Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

there's WHAT in the stew?!

Summary:

While living in New York, one of Will's dogs attacks someone (although the dog was provoked). The victim demands the dog be put down and takes the issue to court. Will seeks out the help of Nelson Murdock & Page, much to Hannibal's dismay.

Matt, Foggy, and Karen are all thoroughly charmed by the sweet (yet somewhat strange) couple that grace their office. However, what happens once they're invited to dinner?

Notes:

i am sure that the venn diagram of daredevil fans and hannibal fans is non-existent aside from me, but oh well, this is my fic i'll write what i want. also first post of 2024!!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

It had been a quiet week for Nelson Murdock & Page. There was nothing more to do than file paperwork and drink subpar coffee, but Matt wasn’t complaining. He believed that they all deserved a calm week.

 

There was only one scheduled meeting for the day, and it was for one Mr. Graham-Lecter. The man who made the appointment over the phone was very brief with the details. He said that his dog had attacked someone and that the victim was demanding the dog be put down. The man on the phone (presumably Mr. Graham-Lecter) was adamant that it wasn’t the dog's fault and that she was provoked. Karen, who was the one on the phone with the man at the time, was incredibly sympathetic and booked him in as soon as possible.

 

It was twenty-five minutes past one, and Matt could hear voices making their way up the stairs. He and Foggy were already waiting in the conference room. Matt tilted his head and focused on the voices.

“My love, I am not one to often pass judgement,” an accented voice said. They were cut off by a scoff but continued, “however, I hardly believe that this establishment will provide you with the help you deserve.”

“Oh, I’m sorry. Who’s dog is being threatened with being put down? Yours?” the second voice sneered. This one sounded slightly gruffer, with a light Southern tint. This also happened to be the voice of their client.

“I would apologise, but I stand by what I said, so it would mean nothing to the both of us,” the first voice said again.

“Listen, you’re only here with me for moral support; other than that, I want you to keep quiet, okay? I’m paying the lawyers because it’s my problem to deal with. Understood?” Matt could hear the sounds associated with nodding.

 

Once the couple (and yes, they were definitely a couple) arrived at the office, Karen almost tore the door off of its hinges. She had been looking forward to meeting the dog all day (it had been discussed over the phone, as Mr. Graham-Lecter made it clear that he would bring the dog to prove her innocence).

 

As they made their way inside the office, Matt was able to get a better picture of them. They were both men, having introduced themselves as such to Karen at the door. They were of similar height and build; however, they held themselves differently. One stood with confidence and grace. He had held Karen’s hand and kissed the top of it upon introducing himself. The other was a nervous ball of energy, though it was well contained. He was constantly moving. His fingers were either tapping at his side or fiddling with the leash that held the dog. Then, Matt noticed his scent. A mix of saltwater, dogs, and something else. It reminded Matt of how Frank smelled. He couldn’t quite put his finger on it.

Karen led the two men into the conference room where Matt and Foggy sat, and introductions were made.

“I’m Foggy Nelson, and this is my partner Matt Murdock, and is it safe to assume that you’ve already met the wonderful Karen Page?” Foggy said, jutting his hand out to shake.

“Yes, we have,” one of the men said. “Will Graham-Lecter, and this is my husband, Dr. Hannibal Graham-Lecter.” Will shook Foggy’s hand, then sat down. “And this little lady right here is Girl,” Will said, presumably holding up the dog.

“Girl?” Foggy asked.

“Yeah, well, when you’ve had at least two dozen dogs over the years, it’s tough to come up with new names. And technically, our daughter named her.”

“I think it’s a wonderful name,” Karen cooed, her bracelets clicking against each other as she petted the dog.

 

Matt and Foggy discussed the case with Mr. Graham-Lecter (“Please, just call me Will. Hearing my last name makes me feel like I’m at work”) and came to the solid conclusion that Girl was completely innocent. She was recently rescued from an animal shelter and had been unable to find a home capable of looking after her. She had come from abusive owners and was wary of everyone. Will told them that he had been training dogs his whole life and decided to take her in. It was a neighbour who saw Girl and Will playing outside and thought it would be a good idea to throw sticks at her, despite Will telling him not to. This caused her to get stressed and disoriented, and when the neighbour refused to relent, Girl bit at the hand that came close to her. The neighbour threatened to sue and demanded that Girl be put down.

 

“So, can you help us? She has all her vaccines and everything, and it wasn’t even that bad of a bite. I don’t want to fail her.” Will ruffled her fur affectionately.

“You have a solid case, Will,” Matt said. “We’ll contact your neighbour and get back to you as soon as possible.”

“Thank you so much; it really means a lot. Most people would suggest just throwing money at the problem, but that’s not fair.” Matt guessed, judging by the slightly elevated heartbeat of Dr. Graham-Lecter, that Will’s remark was directed at him.

