Actions

Work Header

Words of Warning

Chapter Text

Will’s father had raised him to the best of his ability, considering the circumstances. There may certainly be an argument that children suffered from the lifestyle they’d had, but Will was and had always been satisfied with his upbringing. He had no complaints.

Will’s imagination had always run wild, and he had few outlets as a child. One thing he had started doing was writing things down. They hadn’t been books or stories back then. They had just been jumbles of thoughts, ideas, and images. It had been a way to compartmentalize, for Will. By putting these thoughts on paper, Will had been able to organize them in his head and make sense of them.

Will’s dad had started buying him notebooks. Whenever he had money, he would get a notebook along with the groceries. Will had kept every notebook, recognizing the small sacrifice for what it was.

Will’s dad had never been good at expressing himself, but Will had never needed him to. Will could always see and feel how people felt, so he had known that his father had loved him, and these notebooks were tokens and evidence of his love.

Once, a storm had sprung a leak in the roof where they lived, and every notebook Will owned had been ruined. He hadn’t cried, only felt a dull emptiness in his chest, as he threw out the hundreds of pages of random non-sequiturs. He hadn’t needed them. Once they were full, he could have thrown them out right off. He had kept them because he liked to see them all together, know his father loved him, and know they were filled with his thoughts.

That was why Will kept all his notes. Some of the notebooks were gifts, and reminded him he was not alone, but they were all a manifestation that he and his mind were not enemies. He could handle his own disorganized thoughts.

Will’s father had quietly given Will another notebook the day after the storm, no mention of the stack that had been lost. He had not begrudged Will for them, and had never neglected to be sure Will had something to write in.

The notebook that came in the mail today was so unexpected Will didn’t immediately know what to make of it. It was hardcover, glossy, dark red, almost black, with Will’s name printed in silver. It was clearly expensive, and Will didn’t know why anyone would have bothered to waste the money on him. Especially if they had any idea what would happen to the notebook. Will would fill the pages and then sit it on the shelf with the others, never to be thought of again.

Will opened the notebook and thumbed through the pages, seeing they were college ruled to give him more lines. He felt the paper, and it was the best kind, too. Not at all glossy or waffled, so the ink would dry quickly and not smudge easily. This was the perfect notebook.

An envelope slipped from the pages and fluttered to the floor at Will’s feet. He stopped his inspection of the notebook and retrieved the letter, hoping it would give him some clue as to who had sent it.

It did, but the sender was not exactly who Will had expected.

-To Will Graham,

I hope this letter finds you, despite your attempts to divert your mail away from your true address. I’d very much like to know what you think of my own work, but I understand that’d be difficult for you to do. I Will have another gift for you soon, and I hope you Will appreciate it. I was pleased with the reception of my first gift by the public, some horrified and some awed. 

I think that’s how your work should be viewed, with fear and respect. 

I believe you’re the only man who can truly understand why I do the things I do, because you have a similar darkness in your head and, rather than struggle with it as most would, you’ve learned to flourish in the shadows.

I Will not make this letter excessively long, to avoid boring you. I only hope this Will be of use to you and that you may think of me often.

Kindest regards,

Your Friend-

It was a gift from the killer. From whoever had recreated the scene from his book. Will hadn’t expected him to reach out like this. He had thought the murder would be enough, a message to Will from the killer.

Will called Catherine, and asked what he should do, but he couldn’t bring himself to tell her about the notebook. He only told her about the letter.

“You’re sure it’s from the real killer, and not just someone wanting to take credit for it?” she asked, sounding concerned more than doubtful, which Will was grateful for.

Will turned the brown paper the book had been wrapped in over in his hands. There was no return address. 

“Yes,” he told her, “they aren’t taunting or trying to get a rise out of me. They didn’t even mention the murder outright. They only alluded to it, knowing I would make the connection. If they wanted to take the credit, they would have sent this to the police and mentioned me by name, saying something about the police being incompetent. This isn’t that.”

Catherine considered it for a moment.

“Our interview with Agent Crawford is tomorrow,” she said, “Put all of it into a bag and give it to me in the morning. I’ll give it to them.”

Will felt a stab of jealous selfishness, and it made him shut his mouth about the notebook again. He didn’t want to give it to them. They wouldn’t give it back. He wanted it. He wanted to have it, and write in it. He wanted to put it on his shelf when it was finished and see it every day, remembering who had sent it to him. 

So he said nothing about it.

“Alright,” he said, “I guess I’ll see you tomorrow, then.”

Catherine hummed her agreement.

“Don’t worry, Will,” she said, “I won’t let them do anything to you without putting up one hell of a fight.”

Will smiled, but didn’t feel all that comforted by the thought. She would fight them, but she couldn’t stop them.

“Thanks,” he said, and they ended the call.

Will stared at the notebook for a long moment, wondering if there was some way he could do the right thing and still get to have the notebook. 

Will loved getting notebooks as gifts, and he felt selfish for wanting this one, but he did. People always gave him notebooks for holidays, if they knew anything about him, but this was by far the nicest one he had ever been given. He wanted it badly. 

So, his next call was to Beverly.

“I’ll be damned,” she said by way of greeting, “being in love with Lecter is turning you into a regular extrovert.”

