Chapter Text
Dr Frederick Chilton had always considered himself uniquely perceptive. It was what made him such an outstanding psychiatrist. As head of the Baltimore State Hospital for the Criminally Insane, he had pioneered the treatment of society’s most dangerous, most depraved (and, if he were being honest, most interesting) patients. His expertise had earned him a coveted position as a senior FBI consultant for the Behavioural Analysis Unit, alongside Dr Alana Bloom, whom he had been graciously mentoring since her return to Baltimore. Under his guidance, she had flourished wonderfully, though Frederick did wish she would spend a little less time trying to win the respect of her old mentor, Dr Lecter.
It wasn’t that he had anything against Dr Lecter. Certainly not. He was a very civilised man. A touch gauche in his clothing choices, perhaps. Those three-piece suits were practically pleading for a more modern silhouette. His decor leaned towards the kitsch. All those antlers. And yet, overall, the man was a reasonably talented physician. Not to Frederick’s standards, of course, but then few were.
For example, it was only due to his keen insight that he had unravelled the little secret Hannibal Lecter had managed to conceal from everyone.
His wife had left him.
Not that Frederick could blame the poor mystery woman. Being married to a man that self-involved must have been insufferable. No, Frederick sent his deepest sympathies to her, wherever she was. Most likely, she had been some fresh-faced girl from the old country, barely speaking a word of English, who had bolted with the metaphorical candlesticks the moment the ink dried on her visa. Or perhaps she had been a well-bred socialite, drawn to prestige but finding more passion in the arms of the gardener than in her cold, detached husband.
Sometimes, when he had nothing better to do, Frederick found himself idly speculating on what kind of woman had wounded the good doctor so deeply that he now conducted his elaborate dinner rituals as if summoning her presence. He had always found Lecter peculiar, even before dining at his home. An evening of unidentifiable meats served under grotesque decor wasn’t exactly Frederick’s idea of fine dining. However, the guest list at such events more than made up for it. The last time he had secured an invitation, he had been seated next to the newest conductor at the Philharmonic.
No, Hannibal was an oddity, but one to be tolerated—for now.
Perhaps, once Frederick had published his newest research paper (which would, of course, inevitably lead to a lucrative book deal), he would be hosting his own elegant dinner parties. Ones that wouldn’t be desperate attempts to memorialise a misplaced wife.
The paper in question was one he had been itching to write for years: Extreme Empathy or Latent Psychopathy: A Neuropsychiatric Analysis of William Graham.
The man himself had been avoiding him for quite some time, no doubt wary of what an expert in the human condition might uncover about his so-called empathy disorder. But that particular game of cat and mouse was about to come to an end.
Frederick had overheard—entirely by accident, of course—Jack Crawford speaking to Alana about bringing Mr Graham to one of Hannibal’s little soirées under the pretense of introducing him to his potential new team. Apparently, Jack had decided that William’s so-called gifts would be of use to the FBI.
Frederick knew better, of course. But who was he to look a gift horse in the mouth?
Frederick leaned back in his chair, steepling his fingers as he considered his plan. This dinner was an opportunity, and he intended to seize it. William Graham had been an elusive subject for far too long, skirting around interviews, declining research studies, dodging even the most well-crafted invitations. But now, now, Jack Crawford had unknowingly done the hard work for him. Will would be seated right across the table, trapped in polite conversation, none the wiser to Frederick’s true intentions.
It would have to be done carefully, of course. Will Graham was, by all accounts, skittish. Prone to discomfort, reluctant to talk about himself, generally off-putting. Frederick had read the reports. Not good with eye contact, one former colleague had noted. Resistant to personal questions, prone to irritation when pressed.
Frederick, naturally, was not just going to press. He was going to excavate.
The key would be subtlety. A casual, well-timed question here, a keen observation there. Ease Graham into the conversation, let him feel like he was leading it. Stroke the ego a little. Make it seem as though Frederick was simply fascinated by his work, by his unique insights into the criminal mind. Appeal to his intellect.
And then?
Then, Frederick would gently guide the discussion towards what truly mattered. The fine line between empathy and psychopathy, the neurological anomalies that set William Graham apart from normal people. Because that was the heart of it, wasn’t it? The real question no one had yet answered.
Did Will Graham understand killers because he felt too much?
Or because he felt nothing at all?
Of course, there was one problem.
Alana and Hannibal.
Frederick had no doubt that both of them would have their own interests in Will Graham. Alana, with her tiresome moral streak, would likely try to protect him, keep him from feeling cornered. And Hannibal? That was a trickier matter.
Hannibal Lecter was a collector of interesting minds. He had a way of drawing people in, making them feel seen, understood. It was almost admirable, really, how effortlessly he got into people's heads. A cheap parlour trick, in Frederick’s esteemed opinion, but an effective one. He wouldn’t be surprised if Lecter had already marked Graham as a project, a curiosity to be studied over fine wine and unnecessarily elaborate cuisine.
Frederick would have to outmanoeuvre them both.
Alana might be distracted by her apparent concern for Graham’s well-being, but Hannibal? Hannibal would know exactly what Frederick was trying to do, because he would be planning to do the exact same thing.
Still, Frederick had an advantage. Hannibal Lecter played the long game—he would want to spend months, years drawing Graham in. Frederick, however, could be direct. A sharp question over dinner, a probing remark over dessert. Just enough to plant the seed.
By the time the evening was over, Will Graham would be left wondering—about himself, about how his mind worked, about what Frederick might have seen in him that no one else had.
And then?
Then, the real work would begin.
