Actions

Work Header

to rule the fate of many

Chapter 6: Paths to tread

Summary:

Esmeralda brings forward truths that Thorin would rather not hear.

But there are other truths in the forest to be found, and with them comes a terrible choice the company must make.

Notes:

Have amazing art!!! A-Hobbit-At-Heart drew absolutely adorable Esmeralda and Tauriel art!!

http://bilboluckwearer.tumblr.com/post/59180517788

Go look go look go look!

Chapter Text

The first night in the forest was a cold one. A low flame was built, under Gandalf’s careful eye, and though it burned higher than Thorin would have liked, fearing it would give them away, Gandalf seemed pleased with it. If the wizard was comfortable with how bright the fire was, then Thorin would not argue with him.

Bilbo knelt beside him. “How is it, even with a fire, I’m still chilled to my bones?” he asked.

Without speaking Thorin opened his great traveling coat and pulled Bilbo into his side. Dwalin snorted in amusement from across the camp, and Bilbo muttered something uncomplimentary but shifted in beside him. “Thank you,” he said, and Thorin shook his head.

“You could have asked, you know.”

“Why, when you knew what I was asking for?”

True enough. “Where is your bedroll?” Thorin asked, brow furrowing slightly as he searched near his own. His bedroll was laid near the edge of the camp, but it was alone, the closest one being Aragorn’s.

“I thought this venture a wonderful way to not have to sleep next to you and your snoring-“ and then Bilbo choked on a laugh when Thorin poked him in the side. Served him right; Thorin did not snore.

“Insufferable hobbit,” Thorin muttered, but when Bilbo pressed a kiss to his cheek, he gave a grin of his own. Watching Bilbo breathe easier, watching him actually smile, left Thorin feeling so light he wondered how he could still feel the ground beneath him. This, at last, was his husband, the hobbit whose smile he relied on. If he could but give Bilbo moments like these forever. “Please tell me you remembered to bring your bedroll.”

“It’s right beside Esmeralda’s,” Bilbo told him. His smile fell as he glanced at his cousin. She was seated in front of the fire, helping Legolas and Gimli toss things into the small cooking pot. “I just…didn’t want to leave her alone.”

Sometimes, the strength and size of Bilbo’s heart could still leave him warm and blessed, even when that heart wasn’t aimed to comfort or please him. “I think she will appreciate that greatly; I know Tauriel will sleep close to her as well.” Even now, the elf was moving forward to join the others around the pot.

Bilbo hummed in agreement but made no effort to move. Thorin was in no hurry to make him; not when he had a warm husband pressed against his side.

Soon enough, the lure of food was too much for everyone, and they all drifted to the center of the camp. Esmeralda helped out in much the same way Bilbo had, on the first journey to Erebor, and Thorin knew now that this was the way of hobbits: to busy themselves and aid where they could, simply because they wanted to help. Even as they hurt within, they would still do anything in their power to help another.

And cook: hobbits could cook, and Esmeralda was a proud example of her people. Somehow, she’d taken the packed food and turned it into something far more lively, far more delicious than it had a right to be. “This is fantastic,” Kili said around a mouthful of stew. Legolas gave a fond grin in his husband’s direction.

“Spices,” Bilbo and Esmeralda said together. Even Aragorn smiled. “Spices make the difference,” Esmeralda continued when Bilbo gestured for her to speak instead of him. “Just a few favorites, that’s all. They were a wedding gift, a small one, from Saradoc.” Her face clenched in grief for a moment, and then she let out a sigh, a small smile on her lips. “I think he was half looking forward to eating something with the spices, if you want the truth,” she said at last, throwing a bit of cheer in her voice. Her smile was genuine, but it was tinged with sadness. “I suppose I’m lucky he didn’t gift me a barrel of Southfarthing leaf that he could ‘borrow’. Honestly.”

“He steals mine,” Kili said, nodding to Fili, and Esmeralda’s smile tried to even out. Fili rolled his eyes but did not dispute his brother’s claim. Thorin hadn’t raised them to tell falsehoods, after all.

