Chapter Text
The fog rolled in on the fourth day through the mountains. At a full gallop, it hadn’t taken long to get to the Misty Mountains, nor to the valley that cut through it. Up above, the stones appeared to be silent and still, but Bofur knew better. He’d seen them up close and personal once, and the once had been enough.
Waiting for a potential attack wasn’t much better, though. Though their pace was a fast and steady one, there was only so fast one could go through the rocky terrain, and only so fast one could take the horses. He could see it in Gandalf’s furrowed brow, Aragorn’s pursed lips, the hand Thorin constantly kept on the hilt of Orcrist. No movement for several days, no sighting of any thieves or other travelers, had made them all wary.
Not enough to dampen Bofur’s cheer, though. Especially not now.
“I swear I won’t tell anyone what it is.”
Bofur just grinned and kept whittling. Esmeralda gave a huff and crossed her arms, but it only left her looking all the cuter, a sentiment he was sure she wouldn’t appreciate. “I’m wonderful at keeping secrets, you know-“
“You are not,” Bilbo said, glancing back at her. Though his voice was pitched low, Bofur could still hear what he said. “You’re dreadful at it. In fact, you were the easiest way to share a message around the Shire: just tell you and everyone would know by nightfall.”
Esmeralda’s cheeks went pink and she stuck her tongue out at her cousin. Tauriel grinned, a bright and happy thing to behold, and even the two kings and wizard were hard pressed not to smile. “I wasn’t nearly that bad,” she said. “I promise I won’t tell anyone what it is you’re carving!”
Bilbo had been right: a Took’s curiosity was a dreadful curse. Fortunately, it was a curse for the Took and not for those who encouraged it, like Bofur was, if just to have her speak to him. “I’ll tell you when it’s done,” he said for what had to be the sixth time just that day. In truth, he would’ve happily told her, if it hadn’t been for her. He’d been torn between giving her what he'd been carving or not before leaving Erebor, but upon hearing more and more of her tale, he’d finally given into his urgings and focused on making the item hers. He thought it was quite the accomplishment: to ride a horse while carving. That probably had more to do with the horse’s skill than his, but still, he hadn’t lopped off a finger yet, and he hadn’t fallen off the horse. Good signs all around.
Esmeralda gave another huff but settled back down onto the horse. It was a more sedate pace they were taking today, in deference to the small slopes and uneven parts of the path that they were traveling. Yesterday had been all about speed, taking large runs with only a few short breaks in between. But now the path had narrowed, and there was evidence of old rockslides around them. Nothing too recent, but they still kept an eye out for any movement, ears to any sound.
“How close is it to bein’ done?” Dwalin asked. It only served to encourage Esmeralda’s curiosity, if the way she looked to Bofur for an immediate answer was any clue. Bilbo gave Dwalin an exasperated glare, and Thorin merely gave his husband a sympathizing pat on the shoulder.
“Close enough,” Bofur replied enigmatically. Esmeralda settled back on her horse reluctantly. It almost made him want to speak more, but he was still worried he’d put his big old boot in his mouth somehow. He’d been startled when she’d spoken to him, as the company had first split, and he’d been left stammering and stuttering in a way he’d never been before. She’d continued to speak with him, asking questions, and slowly they’d begun to converse, his tongue loosening after he’d realized she simply wanted someone to talk to. With his horse beside theirs, he made a perfect conversant.
He was trying to ignore the fact that she could speak with Tauriel if she so desired and was instead speaking to him. It wasn’t good for his heart.
But the truth of it was that she’d started talking to him, and Saradoc had been a friend, not her heart’s desiring – not yet at least – and Bofur would at least not be completely out of turn in presenting her with his gift, with at least being her friend. And perhaps, one day, if they remained friends and her heart wasn’t taken…perhaps making his intentions known.
Because his heart was still wrapped around her like a strand of gold wrapped around a vein of mithril. Every day he spent beside her, watching her, listening to her voice, hearing her tales and what she had to say, it only left him feeling all the more besotted. Oh, Bombur would be having a laughing fit at him right now if he knew. He was fairly certain Dwalin knew, and the only reason the dwarf hadn’t said anything was because of Balin. Or Ori. Maybe both of them. He didn’t know if Bilbo knew.
What if Bilbo didn’t approve? Oh Mahal, he hadn’t thought of that. Sure, Bilbo was one of his dearest friends, and he Bilbo’s, but that didn’t mean that Bilbo would think him suitable for his little cousin. It was clear that he was protective of her, that she was like a younger sibling to him. He felt like dragging his hat over his head to bury his face in. He wasn’t even going to offer his intentions, and here he was, worrying about her kin.
The gentle tapping of stones upon stones paused his thoughts and stilled his hands. The others continued on, having not heard, but Bofur knew that sound. He glanced around for the source but found nothing. He quietly went back to carving but said, “You should see the rocks I’ve carved; they make a joyous sound when I’m done and they’re sliding all about.”
