Chapter Text
There was the tingle again.
The last of the familiar sting was hours ago… when the world swayed while the men around me stood still. I thought I had escaped it but I didn’t. It was back again, creeping under my toenails like slender wooden spikes digging deep into my bone.
I should feel safer, now that I was sleeping, presumably near Mads, especially after the confrontation with Hannibal. The doctor had his signature dread over me, even in this state. Like a shadow weighing much like a damned sarcophagus. I knew in my heart that I was safe, that he was not here. But safety didn’t mean I was free from pain.
Eurybia lycisca. A fun fact wedged in my brain from middle school. A butterfly with a proboscis twice the length of its body. It is found mostly near the equator, in regions around Mexico and the Caribbean. My biology teacher had once taken us to visit an entomologist, allowing us goofy little kids a firsthand look at the strange creatures.
“Their wings have eyes!” I had once commented, pressing my prepubescent nose to the cold, misty glass of the terrarium.
I knew those false eyes were not supposed to blink. Back then, it didn’t.
So, why now?
I stared at the pair of butterflies perched on my toes, their wings fanning slowly, in sync with the pulse hammering beneath my skin. I knew I was sleeping, but it didn’t make it less reassuring. The beautiful butterflies, large as a man’s palm, still fluttered like delicate yet terrific feathers all over my feet.
The pain sharpened, the source suddenly and irrevocably undeniable. The semi-transparent straws of their mouths—as scientifically inaccurate as it may seem—pierced under my nails, drinking deeply. Greedily. Insatiably. Relentlessly. My blood crept, like warm chocolate, through their tiny bodies, staining their once-blue and brown wings—first purple, and then finally, red.
The false eyes on their wings blinked at me. Taunting.
My feet began to shrivel.
I gasped, jerking my legs, but the butterflies clung closer, the spines in their little legs digging deeper. Their swollen forms pulsed, growing darker with blood every second. Greedy little thousand eyes in those beady spheres quivered atop their ballooning thoraces. Their little suckers were turning my shriveling feet grayer. I kicked my feet into the air.
Kick, kick, kick. It was no use. And then…
Pop!
No more wings. No more blinking eyes. The butterflies imploded . For a second, I saw a flash of black and red. Concurrently, I detected the faintest hint of chloroform and ammonia mixed with blood. It was incomprehensible. I could not bring it back to my vision. The red blood? Sprayed into the unseen, leaving only the vast, blue sky overhead. Mads and Hugh peered closer, hovering over me like exhausted, grim-faced planets.
“You were dreaming.”
The two men, each with distinguishable pairs of eyes, regarded me. Hugh’s eyes—almond, haunted, ever-changing in color—darkened and lightened every time a huge cumulus passed over us. One moment, he was looking. The next, his eyes were fixed on the zooming clouds. Mads’ eyes—gentle yet foreboding, warm yet suffocating with its heat—stared at my face for a long second until he joined Hugh in staring at the big blue sky.
There was only silence. Hugh sat next to me, the smell of dog, sweat, and pine seeping into my nostrils. He was wearing a blue sweater, which I could never understand. I always felt hot. Even the first time we met, I believe he was wearing a sweater. I could believe it was years ago.
The air felt dry and smoldering. It was as if I was lying in the desert, except under me was the crawling, slightly itchy ivy instead of the soft, traitorous sands of Arabia. The air picked up again, this time with the whirl of sand from the imaginary desert. We were not close to any shore but the grains kept buffing my withered, dry soles.
“Even now, I feel like I’m dreaming,” I whispered, earning a tilt of Mads’ head in my direction.
Mads didn’t say anything. He just sighed, pulling a stick of cigarette from his pants. Hugh, perhaps feeling the crawling ivy underneath us, abruptly stood up, tugging at Mads’ windbreaker for a stick of his own.
There was another pause. The two men—these two, poor men—had just seen Hannibal Lecter.
As if reading my thoughts, Hugh grinned despite himself, “Can’t fucking believe it. Hannibal and Will… living and breathing as themselves.”
Mads nodded, his eyes scanning the horizon for any sign of the doctor. “Let’s hope we don’t see them again.”
“It’s impossible, now that we’re in it.” Hugh huffed out a huge cloud. I remained lying on the ivy as the two men exchanged embers of their limping sticks. Even if I wanted to stand or sit, I was sure the butterflies had already emaciated my flesh from the thighs down.
“You’re asking for the impossible, Mads,” Hugh continued, the green in his eyes turning blue, turning his earthen irises to me, “madness, as we know, is infectious. We learned that from the show.”
