any impression that I knew anything about mer, Hannibal?”
“Well,” Hannibal says, “yesterday you heard my Song.”
Will rewinds the day’s events in his head: casting the lure, reeling it in, finding Hannibal on the other end to his shock. Learning about mer and filleting his fish. Eating dinner by himself and barely tasting it while thinking over the revelation of Hannibal not being human. Going to bed and then getting a horrible night’s sleep because –
“Wait, wait, wait,” Will says. “That racket from last night – that was you?”
The smile drops from Hannibal’s face so fast that it’s like it teleported. In the most insulted tone Will has ever heard from Hannibal – which is saying something, considering it is Hannibal – Hannibal says, “You call my Song – the Song of minds and souls and hearts, of bewitchment, of temptation – a racket?”
Will eyes the spines on Hannibal’s tail. He wonders, briefly, whether Hannibal would use them to give Will a quick death or let him bleed out slowly, for he has no doubts Hannibal can be as surgically precise with them as he was with his knife.
Then he says, “If that was your Song, then yes it was. Tip from a human to a mer: next time you try to Sing to me, turn down the volume.”
To his relief, Hannibal does not do anything crazy, like stab Will with his spines or pull him overboard to drown.
To his irritation, Hannibal does appear very interested.
“Fascinating,” Hannibal says. “My Song should have been enough to make you do as I wished.”
“What, it makes you some kind of siren?”
“That is what Odysseus called us when he met some of us, yes,” Hannibal says. “My Song is the Song of temptation. It gives me influence over the mind, and bewitchment of the ear, and power over the heart. It has never failed me.”
“Well, there’s always a first time for – Wait,” Will says abruptly, thinking back to the sessions where Hannibal had employed soft music and a swinging pendulum for what he called a hypnosis session and what Will realized later was premeditated framing. “Have you used your Song on me before?”
Hannibal’s face remains perfectly neutral. It’s such a perfect expression that Will’s pretty sure it would enough to fool even him – if Hannibal’s blood-red tail wasn’t present and twitching.
“As I said: it has never failed me,” is all Hannibal will say.
Will scowls. “I should’ve aimed for the throat when I had you in your kitchen,” he mutters, biting savagely into his breakfast bar.
“That wouldn’t have killed me, you know.”
Will considers several responses to this, ranging from of course it wouldn’t have to then what would be enough to kill you. Finally, he settles on, “Good. Because now I think you deserved to have been shot twice.”
Hannibal looks at him with interest. “Are you going to try now?”
“Am I – No, Hannibal, I am not. I am going to drink my coffee and eat my breakfast, because I am not a crazy person. Also I didn’t bring my gun with me.”
“You have a knife,” Hannibal notes, and his voice actually contains a note of eagerness, because he is a crazy person. “You could – ”
“Go away, Hannibal. Or I’m going to dump another bucket of water on you.”
Hannibal looks disappointed. But he does grip the side of the Nola, as if preparing to go back to the ocean.
Unfortunately, he also asks, “When shall I return?”
“Preferably never.”
“Will.”
“Then two more cups of coffee. At least.”
Hannibal returns after one cup of coffee, because he is the most annoying creature in existence. Also, he brings a fish with him.
It’s a large fish, to be fair. Probably not something Will would’ve been able to hook, much less reel in. And it is very, very fresh, considering that it is flopping around on Will’s deck like a trout in a bucket. From any other person, Will would have been gracious enough to take the gesture for what it was.
From Hannibal: “And what, exactly, are you expecting me to do with that?”
“Prepare it,” Hannibal says. “And then eat it.”
“I have an entire freezer full of fish, you know.”
“Then one more should not be a problem. Alternately, you can enjoy it fresh, as it is meant to be enjoyed.”
Will narrows his eyes, mostly because Hannibal’s definition of “fresh” was already wild even before Will knew Hannibal had a fish tail. “I’ve seen how you enjoy fresh fish,” Will says. “I am not doing the weird twisted tail thing, that was gross.”
“I distinctly remember you saying that you liked how I served that fish.”
“It’s called being polite, Hannibal. I distinctly remember politeness being a big thing for you.”
