Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Trick or Treat

Summary:

Once upon a time there was a sophisticated doctor and a grumpy hermit. There was also a forensic analyst who knew these two would be the perfect match.

Notes:

Happy Halloween! We hope you enjoy!

Work Text:

Hannibal knows instantly who he’s been set up with when he walks into the over crowded bar after a particularly long shift at the hospital. Beverly consults with the hospital from time to time on certain cases, and she has… quite the sense of humor. 

Will is dressed in faded jeans with a rip in the knee and dog hair clinging to the fabric Hannibal can practically smell from across the room. He’s wearing checkered plaid slung loosely over a form fitted white shirt, tight enough Hannibal can see he has toned muscles hidden beneath the layers of unassuming attire. His entire outfit likely costs less than a pair of Hannibal’s socks, yet he finds himself instantly intrigued. 

“Will Graham?” Hannibal stops at the edge of the high top, watching Will’s twitching foot still momentarily with his arrival. The nervous energy doesn’t dissipate, however, the man’s fingers twitching against the slightly sticky surface of the table instead.

Will laughs — not necessarily a kind sound but not unkind either — and gives Hannibal a long once over. “Katz must think she’s funny. Sorry you’ve wasted your time, doctor.” 

Self deprecating gets added to the list of traits Hannibal is already filing away in his memory, slotting in alongside: dog owner, fisherman, teacher, and entirely unaware of how he looks. 

Because Will is beautiful and made even more so by the fact he’s entirely unaware of it. His shoulders are hunched nearly to his ears and his nails are bitten down to the quick and he has mud clinging to his boots and dirt embedded into the grooves of his fingers.

He’s perfect.

“On the contrary. If you’re amenable I’d like to join you for a drink. My treat.” 

Will huffs another laugh. “I won’t stop you. But it’ll hardly be a treat, you’ll be paying more than full price since I declined to wear a costume.” 

Hannibal recalls the sign at the front door declaring:

Trick or Treat! Wear a costume for half off drinks. No costume? Pay double pricing!

“I’m not in costume either.” Hannibal points out, and he nearly purrs with pleasure when Will looks at him again, his gaze intense. His eyes feel almost like a caress, Hannibal uncertain whether he’s ever felt quite so perceived by another human.

“They won’t know that. You’re still in scrubs and a doctor’s coat, after all.”

It’s Hannibal’s turn to laugh. “Halloween always brings an influx of patients into the emergency room. Beverly assured me you wouldn’t mind if I bypassed returning home to change into a suit.” 

“Well I don’t hold my dates to very high standards. Or, you know, go on dates,” Will pauses and casts a longing look in the direction of the bar. “One overpriced drink won’t sink you, I suppose. I’ll have a whiskey, please.”

It’s the first time Will allows his eyes to fully meet Hannibal’s, and Hannibal rewards the contact and the good manners with a pleased smile. Pink flushes Will’s cheeks and he immediately averts his eyes, suddenly intensely focused on his empty hands as he picks at the edge of his thumb.

Beverly had warned him of Will’s aversion to social situations – skittish, was the precise word she’d used – and at the time, Hannibal had thought perhaps she was exaggerating. She was not.

It’s no matter. Hannibal has no qualms at all with the notion of coaxing the younger man out of his shell. Especially if it means more glimpses of those startlingly blue eyes.

“I’ll just be a moment,” Hannibal promises him and departs for the crowded bar.

The crowd has already grown in size, bodies pressing tightly together as the evening progresses and more revelers show up to the Halloween festivities. Hannibal has never cared much for Halloween himself, but as he watches the crowd he understands a bit of the appeal. 

Dressing up. Pretending to be something other than what society deems appropriate for a single night. The chance to be something different from what one might usually be. He understands the desire to shrug off the mantle of appropriate or socially acceptable. He’s always found himself above it all. 

But the rudeness of some of the bar patrons is something he still takes note of as a few people shove into him or curse at him as he moves through the throng. 

