Chapter Text
Will never knew how long that trip took him. Weeks.
He did everything he could think of, during those long however-many weeks, to prevent himself from thinking. He kept a constant stream of subspace chatter playing, a substitute for the constant psychic background noise on Daphne IV, and he took meds to keep himself awake for as long as he could – the sleep deprivation blurred out the higher-level brain functions that he might otherwise use to logic himself out of this. And after the meds wore off and he was too exhausted to keep going, he only let himself sleep with tranqs, so that he wouldn't dream. Hannibal could find him there, where they dreamed. He might be able to keep him, if he found him. Then they could...
No. No, no, don't think, if you try to think you might let him think for you, don't think, just go –
His back and shoulders were permanently knotted, and his jaw was permanently sore from clenching. And the pain from his broken ribs was still there – he hadn’t healed them. They were the price he’d paid for letting that man live. He used the pain from them as an anchor tying him to himself, a constant reminder that for now he was still in control.
Besides, he didn’t want to do any more doctoring than he absolutely had to. He had to repress every scrap and shred of everything Hannibal knew.
Don't even think about him. Don't think at all . Hannibal's dead.
No. He isn’t.
Will knew that he didn’t have to do what he was doing now. He didn’t even want to do it. He wanted to land the shuttle someplace nice and uninhabited and fix his broken ribs and sleep for about twenty hours, and then he wanted to think about all of the different lives he could have now, and then he wanted to go off and live them.
He smothered those thoughts under the pain in his body and the voices from the comm, and he followed the trail of hints from subspace until he found what he was looking for.
Aside from the soft beeping of instrument panels and the occasional whirr of a door, the bridge of the Chesapeake was still and quiet. Jack sat at the ready in the captain’s chair, but there was no real reason for him to be there. They hadn’t seen anything of note for the past ten days. They had been on light patrol duty near the galactic rim, ever since…
Well, it was generally felt by Starfleet brass that the crew of the Chesapeake would benefit from a few low-stress missions, considering.
Jack was considering getting up and leaving when Lieutenant Commander Katz looked up from the bridge’s Security console and said, “Captain, there’s a shuttle approaching us.”
The Lieutenant Commander had had a few decidedly un-Vulcan words to say about their most recent assignment. She had taken it, perhaps correctly, as a punishment for Jack rather than a kindness towards the crew. Now Jack could hear in her voice a hint of inappropriate excitement that something was finally happening.
Jack glanced over his shoulder at her from the captain’s chair. “Status?”
Her fingers tapped across the surface of the console. “Looks like Ferengi tech. It seems fully operational. There are two life signs aboard, but they're relatively weak. They may need medical assistance.”
“No distress beacon?”
“None. Possibly their transmitters are knocked out.”
Lieutenant Lass turned from her station at Comms. “No,” she said, “the transmitters are working. The shuttle is hailing us.”
“On screen,” Jack said. Lass keyed in the code, and the viewscreen flickered to life.
There was silence on the bridge again.
White and trembling and damp all over with sweat, thin and frail and clutching his side and leaning his full weight on the shuttle console, was the man who had once been Lieutenant Will Graham. He stared at them through the viewscreen. He looked as if he were trying to breathe or speak.
Someone whispered “Captain...” Jack held up a hand.
Will took a long, shallow breath.
“I surrender,” he said. “Arrest me.”
Security evacuated a wing of Sickbay and threw three layers of force fields up around it before beaming Will in, and Medical called up the ship’s Emergency Medical Hologram rather than risk any crewmen on treating him. But it was hardly necessary. Will passed out seconds after he rematerialized aboard – more from simple exhaustion than anything else, the EMH said. It was almost three days before he was conscious again.
And for those three days, between endless calls with Starfleet and the Trill Symbiosis Commission and meetings with Beverly regarding the increased security arrangements, Jack spent his spare time wondering if there was any possible way that this was not a trick or a trap.
Everything he had learned in the previous months told him that it must be. He knew that the person lying unconscious in Sickbay was not Will Graham, because Will Graham had ceased to exist when the Ripper had been placed inside him. And he knew what the Ripper was – he had studied its history in sickening detail after Will had run, and what he had read told him that the Ripper would never voluntarily give up his freedom.
A trap, then. That was what Starfleet thought, what the Commission thought. What Beverly thought. It was what Jack thought, too, in his logical mind.
And yet Jack had seen Will’s face when he had surrendered, and he couldn’t abandon a tiny, irrational scrap of hope.
Fight him. Those were the last words Jack had said to Will, after watching him open up his crewmate’s throat. And now Will had come back...
Jack knew it was a foolish thing to hope for.
A musical note chimed in Jack’s quarters. It would have woken him up, if he had been capable of falling asleep that night.
“What is it?” Jack asked.
“Captain,” said Beverly, “the prisoner is awake.”
Jack swung himself out of bed. “Has he been moved?”
“He was transported directly to the brig as soon as he regained consciousness. Captain, regarding-”
“I’m aware of your objections, Lieutenant Commander, but I assure you that I will not allow my feelings about this situation to influence my thinking when I speak with him.”
“I would never presume to suggest such a thing,” she said. “Just take care, that’s all.”
“I will,” Jack said. “Tell the brig that I’m on my way. Crawford out.”
Jack changed into a clean uniform and left his quarters. He tried not to think about whether Will could feel him coming. He arrived at the door to the brig and walked in without hesitating.