Disappointment flickers over Hannibal’s face. The idea that Hannibal Lecter – respectable doctor, upstanding member of society, secret mer with a Song of temptation – is disappointed that Will didn’t like his food is a heady thing. Then again, Will’s not sure what Hannibal expected. He’d always been clear that he enjoyed Hannibal’s more casual meals over his elaborate dinners.
Well, until he’d found out that Hannibal used human meat in literally every dish.
“I suppose,” Hannibal says, rallying admirably, “that you have your own preferred method for preparing fish.”
“Yep.”
“May I watch? It would be very illuminating.”
“No,” Will says immediately, because he’s always hated being watched. Doubly so if the person watching is actually interested.
That disappointment doubles in size. “Then may I at least inquire as to your preferred method?”
“You may.”
“Thank – ”
“Doesn’t mean I’ll answer,” Will continues, blatantly ignoring Hannibal. He takes another sip of coffee, gratified to see how disappointment and irritation chase around on Hannibal’s face. Hannibal has always been so composed and unmovable; Will finds that the idea of provoking genuine emotion out of him to be beyond fun. “Especially since I told you two cups of coffee and it’s only been one.”
“One and a half,” Hannibal points out.
“And what would you have said, Dr. Lecter, if I was at your practice and when you, ah, inquired after my caffeine habits, I told you two when it was really one and a half?”
Hannibal opens his mouth. Frowns. Closes his mouth.
“Thought so,” Will says. “Now get off my boat and take your fish with you.”
To Will’s surprise, Hannibal actually obeys. Well, half obeys. He does get off the Nola, but he leaves the fish behind, because of course he does. Will throws it back overboard, although it does take some effort, and then sits on the deck to enjoy the sunlight and the breeze.
Hannibal does not show himself for the rest of the day. However, Will does keep finding random fish flopping all over the deck that he has to throw back, so he knows Hannibal hasn’t gotten bored and left.
He’s not sure if he’s happy or upset about that. Because on one hand, it would be nice if Will could have a calm trip without worrying about Hannibal or fish or mer, even if he now knows that the trip is pointless because Hannibal is not in Europe and is instead hanging out in the Atlantic Ocean stalking Will’s boat. On the other hand, though, he can’t deny the little thrill in his chest that Hannibal – for all of his talk about separation and forgiveness – clearly hasn’t managed to completely sever his bond to Will, because he’s hanging out in the Atlantic Ocean stalking Will’s boat.
Will weighs that little argument in his head for approximately five seconds before he decides that he’s done enough psychological inner examination for a lifetime and moves on to cooking some fish.
He is eating said fish on the deck under the light of the stars when he hears thud thud thud – the distinctive sound of a fish lobbed over the side and then flopping around madly on his deck.
Will groans. “You can’t even let me eat in peace?” he complains. “Come on, Hannibal. I clearly have food.”
“A little more never goes amiss,” comes Hannibal’s voice out the darkness, because apparently his dramatic side stays present regardless if he has legs or a tail.
“I’m just going to throw it back.”
“Or you could prepare it and eat or store it.”
“Or you could believe when I say I have enough food and also that I can feed myself,” Will says, shoveling another bite of fish into his mouth. “Like, for example, the fish I am currently eating, which I caught and prepared and cooked. So stop bringing me fish, Hannibal.”
In response, Will gets not a witty comeback or a dramatic metaphor, but rather the gentle sound of water.
He sighs. “You know, I don’t know if it’s more or less creepy that you’re a cannibal towards fish as well as humans,” he says without thinking.
Luckily, Hannibal takes it in stride, as he always does when Will is rude. “It is only cannibalism if we are equals.”
“You have a tail and the ability to breathe underwater; they have a tail and the ability to breathe underwater. Seems pretty equal to me.”
“I have a Song and the ability to transform,” Hannibal counters, “they do not. They are nowhere near an equal to me.”
“So no Flounder sidekick for you?”
Even in the darkness, Will can practically see Hannibal’s bewilderment. “Why would I have a flounder at my side?” Hannibal asks. “They prefer the ocean floor, and furthermore spend most of their time buried in the sand without moving or speaking.”