The stew was consumed in quick order. After finishing, Tauriel moved to sit beside Esmeralda. “There may yet be others for you,” she said softly, and other conversations began to fade in order to listen to the elf’s words. “You could still find your heart’s desiring. You are still so young; you could remarry, if it is something your people encourage. You have many years-“

“Not that many,” Esmeralda cut in. She shook her head. “There’s only so many years in a lifetime.”

“You could still marry,” Dwalin rumbled, giving a nod in Tauriel’s direction. “Even if it took years to find someone your heart would yearn for, you could do it. You’ve many years left.”

“Perhaps another 75, 80 years,” she said.

The number, laid so bare and so small, caught everyone’s attention. “But you’re barely of age!” Ori sputtered. “And your coming of age is so much younger than ours!”

“Because we don’t live as long. Your lives, compared to ours…it’s not like that, for hobbits,” Esmeralda said quietly. She wrapped her arms around her knees and pulled herself into a small ball. The fire cast a sharp light on her face, and she looked so fragile that Thorin wished he could offer her some form of comfort. “We have short lives. A little longer, perhaps, than men, not as long as dwarves, and we’ll never see eternity pass as the elves do. But it’s what you do with the years you’re given that counts, doesn’t it?”

From across the flames, Fili stilled. Legolas, too, had paused, gazing at her as if he’d never seen her before. Esmeralda didn’t notice their looks and continued on. “I’m still young, yes. Which Bilbo keeps reminding me of, as if he were old or something.” She shook her head with a wry smile, ignoring her cousin’s rolled eyes. “He’s only 60; barely over half his life. He’s only got 25 years or something on me. It passes by so quickly, though. I just…I wanted my years to pass with someone. Even if they were just a friend.” She rested her chin on top of her knees. “That’s all,” she finished quietly.

There were a few times that Thorin felt as if he’d been physically struck by words. Her soft, gentle, almost playful words left him reeling, and he turned away from the others, fighting to maintain his composure. He had known, in his mind, that Bilbo was older, now. 60 was not even of age for a dwarf, but for a hobbit, it was well into the second half of one’s life. He had thought of it, he’d even known of it. But he hadn’t really known it.

Over his shoulder, he could see Bilbo coming to join Esmeralda beside the fire. His beautiful, brave hobbit. His Bilbo, who’d braved the fires of Mordor and traveled alone, was going to risk his life again to seek out his cousins. The flames cast a red haze on Bilbo, as if he were on fire himself, and when he rested his head upon Esmeralda’s shoulder, he appeared lifeless.

The image was so startling that Thorin had to turn away again. A buzzing filled his ears, and he felt so dizzy he thought he would pass out. He pushed his feet against the ground and forced himself to breathe. He swayed, just slightly, but enough to make him tighten his muscles.

Slowly, the buzzing faded, and there was a soft murmur of conversation around him. Bilbo’s gentle, teasing voice came in, and Kili laughed while Esmeralda giggled. Alive. Not on fire, not dead. But Mahal, it had been every one of his fears dragged up from the past and brought to life.

Bilbo had so few years left. Thinking of Bilbo in danger, now, when Thorin had so little time left with him, left him with a stone rolling in his gut. All he wanted was peace. All he wanted was peace with his husband, to be with him, to not have to fear for his life with every breath he took. And though the past ten years had been without war, he’d still been forced to fear for Bilbo’s life again and again. He had been gifted good luck, in regards to Bilbo’s safety, but eventually, that luck would run out.

He just wanted peace. And he had fought for that peace for nigh on ten years now. Yet still it was denied to him. Still he was forced to face Bilbo’s mortality in the worst, most terrible ways.

He thought of the happy moment he’d had with Bilbo just a short time ago, of his husband tucked under his coat. And he wondered how many more times he would be allowed to have that before it all came crashing down upon him.

He forced himself to push the thoughts from his mind. He could not think about them. He just couldn’t. If he focused on that now, he’d get nowhere. Later. He would deal with his fears later.

Sleep came uneasily that night, nevertheless. His husband not lying beside him only made it all the harder.



It was nearly at the edge of Mirkwood a few days later when they heard voices. Thorin threw up his hand to call a halt, and everyone immediately stopped. Aragorn drew his horse quietly beside Thorin, Gimli seated in front of him, and both looked ready to charge at the slightest motion. At least, Gimli did. But how that was different from any other day, Thorin didn’t know.

