Chapter Text
What a beautiful butterfly.
I heard my mom’s voice. Soft, in awe, and full of love. It rang clear, blessing both my ears.
“Amelia, look at your wings!” She exclaimed through the silence where I floated. I couldn’t open my eyes. Not yet. But I knew there was a lightness that I hadn’t felt in the last couple… days. Or hours. Or weeks.
I don’t know anymore.
Slowly, my eyes were pried open by the unknown. I expected the void to greet me as it had before. All those times I woke up staring at a ceiling or even at unfamiliar faces. Instead, there was the thick, bright gossamer of sunlight sweeping back to greet me at the end of the tunnel. As I walked out of the darkness, I fluttered through the hazy curtains of my old home’s kitchen window. Dust danced across the space, twirling gently while it moved in and out of the shadows.
I was seven again. I could tell from the rush of excitement coursing through my body. It had been drained from me over the years.
From the corner of my eye, I saw myself in the sheen of the refrigerator door. About four feet and seven inches tall. I was wearing a white, silvery pair of butterfly wings for my fairy costume. My hair was a huge fluffy veil around me, brightening the room with its delicate reds and golds.
“Look at you,” my mom smiled down at me. She anchored her hands under my arms to twirl me around the kitchen. My mother was wearing the cardigan that she had worn the moment she had collapsed and was later diagnosed with terminal cancer. The striped cream-and-red made her look like a candy cane, topped with the poofy cotton candy that was her carrot-red hair.
Despite everything, I closed the tile-long distance between us.
“Mom,” I whispered, burying my head into the safety of her bosom. I gripped her arms, tiny and fragile against her sleeves. It had been years since I felt my mother’s embrace. To my broken memories, she was taken from me way too early. Cancer. Or maybe autoimmune disorder. I wasn’t sure.
I don’t know anymore.
As I stood there hugging her, words spilled from my mouth, but they were not from that memory. They were from the mouth of the current twenty-three-year-old, where the heart clenched to grasp at any remnants of my sanity.
“They say I’m not real. That you’re not real.”
Mom stopped spinning me mid-air. Silence. My mom kept carrying me but she stilled. I could feel my limbs growing, my legs elongating into the adult that I was. My costume felt tighter, like a useless towel around me but I didn’t check. If I still had the wings on my back, I did not care. My back still stung, however, as if the wings had been permanently pricked deeply into my flesh.
I looked up at my mom. Her eyes were searching mine, like she was sorry. Yet she remained silent as she caressed my head. She pressed my head down to her chest again, where my tears began to flow.
“Mom,” I quietly asked, “I’m real, aren’t I?”
I gazed down at the kitchen floor. As the cold crept from my soles, blood was pooling where I stood. It avoided my soles but soaked through my mother’s feet. Her ankles shimmered as the blood seeped under her translucent shoes.
Despite the imagery, I took a deep breath. I gripped her arms. “I’m real,” I asked again, desperate for affirmation, “aren’t I?”
[INT. KITCHEN — EARLY AFTERNOON]
Her mother strokes Amelia’s hair, neither denying nor confirming her question. They both stand in the kitchen, silent.
AMELIA
(after a complete minute of silence, she whispers again, resigned completely, as she looks up at her mother)
Guess it’s both of us.
Amelia’s mother tightens her grip around Amelia. Amelia tries to hold her, too, but her mother slowly disappears. The kitchen slowly fades into black, till Amelia is the only person in the fading room, and then, finally, in the void.
I wiped my tears away, embracing myself to preserve the warmth of my mother’s memory. If I couldn’t have answers, at least she had been here. Real or not.
That didn’t matter anymore.
I walked back out of the darkness, the void wrinkling and crunching to a singular point. And as if time and space were unspooled all around me, I was back on solid, earthy ground.
“Where are we?” I murmured, asking nobody.
“Do we really need to know?” A gravelly, tired voice answered. Thankfully, it was Hugh.
I turned to him, the surroundings blooming a greenish tint, the doom creeping in over its presence. I knew exactly where we were again.
“Yes.” I stood next to him, gazing at the dark silhouette of the forest. We stood still in the middle of a field, grass prickling through our pants. I wasn’t sure if he saw what I was seeing, but it didn’t matter.
I was tired.
