Chapter Text
One finds Two
Throughout Frodo’s life, every second (sometimes third, sometimes every, but mainly second) year was Shire Year. Shire Year meant that Bilbo would kiss Thorin firmly on the mouth and tell him to not start any wars without Bilbo, kiss Fili and Kili on the tops of their heads and tell them not to start any wars without Bilbo, hug Dwalin and Balin and Nori (royal guard, head advisor, and king’s spymaster respectively) and tell them not to let the other Bagginses start any wars without Bilbo, just in case they still didn’t get it. So in general: No Wars Without Bilbo. That was his rule, his one and only rule. Please keep to it.
But only rule or not (Dwalin would definitely say ‘not’), that was not the point of Shire Year. The point of Shire Year was to gather up Frodo’s things, pack his own bag, and head Home.
Of course, after all these years Erebor was far more Home for Bilbo than the Shire, and he did not bother to deny it when a slightly hurt Thorin asked about this tradition. But there was something about going back to the place you were born and raised that was very important and necessary in one’s life, and shouldn’t Thorin know all about that anyway? (At that, Thorin wisely shut up.) Besides, it was good for Frodo. This way he would not forget the other half of his heritage.
Frodo was honestly not of the same opinion as Bilbo.
Frodo would forget the other half of his heritage without a fuss if it meant no more Shire Year.
Frodo hated Shire Year.
The only thing that made Shire Year at least slightly bearable were Shire-made seed cakes.
And even then it was a close thing.
This vehement hatred arose because Frodo, from an early age, had realized that he was Not A Cool Hobbit. Oh, he was cool for a Dwobbit, that was true: when the Shire-folk came to visit, there would always be plenty of Hobbitlings eager to hang out with Prince Frodo of Erebor and his Dwarven friends. The Hobbitlings delighted in the exotic games and entertainments that Frodo and the others amused themselves with, and they all enjoyed exploring the grand halls together. But when Frodo was in the Shire? They dropped him faster than a hot potato.
You see, Hobbits are communal creatures, and thus the majority of Hobbitling games are of a communal nature too and most of them involve teams of some sort. Now to be picked for a team you have to be good. Which Frodo wasn’t. At all.
It wasn’t that Frodo was bad at sports-- in fact, it was pretty clear to all that he was more dexterous and had more stamina than the rest of the Hobbits his age, seeing as how back home he was constantly trying to keep up with kids who were a whole lot taller and sturdier built than him (and there was the whole warrior training too). No, the physical part wasn’t the problem. See, there’s one other little thing you have to be able to do in order to play a team game: Remember The Rules.
And little Frodo just could not keep up with the intricacies of Hobbitling games.
The others would explain it to him, but they would honestly not explain it well. See here Frodo, they would tell him, you’re supposed to go with the ball over there, but once you get past those trees you’re supposed to pass it back, only to a person wearing green though! and then you have to run back over past that house, got it? ok I’m gonna pass the ball to you next time, go Frodo, go!! --no stop stop what are you doing idiot don’t you understand you’re not allowed to run on this part?! The others just scored because of you!! Ugh. Whatever. Merry, catch.
Frodo tried, he honestly tried. But he just couldn’t manage it, and it made him feel stupid and awful. And to make things even worse: the Hobbitlings changed the rules whenever they felt something else would make the game funner, but he didn’t understand the original rules in the first place so it was impossible to keep up with the changes.
But worst of all was when he actually did manage to get the rules-- generally somewhere in the last two weeks before he and Bilbo went back home. Then Frodo, with his awesome Dwarf-trained battle skills, would suddenly become popular again-- for those last two weeks. The day before he left, the kids would all promise each other that they’d practice super hard, so that next time Frodo visited, they could show each other all the awesome skills they had learned in the meantime.
And Frodo really would practice. He would teach the game (in its latest variation) to all his friends back home and they would all play and help him get better at it. (Not even intentionally really, but it was a simple fact of life that getting past a Dwarf goalie is harder than getting past a Hobbit one.) And sometimes, Thorin even sat watching them play with a thoughtful look on his face, and after the game was over he would explain to Frodo which strategies would work best and why. (Those were Frodo’s favorite times.)
Then, eager to show off his skills, he actually would look forward to Shire Year, and race back to the game field as soon as he and Bilbo had arrived in Hobbiton again.
--only to find out that the game they were playing was completely different from what he had been practicing.
“That..?” said Merry, scratching his head. “Have we ever played something like that before?”