While he waits at the bar he watches Will from across the room and wonders at what flight of fancy had managed to convince Will to go on a date when he has such a clear lack of desire. Just as the bartender is returning with his order, a figure approaches Will and Hannibal has to blink twice to ensure he’s seeing things right. 

A twin. Interesting. 

“…you were gone for half an hour, Adam. And there’s come in your hair.” Will grumbles, looking judgmentally at the man who shares his face if not his fashion sense. Hannibal is still far enough away that the two companions haven’t noticed him yet, and he slows his pace to see if he can catch more of their conversation. 

“At least I wore a costume,” the second brandishes one hand at his outfit while his other surreptitiously runs through curly locks to check for the offending bodily fluids. He does indeed seem to be dressed up, though Hannibal cannot discern what the young man’s goal was. He’s wrapped in skin-tight black leather pants and a black corset that reveals more than it covers.

“Slut isn’t a costume when it’s something you wear every day, Adam,” Will scowls at his brother; the words sound as though they are a point he has to remind often.

Adam’s face twists into an identical scowl. “I’m a cat,” he declares, jabbing a finger at the set of ears barely visible in his riotous hair.

“Then where’s your tail?”

Hannibal edges closer, stepping up with an uncertain step as though he had only just returned from the bar and realized he and his would-be date had company. As he nears, he can hear Adam mutter something about ‘having it before the bathroom’ as he glances behind himself with concern.

“Forgive the intrusion,” Hannibal begins, placing Will’s whiskey in front of him. “And the inappropriate number of drinks. I wasn’t aware we would have company this evening.”

“He’s the intrusion,” Will mutters with a jerk of his head in his brother’s direction. “Wouldn’t let me hear the end of it once I told him I was going on a blind date.” 

“No way I’m letting my baby brother run off to meet up with some stranger! Not until I vet him out first.” Adam turns a discerning eye upon Hannibal, and by the way his gaze lingers as he takes him in, Hannibal has a feeling the bar is set rather low.

“‘Baby brother’,” Will scoffs as he raises his glass. “It’s a wonder how much more worldly and knowledgeable you are with three minutes on me.” He takes a sip and his eyes widen slightly before Hannibal is gifted with another direct peek at those gorgeous blue eyes. “You didn’t have to go top shelf,” he mutters, eyes cast down to the table once more. “Promise I’m not worth it.”

“On the contrary, I’m a firm believer in savoring the things we enjoy to the fullest extent. I’d never dream of serving a friend something subpar any more than I would myself.”

“We friends already?” Will challenges, tsk ing with another scowl as Adam’s hand swoops in to retrieve the tumbler he’d set down.

Adam’s own sip is twice that of Will’s, and his reaction to the quality of the alcohol is far more pronounced than Will’s own. It seems as though sharing a face is the only thing the twins have in common. “Damn, that’s magnificent. I suppose someone that knows their whiskey so well can’t possibly be of harm.” Adam pauses and peers at Hannibal again, “Unless you’re the sort to charm them before he nabs them. This a Bundy sort of situation?”

“He’s friends with the FBI, Adam!” Will growls, snatching back the glass, careful not to slop any of the remaining contents. “As I’ve said ten times already. You met him, alright? Now will you leave us alone?”

“Not quite,” Hannibal corrects, extending his hand. “Doctor Hannibal Lecter. It’s a pleasure to meet you…” Hannibal trails off, prompting the twin for a name he’s already heard tumble from Will’s lips several times.

“Adam. I’m absolutely certain the pleasure is all mine,” Adam flirts, and Hannibal meets his smile with one of his own. He’s a hedonist at his core and has had his fair share of passionate trysts. Never with twins, however, and he wonders if that is something Will and Adam are interested in; curious at the dynamic between the two. 

He doesn’t have to wonder for long, however, when Will clears his throat and Adam rolls his eyes before those same eyes sharpen and focus on something across the room, behind Hannibal. “I believe I’ll take my leave, I think I see someone I’d like to know.” 

As quickly as he appeared he’s gone, and Hannibal follows Will’s gaze as he watches Adam walk away, spots the woman across the room openly smirking at Adam as he approaches. 