Will opens his mouth with the full intention of informing Hannibal that it is a joke from a children’s movie.
What actually comes out of his mouth is: “What about your human sidekick then?”
For a long moment, Hannibal is silent. The only sounds on the Nola are the waves lapping against the hull and the thud thud thud of the fish still flopping about on the deck, although less fiercely and often.
Then Hannibal says, “You are referring to Dr. Du Maurier.”
Will raises an eyebrow. “Dr. Du Maurier,” he mimics, tone and all. “Not Bedelia? I thought you were on first name terms. Given that you ran away together, after all.”
“Bedelia was useful,” Hannibal concedes. “The warrant was for a man traveling alone; it was useful to be seen as a man traveling with a companion.”
“I’m pretty sure your fake passports had you two as a married couple, not companions. Mazel tov. I think have some beer in the back.”
“It would take a great deal of beer for me to become inebriated in this form. Also, considering your taste of aftershave, I am not sure I would enjoy whatever beer you chose to stock on this vessel. Lastly, I’m afraid that your celebration would be premature. We have been divorced longer than we were married.”
Will blinks in surprise. Perhaps he should have expected such an answer, given that Hannibal is hanging around his boat instead of being in Europe with Bedelia. But still: it had been to Bedelia’s house Hannibal had fled, and it had been Bedelia Hannibal had flown away with, and it had been Bedelia Hannibal had bound himself in matrimony, even if only on paper. The FBI had found no such preparations for Will to flee the country with Hannibal, nor for Abigail.
The reminder of Abigail’s death burns away the rest of the surprise. Will takes a bite of fish and says, “Was it an amiable divorce?”
“It was due to, shall we say, irreconcilable differences.”
“Over what?” Will asks, because his meeting with Bedelia might have been brief, but even that brief meeting had been enough to tell Will that Bedelia was an ideal equal to Hannibal: they shared a profession, they shared secrets, they shared tastes. She’d even known, or at least suspected, that Hannibal was a killer, and yet she’d still come back and willingly boarded an airplane with him.
“On the difference of observation versus participation,” Hannibal says. “She preferred to observe. I preferred participation. We had . . . a disagreement.”
Will discards all flowery language then. He asks, “Did you eat her?”
“No.”
“Why not?” Will says, because the swirling mass inside of him can’t tell if he’s more upset or more pleased that Hannibal did not eat Bedelia.
“I have a sophisticated palate. I’m very particular about how my meals taste.”
“And Bedelia, what, wasn’t done marinating?”
“Precisely.”
Will blinks. “I was joking, you know. You were seriously marinating her?”
“Oysters, acorns, and Marsala,” Hannibal replies matter-of-factly, as though he thinks Will is going to know what that means.
“ . . . You going to explain what those three things mean?”
“That is what the ancient Romans would feed their animals,” Hannibal explains. “To improve their flavor. And Bedelia declined to eat anything with, as she put it, a central nervous system. This diet fulfilled both of our needs.”
Will tries to remember if Hannibal had ever fed him oysters and acorns. Upon finding nothing, he says, “So where is Bedelia now?”
“Sebastian’s ilk have a far less sophisticated palate than I.”
Will fights down the urge to strangle Hannibal. He tells himself that the fight is only successful because the post-dinner food coma is making falling into bed a lot more appealing than getting up and strangling Hannibal.
“Of course you knew what children’s movie I was referencing all along,” he mutters. “So you fed Bedelia to some crabs?”
“They were quite pleased to find such a feast on their doorstep.”
“ . . . Well, that’s one way to hide your tracks from the FBI and Interpol,” Will says, for lack of any idea what else to say. “For the record, I might have been tempted by the oysters, but you never would have gotten me to eat acorns.”
“Could I have gotten you to participate?” Hannibal asks. “Or would you too have only preferred to observe?”
Will hesitates. He had always known that part of him had wanted to give up everything – his job, his house, even his dogs – and run away with Hannibal. But his imagination had always ended there, with them vanishing aboard a boat or plane. He had never imagined what might come after that.