“He’s probably just making it up so that he can be good at something,” hissed a voice from the back quietly-- but not quietly enough. There were a few titters, Frodo’s face fell.
Merry shrugged helplessly, and perhaps a tiny bit guiltily. “Maybe you could try this game? It’s pretty fun. Here, let me explain how it works...”
Like clockwork, this pattern had repeated for four Shire Years. Now he and Bilbo were on their fifth one, and Frodo was not falling for it again. It was a beautiful sunny day, which meant a huge party-for-nothing-in-particular was taking place in front of the aptly named Party Tree. Already Frodo could see the other children lining up and playing rock-paper-knife to see who would get to be team captain. But Frodo was not falling for that, nope.
Frodo was not gonna line up with the other kids, Frodo was gonna climb under one of the low tables and Sulk.
--only to find that there was somebody already there.
“Sam?!”
“Frodo?!”
The two children stared at each other.
“What are you doing here?!”
“I... well what about you?!”
“...I didn’t wanna join in their stupid game.”
“...Me too.”
Frodo and Sam stared at each other, a kind of bitter understanding reflected in their eyes. Honestly, Frodo didn’t know exactly why Sam didn’t want to join in the game. He knew very little about the other boy in general: when Sam came to Erebor he tended to mainly hang out with Oin. Now Frodo loved Oin, just as much he loved everyone in Thorin’s old Company, but he wouldn’t exactly travel over 400 miles to hang out with him, and anybody who did was just a tiny bit weird in Frodo’s books.
But maybe a tiny bit weird wasn’t bad. Maybe being a tiny bit weird was a whole lot better than being a tiny bit cruel.
“You know,” said Sam slowly. “If we crawl for ten feet in that direction, we can reach up and grab a whole plate of seed cakes without anyone noticing.”
Frodo smiled back.
Yeah, the only thing that made Shire Years bearable were seed cakes.
And Sam.
Two knows Three
Honestly, Sam couldn’t say he really knew Aragorn before the journey started.
He’d met him many times, at least once a year in fact: Frodo and Bilbo celebrated their birthday together, and they always invited pretty much everyone they had ever seen in their lives. (Sam was pretty sure Orcs would be invited if there was any chance they’d drop by.) The party that ensued across all Erebor and the surrounding area probably accounted for about a fifth of Dwarvish revenue per year; by now the 22nd of September was practically a national holiday and there was no way anybody who was invited would ever dare miss it. (Bilbo would Know, and be Disappointed.)
So yes, it was safe to say that Sam had met Aragorn before, many times.
But they had never really talked. Sam knew that Aragorn was friends with Frodo’s older brothers and Gimli, and he was on good terms with Sam’s own da. At the party (that is, before, during, and after the banquet), Sam and Aragorn would share friendly smiles, jokes, and express polite but genuine interest in each other’s lives.
But they had still never really talked. After all, what would they have to say to each other? Sam was growing up like his da, and would take over his da’s job later, too. Aragorn was-- Aragorn was a great warrior, fighting for the weak in dark places. What did a gardener and a hero have to say to each other?
So it was more than a little strange to Sam that, at the beginning of their quest at least and besides Frodo, Aragorn turned out to be the one he chatted to the most.
Perhaps it was only by ‘means of elimination’ (as Mister Bilbo would put it) that this came about. Merry and Pippin tried to hide it, and didn’t even do it on purpose honestly, but they couldn’t completely cover the fact that they thought of him as ‘that gardener boy’. It wasn’t anything bad because he knew that this was how they’d all been raised: them to think he was ‘that gardener boy’, him to know that they thought that and accept it without a fuss. But it still made them all just the tiniest bit awkward around each other. As for the others? Legolas was still too unreal, for all that they had also met many times; Gimli was fun to chat with but had a very different sense of humor from Sam’s; Gandalf was honestly a bit scary. And he didn’t know the other Man, Boromir, at all.
He hadn’t really been planning to get to know Aragorn either, except that the first two weeks the two of them keep getting stuck together on the same watch.
Sam wasn’t used to doing something like this: waking up in the middle of the night and keeping watch for several hours, then dropping off again. He was a gardener; he had been planning to show Merry and Pippin the shortest way to Rivendell and then head back, not go along on a huge adventure too. It was just that his best friend in the world was going and Frodo tended to wander off and get lost by himself so Sam couldn’t exactly let him go alone... Well, regardless, now it was done, and he had best learn how to keep watch.
Aragorn told him it was easier if, the first few times at least, you quietly talked to each other.
