Chapter Text
“You should sit next to the fire so you dry faster,” Fili walks over. “If night comes upon us and your clothes are still soaked through, you will have a rough time healing up that shoulder.”
Bilbo nods and pushes himself to stand. Thorin is still lying down as he manages to get himself to a standing position. He walks over to the fire and relishes in the feeling of the flames drying his clothing. A few of the other dwarfs saunter over and take spots around the fire. The sun is still high in the sky, only just starting to descend toward the horizon.
“Can I speak to you… without the company of our group?” Bilbo can hear Thorin ask Gandalf, both of whom are still lying down by the bank of the pond.
“If that is what you desire,” Gandalf and Thorin both stand.
“We will be back in a short while. Hold down the camp,” Thorin nods toward the group around the fire and lastly to Bilbo before the two men disappear into the woods.
Bilbo cannot hear their conversation and can only imagine what they are talking about. Thorin, undoubtedly, is quite bitter at Gandalf for calling off the search when Bilbo was clearly alive all along.
However, he is not supposed to know why Thorin is hostile towards the wizard. Therefore, Bilbo decides to act ignorant towards the whole situation. A lie constantly requires vigilance.
“Why is there so much tension between Thorin and Gandalf?” Bilbo turns to his right to ask Balin. The entire group of dwarfs seems to tense up and after exchanging a few glares, Balin clears his throat.
“When you were taken from us,” He starts, “Thorin was in a rightful rampage to try and get you back. Gandalf, ever the voice of reason, told us to not follow after you. He was entirely too convinced that you were already gone from our reach. He offered Thorin the ultimatum; search for you and delay our quest, and risk failing it, or carry on and hope for the best. Thorin picked the latter,” Balin then picked up a defensive tone, “But that does not mean that we do not care for you. We took your words into account. You wanted us to help reclaim our home and if we do not do it now, someone else would have,” Balin negotiates and Bilbo just nods, edging closer to the fire as he pulls Thorin’s fur coat tighter around his shoulders.
Bilbo then lifted up his head and looked at the rest of the dwarfs.
“Surely delaying us an extra day to give me time to recover is cutting us thin on time?” Bilbo poses the statement as a question and, once again, the dwarfs look at each other.
Gloin decides to speak up.
“Grieving is normally what follows a death. You wish you had made different choices. You wish you could have saved the person in order to keep them in your company. We thought you were dead so those wishes crossed our minds. Normally, when a person dies, they do not come back,” Gloin laughs. “You returned and therefore, we have had time to regret our previous decisions.”
“There is a significant difference between someone being taken away from you and offering them up to be taken,” Bofur adds and the rest of the dwarfs nod.
“In less eloquent terms,” Kili speaks up. “We all missed you. We all were sad without you and we really do not want to go through that again. Don’t make us go through that again,” Kili begs and Bilbo just laughs.
“I will try not to make you all suffer but,” Bilbo frowns. “As of late, I am finding myself to be an attraction for danger.”
“Danger is okay,” Kili adds in. “Danger is fun.” Fili shoves him back out of the ring around the fire while all the rest of the dwarfs laugh without care.
“If you are able to convince Thorin, I should be okay to ride a horse. If I can follow someone one a lead, I will not have to use my shoulder,” Bilbo looks to some of the older dwarfs.
“Thorin is sometimes blind to logic when it comes to the things he cares passionately for,” Balin interrupts another exchange of glances.
“Passionately?” Bilbo asks and Kili, across the fire, coughs on the water he was drinking.
“He cares about the members of this expedition and he cares about this quest,” Fili jumps in, slapping Kili on the back to help him while he is choking. “If Thorin brings himself to do something, he puts all his passion into it.”
Bilbo, who is currently supposed to be unaware of Thorin’s feelings, of his intended courting, simply nods and accepts the answer. He knows now who to question about Thorin’s “almost” actions. Kili seems to be the most on edge when he almost slips in crucial information and, if he can get him alone without Fili, Kili is the dwarf who is most likely to spill out little bits of details.
After a few minutes of the dwarfs and Bilbo sitting in silence, staring down into the flames, Thorin and Gandalf emerge from the woods.