“Is that his friend from earlier?” Hannibal asks, humor lacing the words. 

“I’m afraid not,” Will grimaces, and Hannibal laughs lightly, picking up his tumbler to sample the smooth liquid inside again. 

“Your brother is quite the extrovert it seems.” 

It’s Will’s turn to laugh this time, though his chuckle is a bit darker in tone. “We would have made an excellent, if unethical, study on the differences between twins. Nature versus nurture and all.”

Hannibal decides not to pursue that path of questioning as it seems something Will is clearly uncomfortable discussing further, and he’s far more interested in the man before him anyway.

“I’m only interested in learning more about you. Tell me more about how you met Beverly.” 

Will jerks one of his shoulders in a gruff shrug and peers despondently at the sparse liquid remaining in his tumbler before downing it in one final sip. “Same way you did, I suspect. I consult for the FBI on occasion, so contact with the BAU is pretty much a given.”

“Is the FBI in the habit of calling on its professors to assist in their active cases?”

For a split second, Will’s expression twitches with irritation before smoothing out into a deliberate facade of passiveness. When he turns his gaze to meet Hannibal’s – the third time that evening – his blue eyes are icy and detached. “I teach behavioral studies and psychoanalysis. That alone would qualify me for clearance to help on the case.” He pauses for a moment, eyes dropping to the now empty tumbler he twists idly on the tabletop. “Beyond that, I have a unique way of thinking that has proven… useful in the past. I can examine and interpret evidence and make leaps to conclusions quicker than the average agent. They like to bring me in on the real headscratchers.”

For the first time in a very long time, Hannibal finds that he’s holding his breath. He’s actually so captivated with interest for the man across from him that he’s taken a bit by surprise by it. Will finishes speaking, his voice softening enough as he speaks more about himself that Hannibal has to lean in to hear him over the din of the other patrons, and Hannibal finds that he’s not entirely sure how to respond. It’s less self-consciousness to speak about himself, Hannibal determines quickly by observing the way Will seems to tighten like an overwound string as he does so, but more self- loathing.  

How curious.

He clears his throat, wets his lips, and goes for whatever blanket statement he can piece together in the moment to salvage the conversation from souring Will’s mood further.

“I apologize, Will. I never meant to cause offense or suggest that I didn’t believe you to be qualified.” 

Miraculously, Will’s lips quirk into a small smile at that, and he gifts Hannibal with his direct gaze for a fourth time. “You may have just met me, but you can trust me when I say that if you’d have truly offended me, you’d know it.” The smirk widens, turns playful. “Though if you’re set on making it up to me, you could always buy me another drink.”

Hannibal is surprised – twice now in as many minutes – to find that he’s relieved to still be in Will’s good graces. He takes a moment to ponder as he drains the last of his own drink as well, his decision made and plan set in motion before the empty tumbler has reached the table.

“While I’m more than willing to pay double for whatever drink you might desire here, I’m wondering if it might be more beneficial to breakaway from the revelries of the crowd and have a nightcap at my home instead.” When Will doesn’t immediately balk at the invitation, Hannibal continues, “There are no expectations upon you whatsoever, I assure you. While I was agreeable to meet in a public space given the circumstances, I find that I thrive socially in a more intimate setting than a location such as this can offer.”

There’s a beat of silence between them, which Hannibal breaks with a small smile and the offer, “I actually happen to have a Macallan that surpasses that which they offer here at home that I’ve been saving for a special occasion.”

Will’s eyebrow quirks at that, the first motion to break his passive facade in minutes. “You’d deem this a special occasion?”

Hannibal’s answering smile is easy. “Making a new friend? It’s the most special occasion of all.”

—

In hindsight, going back to Hannibal’s place probably wasn’t the best idea Will’s ever had. But he’ll just add it to the ever lengthening list of stupid decisions he’s made. He hadn’t seen Adam again before he left but he’d sent him a text from the leather passenger seat of Hannibal’s Bentley and hoped Adam wasn’t doing anything too stupid himself. 

