Chapter Text
Freddie Lounds looked for once, like a pale ghost, as she was sworn in. All of her smugness and arrogance seemed to have melted against her, leaving a pale human facing the consequences of her reckless actions.
“So Miss Lounds,” Scott walked over to Freddie, that hint of calculated anger sharp in his gaze. “In the last trial, Will Graham vs State, you are on record having claimed that Abigail Hobbs had confided in you, and claimed that she was afraid of Will Graham cannibalizing and eating her. And yet, Ms. Hobbs has now miraculously returned from death and claims to have never done so. In fact, she claims that she even told you once that she did not want her book deal to reflect badly on Will Graham or Hannibal Lecter, her official guardians at the time.”
The judge leaned down to peer at her. “Miss Lounds, your testimony of such a clear-cut accusation of the presumed dead against her alleged killer had significant implications for the court. This isn’t a game of tabloid journalism where you must feed the juicy details over the truth. I understand I do not have to tell you the implications of perjury?”
She exhaled slowly. “Will Graham is a hero in today’s world. He wasn’t always like that. He was a sweaty twitchy man who prioritized his dogs over people and could follow the paths that criminals took because he could think exactly the way they thought. He was brilliant and I was afraid he might wiggle out of the justice system simply because he was that clever. I just needed to make sure that Abby got the justice she deserved.”
Williams snapped up. “Miss Lounds, the court of law does not and has never prosecuted people on the basis of gut feelings and thoughts. There is a reason that the art of profiling does not hold in a court of law. If we started doing that, I am afraid we would need to round up all the mystery writers and tabloid journalists and send them to jail. What counts in court are actions and cold hard facts. And the facts are that while Dr. Graham’s actions have shown him to be the FBI special agent he never officially got to be, yours have sentenced an innocent man to death.”
“Objection, your Honor,” the prosecutor said, just as the defendant stepped aside with a murmured apology. The damage however was done.
The prosecutor, Nade Jackson stepped up with a smile when it was his turn. “I would like to allude to Will Graham’s journal that had been confiscated in the BSCHI in his two years stay there and I have with me here now.”
The judge raised an eyebrow. “I take it that is not official policy to do so?”
“No, sir,” Jackson admitted reluctantly. “As it is supposed to be a part of therapy, it was neither meant to be read nor confiscated for any reason. It was an abuse of power and authority.” It called for sympathy, it called for outrage against Will Graham’s wrongful incarceration. It went against Jackson’s lawyer book to not divulge the reason for the confiscation.
One day, Will had snapped at some guards who had been a little too easy, a little too rough on their patients. After all, who would step up for the rights of these monsters? Who would even believe them? And Will had snapped up and tore out half the cheek of one man. He had almost been assaulted. He had survived it. Jackson could freely admit, if only to himself, that he must have had to pay back for it in triplicate.
Still, Jackson refused to put it forward, put Graham into a position where he would be seen as pitiful and vicious. Something to grimace over from a distance but not come too forward for fear of catching their crazy. Dead or not, the man had suffered enough indignity and scorn in life that even he would not be monster enough to drag his name down in death.
Alana, unbeknownst to the history behind the journal, looked away. She wondered what sort of outlet Will exercised in such an impossible situation.
“In this one journal entry, it reads:
This is Will Graham. The date is the 23rd of December, and I suspect the time is anywhere between 7 to 8ish PM, considering when the lights came on. PS to anyone reading my diary and don’t lie, I know you are: these lights are an exercise in psychological torture and need to be banned ASAP.
A chuckle went around the courtroom.
I hate the holidays, I really do. Truth be told, I have never really been fond of them in the least because they call for consumerism and socializing, two things I am not too fond of; and when people hear I plan to spend Christmas alone, they pity invite me to some party or the other, never mind the fact that the only thing I look forward to in the holidays is sleeping in and not having to be around other people.
How relatable, a journalist smiled behind Alana with a soft laugh, as if she really understood or empathized with the depths of Will’s neuroticism. Alana resisted the urge to scoff.
The one thing I could have hoped for in prison (oops, sorry, psychiatric care, not that’s any better) is that people would finally stop disturbing me in here. Not so much. So far, I have been approached by my lawyer for a quick pity gift: a book I had been meaning to read for a long time that he knew about (it’s almost alarming how genuine he is sometimes though I like him anyway), Hannibal Lecter for a very long session that he seemed very reluctant to shut down despite me almost falling asleep on him (he ordered the dose be brought down, which is hilarious because all these people love playing Russian Roulette with my medication and I am sure it’s not even gonna affect them but its gonna blow up in my face someday) and then Freddie Lounds for a quick quote on something I was too stoned to hear properly.
Alarmingly, the dosage has brought down the walls that I spent an eternity building up. My empathy is going haywire and I latch randomly onto people I wish I wouldn’t latch onto. I have settled for keeping an OCD-level organized cell, thanks to the doctor’s influence (as long as he doesn’t infect me with cannibalism and serial murdering, I think I am good).
