Chapter Text
As they would learn in the months to come, Bilbo could indeed purr (though the purring itself would remain a closely guarded secret for considerably longer), among other useful traits that came with his tail.
Some of those became apparent immediately as after that mortifying evening around the campfire, Bilbo had entirely abandoned his attempts to hide his tail. There seemed little point after thirteen dwarves and a wizard had seen it, and despite his earlier vehemence when claiming the tail was not a third arm, he proved capable of using it for a surprising variety of practical purposes.
In truth, those first weeks of pretending he didn't have a tail had been exhausting, not to mention uncomfortable and as time went by, painful. The constant tucking and deliberate stillness had given him lower back ache and significantly impaired his balance.
Besides, having a tail was far more useful than hobbits ever let on to the Big Folk of Bree or the occasional wandering wizard, as it was as intrinsic to their nature as their curly hair or furry feet, as much a part of their personality as their love of second breakfast.
At first, the dwarves couldn't help but stare whenever the furry appendage moved, which it did a lot when he was annoyed, which, given their company, was often on those first days, tail lashing back and forth like an angry cat, though only Kíli had been fool enough to compare Bilbo to a cat. The resulting swat from the surprisingly strong tail had sent the young dwarf sprawling and earned a chorus of laughter from his companions, who had learned to read Bilbo’s mood in the remarkably expressive appendage, that would curl tight when he was nervous, swish about in annoyance, or even puff up to nearly twice its usual size when he was frightened and angry.
But soon, curiosity gave way to grudging respect as they realized how much the tail aided their burglar… and them.
In densely vegetated areas, while the dwarves hacked clumsily at the undergrowth with their axes and swords, Bilbo would slip ahead and more often than not, overhead too, using his tail to grab low branches and sometimes he even helped clear a path for the dwarves to squeeze through in the brambles.
When after a rainy day they had to make camp in the mud, Bilbo would hang his pack from a high branch using only his tail, keeping his belongings dry while the dwarves' packs soaked up the damp ground.
Of course it was useful when gathering or processing food, as hobbits were very much concerned with it.
Bombur particularly appreciated Bilbo’s tail during cooking duties. The hobbit could stir a pot while simultaneously chopping vegetables, much to the rotund dwarf's delight.
It also made foraging significantly easier, as he could hold gathered berries and mushrooms in both hands while his tail continued to clear his path through the thickets.
Kili and Fili found endless amusement in Bilbo’s ability to snatch small objects mid-air with a quick flick of his tail. They made a game of tossing nuts or berries toward him without warning, only to find themselves increasingly impressed by his reflexes.
At night, while other company members struggled to stay alert during their watches, fighting heavy eyelids and the hypnotic sound of the Ur brothers rhythmical snoring, Bilbo would wrap his tail around a branch or rock above, so if he began to doze, the sudden yank in his tail would jolt him awake. Nori had tried to mimic this technique with a rope, only to wake the entire camp when he toppled over with a startled yelp.
When they encountered the three trolls, Bilbo, who had been sent forward to investigate the light through the trees, had used his tail to pull him silently up and out of the way of the troll's massive hands and boots. But before he could go back to his companions, they had all come barrelling into the clearing and got themselves packed into sacks, while Bilbo had to buy them them time until dawn arrived, taunting and dodging the massive creatures, his tail as counterbalance for sharp turns or sudden stops or squarely smacking the trolls in their faces if they came too close. By the time Gandalf's voice rang out and the first rays of sunlight turned the trolls to stone, Bilbo was breathless and trembling from exhaustion, but intact, and so were the dwarves.
But not for long, for soon after they were fleeing across a plain, sprinting to hide from rock formation to rock formation, with the sound of warg howls echoing behind them. Bilbo, smaller and shorter of stride than any of his companions, should have been left behind, were it not for his tail that he used as a lifeline to wrap around good old Dori’s wrist, allowing the strong dwarf to help pull him along as he struggled to keep stride.
Upon reaching a hidden cleft between the rocks that led into a very narrow and dark passageway, Bilbo, lighter and smaller, used his tail as a probe, feeling ahead in the darkness for obstacles or drops.
