Actions

Work Header

take my caged heart back (it is always yours)

Chapter 4: Two sides of a coin

Summary:

Donys makes Bilbo a heartfelt offer.

Thorin waits above Erebor's gates and answers the ransom.

Dwalin and Bilbo get free. But the price this time may be too high.

Notes:

This chapter will catch us up to the beginning of the fic.

I did promise an update today!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“Home sweet home,” Caledon said, in a cheerful mood once more. Bilbo tried to catch a glimpse of the area through the dark, but wound up having to wait for a fire to be lit before he had a better chance.

A few tents were set up, leaves scattered all over them to better blend into the forest around them. A small stream trickled through nearby, too small to be significant on a map. A few crates were set up haphazardly around the area, making it look abandoned. Yet when Arius pulled blankets from them, it was obvious that this camp was very much inhabited.

“Feed them,” Caledon said. “I’m traveling tomorrow to gauge whether our king is willing to deal. We’ll see if he values you over the heart of the mountain, little Halfling.” He let his gaze fall to the cage, and Dwalin slowly curled a hand around Bilbo’s wrist. Just enough to keep him solid under that hateful stare.

Then Caledon was moving over again to another part of the camp, whistling jauntily as if he had not a care in the world. Even Arius gave him a wider berth than usual. Bilbo could well imagine that they’d learned the trick years and years ago: Caledon’s good moods often led to worse moods, and swiftly.

The night fell, the warm air almost comfortable, given how hot the cage had gotten through the day. Arius and Caledon both went to their respective tents, Donys having already retired, and Bilbo tried to curl up in a comfortable place. Dwalin was already out for the count, and the place near him held just enough room for Bilbo to rest. Despite the circumstances, Bilbo couldn’t help but smile. “Always looking out for me, aren’t you,” he said softly. Dwalin didn’t answer, slumbering on. His friend, the stalwart strength he and the others had relied on through the years. The man Bilbo had come to call his older brother. He moved over, then froze when something caught his ankle.

By the door of the cage knelt Donys, and he was slowly unlocking the door. He jerked his head, then tugged at Bilbo’s ankle in a sort of warning when Bilbo went to reach for Dwalin. He had no weapon in his hand, but Arius and Caledon weren’t that far off. The very thought of what Caledon would do to him, do to Dwalin, if they were found…

Slowly Bilbo backed out of the cage. Donys caught him by the arm as he quickly locked the cage again, then pulled him towards his tent. “I want to speak with you,” he whispered.

Bilbo’s heart was hammering in his chest. This could be his chance. Maybe he could convince Donys to let them go. They were in the Greenwood, he was sure of it, and if they could get free, Bilbo knew he could find the Elven-King’s palace. Maybe Legolas or Kili was there, even. They could hide, they could get back to Erebor.

Donys closed the tent flaps behind him, and Bilbo took the chance to look around. It was a meager pallet spread across the ground, with little pillows that ranged from the badly stitched to the most plush, decorative things he’d ever seen before. A little candle sat atop a wooden stool, finely crafted, next to a plate of random fruits and cheeses. It was very obviously someone’s space, and as rich as some of the things were, it left Bilbo’s heart twisting for the young man who had so little.

“Donys, you don’t have to stay here,” he began softly, mindful that the others were but a few crates away. “You could leave them. You’ve got a good mind, you could find a better life.”

Donys’s eyes lit up. “That’s exactly what I wanted to ask you! That’s what I want. I’m so glad you feel the same way. I promise I could get us far from here before they even notice-“

“Wait, what?” Bilbo shook his head. “No, Donys. I mean, I’d like for you to let me and Dwalin go, but I wouldn’t go with you.”

There was a long pause. Donys finally caught the plate of fruits and cheeses and offered them to Bilbo. “I thought you might like them,” he said. “Instead of hard crusts. It’s the least you deserve.”

Bilbo forced himself to breathe. “Donys, I can’t go with you,” he said again, not taking anything from the plate. “But you could settle in Dale-“

“Where I could, what, watch you from afar?” Donys snorted. “I promise I’d take care of you, give you anything you could want, I would…I would make you happy. So happy, if you’d just let me.”

He’d heard tales from the young people of the Shire, of having suitors so infatuated with them, and no returned feelings. How it had made them feel so awful and so uncomfortable, how they’d sometimes wished, just a little bit, to feel the same, while others had never wanted to be left alone so desperately before. But Bilbo had never understood what it even meant to be in love, had never expected to have his heart reach out to another.