 

Will and Girl left first, as she was beginning to grow uncomfortable in the office, and left Hannibal to sign documents and work out payment. Hannibal noticed that one of the lawyers (Mr. Murdock, if he remembered correctly) was blind.

“I would hate to be rude, Mr. Murdock, but if you ever find yourself on the search for a guide dog, my darling Will is a fantastic trainer and would be able to assist you,” Hannibal said as he stood at the door.

“I appreciate the offer, Doctor, but I’ve made it this long without a dog; I think I’ll be fine.”

“Ah, my apologies. Well, thank you all very much for your help. I hope to hear good news from you soon.” Hannibal bid his farewells and left the rather dingy office.

 

Hannibal pocketed the business card he had procured from Karen. He didn’t find any of them particularly rude (however, he thought Mr. Murdock was a bit abrasive), but it was so hard to make friends in the city, so he thought it would be a good idea to be able to contact them in the future.

 

They had moved to New York shortly after officially adopting Abigail. All three of them agreed that a change in scenery was what they needed to get away from all of the bad memories. Abigail was in college for nursing and would stay with Will and Hannibal on the weekends. Will was able to find a teaching position fairly quickly, and Hannibal was in the midst of establishing a new practice.

 

“So, what do you think of your new lawyers?” Hannibal asked over dinner. A succulent, slow-roasted heart that came from an unsavoury real estate agent.

“They’re nice. Seem like some genuine people. I’ve worked with my fair share of lawyers, and they’re definitely the nicest I’ve ever met. What about you? What do you think of them?”

“They’re…pleasant. They are very passionate about their work. There’s something peculiar about Mr. Murdock, however.” Hannibal couldn’t forget the smell of blood that followed the blind man around.

“No,” Will said, pointing his fork at Hannibal.

“No?”

“No. You’ve got that look on your face.”

“What look?”

Will huffed. “You get this look on your face whenever you’re thinking about violating someone’s privacy.”

“Will, I am shocked that you would think I would go so low as to stalk a blind man,” Hannibal said in faux offence.

“I never mentioned stalking. Whatever, just don’t eat these guys; they’re nice.”

“Whatever you say, my love.”

 

“What do we think of the new clients?” Foggy asked while unbagging their Thai food.

“They’re interesting. And Girl is just so cute,” Karen said, reaching across the table to grab her dinner.

“I dunno,” Matt said from the couch. “Will seems nice enough, but there’s something off about the other one. Fogs, didn’t you say he was wearing a full three-piece suit?”

“Yeah, but damn, he looked good.”

“He had a pocket square too; I think it matched his tie,” Karen added.

“That’s weird, right? Who walks around in full suits?”

“Rich European doctors do! That’s who,” Foggy said. He walked over to the couch and set Matt’s food on the coffee table.

“If you ask me,” Karen started, “Will did well for himself. I mean, he got a doctor, and all I’ve got are two broke lawyers.”

“Hey!” Matt and Foggy said in unison. Karen smirked and sat down between the two of them.

“You know I love you guys, regardless of monetary status.”

 

It was two weeks later when Will received a call.

“Hello?”

“Hi, Mr. Graham-Lecter?” a familiar voice asked.

“Yep, that’s me.”

“This is Karen from Nelson Murdock & Page. I think you’ll be happy to hear that the issue with your neighbour and your dog has been sorted out outside of court. We did some research and found out that he had no case against you. He sustained no lasting injury, and he also has a history of abusing animals, so no one would believe he was attacked unprovoked. Congratulations, Will. Girl has no risk of being put down.”

Will sighed with relief.

“That’s amazing news, oh my god! I’m so relieved. Genuinely, thank you so much for your help. Is there anything I can do to repay you?”

Will heard Karen laugh down the phone.

“Your paying us is good enough. We don’t mind pro-bono work, but it’s nice to have a salary for once. Listen, I’ve got to go, but if you ever need anything, you know where to find us.”

“Yeah, of course. Thank you again!”

Will told Hannibal and Girl the news, smiling so wide it almost hurt. And if he noticed that his neighbour was sporting a black eye and a limp, he didn’t mention it. Motherfucker deserved whatever caused it.

 

The day after Karen called Will to let him know about the good news, his husband showed up.

“Hello again, Ms. Page,” he said brightly.

“It’s nice to see you again, Doctor! What can I help you with? No more trouble with your dog, I hope."

“No trouble at all, thankfully. This is actually a social call.” At that moment, Matt emerged from his office.

“Karen, who’s at the door?” he asked. She playfully rolled her eyes. She and Foggy were both well aware of Matt’s night job, so she found it funny how often he would act more helpless than he was.

“It’s Doctor Graham-Lecter, Matt.”

