Actions

Work Header

Invisible vs Indivisible

Chapter 10: Visions, Gifts and Small Miracles between Breaths

Summary:

The tension between Donri and Thorin comes to a climax as Thorin pledges to kill the dwarf for attacking Bilbo. Meanwhile, Bilbo is plagued by the past and cannot sleep. He skirts Thorin's rules and heads to the forest where he meets an interesting female dwarf- A female dwarf who has some important words for Bilbo.

Notes:

Wow, so... 5 days since my last update. I am sorry for the long wait. This chapter is a monster though. Longer than the rest- approximately 16 pages typed out. I'll admit, I had a few distractions- The semester is starting soon so I am trying to get everything together. I have also started watching Merlin and Torchwood so... yeah.. that kept me away from my laptop. I have been working up to this chapter for a while. People have been asking me how dramatically I am going to change the ending of the book and this might answer it (just a little). Thank you for all waiting and thank you for all the kudos and the wonderful reviews. I am surprised at the popularity of this story. Without keeping you for any longer, her is the tenth chapter of Invisible vs. Indivisible.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

                Bilbo expected Thorin’s face to be a tight mask of anger as he paced back and forth in front of Donri. Instead, Thorin is calm and collected. He motions with his head and some of the dwarfs leave the room. Thorin turns his back from Donri and looks to inspect his sword, turning it over and over, the elfish blade glimmering off of the torches illuminating the room. Thorin’s face falls into a frown and he shoves his sword back in his sheath. A pensive look emerges before Thorin draws a short dagger from his belt.

                When he turns around, only Balin and Oin remain, sitting in the corner as Donri fights against his bonds. Bilbo silently pads over to the corner where the other dwarfs sit and takes a seat next to Balin. The old dwarf simply pats him on the arm sympathetically before directing his attention back on Thorin.

                The dwarf-king does not remain in one spot. He paces back and forth, knife in hands, looking only at Donri. Bilbo wishes at that moment that he would have been blessed with telepathic powers, or any gift that would allow him a small glimpse into Thorin’s mind. Donri’s death is certainly sealed. It has been since the moment he placed his hands on Bilbo after he had made eye contact with the golden necklace proclaiming Thorin’s courting. The only question now is how long Thorin will drag out the death, the most likely painful murder. Bilbo has seen Thorin’s ruthless side, on the battlefield against Orcs but he has also seen the soft side, the protective and caring side to Thorin. He has seen Thorin stay awake at night and stare at his nephews, watching the rising and falling of their chests before falling asleep himself. Thorin has held him close when he was injured and vowed to protect him. He simply does not know whether Thorin is one to torture someone, let alone a member of his own race. Then again, he has seen Thorin furious at the crime of another dwarf violating his claim. Rationality and remorse may be vacant from his dwarf-king’s head.

                “I wanted no trouble here. I held no malice in my heart when I entered your stronghold but you went and you did the one thing that would guarantee you to become a target for me; you touched one of my companions and not just that. I would have understood perfectly if you were drunk and came onto Bilbo but even after I laid a claim on him, you ignored it and attacked him in his sleep. I have been wracking my brains to figure out why you would go after something that would get you killed and I came to no other solution than the one that labels you suicidal,” Thorin crouches down in front of Donri, knife in his hands. Bilbo shrugs himself a little behind Balin, limiting his view of the scene.

                Thorin reaches down and shoves his knife into the cloth of Donri’s shirt. The dwarf’s eyes widen as Thorin drags the blade down and rips the cloth off of his chest. The shirt comes free and Thorin exposes the open flesh of Donri’s chest and abdomen. Donri shakes and tries to shove himself farther against the wall but the bonds are tight. He is screaming something against the gag.

                Bilbo does not want to watch Thorin torture someone on his behalf. He does not enjoy the screams of people in pain. He does not enjoy seeing his courted dwarf-king with intense anger on his face, ready to kill someone who had attacked him earlier. He loves the protectiveness and he loves the fact that he feels safe again.

                Thorin is standing in front of Donri so he cannot see the next move but after, he hears the muffled screaming of the other dwarf. When Thorin moves back, Bilbo can see a long bleeding gash on the top of Donri’s chest. It does not look like it hit anything vital or an artery, but the blood continues to flow down his chest.

                “I would leave if I were you, lad,” Balin looks at Bilbo who is cringing behind him.

                “I cannot,” Bilbo shook his head. “I do not know why but I feel as if I have an obligation to be here.”

                “This is not a place and time for people who do not know violence or the battlefield, Bilbo. I am sure that Thorin does not want you to see him like this,” Balin whispers, sticking close to Bilbo’s ear so that Thorin cannot overhear them.

                He bends down again and there is another new cut on Donri’s chest. Bilbo looks away, willing himself to not look at the scene in front of him. He knows that the dwarf struggling and screaming against his bonds will soon be dead. He knows the loss of life will be caused by Thorin’s hands.

                “Now, listen up because I want some words in your thick skull before you meet an untimely end,” Thorin stands to the side of Donri, now with blood coating his entire torso. “I am used to losing things, to permanent things drifting to a more temporary time span. I may even lose the relative permanence that can keep me alive until old age but I will not have you take Bilbo before his time is up nor will I have you spoil any small amount of that time. I know the small gift that comes with each second, each inhale, each blink of an eye and you have been wasting it,” Thorin leans down and presses a hand angrily against the dwarf’s chest. He shoves a thumb against one of the wounds and pushes. Donri grunts behind the gag and his eyes roll back slightly.