Hannibal is handsome. But more than that, he’s quiet. When Will is around most people his thoughts are a cacophony of sound – of other people’s thoughts and feelings, desires and fears. With Hannibal, things are blissfully silent. The moment they’d gotten into his car it had felt like a blanket of tranquility had surrounded Will, like being in the middle of a forest in a snow-laden winter. 

Perhaps Hannibal is just better than other people at hiding his emotions. Maybe he’s broken in a way similar but altogether different from Will. Will doesn’t know, and he doesn’t particularly care after his third glass of fancy whiskey. 

They’re moving too quickly, Will is absolutely certain, but it can’t be helped when Hannibal fills his drink for the fourth time, ice clinking against the crystal tumbler sides, and then takes a seat beside Will on the leather couch. Mentally things are totally silent for Will, but physically Hannibal is like a hot brand held inches from his skin. He can feel him seeping into every pore, every inch of his flesh set ablaze from the scant distance separating them. 

And then he’s leaning forward to press his lips to Hannibal’s without warning and Hannibal responds like it’s the most natural and expected thing in the world, as though he’s been anticipating Will’s kiss his entire life. He doesn’t instantly take over the kiss either, which Will notices with appreciation, instead allowing Will to make that decision for the moment. 

He allows their lips to slot together for a few moments, an electric thrill running through him when Hannibal’s lips part on a silent sigh as Will’s hand comes up to cradle his jaw. He can’t help but take the opening, curiosity coaxing his tongue out to explore this new territory. 

Hannibal tastes like single malt and rosemary and sin, and his own tongue meets Will’s with enthusiasm. This is not at all what Will does, not who he is. This is something new and addictive and it draws a groan from him even as he forces himself to pull back.

“This is…I don’t do this,” Will tells him, even as he leans forward to erase the space between their mouths once more. Hannibal continues to give him complete control, meeting Will’s lips when offered, retaining distance when sought. “I mean it’s great. Obviously it’s great but I…I’m not someone who…”

“Dates?” Hannibal supplies. His voice is low and husky and it sends another violent shiver spilling down Will’s spine even as something molten hot twists in his gut. “You mentioned.”

“Socializes. At all. Let alone…” Will trails off, waving a hand between the two of them – what little space remains there, at least. When did he move his hand to Hannibal’s shoulder? When did Hannibal’s own find Will’s waist?

“Very unlike your twin indeed,” Hannibal notes, not unkindly but with the slight edge of good-natured humor. “Though if I may point out – with no intention to push your boundaries or pressure you – Halloween is, in fact, an evening in which it is customary to be something distinctly other than yourself, is it not?”

Hannibal’s hand is scorching upon Will’s waist, his other arm stretched along the back of the couch and in the perfect position to wrap around him at any moment. His eyes are molten honey, warm and sweet with a hidden promise of a sting to come. And his lips, red and kiss swollen and shaped perfectly to fit Will’s own, are calling to him.

This isn’t who Will is, any other day of the year. But on Halloween, maybe, it could be.

“Yeah,” he finds himself agreeing in a hoarse whisper. “Yeah, it is.” And then he’s shifting without thinking, reaching out, seeking, settling into Hannibal’s lap, pressing against his broad chest, meeting those delicious lips once again and falling, falling, falling –

There’s a buzzing in his ears that vibrates throughout his entire body, leaves him feeling on edge and tangled up in whatever is happening. But then the buzzing stops, starting up again a few seconds later. 

“It’s your phone,” Hannibal pulls away with a smirk, his lips spit-slick and shining in the low light of the fireplace he’d set ablaze upon their arrival. 

“Fuck,” Will mutters, realizing the truth of Hannibal’s statement when he feels the vibration originating from his back pocket. Before he can retrieve it, however, there’s a sharp, loud knock at the front door. 

Hannibal frowns, hands going to Will’s hips to guide him gently from his lap. “I apologize, Will. I’m not expecting anyone at this time of night.” 