“Ah. Nice of you to come down again, Doctor.”

“It’s nice to see you again, Mr. Murdock. As I was just saying to Karen, Will and I are both incredibly grateful for your help, and I would love to have you for dinner. All three of you.”

“That sounds wonderful, doesn’t it, Matt?” Karen said, looking over at her partner.

“Uh, yeah, it does. Thank you very much, Doctor.”

“Please, we are not strangers; call me Hannibal.”

“Hannibal,” Matt said, as if he were tasting the name.

"Please leave the information with me, and I’ll let Foggy know later. I can’t wait to see your dog again,” Karen said, grabbing a pen and paper.

“Dogs, Ms. Page. We have seven.”

A grin broke out across her face. She took down the time and address Hannibal gave her with a smile.

 

That evening, while all three of them were getting ready, Matt spoke up.

“I think he’s weird,” he said.

“Who’s weird?” Foggy asked while fiddling with his tie.

“Hannibal. Wanna know what he said today? ‘I’d love to have you for dinner.’ Who speaks like that? Dracula?”

“Matt!” Karen scolded.

“Dude, English obviously isn’t the man’s first language. Please don’t be rude at dinner.”

“I wasn’t being rude! It’s just an observation. Plus, his name literally rhymes with cannibal! How come neither of you think that’s weird?”

“You’re being paranoid. If you’re nervous about dinner, no one will be upset if you don’t go,” Karen said. She smoothed the wrinkles on Matt’s shirt.

“It’s not that. It’s just… I don’t know. Maybe I am paranoid.”

 

When Foggy imagined Will and Hannibal’s home, it was nothing like reality. It looked massive, and a Bentley was parked outside! The whole outside had intricate designs all over, and Foggy felt ten times poorer than he already did. The three of them walked up to the door, and Foggy used the fucking door knocker. They didn’t have a doorbell; oh no, they had a gothic-style door knocker.

 

The door was answered by Will, who was surrounded by a swarm of dogs. They weaved in and out between his legs and nosed at his hands, but he appeared unbothered.

“Hey guys. Please come on in and make yourselves at home. Sorry about the dogs; they’re all very well behaved, but they love company.”

“No need to apologise,” Karen said. As soon as she made it through the threshold, she lowered herself to be eye level with the dogs, petting them all.

“What are their names?”

“Zoe, Buster, Ellie, Winston, Jack, Max, and of course you’ve already met Girl.” He beamed with pride as he named the dogs. Foggy petted a few and made a mental note to ask Matt if they could get a dog for the apartment.

 

They were given a brief tour of the downstairs portion of the house (they had two floors!) and shown the incredibly fancy dining table.

“Hannibal is in the kitchen, adding the finishing touches. He’s very ostentatious, I’m afraid. I’m gonna put some of the dogs outside; I’ll be back in a minute.” Will left with most of the dogs, leaving Girl behind. She instantly went over to Karen and put her head on her lap.

“Guys! She loves me!” she squealed. “Matt, we need to get a dog.”

“No,” he said.

“We’ll wear you down,” Foggy said. He looked down at his place on the table. There were so many forks. Why were there so many forks? How many forks did Hannibal own?

 

Will returned with a bottle of wine and poured it into all of the vacant glasses.

“Hannibal said that this wine will go well with the meat, but I think he’s full of shit. It tastes good, though.” Will sat down in the empty space next to Karen, which was next to the head of the table. Foggy assumed Hannibal would sit there.

“Woah, what’s this?” Will exclaimed. He looked down between himself and Karen and smiled. “Have I been replaced as her favourite person?” he said lightheartedly.

“It appears so,” Karen said while ruffling Girl’s coat.

“Y’know, she’s been really timid ever since we took her home; it’s nice to see her so affectionate with someone other than myself.”

 

A few minutes later, Hannibal entered the dining room carrying several plates with steaming hot food atop them. He placed a plate in front of Foggy, then Matt, Karen, Will, and finally his place at the head of the table.

“A traditional boeuf bourguignon, made with homegrown vegetables from our garden. I also slaughtered and aged the cow myself. Bon Appetit.” Hannibal sat at his place at the top of the table.

“This smells amazing,” Matt said. He felt for the appropriate spoon (his time with Elektra had taught him the basics of formal dining) and brought the stew to his mouth. It was rich and aromatic, genuinely one of the best things he had ever tasted. He couldn’t taste anything artificial. Just pure raw flavour. Then he got to the meat. He used a fork to spear a chuck of beef. It was as tender as anything. The moment it touched his tongue, however, he knew something was wrong.

