Chapter Text
“Good morning, Will,” Jack said, smiling in such a blatantly false way it made Will wince.
Jack wasn’t alone. There was a man standing just behind him, studying Will over Jack’s shoulder. He was taller than Will, but not by much. Maybe an inch. He had high cheekbones and dark eyes. The impressively loud suit he wore was definitely tailored for him, and probably expensive enough that Will would have to get a real job again just to pay for one. Despite the lack of outward emotion, Will could tell the man was amused about something, and he looked at Will like some particularly interesting goldfish.
“Jack,” Will said bluntly, then tipped his chin at the stranger, “who’s this?”
Jack turned, as if he was pleased to have the opportunity to introduce them to each other.
“This is Doctor Hannibal Lecter,” Jack declared, “Doctor Lecter, this is Will Graham. I did warn you he is not the most sociable person.”
Doctor Lecter nodded politely, still amused about something. It was itching at Will’s skin like poison oak. He didn’t back down or show his aversion, though. He tried not to show weakness in front of any humans. Creatures were different, and more likely to accept you if you seemed weak or vulnerable. Humans would either choose that moment to strike, or reject you outright.
“I understand, and I know we are likely seen as intruders in this case,” The doctor said casually, “though I do hope we are not a terrible inconvenience to you, Mister Graham.”
Will huffed, stepping aside to beckon them in.
“Call me Will, and I’ll consider forgiving the intrusion,” he told the man as the two walked into the somewhat dark house.
Will didn’t have a lot of lights, or particularly bright ones. He didn’t need them, though that was another thing that set him apart from normal humans. He had really excellent night vision.
The doctor’s lips twitched up in something resembling a smile, and Will got the sense it was the most expressive the man got. That was fine with him.
“So, what makes you come out here and bother me, Jack?” Will asked, pouring them each a mug of coffee, offering it to each of them with a raise of his eyebrow.
Hannibal accepted the coffee, though Will could see it was more out of politeness than any desire for the mediocre beverage. Jack took his without giving it any thought at all, and didn’t even seem to notice he held the mug as he replied.
“There have been some disappearances in this area,” Jack explained, “and I could really use your imagination on this one. We don’t have any leads, and I need something.”
Will glanced at the doctor, who was managing not to look like he despised the coffee as much as Will could tell he really did.
“You already have a psychiatrist to give you a profile. That’s what I do best, Jack. I don’t see what I could do to help you. Lecter seems a capable individual.”
Jack blinked in surprise, and Lecter smiled softly again. It was more in his eyes, and Will could tell he was growing more amused with every word spoken.
“Will. You know you do more than that. You interpret the evidence, and make jumps you can’t explain. I need someone who can interpret evidence like that. I need some jumps,” Jack said.
The desperation was leaking through, despite Jack’s attempts to seem in control of the situation.
“If I may,” Doctor Lecter said gently, cutting in before Will could tell Jack off again, “Will, there is very little evidence to work with, and even less resources to utilize regarding the victims. All Jack is asking for is for your thoughts. You needn’t work on the case past that.”
Jack seemed a bit deflated, as if he had hoped not to make that clear to Will. He had probably hoped to rope Will into the investigation until the end.
Will eyed the doctor warily. Usually, when someone acted that nice around him at the first meeting, they wanted something from him. He just didn’t know what the man might want, or what he might have heard about Will.
“Be that as it may, Doctor, I still don’t intend to get my head wrapped up in this kind of stuff again,” Will said, “and regardless, I can’t do anything without evidence . All I do is interpret the evidence. I can’t do that with nothing.”
Lecter tipped his head curiously, continuing to study Will like he had been. Will wasn’t sure why it unnerved him so much. He was used to odd looks from people. He shouldn’t have been bothered by one more.
“If you cannot do anything with the amount of evidence we have, would it really be a threat to the peace you have found here?” he asked.
Will cursed under his breath, but he saw the slight twitch of the man’s ears telling him he had been heard.
“You make a damn good argument, Doc,” Will said, taking a swig of his coffee, “but I’m not hearing a lot of appeal to my nature. I would think a psychiatrist would try to garner sympathy, making me feel bad for not wanting to help.”
Now the man was really amused. His eyes seemed to sparkle with interest, and he tipped his head just a bit.
“If I were to do that, would it be an effective strategy?” Lecter asked.
Will smiled wryly, not showing his teeth.
“I didn’t say it would be, but most people would try anyway,” he said with a shrug, “I was wondering if you were refraining from doing so out of a sense that it wouldn’t work, or because you don’t want to be like most people.”
Doctor Lecter smiled, and he flashed his teeth for just a moment. Will could have sworn they were a bit sharper than most, but he didn’t get a good enough look at them to be sure.