The wind picked up, causing me to shiver. When Hugh offered his jacket, I declined.
“We have things to do, right?” I gazed at him, at his earth-like irises. Even now, I still could not tell if his eyes were just brown, blue, or gray. Though as he gritted his teeth, his eyes darkened to pitch black.
“Right. We’ve tried convincing them to join us,” Hugh murmured, his eyebrows furrowing in thought. “But I am not counting on it,” he clenched his jaw, very much like that man Will Graham.
He closed his eyes, as if contemplating saying more than he needed. “I mean, in the story, Jack was a beast of skepticism. It would take a miracle for him to accept us.”
Hugh scoffed at his own words, chuckling to himself, “Let’s see. Maybe the gods of this world would let us live.”
We walked in silence, the word gods polluting my head. It could have been anyone. Those men—Bryan and Thomas—should have been the all-knowing creators behind this ordeal. But no. It was out of their hands, it seemed. Like the Oracle of Pythia, they had proclaimed I was doomed. Worse, I was a footnote. The crack that broke the iceberg. The box and Pandora altogether. There was no maybe in my brain now.
I was the crack that broke the iceberg.
Wrestling with my thoughts, we trudged our way across the field, wading through the tall grass and soft mud.
“What a fucked-up god, indeed.” I agreed under my breath, my eyes back where the darkness had melted to a single point. No stag stood at that spot, but the mirage of me and my mother remained, shimmering in and out of view.
I looked ahead this time. Mads was at the other end, standing by the asphalt road. His eyes were narrowed at the horizon, looking every bit of a gazelle that had shed its skin. My eyes surveyed his tall stature, to take in all that unreadable elegance that he had, Hannibal Lecter or not.
“We were inspired,” Mads started, his voice low and simmering, “by the murmurs in your sleep, Amelia.”
I felt my flesh shrink under my skin as he used that tone. It would never go away. “What?”
Mads turned to me, his eyes black and his smile warm and inviting. “That we can keep Hannibal here.”
“Isn’t that the plan already?” I crossed my arms, “I don’t remember sleep-talking.”
I was pointedly looking at the horizon to avoid his gaze. It was not in the way that I was used to. Rather, his eyes seared through my ribs, as if he were contemplating how to cut through the flesh without bleeding. I crossed my arms tighter.
“You have been,” Mads assured me, closing the distance casually, “and we went ahead to contact Will Graham while you were unavailable.” Mads lowered his voice, shoving his hands into his pockets. He was wearing a simple white dress shirt, his tie the paisley patterns of blood and midnight.
At his whisper, the feeling of my skin wrinkling and crawling rose across my back again. “We’re losing time, Amelia.”
A drop of sweat rolled down his nape. My eyes focused on the pores dilating with his breath, echoing the subtle rhythm of his nostrils. When the winds died down, I could hear his heartbeat. Beating relentlessly. Mads blinked—a flicker of red in his eyes appearing and disappearing. He fixed his cuffs, a sliver of that ‘H’ in his wrist briefly seen till the fabric covered it. Another blink, and the color red was replaced by pitch-black.
“I know,” I whispered back, an agreement passing between me and Mads.
[EXT. FIELD NEXT TO THE ROAD — LATE AFTERNOON]
All three of them wait out on the roadside, their eyes on the horizon. Since the shift in Mads’ tone, Amelia has stuck closer to Hugh.
HUGH
(crosses his arms, squinting at the road like he is missing his glasses. Then he looks at Mads.)
I hope this ends soon. We are abusing this world’s welcome, Mads.
Mads, who is fiddling at his sleeves, looks at Hugh. His eyes gaze at Amelia and then at Hugh. He slightly tilts his head in a fashion that unsettles Hugh.
MADS
(chuckles, his eyes still black from the greenish darkness of the surroundings)
You and I both, Hugh.
You and I both.
A few minutes after, a large yet sleek black van started speeding toward us. We stepped away from the road as the passengers stepped out of the car.
A tall, black man, as imposing as a Rottweiler, came out of the car. His graying buzzed head looked like a overly-burnt match, but I was sure he had more fire than the average man. The badge on his belt confirmed it. The deepness of his dark eyes heightened it.
The man immediately looked at Hugh and then at Mads. His gaze held Mads’ for a full minute.
“Lookin’ pretty much like the good doctor, huh…” the man murmured.