Today, I latched onto Freddie Lounds.
She drove out of her way near the holidays just for a quote on a story she should know holds little public interest today. She didn’t come here for a smug reflection of our past or just to taunt me with my grey lifeless walls (though of course, now that she was here, she did not hold back on an opportunity to do either).
She was lonely, and she came here for Abigail Hobbs. Despite herself, she did care for Abigail and she needed to see with her two eyes that her murderer was still rotting in a cell somewhere. He is honestly holding a dinner party for 50 with dishes accounting for another 10 of the population, but as far as she is concerned, she did her part right.
I have never been too fond of her, though I confess I am not too fond of most people. They are all capable of being good, and they are all capable of being just as bad. Most of them have the capacity to love well and to kill well, regardless of whether they admit it or not. She is no better. She may even be worse than some.
Her tendency to ambition put her at odds in school playgrounds and isolated her peers and family from her. She has no contacts, save for the ones she exploits and discards at the whim of a moment and believes she can fill the emptiness in her rooms with pockets full of cash, but she won’t. She will do anything to get to the top, and that is precisely why she never will. She has made too many enemies for them to let her win big.
Unsurprisingly, I hate her for her role in my incarceration. If she weren’t around, if she hadn’t poked her fingers in places she didn’t belong, I would perhaps still end up here. I might have more allies though. It really is true; she is busy destroying me for money, Chilton is doing it for fame and Hannibal Lecter for fun.I almost thought of sending her away and telling her exactly what I thought of her.
But I marched down to say hi. Because she didn’t come here for me. She came here for Abigail. And after everything, after my poor choice in friends and a poorer call of judgment, Abigail deserved at least this much effort from me.
She sat down and stared at me. Asked me questions. Told me that she thought I belonged here, she was glad I was here. I think just this once, I’ll forgive her obnoxiousness and her ignorant hypocrisies. For all her faults, she genuinely cared for Abigail. She genuinely wanted to see her succeed. And her lonely fear and outrage shone back at me with the perfect sentiment that I can’t not forget her.
I feel good today, her words may have been cruel and callous but her sentiments were clear. Whatever has happened, I have too many enemies as is. I think I’ll forgive her.”
Freddie was sobbing at the side, and there were tears in a lot of people’s eyes as they heard that. “Will Graham was an excellent judge of character. He saw in Miss Lounds the capacity and propensity to do good, and by his own voice and words, forgave her her actions.”
Scott Williams got up, his expression pained. Nobody could tell whether it was real or a farce, he was that good an actor. “Objection to the relevance of the reading, your Honor.”
“Granted.”
“In the same journal, he once wrote, I wish I could hate Hannibal Lecter for all he has done me wrong. And yet, he does not realize why his actions are wrong, only that they do not align with that of polite society and so he must hide them. In his head, he is freeing me of societal obligations by removing me from society and giving me a chance to test my strength, to see that I am stronger than I perceive myself to be.
In his head, he has gone out of his way to do me good, and hating him for his actions would be ridiculously insane, and I am not insane, not anymore. I cannot hate him, but I still find myself disappointed in myself for not having taken the warning signs for the red flags they were, back when I had still had the chance to do so. Still, these emotions he invokes in me when he crosses my mind, and he crosses it regularly…I really must find a way to deal with my feelings for him, before I can deal with him in real life.”
“You argue that Freddie Lounds was doing good and that Will forgave her,” Williams snapped the diary shut. “I argue that he even had the caliber to forgive a monster like Hannibal Lecter despite the personal nature of the crimes against him. Empathy is a perception pointed at both ends. As long as he understands people, he will forgive them for their bad because he can see their propensity for good. He once claimed in one of his unfinished unpublished academic papers, The Insights into the Criminal Mind and their Perception of Society that he believed there was no good or evil, only people on a spectrum of emotions. I plead a motion to not let his forgiveness color the depth of the crimes against him.”
“Granted.” Williams smiled at Jackson, who frowned, knowing well he was against a league of lawyers he had no hope of fighting against. The plethora of evidence and public opinion backed Williams as well. But then again, his job wasn’t to prove Will Graham guilty, it was to protect the FBI in their hamfisted attempts to save face publicly.
Freddie Lounds could burn in the bed she had made herself if that was what pleased her.
~
Dr. Alana Bloom, gossiped the tabloid rags, was a lovely psychiatrist, specializing in family trauma; and on the side, they coldly gossiped, she was really good at inducing trauma. In unofficial accounts and by eyewitness gossip, Will Graham and Alana Bloom had once had a little something on the side.
‘Never saw them kiss or anything, they just had a spark,’ a colleague chasing after his 5 minutes of fame admitted. ‘Of course, you just don’t know what they were doing off on the side, in that isolated house of his.’
As soon as the news about Will Graham’s crimes broke, she was in bed with her mentor, having taken in all of Will’s seven dogs and putting him in the impossible position of being in debt to a woman who was once a former lover and had since abandoned ship to fall in bed with his own worst enemy.