The horses, though well trained, would be too loud in the brush. Thorin quickly dismounted, Bilbo already on the ground and heading for the trees. Silently the group crept closer until the voices began to make coherent sounds. Thorin resisted the urge to catch Bilbo and pull him back behind him. There was such a thing as attempting to be careful, one that Bilbo was ignoring in a very un-Bilbo like way. One that was leaving Thorin more nervous than ever, especially with the possibility of a ransom ringing in his mind.

A ransom made sense, and Thorin had agreed with Bilbo as to why his kin may have been taken. But no missive had arrived in Erebor before they’d left, no insistence on a sum of gold for the exchange of the hobbits. No, more and more Thorin had the terrible feeling it would all come down to his hobbit who even now was crouching and moving silently across the various leaves and sticks on the ground. Esmeralda, too, was scurrying through the brush after him, and thankfully Tauriel and Legolas were not far behind the hobbits. The lack of sunlight helped them to hide better amongst the thick leaves and branches that swooped down towards the ground, and never before had he been so grateful for the clouds above.

When the voices were loud enough to understand, Thorin stopped, and the company with him. Hidden by the trees and various bushes, they were able to focus their attention on the figures before them.

Tall men moved about in a small clearing that linked to a hidden path, pulling things from horses, as if to bed down for the day. “Could still move a bit further,” one of them said, and the answer came from someone else Thorin hadn’t expected.

“We’re to wait ‘ere until the order’s given,” the orc said, and though the man glared at it, he made no move to strike it down. Thorin stared in aghast horror. Men, working with orcs?

Worse yet came the sharp pain of betrayal when two dwarves moved into the small camp. “Order’s been given,” one of them said gruffly. “’Sides, all we’ve got to do is get to the docks. Collect the payment, move on.”

“Think we could keep part of it?” one of the men said, and the others looked to be pondering the idea. “She’d have her prize; could we take some? All that gold?”

Thorin focused on breathing evenly. Ahead of him, Bilbo looked as taut as Legolas’s bow when pulled with an arrow. So Bilbo had been right: this was about the gold that the thieves had attempted to take two years prior. The men and dwarves before him seemed of the same ilk as those whom they had contended with: scarred, filthy, no care for anything save for the gold waiting for them at the end.

He forced his other questions away as he listened.

“You try to take from ‘er and you’ll ‘ave your ‘ead off,” one orc insisted. It looked fearful, and Thorin’s gut twisted. “Nah. We get the prize at the docks, we take it to ‘er, we get paid our own share.”

“Can’t do any of that until we get our orders,” a dwarf growled. He kicked the wheel of a cart, drawing hisses from several orcs. “Tired of this grub, tired of sleepin’ under trees for measly hobbits.”

Tauriel pressed a hand to Esmeralda’s shoulders even as Bofur moved in to stand beside them. Thorin risked shifting closer into the bushes to catch Bilbo by the ankle. His skin was warm, but not too much so, and Thorin tried to say everything he wanted to through that simple touch. I’m sorry  went with I will not let them harm you and a touch of I love you, the undercurrent of any message he sent.

A commotion caused the thieves to all look up, but thankfully not in the company’s direction. A man on a horse rode in, and he spoke in a loud, clear voice. “Prisoners are on their way home,” he announced, and Bilbo inhaled sharply. It was lost in the din of approving snarls from the thieves. “You need to get down to the docks. Payment will be shipped shortly, and your job is to haul it back to the den.”

“We know our job,” one of the orcs snapped. A few men chortled and nodded in agreement. “Just because you’re her favored pet doesn’t mean you’ve more brains than us.”

The man glared at the orc, his long dark hair combed and tied back smartly, his face clean, setting him instantly apart from the rest of the group. “Yet I’m the ‘favored’ one, and you’re doing the grub work,” he said. “What does that say about you?”

The orc gnashed its teeth and moved forward, but a dwarf swung his axe up to halt it. “We’ve not the time for this,” he said when the orc turned its rage towards him. “We’ve gold and a prize to catch.”