                Bilbo refuses to look at Donri’s face after that. He appears mesmerized with the red droplets on the floor that are falling in even seconds. They fall off of shaking fingers and a trembling chest. They hit the stone ground and sit. They even out. Occasionally two drops would fall on each other on the dark stone. Bilbo continues to watch and the red only continues to fall. Bilbo keeps his head down, watching the process until he hears the sound of metal dropping against the ground. Bilbo is forced to look up to see the source of the noise and notices that Thorin has dropped his knife to the ground. Bilbo can no longer see any of Donri’s pale flesh. Now it is covered in vertical and horizontal gashes, splits in the skin currently letting loose crimson rivers. Thorin’s hands are covered in the same color and he turns away from the paling Donri. He looks only at Bilbo.

                “I thought that this would stop my blood from boiling, would ease the rage in my veins but it does not such thing. It is only heaping guilt onto an already overflowing pile,” He looks back at Donri. “I will ease your passing dwarf, but only to quell the thoughts in my head.  Close your eyes dwarf and it will be over sooner than you think,” Thorin remarks and wipes his hands off on a rag. He unsheathes his sword and turns it over in his hands.

                Bilbo finally musters up the will to look straight at Donri. The dwarf was able to look Bilbo in the eyes during his most vulnerable moments, when he was pinned on the floor, completely submissive and at the will of his attacker. Bilbo figures that he should be allowed the same privilege.

                What Bilbo sees however, is by no means settling. Like Thorin, he figured that the sight of Donri in pain and fearful would do something to calm his nerves and settle his mind. It does no such thing. Donri is on the ground shaking, his face pale and covered in perspiration. His physical state is not what so affects him. When he looks into his eye, Bilbo sees fear and misunderstandings. He can see several broken dreams coming to the surface, missed opportunities and overlooked adventure. He can see through to the soul of a man who is staring down death’s open arms. Bilbo has no amount of mercy in his heart for someone who attacked him, who held him down with such ill intentions, but he does have mercy for the soul of a dwarf who has not yet lived to fulfill his full potential. Any life cut too short is such an overwhelming tragedy. Bilbo stands on shaking legs as Thorin faces Donri, not seeing his hobbit rise to his feet.

                Donri shifts, sending rivers of red fluid to the stone floor even faster than before. He grunts as Thorin grows closer. Balin just looks at Bilbo with a slight and almost knowing smile. Bilbo pads on silent feet right behind Thorin. As Thorin lifts up his blade, Bilbo gently wraps his hand around the dwarf-king’s wrist.

                “Bilbo?” Thorin inquires and Bilbo simply eases Thorin’s sword hand down. Donri trembles in the corner, obviously frightened but looking curious as to the scene unfolding in front of him.

                “Can you hear me out for a moment?” Bilbo requests and Thorin lets his sword hand return limply to his side.

                “Of course but can it not wait?” Thorin demands and Bilbo just shakes his head.

                “I am afraid not,” Bilbo soothes. “If we wait then my point will be invalid.”

                Thorin shoves his sword into his belt and turns to face Bilbo. He places a hand on the right of his jaw and lowers his forehead so they are close to one another.

                “You swore to me you would not view me differently. That you would not judge me for what happens in this room,” Thorin turns to look at Balin and Oin who have conveniently, and coincidentally, looked away. Thorin drops his hand and averts his eyes. From the corner, Bilbo can make out the look of pain and betrayal. The hobbit knows he has to speak up.

                “My views of you have not strayed, Thorin. Nor do I think that you have cruelty and mercilessness in your heart. I simply wished to speak to you for a moment,” Bilbo reassures as he grabs Thorin’s arm.

                “Then speak,” Thorin looks at Bilbo with a half-smile. He lays a hand atop the one Bilbo has already placed on the king’s arm. Bilbo pulls him over to the corner of the room.

                “A good friend told me once that courage is not being able to take a life but knowing when to spare a life,” Bilbo smiles as he quotes Gandalf. “I will not deny you the right you have to end his life but I am asking you to consider the crime versus the punishment.  He has violated your claim, yes but there are alternative ways to punish someone besides death,” Bilbo reasons. He cannot bear to see the loss of opportunity, of a life long lived, in the dwarfs eyes.

                “But you will not judge me if I were to heed your statement but take his life anyway?” Thorin asks and, although Bilbo feels his heart sink into his abdomen, he nods.

                “He has assaulted me so I hold no mercy in my heart for the likes of him but I am a hobbit of simple nature. We know not of executing people for violating claims or courting rituals. Thorin, I respect you greatly for taking this onto your hands, to punish him the way that you see fit. It is no longer my say as to what happens to him,” Bilbo argues and pulls away his hand. Thorin just nods.

                “Take a step back next to Balin and Oin, please?” Thorin asks and Bilbo looks away but nods, trotting over to his spot and sinking back into a sitting position. Balin pats him on the shoulder, his uninjured one, with an air of sympathy.

                Thorin draws his blade again and looks at Donri straight into the eye.

                “I hope that gave you a glimpse into the heart of the hobbit you tried to take advantage of. You tried to corrupt that goodness. Even after you held him down and attacked him, he pleads for mercy for you. Do you think you are deserving of such mercy?” Thorin demands and look straight at Donri. The dwarf-king even kneels and unties the gag in Donri’s mouth, letting the cloth slip out to reveal his chapped lips.