 

He had tasted something like it decades before. It was during one of his lessons with Stick. On that particular day, the old man had been rambling about the war that was soon to come. He said that there would be a time when things got so bad that Matt would have to learn to put his emotions and senses behind him if he wanted to survive. He brought a plate with several different meats on it. He told Matt that one of them was human and that he had to guess which one it was. He never did guess. But he had eaten them all.

 

Matt had thought that Stick was bluffing, that none of the meat was human, and that he just wanted to scare Matt. But now, as he sat at Hannibal’s dinner table, he knew exactly what he was eating.

 

He could feel Hannibal’s stare as he ate. Had Matt made a face? Had he given himself away?

“You okay, Matty?” Foggy asked.

“Hm? Oh, yeah. I’m fine; I just bit my tongue.” Matt cleared his throat and set his fork down. He didn’t want to be rude, and what was more rude than refusing a meal? Matt continued eating the stew but avoided the chunks of not-beef.

 

“So, Hannibal. You’re a doctor. Of what exactly?” Karen asked.

"Formally, I was a surgeon; however, I am currently a psychiatrist. I used to run my own practice in Baltimore, and once I complete some paperwork, I will be licenced in New York.”

“What about you, Will? What do you do?” Foggy asked before taking a sip of wine.

“I’m a teacher. I’ve just started teaching criminology at a local community college. But, back in Virginia, I taught at the FBI academy. I wouldn’t say I missed it, though.”

“Is that how you two met?” Matt decided to participate in the conversation. He was worried that if he stayed silent for too long it would look suspicious.

“Unfortunately,” Will said. “I did some consulting work for the FBI, and Hannibal was the psychiatrist who had to clear me for field work. While working on a case, he showed up at my door with breakfast, and the rest is history." Matt assumed that there was something deeper to the story that Will refused to share.



Hannibal had suggested that after dinner they retire to the study and enjoy some drinks. While Hannibal, Foggy, and Matt all sat and drank, Karen and Will were outside with the dogs.

“I hope you don’t feel obligated to keep me company, by the way,” Will said. They were both sitting on the grass, throwing sticks at some of the dogs.

“I can go back inside if you like. I’m just more comfortable out here. No offence to Hannibal or your home, but it’s nice to just sit quietly for a bit,” Karen said while idly petting Girl.

“I know exactly how you feel. Back where we used to live, Hannibal would always throw massive dinner parties. They’d last hours and hours, and I just hated them. I’d always make an effort for him, of course, but the small talk was just unbearable. More often than not, around halfway through the night, I would disappear upstairs or outside so I could sit with the dogs. Hannibal would never make a fuss, and he’d always make sure there was food left for me if I left before the meal was over.”

“I can tell he really cares about you,” Karen said softly.

“He does. But, hey, the way Foggy and Matt act around you? It’s like you hung the moon."

Karen laughed softly.

“We’ve been through a lot, all three of us. And I think we’ve all got a history of not being able to ask for help. But we bring out the best in each other. I wouldn’t have it any other way.”

 

Foggy had excused himself to go to the bathroom, and Matt was left alone with Hannibal. Something he had been dreading since he met the man.

“Tell me, Doctor, how did you slaughter the cow we just ate?" Matt asked.

“The same way anyone does. I rendered him unconscious before slicing his throat to bleed him out. Over the course of a day, I dismembered him and prepared some of the cuts for various uses. Some went for dry ageing, others went straight into the freezer.”

“He was a cow. In what sense of the word, Doctor?”

“Whatever do you mean, Mr. Murdock?”

Matt could feel the predatory grin that must have appeared on Hannibal’s face.

“Was he a cow literally? Or figuratively?”

“You’re a smart man, Mr. Murdock. I am sure you can draw your own conclusions.”

Matt felt anger bubble close to the surface, but he heard Foggy coming back, as well as Karen and Will. Matt leaned back in his chair and finished his whiskey.

“Thank you so much for dinner, Hannibal,” Foggy said. “It was delicious, but I think we should be heading home.”

“Of course, allow me to show you out.”

The trio followed Hannibal and Will to the door, where they exchanged goodbyes (however, Matt opted to simply wave his hand) and Karen and Will made plans to meet at a local dog park. Neither Karen nor Foggy noticed Matt’s shift in demeanour, and perhaps that was for the best. He would tell them his findings later.


The next day, Will was just outside the office door, about to return Karen’s purse which she left, when he heard someone yell at the top of their lungs.

“There was what in the stew?!”



 

Notes:

over the course of writing this i thought it was cringe but then i stopped and thought "wait, i actually don't care what's cringe or not" then wrote it instead of studying. never be afraid to write fanfic, even if you think it's cringe! you never know, what you write could be something someone has been searching for. share your ideas with the world!

i hope everyone who celebrates enjoyed their Christmas! and happy new year! thank you all sososo much for reading. feel free to leave a comment to let me know what you thought and i'll see you all next time :D