Mads showed his wrist to the man, the tattoo in full view. “Trust me, I am not him.”
“Does that stand for Hannibal ?” The man asked the actor. Mads visibly recoiled.
“No, this is for my wife. Hanne.”
And as if to truly separate himself from Hannibal, he declared, “We’re both Danes.”
Unconvinced but remaining silent for a beat, the man’s eyes fell back to Hugh. “And you… you look awfully like Will.”
Hugh, for all his expressions, shrugged, doubling down on his English accent, “I don’t think Mr. Graham has the same accent as I, Mr. Crawford.”
Speaking of the devil, Will Graham stepped out of the van. His dark curly hair was disheveled as he tried to fix the glasses on his nose. Our little group suddenly smelled too much like dog and dried sweat, which Hugh tried to blink away.
The man nodded at Will and then glared at Mads, “Director Jack Crawford of FBI. Behavioral Science Unit,” he extended his hand to Mads, “I believe you’re the man we talked to on the phone?”
“Yes, correct,” Mads shook Jack’s hand once and gestured at me and Hugh. “We’ve been looking out for a man who can potentially answer our questions regarding some… recent killings.”
Hugh stood next to me, straighter and more authoritative. “Yes, this is Mr. Mikkelsen, a special unit agent at…” I could feel Hugh quickly regret this, having no solid alibi to check on Hannibal Lecter.
What could we fucking do? Tell Jack that they knew Hannibal was a murderer because they’re the actors of his story?
“At a distant European county police,” Will Graham chimed in, glaring at Hugh like he owed him money.
Will cleared his throat and continued, “These are Mr. Mikkelsen, stationed in Central Europe, and Mr. Dancy, a friend of his who offered to look here in America for answers.”
Understandably, Jack frowned, “So let me get this straight. Some New Yorker and his ‘specialist’ cop friend just happened to know that a respected doctor is actually the Chesapeake Ripper?”
“ Might ,” Mads added coolly, his eyes at me and then at Will, the intent unreadable. “He might be the Chesapeake Ripper, Mr. Crawford.”
Will elbowed Hugh, like a student caught in the act. Hugh stood closer, smelling just like the dog-and-sweat combination I got from Will.
I nodded, my voice soft, “I was… I was his victim. Or… at least he tried to make a victim out of me.”
“Then why have you not reached out to us ?” Jack remained skeptical, his eyes now boring into my face.
“It was coincidental,” I lied. Well, not really, if you think about it. “I was found by them.” I gestured weakly at the two actors.
“And then, we all just wanted to… understand if the doctor is the Chesapeake Ripper.” I remained looking at the ground, focusing on my toes as they twitched in my shoes.
Under his breath, Will grumbled, “I’ve been telling people this one.”
“Graham,” Jack warned and shook his head. For a long, thoughtful minute, he was silent.
Finally, he exhaled, “Fine, but we’re not arresting him. We don’t have a warrant nor solid evidence that Lecter was behind your… attack.”
It was not a yes, not a no. It was all I could get, but I was grateful.
Jack looked over his shoulder as he turned, “But I know for a fact that Lecter is smart enough to know what you’re trying to do.”
“Then why did you agree to this?” I asked back, wanting to at least have an answer from someone who didn’t look like Mads or Hugh. “If you know we cannot pull this off, then why are you here?”
[EXT. FIELD NEXT TO THE ROAD — LATE AFTERNOON]
The field quiets as Amelia’s question is left unanswered. For a long time, there’s a pause. Jack turns back to her, his eyes glittering with a combination Amelia is too familiar with: fear, uncertainty, and curiosity.
JACK
(voice sounding a little too low that when he finishes, Amelia gulps)
Maybe I’m just like you.
I was silent until I wasn’t. I moved along, my feet hesitant until Mads nudged me to get in the car. All three of us were cramped in the backseat as Jack started the vehicle. Will was on the passenger seat, his eyes at me, Hugh, and finally, at Mads.
He didn’t say anything but his jaw clenched just loud enough before the engine started purring.
Biting my lip, I pressed my palms together. In a prayer, maybe, but who should I pray to if this world wouldn’t allow me to be real?
“We’ll be okay, right?” I asked the two men.