But what could a hero have to say to a gardener? Or, more importantly, the other way around: Sam decided that if it was him that needed the conversation, it was him who had best come up with the topic. So Sam adjusted his blanket (it was a cold night) and leaned in a little closer to where Aragorn was methodically wiping his sword with an old rag. Then he cleared his throat awkwardly and said the first thing that popped into his head.
“So... do you like plants?”
It took Sam a second to realize what he had just said. He could have slapped himself; there was no way he could have sounded any dumber. Of course Aragorn didn’t like plants, Aragorn liked killing evil things, rescuing the poor, and bringing light to dark places. Plants weren’t even in the same universe as what Aragorn liked. The only reason he had asked was because plants had never failed him before.
They didn’t fail him now.
“Lord Elrond taught me the healing arts from when I was young,” said Aragorn quietly, not looking up from his sword, as though this was the most natural question in the world. “But I must confess I know too little about non-medicinal plants to really consider myself a connoisseur.”
Huh.
Huh?!
Sam blinked at Aragorn and scratched the back of the head. “Well, it’s not that difficult to go from medicinal plants to other ones...” he mumbled self-consciously, not sure how to reply even though it had been his own chosen topic.
At his words, Aragorn finally looked up from his sword and smiled at the gardener. “Will you teach me?”
Honestly, Sam couldn’t say that night was when he first got to know Aragorn. That came on a different night a lot later, when he had whispered to a person he in his head tentatively called 'friend': Does it get easier when you find out that the girl you like is waiting for you to come home? Or does it get harder? Because if it gets harder, I don’t think I can handle it. But the night with the plants was a good start nonetheless.
Three copies Four
Aragorn had always known he was too serious. When he was a child, this made life quite difficult for him, for most other children just didn’t understand. But how else could a child raised by Elven lords grow up?
Then he met Bilbo, and Hamfast and Oin, and Fili and Kili, and then, a bit later, he met Legolas and Gimli. And his way of life changed, for how else could a child going on playdates with Hobbits and Dwarves grow up?
But a thread of his solemnity still remained in him, forever and always.
And entwined with that solemnity there was in him a thread of envy for those who laughed easily and freely. For many years, he tried to deny it, but in the end arrogance faded and the desire to live truthfully won out: he, Aragorn son of Arathorn, was secretly jealous of those who could make others laugh.
(It wasn’t that he didn’t try.
“What sort of room has no windows or doors?” he asked Arwen, in one of those rare moments they had alone.
She just looked at him with a quirk of her lips that he could not interpret. It was a good sign that she didn’t look angry that he was wasting their precious time together on jokes; it was a bad sign that she didn’t even attempt to guess, instead merely shrugging her shoulders in askance. Nonetheless, Aragorn still waited out a short pause, trying to get the timing that he vaguely knew was so important right.
“A mushroom!” said the Heir of Isildur with a broad grin.
At that, Arwen did something he could interpret: she laughed so hard tears of mirth rolled down her cheeks. But when a pleased Aragorn asked her whether the joke he had heard on his travels was really that hilarious, Arwen just shook her head.
“I’m sorry-- but your proud face-- at that silliness-- sorry-- ahh--” she pressed a kiss to his lips before dissolving into further giggles, but it was not enough to completely wipe away the sting.)
And thus, when he knew all of the others were otherwise occupied, Aragorn watched Pippin. He tried to copy the Hobbit’s light posture, mouthed the Hobbit’s easy jokes to himself, trying to get right that ever-important and ever-elusive timing.
It didn’t work.
It didn’t work, and the thread of envy within him just pulled tauter and tauter, until he was scared it would break and lash out at everyone around him. Something had to be done before such an awful thing happened. So, folding away all his pride, he waited for a quiet moment to talk to Pippin. One arrived soon; a quiet morning. They had all agreed to take a one day break from walking to replenish supplies, and Pippin had decided to contribute by fishing in the river. (So at least there was no one else there to witness his humiliation.)
Aragorn padded softly up behind the fishing Hobbit, and said quietly: “Pippin, may I have a word?”
The Hobbit spun around in surprise, accidentally dropping the fish he had just caught back in the river. Aragorn watched its fall in dismay; he hadn’t intended to start this conversation off on such a sour note. But to his great surprise, the Hobbit just flung back his head and laughed. And at Aragorn’s puzzled face, Pippin just laughed harder.
“Sorry, sorry,” said he. “It’s just that... you just scared the carp out of me.”
Saying that, he dissolved into giggles again while Aragorn blinked. That was... perhaps the worst joke he’d ever heard. Even worse than his own. And yet here Pippin was, laughing so hard at his own cleverness he was practically getting cramps.
