Actions

Work Header

A Second Chance

Chapter 20: In Which Things Take Another Turn

Notes:

we are closing in on the end! i don't know what i'll do when this fic is over! D:

lol that's not true. i'll be working on more fic!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

After Frodo arrived, Thorin and Bilbo split their time evenly between Erebor and the Shire, or as evenly as they could. Sometimes Thorin had to stay behind, while others of the Company went with the two Hobbits. This was one of those times. It was three years into Frodo arriving, when Gandalf showed up on a foggy morning. He brought word of Orc movements and said he would help guide Bilbo and Frodo to the Shire.

Bilbo frowned as he spooned some eggs onto his and Frodo’s plates. “We dealt with Azog and Bolg though.”

“Orcs always find new leaders,” Gandalf sighed as he sipped some tea.

“All the ones left are stupid anyway,” Dwalin grunted. He bounced Bulin a little and his son giggled.

“Do they still mass in Moria?” Balin asked calmly. He gave his daughter, Daglari, a piece of bread and smiled at her.

Dwalin froze, his food halfway to his mouth. No. He looked at his brother, barely breathing. For the love of Mahal, Balin, no!

“Aye,” Thorin jumped in. “However, reports on their movements have dwindled.” He looked at Gandalf. “Some of my counselors think it’s safe to go back again. We could win.”

Dwalin couldn’t listen anymore. He gave Bulin to Ori and left the room. He knew his husband was confused and he was sure everyone was looking at him strangely, but Dwalin couldn't take it. Moria is where he lost his father, brother, and One. He would do everything in his power to make sure Balin never left to Khazad-dûm.

****

That night, after the children were in bed, Ori sat on Dwalin’s lap. Even though, Dwalin was staring, unblinkingly, into the fireplace, his hands went around Ori’s waist automatically. Ori bumped his head with Dwalin’s. Dwalin blinked at his husband.

“Hello,” Ori said softly, as he pulled on the marriage braid in Dwalin’s hair.

“Hello,” Dwalin replied.

“You were off in the mines.”

Dwalin hummed. “Just thinking.”

“Very hard,” Ori teased and kissed Dwalin’s neck.

When Dwalin didn’t say or do anything, Ori pulled back, a bit offended. “What is it? You can’t even see my hints!”

“I…” Dwalin trailed off. “It’s Khazad-dûm,” he whispered.

“Oh. What about it?” Ori cocked his head. He stroked Dwalin’s hands, as a way to comfort his husband.

“I lost my father there and I don’t want to lose my brother there.”

“You think Balin wants to go to Khazad-dûm?”

Dwalin nodded. “He’s mentioned it a few times since we reclaimed Erebor. I thought it was just a thought of his.”

“He does have many.”

“Aye,” Dwalin snorted. “But I knew when he asked Gandalf, and then when Thorin jumped in, I knew he wants to reclaim it.” Dwalin’s hands tightened on Ori’s waist.

“That would be kind of fun. I’ve never been to Khazad-dûm.”

“No,” Dwalin growled. “I won’t let you go. It won’t be fun! It’ll be filled with Orcs, Goblins, and other Evil Things!”

Ori frowned at Dwalin. He grabbed Dwalin’s face and turned it to face him. “I don’t want to go to Khazad-dûm. Well, I do, but I want it to be safe. I won’t leave you or the children behind.”

Dwalin swallowed hard, trying to keep tears back. He must not have succeeded, because Ori started to tear up.

“My One,” Ori whispered sadly as he brought their heads together.

Dwalin looked into Ori’s eyes for a long time, before pulling him into a kiss. “Let us go to bed.”

“A fine idea.”

Dwalin stood, picking Ori up. Ori let out a little squeak, but held on as Dwalin walked them to their bedroom.

Dwalin would spend time with his husband before putting his plan into action tomorrow.

****

The next day, Thorin called a meeting of his counselors, plus Gandalf, together. Dwalin snuck in and stuck next to Thorin. His cousin gave him a strange look, but said nothing. Dwalin listened, stone faced, as the counselors explained why it was a good idea to go back to Moria. Balin was the most impassioned about going. Dwalin ground his teeth together in an effort to stay silent. He glanced at Gandalf, but the Wizard was just puffing on his pipe.

Stupid Wizard, Dwalin growled mentally. You know what’s in there! Stop them!

He kept his mouth shut until everyone but Balin, Thorin, and Gandalf had left. “You can’t go, brother!” he practically shouted.

Thorin, who had stood up and moved down to the large table in the middle of the room, and Balin, who was showing Thorin some maps, both turned to look at Dwalin. Gandalf kept puffing on his pipe.

“Why not?” Balin asked. “It would be good for Erebor and our people to have our first home back.”

“There’s Orcs!” Dwalin said. He knew it was a poor argument, but he didn’t want to say anything else.