“You’re the one who had plans within plans, Hannibal,” Will deflects. “What do you think I would have done?”
“I do not know. Despite all my knowledge and intuition, I could never entirely predict you.” Hannibal pauses. “What do you think you would have done?”
“ . . . I don’t know,” Will is forced to confess. He cannot deny that part of him still insists that he is a good man, a man of the law, someone who would only kill in self-defense. And yet: he had killed Randall Tier, following through with the kill even after Randall had been disarmed, the stage that a good man might have stopped and called the police at. And if pretending to kill Freddie Lounds hadn’t been part of the plan, he isn’t sure he would have stopped at pretending.
Of course, there’s a more pressing issue to consider. Will licks his lips. “Would you have also divorced me if I only observed?”
“No,” Hannibal says instantly. “I told you before, Will: I can feed the caterpillar. I can whisper through the chrysalis. But what hatches follows its own nature and is beyond me.”
Will should not at all take pleasure in that. No good man should. No good man would.
Will lets his head fall back against his chair. He breathes in the cool night air. He thinks about how, even when he had refused to leave with Hannibal, Hannibal had been displeased, but had not killed him. Whereas Bedelia, apparently, is now crab food.
Just as Abigail is now worm food.
“You fed Abigail,” Will says. “You whispered to her. And then you killed her.”
“I did.”
“You gave her to me and then you took her away. Like Lucy with the football.”
“I did.”
Will closes his eyes. The anger inside him is still a fire, but it’s a smaller one now. He doesn’t want to examine why. He especially doesn’t want to examine the faint hint of remorse underlying Hannibal’s replies.
He doesn’t want to do anything, he realizes. He wants to sleep.
“Good night, Hannibal,” Will says wearily. “And take your fish with you when you leave.”
“Good night, Will,” Hannibal says, and the rhythmic thud thud thud of the fish finally stops.
The next morning, Will goes onto the deck fully expecting to find either Hannibal or another fresh fish flopping around. To his surprise, he finds neither.
He does find, however, what he can only describe as a sculpted fish, twisted and curved and arranged at the bow of the boat.
Will’s empathy is never off. Long as he breathes, it runs. Hannibal had been one of the few to realize that. Now, with Hannibal’s gesture, it awakens with a vengeance, clamoring interpretations into Will’s head like an overeager dog announcing the arrival of the mailman.
I scaled you, skinned you, twisted and trimmed you.
I splintered every bone, fractured them dynamically.
I made you malleable.
Absently, Will notes that Hannibal made sure to include every part of the fish: head, fins, tail. Even the scales Hannibal had removed are scattered beautifully around the twisted fish like rose petals, in a pattern that at first glance seems random but Will is sure Hannibal spent hours over. And when the sun comes out from behind the clouds, the fish casts a shadow in the shape of a heart.
“A valentine written on a broken fish,” Will realizes. Because of course it is. Of course the only way Hannibal could think of to communicate to Will would be to make a display of a fish.
And the worst – or best – part of it is that it works.
Will can see Hannibal’s design. He can feel the emotions that drove Hannibal to arrange such a display. All of that sorrow, all of that determination, all of it, everything, wrapped up in a twisted fish in the shape of a heart, one that Will’s pretty sure would be edible if he cooked it.
He’s also pretty sure that Hannibal is being a creepy stalker, hanging out in the ocean just out of sight of human eyes, waiting to see what Will is going to do.
Will leans against the side of the boat. He cranes his head over the water and says, “I see you, uh, you left me your broken heart.”
For the first time, Hannibal does not immediately start talking back. For the first time, Will kind of wants him to, if only so that Will doesn’t have to say all of this by himself.
But Will’s an adult, and being an adult means doing things one doesn’t want to, so after a few more minutes of silence, Will continues, “Strange. I do feel closer to you here. In the ocean, with no one to see us, nothing but water for miles. God only knows where I’d be without you. Fishing, probably. Or grading papers. Or with my dogs. But you knew I’d come.”
There’s no splash to betray Hannibal’s presence. One moment, Will is looking at some waves; the next, Hannibal is just there, hair damp and eyes solemn. But he still does not speak.
