Chapter Text
Why was he so surprised?
What did he think was going to happen?
It was clear enough what was going to happen thanks to the universe, but he had also made a promise. A promise that he knew would not be easy to break if he was even willing to sever it in the first place.
Hannibal had known that there was no way things were going to work out.
He placed a finger on his lips, missing the lips he had been waiting to kiss for so long. He had gotten that chance just for it to be a goodbye to Will. It was a cruel joke.
It was still dark by the time he made it back home. Chiyoh and his mother were in their own rooms which gave him the perfect opportunity to wash up and change his clothes. He would have to really wash them or just get rid of them. He did not want his mother or Chiyoh panicking.
When he exited his room, he spotted his mother and Chiyoh sitting down at their little table.
Simonetta rose from her seat. "Figlio, where did you go? We were worried but Chiyoh said you-"
"I'm fine, I promise. There was just something I needed to do, Mama." Hannibal said reassuringly, not wanting to male his mother panic.
Chiyoh crossed her arms. "Where's Will?"
Hannibal was quiet for a moment before replying. "He uhm...he went back to Portofino."
Simonetta frowned. "Oh...I'm sorry, figlio. I wish he could have stayed longer. He left right after being introduced to Bedelia."
"Maybe he'll come back to visit some other time." Chiyoh said hopefully.
Hannibal was not so sure about that. "Maybe. Sorry for disturbing you both. I think we should all head to bed. It's been an eventful day."
"Sí. Buonanotte, figlio." Simonetta said, walking towards her son and placing a kiss on his cheek. "Buonanotte Chiyoh."
Chiyoh nodded at her. "Buonanotte, signora." Once Simonetta was out of the room, Chiyoh got up from her own seat. "How was the conversation?"
Hannibal figured she would have had questions. All he could think about was how the whole night played out. "He wasn't happy, but we did talk." There was the whole killing a merman thing he had to leave out. "He left...giving me a kiss goodbye."
Chiyoh's eyes turned sorrowful. "I'm so sorry, Hannibal. I was hoping something."
"I don't know if anything was possible, Chiyoh." Hannibal frowned, moving a bit of his hair out of his face. "Some things are just not meant to be."
Chiyoh approached him. "Maybe, but I still wished for it. You two seemed so happy together. I'm still hopeful, Hannibal."
Hannibal smiled at her sadly. "Buonanotte Chiyoh."
"Buonanotte Hannibal." Chiyoh said to him as he was the first one to leave the room.
Once he was back in his room, Hannibal headed to his little balcony in his room. He glanced at the direction of Castiglioncello. It would never be the same again without Will.
If only things were different, kept repeating in his head.
🐚 Hannigram 🐚
Agony. It was all he could feel.
There was only one emotion he could feel and the only emotion he had felt ever since returning back to Primavera.
No one had questioned or talked to him. They all believed he just wanted to be left alone. Everyone close to Will (including Margot and Bella) had been made aware of what had happened. Will had offered the one he loved a chance to be with his under the sea, but it seemed like Will had been rejected since he had returned home all alone.
If anyone wanted to try and talk to Will, no one did. He would tell them he just wanted to be left alone for now.
All Will did was sob. He would cry himself to sleep and he would dream of the life he could have had. Everyone could see he was not eating much since he never left his room. All he would do is look at his collection and cry himself to sleep.
Near his bed was the little potion bottle. He would just stare at it and he could hear all different voices in his head.
Thank goodness you didn't tell him - so he wouldn't have to see how pathetic you are.
Why did you not tell him? Just because he has a life up there doesn't mean he wouldn't want to have one with you!
He would be ashamed to have you as a life mate with how weak you're acting.
You made a mistake not telling him. He should have gotten the chance to decide.
He doesn't love you.
He loves you.
The voices became too much and he knew it was all the doubt in his heart. Sometimes, he regretted it and other times, he knew it was what he had to do. Everyone thought Hannibal had rejected him, but the human had never even gotten the option to accept or reject. Will did not give it to him which no one knew, of course.
If he had told him, what would he have said? Will did wonder that.
He knew if Hannibal did reject, he would have done so in a kind way. There would be no rudeness in his voice because Hannibal hated rude people and did not consider himself rude or stooping down that low.
Will could not consider the possibility that Hannibal would have accepted. It would just break his heart.
Then again, he did not give Hannibal a choice.