Bilbo immediately tries to judge their expressions. Gandalf is calm and pensive as ever. He winks at Bilbo with a smile as he sees the hobbit’s curious eyes. Thorin however, has a confused look pasted on his face. The dwarf-king looks like he has just encountered a particularly hard riddle with an answer no one yet has discovered. He shakes his head and clears the expression off his face as he walks over to the fire.
“Can we talk now?” Thorin kneels down in front of Bilbo, who is still drying himself out with the flames.
Bilbo looks at Gandalf, who simply nods. The hobbit nods back at Thorin. The dwarf offers out his hand and Bilbo gratefully accepts it and lifts himself off the ground. Thorin then extends a hand out towards the forest.
“If you were conducting conversations with anyone other than those in our group, I would assume that you were taking them out back to kill them,” Kili remarks and Thorin just lifts an eyebrow and rolls his eyes.
“That is reassuring,” Bilbo looks at the young dwarf who is gripping his sides as he explodes into laughter.
“Thorin has his mean moments but I can assure you he is not an orc,” Bofur watches as Fili rolls over on the ground.
“I offer my word, if you need it, that I will not harm you,” Thorin looks at Bilbo before glaring down at Kili. “If I were killing people, would you not think that Gandalf would not have walked back so smugly?”
“Smugness is not one of qualities, Thorin,” Gandalf pulls out his pipe. “I am patient and I take the time to analyze each potential journey every single one of us may embark upon, every single outcome and the moments that test our strength. I am prepared and I am old but I am not smug.”
“Are you quite sure of that, Gandalf?” Bilbo smiles as he puts his hands in his pockets and rolls onto the toes of his feet. “As I recall, you were positively beaming with pride when you mentioned your firework –making abilities. One, other than myself of course, might call that smug,” Bilbo grins from ear to ear and Kili, Fili and Bofur are by the fire, holding hands over their mouths to avoid laughing audibly.
“And as I recall, Mr. Baggins, my extraordinary firework-making abilities are what you remembered specifically about me. One, other than myself of course, might take pride in such a memory,” Gandalf smiles as he lights his pipe and Bilbo rubs at the back of his head with his good arm. He grins sheepishly. He knows well enough when to stop and to know when he has just been put in his place.
“Let us spare our hobbit from further embarrassment at the hands of his elders, shall we?” Thorin laughs as he points back to the forest. Bilbo wants to hide his face in the fur coat again.
The dwarfs decided that this current moment seemed as good as any to stop suppressing their laughter so, as Bilbo walked away all he heard was the unmistakable roaring of excessive dwarf mirth. Thorin just shook his head and Bilbo followed after him into the forest. During the walk, Bilbo slings the fur coat back around Thorin’s shoulders. The dwarf-king accepts it back with a smile.
Thorin walked deep into the forest, constantly looking over his shoulder to see that Bilbo was still following behind. He occasionally got tripped up on a few roots, as he was focusing more on the pain in his shoulder than the uneven ground, but he always ended up running into Thorin’s back who simply steadied him with a smile. Eventually, the two of them reached another clearing, alongside a stream where two big rocks overlooked the water.
Thorin climbs atop the tallest rock and looks down at Bilbo. The hobbit, unsure of how much strength he had with one arm, simply leans against the shorter rock and looks up at the dwarf-king.
“What do you wish to talk about?” Bilbo asks as he bends down with great care, to pick up a handful of rocks.
Thorin frowns a little. “About what happened when you were taken…” He asks slowly and Bilbo looks up at him with a frown.
When Bilbo was a little hobbit, he would hear tales of great adventurers who would have to make epic and important decisions in a matter of a split second. This decision would affect the entire course of the quest, the lives of many people and the success of the adventurer. Bilbo felt the weight behind that moment right now. He can come clean and tell Thorin or he can continue with his deceit and sink further into his guilt. Luckily, he has a much longer time to think than the average adventurer. Thorin sits silently as he digs through his mind.