“I know you’re playing with me.”
“I am not.”
“You are,” Will says. “You’re always playing. You – You follow several trains of thought at once without distraction from any of them. And one of those trains is always for your own amusement. But I can’t fault you. It’s in your nature.”
Hannibal swims a little closer. He keeps pace effortlessly with the Nola; a tiny part of Will wonders just how fast he can swim.
“Perhaps it is in my nature,” Hannibal acknowledges. “But not all of my trains are for my own amusement.”
“Which train did your fish valentine come from?”
Hannibal looks at him steadily. “The one that wants you to run away with me.”
Logically, Will has always known that Hannibal wanted Will to run away with him. Hannibal had even outright confessed it, that horrible night at his house. Yet something about now makes it real, makes it sink deep into the castle walls of Will’s mind and resonate like a gong, makes it feel like pure unadulterated truth.
Back then, Will had almost run. He’d only been held back by thin threads – Jack, his job, his dogs, his life.
Now, Jack is on medical leave, which will likely get extended to compassionate leave while the FBI figures out whether to fire him or just force him into retirement. Now, Will doesn’t have a job; he resigned before the FBI could fire him. Now, Will’s life is the Nola, and he only brought on her what he could carry.
But: “I run a lot slower nowadays, you know. Because you sliced me open.”
Hannibal doesn’t even flinch, because he’s like that. “Allow me to rephrase, then. Swim away with me, Will. Leave everything behind here, right now. Make a new life.”
Against his will, Will can feel his mouth twitching into a smile. “Under the sea?”
“Under the sea,” Hannibal agrees.
“Pretty sure I have the wrong equipment for that. Unless you intend to stick to the shallows in some small, sparsely populated, non-extradition country.”
Hannibal tilts his head. “Equipment can be changed.”
“What, you can make me like you?”
“Me? No. But a sea witch could. And I know one who owes me a favor.”
Will processes that sentence. On one hand, if mer exist, it’s not really surprising to consider that so do sea witches. And Hannibal’s already admitted he has magic in the shape of his Song.
On the other hand, Will is not sure he wants to know how, exactly, Hannibal became owed a favor from a sea witch. He’s also not sure he wants to know right now.
Will looks at Hannibal. At his ruby-red Song, at his blood-red tail. Somehow they’re already familiar to Will, even though he’s barely known them more than few days. He wonders if he could acclimate to his own tail so swiftly.
“Do you believe you could change me,” Will asks, “the way I changed you?”
Delight sparks in Hannibal’s eyes. Clearly, he hasn’t forgotten their conversation that fateful night any more than Will has.
“I already did,” Hannibal tells him.
And, well. Will can’t do much but concede that. The Will Graham of before – back when Will had still been hiding behind the mask of a good man – would’ve stabbed Hannibal, or at least thrown back his fish valentine into the sea and refused to speak of it.
Still, Hannibal can never let three words do when he can add a dozen more. He continues, “Fate and circumstance have returned us to this moment. The teacup has come together again. Flawed, perhaps, but still whole. Will you shatter it? Or will you swim away with me?”
Will thinks about it. To his surprise, all of his objections have crumbled away like a sandcastle before the incoming tide. He finds only one concern remaining.
“Is there even a place for me?”
Hannibal smiles. “I wanted to surprise you,” is all he says, but that’s answer enough.
Will leans over the Nola and holds out his hand. With a swish of his tail, Hannibal swims over and grabs it. His hand is as just as Will remembers, strong and callused and familiar.
“I suppose I should cook your fish, then,” Will says. “And I suppose I could let you watch. Come aboard, Hannibal.”
“So how do I do this again?”
Hannibal hums in consideration. He circles closer in the water, a movement that Will’s human eyes never would have been able to see in the darkness of dawn but that Will’s new mer eyes have no problem seeing, and rests a hand against Will’s back. Their tails brush together, blood-red against sapphire-blue; Will can’t quite help the shiver of feeling scales against his own.
“It is difficult to describe,” Hannibal says.
Will rolls his eyes. “Very cryptic, Dr. Lecter. Can you try putting that difficulty in words?”
