Actions

Work Header

A Thief in Erebor

Chapter 8: Regret and Redemption

Chapter Text

There were a lot of words that could describe Kili, son of Dis. He was wild and reckless, stout and heroic but there were several that it would be a stretch to use. He wasn't contemplative or pensive, foresighted or prudent and above all he wasn't prone to regret. He lived in the moment without a care as to how his actions would affect others. The only exception to this rule was Fili, he usually put Fili's feelings first and if something would hurt or anger Fili he'd give it a second thought. The only times he actively went against these instincts were to protect Fili from something that would hurt him in the long run. That was why he had schemed and plotted to remove the thief from his brother's life, what he didn't know was that in the process he'd be ruining his brother's life and the lives of many others that were dear to him. For the first time in his life Kili felt bitter, painful regret and knew there was only one way to bring the people he loved their happiness once more and that was to find the thief, bring her back and face the consequences for his thoughtless actions.

…

"Why won't you help me? I know you cared about her." Kili pleaded with Nori as the recently appointed head spymaster sat in his seat in the dining hall.

"I told you, I don't know why you're searching for the lass and I don't trust you. You were all too pleased with her apparent thievery and went out of your way to ensure that your brother would abandon her. I see no reason to aid you in further destroying an innocent lass's life." Nori explained as he took a bite of his roll and Kili sighed.

"If I tell you something do you promise to keep it between us until I'm ready to tell the others?" Kili asked and Nori nodded, already having a theory as to what the young dwarf would be confessing.

"I know Lor was innocent, I know it for a fact and I have the proof needed to clear her name. I want to bring her home so she can be reunited with Fili and Dori and attempt to get the life back that was cruelly taken from her. Believe me when I say there is no mischief in my heart in this matter, only love for my brother and pain brought on by his suffering." Kili swore with his hand on his heart and Nori felt a simmering anger rest in his heart. He knew the prince was behind what happened, months of conducting his own private investigation had led in that direction and now the proof was sitting in front of him. He wanted to throttle Kili but he knew doing so without evidence would be his own death sentence and he'd be no good to Lor or Dori dead and Lor would have no hope with the princeling gone.

"I know where she is but I will not take her to you until the truth comes out. I will not give her hope only to have you turn on her once again. She deserves better than that." Nori told him and Kili nodded.

"I agree, she didn't deserve what was done to her and I see it now. She truly had changed and she loved my brother dearly. I was so caught up in hating her for stealing my bow that it blinded me to who and what she really was. I'll never be able to make up for what happened but I want the chance to make things right. Can you help me do that?" Kili asked as Nori thought for a moment as he looked in Kili's eyes for any sign of deceit. Finding only sincerity and regret in his features Nori nodded and picked up another roll as he gave the young prince a steady look that made him squirm.

"Be up and ready to go at dawn, have a pony and supplies. You'll be traveling with me and Dori and if anyone asks you where you're going come up with a likely story. I can't do everything for you. Now I think you should be going...your highness..." Nori dismissed Kili coldly and Kili knew without a doubt that he'd lost a friend he'd held dear and couldn't even blame Nori, he deserved his disdain. Regardless he nodded in the affirmative and got up. He had a lot to do and a short time to do it in but he'd do whatever it took to make things right.

…

Kili yawned widely as he led his pony Honeycomb down the path behind Dori and Nori. When he'd shown up that morning he'd received a cold reception from the two eldest of the Brothers 'Ri but after explaining his motives for going with Dori the elder dwarf simply nodded his acceptance and allowed Kili to journey with them. That had been the last acknowledgement he'd been given from either of them and he felt alone for the first time since he was small. Even so he soldiered on and followed the brothers as they left the main road and followed one of the lesser used routes that led to the edge of Mirkwood forest. As they neared the edge he sped up so he was riding beside Nori.

"Why are we going into Mirkwood? Thranduil won't like us going in unannounced." Kili fretted and Nori chuckled as he kept his pony at a trot and he looked at Kili.

"Ol' King Pointy Ears knows we're coming. We've been given leave once a month to enter his forest on our errand. You'll see when we get there." Nori told him, exhibiting the first bit of warmth that he'd shown all morning. Not wanting to upset this new kindness Kili shut his mouth and rode along.

They continued to ride deeper into the forest and as the world darkened around them in the thickness of the trees, Kili was startled by an arrow whizzing past his head and hitting the ground behind him. Moving quickly he took out his bow and was about to knock an arrow when Nori stayed his hand and used his free one to whistle loudly and shrilly. The whistle was returned and suddenly three tall figures leapt from the trees and stood in front of their stopped ponies.

"Greetings and well-met Nori and Dori of Erebor. Who is this that you wish to bring into our home unannounced?" The elf in front of them asked and Kili took in his appearance. He was shorter and stockier than most elves he'd seen and it appeared that he was quite hairy, most surprising was the short beard and stubble on his face. If Kili hadn't known better he would have assumed that the elf was part dwarf.

"Greetings and well met Glir son of Glis. This is his majesty, Prince Kili, he is here to speak with Lor and beg her forgiveness." Nori told the elf who frowned and continued to just look at Kili before one of the elves behind him raised his bow and walked forward, glaring at Kili.

"I should kill you where you stand, for hurting her so!" He shouted in anger and Glir put a hand on his shoulder.

"Easy Kir, perhaps it would do our little dear some good to see this slime debase himself before her. She deserves no less from this cruel and worthless creature." Glir spoke calmly as he placated the angry elf who lowered his bow and nodded once. "Come, Mother is preparing breakfast. Seeing you might give our little dear a bit of peace."