Finally, the Hobbit pulled himself together. “Sorry, what was it you wanted?”
And Aragorn had a sudden moment of enlightenment, something that made the tightly wound thread of envy in his chest snap and fade painlessly. Maybe all hope was not lost. Maybe it was just that it would take him a while to work his way up to impressing Arwen with jokes. After all, he hadn’t started swordfighting being able to beat Elladan and Elrohir. He had had to work his way up. And part of the reason he and his beloved understood each other so well was because of their similarly solemn natures. So he would have just have to work his way up to her difficulty level too.
For now, perhaps it was alright to start with the easier audience, someone who laughed more easily and lightly.
“Nevermind...” Aragorn said. Then he worked up his courage. “Actually, no. Hey, Pippin, stop me if you’ve heard this one before. What sort of room has no doors or windows?”
Four admires Five
Privately, Pippin had always kind of thought that Gimli was, like, the coolest guy ever. He never really admitted it because you know, you can’t really say that to a friend, and anyway, even amongst the other Hobbits, he knew that you were supposed to admire Legolas or Aragorn or Thorin, not Gimli.
But he did.
‘Cause Gimli was just plain amazing.
Maybe it was because Gimli had already saved his life twice. No, thrice. No, a lot more than that... Er... Hmm... Well, a bunch of times anyway. In any case, the first time was the most important and the one Pippin remembered best, because it was the first:
Pippin had just turned fifteen, and his parents had decided that he was finally old enough to visit Erebor. That was definitely true: Pippin felt himself ready for all sorts of possible adventures! And thus, next time half the Shire got ready to go to Erebor for Bilbo’s birthday, Pippin and his parents went along.
Erebor was amazing, and huge.
No, seriously, wow.
Pippin fell in love with it immediately.
And Pippin had not been lying when he had said he was ready for all possible adventures, but perhaps he had said it too quietly or perhaps his parents had just not believed him. Whatever the case, they for some reason decided it was alright to leave their boy in the Hobbit quarters for an hour, while they visited old friends. (Something about Da seeing somebody with a starfish? which sounded like a pretty cool adventure, but he wasn’t allowed to come with; Mama was off to get her hair braided by somebody, which did not sound like a cool adventure at all, why would you even travel this far for that, eww.)
Well, Hobbit quarters were pretty small and Erebor itself was pretty gigantic, so there was no way Pippin was staying put. Sneaking past the other Hobbit mothers wasn’t difficult for a Hobbitling who was used to crawling into Farmer Maggot’s mushrooms. And then he was off!
And off. And off.
Wandering around Erebor took a while, seeing as how Pippin had tiny Hobbitling legs. It didn’t help that he was trying to stay in the shadows as much as possible, too. (He still remembered the stories that Mama had told him, about his parents’ older friends sneaking away to find treasure and being caught by Mad Mister Bilbo. Pippin was determined that he wouldn’t be caught; after all, he had to restore the Took family honor-- how could Mama and Da have not joined in the Quest?!)
After what must surely have been a couple hours, though, Pippin honestly got a bit bored. In his excitement, he had forgotten to ask Merry to come along, and exploring a strange new place was not quite as much fun when you didn’t have anyone to talk to meanwhile.
He was beginning to regret the note he had left his parents so that they wouldn’t worry about his absence (‘OFFF ADVENTARIN. BAK LATER.’); perhaps if he hadn’t been such a polite child, they’d have decided he was kidnapped by now and come to search for him. Even worse, he couldn’t exactly turn back anymore, because he was out of the city proper and kind of lost. (To be a bit more precise, he was in this weird tunnel where had been following a sign that pointed to a place called ‘Mine 3’ because that sounded really cool, but he wasn’t sure if he’d taken a wrong turn or not.)
And worst of all, as he was wandering around thinking glumly of his no-doubt-very-cold supper, Pippin suddenly slipped and slid head-first off the path he was following. The Hobbitling cried out, but it was in surprise and not pain. Somehow, Pippin the Brave Adventurer had managed to neatly fall into some sort of hole.
Not even a comfortable Hobbit hole, no, this was just what it sounded like: a tiny downward sloping cave in the mountain face. And there he was stuck, the upper half of his body inside the tunnel and his feet sticking out for the world to see.