                “Speak up and speak the truth,” Thorin proclaims. “Your life does depend upon it.”

                Donri takes a minute to just lick his lips. He coughs a few time and analyzes the room, his eyes scanning over every wall fixture, every blemish of the stone floor.

                “Do you deserve such mercy, dwarf?” Thorin yells and Donri flinches back, eyeing the blade with fear.

                “N-No, I do not deserve his mercy,” Donri looks at Bilbo before hanging his head.

                Bilbo watches the scene with an intense mixture of fear and suspense. It is as if he knows something tragic will happen but needs to keep watching to see exactly how it happens.

                “Then we finally have something that we can both agree upon,” Thorin grabs Donri’s chin and pulls it up. “He is mine. It is hard to believe a hobbit such as him would agree to a displaced king’s courting offer but he did and I will protect him and cherish his every breath. You did something that endangered him and I can never forgive you for that.”

                Thorin brings the blade up to his throat and looks down, Donri staring at the blade with a mournful look. The two stay like that for a good few minutes before Thorin sighs and drops the blade down. Instead, he walks around Donri and starts sawing away at the bonds that keep him captive.

                “If Bilbo can dig up the mercy in his heart to spare you, the kindness to reconsider your rightfully deserved execution, then I can certainly find some in my own. You are free but you must leave this stronghold. You must never return here, I will arrange it with Kubla. If you presented a risk to my courted, you present a risk to any unsuspecting dwarf. I will set you free on the condition that you leave and that I may never cast my eyes on your face again,” Thorin looks Donri dead center in the eyes, waiting for his response.

                Donri looks between Bilbo, Balin, Oin and Thorin before nodding quickly.

                “Do you understand and agree to this? Speak a word of dissent and I will be more than happy to end your life quickly.” Thorin runs a hand through his hair while he waits, shifting feet anxiously.

                “I… I accept. I accept graciously. I know that this is not deserved and I am thankful for your clemency,” Donri stutters out as Thorin releases the bonds on his legs.

                Donri stands up but does not run away. He looks to Thorin as he re-sheathes his sword.

                Thorin grabs him by the collar as he shoves him out the door. “You will accompany me to Kubla’s chambers or I will have the guards shoot you down as you stand. I need him to guarantee your exile.” Donri just nods. Thorin watches him as he walks backwards to Bilbo. “Daylight is almost upon us. I would have you rest but I know you will not. I need to head down to the forges with some of our men, repair our weapons and armor and such. You may do as you wish but do not venture beyond the walls of this dwelling, okay? Evil may also be found hiding within the hearts of dwarfs, as you have no doubt uncovered by now. I will see you later. I will return and we will find some rest then, yes?” Thorin requests and Bilbo just nods. Thorin looks back at Donri, making sure of his presence before bending down and placing a kiss right above Bilbo’s brow. “If you find my nephews, one of them may accompany you throughout the day if you so wish.”

                “Thank you,” Bilbo responds and looks towards the still shaking dwarf ex-captive. “In more ways than one.”

                “Your thanks and gratitude are not well placed. You are not the one that should be thanking me,” Thorin replies softly. He lays a hand on the side of Bilbo’s neck. He withdraws it after a moment and nods towards Balin and Oin. The two dwarfs stand and brush off their clothing before stepping beside Thorin to accompany him.

                “Idle times make for mischievous hobbits, Thorin,” Balin laughs.

                “I have faith in Bilbo to make good use of his down time,” Thorin looks towards Bilbo for confirmation.

                “Ay, I have no yet been to a dwarf dwelling and, as I have a lot to learn,  I feel as if I will have no free time at all,” Bilbo smiles and Thorin just laughs as he walks out of the room with the three other dwarfs.  Balin closes the door behind them.

                Standing in a room, all on his own, Bilbo looks around. He notices the large bed in the center. His eyelids feel heavy but he does not have the fatigue or weakness that indicates he must sleep. Bilbo hesitantly walks over to the bed and climbs atop, nestling himself amongst the covers. He closes his eyes and inhales deeply. He catches a small scent of Thorin, of the smell he recognizes whenever Thorin embraces him. He smiles and tries to fall asleep, the events of the day weighing away at him. Bilbo breathes out and tries to relax.

                His mind does the opposite of relaxing. As he tries to calm his breathing, his mind races. He can feel the ice in his veins. The screeching resonates in his ear canals. He can feel the dirty hands of the orc holding him, dragging him away. He can practically feel Donri’s chapped lips against his own and the overpowering arms pinning him against the ground, leaving him defenseless.

                Bilbo sits up in bed and comes to the depressing conclusion that he will not sleep while the other dwarfs are out and about. He simply does not want to fall asleep, alone in a room, where any dwarf with the knowledge enough to pick a lock can come in and attack him. He simply will not have that happen again so he heeds Thorin’s words. He will look around while he has the time off from the quest.

                Bilbo slowly opens the door and looks around. He runs back to his room to retrieve his sword and a small pack of stuff. While Thorin and the rest slave away in the forge, he will go out for a bit of exploring. He walks down the hall and sees two open doors at the end. He walks over silently and sees Fili and Kili, in a room, packing stuff into a bag and checking their weapons.

                “What are you packing for?” Bilbo asks, watching the two brothers notice his presence before going back to checking their packs.

                “Ah, Bilbo… I see you are out and about. That is good to see,” Kili walks over and pats him on the shoulder before reaching behind him to grab an outer coat. “We are going out with the hunting squad to bag us some food. You are welcome to come with us,” Kili pulls on the coat.