Then he’d met Thorin, and twelve years later, his heart was still firmly wrapped around his husband. The thought of him, the memory of his smile, of his fingers caressing Bilbo’s face, it made him want to close his eyes and pretend to be anywhere else except for here, with this eager youth he didn’t know what to do with. “Donys-“

“I love you,” Donys insisted, and Bilbo froze. “I do. You, you make my heart sing, you and your fabulous tales, your courage and your kindness-“

He didn’t have a single idea about Bilbo, not truly. “You think you love me, but you’re in love with an idea, a story,” Bilbo said. “This is hero worship, Donys. And I’m flattered, but you’ll find someone else, someone who will be your world, your everything. I’m not that person.”

“You could be,” Donys said stubbornly. “If you let yourself.”

“That’s not how love works. I already gave my heart to someone else, and I love him.”

“We could go to the Shire,” Donys said, completely ignoring him. “That’s where you’re from, right? What’s it like?”

Bilbo sighed. “Green hills, a little river, lots of hobbits.”

“And food?” Donys persisted. “Cakes?”

Bilbo began to answer as dismissively as he had before, then paused. Donys was truly hanging on to every word that Bilbo had spoken thus far, as if desperate for a dream, a world better than the one he was in. “Pies and cakes,” he said quietly. “The smell just wafts through the entire town. There’s flowers and trees that lend their own fragrance to the breeze, and children play and laugh in the paths while the adults just talk and enjoy each other’s company.” Donys was enraptured, watching him with bright eyes. Sensing a chance, Bilbo began, “You know, my kin are planning a trip to the Shire, soon. I might go with them. You could come with us, my husband and I, he wouldn’t mind, and you could see it-“

“We could go, you and me,” Donys said firmly. “I’d take you. I’d brave the mountains for you, you’d see how dedicated I am to you.”

It just wasn’t sinking in. “Donys, I’m married to Thorin, he is the only one I’ll ever be with, the only one I’ll ever love. I can’t just, just give my heart away, not when he has it.” And would always have it.

Donys suddenly sat up, and Bilbo was quickly reminded of their size difference, that if Donys had half a mind to, he could hurt Bilbo without even breaking a sweat. “He won’t ask for you back,” Donys said sharply. “Why would he part with the Arkenstone? He doesn’t love you that much.”

Unbidden, memories of pain from all those years ago ran through his head. The bright, glimmering Arkenstone in his hands, giving it to Bard and Thranduil when Thorin refused to listen to reason. Thorin nearly killing him, the gold lust running through his veins, calling him betrayer and traitor and banishing him. “It’s but a trinket.”

Even now, the gold pin was carefully tucked away beneath his vest, reminding Bilbo that it had been given back, that Thorin had begged his forgiveness, that they were married and he was loved. The Arkenstone was buried somewhere in the depths of the mountain.

But…what if it was true? Thorin hadn’t laid eyes on it since that day, as far as he knew. What if the temptation of so many years ago came rushing back?

“You know it’s true,” Donys pushed when Bilbo didn’t answer. “I wouldn’t give you up for gold. I wouldn’t. I would love you, if you’d just let me-“

“Donys, no,” Bilbo said firmly, and Donys reared back as if he’d slapped him. Bilbo swallowed and tried again. “I can’t love you when I love him. And even if…even if Thorin were to keep the Arkenstone, and choose the stone over me…I wouldn’t stop loving him. He has my heart, my very being. I love him.”

The young man looked close to tears. Bilbo slowly, carefully, reached out and rested his hand on top of Donys’s. Donys bit his lip, as if Bilbo’s touch was all he’d ever wanted. “You’ll find someone, one day,” he said softly. “Someone who adores you for you. But you can’t do that here, Donys. You’ve got to get out. Let us help you.”

“They’re all the family I’ve got,” he said helplessly. “You don’t, you don’t understand, Bilbo. Not even the same mother. Maybe not even the same father. The only thing I remember is Lenegar, Caledon, and Arius. Just the four of us. And Lenegar got all wrapped up with that woman and then he never came home, and Cale told us we were supposed to live off of those riches, that we wouldn’t be thieves anymore. That we’d have a home.” He snorted. “Should’ve known better than to listen to him. Cale’s always been out for himself. Arius he’s all right with, but me? I’ve always been trapped under him. But he’s still taken care of me, he’s still cared. I can’t turn my back on them now.”

He glanced up at Bilbo, tears in his eyes. “I would’ve, would’ve left,” he managed. “If you’d have come with me. But I won’t go by myself. I want you to come with me, please.” And he leaned forward, before Bilbo could back away. His breath was heavy on Bilbo’s face, and Bilbo froze, heart pounding in his ears.