They manage to untangle themselves from each other, Will pulling his phone free to see two missed calls from his brother, and Hannibal wandering down the short hallway to the front door. 

Will presses the call button, something like dread settling in his stomach. He had assumed Adam would be fine on his own at the bar. He’s capable and it isn’t like he doesn’t regularly hook up with strangers. As the line starts to ring, Adam’s annoying ringtone can be heard from the now open front door.

Will looks up to see him standing in the bright light of the streetlamps, silhouetted against the front porch. “What have you done with my dear brother?” Adam’s voice floats into the room and then he seems to catch sight of Will and his concerned frown turns into a pleased smirk.

“Ah. I see I’ve interrupted something. Well that’s what you get, Will, when you don’t answer your phone. You wandered off without telling me so I had to check your location. When I didn’t recognize where you were I figured I’d come find you myself in case you’d gotten yourself into trouble.” 

It’s rich, coming from Adam, who is constantly getting himself into trouble. For once Will was simply trying to get laid. 

“My apologies, Adam. I’m afraid I encouraged Will to come back to my home for some refreshments.” Hannibal is the ever-patient and polite host, though Will notices he still stands in the doorway, blocking Adam’s entrance. 

“I’m sure whatever you’re offering him is quite refreshing,” Adam smirks, eyes never leaving Will’s. “Shall I go, then?”

“I’m fine, Adam. Go home. I’ll see you in the morning.” Will grimaces at the gleeful look on Adam’s face. 

“Morning, is it? I see. I see. Well, have a wonderful evening you two. Don’t do anything I wouldn’t do.” 

“Because that’s such an exhaustive list,” Will bites back sarcastically as Hannibal murmurs his own farewell and closes the door. Another flush of heat surges to Will’s cheeks and ears, this time from embarrassment, as he sheepishly meets his date’s eyes. “Sorry about that. He’s not psychotic, I promise. Just an idiot.”

“I would say more protective than anything.”

“You would be generous.”

Hannibal gives a small smile at that and Will’s stomach flips in a way that it hadn’t even when he was straddling the man with his tongue jammed in his mouth. He realizes, quite mortifyingly, that the warmth blossoming and spreading in his chest is fondness, and all at once this seems too much.

It would be uncharacteristic of him to hook up with a blind date, sure, but to actually develop feelings for his partner in the process? It’s not unheard of, it’s unimaginable. He has no frame of reference for a brilliant first date with the hope of more to come, and suddenly Will feels overwhelmed and underprepared all over again.

“I certainly don’t hold your brother’s actions against you, Will,” Hannibal tells him, perhaps mistaking Will’s silent, horrifying revelation for embarrassment over the situation. “Especially not when I can see he was acting out of love and care for you. You’re very lucky to have such a devoted sibling.”

There’s a tone to Hannibal’s voice that doesn’t entirely coalesce with his words, and in the span of a breath Will both considers inquiring about Hannibal’s own siblings and realizes that he no longer has any. He does the smart thing for the first time that night and keeps his mouth shut.

“Don’t be upset with him,” Hannibal continues, misinterpreting Will’s silence on the matter now for anger. “He’s only looking out for you.”

Will can’t even begin to describe how ironic it is for Hannibal, a complete stranger, to be sticking up for Adam. Brash, uncensored, completely unapologetic Adam. “I’m more relieved he didn’t attempt to invite himself to the party.” 

Will’s only known Hannibal for a few short hours, but he’d marked the other man as a hedonist within minutes of meeting him. His love of suits and top shelf whiskey notwithstanding, the man just exudes an aura of excess in all things. So Will isn’t in the least bit surprised when his subtle statement catches and holds Hannibal’s attention. Anyone else might have missed Will’s implication but he can see clearly that Hannibal hasn’t misunderstood. 

Adam and Will have… shared partners in the past. Hannibal’s intrigue makes Will’s teeth ache. It would be a profoundly terrible idea to call his brother back for a threesome with a relative stranger – especially one that knows several of the same people Will has to interact with on a regular basis – but the idea still passes through his thoughts nonetheless. 