The man on the horse raised his nose and trotted back off through the forest. Slowly the men and dwarves began to pack up camp, and the orcs went to tend to their wargs. Thorin stayed still, quietly breathing through only his nose, until they were all gone. Once the band of thieves had departed, he felt safe enough to slowly move back and away, tugging at Bilbo’s leg once before letting go. The others were just as cautious to move, but when they were back at their horses, their movements were quicker. No one spoke for a long time.

Finally Fili cleared his throat. “So, that clears up everything and nothing at the same time,” he said, and the quick joke in his tone let Thorin breathe more easily. Even standing beside Bilbo, his husband breathing a little unsteadily from tension, Thorin couldn’t find himself able to completely relax. The words of the thieves had left him too unsettled, too full of questions.

Thankfully, Legolas voiced one of them, saving Thorin the trouble. “Who is ‘she’?” he asked. “She sounds as if she holds power.”

“And someone who holds power over orcs, dwarves, and men isn’t someone I want to mess with,” Balin said. He looked at Thorin, his gaze troubled. “But I’ve a feeling we’ll need to.”

Sooner and not later, most likely, given their luck. Thorin shook himself. “They spoke of taking the prisoners home,” he said. Bilbo glanced at him briefly before looking away. So he had thought of it, too. “Do you think they mean…?”

“The Shire?” Bilbo gave a terse nod. “I’m sure of it. If a group like them is taking Primula, Drogo, and Elodie back to the Shire, it’s not as a kindness.”

No, it only spelled disaster for the quiet, peaceful lands that the hobbits called home. Thorin felt a pang at the memory of losing his own home to Smaug so many years ago. Thinking of Bilbo’s homeland being lost to destruction, his kin slaughtered by orcs, only set his blood boiling. It would not happen.

“Are we sure they weren’t talking about their home? Their own place they crawl back into at the end of the day?” Nori asked, causing Thorin to pause. “Because if they head back there instead, we could wipe them out, all in one blow.”

The idea was tempting. “They’ll head back to the Shire,” Bilbo insisted. “They spoke of their ‘den’ and the ‘home’ as different things. No, I’m positive they’ll go to the Shire.”

“But if we knew where they were hiding, we could stop them,” Fili said. “Uncle, you know we could.”

“Stop!” Gandalf ordered, and everyone quieted. He turned to Aragorn and Thorin, his gaze more serious than Thorin had ever seen it before. “Both are legitimate courses of action,” he continued. “But we cannot all do both. We must choose which path to take, and take it.”

“Could we make it to the Shire before they do?” Dwalin asked. “Any chance we could beat ‘em there?”

“There are paths through the mountain that are swifter on horse than on foot, yes,” Gandalf agreed. “But they are more widely known. We would have less chance of being spotted if we took a smaller, though slower, route.”

“They can’t be watchin’ all the roads at once,” Bofur protested. He stopped and glanced at Gandalf when the wizard didn’t respond. “Can they?” he asked, eyes wide.

It was all Thorin could do to not put his head in his hands. There was danger in every step they took, and no matter what they chose, it could end in tragedy. What had been a quick following through Mirkwood was already turning into something much bigger, something with not enough answers and too many questions. This did not sound like a few thieves who intended on burrowing into Erebor, much as Thorin had once hoped. This sounded too much like a clan of thieves, of ones who thought of more than just a simple payload. This had been planned, methodically put together one piece at a time. This had been targeted towards Erebor, towards Bilbo.

Yet there had been no sign of any thievery or danger for two years. Had they truly hidden that well? Had they kept to themselves, biding their time, until they could strike out at the most opportune moment? It hadn’t escaped his attention, either, that they had struck at Bilbo’s relatives. The other travelers had not been disturbed. They had not attacked Morwen, nor Aragorn, but the little hobbits of the Shire. The innocents.

No, this spoke of something much bigger, far more vast, than a simple theft. They wanted something more.

“They said something about gold and a prize,” Aragorn said, gazing at Thorin. “You mentioned thieves from several years ago. What had they wanted?”

“The Treasury, at the time,” Thorin said. “They mentioned no prize, then.”

“No, they did,” Bilbo said. He shook his head. “They simply never said what it was. I wouldn’t be surprised if it were…” He cut himself off, but the way his brow pinched together spoke volumes. Thorin knew what he would have said.

