Actions

Work Header

The Oddly Charming Professor

Chapter 5: Honesty and Desire

Chapter Text

Later That Night

Will’s Apartment – 2:03 a.m.

 

He couldn't sleep. Again.  

 

The apartment was quiet, save for the low hum of the radiator and Winston’s gentle breathing at the foot of the bed. Will lay flat on his back, staring at the ceiling, every nerve raw.  

 

He kept hearing the words.  

“That was you, unchained.”

“It was a courtship.” 

“You’ve been speaking to me honestly for weeks.”

 

His laptop sat on the nightstand, screen still open to the private messages. He hadn’t deleted them. He’d thought about it—more than once—but his fingers wouldn’t let him.  

 

He scrolled. Again.  

 

There it was. The first time Ravenstag1 had used the quote:  

“Loneliness is the tax we pay to be different.”

Will had responded with:  

“Then I must be paying in advance.”

And the reply:  

“Or collecting interest.”

 

It had felt like being seen.  

Now it felt like being studied.  

 

But…  

God help him—  

It still felt like being seen.  

 

Will closed the laptop. Sat up. Ran a hand through his hair, jaw clenched so hard it ached.  

 

There had been something else in Hannibal’s voice, back in that seminar room. Not just manipulation. Not just arrogance.  

 

It was the certainty.  

 

Hannibal had known that Will wouldn’t report him. That he wouldn’t storm out and file a complaint.  

 

And he was right.  

 

Because Will didn’t want to blow it all up. Not yet.  

Because he wanted to know.  

 

Know what else Hannibal had seen.  

Know why he’d done it.  

Know what he meant by “courtship.” 

 

And worse—Will wanted to know what would happen if he leaned into it.  

 

He stood.  

 

Grabbed a hoodie, slipped on his boots. Winston stirred but didn’t rise.  

 

Will stepped out into the night. Cold. Damp. He didn’t check the time. He already knew where he was going.  

 

---

 

Hannibal’s Townhouse – 2:41 a.m.

 

The lights were on. Not glaring—just a few lamps inside, enough to bathe the windows in amber. Like it was waiting for him.  

 

Will hesitated on the step, hand hovering over the doorbell.  

 

Then the door opened.  

 

Hannibal stood there, dressed, as though he'd never gone to bed. Not surprised. Not smug. Just… expectant.  

 

“You couldn’t sleep,” he said.  

 

Will’s throat felt tight. “You were waiting.”  

 

“I hoped,” Hannibal corrected. He stepped aside. “Come in, Will.”  

 

Will hesitated.  

 

Then—  

He crossed the threshold.  

 

Hannibal closed the door behind him.  

 

Not a word exchanged for several long seconds.  

 

Then:  

 

“Tell me the truth,” Will said, turning to face him. “Why me?”  

 

Hannibal’s gaze didn’t waver. “Because you fascinate me. Because you ache in ways I understand. And because”—his voice dropped—“you look at darkness, and don’t look away.”  

 

Will stood there, breathing hard, unsure if he was burning or freezing.  

 

“Is this about power?” he asked. “Is this about control?”  

 

Hannibal stepped closer—slow, deliberate. “No. It’s about recognition.”  

 

They stood in silence, breath close, the air electric.  

 

Will didn’t move. Didn’t speak.  

 

And Hannibal waited—just like before—watching to see what Will would do when the boundary was his to hold.  

 

And maybe to break.

 

Will didn’t step back.  

 

That was the first betrayal.  

Not to Hannibal.  

To himself.  

 

He should’ve moved. Should’ve created space.  

Instead, he stood still, letting the heat of Hannibal’s nearness sink into his skin like poison wrapped in silk.  

 

“I shouldn’t be here,” he said, barely above a whisper.  

 

“No,” Hannibal agreed. “But you are.”  

 

Will’s eyes flicked to his. Searching. Wary.  

“Are you going to pretend this is normal?”  

 

“Nothing about you has ever been ordinary,” Hannibal replied. “Why should this be?”  

 

There was a flicker in Will’s eyes—shame, maybe. Or the last flicker of resistance before it gave way to something older.  

He turned away. Pacing. Hands on his hips, breath ragged.  

 

“You didn’t just watch me. You guided me. Every message—every word—it was calculated.”  

 

“I never lied,” Hannibal said softly. “Everything I wrote was sincere.”  

 

Will whipped around, voice sharp. “But you hid behind it.”  

 

“I listened.” Hannibal took a careful step forward. “When no one else could hear you. I gave you something you never allowed yourself: to be known.”  

 

Will hated how true that felt.  

Hated how the words curled into his chest and fit.

 

He dragged a hand down his face. “You’re my professor.”  

 

“And you are free to walk away.” Hannibal’s tone was maddeningly calm. “Right now. No consequences. No retaliation. I won’t stop you.”  

 

Will stood there, frozen, every nerve screaming at him to move.  

To do something.  

 

But what rooted him wasn’t confusion.  

It was curiosity.

And the terrible, aching pull he couldn’t explain.  

 

“I read those messages,” he said. “Over and over. Even after they stopped.”  

 

“I know.” Hannibal’s voice was gentle. Almost reverent. “So did I.”  

 

Silence pressed between them again. Not empty—never empty—but dense with possibility.  

 

And then Will said, almost inaudibly:  

“Say it.”  

 

Hannibal’s eyes met his. “Say what?”  

 

“That it was me. From the start. That you wanted me.”  

 

A breath.  

Then:  

 

“I wanted you,” Hannibal said. “Every version of you. The fractured. The lonely. The brilliant. The cruel.”  

He stepped closer. Slowly. “And I still do.”  

 

Will didn’t move.  

 

But he didn’t leave, either.  

 

He just stood there, caught between gravity and instinct—  

between the man in front of him  

and the line he'd already crossed.

