Actions

Work Header

Words of Warning

Chapter 32: 32

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Will Graham,” Jack said, setting a file down on the table, bringing the memories of their previous discussion to the front of Will’s mind, “I understand you have some potential evidence for us.”

Will nodded and Catherine produced the two Ziploc bags and set them on the table. The real letter was on the top, and Will had to restrain himself from staring at the neatly typed lines.

“Honestly, I think only one of the letters is really of any use to you, but I brought any I thought you might want. I want to show I’m cooperating to the best of my ability.”

Will could tell Jack wished he wouldn’t. It would be easier for Jack to be hostile towards him if Will would only give him reason to. Will was frustrating him.

“Thank you,” Jack said, and accepted the bags when Catherine slid them towards him, “now, I want to talk to you about the murder.”

Will nodded again, wondering why Jack felt the need to clarify that. He didn’t imagine the man would ever come to him for anything like writing tips. 

“I can’t rightly guess what it is I would tell you I haven’t done already,” Will said, hoping he didn’t sound like he was lying, “but I’ll try to answer any questions you have, as long as my legal counsel says it’s alright.”

Jack glanced at Catherine and a brief expression of contempt flashed over his features. If Catherine noticed, she made no indication of it, and Will thought she must have to deal with things like this often in her line of work.

Will itched for a notebook and pen, wanting to write. He tried not to fidget like someone experiencing withdrawals, but he thought that might be the nearest thing to the truth.

“What was the motive of the killer in your book?” Jack asked.

Will had to bite back a response, because he knew Jack had read the entire book. He had forced the team to read the description of the scene, and had taken it upon himself to read the entire book in order to answer these exact questions. And the answers had been there.

Will smiled wanly.

“Would you like the plain answer, or the philosophical one?” he asked instead, because he had an idea Jack hadn’t considered that yet.

Catherine shifted slightly, and Will could tell she was nervous about how Jack might respond. It didn’t matter too much, though Will did regret putting her through all of this. Beverly had been right. This was one hell of a circus.

Jack considered that for a long moment, proving Will right in thinking he hadn’t already considered it. Jack’s expression was the one people often wore when they thought Will considered himself much more clever than he really was. When they thought they had the drop on him.

“Both, most likely,” Jack said, “but let’s start with plain, as that shouldn’t take as long.”

Will agreed with him. Partly because this was the answer Jack already knew. He wouldn’t be as prone to arguing about it or misunderstanding.

“The plain motive, meaning the reason the fictional man had for killing, was ecological preservation. The man was a preservationist, and wanted to protect places that were natural. The victim had been on a committee that had voted to destroy a park in order to build a shopping mall and parking lot. The killer was upset about that, and so killed him. It was all very poetically just, if not insane and brutal.”

Jack had been nodding along, probably to encourage Will to say more than he had set out to. In fact, Will had now said precisely the amount he had planned on that subject, so fell silent. Jack looked up at him expectantly, letting the silence stretch between them in another attempt to get Will to continue.

“And the philosophical reason?” Jack asked when he realized Will wasn’t about to say anything else.

Will looked at Catherine.

“I know it is going to initially sound very potentially bad,” Will said, more to her than to Jack, “And I might not say it at all if I didn’t think it would be of use to the investigation.”

Will saw Catherine set her jaw and square her shoulders ever so slightly as she prepared for what else he would say. Satisfied she had been properly warned, Will turned back to Jack.

“The philosophical explanation is that I wanted him to.”

Jack and Catherine had matching expressions of shock for a moment. Catherine had herself back under control first, then Jack schooled his own expression. Will’s admiration for Catherine grew. She was better at this than the FBI’s own.

“I want the record to show that Will Graham does not condone or encourage murder in reality. He is an author of fiction.”

Jack waved her away, his eyes fixed on Will with vapid fascination.

“Go on,” Jack prodded.

Will nodded, satisfied he had been understood well enough.

“The reason I think this is important to you is this is the part that seems to be of the most interest to the killer. I am the god of the worlds in my books, and I decide what happens. Therefore, every detail is my will. I wanted to write about a man who killed the committee member in that way, so he did it. The real motivation was purely divine.”

Jack sat back in his chair, his expression pensive.

“What makes you think this is more important to the killer?” Jack asked after a long pause. 

Will glanced at Catherine. She was clearly not pleased with how this was going, but she nodded. Will thought it was a gesture of good faith, saying she trusted his judgment for this one, regardless of if he had earned that trust. 

“Just look at what they’ve done so far. They haven’t been trying to contact you, and they haven’t gone on a spree. It’s just the one body, displayed exactly as I wanted it to be. They sent me a letter, not you. If they cared about why the man was killed, not how, then they would have contacted the public through a paper or directly to the committee members who made the decision along with the victim. I’m sure the killer picked a fairly similar man to the one in my book, and there would be such people. But they didn’t do that. The killer didn’t send letters to the people who would be to blame in my book, or the ones responsible for catching the killer, they sent one to me. They didn’t brag, or ask if they had done well, because they are sure they have. They are sure of it, because it was my design, and they merely followed the blueprint. They didn’t ask me to contact them, to let them know if I liked it. They said they’d like to know, but they didn’t show any real doubt that I liked it. They’re sure they have done well, and that I approve.”

Jack was listening. For the first time, he seemed to be really, truly listening to what Will was saying. Not just with the intention of catching him in something, but actually searching for the meaning behind his words. To hear the information Will was trying to give him. 

Learning.

Catherine was watching Jack carefully, probably anticipating a poor reaction. But Will could see he had finally gotten through.

“You have a knack for criminal psychology, don’t you?” Jack asked after a long pause, seeming a bit fascinated. As much as he could be when only just getting over his prejudice.

Will smiled wryly.

“You should have done your homework, Jack,” he said, “I was fitting to work with you in my salad days. I took all the courses and every class to be a profiler, and I was good at it. Don’t call me vain for that, just see what I’ve done here. My one flaw is that I’m terribly imaginative, and that doesn’t lend well to mental stability. I wasn’t doing well at the time, and couldn’t get into the FBI. I put my imagination to other uses, as you can see now. I’m doing better now than I was then, but I no longer have any interest in the FBI. Now, with all this mess, all I want to do is help you, and all you want to do is make a villain of me. How fair do you think that is, Agent Crawford?”

Jack frowned, but he didn’t seem angry. He looked for all the world like a man who had just had his entire understanding of the world shifted a degree. Will was satisfied he had finally gotten through to the man, and Jack would finally begin to act on what Will said to him.

“Alright. I can see I made a mistake,” Jack admitted, and Will thought that must have been very hard for him, being the way he was, “can you help me understand how we can catch the killer who did this? You understand them so well. There has to be a way to catch him.”

Will let out a soft sigh. He was glad Jack was listening to him, but there was something niggling at the back of his mind that told him this was betrayal. Betrayal to someone who had never doubted him or tried to accuse him of anything. Someone who had admired him from the beginning. 

Will pressed forward, against that voice. He didn’t want to be complicit in any crimes, and didn’t want to encourage them. Of course. Of course he didn’t want that. He didn’t want more people to die.

But the notebook sitting on his desk at home called to him, telling him the killer had only made something beautiful. They had made something beautiful out of something ugly. And they thought Will’s work was beautiful. They were inspired by him.

The killer loved Will’s work. 

Will was going to help catch them, even despite all this.

Notes:

This chapter was a mite short, but only because I think the next one is fitting to be long. Stay tuned for it, because it's going to be fun.
Thank you for reading <3