The Arkenstone.

He shook himself. They were jumping to conclusions when they were low on time as it was. “We must decide, and quickly,” he said, voice low and urgent. If they had any chance of following the thieves to whatever ‘docks’ they spoke of, or to their den, they had to leave now.

“What if we split up?” Kili said. He held up his hand when protests poured in. “Hear me out, hear me out. A small group of us follows the thieves. The rest of you go on to the Shire. Smaller groups move more quickly, so you could barrel down the known roads with more safety. We could track them and then send you a raven with details. We’d know where you were, easily enough.”

As much as Thorin wanted to disagree with his nephew, it was a logical, sound plan. He simply did not want to do it. “We’re safer together,” he argued, but Kili gave him a firm look, one that Thorin had seen in the mirror many times.

“We don’t have time to be safe, Uncle. We could rescue Primula and Drogo and the Shire but lose something else in the process. We have an upper hand: we can’t afford to lose it.”

“I’m going with Kili,” Fili said determinedly. As if there’d been another choice.

“I’m swift and silent; I’ll go with Kili as well,” Legolas added, and Thorin wondered when someone would say something not quite so obvious.

He wound up surprised with the next choice, at least, when Nori spoke. “I’ll go with them. We’re all quiet as quiet can be. Nice, small group to keep track of them.” He glanced at Dwalin. “You keep him safe,” he said with a nod towards Ori. Ori didn’t roll his eyes, but it appeared to be a near thing.

“The rest of us will go to the Shire, then,” Thorin said. He grasped Bilbo’s shoulder, speaking quietly once his husband had looked over to him. “You and I will go together, this time. I won’t be parted from you.”

Bilbo gave a half smile. “Good. I’ll warn you; trouble tends to follow me like a duckling follows its mother.”

Again with speaking things Thorin already knew. “Then let us be off,” Gandalf said. “Spread out over the horses. We will stop in Rivendell to tell Lord Elrond of what has transpired and to leave some of the horses there with him.”

Kili and Fili turned away, and Thorin suddenly called them back. When they stopped, confusion on their faces, Thorin took them in his arms and held them tightly. “Be safe,” he murmured. Though they were well past their coming of age now, they were still his sister-sons. Losing them was a fear that would never truly separate from his heart.

They wrapped themselves around him, just as eager to hold on. “You too,” Fili said, and Kili could only nod. But when they stepped back, they were determined young dwarves once more, power in their stances and gazes. They had grown so much, over the years. And Thorin was proud to have seen it happen.

“There’s no point to our taking the horses,” Nori said, pulling his pack from the horse he’d shared with Bofur. “We’ll need to be more silent than that.”

“How will you keep up with them?” Esmeralda asked, confusion on her face. Tauriel helped her up and back onto her horse, and she looked uncomfortable at the height. At least she was with Tauriel, and that was a small comfort indeed. Thorin only wished he had better news for her, and for Bilbo, too.

“They’re taking carts,” Kili told her. “They’ll be moving at a pace we can follow. We’ll keep up, no worries there.”

No, that was nowhere near the biggest worry that Thorin had. But before he knew it, the four were gone, moving quick and quietly through the forest. He told himself the twirling in his gut had everything to do with a hastily eaten meal from earlier and nothing to do with the spike of fear as he watched them disappear.

A hand caught his, and Thorin didn’t even need to feel the familiar ring to know whose hand it was. He’d been holding it for nigh on ten years now. He would know his husband anywhere. “They’ll be all right,” Bilbo promised in a hushed tone. “Four are safer than two.”

“One would think that we would learn to not separate,” Thorin murmured. “Nothing good ever comes of it.”

“Would fate be so kind,” Aragorn said quietly, coming to stand beside them. “If anyone could do their mission and do it well, however, I know it would be your sons. With Legolas and Nori, their success is all but assured.”

Thorin took the words for the compliment that they were and gave a sharp nod of thanks. It was not their abilities he held mistrust for, no, but fate.

“We will take follow the river over the Old Ford,” Gandalf said, “and follow the road through the mountains. The High Pass would be easier, but I would not dare take a horse through it. No, we will follow its smaller, though still broad, twin in the valley below. Keep your ears and eyes aware: the path is a well known one. If they are so daring as to come out in broad daylight, they would not hesitate to guard the pass…or the road below it.”

