Work Text:
It starts with the fact that Hannibal has a vinyl collection but no record player.
"What do you mean you don't have a record player? How can you not have a—" Will gestures to the entire shelf stuffed with vinyl records.
Hannibal retrieves one of the sleeves—the text on the cover is French, and a black-and-white image of the performer is bordered with a vivid red box. "This is Leonid Kogan, with the Orchestre De La Société Des Concerts Du Conservatoire, performing Beethoven's Violin Concerto In D Major, Opus 61. But you couldn't listen to it if you wanted to—my last record player developed a fault, and scratched the vinyl beyond recovery. I retired the player, with prejudice."
"And you never replaced it because you didn't trust another player not to scratch the vinyl."
“These records are not trivial to replace. I intend to preserve them.”
Will hums, tilting his head at the shelf of records. “There's something to be said about a ship in harbor, don’t you think?”
But Hannibal gives him an unamused look, then changes the subject.
Later, when he's idle at home before bed, Will toys with the idea of purchasing a replacement for Hannibal's destroyed vinyl. Then he sees the eye-watering price for that particular record, and he decides that maybe he should look into another way of doing this.
Two weeks later, Will carries an oversized boombox over his shoulder into Hannibal's house. Hannibal gives him an odd, amused look but welcomes him in, and instructs him to set the thing down in the sitting room, which Will does gratefully. Then he pulls the CD out of his pocket—same black-and-white photo, same bright red border.
Hannibal blinks at it for a long moment, mystified. "You tracked this down... for me?"
"I ripped the audio files onto my computer, too. Just in case the CD player decides to eat this copy."
It's worth it, for the way Hannibal's face breaks into a rare, almost boyish smile. "Thank you, Will. This is an extraordinarily thoughtful gift. Would you—would you like to listen to it with me?"
So that's how it starts. The evenings they spend together are colored with music, now—in the background of their conversations, and also in the later hours when the air is charged with the memories of past transgressions which any wrong word could detonate… music fills those silences.
Eventually, Hannibal loses his patience with the CD format. Something about sharing his music with Will reawakens the snobby audiophile which had been lying dormant since the fiasco with Leonid Kogan, overpowering his lingering fears about preservation. Hannibal hires a technician to install a sound system and record player that probably costs more than Will’s car, and then every visit is punctuated with Hannibal retrieving a new vinyl from his collection, chattering about where and when he bought it, and when it was recorded, and the history of the music.
One evening, Hannibal shares with him an aria from the 1963 Decca recording of La Traviata. Joan Sutherland’s voice flutters with anguish and grief, though the Italian lyrics are lost on Will.
After the aria has concluded, Hannibal turns off the record and shares more contextual information with Will, and their conversation carries all the way back to the kitchen and through their dinner. But a few hours later when Will is preparing to leave for the night, Hannibal turns it on again, and skips the tracks forward until he reaches the final few notes of the aria from earlier.
“Why did you skip it?” Will asks, pulling his coat over his shoulders. “I thought that aria was your favorite.”
Hannibal hums thoughtfully. “This opera holds a special place in my heart. I find that once I have begun to listen to a track from this record, I feel compelled to listen through the rest of the album in its entirety, or the sense of suspension will continue to irritate me, like an unclosed parenthesis.”
Then, he sees something in Will’s face that intrigues him enough to ask, “Do you have any records in your life that evoke the same feeling, Will?”
Will stiffens, shutting down the question with a "Yes," and no further explanation. Then he leaves.
The relationship between a person and their music is extremely intimate, and while he might have felt okay with sharing certain things with Hannibal over these past few months of musical exploration (the novelty of watching Hannibal listen to Metallica can't be overstated), he's not ready to share other things. He's not ready to share something that he feels deeply connected to... not until he's sure that Hannibal will treat Will's things with reverence instead of derision.
It doesn't help that Hannibal's favorite things are all widely accepted to be classical works of art and literature. Hannibal's tastes are refined, and more than socially acceptable. Hannibal's tastes align with high society and culture, with a pedigree extending back centuries.
Will's tastes are a product of circumstance, mapped and melded into his adolescence. Sure, there are pieces of culture to which he feels a spiritual connection, but those pieces of culture are rarely older than him, and none of them older than his father was. Those pieces of culture were marketed and sold to Will as a consumer, not as an art critic. It makes them feel cheaper, when he contrasts them with the grandeur suffused through Hannibal's daily life.