                “Thorin forbade me from entering into the woods, from leaving the stronghold,” Bilbo answers hesitantly, watching the expressions on the faces of the two dwarfs.

                Fili smiles and patted Kili on the shoulder.

                “Do you hear that, brother? Uncle forbade Bilbo from leaving the stronghold. Do you know what dear Bilbo should do now?” Fili inquires and both brothers soon develop wicked looking grins on their faces.

                “Well, Fili… that leaves him with only one thing he can do,” Fili shifts back and forth from the heels of his feet to his toes and back again.

                “What is that?” Bilbo asks, knowing he is walking right into a trap of a conversation.

                “You must follow us into the forest for the hunting mission. After all, what fun is listening to an order?” Fili responds.

                “The fact that this is coming from the heirs to the throne of Erebor is quite alarming,” Bilbo crosses his arms and looks at the two brothers with a look of disdain.

                “As Thorin is currently the reigning king, Fili and I both have some time for trickery and deceit. We know well our limits, Bilbo. However, following the rules in life only makes you miss out on several experiences. Now come and follow us out into the forests. Some of the other dwarfs may even give you a lesson in sword fighting,” Kili answers and throw his pack over the shoulder. They dwarfs both stand there, ready to depart and looking at Bilbo with smirks on their faces.

                Bilbo paces back and forth near the entrance, considering his options. Thorin did say that if he were to go exploring he should see his nephews. Also, Thorin has known the dwarfs for many years so he must know that the two heirs are notorious for skirting the rules. Bilbo knows that this line of reasoning means that he has already made up his mind. He is simply trying to find a way to validate his decision in case Thorin is angered when he does not heed his warning.

                “I will accompany you but, and I trust that you will not disagree, it is best for Thorin to not know about how I spend my day,” Bilbo smiles. As a young hobbit, he was more than used to skirting the rules around Bags End. He would miss meal times while exploring the forest and he would track mud all over the house, much to the contempt of his relatives.

                “Oh, we more than agree but is it best for Thorin or best for you?” Kili grins again and raises an eyebrow.

                “Best for the both of us, perhaps,” Bilbo scratches the back of his head.

                “No use arguing who is keeping secrets versus who is being kept from the secret,” Fili guides both his brother and the hobbit out the door before checking the locked door twice before setting out.

                Bilbo, Fili and Kili met with a group of ten other armed dwarfs in the lobby. The entire time, Bilbo was on alert. He would walk down the hallways checking every corner to make sure the dwarf-king was not lurking around, spying on him and shaking his head at Bilbo’s disobedience. They set out for the forest, singing along the way and wishing towards unknown deities, their ancestors, for a good hunt.

                Bilbo stayed a little behind the group. Even though they accepted him with open arms, eying the chain around his neck with smiles and congratulations, he felt as if he did not belong. He kept his eyes on the two brothers and kept his hand on the hilt of his sword. At the same time, he watched at all angles for his prey. He knew he would most likely not catch something on foot, chasing after it with a sword but he was to inform the hunting party, mainly the archers, if there was a chance of bagging a decent meal’s worth of meat.

                After ten minutes and a few game hunted down, Bilbo catches something out of the corner of his eye.  He swears, from his first impression, that it is an elderly dwarf. He does not say anything to the hunting group. He simply watches as the image comes and goes. When he sees it a second time, the hunting group is running after a pack of wild hogs.  With thoughts of a hearty pork meal in their minds, they do not notice as Bilbo slips away.

                He follows the rush of color and cloak into the brush and sees the side profile of a dwarf kneeling over a river and picking plants. The dwarf places the roots and flowers into a basket already half-full with colorful petals and dirt covered fibrous stems. Bilbo’s acute hearing can pick up a slow happy hum floating around in the air and Bilbo steps forward to ask a dwarf why they may be so far out in the forest. Normally dwellings have a set distance for how far the citizens can venture out while still maintaining the security granted from the kingdom. The dwarf dwellings were not exceptions. Bilbo saw the handwritten signs awhile back and this dwarf was well outside of that boundary.

                He steps forward to speak to the dwarf but his foot slips into a rabbit hole and he goes falling forward. He grunts in surprise. The dwarf looks up in fear but, after seeing Bilbo in complete disarray, the dwarf just snorts and goes back to gathering foliage.

                Bilbo snuffs and stands up, brushing the dry dirt off of his clothing and shoes. The dwarf continues humming. Bilbo moves forward, aware now of a new pain in his ankle. He grins and bears the pain, stepping forward towards the riverbank and towards the new dwarf.

                “Well, lad,” The dwarf responds and there is a lighter pitch to their voice. “Are you just going to stand there or will you do a good deed and help an old maid with her duties?”

                Bilbo stops in his path and just stands there. He looks the dwarf over from head to toe.

                “You are…” Bilbo pauses and shakes his head. Instead, he kneels down and watches the dwarf pull up a long, tall flower with pink and purple flowers. He does the same and starts tossing them into the wicker basket.

                “I am indeed a female dwarf. Many of us are not granted the permission to leave the stronghold walls but I am allowed to leave to collect my plants,” The old dwarf responds and Bilbo starts to notice differences in the female dwarf. He sees a bust line, a different jaw and cheek structure. Her figure is slightly different, curves in different spots and different body angles. She has no beard but there is stubble present enough to make Bilbo question her gender. “I may not be as young and beautiful as I once was, long beard and beautiful brown hair but being female will not change with age. Not those Amaranth colors ones, those are toxic. You want the flowers with the deep carmine petals that promote wound healing.”