In Rivendell, after weeks of sleeping rough and eating Bombur's increasingly creative interpretations of stew, Bilbo delighted in exploring the terraced ornamental and edible gardens, abounding with branches, sprouts and brambles laden with delicacies free for the taking.
Gluttonous creature that he was, even during the formal dinners, while he had both hands occupied with his fork and napkin, his tail would roam around and delicately pluck morsels from serving dishes two tables away. A cake here, a candied violet there, even a particularly tempting cream puff that had been stationed near Elrond's elbow, all disappearing with such smoothness that it took the elves several minutes to notice the redistribution of desserts occurring right under their noses. No wonder the elves would entertain themselves composing verses about hobbit’s cake-burgling abilities for decades to come!
On the narrow mountain paths into the Misty Mountains, Bilbo’s tail wedged itself into crevices for extra stability wind threatened to push him off balance, and snaked out to grab protruding rocks for purchase whenever his feet slipped on loose scree or ice-slicked stone.
More than once, his tail aided his companions as well. When Bilbo was crossing behind Ori and the young dwarf's foot slipped on a patch of hidden ice, Bilbo’s tail shot out to loop around Ori's belt, bracing against the mountain wall to help steady him until he regained his footing. On one particularly narrow traverse, Bilbo went first, and his tail became a guide rope of sorts that the dwarrow gripped as they edged along behind him. And when the stone giants were waging their battle, and Bilbo was swept off his feet by a cascading of crumbling rocks, it was only a desperate lashing out of his tail around a jutting piece of rock that arrested his fall. He’d dangled there, spinning slowly over the abyss, his tail burning with the strain of holding his entire weight, until Thorin's strong hand had hauled him back up onto solid ground.
Later, when after their brief respite in a not-so-safe-cave, they'd been captured and dragged before the Great Goblin, Bilbo had been shoved roughly to the back of the group, largely ignored by their captors. While the Great Goblin ranted, his minions chanted and Thorin argued, Bilbo’s tail had been quietly, carefully working at the knots binding his companions’ hands behind their backs, so when Gandalf had appeared with fire and thunder turning the goblin king’s throne to splinters, they could all run to their weapons and fight for their freedom.
However, in the following stampede Bilbo’s lithe body was shoved aside, and not even his tail, desperately windmilling, could prevent him from plummeting into the darkness. Dazed and alone, he encountered the wretched creature Gollum, and after their game of riddles, while Gollum shrieked about his precious being stolen and lunged for him, Bilbo’s tail snatched the small golden ring from where it had fallen behind the creature and, in his panic, coiled it tight around itself for safekeeping as he fled blindly through the tunnels. It was only when he pressed himself against the cavern wall, certain the creature would kill him, that he realized with shock that Gollum had run right past him, and the goblins too were looking everywhere but at him. The ring, clutched in his tail's grip, made him entirely invisible.
Outside, Bilbo found his companions gathered in a tense conference, and his heart sank when he heard Thorin's gruff voice declaring that the hobbit had either abandoned them or met his end in the goblin tunnels, that they could not wait any longer. The words stung worse than any of his bruises he’d accumulated during the fall, and before he could think better of it, Bilbo unwrapped his tail from the ring, depositing it in his pocket and materialized before their startled eyes which sent several dwarves stumbling backward in shock and Gandalf into a fit of delighted laughter. Thorin's expression cycled rapidly through surprise, relief, and what might have been shame before settling on his usual gruffness, but then he clasped Bilbo's shoulder with unexpected warmth while the others crowded around with exclamations of joy and demands to know how he’d escaped, questions Bilbo deflected with vague mentions of luck and dark tunnels, but his tail betrayed him by wagging a bit, all the while his right hand protectively hovering over the the ring safely tucked in a pocket.
When night fell, the wargs and their riders made their appearance and the dwarves had no option but scrambling up the pines, following Bilbo’s lead who had quickly boosted himself up before using his tail to help the others and even pass supplies up the line when Gandalf began lighting pinecones, the furry appendage proving surprisingly flame-resistant as it caught and distributed the burning missiles. But the trees were burning now, while the wargs circled below, and when their tree began to topple, so there was no other option but fight.