“Least we won’t have to deal with the stone giants, this time,” Bofur said. Thorin watched as Esmeralda’s eyes went wide.

“We didn’t see stone giants when we took the High Pass! Are they really, well, real?”

Bofur’s response, to go pink in the cheeks and duck under his hat, was so unlike the dwarf that Thorin could do nothing more than blink in dumb silence. “Ah, well, they are, actually,” Bofur said. He sounded much like Kili or Fili would have, when they said something they had not intending to say out loud. Except Bofur typically never sounded that way. Bofur stood by what he said, be it serious promises or tongue-in-cheek humor.

Esmeralda looked excited for the first time since they’d begun the quest. “All Bilbo said was that they were terrifying,” she said, and she leaned so far over in order to move within earshot of Bofur that Tauriel was forced to catch her around the waist. “Were they? Were they truly?”

“Onward,” Gandalf said, mounting his steed once more. Thorin did the same, pulling Bilbo up with a simple hand. Bofur still sounded as if he were stumbling over words behind them, but Thorin would puzzle it out later. As far as questions that needed to be answered went, he had more urgent ones at the forefront of his mind, such as why the thieves would return Bilbo’s kin to their homeland. What could they gain from going to the Shire?

Unless the Shire itself was the prize. Thorin gripped the reins of his horse a little more tightly. “Has anyone ever tried to take the Shire before?” he asked his husband. Any movement forward was brought to a quick stop. Even Gandalf paused, waiting for the answer.

Bilbo shook his head. “Not in my lifetime. Not in a very long time. The land has always been ours, and we’ve traded equally with anyone who’s wanted the food or the plants in it. The Shire isn’t a kingdom, it has no treasure beyond good food and leaf, no one’s ever needed the Shire.” He looked more troubled than before, and Thorin ran an apologetic hand up and down his arm. He hadn’t intended on upsetting his husband any more than he already was. But the question had to be asked, and he could see the thought now on everyone’s faces.

For though the hobbits saw only what the Shire could offer in terms of farms and orchards, orcs wanted nothing more than to pillage, to make slaves of any they could put beneath them. The men and, Mahal help him, the dwarves Thorin had seen were no better. They would devastate the Shire, take personal slaves from those who were hardy and able. The rest they would slaughter.

“Gandalf, go,” Aragorn urged, as if thinking the same thoughts, and Gandalf took off, leading them through the forest at a rapid pace. Branches flew by, threatening to whip at their faces, but Thorin had no care for them. No, all he could see were the bright and friendly faces who had wished him and Bilbo well after they had married, of the warm lights in the tent as they had all celebrated the wedding, of the heart’s tree he had been wed beneath. He could only see Bilbo’s bright eyes from the hanging lamps, the smile on his face, the feeling of his hands in Thorin’s.

Then it was all in flames, all of it, the orcs and men and dwarves burning and killing and tearing it all apart.

His mind drifted to his earlier thoughts and memories. When Erebor had been taken, there had been a darkness in Thorin’s heart, an angry fear, one that had lasted through the years. It had left him cold and hollow, unable to see the good in outsiders for fear that no help would be given, no aid would come. He had learned to trust in himself, in the few who had been sincere and loyal, in those who had been kin. Then he had met Bilbo, and he’d learned to feel, to trust, once more.

But when he thought of the orcs taking the Shire, when he thought of whoever ‘she’ was tearing apart the innocent lives that lived in Hobbiton, his rage was bright and burning and refused to be tempered. He could feel Bilbo in front of him, body as hard as steel, all but trembling. He could only imagine the thoughts running through his mind, of the kin he could lose, of whatever Bilbo was most certainly blaming himself for.

He leaned forward to put his lips to Bilbo’s ear, lest the wind take his words. “I will not let them take the Shire,” he murmured. “I swear to you, beloved.”

Bilbo’s head jerked forward once, just enough to acknowledge that he’d heard Thorin. Then Thorin put all his focus on guiding his horse as the forest began to give way to open plains and the Misty Mountains that rose high above them in the not so far distance.