Curiously enough though, Pippin did not feel scared. What he mainly felt was a kind of dull resignation: the adventure so far had not proven anywhere near as exciting as he had hoped, and this was just the dessert of boredom piled onto the earlier main course. Hey, at least maybe if he stayed away long enough, Marvellous Mister Bilbo would use his special Hobbitling-In-Trouble powers and come get him. That would be pretty cool. And with those cheery thoughts, Pippin lay his head in his arms and dozed off.
He awoke to the sound of someone whistling cheerfully. The sound of heavy boots passed by him, then stopped, and came closer. Pippin wiggled his toes; there was a quickly stifled burst of laughter in reply.
“Need some help?” said a voice, with a grin that could be heard even unseen.
“No thank you,” said Pippin, because adventurers have their pride, and he was pretty sure this was not the Mysterious Mister Bilbo. “I’m just resting for a little while. Then I’m going to continue adventuring.”
“Ah, of course,” said the voice. “But why don’t you rest somewhere a little more comfortable at least.”
Saying that, a few rocks were shifted, and Pippin was picked up out of the hole by his right ankle. Upside down as he was, Pippin had to look down, down, down to see his rescuer. He was greeted with a warm smile and a great big bushy beard. Pippin grinned, good humor restored. His rescuer looked amazing! It was alright that it wasn’t the Magnificent Mister Bilbo who had rescued him after all; a Dwarf with a beard like that was exactly the reason he’d gone to check out Mine 3 in the first place.
The Dwarf chuckled back. “Well, Master Hobbit, let’s get you right-side up and figured out. And then we can resume your adventuring together.” Saying that, he placed Pippin on his shoulders and continued whistling.
After that it became a habit.
Over the years Gimli rescued Pippin from two avalanches, seven collapsing mines, and a few dozen falling trees. And more. Pippin was just not always clear about those other times, because sometimes it took Gimli a little while to unbury him and deficiency of air tends to mess with your head. But in the end, unbury him Gimli always did!
So maybe, a bunch of years later and on a Very Important Quest, Pippin was still a little brash and thoughtless about charging into battle, or running headlong down a mountain. Aragorn, at least, always paled at Pippin’s lack of planning ahead. But hey, if you had an amazing Guardian Dwarf like that, what would you be worried about?
(And a lot later, after the great battle, when Merry told him in a hushed voice that if Gimli hadn’t recognized his feet sticking out from under a troll, he would have been dead, Pippin just laughed. He explained to his cousin: There are no ifs in their friendship; when Pippin is buried under something, Gimli finds him and digs him out.
That was because Gimli was, like, the coolest guy ever.)
Five informs Six
Gimli had no particular love for boats. He liked soil under his feet (and even better, soil over his head as well). He also knew Merry was the complete opposite of him: even as a child, Merry had always delighted in constructing little boats from paper and metal.
So when the Lady of the Woods gave them all wonderfully elegant boats (Gimli didn’t like boats; that didn’t mean he didn’t appreciate well-constructed ones) and he somehow ended up with Merry, Gimli wasn’t sure whether to be delighted or horrified.
On the one hand, there was nobody in their group he trusted more on water, not even his dear constant brothers-in-arms Legolas or Aragorn. On the other hand... what if Merry decided to experiment and test out exactly how maneuverable and well-made the boat was? Gimli wasn’t sure he could handle anything dramatic.
And unfortunately, his other hand’s assumption seemed pretty correct: Merry immediately set to work looping and twisting their little boat between all the others’.
Gimli decided it was time to act. He cleared his throat. “Merry... Merry, just so you know, I can’t swim.”
“What?!”
“So if I fall into the water... just leave me. Save yourself.”
Being a generally truthful person, this was perhaps the biggest lie Gimli had ever told. Although he had no great fondness for water, after the little Thorin-and-Frodo-water-incident, Bilbo had insisted that everybody he knew learned at least the basics of keeping afloat. Gimli could kick off his heavy boots and drop his heavy armor within thirty seconds of being in the water, and he could do it without panicking underwater as well.
Still, when Merry abruptly slowed down and became almost overly cautious with his steering (though as far as Gimli was concerned, there was no over-cautious in boats), Gimli decided little white lies weren’t always too bad a thing. Besides, it had been little Merry who had taught him to keep a straight face when lying in the first place.
The next time they took a break, though, he let Legolas switch places with him: Merry’s concern had been touching and he wanted the Hobbit to enjoy his time on the river with someone else who appreciated it. Even if it had been a bit insulting that the Hobbit had obviously forgotten how Gimli had won a swimming race across Lake Nor against him, just five Autumns past.
Six teases Seven
The first time Merry met Legolas, he had been completely awe-struck.