He's not willing to expose that part of himself to Hannibal’s scrutiny.
But then Will arrives early to Hannibal’s home one evening, and he discovers Hannibal alone in the sitting room listening to La Traviata again, but this time he's crying. Will hesitates as he comes into the room, briefly scanning their surroundings for weapons. "Is something wrong," he asks stiffly.
Hannibal laughs through the tears, though, and that cuts away some of Will's tension. "No, my dear, nothing is wrong. It is only that Verdi has ensnared my soul yet again. Come and listen."
So Hannibal gives further explanation of the plot of La Traviata. It’s the sort of tragedy you would expect from a famous opera, and Will isn't terribly compelled by a third-hand retelling of a 19th century novel, but he does notice something different about the way Hannibal recounts it. Usually Hannibal recounts things to Will off the cuff, as if he's a lecturer in an academic hall, repeating a story specifically to further Will's education in fine arts. This time, though, Hannibal's voice wavers, and he lingers on the tragedy with a resounding empathy that is otherwise often absent from his world. Will understands, finally, when Hannibal gets to the part where Violetta sacrifices her own happiness to protect the innocence and reputation of the young girl.
Ah! dite alla giovine sì bella e pura
ch'avvi una vittima della sventura,
cui resta un unico raggio di bene -
che a lei il sacrifica e che morrà!
Oh, tell your daughter, so lovely and pure,
that a poor and wretched woman,
who has but one precious thing in life -
will sacrifice it for her - and then will die!
As the aria plays, he looks at Will searchingly with watery eyes, waiting for something. "Shall I—" Hannibal begins to ask, then simply offers, "I could replay it for you."
While Hannibal has always seemed invested in Will's opinions on things, that investment always stemmed from purely intellectual curiosity. This time, though, it seems to matter to Hannibal. He cares what Will thinks. It's important that Will appreciate this piece.
So Will consents, and tries to find the thread in the music that has been tugging so deeply at Hannibal. It is a beautiful piece, and the honor of sacrifice to protect the precious, innocent daughter would naturally weigh heavily in Hannibal’s aesthetic judgements.
And Will feels comfortable, suddenly, with the idea of maybe sharing some of his own important music with Hannibal.
He plans it out ahead of time. He didn’t have a copy of the vinyl to begin with, so he tracks one down and spends a stupid amount of money on a first pressing, rather than use the CDs and the boombox again. And he listens to the album over and over in the car on his commute, trying to imagine it from Hannibal’s perspective, and anticipate which things might turn Hannibal off.
On the day he finally brings the record, he warns Hannibal that he might not like it at first. "It's not... it's definitely not your style," Will explains to him, "but once you get past that—"
"I'm a strong proponent of the merits of the mere exposure effect, Will," Hannibal interrupts. "I know that the more I listen to this piece, the more I will come to appreciate it, regardless of any initial biases or misgivings. This music matters to you, so I intend to submerse myself in it."
Will makes a face. "Right."
"That said, with keeping such an open mind, I am exposing myself to you taking advantage of me," Hannibal adds, smirking faintly. "Tricking me into devoting hours to admire a work that you truly despise, solely for your amusement."
That startles Will into a sharp laugh. "I never said that I liked Rick Astley, Hannibal. I said the song was culturally relevant, but I didn't mean that you had to go and devote time to—"
"Let's begin, then," Hannibal says, fondly.
Will puts on the record, then stops before pressing the needle down. "He's—Jeff Mangum, he's not a very good singer. I mean. He's a good singer. But he's not polished—this isn't opera, Hannibal."
"You don't need to disclaim anything."
"But I—I'm just not sure how much context I should give you. It's sort of... religious for me? Which is stupid, probably. I barely know anything about him, or the band, or anything. It's completely divorced from its context in my head. Except for... for certain parts of that context."
But Hannibal's patience is probably waning, now, and Will doesn't want to influence him to dislike the music before even hearing it, so he just presses play, and the record starts spinning, and those thick, warm acoustic chords fill the room from Hannibal's surround-sound speakers.