All the dwarves sat up straighter, and those who didn’t understand still caught the tension. “Where,” Balin muttered from behind him.
“Off to th’right, I think,” Bofur said quietly. Thorin gave a tight nod and kept his horse marching onward. Bilbo was trying to not look back at his cousin and all but failing at it. Bofur nudged his horse next to Esmeralda’s and saw Tauriel’s hands already off the reins, fingers just waiting to catch her bow and an arrow.
Silence echoed through the valley. The fog made it harder to see too far above them, but Bofur couldn’t make out any shapes in the crests. No more rocks slid, and though he strained to hear, no more taps were heard.
A harsh rumble of rocks behind them was all the warning they got before the orcs were there. “Go!” Aragorn shouted, and Tauriel shot her horse forward past Thorin and Aragorn, who were both turning around. Bofur hurried his horse onward to catch up with Tauriel’s. Esmeralda was gripping the horse’s mane as best she could, and Tauriel was already turning to fire an arrow behind her.
Orcs appeared out of the fog ahead of them. “Tauriel!” Esmeralda shouted, and Tauriel’s next shot swung over the hobbit’s head to those approaching. She took out three orcs before they were close enough to swing their blades, but Bofur was ready and waiting. He threw himself off of his horse and into the fray, his mattock clearing the area around their horses. No one was getting close to Esmeralda again. No one.
“Bofur-!”
He turned halfway through Esmeralda’s cry and watched the orc drop by a single arrow. “Nice shot,” he said to Tauriel, throwing her a grin. An orc shouted behind him, and he didn’t even pause, simply swung his mattock back behind him before finally turning to look. Straight through the chest.
“Good swing,” she returned, and reached for a nearby orc corpse to pull an arrow free. Bofur caught two more arrows for her and returned them in time to see only three orcs ahead of them. By his weapon they fell, and though he peered through the fog, no more seemed to be coming. The sounds of the fight were behind them, not ahead.
“Go back,” Esmeralda said, gritting her teeth. “Tauriel, Bofur, we have to go back.”
“Your cousin’ll skin me alive,” Bofur told her, and if there was ever going to be a reason why Bilbo disapproved of Bofur and Esmeralda, it’d be leading her back into the fight.
“Hard for him to do that if he’s dead,” she said, and though the pain in her eyes was a remembered grief, her mouth was still set in determination. Thinking of Bilbo dead by the hands of an orc was enough for Bofur: he raced back, mattock swinging high and into an orc’s skull as it tried to creep up on Balin. Balin nodded his thanks and took out another orc coming up to his left.
“Death to the thieves!” an orc shrieked, and those remaining took up the cry.
“We’re not thieves!” Ori shouted, and Dwalin cast his husband a bewildered gaze.
“Are you seriously tryin’ to reason with ‘em?”
An orc waggled its tongue at them, drawing two short and broken blades. “We know what you lot are,” it hissed. “Traitors and thieves, the lot of you! We’ll get it back!” It charged forward with a cry, and Thorin’s blade struck it down before it came anywhere close to his horse, where Bilbo was still seated. Another orc ran forward with a crazed cry, and Bilbo hurled fairly large stones at it, catching it perfectly in the head, stunning it enough to allow Aragorn to finish it.
“Good aim,” Balin said when Dwalin had finished the last orc off.
“The best I can do, since someone won’t let me down,” Bilbo said, giving Thorin a look. Thorin shook his head.
“I will do all I can to keep you safe. It is not your skill I fear for, beloved, and you know that.”
Bilbo finally sighed and tossed the stones back into a pouch at his side. “Doesn’t make it any easier to sit up here while you risk your life,” he groused, and Thorin gave a half smile.
“If it means keeping you safe, I’ll suffer it.”
“Is no one going to care that it called us thieves?” Ori said, and Bofur thought he looked fairly put out about it. “We’re not thieves!”
“I think what my husband is tryin’ to ask is why the orcs want to kill thieves,” Dwalin said. He wiped the end of his warhammer on one of the dead orcs. “Thought the orcs were sidin’ with them.”
Aragorn, after cleaning his sword, slid it back into his sheath. “It sounded as if the thieves stole something from them. I have never heard of separate factions of orcs, however. Uruk-hai and orcs, yes, they’ll fight one another. But orcs on very separate sides?” He shook his head. “This leaves an ill feeling in my gut.”
In Thorin’s, too, if the look on his face was any indication. “I’ve seen orcs turn on each other before,” Bilbo said. “But Aragorn’s right: I’ve never seen them fight against each other. If these orcs were against the thieves we saw, we would almost be like…like allies.”
Bofur stared. Thorin looked as if he’d bitten into something sour. “The world changes day by day in strange ways,” Gandalf murmured. Louder, he said: “I would not go so far as to call them allies…not just yet, anyway. We must hasten to Rivendell. Hopefully Lord Elrond can shed more light upon this matter.”