“Am I?” Mads murmured, his eyes once again tracing my face. After surviving Hannibal Lecter, I was back to thinking Mads was just Hannibal in disguise. But this man saved me from the doctor. I was sure of that. And when he smiled at me just now, I knew—or, at least, hoped I knew—that the doctor could not replicate that smile.
The stain on his fanged teeth. The windbreaker. The casual look. They were all Mads. They were not Hannibal. I dutifully reminded myself of that ever since I saw Hannibal separate from him. It was like a chant, an ululation, a prayer.
He’s not him. He’s not him. He’s not him. He’s not him. He’s not him.
“You’re overthinking, Amelia,” said Mads once more, again in that cruel yet gentle tone of the monster. I don’t know how he does it, but I guess he could sense when my mind went haywire with doubts. Hah, now if only he could stop sounding like him, too.
“We’ll think of ways to help you.”
“Can you please stop that?” I asked, snapped, and demanded. No longer my feet looked withered from the butterflies, but the pinpricks of the sharp grass blades and ivies still pinched my skin.
“Stop what?” Hugh tilted his head, his eyebrows meeting and parting to an arch.
“That… thing. He is doing that thing again.” My finger pointed accusingly at Mads. “You sound so much like him.”
Mads didn’t want to be a witch. And I, the emerging puritan of this triad, was getting on his nerves. For a moment, I saw him glare exactly like Hannibal did back then. But like the shadow of a sparrow passing over us, it was gone in an instant.
He managed an exasperated, half-amused smirk. “Why, I played him. Of course, I would sound like him.”
“But you don’t… didn’t… sound like that before.” My eyes darkened with accusation. “Even now, you sound like him.”
Mads closed his eyes and dropped the stub of his cigarette, his shoe digging it slowly into the ground. “Amelia, I understand you’re not in the best mood right now, but please…”
He looked down at me. There. Now, it was the Mads that I saw on my hospital bed. The perplexed one. The one who’s exhausted . “You and I have seen him. The first step to overcoming him is to believe I am not him.”
Hugh grunted as the two men helped me up. He leaned against the oak tree, his cigarette ash miraculously still in a limp, singular piece. It fell as soon as he spoke, disappearing into the grass. “‘ Overcoming? ’ Mads, mate, you really do sound like him just now.”
“It doesn’t help that I am trying to be the sane one here,” Mads muttered in retort and shook his head. He was smiling for a brief half-second until the moment he sighed. “What am I supposed to do, act like a fucking idiot while this woman”—he gestured at me desperately—“is quite literally losing her mind?”
Hugh narrowed his eyes at the older actor. “No, what you need is to act like yourself.”
Mads scoffed and removed his cap to card his hand through his salt-and-golden-brown hair. “You credit me too much, Hugh.”
Another round of silence, perhaps the third that day. Mads had two more cigarettes while Hugh circled the flowerbed nearby, his eyes teetering between us and the horizon. I, the anomaly, sat quietly on the exposed obsidian. Not quite a rock that tumbled and settled on the ground, instead, it was born from the eroded reddish black soil.
I tried to replay the scenes in my head. The moment I woke up on that hospital bed. The moment I saw the Stag. The moment Hannibal tried to lunge at me, only to realize it was all a figment of my imagination.
A figment of my imagination. Five words that should be harmless yet for me, it was the gunshot that sparked the Great War. As soon as those words populated my head, they were all I could think of.
False memories. I tried to remember again.
I was certain there was no kiss between me and Hannibal.
We wouldn’t. And yet there was the warmth lingering on my cheek.
I was certain Hugh didn’t stab Will Graham when they met.
He wouldn’t. And yet I could see the blood darkening his clothes.
I was certain Hannibal didn’t set Mads on fire.
He could —
No. Stop.
Yet here they were, the images polluting my memory.
A figment of my imagination. A figment of my reality. And the worst part? I wasn’t sure which one I wanted to be true.
“There must be a way to stop him.” I finally whispered under my breath, defeated by the false memories that were consuming my head.
“Well, we plan to turn him in, right?” I wasn’t sure who asked between the two men. The inconsistencies still overwhelmed my brain. I waded through it—a sick, unending sea of scalding falsities. Each of them tried to grab my legs to drown me in it.
Join us, Amelia. I know you love your misery. They seethed and taunted.
I nodded, despite the noise in my head. “He’s still at large as the Chesapeake Ripper.”