That familiarity is what lets Will exhale.
He imagines it's how someone religious might feel, stepping across the threshold into the church sanctuary. Like, here is a place of safety. Here is that warm, dark, intimate place in your mind where you can let yourself feel things. Back on the sofa, he tucks himself into Hannibal's body, and they listen.
Halfway through the second King of Carrot Flowers track, Will dives for the liner notes and shoves them into Hannibal's hands like an unspoken order to read along with the lyrics. Amused, Hannibal reaches for his reading glasses and follows along with the big block of tiny text, squinting at it and using a fingernail to keep his place. Like a yad on a scroll of Torah.
Hannibal doesn't say anything to interrupt the music. Will supplies, "Yes, that's a theremin," at one point, but he otherwise remains silent, except for the way his feet and his hands can't stay still, tap tap tapping on the floor, clutching the fabric of his pants when Jeff's voice wails for a heart displaced in time.
Will also mouths along with the words, but that's reflex more than a choice.
Hannibal's brow furrows when he reads the lyrics that reference specific years and locations, and it's probably not very difficult for him to understand the allusions, the context. It's not very hidden to begin with. Will's mouth wants to jump in to say, It's reverent, it's reverent, I swear it's not appropriative, I swear it's not weird, but he knows that defensiveness isn't really necessary, because art is art. It's just that Will feels defensive because.... Well, he probably doesn't need to explain that Jeff Mangum's parasocial obsession with a tragic dead girl feels like a perfect reflection of the empathy disorder tormenting Will, feeling these intense time-bending spiritual connections to people he's never met, people who have nothing to do with him. People who were dead before he was born, and people who were dead only hours before he arrived at their final resting place.
He knows that his empathy isn't always based in fact. He knows that his empathy is really just one part evidence and three parts overactive imagination, mixed with his oversensitive emotions feeling gutted about the death of someone whom he only ever met in his mind, in an invented caricature of them.
He knows that he's Pygmalion falling in love with images he himself created in his mind; he knows that he's not falling in love with the real people.
He thinks Jeff knows that, too.
Listening to this reminds him that, while his constructed images of people aren't necessarily real, his experiences of those images are real, acute, and profound.
It's a church of empathetic spiritualism, where the spirit of a deceased person is not just the person's own consciousness, but also every thought anyone else has ever had about that person, woven together in a tapestry of eternal life. Where Will's apologies can reach the dead. Where his sacrifice brings them comfort. Where he can deliver them justice and truly lay them to rest in peace. It's a church of empathetic spiritualism and these are its hymns.
But he doesn't need to explain that to Hannibal.
Hannibal's undoubtedly already figured that part out.
It's weird, though, to listen to this with Hannibal, who thinks so little of other people, and takes lives without concern for the suffering that trails in his wake. But the suffering Hannibal causes is... well. Before Hannibal began acting upon the world, the world had already acted upon him. Hannibal is an animal, really, and despite all bluster, he kills like an animal, too. Graceful, yes, but also compulsive, and compulsory. (The point is, he's not a fucking Nazi, and that assuages most of Will's discomfort.)
Anyway, they make it all the way to track 9 before Hannibal shuts down.
Will had a feeling it would be that one.
Ghost, ghost, I know you live within me, feel as you fly
In thunderclouds above the city into one that I
Love with all that was left within me til we tore in two
Now wings and rings and there's so many waiting here for you
And she was born in a bottle-rocket in 1929
With wings that ringed around a socket right between her spine
All drenched in milk and holy water pouring from the sky
I know that she will live forever, she won't ever die
And she goes and now she knows she'll never be afraid
To watch the morning paper blow
Into a hole where no-one can escape…
It’s easy to tell when someone stops listening to an album you're trying to share with them. Hannibal stops looking at the liner notes, for one thing. He looks up and into the room, at the doorway, and Will knows how it feels to be trapped and forced to endure a sensation that is causing you distress. There's no point in leaving the album on at that point. Will stands up halfway through the first chorus without saying anything, and he lifts the needle from the record.
It takes a moment for Hannibal to turn to look at him. "Why did you stop it?"
"You weren't listening."
"My apologies, beloved," Hannibal says, somewhat roughly. "You have my full attention."
But Will just sits down beside him again. "It's a lot to take in all at once."