There he was. Him, and five guards. Will stood alone in his empty cell. He was moving his hand in slow patterns millimeters away from the force field, watching the energy crackle and glow under his fingers, risking a painful shock if he were to make contact.
Before Will glanced up at him, Jack saw his face in profile, and he noticed with a jolt that Will’s trails of Trill markings were gone. Other than that, he looked exactly the same as he had looked before. It reminded Jack of a child’s puzzle. What’s different about this picture?
“Hi, Jack,” Will said.
There was no sensible way to open a conversation like this.
“Hello, Will,” Jack said. “You look better.”
Will smiled. It was Will Graham’s smile. How could this man not be him?
“I feel better,” he said.
“I'm... pleased to see that you're safe.”
Will laughed. “You mean you’re pleased to see me safely locked up in here where I belong?”
He sounded almost cheerful. Jack was totally at a loss. He grasped for something else to say. “I hope the crew’s emotions aren’t causing you too much distress,” he said. “I'm sorry we can't put you somewhere more tolerable.”
“Don't worry about it,” Will said. “I've gotten a lot better at dealing with that. Hannibal taught me.”
Jack kept his face perfectly still, but he couldn’t quite repress the anger that flashed across his mind when he heard that name.
“Still holding a grudge?” Will asked. “Can’t say I blame you. He really was a world-class bastard, wasn’t he?”
“Yes,” said Jack.
Will laughed again. He was still running his hand along the force field, watching the crackling light as it danced underneath his hand. Thus far, this was not a productive conversation.
“Will,” Jack said, “I know that you have been through a terrible ordeal. I need to ask you some questions about your, ah, experience, so that we can determine whether-”
Will stilled his hand and fixed his eyes on Jack. Jack had forgotten how unsettling those eyes could be, when Will wanted them to be. Velvety black, like the space between the stars. They seemed not to reflect the lights of his cell anymore.
That was when Jack was sure that this was not Will Graham.
“Will,” he said quietly. “Why did you come back here?”
“To surrender,” Will said.
To surrender. And suddenly Jack was horribly aware of what he meant by that. Will had dragged himself all the way back here in order to let himself lose. To let himself become this thing.
Jack had hardly ever felt less in control of his emotions. He buried them as quickly as he felt them – grief for what had been done to Will, guilt for the part he had played in it, hatred for the Ripper –
“Have something you want to say to him? He's right here, Jack. He's me.”
“I don't accept that,” Jack said.
“Neither did I,” said Will. “Still true.” He hesitated then – he wasn’t smiling anymore. He looked almost...
“You knew, before,” he said. “Right after I was joined. You knew something. You should have had them put up a force field around sickbay before I woke up.”
No. I should have had that thing ripped out of your body. “Believe me,” Jack said, “I have been telling myself that every day since the day this happened to you.”
“It didn't happen to me,” Will said. “I did it.”
There was nothing Jack could think of to say after that. Will waited for a few moments to see if he would speak. Then he said, “You hate me, Jack. That’s one thing I regret. I always thought of you as a friend.”
This was intolerable. “I'm still your friend, Will.”
That familiar smile crept onto Will’s face again.
“You shouldn't be,” he said.
Enough. “Goodbye, Will,” Jack said. He turned away from the force field and headed for the exit door.
“Hey, I almost forgot,” Will said, as the brig doors slid open for Jack. “Sorry about that guard I killed.”
Jack couldn’t bring himself to turn around and look at him again. He stepped through the doors and let them glide shut behind him.
After they dimmed the lights in the brig, Will didn’t try to sleep. He didn’t think he’d be able to. It didn’t quite feel right yet to feel safe and still, for there to be nothing left for him to strain against. So he just sat on his bunk and curled up into himself like a broken harp string, and tried to let himself feel what it felt like to simply exist.
It didn’t feel anything like he’d been afraid it would feel. It was almost anticlimactic.
He had thought he would be furious, locked up in here. As furious as he had been down on the planet. Like a wild animal hurling itself against the bars of a cage. But he couldn’t remember the last time he had felt so free.
It was like he had spent his whole life flying through an endless murky nebula, and then he’d finally broken through the edge and seen the stars.
He didn’t feel like a different person than he had been before. He still felt like Will. But there were things that were different. There were things he understood now that he had never been able to understand before.
When he had first met Will Graham, before he had become him, he had thought that Will was delicate, vulnerable. Malleable. And he had thought so as Will Graham, too – had spent most of his life hiding away, with no one but Vulcans for company, for fear of being overwritten and destroyed.
They had both been so wrong.
He had learned so much about himself over those months on Daphne IV, things neither of him had ever suspected. His strength of will, his resilience, his bravery and endurance. The beauty and power of his gift.
Back there on the planet, his efforts had felt so pointless. But now that he could see himself more clearly, he understood the magnitude of what he’d done. He had made the Ripper struggle and suffer more than it had ever suffered in its life, and he had known that he was going to feel every ounce of that suffering himself, and he had known that it would make no difference in the end, and he had done it anyway.
Will was the most powerful person he had ever been.
He didn’t feel at all like he had lost. He felt as if he had taken the parts of himself that he had struggled so hard against and feared so much, and had placed them completely under his control.
And he knew that this feeling was exactly what losing would have meant to him, back before he had won.