“As you wish,” Hannibal says, as though Will has the Song of temptation and not Hannibal. “I would suggest . . . picturing what you want to happen and then singing with that scenario in mind.”
Will squints. The Nola is drifting in the waves. With her engines off and her sails drawn, she moves slowly and quietly. To anyone else, she might appear to be just another boat.
To Will, she’s home. And Will’s going to have to destroy her.
He’s already taken what few things have value to him. Some comfortable shirts, because he knows Hannibal is itching to go shopping for him and he’d like to delay that as long as possible. A handful of the fish, since they’ll only go to waste during the investigation or be sealed in evidence. And, of course, his favorite lures.
Everything else, he has left behind, so that no one will question the conclusion that the Nola was wrecked in a storm and Will Graham – poor unfortunate soul – was lost at sea.
“You have the Song of water,” Hannibal says. “The waves and the tides are yours to command. Assert yourself as their master, and they will obey.”
Will reaches up. His Song is cool and hard in his throat, a vibrant blue that still startles Will whenever he catches sight of his reflection. He has no doubt of its power; there is no such thing as a mer without a Song, after all. In fact, the sea witch had warned them that if Will did not grow a Song, then his transformation would fail. Nor does he doubt that it is the Song of water, for Will can feel the waters around him. They whisper to him, like distant birdsong in the morning.
But when he opens his mouth, no Song comes.
“Will?”
“It’s just hard,” Will says. “To destroy my home.”
“Sometimes, only through destruction can there be evolution.”
Will snorts. “I thought I had already evolved,” he comments, gesturing at his blue tail. “Or have you decided mer are no longer the superior life form?”
“You are becoming,” Hannibal acknowledges. “But you remain on the precipice of your evolution. All that remains is one final step.”
“To sing?”
“To be a mer is to sing,” Hannibal says simply.
Will takes a deep breath. He looks at the Nola again, committing her to memory. He had touched every part of her – fixed her engines, painted her hull, sealed her windows. He had made her whole. Saying goodbye to her is not an easy thing.
But then again: he had always intended to say goodbye to her. His post-Europe plans had been vague, but in every scenario, he’d flown home, not sailed home. His journey with the Nola had always been going to end, one way or another. And this way, she shall know no other owner. Will won’t have to wonder if some future buyer is mistreating her or leaving her to rot in a dock.
The Nola will die, and William Graham will die with her.
This time, when Will opens his mouth, the Song comes without conscious thought. Goodbye, he sings, and the waters quicken. Farewell, he sings, and the waters churn. Buonanotte, he sings, and the Nola shudders and sways and bobs as the waters swallow her whole.
At his back, Will feels Hannibal lift his own voice in song. His Song ripples over the water, somehow perfectly in tune with the whining groans and deafening cracks of the Nola, tempting all nearby sailors to come and investigate.
Together, they sing, and the whole ocean trembles.
Later, as they watch from a safe distance while distressed sailors exclaim over the Nola’s wreckage, Hannibal curves an arm around his waist and asks, “So, tell me, Will: how did that make you feel?”
Will rolls his eyes. It’s such a Hannibal question. And it’s not like Hannibal can’t guess the answer.
So Will says back, “How did God feel when he dropped a church roof on his worshippers?”
Hannibal lights up in excitement. “Are you going to – ”
“No, Hannibal, I am not going to drop the ocean on these poor people. We need them to report my death, remember?”
“Very well. Although I must inform you that you will find human flesh quite a succulent delicacy to your new palate.”
“Powerful, Hannibal,” Will says, because clearly he needs to distract Hannibal before he decides that only one person is needed to report Will’s death and uses his Song to lure the rest of them to their death for lunch. Fortunately, nothing distracts Hannibal more swiftly or more easily than Will actually giving him a straight answer. “I felt powerful.”
Hannibal hums in delight. “As you should,” he says, curling his tail around Will’s. “Welcome to Mother Ocean, Will. Let me show you a whole new world. Our world.”
“Well, with an invitation like that,” Will teases. “Let’s swim away, shall we?”
FINIS
