Chapter Text
One day, Thorin woke and decided it was time to look for adventure. He called his band to him and told them, “For a fortnight we have had no adventure and it has become boring. I am going to go looking for an adventure. If you hear me call, or blow three blasts upon my hunting horn, then hurry to where I am.” The others agreed, so he set out to find an adventure.
He passed a milkmaid, a messenger, and a farmer, all headed towards the town, but no adventure. He followed his path into the forest. The path crossed a river, which was spanned by a log bridge, wide enough for one man to cross at a time. As Thorin approached the bridge, a stranger also neared it from the opposite side. Thorin sped up, intending to cross first, only to notice that the stranger had obviously had the same idea. They reached the bridge at the same time.
“Stand back and let the better man cross first,” Thorin called.
“Stand back yerself,” the stranger growled, “Because I wager I’m the better man.”
“We’ll see about that,” Thorin said, snorting. “Now stay where you are, or by Mahal I’ll have an arrow between your ribs before you can blink.”
“And I’ll beat ya black n’ blue if ye think of touchin’ that bowstring,” the stranger said, twirling his staff.
“You are a fool,” Thorin said, chuckling. “I could send this arrow clean through your boasting heart before you could finish saying your prayers to the Maker.”
“And ye are a coward,” the stranger returned. “For ye have yer bow, while I have only my blackthorn staff to defend myself.”
“I have never been called a coward,” Thorin snarled. “I will lay down my bow and arrows and cut a cudgel with which I will test your mettle. Agreed?”
“Agreed,” the stranger said, leaning on his staff while Thorin went to cut himself a cudgel.
Thorin watched the stranger while he cut and trimmed his staff, taking in that the other. Thorin, tall though he was, stood at least a head shorter than the other, and while Thorin’s shoulders were broad, the stranger’s were broader.
Nevertheless, Thorin thought, finishing up, I’ll tan his hide and show him what it means to call Thorin Oakenshield a coward. Out loud, he said, “Now, I have my staff, meet me in the middle of the bridge and we will settle this. We will fight until one of us manages to knock the other into the stream.”
“Alright,” the stranger agreed, stepping forward and twirling his staff.
The two fought greatly, giving and receiving blows that would have felled lesser men and parrying others. Each struck, parried, and struck again. They fought for an hour, neither able to land a winning blow and unwilling to yield. Once or twice they stopped to rest, and both thought that they had never seen a better opponent.
Finally, Thorin gave the stranger a blow to the ribs that came within an inch of tumbling the other man off the bridge. The stranger, however, righted himself quickly and gave Thorin a blow to the head, hard enough to make his head spin. Thorin was angry, and he attacked again and again, but the stranger blocked every blow. He gave Thorin another hard whack, and Thorin lost his balance and fell head over heels into the river.
“And where are you now lad?” the stranger laughed, leaning on his staff once more.
“Oh, in the river and flowing out with the tide,” Thorin said wryly, laughing at his predicament. He got to his feet and waded out of the stream, fish swimming away from the disturbance.
“I must admit you are a brave man, and a sturdy one too,” said Thorin, shaking the stranger’s hand. He then raised his hunting horn to his lips and blew three times, calling his band to him. “There isn’t a man in Arda who would be able to do that to me.”
“And ye take a beating like a strong man,” the stranger returned.
Seconds later, Thorin’s band of followers burst into the clearing, all dressed in Lincoln green.
“Thorin, what happened to you?” Bofur asked, eying their sopping wet leader. “You’re soaked.”
“That fellow over there knocked me into the stream, and gave me a beating besides,” Thorin said dryly.
“Then we’ll do the same to him,” cried little Bilbo Baggins, and the men charged the stranger, only stopping when Thorin called for them to halt.
“He’s a good man,” Thorin said, walking to the head of the Company and looking at the stranger. “Would you consider joining my Company? You shall have clothes of Lincoln green and a fair wage, part of everything we earn. We eat sweet venison and drink the stoutest ale, and you would be my right hand man. What do you say?”
The stranger shrugged. “If you are no better with your bow and arrows than you are with a staff, I’ll pass. However, if any of you beat me, I will join your company.”
“Very well,” Thorin said, rolling his eyes at the other man’s cheek. “Bifur, cut a target, four fingers across and set it twenty yards away. Now stranger, choose a bow and hit the mark.”
The stranger chose the sturdiest bow of the lot (beside Thorin’s), taking the arrow offered by Gloin and moving to the mark, saying, “If I don’t hit the mark, I give you permission to beat me black and blue with the bowstring.” So saying, he let the arrow fly, and it hit the target in the very center. “Beat that if ye can.”
The Company clapped, because it was a good shot, and then Thorin stepped up to the mark. “That is a good shot,” Thorin admitted, drawing an arrow from his quiver. “I doubt I can beat it, but perhaps I can match it.” He let the arrow fly, splitting Dwalin’s arrow to splinters. All of his Company jumped up and cheered that their leader had shot so well.
“By Mahal’s halls,” the stranger said, wide-eyed, “I have never seen a better shot in my life, and I have seen Bard of Dale shoot. He was a fair shot, but ye have him beat. I am yer man from here on out.”
“I’ve gained a good man today then,” Thorin said, smiling. “Now, what is your name.”
“Dwalin,” the stranger replied, “Son of Fundin, at yer service.”
