Chapter Text
Later That Day – The Campus library
Will paced.
He had pulled up his messages with Ravenstag1 again—rereading them, replaying the phrasing. Then he'd remembered Hannibal’s lecture. The exact line. Word for word.
He opened a new tab. Typed "art I want to understand" into the search bar.
Nothing.
Not a quote. Not a line from some obscure book.
So where had Hannibal gotten it?
Will sat down and rubbed his hands over his face.
It doesn’t mean anything, he told himself.
Except… it did.
He stared at the failed search attempt on his phone again.
Will’s stomach twisted.
____
The Next Day – Hannibal’s Office
Will hadn’t scheduled a meeting. He just showed up, knocking lightly on the polished wooden door. The smell of tea and books drifted under the threshold.
“Come in,” came Hannibal’s voice.
Will stepped inside.
The office was immaculate, of course. Everything dark wood and velvet shadow. Hannibal sat at his desk, hands folded, a half-full teacup near his elbow.
“Mr. Graham,” he said, pleased but unsurprised. “What a rare visit.”
Will closed the door behind him.
“I wanted to ask you something,” he said, more guarded than he meant.
“Of course.”
Hannibal gestured to the chair opposite him. Will didn’t sit.
He stepped closer instead. Studied Hannibal’s expression. Still, calm. Watchful.
“There’s something familiar about the way you speak,” Will said carefully. “Something about the way you write, too.”
Hannibal tilted his head, ever so slightly.
“I wasn’t aware I’d written to you, Will.”
Will exhaled through his nose, pacing once.
“You said something in class—art I want to understand. That wasn’t a quote. It wasn’t from anything I could find.”
“A personal thought, then,” Hannibal said evenly. “Are you suggesting I plagiarized?”
“I’m suggesting...” Will hesitated. “I don’t know what I’m suggesting.”
He studied Hannibal’s face, searching for even the smallest flicker. There was none.
“People slip,” Will said. “Even clever ones.”
Hannibal smiled faintly. “Do you believe I’ve slipped?”
Will’s voice was tight now. “I believe someone’s pretending to be someone else. And I don’t like being manipulated.”
That earned a pause. Hannibal set his teacup down with deliberate grace.
“I see,” he said. “And would this... suspicion, be something you’ve shared with your online confidant?”
Will didn’t answer.
The room was silent for one long, suffocating beat.
Then Hannibal leaned forward, eyes catching the light just so.
“Perhaps, Will... what you fear is not that someone is pretending to know you. But that someone already does.”
That stopped him.
Cold.
Will didn’t speak. Couldn’t.
His hands clenched at his sides.
Then, quietly, “You don’t deny it.”
Hannibal stood, slowly—measured, unthreatening, but close now.
“I don’t confirm things you’re not ready to hear.”
Will backed away before he realized he’d moved.
He left without another word.
___
Later That Night – Will’s Apartment
The night had teeth.
Will suspected Hannibal. But he couldn't outright accuse him. He could, however, bait his online friend instead. To see if he'll slip.
Will sat on the floor with his back against the couch, Winston curled against his leg. A half-drunk glass of whiskey sweated on the coffee table, untouched.
He stared at the open chat with Ravenstag1.
The cursor blinked.
> [W]:
> Funny thing happened today.
>
> My professor said something. Almost *exactly* like something you’ve said to me before.
He paused.
Watched the screen like it might blink back.
Then added:
> [W]:
> Weird coincidence, right?
The typing bubble appeared.
> [Ravenstag1]:
> Coincidences are rarely as accidental as we want them to be.
Will’s heart skipped—because it sounded like something Hannibal would say. The same patient confidence. The same invitation to look deeper.
He stared, letting the silence stretch before he typed again. This time, careful.
> [W]:
> He said I reminded him of something unfinished.
>
> Something he wanted to… understand.
It was a lie.
Hannibal hadn’t said that part aloud. But Will wanted to *see* if the man behind the messages would take the bait. Would recognize his own unsaid thoughts.
The pause was longer this time.
Then:
> [Ravenstag1]:
> He sounds insightful.
>
> Maybe he sees something others miss.
Will exhaled.
Carefully. Slowly.
> [W]:
> Do you see something?
Another pause. Will waited, jaw tense.
Then the reply came—
Soft. Direct. Too close.
> [Ravenstag1]:
> I see you.
>
> And I know how easy it is to pretend no one can.
Will stared at the screen, heartbeat in his ears.
That wasn't a flirtation anymore.
It was something else—something aware.
> [W]:
> If you were him… would you tell me?
> [Ravenstag1]:
>
> I would wait.
>
> Until you asked me not out of suspicion—
>
> but desire.
Will closed his eyes.
Something twisted deep inside him. A low pull of fear, of thrill.
He didn’t know what he wanted more:
To be wrong.
Or to be right.