“You and your brother–” Hannibal doesn’t continue, he doesn’t need to. They both know what he’s saying without saying it. The words are free of judgment and, again, Will doesn’t find himself surprised. A man with Hannibal’s tastes and penchant for hedonism wouldn’t really be fit to judge.

“Hm. Sometimes. We weren’t raised together –” Will starts, and Hannibal does surprise him this time by interrupting him.

“You don’t have to explain yourself. You’ll find no judgment here, Will.”

“No, I wouldn’t, would I? You’re too intrigued by the idea to be judgemental, aren’t you?” Will teases, taking a few steps closer to Hannibal. He watches with a jolt of electric arousal and pleasure as Hannibal smirks at him, tilting his head to the side like a curious bird. 

“I’ve always found myself to be a staunch supporter of following one’s desires.”

“No matter where those desires may lead?” Will challenges with a quirked brow.

“In my experience, those paths are often the ones we need to follow the most,” Hannibal does his own part to close the distance between them with slow, measured steps.

And Will finds he wants to kiss him again. To throw his usual skepticism and caution to the wind and simply succumb to his desires. Halloween, as Hannibal had reminded him earlier, is, after all, a night to be something different. 

Will lets himself be kissed for several long moments, pulling away to catch a breath with a smirk on his lips. 

“Alright then, Doctor Lecter, trick or treat?” He teases, grinning wider when Hannibal’s fingers go tighter around his hip. 

“What if I want both?” Hannibal’s voice is low, husky, not at all how Will imagines he ever allows himself to be heard. A thrill ripples down his spine at the thought as something molten blossoms and twists low in his gut.

“Typically one has to choose. And people don’t normally choose the former,” Will’s own voice is breathless as Hannibal tilts his face closer still, until their mouths are near enough to brush together with the formation of each syllable. 

“I’m not in the habit of denying myself any experience,” he murmurs, and then chases the ghostly kisses with an intentional one. “Regardless of social norms or expectations.”

Will snorts into their next kiss. “I bet.” He can’t stop the wolfish grin from spreading across his face when the fingers at his hips clench tighter still. He wants to continue this banter, this thing that is somehow both playful flirtation and meaningful connection – but Hannibal’s next words dampen the flame kindling within him.

“Stay with me tonight.”

And Will remembers all at once who he is when it’s not Halloween, why he’s always been alone and chosen to be so. Why he doesn’t do dates, of either the first or blind variety, or hook-ups, or even one night stands. Even as much as he wishes he did now.

“I’m…not…” Words fail him, but Hannibal simply waits patiently, neither pressing forward to pressure Will nor ceding the ground he’s already gained on him. Patiently, as Will seems to withstand his internal struggle for an eternity if it’s a second, because how in the world does he finish that sentiment with the myriad of appropriate options presented before him?

I’m not into casual things. I’m not into things at all. I’m not a relationship person. I’m not enough of a person to be one.

“...Ready.” Not ready to sleep with you. Not ready to be seen, to be vulnerable, to be rejected.

Not ready to leave.

“For sex? Or for a relationship, and all that one entails?”

Somehow, impossibly, the tension that had begun to spin tightly within Will unspools all at once. “Either? Both?”

“And if I assured you I would be more than happy to simply spend more time with you? To learn you and hold you and sleep beside you?”

Will’s eyebrow quirks of its own volition, and he tries to suppress the suspicion that he knows Adam would be feeling right now. “What’s the catch?”

Hannibal’s features twitch into something almost like contrition, his pale lashes batting as though he’s been caught out at something. “Well, should you decide to stay, I must insist on cooking you breakfast in the morning.”

Will’s shocked and appalled to find something akin to fondness unfurling swiftly and warmly within him. He resists the temptation to snuff it out just as swiftly, allows a smile to slide across his lips instead. Maybe it’s okay to allow himself this, if even only for tonight. Maybe it’ll be okay to allow it a longer while, even.

“Well then I guess the trick’s on me.”

Hannibal’s answering smile is equally warm, equally fond, and sharp as a knife.