Mads and Hugh didn’t answer as the van moved, but I felt their hands on mine, gently gripping all five digits around one finger like a baby.
Maybe that was a yes.
Will Graham kept his eyes on me through the rearview mirror, but I didn’t say anything. I looked down as the car swayed to the motion, noticing the ‘H’ barely shown under the fabric of Mads’ sleeves.
Sensing my curiosity, Mads allowed me to look at it by pulling down his cuff, “Don’t worry, Amelia. This will be your truth.”
I took a shaky breath. From my other hand, I felt Hugh’s fingers wrapping tighter around my ring and little fingers. “I hope so, Mads. I hope so.”
When I looked up, Will stared quickly at the road ahead, tearing his gaze from us. Will rested a hand on the edge of the seat, leaning against the car window. “It will be okay.”
I looked at him, my eyes trying to take his own to be held, “You know that can’t be true… especially when he’s around.”
Will’s mouth tightened. He looked ahead, his knuckles white around themselves. “He is inescapable,” he admitted, almost a whisper.
“And you just… let it be?”
“No,” Will said, frowning, eyes lowered to his hands. Shaking and sweating, just like the rest of his body, “But he’s a black hole, Amelia.” His voice wavered. “Hannibal is a black hole.” Then his gaze met mine. “You would know.”
I crossed my arms and stayed silent. My eyes found the forest that sped along us, “I wish to escape him,” I said, almost to myself.
From the corner of my eye, Will’s eyes softened. “Then be better than me at it.”
The van jerked slightly as it stopped. The doors opened to the grim, regal silhouette of Lecter’s home.
A wave of dizziness passed over me, soft as breath but cloying like fleshy rot. The air shimmered as my vision stuttered. One second I was myself. Another, a child again, stuffed animals appearing and disappearing beside my feet. Mr. Bunny found solace around my ankles until the third yard away from the van. The pavement flickered like bad VHS tape.
“Focus, Amelia… we’re getting there,” Hugh said beside me.
“Tell that to my fucked-up brain,” I muttered, my breath unsteady and shallow.
Hugh slowed down to walk at my pace. Will followed Hugh, flanking my other side, saying nothing but matching my breath like a metronome.
“I’m bleeding,” I said suddenly. My feet felt warm and wet inside my shoes. “Am I?”
Will and Hugh looked down instinctively, scanning for the blossom of dark brown, but their faces didn’t answer me—only a quiet concern passing between them. Maybe they saw blood. Maybe they didn’t.
Then I glanced at Mads. The ‘H’ on his wrist snuck into view again. A relief. But when I met his eyes, they weren’t brown. They were black. Deep and glassy like unearthed onyx. I blinked and they were brown again.
“I’m not invalid,” I snapped, chest tight.
“We know,” Hugh said, gently. “But you need us. We’re here.”
Mads turned his face toward us. His eyes were too black to read, but his chirpy tone still bled through the unreliable visage. “We should move on. He could be anywhere in the house.”
Hannibal’s home creaked as we stepped inside, like it had been waiting. Empty, polished, tasting of old mahogany and secrets. His hallowed library stood tall and imposing as we gathered in his drawing room, my eyes wheeling around to see if any of his furniture could come alive.
“Odd,” Mads said, surveying the space. “Why is he not here?”
Jack, ever pragmatic, flipped through a calendar on the hallway table. “No appointments today. He should be.”
I wasn’t listening to them anymore. My body moved ahead of me, like a magnet finding precious metals.
“He’s here,” I whispered. Maybe it was the call of nature, of how deer still managed to walk into the lion’s den, despite all the signs that it shouldn’t.
I took a step into the hallway. Then another. Until I was walking closer to the darkness of Hannibal’s home. The path narrowed as I walked. If the walls could scream, they did. Maybe they did but my blown-out pupils were focused on the red footsteps that I instinctively followed. It wasn’t a man’s. It was much smaller. I didn’t dare to look back, but I knew I was filling in each step with my own. Darker red. Maybe blood. The light bent inward as I moved through a tunnel carved by silence. Jack, Mads, and Hugh were gone behind me. I couldn’t care less as the cavern opened to the cold, clinical, gray-tinted room that was Hannibal’s kitchen.
Then I saw him.