“Then we’ll get onward to the Shire right quick enough, too,” Gimli said. He spun his axe and put it in its leather hold upon his back. “We’ll not let a few orcs slow us down!”
“May he never lose his energy,” Balin murmured. Bofur grinned.
Soon they were back up on their horses, and Gandalf rode to the front. “It may be wise to ride in a condensed formation, as much as is possible,” he said. “For I’ve no doubt there are more orcs around. Perhaps, if we meet with others, we may gather more information. Aragorn, if you and Gimli will take the rear, please. Thorin, you and Bilbo ride to the front.”
Bofur flanked Tauriel and Esmeralda while Balin took the other side. Dwalin, after a quick conference with Thorin, rode to the back to stand beside Aragorn and Gimli. Their small caravan sorted, they set out once more, hurrying as much as the terrain would allow. Down a small slope ahead, Bofur could see the path widening out. And though he couldn’t see it yet, he knew there was a valley waiting for them, filled with elves and true allies.
“No more carving, I suppose,” Esmeralda said, but her tone was no longer light and teasing. Her words hadn’t been a question.
Bofur shook his head. “Not for a bit. But when we reach Rivendell, I might be able to finish it up.” Then he could gift it to her, perhaps.
The small smile on her face made him all the more determined to finish his gift before they left for the Shire. After Rivendell, there’d be few chances for her to smile, and he was determined to give her a reason to. Even if it was just a small one of kindness for his efforts.
They rode on.
In the darkness, a crow of triumph was heard, and a small, shining token was held aloft. One more rediscovered, and it was beautiful.
Footsteps on stone echoed through the room. “Are you pleased?” a voice asked.
Her lips turned up into a wide smile. “Yes,” she said. “Yes I am.” She turned her prize around with her long fingers, watching it catch the light with each pass it made.
The man cleared his throat and brushed a hand over his dark, slicked back hair. “They worked hard to find it. I didn’t let them rest for a minute. But…now they’re asking about their share. What they deserve-“
“Then kill them. We have new recruits every day, deserters from the villages of men, dwarves from the mountains, orcs from…wherever they’ve been hiding for the past decade.”
“But-“
“Stop whining, Lenegar. It doesn’t suit you.” She turned to him and flexed her hand, long nails shimmering like a dragon’s scales. Her green eyes stared him down. “Or do you doubt that we will have the treasure we seek?”
“I-I wouldn’t doubt,” he stammered. “Not at all.” He paused. “I only wondered if there was something I could but share with them. To put their doubting hearts to rest.”
She smirked, but it was not a kind one. Slowly she sashayed through the room to her lounging chaise. Once seated and spread out, she lifted her prize into the air again. It caught the light once more, and she glanced at Lenegar. “Have you ever played a game of strategy?” she asked him.
“My brother did, as a child. I was never any good at it.”
She hummed and placed her eyes back to the glittering object in her hand. “There is no trick to playing a game such as that. Anyone can play. But only one can win. And the trick to winning is that you have to think of multiple things at once. If you show your opponent what your move is, they will all know what you intend to do and rush to cut you off.” With a flick of her hand the item flew up into the air. Just as it was about to land in her palm, she caught it with her other hand. “You’ll never win if you have only one goal in mind.
“But. If you plan to divert them, if you plan to sweep them off the board, you must give them a fake win. A false hope.” She tossed the item into the air again, but this time it landed neatly in her palm. Only then did she turn to Lenegar. “That is how you win a game of strategy. Have you heard any other news?”
“A band heads south; I have heard nothing from those who head west.”
She nodded. “When you have heard from the west, we begin.”
“What of the…the one Halfling? The one who vanished into the forest?”
“She is of no consequence,” she said, waving her hand. “She knows nothing. I would have preferred another carrot to dangle, but then again, I would have preferred to dangle all the little carrots. I don’t, however, have that luxury.” She pinned Lenegar with a glare, and he swallowed hard.
“They’ve been warned to not harm the Halflings. Not after what happened during the capture.”
“Good. I have no want or need to tip my hand so soon.”
A flurry of footsteps made Lenegar turn swiftly, blade in hand, but it was only a man, panting heavily from the run. “My lady,” he said, “a missive from the west. They have arrived and are taking swift control.”
Her teeth glinted in the light. “Good; you may go.” As the man hurried away, she turned to Lenegar. “The next step begins now. You know what to do.”
Lenegar nodded and gave a swift bow. He took her hand and pressed a long kiss to the back of her hand. “My queen,” he said, and she smiled broadly at him. He left her then, and she leaned backwards to admire the item in her hand. Long years of wanting, of waiting, and finally she would have what she deserved.
“Finally,” she murmured. “The outcast returns home.”