Will’s mind went momentarily blank as he wondered what in the world she was talking about. 

“Oh,” Will said eventually, now unsure what to say. He felt as if his entire train of thought had been derailed.

“What?” Beverly asked, now sounding concerned rather than lightly teasing, “Isn’t that why you called?”

Will stumbled over his words for a moment, trying to put them together in a way that would make sense.

“Uh, no,” he told her, “this has nothing to do with Hannibal.”

“Huh,” Beverly said, “okay then. What’s this about?”

Will sighed, tracing the letters of his own embossed name on the front of the notebook.

“The FBI,” he confessed. 

Beverly was silent for a long moment.

“Is this going to endanger my job?” she asked.

“No!” Will said immediately. He would never ask her to do something that could get her into trouble. That was why he was asking her this. So she wouldn’t be in danger from whatever he chose. “I just want to know something.”

Beverly sighed lightly, and Will knew she would be shaking her head. He hoped she wouldn’t get in trouble with anyone for talking to him, but he might not even be doing anything against the rules. It depended on what she could tell him.

“What do you want to know?” she asked.

Will swallowed and steadied his nerves.

“If the FBI had something as evidence, would it be given back to the owner when they were done processing it?” 

Beverly thought about it. Will hoped she would say he could eat his cake and have it too, but he doubted she would. He wasn’t that delusional. 

“It depends on the crime, and the court proceedings and all that,” Beverly said, “Usually, they’ll hold onto it until everything goes through court, and then some things will be returned. Sometimes it’s a bit of a toss up. It depends on the crime, and the circumstances of it being taken as evidence. Some things get lost in the shuffle and never make it back.”

Will bit his tongue against a curse, not wanting Beverly to know just how much of a disappointment that was to him. 

“Okay, just curious,” Will said lightly, “might use it in the next book. You know how it is.”

Beverly huffed a laugh, and Will hoped she was convinced. 

“Yeah. Usually you just text me these kinds of questions and I have to type out an entire essay response. I don’t know why you decided to call this time, but I’m always happy to help.”

Will smiled, though it was more of a grimace. He felt like everything he said today was hiding the things he wasn’t saying. Lies of omission were everywhere, and he was starting to get anxious about them.

“And I always appreciate your help, Bev,” Will said, “you know it. Where would I be without you?”

Beverly snorted.

“Dead in a ditch somewhere, probably,” she said, and Will heard someone else on her end. She must have been at work or something. “Sorry. Gotta go. Talk to you later.”

The call ended, and Will struggled over the pit of dread and guilt in his stomach.

That had sealed it. He wasn’t going to give them the notebook. He was going to withhold evidence, all because he selfishly wanted to keep a notebook gifted to him by a killer.

Will read over the letter again, noticing small things. For one, the letter never mentioned the notebook. Will thought that was most likely for this exact purpose. The killer had known he would give the letter to the FBI, and had given him an opening to keep the notebook.

The killer used contractions just about everywhere they could, except when one of the words was will. 

They always capitalized Will, even when it was not in the context of a proper noun. They had probably done this because it was Will’s name, and they wanted to draw attention to it or make him feel more directly addressed.

There was something slightly off about those two things, and Will thought they might have been done with another purpose in mind. The killer knew Will would hand the letter over, so was laying a false trail. They were establishing patterns that were entirely unlike their actual way of writing or talking.

It was genius. The FBI might not be able to tell the difference between what was real and what wasn’t. They might think it was all real, which would lead to them looking at all the wrong people. They might think it was all false, which would leave them no better off than when they started.

Regardless, Will hoped handing the letter over would make Jack trust him a bit more. He hoped beyond hope Jack would stop treating him as a suspect, and instead listen to him as a source of information.

The rest of the mail had contained a few letters from people who claimed to be the killer, though they had all been easily dismissed as lies. Will thought about it for a moment before he pulled out two Ziploc bags. He carefully slid the real letter into one of the bags and sealed it, then dropped the rest of the letters into the other and closed it as well.

He would hand over all of them, as a gesture of good faith, and to further push suspicion away from himself. The more he gave, the less they would suspect he was hiding.

At least, he hoped so.

Will sighed to himself and sat in his chair by the window. He looked out at the trees and allowed his mind to drift for a while. He came back to himself as he realized Hannibal had sat in that chair. 

Will hadn’t even consciously decided to allow it or recognize what he had done, but he had. Hannibal had sat in the chair where even Beverly was not allowed to sit, and Will had allowed it.

If Hannibal had noticed that, or known about the significance of the chair, he would certainly have realized Will’s feelings towards him. Hannibal was not a stupid man, Will didn’t believe he could have fallen for anyone stupid, and he very well may have put the pieces together.

Hannibal’s behavior had not changed noticeably while he had been at Will’s house, but it was possible he had put it together after the fact. After he had left. Will would have to watch carefully to see if there was any shift in Hannibal’s behavior the next time he saw the man.

But, for now, Will had a new notebook, and the stallion of inspiration was chomping at the bit. Will wanted nothing more than to set it loose.

Will opened the notebook, taking in a deep breath of the scent of fresh paper and binding glue. He clicked his pen and set it to paper, smiling as the words began to flow.