Thorin charged, and he was quickly struck down. And before his mind caught up, Bilbo’s feet and hands and tail were moving, running towards the enemies, his little elven blade drawn in hand, and the fallen oakenshield snatched up by his tail. The orcs laughed at the poor little hobbit, but their laughs petered off when Bilbo's tail smashed the shield into the nearest warg with such force that it tumbled backward into the flames.
In the skirmish that followed, all the other dwarves joined but it was Bilbo’s tail that took center stage, lashing out to trip riders, slam the shield into snarling faces, and even grab a dropped orc blade to parry a blow aimed at Thorin's unconscious form, all while Bilbo’s little sword stabbed and dodged with berserk-like fury. Though he knew he couldn't hold them off forever, he would die before letting them touch Thorin’s prone form.
Thankfully the eagles arrived in a thunder of wings and they were transported to safety.
Later, when consciousness returned to Thorin and he pulled Bilbo into a fierce embrace before the entire company, murmuring words of gratitude and friendship that made the hobbit's ears turn pink, Bilbo's tail curled around Thorin's arm in an answering gesture of affection, and not even Kíli dared make a joke about it.
He had purred then, a shy, yet deeply resonating sound, more felt than heard, that went unnoticed in the general commotion of reunion and relief, though the dwarf king found his racing heart inexplicably slowing, his battle-worn shoulders dropping from their tense hunch, the fierce smarting in his wounds lessening to a dull ache that seemed suddenly bearable, and a tingling warmth spreading through his body and curling in his lower stomach.
Their arrival at Beorn's homestead brought new complications, for the skin-changer took one look at Bilbo and let out a roar that sent several dwarves diving for their weapons before they realized it was laughter. Beorn had studied Bilbo with the intense fascination of an animal-lover who'd just discovered a creature previously thought mythical, and proceeded to pepper him with questions about hobbit dietary habits, agricultural practices, and, to Bilbo’s mortification, the practical applications of his tail, in comparison to that of the various domesticated animals he kept under his protection, holding up dogs and cats and a rather affronted pony to compare appendage strength and flexibility, and even suggesting Bilbo might try hanging from a rafter like the bats in his eaves, which Bilbo very much could, but politely declined to.
Still, the delights to be found in Beorn's garden were worth the embarrassment, vegetables of a girth and taste even unmatched by Farmer Maggot’s own, herbs and flowers that filled the air with intoxicating scents that made Bilbo’s hobbitish soul sing with joy, and his tail swish in tune to his private melody.
Soon, too soon, Mirkwood loomed before them and even from the forest's edge Bilbo could feel a wrongness emanating from the trees that made his tail curl tight against his back in instinctive wariness, doubled by Gandalf's departure and his ominous warnings about staying on the path.
The forest pressed in on them with malevolent intent, filling their heads with strange whispers and half-glimpsed movements in the shadows, and time seemed to lose all meaning as they trudged forward through the green-tinged darkness.
Even at midday the sunlight struggled to penetrate the dense canopy and the path was littered with roots that seemed to shift when no one was looking. Bilbo found his tail constantly at work, testing the ground ahead for solid footing, wrapping around tree trunks when the path became barely wider than his shoulders, reaching back to steady the dwarves when they stumbled over devious roots.
When they reached the black stream that cut across their path, Bilbo used his tail to swing from branch to branch and to leap from one bank to the other and back again, testing the route and proving it could be done with strategically placed ropes. The lighter dwarves followed his example and Bilbo was making his third crossing when Bombur, attempting to follow Bifur across a sturdy branch, lost his balance and despite Bilbo's tail desperate lunge, plunged into the enchanted water with a splash. After they hauled him out he was found to be asleep, and no amount of shaking or shouting could rouse him, which meant they had to take turns carrying him through the forest. Bilbo's tail, useful as it was for many things, could help little with that.
Driven to desperation already by their dwindling rations, the dwarves grew increasingly agitated in the darkness of the night, slapping at phantom spiders, scratching at bites that might or might not be real, their breathing becoming panicked and preventing them from necessary sleep. One night, Bilbo, wedged between the pile of trembling, cursing dwarves, without quite meaning to, began to purr, a gentle vibration spreading outwards that seemed to push back the oppressive malevolence of the forest just a bit, and thus helped his companions rest.