"Yes," says Hannibal cautiously, "but as I have said, I intend to submerse myself in this. I wish to understand you."
"It feels invasive," Will says. "For you. That song—a lot of this album feels invasive to you, but that song in particular does, because it's speaking to a grief that is intensely personal to you and you're not ready to share it with the person on the other side of the voice—a stranger."
Hannibal lets out a long sigh. "It is natural to feel discomfort when encountering something new. With art, that discomfort leads to a mix of attraction and aversion—we are attracted to the artistry, but averse to the way it makes us feel, the power it holds over us. But further exposure to the art inures us to that initial discomfort."
"Yeah," Will says, "I know. But you don't have to push yourself right now. I don't want you to resent this album because it came on too strong when you weren't ready."
Hannibal nods, swallows, and stares forward at the opposite wall. He's not misty eyed—Will's not sure if he would have become misty eyed had the music gone on longer. Probably not—Hannibal probably would have just erected his typical defenses, attacking the intruding sensation like white blood cells attacking an infection.
"There was nothing grand about her death," Hannibal whispers firmly, after stewing for a little while. Will knows that he's talking about Mischa, not Anne, though the same statement might apply to both. "She was extinguished without ceremony, like a calf to slaughter. It did not grant her wings, it did not free her from—She is dead. All that remains of her is within me."
"The song is euphoric," Will counters softly. "She's freed from suffering."
"For a time, I carried her milk teeth in a stained handkerchief in my pocket, until that, too, was taken from me," Hannibal replies. "She is dead, Will. Don't—don't sing to me of the circularity of time, it always leads to her dead—" and then he stops, pinching his forehead. "You're right. I can't speak of this right now."
"You don't have to—" Will begins, but Hannibal has already gotten up to leave the room. Will hears the sounds of him in the kitchen, filling the kettle and lighting the stove.
The thing is, Will knew that this would affect Hannibal like this. He expected this. He knows that they'll return to it when Hannibal is ready, when he's shored up his defenses and prepared himself for the experience. He knows that Hannibal was unprepared today. So he doesn't feel like he has to... regret it, or apologize. Eventually, Hannibal will let himself feel this, and things will be better. Today just isn't that day.
So Will stays in the sitting room and gives Hannibal the space he needs. And he knows better than to turn the music back on—Hannibal would hear it, and it would be too much, even with the lyrics muffled through walls and doorways, it would be too much just to know that the song has continued and that he can't escape it.
But Will also can't really leave the album unfinished, because it's still playing in his head; it would feel suspended, like an unclosed parenthesis.
So he sings to himself softly, with his eyes shut; a meditation. Even if he only finishes Ghost it will be enough, because it's the one that matters to him most. Feels like he's singing to Mischa, or the spirit of her that hangs over Hannibal like a canopy protecting him from the eyes of God.
"...and when her spirit left her body, how it split the sun!
I know that she will live forever, all goes on and on and on...
and she goes, and now she knows she'll never be afraid..."
Eventually Will feels complete enough to stand. He feels heavy with presence—an imagined presence, but a presence nonetheless. He knows it's in his head, but his head is real, and so are the things within it, in their way.
He doesn't know if he's feeling Anne or Mischa or Abigail or any of the other people he was too late to save—born too late, or arrived too late, the meaning between them blurs. But he feels satisfied that he's spoken into being the memory of it once again, no matter its metaphysical status.
Then he discovers Hannibal looming in the dark of the hallway just outside the room with tears flooded down his face. He takes Hannibal into his arms automatically, with all the eerie calm he feels after coming to peace once again with the angel of death. "I've got you," he says.
He hums to himself as he steps side to side with Hannibal in his arms, a slow rocking as the other man wordlessly buries his wet face in Will's shoulder and takes a deep breath there. Will hums, and the music continues in his head, and he whisper-sings the ending of the record gently like a lullaby, surreal and nonsensical and slow, "Two-headed boy... she is all you could need... she will feed you tomatoes and radio wires, and retire to sheets safe and clean... but don't hate her when she gets up to leave..."
And finally the tape runs out in Will's head, and it's all finished, wrapped in a bow. He tucks his face against Hannibal's ear, and together they breathe in the silence and the dark.