For one thing, he was only 13 and had only seen Big Folk twice before, and he was too small to really remember the experience. He could barely accept that there were people taller than Miss Noakes, who watched him sometimes when his mother was out. Ori, the first Dwarf Merry had met (part of Bilbo’s very successful campaign to Introduce Dwarves Non-Threateningly In Case Not All Were As Brave And Insane As Primula Had Been, Merry later learned), had seemed huge.
And now there was a gigantic creature standing next to his new friend, Frodo, smiling down at him from somewhere in the distant Up. In short, Merry had been convinced that Legolas was taller than the Party Tree, and in fact it was only a much later visit to the Shire that had completely dissipated that foolish, but heartfelt belief.
The other thing that had struck Merry was something that he had not known a word for until quite a lot later. The word little Merry had been looking for was ethereal. It was a word that he would later use to describe all Elves, but it was a word that he forever associated most strongly with Legolas. Perhaps it was merely because he had been the first Elf little Merry had met. But Merry always secretly thought it was because, compared to the other Elves, Legolas was usually so not ethereal, usually so there. The only Elf Merry had ever seen as there as Legolas was Arwen, who didn’t really count because of the nature of her relationship with Aragorn. Every other Elf-- they participated in conversations, and even smiled and laughed as though they were there, but Merry knew they never quite were. There was always something else hidden behind immortals’ eyes.
But Legolas was different. Sometimes, Merry saw that something in his eyes too, but it was rare. When Legolas laughed, he meant it; when Legolas was sad, it wasn’t the ever-present sorrow of a fading People, but his own personal problems.
So when Legolas went all ethereal for a bit too long, Merry slid over to him and told him the stupidest jokes he could think of. Ones that only Aragorn would think to laugh at. Aragorn-- and Legolas. Legolas always started out of whatever melancholy had gripped him, and looked at Merry with a twitching mouth and wickedly sparkling eyes. And the Hobbit knew then that the only thing that kept him from giggling dementedly was that bit of ethereal in all Elves that never quite went away completely. That, and having a shred of self-respect.
Legolas never thanked him directly for pulling him back into being there, but Merry kind of sensed that nowadays there was a bit of awe-struck lurking in Legolas’ eyes when he looked at Merry, too. And that-- that was pretty awesome in and of itself.
Seven counts Eight
Legolas knows that Aragorn counts by years.
Legolas also knows that Gimli counts by decades.
Legolas himself counts by centuries.
What does Mithrandir count by?
Legolas cannot guess. Perhaps Mithrandir does not count at all.
Legolas knows very little about their Istari companion, and he knows that all he knows is what Mithrandir chooses to reveal. He does not begrudge the Istar for it; Legolas grew up amongst ancient beings and he knows why they sometimes choose to hide.
So sometimes, when counting by days and hours and seconds grows too difficult to bear, he steps away from his mortal companions for a little while. Instead, he lays down his cloak next to Mithrandir, and falls into a half-sleep just as Mithrandir falls into his.
Sometimes though, sometimes Mithrandir does not pretend to sleep.
Instead, his wizened hands, wrapped still in a soft, soft grey wool, brush Legolas’ hair out of his face. And in his deep, melodious voice, he hums to Legolas songs that have not been heard on these shores for millennia.
On those nights, Legolas forgets to count to sixty or three hundred sixty five or one thousand. On those nights, he lets go. And in the mornings, he laughs freely with Gimli and Aragorn, while Mithrandir smiles in the background.
It is good.
Eight to One
Mithrandir is always glad to see how much of Bilbo there is in Frodo. Not only because it is Bilbo’s good, sweet natured character and hidden strength that the newest Ringbearer has inherited. There is also more than a little bit of the fact that Mithrandir privately calls Bilbo friend and he thinks that he’ll be able to call Frodo friend too. So he tries to give Frodo the same advice that had served Bilbo well in the past: Pity? It was pity that stayed Bilbo’s hands.
Tharkun watches Frodo with both sorrow and joy, because there is so much Dwarf in Frodo it hurts. Frodo is wonderful in his loyalty and his determination, traits Tharkun knows Dwalin and Thorin molded into him. But Tharkun is unsure how much of Thorin’s old madness has been passed along as well, whether Dwalin’s loyalty and determination will turn into foolhardiness and stubbornness in this young boy. I would use this ring from a desire to do good... But through me, it would wield a power too great and terrible to imagine, he tells Frodo, and hopes that Frodo understands the warning applies to him too.