“I can assure you, Will, neither of us are like most people,” he said, his voice smooth and enticing, as if he was trying to lure Will into something.
As much as Will was aware of the temptation, it still worked.
“Alright, I’ll bite,” Will said at last, sighing at himself and putting his coffee down on the counter, “What do you have to work with?”
Jack brightened up considerably, having all but wilted with the idea that Will would not help them. He pulled a file out of his bag and handed it to Will, eyes intent on watching him work.
Will opened the file and looked over the pictures.
There really wasn’t much. Each person’s home was seemingly untouched, though their doors had been left slightly ajar. No signs of forced entry, burglary, or a struggle. Everything exactly in its place, aside from the resident. Even their keys, wallets, personal items, phones, everything , had been left behind. It was as if they had been spirited away.
The only thing that tied them together was the general proximity, and something else that Will couldn’t quite place. He could taste it on his tongue, like cinnamon among the other flavors that mingled across his palette. He recognized it, and appreciated it, but it was not the only thing to consider.
Will looked at the pictures, knowing how to look in the places the agents and investigators hadn’t. That was his expertise. Seeing what others didn’t, and thinking in ways they couldn’t.
“You’ll want to see if the orientation of their houses is similar, and check the perimeter of the properties for anything, like prints in the dirt, or marks on trees,” Will said absently, turning to another picture as he spoke, “and they are going to have something in common. It might not be obvious. It might be something in their personality, or something from their past. Ask people who knew them what they were like, not just the usual sort of questions.”
Will flipped the file shut and handed it back to Jack, taking up his coffee to drink again. He ignored the bright look of awe and determination on Jack’s face. He wasn’t going to entertain the thought of joining the investigation. He wanted to see what the doctor thought of his observations.
Lecter was impressed. Will could tell that much. There were also some unspoken thoughts that swam behind his eyes, but Will couldn’t make them out. The man’s eyes flicked over Will as if looking for some sign or hint that would explain how he did it.
“See, Doctor Lecter?” Will asked, “I’m really not like most people. I have yet to be convinced about you.”
That got a reaction. Lecter smiled again, and Will was sure his teeth were sharper than average. That alone was proof of nothing, but it was odd. The man huffed a soft laugh before the smile turned into something more tame.
“Well, I shall have to endeavor to prove myself, then,” he practically purred.
Will felt his hackles rise at the tone, as if his body was reacting to some sort of challenge. He couldn’t quite put his finger on what about the man felt off, but there was definitely something. Something that was screaming at Will that Lecter was not who he claimed to be.
These were the kinds of things that made Will stand out, even in the FBI.
Jack stepped forward, his expression imploring. He was about to ask Will to come to the labs, or to a scene, and keep helping.
Will held up a hand to keep him from saying anything.
“I need to head into town for something today,” he offered, thinking back to the paint he wanted to look for, “and if you have something in Quantico that you want me to look at, I may just be amenable to that.”
Jack all but beamed at Will, nodding and assuring him that he would have everything set up and ready for him. Will didn’t care much about what Jack was saying. He was wholly focused on doctor Lecter. The man was watching him with a peculiar expression, and Will was set on finding out what lurked behind his eyes. That was essentially the only reason he had agreed to help more. He had never been wrong about anyone yet, and he was determined to find out what was setting off the alarms in his head.
The men set off soon after Will agreed to help, leaving Will alone to consider what he had just done.
Will sighed, shaking his head at himself. Alana had known he would agree to help, and so had he. They had both known, but he hadn’t been able to stop from doing it anyway. He was too predictable. Even if it was just to himself.
Will let the dogs back in, doing a headcount to make sure they had all come when he called. There had been a few times when one or two of the dogs had decided to linger outside when it was time to come back in, and unsupervised dogs tended to get into trouble if left too long.
Once all the dogs were inside, Will stepped out onto the back porch and took a deep breath in.
He could smell the trees, and the fresh earth. He could smell hints of the dogs on the grass and the wood of the porch. Will knew he had a better sense of smell than most people, but there had been some humans that had an even more acute sense of smell, so he couldn’t definitely attribute it to his otherness.
Will briefly considered changing his mind and not going into Baltimore. He would much rather take a walk into the woods, sketch some more designs to be carved into his work later. He could let his thoughts settle, and allow the mentality of monsters to fall away like autumn leaves. He could go fishing, or just sit on the bank of the stream and listen as the water sang by.
As enjoyable as it was to think of, Will knew he wouldn’t do it. He had told Jack he would go into town, and come by Quantico. Regardless of how he wished he wasn’t, Will Graham was a man of his word. He also really did want to find a paint worthy of the peryton, and he wouldn’t be able to avoid going into town to find it.
