Chapter Text
“No. No, Gandalf,” said Bilbo.
He had stopped short in his steps, as though rooted to the ground. Next to him, Thorin had stumbled at the proclamation too, but seemed not entirely surprised. The old Wizard just smiled sadly. And Bilbo suddenly hated him, him and his meddling ways (even worse now as Gandalf the White), him and his gift. How could he announce this so-- so casually?!
“I’m telling you, no. You cannot do this to me. You-- they-- you cannot make me tear my heart in half. You cannot make me choose.”
But Gandalf just repeated, quietly: “Bilbo, you know this to be true. Frodo’s wounds are too great. He may find peace on these shores perhaps, perhaps for months and perhaps for decades, but in the end--”
“But how could I ever-- between one child or two others--” a sob burst from him and stopped him mid-speech.
A sudden warmth on his wrist. Bilbo looked down, trying to blink away the haze of tears. Thorin had reached over to grasp his husband’s hand. The Hobbit looked up, to meet determined eyes staring sadly back at him.
“You must,” said Thorin firmly. “Frodo will not wish to go alone, no matter how wane he grows or how little the healing helps. You have to-- you have to be there for him. The boys and I...” Thorin squeezed his eyes shut, as though not seeing Bilbo’s face would make convincing him easier. “We understand.”
Bilbo’s other hand reached up to cup his beloved’s face. His thumb wiped away the tears slowly making their way down Thorin’s cheeks. The Dwarf’s eyes fluttered open; he had not realized he was also crying. But when their eyes met, Thorin saw that it was now Bilbo who was more collected.
“It is wrong,” murmured Bilbo. “To choose between my loves. And it is wrong to you and your People-- as it has always been.”
His red-rimmed eyes turned to Gandalf. But the Hobbit’s face was firm and there was a determined glint in his eye. Seeing Bilbo’s expression, Dwalin would have long scurried off to do his bidding. Gandalf, however, had not dallied in Erebor for too many years.
So Bilbo grabbed the Wizard’s elbow and dragged him off to the nearest chamber, slamming the door shut behind them.
Dwarven walls are built sturdily, and Thorin could not hear clearly what was being said. Perhaps it was best he did not hear, he thought to himself as he slid down the wall, unmindful of his aching leg, to sit there, head buried in his hands without a care as to who walked by and saw. Perhaps it was best that he did not hear his lover’s pleas being rejected-- for despite Bilbo’s many years of living amongst his husband’s kin, the Hobbit never did quite realize just how Unchosen the Durinfolk were.
And meanwhile, behind the door the argument raged on.
The world is coming under a different dominion now and Dwarves will be taking as little part in it as Elves...
You know they call him ‘Elf-friend’ now, and Gimli too, and Fili and Kili soon as well I wager-- and the next generation won’t even need those silly titles anymore...
What great purpose would this tearing serve?! If you can look me in the eyes and tell me truthfully...
And a half broken sob.
Where is the justice in this Gandalf where is the mercy and the love...
And then the voices went too quiet for Thorin to hear anything anymore. He leant back his head to rest against the cool, cool stone and closed his eyes.
--*--*--
Many histories have been written of Thorin II Baggins Oakenshield and his court, for his was the most glorious time of flourishing and restoration for our people since Durin’s days. In Oakenshield’s time, Erebor was reconquered, and under his guidance, his nephew Fili Baggins the Magnificent took back Khazad-dûm. Moreover, it was his other nephew Kili Baggins the Fearless who finally completely cleansed of evil creatures the most sacred place Mount Gundabad. Of the third of Thorin II’s nephews, Frodo of the Nine Fingers, nothing further needs to be said. Others of import are Oin son of Groin and his invention of penicillin, Bofur of Eorthscrafu's discovery of the mineral group Apatite, and of course Gimli son of Gloin’s founding of the Glittering Caves.
But amongst all the great deeds of their times, it is a certain Bilbo Baggins of Erebor and the Shire, Burglar and Consort Under The Mountain, called by later generations Light Eternal, that is held above all others. It is he, a father of three children not of his own blood, that plead our case to our own adopted Father. And so it is now, and will be until we are finally called upon to make the world anew: If ever a Dwarf tire of this land and the Dominion of Men, he may travel to find what peace he wishes for in the Uttermost West.