                Bilbo takes a good three minutes to distinguish between the two plants. Of course nature would have it that similar looking toxic plants would grow next to helpful looking flowers of the same color.

                “Do you live in the stronghold as well?” Bilbo asks, trying to make pleasant conversation as he digs his fingers into the dirt to pull out the plants, roots and all.

                “No, I do not like to live far from nature. I live outside the stronghold and Kubla grants me security in exchange for elixirs, antidotes and potions,” The female responds. “I am Edna and what is your name young helper?”

                “I am Bilbo Baggins,” Bilbo nods his head in respect for the elder.  “Is that not a lonely lifestyle? Have you any children?” Bilbo inquires to keep the conversation going.

                “I have four. I have three warrior sons and a daughter that runs the kitchens in the stronghold but I live out here. It is a pleasant lifestyle,” Edna responds, her voice soft and slow.

                “Have you a husband?” Bilbo smiles at the mention of the children.

                “Once upon a time I did. But he is long since deceased,” Edna smiles and pats the basket full of herbs down. “Collect these Malachite colored herbs next. They will provide numbness to the skin needed for disinfecting wounds,” Edna replies and Bilbo examines the plant she holds up. He nods and starts putting more herbs into the basket.

                “I am sorry for your loss,” Bilbo bows his head but Edna just pats him on the shoulder.

                “Our years were happy and joyful. I do not cry over a loss of a dwarf who lived so plentifully,” Edna looks at Bilbo before standing and taking the basket into her hands. Bilbo picks one last herb and slips it in. “If you accompany me back to my dwelling I will make us a mid-afternoon meal and treat that ankle of yours.”

                Bilbo is surprised by the offer and only smiles before easing the basket out of Edna’s hands and following her into the forest.

                “I should not be gone long. I was out with a hunting party and if they find me gone, they will be concerned and send word to…” Bilbo catches himself and stops his mouth from rambling out personal details.

                “They will send word to your courted, the dethroned king of Erebor, Thorin Oakenshield,” Edna smiles and Bilbo’s breath hitches.

                “How did you know?” Bilbo questions.

                “Word travels fast, master hobbit, even to the outskirts and front yard of my cottage. Also, that necklace of yours is fine dwarfen gold. I have seen its type worn by the old warriors of Erebor. But do not fret, hobbit. The dwarf king is busy in the mines, releasing his aggression on forged metal and the young princes are enthralled in the hunt. You have some time,” Edna responds and Bilbo looks at her curiously.

                “How do you know who accompanied me?” Bilbo inquires once more.

                “When someone reaches a level of clarity, there are many paths that may be revealed before one’s eyes,” Edna reflects and, after they climb a small hill, a near mountain, Bilbo can see a small dwelling in the distance.

                “You sound a bit like Gandalf,” Bilbo laughs and walks closer and closer to the dwelling.

                “Gandalf, the wizard?” Edna questions, esteem lurking on the edge of her tone.

                “Indeed, he is the wizard in our company,” Bilbo responds just as they reach the door. The dwelling is made of stone with a metal tiled roof. She pushes the wooden and iron wrought open to reveal a small but humble dwelling. Bilbo follows her in and sets the basket down on a wooden table in the middle of a room.

                The house is well-furnished. It has a few chairs, a bedroom in the back with a large bed and various seats and tables. There are a few cabinets along with a working table full of vials and stone bowls.

                Edna pats the seat of a wooden chair and she pulls it out from the table. Bilbo walks over and sighs as the weight is taken off of his ankle. She rushes around to the cabinet and pulls out some cloth bandages and a bottle with a dark brown liquid inside.

                Edna leans down and gently takes Bilbo’s ankle. She smears the contents of the bottle onto the ankle and pats it in before wrapping it up in cloth bandages. After she finishes, Bilbo flexes his ankle and finds that the pain is gone.

                “Thank you very much,” Bilbo smiles. “I am in your debt.”

                “You are not,” Edna stands. “You helped me with my errands. If you help me with our meal, we will have no unpaid debts.”

                Bilbo nods and walks with Edna to the cabinets to pull out some wrapped up meat and vegetables.

                “So, tell me more about this Thorin Oakenshield. Are you in love Mister Baggins?” Edna tuts and Bilbo just looks at her with surprise.

                “Love?” Bilbo questions, as if the topic is foreign.

                “You have accepted his conditions for courting. Surely you hold some level of affection for the cast out king?” Edna asks, cutting the meat, pork by the looks of it, and putting into a metal skillet pan. She places it over the fire and Bilbo takes a watch.

                “I-“ Bilbo pauses at the question. He ponders it.

                Is he in love? Can a king, someone with a throne and unimaginable riches within his reach, really fall in love with a simple hobbit such as himself? Will he not leave him when he takes his throne chair and looks over a mighty stronghold? No, Bilbo has his hesitations. He held them in his heart even as he accepted the courting. His fantasies of falling in love and following his mate on adventures and great quests influenced his decisions and in the back of his mind, he figured that maybe, just by a small stroke of luck, Thorin would honor his oath and keep him by his side.

                “You need not answer,  Bilbo Baggins. I can guess your hesitations,” Edna answers, smiling as the smell of cooking meat fills the small cottage. “You hold feeling for him but you doubt his feelings towards you,” Edna clicks her tongue while cutting away at vegetable. Bilbo turns the meat over in the pan.