Slowly, carefully, Donys pressed his lips lightly to Bilbo’s cheek. “You’re everything I could have ever wanted,” he whispered. “My hero.” He hung beside Bilbo, his breath hitching, before he backed away. And Bilbo hated sympathizing with him, he hated it, because he didn’t want to feel for this young man who was far too broken for his age. Not this young man who wanted Bilbo in ways Bilbo would never give him. He didn’t want to be his hero. He just wanted to go home with Dwalin, to throw himself into Thorin’s arms.

Oh Eru, Thorin. He wanted his husband to be here so much.

When Bilbo still said nothing, over the next long moments, Donys finally took Bilbo by the arm and led him back over to the cage. The door opened and shut just as quietly as it had before, and then Bilbo was left in the dark with Dwalin, watching Donys return to his tent. His shoulders were hunched, and Bilbo’s gut twisted.

“He hurt you?”

Dwalin’s voice, dark and angry, left Bilbo releasing the tension in his own body. “No,” he said softly. “No, he didn’t. He wanted me to run away with him.”

“You should’ve taken it, then run from him when you could,” Dwalin said immediately. “You did the ‘noble’ thing instead, didn’t you?”

“I’m not going to lie,” Bilbo said sharply. “And I’m not leaving you.”

Dwalin shook his head and somehow, in the darkness, found Bilbo’s hand to pat. “Thorin’s right: you’re insufferable and stubborn,” he muttered, but there was a fondness in his tone.

Bilbo smiled. “Typically, we switch off. He’s insufferable and I’m stubborn, or vice versa. We never claim both titles at once: that’s greedy.”

Dwalin snorted and shifted into a more comfortable position. “Get some sleep. Somethin’ tells me we’ll be free in a short time.”

That would be wonderful. Bilbo finally pulled himself into a ball, away from the edges of the cage, and let his eyes drift shut. The last thing he saw before he fell asleep was the candle in Donys’s tent burning merrily into the night.



The winds whipped a rare breeze over the gates, relieving the heat for just a short bit. Down on the field, the taller grass danced about, looking deceptively soft and beautiful. If one but moved through it, though, it would be sharp and leave one itching for hours. Somehow, Bilbo never complained about it until much later, in the evening, when he took a bath and muttered about tall grass still leaving red and angry scratches up and down his legs.

“My liege?”

Thorin slowly tried to let out a breath, to try and breathe past the iron bands that seemed to have taken up residence around his lungs ever since…

Well.

“We’re ready for you,” Hril said quietly. “We’d have done it, as requested, but Dril and I thought you deserved to be the one who did it.”

Thorin glanced over his shoulder at the dwarf. He’d become an invaluable friend and guard over the past two years, and now, with Dwalin gone, both he and Dril had taken over running the Guard while its captain was away. Something Thorin appreciated more than words could say.

“Lead on,” he said. Hril gave him a short nod and did so, letting Thorin follow at his own pace. With every step he took, his eyes kept begging him to look out to the field, to see if Bilbo was there, if they were holding him just beyond the tree line-

He shook himself, and instantly the ransom note came back to mind.

To the King of Erebor

We have your Captain of Guard, and your husband, Bilbo Baggins. We only want one thing for their lives: the Heart of the Mountain, the Arkenstone. It was promised to my brother, Lenegar, but never given. It grieves us that it has come to this, that our exchange could not be made more peaceably.

But come to this it has, and so, in exchange for the Arkenstone, you will be given back your husband the hobbit, whole and unharmed, as well as the Captain of Erebor. They are being kept in a secret place, and you will not be able to find them. You only chance of seeing them alive once more, and having them returned to you, is to bring the Arkenstone to the field in front of Erebor on the twelfth day of the month.

However, it is a long travel for us, and we understand how precious the Arkenstone truly is. Therefore, if you will not be giving us the Arkenstone, we would like to know in advance. Please hang a green banner from Erebor’s gates if your wish is to keep the stone. We will dispense of the Captain and Bilbo Baggins immediately, sparing you the grief.

If you wish to make the trade on the day offered above, hang a purple banner above your gates, and we will meet you before your mountain. We are very graciously giving you two people for only one stone, so several crates of gold would not go amiss.

Keep the field clear and empty. We will only speak with you. You are allowed two guards. Any more, and we will leave you a dead body.

The note was still in his pocket, and his finger rested over it once more. The desperate writing beneath the note, a written blood stain from Bilbo, had left Fili cursing and Thorin ready to murder. It hadn’t been the careful handwriting of his husband that he’d come to recognize and know through the years. It had been swift and messy, and the last dragged line had only spoken of violence against Bilbo, to keep him from writing further.

It didn’t matter. His clues had been enough, and a raven had been sent to Kili, Legolas, and Tauriel, who were still in the Greenwood.