He exhaled. Slow. Shaky.

Like letting out something he’d been holding in for far too long.

 

“I don’t know what this is,” he said.

But even that was a lie.

He did know.

 

It was attraction. It was fear. It was a hunger that scared him more than anything else in his life—

Because it didn’t come from someone else.

 

It came from him.

 

Hannibal watched, still and patient as a tide. “You don’t need to name it. Not tonight.”

 

“You keep doing that,” Will muttered. “Giving me the out.”

 

“It’s not an out. It’s a choice.”

 

Will’s jaw clenched. “You act like this is some… mutual dance. Like I had any idea what you were doing.”

 

“You did,” Hannibal said gently. “Even if you didn’t want to admit it. Part of you always knew.”

 

Will swallowed hard, throat thick with heat and shame and something dangerously close to longing.

 

He hated him.

He wanted him.

He didn’t trust him.

He couldn’t stop needing to be near him.

 

He stepped back—just a little. Not retreating. Re-centering.

 

“I don’t trust you,” he said.

 

“Good,” Hannibal said. “That’s the beginning of honesty.”

 

Will laughed once. Short. Bitter. “You really don’t care what this does to me, do you?”

 

Hannibal tilted his head. “I care deeply. But I won’t protect you from yourself.”

 

The room felt too warm suddenly. The quiet too heavy. Will turned away again, pacing to the bookshelves, brushing his fingers across the spines like they could ground him.

 

“How many others?” he asked.

 

Hannibal didn’t misunderstand. “None. Not like this.”

 

Will’s voice was quiet. “But others.”

 

A pause.

Then: “Yes.”

 

Will’s eyes closed. Not from surprise, but from something deeper. A weight. A history he wasn’t sure he wanted to inherit.

 

“Why keep pretending?” he asked. “Why not just admit it—this whole thing was a game to you.”

 

“It wasn’t a game.” Hannibal’s voice was firmer now. “It was a message. A pattern. A design.”

 

Will turned slowly, something sharp in his gaze now. “You mean like a killer leaves behind.”

 

Hannibal didn’t deny it.

 

Instead, he stepped forward again—careful, precise—and reached up, brushing a strand of hair from Will’s brow.

 

“You are the only one who’s ever seen it.”

 

Will didn’t pull away.

Didn’t lean in.

Just stood there, like a man watching the ocean creep toward his toes, knowing the tide won’t stop.

 

“What happens now?” he asked.

 

“That depends on you,” Hannibal said. “On whether you keep walking into the dark… or turn on the light.”

 

“And what if I want both?”

 

Hannibal’s expression didn’t change, but something in his eyes softened—something rare.

 

“Then you understand me more than anyone ever has.”

 

Will’s breath hitched. The air was thick again.

He didn’t know who moved first—

Only that the kiss didn’t happen all at once.

 

It was the kind that built itself—slow, deliberate, formed from the space they didn’t take earlier. From every word, every withheld breath, every time Will had almost leaned in.

 

This time, he didn’t stop himself.

This time, neither of them blinked.

 

Will’s hand came up first, fingers brushing Hannibal’s jaw. Testing. Searching. Like he didn’t quite believe he could touch him and still be himself afterward.

 

And maybe he wouldn’t be.

 

Hannibal didn’t move—not to press or take. Just to receive.

He let Will come to him.

 

Their mouths met.

 

Not rough. Not frenzied.

But intimate.

Too intimate.

 

It felt like confession. Like exposure. Like peeling skin.

 

Will’s breath caught as Hannibal’s hands rose, not possessive, but anchoring—one settling lightly at the curve of Will’s waist, the other trailing up between his shoulder blades.

 

Will shuddered. He hated how good it felt.

He hated how right it felt.

 

Because none of this should feel safe.

And yet—it did.

 

He pushed in harder then, like if he could just get closer, he could drown out the part of his brain screaming that this was wrong, that this was dangerous, that this man had gotten inside his head and rewired something fundamental.

 

Hannibal let him. Matched him. Returned the kiss with quiet reverence—like he was tasting something rare, something fragile. Like he was memorizing Will’s breath with his own.

 

Will’s hands found Hannibal’s collar, fisted it. His control was slipping. Or maybe he was giving it away.

He broke the kiss, panting, forehead pressed to Hannibal’s.

 

“I don’t know who I am with you,” he whispered.

 

Hannibal’s voice was silk and steel. “You are exactly who you’ve always been. I simply see it.”

 

Will’s eyes flicked open. Blown wide. Dark. There was something frantic in them now—something hungry and afraid.

 

“I want—” he started. But the sentence broke, unfinished.

 

Hannibal brushed a thumb under Will’s eye, soft as breath. “Then take.”

 

Will surged forward again, mouth on Hannibal’s neck this time, hands mapping him like he could decode the mystery with touch alone.

It was messy. Human. Uncontained.

 

Hannibal’s breath hitched, but he didn’t stop him.

 

The tension between them—months in the making—was finally moving.

 

Will pushed Hannibal back step by step, until they reached the edge of the sofa.

He didn’t think. Didn’t hesitate. Just pressed him down into it, following after, knees straddling Hannibal’s thighs.

 

They kissed again. Deeper this time. More urgent.

 

Hands in hair. Hands under shirts.

 

It wasn’t about seduction.

It was about answering.

 

Everything they hadn’t said—everything they had—spoken now in breath and skin and touch.

 

Will wasn’t

careful.

Hannibal didn’t ask him to be.

 

Buttons undone. Layers peeled away.

The dark pressing in through the windows.

The lamp casting everything in amber and shadow.

 

Will paused only once, breathing heavy, eyes locked on Hannibal’s. “Tell me to stop.”

 

And Hannibal, voice rough and quiet, replied:

“I won’t.”