Hugh crossed his arms and nudged Mads. “And what, we’re just gonna knock on Jack Crawford’s door and tell him? We don’t even know what season of the show we’re in.”
Mads’ eyes darkened, realizing the dilemma. “If we’re on the earlier season… then, we could still convince Jack and Will that he is the Ripper. But if it’s the third season and beyond… then we might have a different problem.”
I frowned as the two men tensed. “What?”
“All bets are off,” Mads continued, “if this is happening in season three or beyond .”
I started pacing, trying to make sense of their logic. They were thinking like actors—as they should—but it felt alienating. The dreadful idea of being fictional pressed against me again, no matter how many times I had tried to shrug it off.
“So… everything depends on when we are in this so-called timeline?”
“We have no choice. We have to think like we created Hannibal.”
“The man or the universe?” I asked, my eyes narrowing.
“Both.”
Hugh dug into his pocket for his phone, his movements casual—but I caught the tension in his fingers. He was keeping it together—maybe too well—but I knew better. This was his reality now, too. No use denying it.
“Maybe our phones can help. Triangulation, timestamps, anything to make sense of this crap.” He flipped the phone over in his palm, like he half-expected it to vanish.
Mads let out a dry chuckle. “And what are you hoping to prove?”
“The year.”
Mads sighed and pulled out his own phone. The two men stared at their screens, scanning for an answer.
Meanwhile, my gaze wandered. We were away from my apartment now, away from the asylum that had bled into it. The world felt… softer. Less foreboding. There was no eerie green tint in the sky, no dramatic shadows creeping like eldritch fingers. The air wasn’t thick with something wrong . But it was too inviting—like an unassuming bar that pulls you in, only for you to realize later that you’ve probably caught something from sitting on the stool too long.
Even then, my heart beat less frantically. The world started to dim naturally. No cuts to daylight to evening, and then back to afternoon. Normal noise—random phone calls, taxi whistles, cars, and sidewalk chatter—began to deafen the symphony of taunts and false moans in my ears.
For the first time, I felt… hopeful. I had brought us back. This time, it wasn’t a violent, jarring shift.
“Well?” I asked, that cautious hope swelling in my chest.
Then I saw their faces.
“Well…?” I repeated, my voice smaller now. Their grim expressions made the air cold again.
Hugh was the first to speak. “2013.”
Mads followed. “2022.”
The ground beneath me shifted. Another rug pulled from under my feet. Another invisible swarm of butterflies landed on my skin, their tiny mouths sinking into my veins, feeding from the ice that was building under my skin.
“Different?” My voice cracked. “But how? We’re in the real world.”
Mads closed his eyes for a second, steadying himself, then looked up at the sky—like he was silently pleading with whatever god was watching.
“Maybe…” he murmured. “But whatever world we’re in now, whatever year we’re in now, there’s one guy who can help us.”
He didn’t elaborate as Hugh and I followed him back toward the convention hall. Night had settled in, and the streets grew busier. Hugh shrugged off his sweater and draped it over my shoulders, wordless. It smelled like sandalwood and pine, though I was certain it smelled differently before. I didn’t comment on it.
Mads walked ahead of us, his long strides difficult to keep up with. I glanced over my shoulder—and saw Hugh had slowed slightly. He had stopped for just a fraction of a second. Not enough for most people to notice. But I did.
His eyes flicked away as soon as he caught me watching him.
“It’s nothing,” he muttered.
Lie.
I followed his gaze.
There. Just beyond the glow of the streetlamp, half-hidden by the press of people, the Ravenstag stood.
Silent. Watching.
My stomach curled in on itself.
Slowly, I turned back to Hugh. He wasn’t looking at it anymore, but his shoulders had gone rigid. He had seen it. He could see it now.
I swallowed, reaching for his hand. His fingers were cold. I squeezed them anyway, hoping to steady him. Hoping to steady myself.
The world felt smaller, tighter, and icier.
“Mads,” I whispered, “where are we going?”
He didn’t answer right away. He only straightened, his grip brushing against mine—first light, then firm, the three of us linked now in a way I couldn’t put into words.
For just a moment, in the dim streetlight, a flicker of gray fur flashed in his irises.
He exhaled, low and steady. The shake in his shoulder was palpable, as it mirrored mine and Hugh’s. Mads’ eyes were glued on the darkness, till he forced his gaze to meet ours.
Hugh didn’t say anything. But he stared at Mads—just for a second too long. Mads exhaled through his nose, looking away for a moment before finally saying the words softly.
“Time to meet his maker.”