---
“Need help finding anything?” the small employee asked. Her hair was bright orange and spiked up, and she stood only about five feet. Five feet at most, actually.
Will had been trying not to look like he needed help. He hated when employees tried to talk to him, and he always wanted to avoid it if he could. This girl had just appeared out of nowhere, and had apparently noticed he wasn’t sure which bottle of paint he wanted.
Will sighed.
“I need paint for a model, but it has to be perfect. It has to be black, but I want it to shimmer, sort of. I’m not sure this is making sense. I don’t normally use paints, and I don’t know what to look for,” he confessed, knowing it was better to accept help when offered than to wander around confused for another hour after having rejected it.
The girl hummed thoughtfully, scanning the shelves in consideration.
“Oh! I think I’ve got just the thing!” she said, snapping her fingers, “I used the stuff once before, and I think it’ll do the trick.”
She waved for Will to follow her, and he did, though he was wary. She led him to an aisle in a section of the store he hadn’t thought to check, and then she studied the shelves of paints carefully. Her eyes lit up when she found what she was looking for, and she pulled out a bottle to show to him.
“This stuff is a temperature-sensitive, color-changing, shimmering gloss coat. They show up mostly clear, but the shade of whatever color you put under it will change when it gets warm or cold. You can get it in whatever colors you want, meaning the shimmer will be a different color. I’ve never used it over black, but I think it’s just what you’re looking for.”
Will took the bottle from her and studied the label. It sounded about right, and if he could get different shades for the wings and the antlers, that would be perfect.
“Thank you,” he said, mentally deciding to find out if he could leave a review of the specific employee, or give her a tip or something, “I think you’re right. I’d almost lost hope.”
Will flashed her a soft smile, careful to keep his teeth hidden, using the opportunity to catch her name off the tag.
Anna grinned at him.
“I’m glad I could help,” she said, and she really meant it, “need anything else?”
Will shook his head, turning back to the shelf of paints to find the perfect colors.
“I think I can handle it from here, but I really do appreciate it,” he said.
“No problem,” Anna replied. She turned and walked away, leaving Will to pick out the perfect paints for his peryton.
Will found some that would shine green and silver, just like the feathers of the peryton. He debated over a few red shimmer paints, but eventually decided on one. He then walked over and picked up a large bottle of regular black paint and carried them all to the checkouts.
The boy who rang him up was in a bad mood, and didn’t engage Will in any conversation. That suited Will just fine, though it left a lingering feeling of annoyance in him from the boy’s own thoughts.
---
Jack made sure to meet Will at the doors, leading him to the labs while telling Will how really odd what they had found was. He didn’t tell Will what it was he was going to see, but Jack was sure to make it clear that it was entirely unnatural. At least in his mind.
Beverly was the only one working in the labs. Will was glad of that, and knew Jack had probably made sure of it just to get Will in a good mood. Beverly was the only one who actually had liked Will, and had tried to convince him not to leave. Will liked her, and was glad to see her again.
Doctor Lecter was in there too, standing near one of the tables. He watched as Will entered, his eyes tracking every movement like a hunting predator.
“Here it is,” Beverly said, waving at the large object on the table, “have a gander, Will.”
Will huffed a laugh at Beverly’s casual expression. She only talked that way to Will, because he was the only person who would talk that way in response and not be annoyed with her for doing so.
As Will drew closer, he saw why Jack was so confused by it.
The object was a plaster mold. The kind they used to preserve tire tracks or footprints. What Will saw was not either of those.
Hoof-prints. Cloven hooves.
“These prints were found outside the most recent missing person’s home. The second missing person’s home had also had hoof prints like these, but they had been near the tree line, so they had been dismissed as irrelevant. These were in the flower garden directly under a window.”
Jack explained it as if it all had to mean something.
Will huffed.
“I don’t suppose the flowers had been eaten ,” he said, taking no small amount of joy in being an annoyance.
Jack crossed his arms.
“No, they weren’t. Not to mention, the garden was on the side of the house away from the trees this time,” he said.
Will raised an eyebrow.
“So both houses were near trees,” he concluded, “you don’t happen to know if all of them were, do you?”
Jack rolled his eyes, but nodded.
“Yeah. They all were.”
Will spread his hands.
“Then there you have it. Statistically, you were bound to find some animal prints somewhere near them. Congrats. You should start keeping score like some nature enthusiast. Two deer out of so many missing people. That’s really fantastic. You could really take it up as a hobby.”
Beverly snorted, turning away to hide her snickering behind her hand. Jack looked like he might be about to explode. Doctor Lecter had a sly smile that he was also obviously trying to suppress.