The next day, everyone’s spirits much lifted, Bilbo decided to climb up one tree with the help of his tail to until he broke through the canopy, and felt the pure, untainted air on his face again and watched butterflies dance in the sunlight that still existed in the world beyond Mirkwood's smothering embrace. For a few precious moments he felt almost himself again, believing they might survive this nightmare, and then he made the mistake of looking down at where he’d left his companions and saw no dwarves, no slumbering Bombur, no anything except trees and shadows.
The spiders found him before he found the dwarves, or perhaps it was the other way around, for in the chaos of clicking mandibles and grasping legs, it was hard to say who had ambushed whom. Bilbo's tail became a weapon again, lashing out to smack aside the creatures, wrapping around branches for leverage as he dodged and twisted, even grabbing his little sword when he dropped it and flipping it back into his hand. The Ring helped, of course, turning him invisible and allowing him to slice through the webs holding his companions.
His success was short-lived, for when his companions were still sputtering and clearing away the cobwebs from their clothes and beards, a wood-elf patrol ran directly onto them. Bilbo, by miracle still invisible and therefore undetected, could only watch in dismay as his companions were marched away to the Elvenking's halls, a journey he followed as silently as possible, swinging from above their head in the tree branches, until they entered the gates and he had to follow them on land for long as he dared, before they were divided in small groups to be put in cells. It took him some time to find them all, and when he did, to come up with a plan to get them out of there, as foolishly halfbaked as it was.
The first part, getting the dwarves into the barrels had been straightforward enough, his tail working bolts and mechanisms while he rolled his grumbling companions into the empty wine casks one by one. The problem was that he’d forgotten to secure a barrel for himself, and the quite important detail of his inability to swim.
In the shock of the Forest River's icy waters his tail became an uncontrollable rudder spinning him about, as he tried to wrap it around whatever barrel came closer, but his grip kept slipping. His head went under many times before he managed to haul himself partially onto Bofur's barrel, clinging like a limpet, or more properly a very clumsy water rat. By the time they reached the shore, Bilbo was shaking violently, his tail limp with exhaustion, and a chill settling deep into his bones.
Then Bard appeared, bow drawn though Balin’s shrewd negotiation ended with passage to Lake-town for all. By the time they reached their lodgings, Bilbo, tail once again wrapped around his waist beneath his soaked jacket, was feverish and light-headed, his nose running and his throat thick.
Due to his sickness, the days in Lake-town blurred together in a miserable haze of fever and discomfort, as whenever he appeared in public he had to tuck his tail away, presenting himself as a perfectly ordinary, tail-less, beardless dwarf-like creature to the people of Lake-town.
Only when they finally departed north through the desolate landscape toward the Mountain, loaded with supplies and ponies courtesy of the Master's avaricious generosity, Bilbo could let his tail free beneath his cloak, though still not quite recovered from its ordeal in the river, it proved less useful than usual for balance and climbing while they searched for the secret door.
And then the door was found, the key turned and the previously imperceptible door swung open, yawning into a dark passage leading into the heart of the Mountain where Smaug the terrible awaited. Whether asleep or dead, that was for Bilbo to find out. So in went the Burglar, his tail extended before him like a cane, feeling for obstacles, testing each step before he committed his weight to it, until the tunnel opened into a cavern so enormous and so full with riches his mind didn’t register it.
Bilbo slipped the Ring and tried to find the damned Arkenstone. As he moved, his tail swung behind him, testing, balancing, keeping him upright as he picked his way over the treacherous gold. It was going fine until his foot stepped on a plate that had been balanced atop a helmet. The plate tilted, the helmet rolled, and suddenly Bilbo was sliding, his tail lashing wildly but finding no purchase on the smooth coins, only exacerbating the cascading avalanche of treasure that seemed to roar in the vast silence of the chamber.
The mound shifted. One vast, lamplike eye, filled with cunning and malice and a terrible ancient intelligence emerged from the hoard.
