Chapter Text
Silence seems to envelop the forest once again. Kíli, Fíli, Glóin and Balin just stand like statues, exchanging glances. Bilbo does not dare to move let alone breathe too deeply.
“It is the grief,” Glóin places a hand on Fíli’s shoulder. “He was carried away by the Orcs. A hobbit could not have escaped a fleet of their size. Come,” He pulls the dwarf along. “Let us scrounge around for some food and let us not mention this to Thorin.” Fíli nods, following the rest of the dwarfs as they turn away.
As they walk away, the panic that has been building up in Bilbo gradually subsides. The hobbit falls to his feet and listens, allowing his mind to convince his body that he is in no immediate danger. His breathing stills and when the forest is quiet except for the sound of rustling leaves and stirring creatures, Bilbo slides off the ring and stares at it.
“How did you run off?” He asks the ring before laying completely down on the ground, his head looking up, past the tree tops and into the sky. He knows he needs to rest for a while. He slips the ring into his pocket and simply breathes in and out, letting his muscles relax and his brain stop whizzing about. “It is a rather unfortunate circumstance to be dead,” Bilbo comments again, to no one other than himself and the ever-watching trees.
The last moments of light are fading and Bilbo predicts that it is no longer safe to remain visible in the middle of a forest without his dwarf companions. He does not want to bear the burden of wearing the ring any longer so he simply remains extra vigilant and silent as he makes his way to the outskirts of the camp. Honestly, Bilbo does not know how much longer he can remain dead. His stomach is growling from hunger and dead men cannot hunt for food. He sees the flicker of flames from a fire and slips back into the camp. The dwarfs are gathered around the fire, cooking up an unknown meat and, with light feet, Bilbo makes his way over to the ring of people and takes a seat in an open area. He does not feel comfortable sleeping with the ring on and his stomach is protesting for missing nearly six meals.
Bilbo contemplates his options while watching the dwarves and Gandalf. There are all staring at the fire and dispersing food. A thought comes into Bilbo’s head and he stands up once more, making his way over to his horse. Upon arrival, Bilbo shakes the reins of the horse lightly in order to alert the steed to his presence. The horse lifts his head up and down a few times and when Bilbo places a hand on his side, he does not stir. Bilbo makes sure no one is watching and throws open the horse pack, where his backpack full of items rest. With no eyes on him, he lets the ring fall from his finger and slips it into his pocket. The horse looks back casually and eventually goes back to grazing on grass. Bilbo hoards food from the pack, items he had stored while he was still “alive” and bolts into to the forest.
Finding a pleasant tree, with long covering branches and soft moss at the base, he takes a seat and starts munching away on some bread and cheese. He even indulges himself on some salted meat and once done, he rubs his stomach in contentment. The ring in his pocket seems extra warm to him but Bilbo finds no desire within himself to slip it back on. Instead, he watches as the sun dips further down into the sky. He pulls a handkerchief from his pocket, the one torn off for him early in the expedition, and wipes his face with a clean edge. He sets it down beside him and lets the uneasiness in his chest sink in.
He wants nothing less than to sleep with the ring on. It makes him feel uncomfortable, like someone was attaching his soul, limb by limb to four different horses and pulling. Despite this lack of desire, Bilbo knows that protection and warmth lay with the dwarfs back at the campsite. To sleep in the forest, alone at night, would guarantee a real and official death for the Hobbit. Bilbo decides to sit here for a while, weighing each and every choice. He does not want to stay dead any longer than necessary but he still has no clue how to describe what conspired when the Orcs took him captive. When he hears rustling in the leaves, and the snapping of branches, Bilbo decides to be safe and slip the ring back on. He curls up under the tree and watch as Thorin and Balin appear between the trees.
“I am concerned about his mental well-being, Thorin,” Balin explains.
“We have all been touched and effected by the death of our robber,” Thorin’s deep voice takes over. “I am no more concerned about Fíli’s mental health than I am for every other member in the group. It has shaken morale and broken some hearts,” Thorin stops and leans against a tree, scratching at his beard.
“But he was absolutely convinced that he saw Bilbo in the forest,” Balin argues and Thorin holds up a hand.