Incanus is suspicious of every little move Frodo makes, but that is not Frodo’s fault because Incanus is always suspicious. He must be, so that he can know who genuinely needs his skills and who would use them for evil, who is genuinely ready to fight darkness and who is merely pretending. So where Tharkun warns of the danger within, Incanus warns of the danger outside. Always remember, Frodo, the Ring is trying to get back to its master. It wants to be found.
Greyhame is called Stormcrow for a reason: he is the bearer of ill tidings far too often, even for his long life. But he wishes the opposite were true, and thus he takes the time to comfort those who seek it. He would do so for any who are in need of it, but he does it especially for poor, confused, oh-so-young Frodo: Bilbo was meant to find the Ring. In which case, you were also meant to have it. And that is an encouraging thought.
Olorin just smiles.
Perhaps in the end, that smile is the best wisdom he can give Frodo after all.
(But perhaps even better than all of that, better than giving warnings and comfort and smiles, is hearing Frodo say Gandalf! I’m glad you’re back.)
Plus Another Makes Nine
With time, Boromir’s envy and loneliness began to fade. But he was still not quite One Of Them, and he recognized that very well. Still, what little companionship was given to him he accepted gladly and returned warmly. And he told himself that it was good like this, far better than what he had expected and certainly far better than what Faramir was receiving at home. And because this was true, he believed it and was content.
Not so the others.
They were walking along a narrow mountain path when the incident happened. It was the incident that changed everything.
See, the others were all busy being astounded by the beauty of their surroundings, but Boromir wasn't really paying attention. He had wandered along this road on his way to Rivendell and he saw no sense in being amazed at the same thing twice in as many months, so he was mainly not concentrating on where he was going. For once, he wasn’t really thinking of anything in particular; his hands fiddled with a small brooch.
Boromir was later never quite sure of what happened (had he suddenly sped up or slowed down?), but due to his inattentiveness, suddenly Frodo bumped into him. They both regained balance quickly, no harm done-- but the brooch he had been playing with slipped out of his fingers in the confusion. Down, down it fell, and Boromir helplessly watched it tumble into the canyon below.
A flash of hurt passed across his face, before he could shove it back inside him. Faramir had found that brooch amongst their mother’s old possessions a long time ago, and stolen it away before, on his father's orders, the things had all been burnt. (His father could not stand looking at anything that reminded him of their mother; Boromir had realized that once long ago when seeing his brother and father talk at dinner.) And before Boromir had set off for Rivendell, Faramir had pressed it upon him ‘for luck’. He had protested: Faramir had nothing left of their mother but the most hazy memories and this brooch was precious. But his little brother had insisted.
And now it was gone, because of a clumsy Hobbit and Boromir’s own foolishness.
He looked down the side of the cliff evaluatively-- but no, the brooch was almost thirty metres down. Boromir was not that bad a climber, but he had never dared a wall quite this steep. Besides, what he would say to the others: 'Everyone, please halt our important quest while I attempt to get a little pin'? No, he would just have to beg Faramir’s forgiveness for losing this precious thing (and subsequently get it because Faramir forgave him everything).
Still, he couldn’t prevent a sigh from leaving his lips as he reshouldered his pack and tore his eyes away from the brooch. His refocused on the road-- and his gaze met that of Frodo. The Hobbit was looking at him with a thoughtful expression on his face. Boromir opened his mouth to crack a joke, though his heart wasn’t in it.
And was interrupted.
“Hey, everyone, halt please!” said Frodo. “We have to take a short break!”
Boromir stared at Frodo as everyone else crowded around the pair.
“What’s wrong?” said Sam worriedly.
“Oh, nothing very much,” replied Frodo. He was already taking off his pack. “But I accidentally made Boromir drop something down there,” he nodded down the canyon wall and several of the Fellowship immediately went to have a look down. “So I’m going to go get it back.”
At that, Boromir finally found his voice again. “You are not.”
“Of course I am,” said Frodo. “It’s important to you-- I saw that. And we Dwobbits understand treasure very well.” He winked at Boromir, his tone light.
The light-heartedness just made Boromir irrationally angry. His tone was tightly controlled as he said: “The climb is dangerous, Frodo. The brooch I dropped-- it is not worth much.”
But his voice cracked on that last word. It was difficult to say that, no matter how true it was in the grand manner of things. Faramir had given it to him, and anything Faramir gave to him was precious. And that it had been their mother’s besides... But he had to make Frodo see reason; the Hobbit was already starting to limber up, ignoring Boromir’s words. The Gondorean persisted nevertheless.
“We are not going to stand here and attempt to get a little pin out of a canyon,” said Boromir hotly. “It is really not necessary and we shouldn’t waste time besides.”