Between the health of his canine companions and his misplaced affection for Alana, Hannibal Lecter had a decent collateral hold over Will. A man at the local farmer’s market claimed he once saw Will, who he had believed mute at the time, tiredly rubbing his eyes, and when asked, signed, My roommate and his girlfriend are much too loud. They go at it for hours every night, every day of the week so far. The farmer had laughed with Will, commiserating with him, never realizing the cruelty of his ex-flame fucking his once-best friend so close to his own bedroom.
“So Miss Bloom,” Scott Williams smiled thinly. “Did you once have romantic designs on Dr. Will S. Graham?”
“He kissed me once. Once. And I rejected him, then and there. We were never romantically or sexually involved.”
“Of course,” Williams nodded. “You were pursuing someone else at the time.”
“No,” she objected, but it came out weaker than she had intended. She cleared her throat, and tried again. “No, I wasn’t looking for anyone at the time. I- every time I get into a relationship, I tend to overthink it, become a therapist to them until they grow disappointed by me or I do.”
“But that didn’t happen with Hannibal Lecter, I presume? He was your perfect white knight, I heard he had to break it off to get you to back off in the end. If only you had done some thinking there…” She colored darkly at his mocking tone, as the prosecutor yelled out an objection and the judge granted it, Williams murmuring an apology that fooled no one around.
“He didn’t break up with me, I broke up with him,” she murmured. “But he didn’t really seem disappointed or surprised.”
“Oh?” Williams rose an eyebrow.
“I was seeing someone else,” she admitted. “It didn’t really work out but…”
The Baltimore Times commented, …sensing a pattern in Dr. Alana Bloom’s ill-fated romantic entanglements here…
“Well, you dodged a bullet there, phew,” Williams smiled wide at her, falsely cheerful. Alana stared blankly behind him. Will had dropped his doe-eyed morose look to look accusingly at her. She was almost thrilled she remembered something else to construct about her friend’s memory. She swore to go through every picture, every video, every testimony, and audio she had of him. She needed to reconstruct his voice again.
“And he never tried to take revenge, never so much as murmured his disappointment when we know now that he ate anyone who seemed to offend him?”
She colored. “I don’t know what you’re implying here, but no, he seemed happy to put his distance between us after that. He never invited me over to his house after that, though he sometimes fed me with the rest of the team on big cases. I don’t- I really don’t know.”
The judge peered down. “The court grants the motion to reconstruct the timeline of events for better clarity here.”
Williams nodded. “Most of it is tied to the case of Hannibal Lecter and his crimes, which is a case in progress and far from ready to present in court. But this takes place almost 3 months past the date he was granted guardianship. Witness testimonies state that the affair was going on long enough that there were rumors of a more serious engagement when he introduced Alana Bloom to his colleague and friend, Anthony Dimmond, and happily turned the other way while he flirted with her all night.
The subsequent break-up gave Hannibal a good reason to put his distance and evict her from his house where we presume she was now starting to get comfortable. It also gave him the excuse to hold off on societal obligations so he could better focus his energies on Dr. Graham, but at this point, it’s mostly conjecture and there is little evidence of the same, though the facts fit this theory.”
The judge nodded thoughtfully. “Please continue.”
“Dr. Bloom, I would like you to construct your thinking process and line of reasoning when signing the forms granting your ex-boyfriend guardianship of your former friend. I am sure your professional instincts had some reasons, apart from your personal stake in the case.”
Alana stared down blankly. She thought about Will’s fear of prison and his even greater apprehension of being declared a vulnerable adult in Hannibal Lecter’s hands. Logic dictated that anyone else, any other person should have taken on Will’s case when he had such a deep fear of Hannibal. Psychosis or not, no relationship could exist in that vacuum of loss of trust and that abject fear and violence Will displayed in Hannibal’s presence.
And yet, Hannibal had taken her hand, fingertips touching in a semblance of soft intimacy that had made her stare down with wonder. ‘I can get to him, I promise. Trust in my professional capabilities. And we are all friends here, Alana. I can get us our Will back, I really can. Don’t you trust me? Don’t you want Will back?’
And she had. She had trusted him. She had wanted Will back. She had said yes.
“Will seemed to get better in Lecter’s guardianship,” she murmured. Nobody missed how she said Lecter and not Hannibal, distancing herself now in a case of ‘too little, too late’. “It was slow at first, but he would come out of his room, talk, listen, respond. He wasn’t violent with anyone, not even aggressive really if I am being honest. The therapy seemed to have a positive impact.”
“And you’re sure you’re not confusing learned helplessness with getting better? Not to mention, this was after your decision to sign away his life, and could not have possibly been a factor in your decision-making. What made you sign those papers, Dr. Bloom?”
She wept. “Hannibal Lecter told me to do it.”
“And you do everything he asks you to do.”
Sun ran the story on their fifth page, the first a tribute to the life of Will Graham. They called her ‘Lecter’s loyal lapdog’.