“Bah,” Thorin said with a wave of his hand. “We’ve dealt with Orcs. Balin and a small team of his choosing, will go into Khazad-dûm and once it’s secure, the rest of our forces shall arrive.”

“Do you not remember last time we tried to take Khazad-dûm?” Dwalin growled as he approached the table.

“I will never forget,” Thorin barked. Then he softened, “But we are stronger now.”

Dwalin turned to his brother. “What about Dori? And your children?”

“They will come along later,” Balin replied, confused.

“What if you die?” Dwalin asked, his voice cracking a little.

Balin’s eyes softened. “Brother,” he said quietly. He pulled Dwalin close so they could knock foreheads.

Thorin looked away and towards Gandalf, who was watching them calmly.

“We may die at any time,” Balin said.

“But not so far away from our loved ones.”

“Sometimes we do.” Balin pulled away and smiled. “Now don’t worry. Oin and Bifur will be coming with me.”

Dwalin couldn’t smile back. He just watched as Thorin and Balin gathered up the maps on the table and started to leave the room.

“What about Durin’s Bane?” he asked. He had to try and save Balin.

“No one has seen or heard it in decades,” Thorin said as he opened the door. “We don’t even know what it is.”

“It’s a Balrog!” he blurted out in a panic.

Balin and Thorin turned back to him, wide eyed. Dwalin swallowed, but held his ground.

“And how,” Gandalf rumbled as he he stood up, “do you know that?”

Dwalin spun around and glared at Gandalf. “I just do! And so do you! You were gonna just let them go and die!” he shouted.

Gandalf pulled himself up to his full height and said, “Do not think I would let anyone die, Dwalin son of Fundin!” His voice echoed in the empty room. Magic radiated from him. Thorin and Balin flinched, but Dwalin stood firm. Then Gandalf pulled his magic back and sighed, “Things happen for a reason. We cannot fix them.”

“Well I did! By the Valar, I did. I won’t let my brother die just because you think it should happen. I know what’s going to happen and I’ll fix it!” Dwalin shouted. “Balin died in Moria once, I will not let it happen again!” His voice broke and he felt tears spring up.

“What have you done Dwalin?” Gandalf asked fiercely.

“What Manwe and Mahal asked of me!”

Gandalf blinked in shock and hummed. Balin dropped his maps and went to his brother.

“What are you saying?” Balin asked seriously, his own eyes wet with tears.

“You died once Balin, I can’t have it happen again. Not yet. Not the same way!” Dwalin sobbed lightly and pulled Balin into a hug.

“Gandalf,” Thorin said, but Gandalf pushed him out of the room. He nodded at Dwalin, who nodded back.

“Brother, what has happened?” Balin asked.

So Dwalin told him everything, from Bag End to when he died at 340, leaving out the War of the Ring. They sat on the floor and Dwalin clutched Balin’s hand like he used to as a child.

“Then I woke up and Manwe was there. And Mahal. They told me I could change some things, so I have been. You and Dori didn’t happen because you left, wrote a letter, then died. Oin died. My One died. Balin, brother, please, just wait a few years. We can go when have a big army at our backs, perhaps even with an Elven unit or aid from Gondor. Just wait a few years, please,” Dwalin cried.

“Okay,” Balin said brokenly. He couldn’t stand Dwalin being so sad. He hadn’t cried since their mother died. “I can wait. For you brother, I can wait.”

They clung to each other for a few hours more before leaving the room. Thorin never mentioned it and told his counselors the plan to retake Khazad-dûm were on hold.

****

A week later, Gandalf, Bilbo, Frodo, Fili, and Kili were ready to leave for the Shire. Thorin gave his husband and nephew a hug. Gandalf pulled Dwalin off to the side.

“Anything else I should know?” he asked.

Dwalin had divulged as much as he could to Gandalf. Now, he hesitated. He wanted to tell the Wizard about the War of the Ring, but that would change things too much.

Dwalin cleared his throat. “Bilbo’s ring.”

“Yes?” Gandalf raised his eyebrows.

“I’d just, you know, keep an eye on it. Not too many magic rings turn people invisible,” Dwalin said cheekily. He hoped that the joking manner would turn Gandalf off.

Gandalf, however, hummed and said, “Yes Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel both mentioned something about you mentioning it.”

Dwalin coughed. “Elves,” he said flippantly. “Have a safe journey, Gandalf!”

“I shall,” the Wizard said. He tipped his hat at Dwalin and mounted his horse.

Fili helped Frodo into the wagon, while Thorin helped Bilbo up. Dwalin moved back over to the Company and put an arm over Ori’s shoulders.

More waiting, I suppose, Dwalin thought as he waved at Frodo. Then it’s nearing the end.

Notes:

‘off in the mines’ is like our equivalent to ‘off in space’. could also be ‘off in the caves’. i just made it up.