“Our group has been trekking for day after day, with many suns rising and falling at our feet without a definite break. My mind is telling me that the best thing for our group is to take a day to rest. As the days continue, however, we must draw closer and closer to approaching Erebor. We may not have the time to appropriately mourn our fallen comrade,” Thorin looks at Balin with a sad smile.
“If it had been anything other than a surprise ambush, accepting his death would be much simpler,” Balin nods. Thorin sighs.
“I wish Gandalf had never spoken of his tragic ending. To be eaten by Orcs,” Thorin shakes his head, “is not a death I would impose on even my worst enemy. Provided, one of my worst enemies is a dragon and the other is an orc,” Thorin smiles and Balin returns the sentiment.
“Kíli told me of your intention to court the hobbit,” Balin supplies and Thorin looks at him before looking away.
“It is the truth.”
“You must be taking the brunt of the loss then,” Balin places a hand on the king’s shoulder. “You know we do not start courting without a-“ and Thorin places his hand on Balin’s to silence him. The dwarf’s hand drops.
“It was meant with the deepest sincerity and feeling. It was well thought out before I made up my mind upon courting him,” Thorin explains and suddenly the lines of wear in his face seem deeper and his face, older. “I wish I had spent less time in my head and more time in action. Alas, it is too late.”
“I am sorry,” Balin replies. “I will head back to camp and demand that you be given some time for solitude. You will need more time to cope than the rest of us who held Bilbo in our hearts as a companion and as a friend,” Balin turns and walks away. “Remain vigilant. These forests are not friendly to dwarfs who travel alone.” With that, Balin disappears from Bilbo’s view.
Thorin is only a few steps away now and Bilbo can make out the worry on his face, the settling sadness of loss etching its way into the wrinkles and crevices. Bilbo wishes to offer comfort, to reach out and proclaim to Thorin that he is still alive, that the dwarf-king is not too late on his confession. Now Bilbo’s course of actions has been sealed the moment he returned to camp and refused to slip off the ring. He is destined to watch Thorin in emotional agony, all without producing a single sound to ease the torment. Bilbo feels like a traitor. He feels dirty and guilty and unpleasant. The spirit world is magnifying the hurt and pushing it against his chest. Thorin does not move. He does not breathe deeply. Bilbo wishes for something other than dark grays and light whites. He wants to see the blackish brown flow of Thorin’s hair, the dark shade of his eyes, the light silver of his rings and the gray strands that show a wealth of experience and knowledge. He wants to see the wide array of greens housed in the forest, the dark brown mud color of dirt and the colorful shades of his own clothing. He is wallowing in pity.
Bilbo tries his best to suppress a sob but catches his mistake too late. A sob chokes his way up his throat and hitches at his lips. The sound is audible and Thorin’s head automatically snaps in Bilbo’s direction. He knows he has just given his location away. Bilbo reacts on instinct and gets up slowly, not making any sound and back away, moving to a different tree to the right of Thorin. The dwarf’s eyes do not move and when Bilbo looks back, he mentally smacks himself.
There, under the tree, is his handkerchief. He very well cannot return it now, picking it up would appear as sorcery to an unknowledgeable dwarf. Instead, Bilbo waits. He listens.
Thorin walks over across the forest and bends down to pick up the handkerchief. He runs it very carefully between his fingers. Thorin must notice the design automatically and he looks around the forest with scanning eyes. Twice, Bilbo thinks that his eyes rest on the spot where he is standing but they quickly dart away.
Thorin looks back down at the handkerchief before shifting his feet.
“Bilbo?” The king calls out hesitantly, his voice shaking and Bilbo feels a chill run up his spine. “Bilbo Baggins?” Thorin repeats, this time louder and more demanding. Bilbo remains motionless, not wanting to give himself away. Thorin turns around in his spot and, when he sees nothing moving, his head drops and he crumples the cloth up in his hand. “It is nothing more than wishful thinking, Thorin Oakenshield. The Orcs carried him away,” Thorin whispers, the words spilling out from his lips and barely permeating the air. Bilbo holds back another sob. He watches Thorin’s back as he turns around and makes his way back in the direction of camp.