                “He is a king and I am a hobbit. Such things are not meant to last,” Bilbo confesses, shaking his head. He cannot even begin to ponder how Edna can read his deepest thoughts, sense his hesitations but he does not care. He wishes for someone to talk to.

                “Things are never meant to last,” Edna responds in a low tone. “Mortality is a curse and a blessing alike. You learn to appreciate things as they come along. Everyone is so eager to wish for an eternity but what matters are the small moments, the seconds between each breath. Those are the moments that should be cherished. So what if you do not have an eternity with your dwarf-king? That matters not. Bilbo Baggins, as a hobbit you should know that even if you are with him for a night, for two different moons or many, it is an experience none the less,” Edna rationalizes and Bilbo only stares at the woman for a short while. She has a valid point. “Do not let that meat burn, Bilbo or I will have you go out and hunt for more.”

                Bilbo snaps out of his reverie and turns the meat over. When he finds it sufficiently cooked, he pulls it out and places it on two plates that Edna hands him. They fill their plates and settle down at the table.

                “You speak as if you have lost? Is it your husband who you speak of?” Bilbo asks and takes a bite of food.

                “My husband and my other loves. I was cast out of my old village because I did not believe in the dwarfish quality of monogamy. I believe each moment was made to share with another, to forge deeper bonds with those we are close to. I was taken up by Kubla, offered a home for my children, who share different fathers.” Edna speaks as she eats. “Thorin promised you an eternity with his courting. As he lives, he will be yours. It is in the nature of dwarfs to heed to that tradition. If you fret on the idea of Thorin straying, he has given you his oath.”

                “But if you strayed…” Bilbo shakes his head.

                “It was not straying as my husband allowed it. He too stood by my idea that life is not permanent enough to grant you connections with only one,” Edna argues, her voice growing louder. “Some things need to be kindled and sometimes things need to be dismantled.”

                “And what of your children? Do they too subscribe to the idea of multiple partners?” Bilbo asks curiously.

                “My children,” Edna reaches out and grabs a book from a nearby shelf, “have found their one true loves and they need not listen to an old dwarf such as myself.” Edna opens up the book to a portrait of six dwarfs, each independently sketched.

                Bilbo catches his breath as he looks at the picture, surprised at one dwarf drawing in particular. He zones out as Edna speaks. “This is me and my husband, Uldo. This is my eldest son, Dwalak, my middle son Barur, my daughter who comes after, Mado and her youngest brother, Donri,” Edna speaks and Bilbo stills.

                Donri is Edna’s son.

                “You hesitate, young hobbit and I know why. You encountered my son in the Great Hall and later in your chambers. He tested the bond between your chosen and you. It is not my fate to interfere in your life any longer, Bilbo,” Edna reasons and Bilbo feels the hair on his arms lower, even if just slightly. “As I said before, some things need to be kindled.”

                “How do you know all of this?” Bilbo shouts. He is tired of being lead around, given cryptic answers.

                “I told you; those with a clear mind can see many chosen paths. I have been watching your path Bilbo Baggins,” Edna cleared her plate and Bilbo choked a little on his food.

                “Why?” Bilbo backs up, sliding his hand to his blade.

                “Let me tell you a story first,” Edna holds a hand up as a peace offering.

                “Go on before I go running off to find the hunting party,” Bilbo threatens.

                “My son, Donri… He was born to a dwarf who dwelled in the woods, next to a small mine. He would make the strongest swords I have ever laid my eyes upon. They would cut through nearly anything, their edges would never dull. He had a keen mind for adventure and after I set forth to this place, I had Donri right on the floor of this cottage. Screaming thing he was. He inherited his father’s mind for adventure but not his courage to start new things. When he was young, he wanted to be a mapmaker, to chart unseen lands, but he never had the bravery to leave. He thought it was his duty to watch out for his elderly and aging mother. I wanted nothing more than to see him off and watch him live out his dreams but he would not leave and I only saw him fall to despair and a broken dream. There was a path; I saw it, that presented the opportunity for him to leave and live out his dream. As long as he could stay here, he would,” Edna presents and Bilbo’s eyes widen.      

                He takes into account Lady Edna’s words. Every single one of them. As long as he can stay here, Edna remarks and everything falls in line for him. With Thorin demanding exile, Donri will leave. He can go and become a mapmaker.

                “Are you a seer?” Bilbo yells. “Did you send Donri to attack me, knowing that Thorin would claim me and your son would be outlawed?” Bilbo withdraws his sword and paces around.

                He has been led here as a trap. He has been used so Edna could reap the benefits of the endgame. She would see her son as a mapmaker. He got attacked and all Donri gets is a chance to live out his dream. This cannot be happening.

                “There are many names for those who look towards the future, who claim fate as their master. Seer is among them. I did speak with Donri about what path an encounter with you could lead him on and he heeded my prophecy. I am sorry, Mister Baggins, that in order to spare my son from a lifetime of an unlived dream, I had to cause you pain but I knew that this path would lead you onto the path of one other, Thorin Oakenshield,” Edna stood up and leaned her weight against the table.

                “How would you know that Thorin would show mercy to your son? If it were not for me, he would be lying in a pool of his own blood. If your plan had not gone even a small amount according to your vision, you would have no son at all,” Bilbo backs against a wall. He wonders how long it will take of him running to reach Kili and Fili along with the rest of the hunting party.