Your search is not in vain. Bilbo and Dwalin are somewhere in the forest.

The clues of ‘spider’, ‘no rocks’, and ‘trees’ were enough for Thorin. Somewhere, off the beaten path of the forest, was Bilbo. And Mahal help these thieves when they were found.

Because Thorin would find them. Until then, he would play their game.

“My liege,” Hril said, gesturing towards the cord. Thorin didn’t even so much as pause as he grabbed the slip knot and pulled hard.

The purple banner unfurled gloriously above the gates, a perfect display of obedience. It was the least Thorin could do. Anything to keep Bilbo and Dwalin alive for just a little bit longer.

It just wouldn’t be the only color Erebor would hang.

“Drape Erebor in the red,” Thorin said, eyes still searching the field. Bilbo was out there, and he was going to find him. “We are a week from the ransom date. We go to war now.”

“At once,” Hril said shortly. He left with several other guards, shouting orders and hurrying to find the drapes. Thorin remained at the gates, hands clasped behind him.

“Hold on,” Thorin murmured. “Hold on, beloved. We’re coming.”



It was quiet, that night. With Caledon gone, Arius had gotten even quieter, not saying a word. Donys, too, had been quiet, but no less kind than before. He continued to feed them, even brought them the grapes and cheese he’d had in his tent. When Bilbo had quietly told him that he didn’t need to do that, Donys had shaken his head with the tiniest of smiles and left them the plate. It was the first real, fresh food that Bilbo had had in three weeks, and it had been savored, every bite. Dwalin had left him the fruit, save for two pieces, and had instead focused on the cheese. It had been an energy booster as much as it had been a lift to morale.

Then, in a stroke of pure luck, the keys had fallen from Donys’s worn pocket onto the ground, just within reach. Whether he’d done it on purpose or not was yet to be decided – Bilbo highly doubted that he had, given how worn the pocket had been where he’d always placed them – but Bilbo had snatched them up before they could so much as make a sound on the forest floor, and he’d clung to them ever since.

In the quiet of the night, they’d acted.

The cage door slid open without so much as a groan, just as it had a million times before that. Bilbo slowly slipped out and Dwalin was quick to follow. The dwarf stumbled, upon getting to his feet for the first real time in days, and Bilbo caught him before he could fall. I’m all right, Dwalin mouthed, but he kept his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. Once he was finally steady, they quickly searched the camp for their weapons, but they were nowhere to be found. Dwalin finally pointed to the small path where Caledon had gone, days ago, and hadn’t yet returned.

The dark of the forest didn’t exactly help keep them quiet, but Dwalin had better night vision, and Bilbo kept a firm grip on his tunic. His arm throbbed, just a little, and oh, it would be so good to be back in Erebor, where Oin could properly treat the burns. He was lucky they hadn’t gotten infected thus far.

They kept going all through the night, leaving Bilbo stumbling more than once after the initial adrenaline rush of escaping faded away. They’d turned north when they could, hoping to throw off their pursuers when they were discovered missing. If they could go north, then come back south to Erebor, that gave them a fighting chance. Plus, if they were discovered, at least they were going the right way for the palace.

Except they were closer to the edge than Bilbo had thought, and by noon he could recognize where they were. “Didn’t go very far from the Grey Mountains, did they?” Dwalin asked as the sun began to beat down on them.

Bilbo shook his head, feeling weary and dizzy. He wiped at the sweat on his brow and glanced around again. The fields around them were bare and empty, and far off ahead of them were the Grey Mountains. Somewhere further to their west, in the forest, was the palace. South east lay Erebor. They weren’t far, perhaps a day of walking at most from Erebor.

The temptation was almost too strong. They could be back in Erebor in the early hours of the morning, Bilbo could be back in Thorin’s arms before the next sunrise. He took an inadvertent step before he even realized what he was doing, and Dwalin caught him and hauled him back.

“Better safe than sorry,” Dwalin rumbled. “Caledon’s watchin’ Erebor, and who knows how close he is. We’ll go a little further north, then go east, then south. We’ll come up from behind the mountain.”

Tomorrow, then. Most definitely tomorrow. “Then hurry,” Bilbo said.

Dwalin grunted. “You and me both. I’m almost lookin’ forward to the tongue-lashin’ that Ori’s bound to give me.”

Bilbo would’ve laughed if he’d had the energy. Thorin would wrap him up and probably pull him off his feet, arms tangled around his husband with the refusal to let go until he’d had his fill. He’d cup Bilbo’s face and brush their foreheads together-

Oh Eru, he was just making it worse. Now it wasn’t just that he wanted his husband there, he was longing for him, with every fiber of his being, needing him as much as he needed the air to breathe and a cool drink to parch his thirst. That was a little more necessary.