Clearing his throat, Hannibal put a hand on Jack’s shoulder to calm him down a bit.
“I think Jack might be considering that this connection means something beyond human involvement,” Hannibal explained, his eyes still sparkling with amusement.
Will sighed.
“Alright. Fine. I’ll consider it,” he said, looking back down at the mold, “I already said it’s probably a deer, but if you’re worried it’s one of the Other, then it could be just about anything. There are plenty of creatures with cloven hooves. Hell, it could even be the devil himself. He’s got hooves.”
Beverly was continuing to snicker in an undignified manner. Will, himself, was having a hard time not laughing. If Beverly hadn’t been laughing so much, it might have been easier for Will to keep a straight face. The fact that Jack was still visibly frustrated wasn’t helping either.
“Do you have any hunches?” Jack asked, his voice tense as he refrained from shouting.
Will sighed.
“Alright. Yeah. I have a hunch that it’s not exactly a person doing this,” he confessed, folding his arms and leaning back against the wall, “I can’t tell you what’s doing it, just that it’s probably not fully human, if it’s human at all. The missing people probably aren’t alive anymore. You’re looking for bodies, or body parts. I can’t help you more than that.”
Jack nodded, his jaw working as he tried to figure out what it was Will was implying.
“Should we scour the woods?” he wondered aloud.
Will started, having to stop himself before he shouted or fell over.
“ No ,” he said immediately, without thinking about it.
All three of the others looked at him expectantly, and Will ran a hand over his face as he tried to decide what to say to keep them from tearing through the woods and killing anything they found.
“Listen. These people offended the creature. They probably trespassed in its territory. If you go into those woods, the only thing you will get is death, whether that’s the death of your men or innocent creatures. I, personally, being one of the people who lives near those woods, would like it very much if you would not anger the animals that live there, especially if one of them has already been taking people.”
Jack frowned. Will knew it was a fine line he was walking, making a case against harming the Others, but he couldn’t help it. He hated the thought of the FBI razing the woods to the ground and killing everything in it.
“So, what do you suggest we do?” Jack demanded.
Will huffed.
“I don’t know, Jack,” he snapped, “I shouldn’t even be here, but if you want my advice, you’ll leave the woods alone. Maybe the people who live near them should be more careful about what they do. It seems like they were tempting fate by living there in the first place, and they just tied their own noose by being disrespectful to the powers that be. I’m going back home, and I’m gonna mind my own business, and if I see any FBI agents trying to use my property to sneak into the woods, I’ll shoot them in the foot. I’m warning you, Jack. Stay away from the woods. Leave the creatures well enough alone, and they’ll let you be.”
With that, Will strode directly out of the labs, ignoring Jack’s calls to come back. He felt his blood boiling, and he didn’t trust himself not to just bare his teeth and growl at them all.
Go searching the woods for some killer beast. Ha . That was laughable. If there was anything in those woods that was killing people, he would be happy to let it. The people of the world didn’t deserve mercy from it. They all thought they were too good for their lives, and didn’t understand how lucky they were to have them.
“Will.”
It was Doctor Lecter.
Will huffed again and continued walking, right out the doors into the parking lot. He was halfway to his car when he was stopped by a hand on his shoulder. Will felt his entire body tense up and he froze. He had to make the conscious decision to keep himself from straight up biting the man’s hand and tasting the blood on his tongue.
“Mister Graham, please,” Hannibal said, all politeness, “I did not follow you with the intention of trying to convince you to return to Jack. I merely wanted to express my gratitude to you for your words.”
Will frowned, confused, and turned to look at the man. There was no hint of irony or untruth in his expression.
“What for?” Will asked, shrugging the hand off his shoulder and crossing his arms.
Hannibal tipped his head curiously at Will and looked him over.
“My native country is Lithuania,” he began by way of explanation, “and as a young boy I spent much time in the woods of my family home. There was not so much taboo and fear of the Others in that time and place. I was taught to consider them as beautiful creatures and to always show them respect. I am pained by the turn humanity has taken since then, and I am glad to see you respect them and care about them as I do. I had thought I was alone in this way of thinking.”
Will pressed his lips together and shrugged.
“You’re welcome,” he said, trying not to channel his frustration at the doctor, “I’m glad to hear at least someone around here has some sense. I thought the last of it had gone with me. Now, if you don’t mind, I have work to do.”
Hannibal nodded, and Will turned back to walk to his car.
“I’ll see you again, Will,” Hannibal called after him.
Will opened his car door and looked back at the man.
“Not if I can help it,” he replied.
Will didn’t miss the sharp-toothed smile Hannibal gave him as he drove away.