                “I know of your heart, Bilbo. My son did not violate your privacy to an extreme and you would not have had him killed at your hands nor the hands of your beloved. You have helped my son, Bilbo and I cannot thank you enough. I do not mean you harm but, because you have suffered, I will offer you a gift,” Edna offers and points to the chair where Bilbo was previous sitting. “You still owe me a finished dinner conversation, please young hobbit,” She requests and Bilbo looks into the eyes of the female dwarf.

                There is no malice and no ill-intent. There is only seriousness, remorse and a glint of something Bilbo cannot identify.

                “I was violated. What can you offer to atone for that?” Bilbo feels like he is a piece in a puzzle, used my some guiding hand and being shoved into a spot in which he does not belong.

                “Advice and a bit of warning,” Edna sits and Bilbo eyes her before slouching down into a chair as well.

                “I am interested,” Bilbo raises an eyebrow, interested in what information a seer could offer a hobbit that is out on a dangerous quest.

                “You and your companions set forth on a quest but a dragon is not your biggest concern. Some of your enemies are intangible qualities, things that cannot be stabbed or defeated with magic or the blade of a sword, the arrow of a bow. Greed and pride are normally at the forefront of such things. Keep your loved ones close to your Bilbo Baggins and make sure your priorities are straight as can be,” Edna warns and Bilbo nods and stands up, readying himself to leave. Edna stands to intercept him. “Wait, hobbit.. I am not done. You will face a battle that will determine the strength of the bond between Thorin and yourself. If you choose a right path, the bond may become harder than any gem, any forged blade. If you choose the wrong path, the bond may be broken by dirt,” Edna warns and Bilbo looks at her curiously.

                “Hard as a gem but frail as dirt? That is quite a difference,” Bilbo speaks up.

                “If only you knew the difference,” Edna speaks and Bilbo just stands there.

                “Have you anything else to say?” Bilbo asks the seer dwarf.

                “Love, even for a moment, is a powerful thing,” Edna remarks. “But not all stories need end the same. In some stories, heroes fall. In others, they flourish. Sometimes things just need a little nudge to fall into place. Find the right path, Bilbo Baggins. Your future happiness may depend upon it,” Edna walks over and places a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder.

                “Am I meant to be alone then? Am I meant to be perpetually sad?” Bilbo questions, tears threatening to fall from his face. He may not be the most intelligent hobbit alive but he can read into some of the queues.

                “No, no you are not. While they are some futures engrained into stone, many are pliable. Some live into legends while others live in the hearts of the people who can tell their stories the best. Bilbo Baggins, you are a strong man. You will do what is best,” Edna reassures him. “You will not need to bear anything alone anymore. The gold chain around your neck reassures you of that. Trust Thorin. You may doubt his love but his heart does not. His mind does not either. He loves you, Bilbo. You must ask yourself if you can reciprocate the feelings. If you do not, it is dwarf courtesy to return the chain,” Edna looks away. “Thank you for keeping me company, Bilbo Baggins and thank you for allowing my son to live out his dream.”

                “Will I lose Thorin?” Bilbo yells as he turns to leave. “Will I lose him? I am not the most intelligent but I am quite good at riddles. That is what you are hinting at, no?” Bilbo feels a few tears on his cheek now.

                “You have Thorin now. It is the moments between breaths that matter. Hold him close,” Edna whispers.

                “No,” Bilbo stands back. “No. We will reclaim Erebor. He will become King, he cannot die. He…” Bilbo falls to the ground, tears finally claiming his eyes and cheeks.

                He is close to Thorin. He feels connected to him. He is being courted by him and now he has been told that he is destined to lose him. It as if he were finding out that he has a terrible and incurable disease that will soon claim his life except it is not his life, it is Thorin’s. He wants to throw things. He wants to lock Thorin away, have him abandon his quest and keep him close to him so that he may never die. Everyone dies, Bilbo thinks. Can he not just be happy? Can he not just love- No. He will not finish that yet.

                “Have you not heeded my words at all? There are multiple paths. Some may already be published in books, in tomes, for future generations but that does not mean that path is the one you need to choose. It lies within our souls and our hearts to direct us upon our intended paths,” Edna lays a hand over Bilbo’s chest, above his heart.

                Bilbo will not stop crying.

                “I need to know that I will save him or I will abandon this quest,” Bilbo drops his sword to the ground.

                “If you choose a path, there are always outcomes. Sometimes the ones we lose are meant to be lost,” Edna reasons and Bilbo shakes his head. “Small little actions are like rolling a small ball down a mountain. By the time it reaches the end, it is a large mountain of frost.”

                “I need to see Thorin,” Bilbo stands to leave.

                “Be warned, hobbit. I gifted this knowledge to you on the sole purpose of hoping you will change some things. If you reveal it to another soul, some paths may be lost to you,” Edna shakes a finger at him.

                “I need to keep this information to myself? That is another burden I am forced to bear alone,” Bilbo mutters to himself.

                “You are not alone. Now go, Bilbo Baggins. If you stay another minute longer, Thorin and his men will storm this house to reclaim you. Walk back to the stronghold on your own free will,” Edna looks out the window like she can see something that Bilbo cannot. Bilbo takes his stuff, his pack and his sword and makes to leave.

                “Thank you,” Bilbo wipes his eyes. “I do not know much about fate but I know that I cannot let Thorin go. I will not let him go. I will save him, Edna,” Bilbo promises.