Maybe. His heart was telling him otherwise.

A whistling sound suddenly got louder, and then it landed so close to Bilbo’s ankle that he tumbled away, wrenching it in the process. The arrow stood straight up from the earth, a threat and a promise. “Get them!” Caledon shouted, and they’d been found. They’d been found.

Dwalin hauled him up, his ankle aching but Bilbo didn’t care, they had to run, now. “Go!” Dwalin roared, and they both took off due east for Erebor. It was over that far plain, Bilbo knew it. They could get past that plain and then they’d be in visible sight of Erebor and probably even Dale. Oh Mahal they were so close-

Then he was being dragged away, hands wrenching him from Dwalin so fast he couldn’t fight back. “Dwalin!” he screamed as Donys and Arius both advanced on the dwarf. Dwalin looked more than ready to take them both, but his eyes kept frantically flitting over to Bilbo. Behind him, Caledon might as well have been made of steel, refusing to let go. He twisted his arm to try and get free, and Caledon ground his fingers into the burn wounds.

The pain, oh Eru the pain. Bilbo gasped and tried to get free, whimpering when Caledon’s grip was too much to bear. “Stop it, please,” Bilbo found himself begging. “Caledon, stop!”

“I’m not giving you two up when I’m this close to my prize,” he snarled. But his head was closer now, and Bilbo snapped his backward and straight into the man’s face. It hurt and left Bilbo’s head ringing, but Caledon let go, and Bilbo rushed forward to Dwalin’s defense. “Arius!” Caledon shouted, clutching at his face.

Arius immediately turned from Dwalin, leaving him to Donys, and made for Bilbo. Bilbo tried to cut under him, but Arius had the eyes and speed of an archer. Bilbo was quickly caught and pinned to the ground, a boot digging deep into his back. Any movement just dug further until he could feel blood soaking through his shirt.

Dwalin let out a yell that made him wrench his head up. Donys had caught the dwarf by the tunic, grappling with him, and Dwalin’s legs suddenly went out from underneath him. Bilbo stared, holding his breath, watching in numb horror as Donys shoved the dwarf into the grass and brought his blade down.

Dwalin let out a choked cry, and then was silent. Donys stood, blade sunk deep, gasping for air. All Bilbo could see were his shoulders heaving as he stood facing Dwalin. Dwalin’s body. His still, lifeless body.

“Donys,” Caledon ordered. Donys slowly wrenched his blade free, and when he turned back, the fresh blood glistening on it was obvious.

No. No, no, no-

Bilbo didn’t realize he was screaming until Arius dragged him up by his hair. Then he was thrown backwards at Caledon, and the punch from the man left him reeling and falling to the ground. The next thing he knew, there was a blade at his throat, and Caledon was ready to kill. He could see it in his eyes, the murderous intent, and this was it. There was nothing left.

“Cale, if you do this, then we have no leverage,” Donys said, sounding desperate. “Caledon! This is the Arkenstone! You said they waved purple, Erebor’s willing to deal. You’re going to lose it now because you’re angry?”

Caledon stopped above Bilbo, fury making his hands tremble and cut just a little into Bilbo’s skin. Bilbo could barely keep himself still, his grief threatening to pour out of him with every breath. Dwalin, Dwalin, Dwalin…

“We caught them,” Donys said. “You caught them. Brilliant as ever, Cale. And now we only have Bilbo, just like you wanted in the first place.”

After a long pause, Caledon suddenly laughed, and the blade was pulled away from his throat. Bilbo felt sobs heaving out of him and forced himself to swallow them back. “Getting smarter every day, Donys,” he said. “You truly are.”

“We can’t stay out here, in the open,” Arius said. “Need to move.”

“Then we will. Move,” Caledon ordered. He hauled Bilbo up by his collar and shoved him towards Donys. “Donys, move him.”

“No,” Bilbo insisted, pushing and shoving because no, it couldn’t be, it wasn’t real, Dwalin wasn’t dead, he couldn’t be. “No, let me go!”

But Dwalin wasn’t moving. And Donys’s blade, coming ever closer, was covered in blood.

Hands caught him harshly, less harshly than they could have, and he didn’t care about Donys’s kindness, he didn’t care, he only wanted to be free, to go home, to help, oh Eru, to help Dwalin-

He thought he screamed, fearful and desperate to be free, to reach Dwalin, but then everything went black.

Notes:

Please read the tags please read the tags PLEASE READ THE TAGS.

You love me. You know you do.