"Will?" He looked up from the bottle he was now holding his hands. It was Beverly. "I wanted to come check on you."
Will sniffled. "Let me just save your breath, Beverly, I am not fine. I feel broken all inside like...like every piece of me is shattered into pieces...and there's no way of putting it all back together."
Beverly swam towards Will and sat down next to him, wrapping an arm around his shoulder. "I know it's hard right now, Will. We all understand that..."
"It's...it's so much more than that what you're thinking..." Will hung his head as he began sobbing.
Beverly pulled him close as her friend began crying. It was hard seeing her friend in such a state. No one wanted to upset Will so when he said he needed to be alone they left him alone.
They all wished there was something they could do.
Beverly glanced at Will and stared at his hands where she could see he was holding something. Was it one of his human objects gifted by Hannibal? When Will's hand moved, she saw a little bottle of glowing blue liquid.
Alana had told them all. It was the potion that would have turned Hannibal into a mer.
It would make sense for seeing the bottle would make Will cry. If he had rejected Will, the bottle would only be a reminder to him that Hannibal did not want to be a part of his world.
"Will, I think you should let this go." Beverly advised, bringing her hand to Will's, hoping he would loosen his grip on the bottle.
Will cried a bit harder. "You don't get it, Beverly..."
Beverly tilted her head. "What do you mean, Will?"
"I couldn't make him choose..." Will sniffled, looking down at the bottle. "I love him with all my heart...making him choose would make me look bad. It'd break his heart..."
Beverly pieced everything together. "You didn't tell him. Will, you should have! He needed to know. He deserved to know he could have had a life with you. As a mer."
Will shook his head. "He loves his life up there. He has so much. He has his family there too...why would I make him choose between that and me?"
"Because you're an amazing mer, Will. He would be lucky to have you. He didn't even know he could have had you in a different situation." Will glanced at her but then looked away. She removed her arms and placed her hands on his arms to make him look at her. "Will, you sacrificed everything for him. You'd do it again without hesitation too. I think there's a possibility he would have done the same too."
"I'm scared, Beverly...I also didn't tell him because I was worried he'd reject the offer...at least he'd get to stay up there with his family and not have to decide..." Will had thought it would have been less painful, but nothing had been painless since he returned home.
"If he truly loves you, Will, he will decide to be with you." Beverly promised. She pulled Will into a hug as her friend began crying again.
Something needed to be done.
🐚 Hannigram 🐚
"I thank you, my Queens, for giving me the chance to be Magic Keeper." Katherine said as she bowed her head at Margot and Alana.
Margot smiled at the older mermaid. "Of course, Katherine. Don't give us reason to take the title away, but Alana and I think it'll be fine."
Katherine smiled at the queens before swimming down the hall to where her room was.
Margot and Alana were not expecting anyone else to come into the room, but then Beverly came swimming quickly into the room. This was most definitely unexpected.
"Beverly?" Margot called out.
Beverly moved a strand from her face. "It's about Will."
Alana rose from her throne, seconds away from swimming to Jack and Bella's. "What's wrong? Is he okay?"
Beverly simply raised her arm to show the little bottle in her hand. "This is potion that was supposed to make Hannibal into a merman, right?"
Alana nodded. "Yes. However, he rejected the offer. Will come back in tears and since Hannibal was not with him..."
"To be rejected by someone you love. I can't even imagine the pain Will must be enduring." Margot said sympathetically.
Beverly chimed in. "That's just it. Will didn't give Hannibal the option. He didn't let him know of the potion's existence."
"What?" Alana was not expecting that.
Margot looked at Alana and then at Beverly. "Why didn't he tell Hannibal?"
"Will didn't want him to choose between the life he had on land and a life with him. He was also afraid of Hannibal rejecting him too. Not telling him made things easier apparently." Beverly explained.
Alana sat back down on her throne, releasing a deep sigh. "Here we all thought he had been rejected..."
"It's not like he told us. It was wrong of us to assume." Margot said to her wife.
Beverly looked at the queens. "So...what now?"
"Hannibal didn't even know that there was another way he could be with Will. It's up to him in the end. He will have to let go of the life he has now in order to be with Will." Alana said.
Margot turned to her wife. "What do you think he'd decide?"
Alana got out of her throne and extended her hand for Beverly to give her the bottle. "Only one way of finding out."