                “I hope so, master hobbit. I really hope so,” Edna pats him on the shoulder and shoves him out the door. “Now get going, Thorin is worried and he has a gift for you.”

                “Thank you,” Bilbo repeats and runs off, the whole conversation replaying itself in his mind.

                Bilbo runs along the path and hears no rustling in the woods. He keeps his sword by his side, ready to draw it at a moment’s notice. When he nears the stronghold, he can hear yelling in dwarfish voices. He hides behind a tree to see what the commotion is.

                When he looks into the clearing, at the base of the stronghold, he can see Thorin yelling to armed dwarfs. He looks worried and pressured. When he looks to the side, he can see Kili and Fili with guilty looks upon their faces. He places what is going on. Thorin is sending out a search party for him.

                Bilbo sighs before running out into the clearing. The dwarf guards turn towards him, weapons out and ready to attack him before an order is heard to stand down.

                “Bilbo!” Thorin yells as he runs over. Thorin does not stop as he runs close to him. Instead, he pulls him into a heavy hug and does not let him go. “Where were you? Kili and Fili said you wandered off and I thought…. I thought that,” Thorin stops and Bilbo can feel as his chest heaves in and out rapidly. “Nevermind that. You are here right now and that is all that matters. Although… the fact that you were in the forest in the first place displeases me. I should have guessed my nephews would be up to some trouble. They will have a piece of my displeasure soon,” Thorin kisses the top of his head.

                Bilbo concocts a lie before he stops himself. He promised no more lies.

                “I saw a dwarf in the forest collecting herbs and I went off to help her. I lost track of time,” Bilbo admits and Thorin looks down at him with a small smile. “I am sorry for worrying you, Thorin.”

                “A female dwarf- eh?” Thorin chuckles. “I do not have any competition for you, do I?”

                “Not at all,” Bilbo laughs, resting his head against Thorin’s chest. When they release the hug, Thorin pats his back.

                “Good, because I would have to find someone else to give this gift to. Although, it would not hold much importance in someone else’s hands,” Thorin grins.

                Thorin is worried and he has a gift for you is what Edna said. There must be some truth to her words, Bilbo tries to mask his sadness.

                Thorin pulls out a small bundle from his coat and Bilbo stares as he sees something wrapped up in cloth and twine.

                “Is this my handkerchief?” Bilbo laughs, recognizing the cloth.

                “I was holding on to it for you,” Thorin grins.

                Bilbo unties the thread from the kerchief and reveals a dagger, sharp and shiny. On it is some words written in a different language. The blade is light and Bilbo can see his reflection in the metal. It looks new, as if it has not yet seen battle. Bilbo lifts his head as a thought crosses his mind. Thorin was in the forges all day. He was working on weapons.

                “Did you make this?” Bilbo marvels at the quality of the blade. It looks expertly crafted.

                “I did,” Thorin smiles proudly as he looks down at the dagger. “You need a back-up to that sword of yours and a dagger suits a burglar well.”

                Bilbo feels the blade with his fingers; runs his fingers over the handle, blue with gems and wrapped in leather strips. It fits comfortably in his hands.

                “What does the blade say?” Bilbo inquires curiously.

                “It says,” Thorin touches the blade and the carved in lettering. “Bilbo Baggins, Hobbit of Erebor.”

                Bilbo looks at the blade and back at Thorin who is looking at him and the dagger fondly.

                Bilbo holds the dagger in the cloth close to him, close to his heart. He looks towards Thorin with tears leaking from his eyes. 

                “What is the matter, Bilbo? Why do you shed tears?” Thorin’s smile drops and he pushes a thumb against the tears cascading down his face.

                Bilbo shakes his head to rid himself from the tears. He does not respond and simply hugs Thorin.

                “Thank you for the gift, Thorin. I love it. It is amazing,” Bilbo nods against Thorin’s chest. Bilbo looks around and sees the rest of the dwarfs suddenly occupied and averting their eyes. “Thorin- I,” Bilbo looks at the dagger and back to the dwarf-king who is staring at him with concerned orbs for eyes.

                “What is it? You can tell me,” Thorin presses, keeping his arm wrapped around Bilbo’s waist.

                Bilbo musters up all the strength he has remaining in his chest. He sighs and knows that it was only a matter of time before he said this.

                “I love you,” Bilbo admits to a now surprised Thorin Oakenshield.

                If Edna and Donri were working towards pushing them together, Bilbo would try his hardest to make sure they do not drift apart. Death is something he just cannot accept right now. He holds his breath and counts the seconds, cherishing them as he waits for the dwarf-king’s response. He is alive now and he has Thorin in this exact moment. If anything else matters, it does not cross his mind. 

Notes:

Another cliff hanger! But it's not bad. We know Thorin's feelings. I simply needed somewhere to cut off after nearly 9,000 straight words of a chapter. Keep reviewing and reading and I will keep writing :) This story is close to me so I will not end it without resolving everything that needs to be resolved. We have unanswered situations still- Why did Gandalf so quickly tell Thorin to move on and pronounce Bilbo dead... When will Bilbo share about the ring? Finally- Can Bilbo save Thorin or is he destined to die? ((Seriously, Merlin and Torchwood have me hoping for a happy ending to a romantic encounter for once.)) Until next time, thank you for reading! :) I can use a fluff chapter next time. Is anyone else feeling up for some fluff? Anyways, I have literally not slept in two nights because I have been slaving over this chapter and trying to include everything.