Bilbo froze, still invisible, his tail rigid with terror behind him. For a long moment, he thought he was safe and unseen. Then Smaug's head lifted, nostrils flaring.
He had been found out.
Instead of instant dead (Flash of light, searing pain, then - POOF! nothing more than a pile of ash!) there followed a game of riddles, half-truths and threats between a very bored, thousand year old creature, and a definitely non-bored, vibing with terror yet cunning enough hobbit, that still invisible kept the dragon entertained as it circled around him, trying to locate him until his patience finally broke, fire filled the chamber and the heat became unbearable.
Tail wrapped around his body protectively, Bilbo sprinted back up the tunnel, Smaug's bulk too large to follow but his voice echoing behind, promising death and destruction, and burst out into the cold night air where the dwarves waited. Mere moments later the mountain shook as Smaug erupted from the Front Gate in a rage of fire and wings, flying toward Lake-town to exact his revenge on those he blamed for sending a thief to his lair.
The dwarves retreated into the mountain when the dragon was gone, and at first it seemed like victory: they were home, the treasure was theirs, Smaug had fled.
The gold sickness took them one by one, though it seized Thorin worst of all. The dwarf king who had held Bilbo’s tail that first night, and then embraced him in the Carrock, who had called him friend, became cold and paranoid, obsessed with the Arkenstone above all treasures. He had the dwarves searching through the hoard day and night, and Bilbo, who for some reason had pocketed that very stone during his second descent into the treasury, felt the truth burning in his pocket and his heart.
When armies arrived, first the Elvenking and the men of Lake-town seeking their share, then Thorin's cousin Dáin with dwarf reinforcements, the mountain became a trap impossible to escape from.
Bilbo tried to reason with Thorin and found only paranoid accusations. His tail, which had once curled around the dwarf king's arm in affection, now stayed tucked between Bilbo’s legs. And the other dwarves looked elsewhere, too gold-sick or afraid to utter protest.
It was this that drove Bilbo to his desperate gambit. Under cover of night, wrapped in his invisibility, he slipped down the ramparts with the aid of his tail, to deliver the Arkenstone to Bard and the Elvenking, hoping it might force Thorin to negotiate rather than fight.
Thorin's rage when he learned of the betrayal, was incandescent. Bilbo was cast out, his tail painfully yanked as he was called traitor and thief and descendant of rats, whose ugly tail should have revealed his true nature. But before he could cut it, Gandalf called out and demanded his Burglar back.
Then a vast army seeking revenge for the death of the Great Goblin appeared, and suddenly old and new grudges meant nothing in the face of such foul dark creatures.
Bilbo did his best, or tried to, under the cover of the invisibility ring, to protect himself and his companions, but what could one small hobbit do in a battle of Five armies?
When the fighting finally ended, he made his way across the blood-soaked snow to where Thorin lay dying. The dwarf king's hand found his, his grip weak but warm, and his eyes, clear finally from the gold-madness, held recognition and regret and something else.
Weeping and bowing over the dying king, Bilbo's tail, without permission, curled around the dwarf’s wrist , and he began to purr without meaning to. It was not the shy, private purr from atop the Carrock, nor the gentle, radiating rumbling to calm his companions in Mirkwood. No. It was a deep purring starting deep in his chest and making his whole body vibrate. Bilbo poured everything into it, all his energy and desperate hope, all his love for this stubborn, noble, infuriating dwarf who had called him friend and then traitor and who wished that, in these final moments, had called him something else .
The vibration spread outward from his body to Thorin’s, and he saw the pain ease in those bright blue eyes, saw the dwarf king's breathing slow from ragged gasps to something almost peaceful.
Then there was a rush of wings, vast and powerful, and the ground fell away. An eagle, the same great bird that had carried them from the burning trees, perhaps, had taken both Thorin and Bilbo in its talons, lifting them up and up and away. Another eagle bore Fíli, and another Kíli, and the army below grew small and distant as they rose.
Even then as they climbed into the sky, even as Thorin's eyes closed and the grip of his hand felt lax, Bilbo didn't stop purring. He couldn't. His tail remained wrapped around him, and the sound that came from him now was grief made audible, a mourning song about a hobbit and a dwarf to be remembered by generations to come.