“Can I,” Bilbo turns his head and puts a hand up to his face. “Can I be honest with you?” Bilbo asks and the dwarf king leans back on the rock, looking down at Bilbo.
“I would certainly expect you to,” Thorin responds. “Have you not been so far?”
Bilbo swallows and recounts his lies. When he escaped from the Goblins, he ended up finding the ring and slipping out. He slipped away from the Orcs with the ring. He followed the group and pretended to be dead. He knows that Thorin wanted to court him. He lost the ring and jumped back into the pond. Everything was just a domino effect with guilty feelings.
“I do not like the underlying meanings of the word ‘lie’ so I will simply say that I have withheld some of the truth,” Bilbo shifts against the rock.
“As is the case with many people,” Thorin replies with no rise or fall in his voice. If he is acting, he is quite good at playing nonchalant. “What segments of information has our burglar been withholding from us?”
“I would tell you to take a seat to hear a tale but, as a small mercy, you are already sitting,” Bilbo smiles before climbing atop the rock and sitting down. The rock brings him closer to eye level with Thorin.
“When I was taken, when the Orcs overpowered me and carried me off, I managed to get away after only a minute or two. I almost was run over by a few Wargs but I stowed away in the forest and managed to walk back to the camp. I found you before you set off. I followed you guys for a while before revealing myself,” Bilbo looks down and throws a rock from his hand, into the water, and watches as it skips across the surface.
The silence that follows almost pushes Bilbo to look up and see Thorin’s face. To resist the urge, he throws a few more rocks into the water, trying to beat his record of 5 jumps. After a minute has passed, Bilbo grips the rock in his hand and decides to face the inevitable. He looks up.
Thorin is looking down at him with a look he has never seen before. He tries to pick out the individual elements that are mixed up. There is some sadness in there, which is clear. His lips are pulled downward. There is some anger because his eyebrows are raised and pulled together. There is surprise there, judging by the fact that Thorin’s mouth is slightly agape. The slight tilt of his head indicates a small level of confusion. He has not seen the combination before but he knows the question that is bound to follow.
“Why did you not reveal yourself earlier?” Surprise and anger dissipate.
Bilbo skips another stone into the water.
“I feared your reactions, I think,” Bilbo watches the rock fall into the water and sink. “I feared the explanation I would have to give. I figured that it would be less of a burden if, for all the group knew, I had died in that invasion,” The answer was true and the feelings were there. He does not want to reveal the ring just yet. If he can keep that a secret for just a bit longer, he will.
“Bilbo,” Thorin calls and Bilbo shifts his attention from the rippling water to the dwarf-king. “We would have accepted it if you had offered no explanations so long as you returned us in one piece. Have I not offered you my apologies for belittling you earlier? I do not want to have you thinking you are burden to our group,” Thorin drops his head and sighs. “You would have saved us a lot of despair if you had returned to us.”
“I know,” Bilbo hangs his head. “It was one of those moments where I had a definite decision to make and I chose the wrong one, the easier one,” Bilbo chucks a stone into the water instead of skipping it with agile fingers. He fleetingly mourns the action. The rock was perfectly circular and flat. “I was that weak creature that was looking out for myself and I wish there were things that I can come out and explain but I cannot. I must not,” Bilbo admits and surprise appears on Thorin’s face again.
Thorin breathes out before continuing.
“There are things I can accept if you choose to withhold them. If they do not endanger our group, your secrets can stay your own. Do not think yourself weak for hiding. Sometimes it is in our nature to remove ourselves from the situation as to, as you think it, make things easier for the group. However, Bilbo Baggins, we need you as we need every other member in this group. I awoke one night to take a head count,” Thorin admits and Bilbo knows where he is heading. “I counted each slumbering companion and I came up one short. I was alarmed until I settled down and realized that we had lost one, that we had lost you. That, Mister Baggins, is a feeling I do not plan on reliving any time soon,” Thorin repeats Bilbo’s action and skips a rock against the water.
“I cannot promise that my secret will not draw attention to us anymore than I can promise that each action I make will, on a grand scheme of things, will affect us in some way. I do not claim to know the infinite amount of paths each of us can take as Gandalf does. I do not even know a few,” Bilbo skips another rock and he feels the ring growing heavier in his pocket.