When he is out of range, Bilbo lets out a sigh. It was a close call but now Bilbo is feeling worse than ever. He needs to watch his things more carefully, unless he wants Thorin to discover him and the power of the ring simultaneously.
Maybe I do, Bilbo thinks.
Saying that nothing good arose from the mistake would be a lie. Bilbo can no longer deny his thoughts. He cannot keep hiding from the group. He is feeling like his soul is being torn apart.
Bilbo decides to make his way back to camp and once there he sees that the majority of the dwarfs have fallen asleep, snoring away in their blankets, close to the fire. Bilbo decides to walk closer and take a seat close to Thorin. He remains as quiet as possible, letting the fire warm him up a bit. The spirit world is chilling him to his core.
“What troubles your mind, Thorin?” Gandalf asks as his leans against a log, blanket spread across his lap.
Thorin lies down, his hair falling over his face. Bilbo’s handkerchief is resting in his hand.
“Grief, regret, despair, longing…” Thorin lists before closing his eyes.
“Are these directed toward a certain hobbit?” The wizard inquires.
It is silent again and Thorin nods, unseen by the wizard but looked upon by hobbit eyes.
“When I was young and the other dwarfs laid me to sleep, they told me that our losses are ways of testing our strength, our will, our beliefs,” Thorin relays and Bilbo looks down on him with a frown.
“Is that what you believe?” Gandalf whispers back.
“I believe there is only so much a being can take before their soul is tainted with misery. Hope can chase away even the darkest traces of taint but hope is only a temporary medicine, a light with a limited lifespan. Eventually, the dark will come pouring back in. Hope needs to be coddled and maintained, worked on and looked over, as a child would,” Thorin lets his eyes open to look at the sky for one last moment before closing them again.
“Rest, my friend. Our dreams often illuminate the solutions to our problems,” Gandalf looks in Thorin’s direction and once again, Bilbo believes he can see him even in the spirit world.
Thorin nods against the ground, a balled up fur against his face. His breathing evens out and, after a few moments of night pass, Thorin is asleep. Looking back, Gandalf is staring at the sky. When Bilbo tries to make eye contact, Gandalf lowers his head. Bilbo automatically looks away. Instead, Bilbo elects to lay down on the ground, his back to the fire. It offers little warmth but he moves closer to Thorin, his body parallel to Thorin’s slumbering form. Thorin’s hand is extended outward, the handkerchief rested against his palm. Bilbo sighs before adjusting his body to a comfortable spot.
Only a few inches away from Thorin, out of arm’s reach enough to avoid flailing limbs in sleep, Bilbo rests. He can feel and hear Thorin’s deep breaths, harmonized with the soft breaths of other slumbering dwarfs and Bilbo wants nothing more than to be “alive.”
Hesitantly, after surveying that the king-dwarf is still asleep, Bilbo reaches out and places a hand against the dwarf’s clothed chest. Upon contact, Thorin grunts in his sleep. Bilbo withdrawals the hand just as Thorin opens his eyes slowly. The dark orbs are almost light against the impenetrable black sky. A few stars glimmer to compare themselves to the color and Thorin eventually falls back asleep, his eyelids dropping before finally closing. He pushes his face against the fur, bring the hand with the handkerchief against his chest, over his heart, before letting dreams claim him once again.
Bilbo is hit with another overwhelming sense of sadness. Thorin is hanging on to a handkerchief as the only thread and memory of him and here Bilbo was, falling asleep and invisible to the mourning dwarf. It is a long night and he fights sleep’s claim against his heavy eyes.
Underneath the expanse of stars, the blanket of constellations and untold stories of legendary heroes not yet born, Bilbo makes a plan in his head. Doubt and frustration meet a climax, a decision that cannot be taken back. Within the rising of the next few suns, Bilbo will slip off the ring and reveal himself. He wishes to put the guilt and sadness to rest. He wishes to give Thorin a little more than a handkerchief to hang onto. Sleep does not find the hobbit. He will reveal himself soon.
Beneath the same expanse of stars, Thorin Oakenshield is deep asleep, wishing to have a certain hobbit, one who he intended to court, falling asleep next to him. As fate and will would have it, the very same hobbit is doing exactly that, regretting each and every decision he makes with a heavy heart.