Hannibal Lecter stood by the butcher block, wearing a white shirt and dress pants. His back was to me, precisely skinning a slab of meat. The slab was indistinct. Could’ve been beef. Could’ve been human. Could’ve been metaphor.
“I was beginning to think you’d left me behind, my dear,” he said, still focused on the meat, his voice soft yet warm, deep yet rotten.
I swallowed. “You’re not even denying this?” I barely motioned to the flesh. My hands trembled.
“There’s none to deny, my dear,” he said, still not turning.
“They’re coming for you.” I steadied myself. “ I’m coming for you.”
“Oh?” he asked, and only then did he look at me. “Are you?”
I hated how calm he was.
I took a deep breath. The murmur escaped my lips. “I’m so tired of you.”
“Then why waste the energy here, mon papillon ?” A rather genuine tone for a situation that made my heart spike blood and terror. Perhaps it was fueled by his cruel curiosity.
“To make sure you’ll never touch me again.”
He approached me—smooth, sure, and unnervingly gentle. He raised a hand, cupping my face like a lover might. Instinctively, my eyes fell briefly to his wrist. No sign of an ‘H.’ Hannibal wouldn’t be the type to ‘desecrate’ his temple with fleeting vandalism or whatever.
“You have no idea how wrong you are, Miss Cartwright.” He let his fingers trace the edge of my throat. A shiver ran down my spine, only for the fact that he could snap my neck yet continued to caress it the slightest.
“Such a delicate frame,” Hannibal murmured. A curl of my hair slipped between his fingers. “Even your hair is delicate spun gold.”
The hunger in his eyes grew, but he remained calm. I yanked my body away from him, from the reverie he was casting upon me.
“What’s stopping you?” I hissed. “From killing me right now?”
He smiled again. That awful, beautiful smile. “Miss Cartwright, I ask you…” He tilted his head. “When you gaze upon a block of marble, do you immediately know how to shape it?”
“I wouldn’t know,” I muttered. “Never seen a block of marble.”
Hannibal chuckled once. “You do. Every day. In the mirror.”
And then, he leaned in.
“What I see is not just a block of marble,” he said. “But a path of marble.”
The silence filled my dreaded realization. His words had flooded my head. The words from long ago. Or maybe hours ago. The ones that plagued a corner of my head.
To walk between worlds… Imagine what someone with... clarity could do with such power.
“I won’t let you,” I announced quietly under my breath.
“Too late, Miss Cartwright.” As if the world spun fast and stopped spinning in the same second, Hannibal’s hand was already pointing a cold, bloody knife against my throat.
“Drop the knife, Hannibal!” Jack’s voice barked through the mind fog. The blade now shimmered at my throat, the blunt point bearable until Hannibal angled the sharp edge against my skin.
Mads stepped forward. “Hannibal.”
Hannibal’s grip tightened. “Mr. Mikkelsen.”
Will’s voice was quiet as he stepped closer, “Drop the girl, Doctor.”
“I could take you with me, Will,” Hannibal said with a smile. “This is something bigger than us. And if you insist… I could take you along for the ride.”
Jack raised his gun as the pain dug deeper into that single point on my neck. “Drop it now!”
I looked at Mads. At Hugh. At Will. And then at the multitude that flickered behind them, splitting and joining in the darkness. Some as the actors. Some as my mother. Some as the people from the train. But as soon as the slow yet imposing gait of the Ravenstag weaved through the shadows, the apparitions melted into the darkness of Hannibal’s hallways.
“You do not even know what it’s like to be, Hannibal,” I whispered as the Ravenstag’s presence doubled, tripled, and more, eating away any apparitions of the people who mattered.
Everyone’s faces began to melt into each other.
Bryan Fuller. Will Graham. Thomas Harris.
Then the ones I barely understood—faces of all forms dressed as Hannibal, grinning staff behind cameras, a line of young women waiting to be choked.
And then them.
Mads and Hugh split like cells under a microscope, each shade another role. But only two rose to the surface—Hannibal and Will. Wayward cells turned predators, lunging out of the slide and straight into my eyes.
Promptly after, I could feel Hannibal pressing closer, his cold breath dragging me back to reality. A gasp left my mouth as Mads lunged forward. His knife found Hannibal’s ribs.
“Hannibal!” Mads cried, eyes wide and desperate.
And then chaos.