“What are you talking about?” said Pippin, full of exasperated confusion. “It’s obviously important to you, and this shouldn’t take longer than an hour...”
“I’m telling you, there is no need for such action! And it is dangerous as well..!”
“But--”
“I said I’ll do it,” said Frodo, squaring his shoulders. “It was more than partially my fault, and this isn’t that difficult a climb. And like I said, that brooch obviously means something. That means we have to get it back.”
Boromir could have growled. Yes, it was important, and yes, it was precious, but it was also silly and sentimental. Warriors had no time to waste on trivial things; certainly none of his comrades back home would have made such a fuss over a little trinket. And yet here he was, surrounded by foolhardy people. But wait, so far only the youngest of their company had spoken! He whirled unto the others, hoping that at least more experienced warriors would see sense.
“Are none of the rest of you going to stop him?” he demanded.
But alas! there was no assistance to be found from their corner either.
Gimli shrugged. “I am confident that if Frodo gets close to serious danger, Bilbo will somehow miraculously appear and rescue him.”
Sam and Legolas nodded in agreement. “I’ve seen it happen before.”
“Besides,” put in Gandalf. “This will be good practice for Mordor.”
Boromir gaped at them, too shocked to be angry for a minute. Weren’t they all supposed to be Frodo’s protectors?! Why were they letting the Ringbearer --no, their friend-- risk his neck for foolishness? He truly did not understand their actions, and his indignation just fed into his simmering anger. These people were insane.
“Boromir, just let him do it,” said Aragorn, and that was the final straw. Boromir threw up his hands.
“As my King commands,” he said with a sneer. (Sometimes, Aragorn would bark out commands, just little things about how this was no place for a rest or how they had better look where they were stepping on this treacherous path. It was a command that was taken as an order by the Shire-folk, and a mere suggestion by the more experienced travelers. Boromir hated how his traitorous feet snapped to attention every time anyway.)
Aragorn flinched a bit at his words, but before he could reply, Merry rolled his eyes and stepped in.
“Great, that’s settled then.”
Frodo set out to making himself ready, and Boromir stomped off to be angry by himself.
--*--*--
But by the time Frodo was ready, a thin, easily snappable rope tied around his waist and seemingly useless bandages wrapped around his palms and the soles of his feet, Boromir had forgotten to be angry. He stared down at the smile on the Hobbit’s face and he still couldn’t understand it all.
“I am asking you one more time to leave it there,” Boromir said quietly. Perhaps there was a note of pleading in his voice, but he did not think the others in this Fellowship would recognize that tone from him; a small mercy. “It is not worth it.”
Frodo’s smile just widened and became more determined. He said confidently: “It is.”
And then he let Aragorn and Gimli loop the end of the rope around their arms and practically dove off the cliff.
Boromir did not watch his climb. Instead, he sat down, facing away from the cliff wall, and looked down at his hands. They were twitching. Unbidden, an old memory rose up within him. He had watched the doctors pull arrows out of Faramir’s chest without blinking, once a long time ago, sitting at his brother’s side and gripping his arm the whole time. His hands had twitched then too; at the time, he had not thought he would ever be forced to bear anything worse. But he had been wrong. This was worse. Faramir’s wounds, terrifying as they had been, had at least served a purpose. This gravity-defying leap into death’s embrace? The only purpose it served was to protect his feelings, and that was a very unnecessary purpose indeed.
But not, perhaps, to the people he travelled with-- his companions.
The thought hit Boromir like a spear from an Orc; his breath hitched. Boromir had grown up with tough, hardened folk in a tough city hardened by war. But perhaps... perhaps it was possible to laugh without bitterness, and to cherish the feelings attached to a brooch, even when one was more used to difficult times..? For Boromir had no illusions that Frodo was a soft creature unused to the world: there were rough calluses upon his hands and he had a reckless glint in his eye Boromir associated most oft with young but experienced fighters--
He could not finish that trail of thought, for a hand was thrust before his face. The warrior flinched back, then his eyes focused on what was in the hand: his mother’s old brooch.
Boromir’s gaze drifted up along that arm, covered in shallow, bleeding scratches, to Frodo’s face. The Hobbit was grinning down at him triumphantly, his eyes wild and glad. Around the pair, the rest of the Fellowship was smiling, winking, and pulling silly grimaces at Boromir. Slowly reaching out to grasp the brooch, Boromir’s face split into a careful, carefree smile as well.
He let Frodo pull him to him to his feet.