“This is something that weighs heavy on your mind,” Thorin speculates and Bilbo just nods as the rock falls in after 4 jumps. “Can I not relieve some of that weight from your head?”
Bilbo chokes and runs his head through his hair. “When I was following the group,” Bilbo starts a story, not intending to answer the question. “I saw you all in mourning and I chose to stay hidden. Sometimes I wonder if I have a dark side, if I have a part of me that is slowly being corrupted. Before this expedition, I think the person that set out would have revealed himself almost instantly, to spare the group the pain.” Bilbo lets the rocks fall out of his hands and onto the ground.
Thorin is silent before speaking. “You speak of this person as if he is not you, as if you two are separate beings.”
“Maybe we are,” Bilbo whispers. “Maybe that corrupt part of me is slowly becoming who I am and that person who set out is only a fragment of a memory now,” Bilbo closes his eyes and hears the water ripple as Thorin drops a rock in.
He can hear feet drop to the ground. “What has happened to you to incite such thoughts? You are no more corrupt than any of the other men in our group. You are the same hobbit that set out!” Thorin urges and his voice is closer now, coming from right next to him.
Bilbo refuses to open his eyes. “I feel differently now. I feel the world differently now. I cannot claim to be ignorant of the things I was so blindly unaware of before,” Bilbo knows he is being cryptic. He knows he is shouting insane rantings to the sun, to Thorin, but he needs things to be said.
There is a hand on his knee now and Bilbo opens his eyes to Thorin’s sad gaze. “I refuse to accept that the hobbit we had in our company a few days ago has changed so drastically as to label himself corrupt. The hobbit I knew was nothing of the sort. The hobbit I knew, the hobbit sitting here right now, is the farthest thing from it,” Thorin’s grip tightens.
Bilbo cannot help but to think of Gollum, leering after the ring and talking to it as if the ring were its own entity. He does not want that to be him, a few years down the line.
Bilbo shakes his head.
“As the leader of our group, can you promise me something?” Bilbo asks, looking at Thorin with all seriousness in his stare.
“I can promise you it as a friend,” Thorin does not drop his eyes.
“If I ever change so much as to endanger the lives of the group, I want you to kill me,” Bilbo needs a contingency plan in case the part of him that craves the ring takes over and he would give up his group for more power.
Thorin instantly shakes his head.
“You are speaking in riddles. Has a spell fallen upon you? Why do you doubt yourself? I will not have you speaking about yourself as if you are livestock up for the slaughter! Bilbo, what has happened?” Thorin asks as he shakes Bilbo’s leg, where his hand is resting on the hobbit’s knee.
“Thorin, please?” Bilbo pleads.
“No,” The dwarf shakes his head. “If that day ever comes, and it will not, I will do everything in my power to make you change, to bring you back. Gandalf was talking to me about some changes, about some things that you are not able to tell me at this present moment and I will give you my trust. I will give you your secrets but do not offer me a reason to question your belief in yourself. Do not ask me to kill a part of me by killing you...” Thorin’s voice rises. “Because I will not. I cannot,” Thorin suddenly shifts his body and pulls Bilbo down from the rocks. Bilbo is surprised as the dwarf-king wraps two arms around him, pulling him into his fur coat in an enveloping hug. “I have things that I cannot yet tell you but I can tell you this,” Thorin whispers. “You have saved me and I will find a way to save you.”
Bilbo turns his head into Thorin’s fur coat and tightly closes his eyes to avoid tears from leaking out. He just stands in the hug for a while.
When he pulls away, Thorin leaves a hand on his shoulder and look him in the eyes.
“Do I need to worry about you running away, worry about you leaving us in the middle of the night?” Thorin asks.
“No,” Bilbo shakes his head as he laughs weakly. “That is not something you will ever have to worry about.”
Thorin smiles before dropping his hand. “Come.” He points to the rocks that they were previously sitting upon. “Do not dwell of the corruption you may have in your heart because I do not see it. I do not think it is more than a mere pin-prick. Tell me more of your story,” Thorin claims the taller rock as his seat. “So the game that Fili and Kili were chasing in the woods, the one Fili was convinced that looked like you, was actually you?”