The fight was swift and savage, choreographed like a deadly ballet. Blades flashing. Grunts. Flesh meeting marble countertops. Blood let and sprayed all over the kitchen island. Jack fell first, too slow to dodge. But he managed to grab someone’s foot—perhaps Hannibal’s—to drag the man down. To be violently yet gracefully tackled by the rest of them.
I could barely follow. Hannibal moved like a ghost. Mads like his mirror. Hugh tackled him. Will tried to shoot someone but the bullet swerved into the fridge. Will ducked and dragged Hannibal, but for a moment I could swear he was dragging Hugh . Then it was Hannibal. Then Mads. It was a blur.
Voices swirled in my ears. I heard laughter, an audience, applause. I twisted to the dark hallway and found no hallway. In the middle of the darkness, under the lone, dim spotlight, a large camera whirred silently. Voices swirled in my ears. I heard laughter, an audience, applause. I twisted to the dark hallway and found no hallway. In the middle of the darkness, under the lone, dim spotlight, a large camera whirred silently. The pink, now-uncanny Mr. Bunny watched silently behind the whirring camera. Gone was his softness. His red eyes reflected the scene behind me.
“Amelia,” Mr. Bunny addressed me, his voice Hannibal’s.
I heard my own scream as the scene all around me cracked, the air rupturing into shards of reality and unreality. As it exploded, a sharp gasp escaped my lips. A blade wrapped in velvet tickled my flesh. Blood bloomed as I looked down, only realizing then that I was speared by the Ravenstag.
It lifted its head, the antler digging deeper inside me. I gasped again, the panic boiling in my throat as I met the Stag’s gaze over my shoulder.
Its red eyes mirrored my face, a look of pure dread washing my features. Pain shot through my body like fire.
I tore myself from it, breaking and holding the piece of antler left in me.
With no luxury to stagger, I ran.
The red on my clothes grew bigger as I dashed forward. The antler in my hand. My feet sticky with something. I saw the moment—Mads stumbling back, Hannibal raising a knife.
And I lunged.
The antler went deep into Hannibal’s eye, staggering back with a swing of his large hand.
“Let’s get out of here!” I cried.
Mads grabbed my arm. Hugh grabbed the other. We ran.
Behind us, his breath rattled. “You…” He yanked the antler from his eye, leaving half of his face dripping with blood .
I tripped on a rock. My knee split open. Blood was coughed up from the gaping wound. The gravel was colored deep brown. But Mads pulled me up. Hugh shoved the car door open.
“Come on!”
We climbed in.
I drove, my lower half bleeding along with my side.
The road blurred.
My rearview mirror caught a flicker—Hannibal, stumbling to his knees, his hands outstretched.
I didn’t stop.
“Oh God… oh God,” I wept. “Thank you… thank you!”
Mads didn’t speak as his knuckles gripped the dashboard and the seat. Hugh groaned from the back.
“This is why we had body doubles for fight scenes,” he muttered, passing out not a minute after against the backseat.
I laughed wetly, wiping my face. “We’ll be okay. We’ll be okay.”
The road stretched out ahead. Pine and oak trees blurred into a wall of dark green on either side of the car.
We were silent. We were breathing. We won.
“I just want to live,” I whispered, the tears stinging the scrapes on my face. The car’s metal coldness seeped into my gaping kneecap. Mads gently pressed his hand on the wound, applying pressure and warmth.
“You will,” Mads replied.
Tears clouded my vision again. “I just want to live, Mads.”
“I know,” he said, smiling gently. His hand jerked precisely around my knee. I could feel his fingers edging the seams of my wound. “Miss Cartwright.”
Something hollowed out in my chest. He had barely ever called me that.
I couldn’t turn. I couldn’t move. His finger pressed deeper into the open kneecap, feeling the exposed pulp with his crooning baritone.
Silence sat between us like a stone.
Amelia Cartwright, you absolute fool. You hoped for no more voices. But perhaps, you will hear one for the rest of your life.
And so he leaned in, as if to force me to look at him. “I’ll make sure you do. For a very long time, Miss Cartwright.”
My eyes unfroze, looking down at his unbuttoned cuff, at the secrecy of his wrist.
I looked down, simmering at the skin beheld by my eyes. I could feel him staring at me, but I was petrified by something as simple as a wrist.
Something was wrong with it.