Thorin laughs when Bilbo nods.
“That will be a relief for Fili to hear. He was questioning his sanity. The rest of the dwarfs were quite sure that he was going mad from a sudden onset of grief. Tell me, how did you follow us when we were riding and how did you disappear as Kili claimed?” Thorin asks and Bilbo swallows. He asked some questions for which Bilbo had no answers.
“Will you accept my answer if I claim that it is not something I cannot tell you yet?” Bilbo asks and Thorin closes his eyes and nods.
“You are alive and safe now so the details do not matter,” Thorin smiles. “I have a strong curiosity now but I have faith that you will someday disclose the answer. So I will ask another, because I believe your answer will have changed. Why did you jump back in the pond?”
At the look on Bilbo’s face, Thorin laughed again.
“Another question I must wait to be answered?”
“Yes, in part.. but as for the fear… It is true. When I fell asleep at night, I would feel the Orcs grabbing me. Worst yet, I was without the group and felt especially vulnerable,” Bilbo looks away and Thorin skips a rock into the water, reaching six skips.
“As we have promised before, you have our protection. You will not be grabbed again so I hope your mind can be soothed,” Thorin’s voice is soft.
Bilbo laughs and Thorin tilts his head.
“You are must less interrogative than I had expected,” Bilbo grins.
“Do not get me wrong,” Thorin offers out his arms. “I am curious but I will not risk your discomfort for answers. Right now, I can be content that you are alive and that there are some things you cannot share. You must accept the things that I cannot share too. It is a bargain between friends, between companions,” Thorin raises an eyebrow.
“What can you not tell me?” Bilbo grins.
“That, dear hobbit, would require me to tell you what I cannot.”
Bilbo lets his laughter die down before I serious look crosses his face.
“Are you honestly okay with placing our group in danger by this secret I am holding? When even I do not know what lays in store for us?”
“Why, Bilbo Baggins, I do not know how you even got the slightest idea that our group is the safe sort. In case you did not read the fine print, we are on a dragon-hunting mission! Your safety, our safety, is never guaranteed. We hardly ever know what is trying to hunt us down but, whatever it is, we will face it together as a group.” Thorin smiles.
“What will I tell the others?” Bilbo asks Thorin.
“I will handle the others, you need only handle yourself,” Thorin steps down from the rock and offers his hand out to Bilbo. The hobbit accepts it and slide off his rock.
When his feet are firmly on the ground, Thorin pulls him back into a one-armed hug.
“I hope you feel better from these small confessions,” Thorin breaths against Bilbo’s hair. “This corruption that you fear, I do not think it is something you have to worry about. Someone who is beyond help does not feel the guilt that comes with undisclosed information. I saw the way it weighed on you. You are not corrupt, Bilbo. I have seen many qualities within you but none of them were ever ones that tainted your being,” Thorin laughs and released him.
“Thank you,” Bilbo bows. “And I hope to know this information that you cannot tell me just yet,” He smiles. If Thorin does not want to talk about the courtship, just as Thorin is giving him time, he will give him moments to gather his thoughts.
“I will show you rather than tell you, hopefully,” Thorin looks back and waits for Bilbo to catch up as they walk back to camp.
“What did Gandalf tell you?” Bilbo asks, looking up at the dwarf.
“He told me what I needed to know,” Thorin pulls his fur coat closer. “He reinforced things I knew. We need you in our group and you are back. I need time to think things through as do you. He told me that you and I walk on paths that have finally converged. Gandalf is a curious man,” Thorin chuckles. “He can be cryptic and still convincing.”
“Do you accept what he has to say?” Bilbo squints.
“Yes, because I have a selfish interest in believing that his words are true,” Thorin grins.
“How so?” Is this related to the courting?
“Someday, I will show you,” Thorin places a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder and urges him forward. “Now come, let us take a weight off of Fili’s mind and assure him that he is not losing his wits. We must also rewrap your wound.”