With that he turned and blended into the forest followed by the silent elf then, with one last glare, Kir followed and Kili felt at ease when the other melted into the trees. He was so relieved that he almost missed Dori and Nori entering the thick of the forest and had to rush Honeycomb along after them. They rode in silence for a short while before the woods suddenly opened up and they were suddenly riding into a wide, open encampment. Kili could only stare as he saw elves and dwarves mingling together as they shared campfires and laughed with one another. He even saw a tall elf male lean down to kiss an elderly dwarf woman gently on the lips, the look in their eyes as they parted one of pure love and adoration. It all struck him as insane and when he looked over at Dori and Nori, he noticed them watching him.

"Welcome to the lands of the unclaimed young prince." Nori said solemnly then he dismounted. Dori quickly dismounted as well and they walked their ponies to a post and tied them while Kili got his bearings and followed suit.

"What is this place?" He asked loudly as he tied Honeycomb with the other ponies and Dori turned to answer but he was saved by another voice coming up to them.

"It is a home to thieves, beggars, outcasts and bastards. No one here had a home so we've made one." At the sound of her voice Kili turned and he almost wept with joy as he saw Lor standing before him. She looked well with color in her cheeks and eyes bright with life once more. Even better was the sight of her sideburns, not as splendid as they once were but plentiful nonetheless and she had the start of what promised to be an impressive beard. She smiled as she saw Kili. "Greetings and well met Prince Kili. I take it you are well?"

At her question and tone Kili was dumbstruck. He had expected hate and venom to roll off her tongue but instead she seemed genuinely pleased to see him and cared about his well-being. He was about to say something when the angry elf from the forest came up beside Lor and placed a hand on her shoulder and squeezed it affectionately.

"Is this orc shagger bothering you?" Kir asked and Lor reached up and patted his hand before she shook her head.

"Not at all. Can you take Papa and Uncle Nori to Mama Glis and get them some food? I was banned from the kitchen again." She told the elf who chuckled before he leaned down and kissed her gently.

"As my lady wishes." He said softly before he looked at Dori and Nori and gave a sharp jerk of his head toward the heart of the encampment. As Dori walked by Kili he put his hand on the prince's shoulder before he stopped in front of Lor and hugged her, then Nori followed suit and did the same. Once they were gone Lor looked at Kili who was livid.

"Such anger in you princeling. Here, I thought I had the right to be angry with you." She said as she smiled condescendingly and Kili growled.

"You whore! How could you do that to Fili? You owe him your fidelity." He asked and Lor let out an unexpected bark of laughter.

"Oh, dear princeling, I owe nothing to Fili any longer. He abandoned me without a second thought after they found that box. He didn't even give me a chance to explain myself to clear my name. Then when I pleaded with the king to end my suffering Fili begged him to keep me alive and prolong my torture, all for his own selfish reasons." She told him and Kili's rage dissipated somewhat, what she said was true, but what she didn't know was that he was the reason Fili turned his back on her. If he hadn't browbeat his brother with the "evidence" then Fili would have fought tirelessly to free her but he trusted his little brother a little too much.

"He still loves you, he's remained faithful to you." Kili told her and she looked at him sadly.

"I admit, I do sometimes feel as though I am betraying Fili and that breaks my heart but I owe so much to Kir. When I arrived here I was so lonely, so heartbroken that I had given up on life, I had started to fade. Kir gave me a reason to wake up in the mornings, a reason to keep going. He loved me and I owe it to him to love him as much as I am able. Please understand that Kili, I owe Kir a life debt and all he wants as repayment is my affection." Lor explained and Kili's eyes filled with pain and as he spoke his voice broke and shook.

"He saved you but you're the only one who can save Fili. He's dying Lor, he's fading and only you can save him." Kili spoke as his emotions broke him. He cried into his hands as Lor stood, rooted to the spot. Her Fili was dying? No, she would have felt that, she was certain she would have. In that moment a veil parted and suddenly she was on her knees, the pain too much to bear. Kili was at her side in an instant and she gripped onto his shoulder for support. She remembered this pain and it killed her to think that Fili was feeling it too.

"How much longer?" Lor suddenly asked and Kili swallowed before he spoke to her.

"Oin says that Fili only has a few months, if that. No one knows other than myself, Uncle Thorin, Uncle Bilbo and Mother. We can't let anyone know." Kili spoke in a pained voice and Lor nodded.

"I need to make arrangements, no matter how hurt I am by what happened and his lack of faith in me I can't let him die. I will leave here and arrive in Erebor with an escort by day's end in three day's time. I won't abandon Fili like he abandoned me." Lor spoke as she rose and shook herself in an effort to get back to normal. "Come, meet Mother Glis and Father Caranthir, they will feed you and tell you of the founding of this place. Then we can discuss my departure."

Kili nodded and followed Lor to the large fire pit in the center of the encampment where the elderly dwarf woman was seated with the elf who had kissed her so lovingly earlier. Theirs was a story Kili wanted to hear at some point but for now he was focused on returning to Erebor to help his brother, he had already been away from him for far too long.

…

Three days had passed at a torturously slow pace for Kili as he awaited Lor's arrival. He had put all of his faith in her ability to save his brother and he wanted the saving done as quickly as it could be. He didn't even care that he ran a very real risk of being exiled, all that mattered was Fili's life and if telling everyone the truth and bringing Lor back into their lives would make Fili well again he'd do it a thousand times. Is brother was far more important to him than any risk he was about to take. He was jolted out of his thoughts by a knock on his door and quickly walked to it and flung it opened, relieved when he saw Nori there.

"Lor has ridden up to the side entrance with Kir. Dori is meeting them, what do you wish to do?" Nori asked the prince who was almost overwhelmed with relief.

"Bring her here and wait until I'm ready to collect her but send Dori to the meeting hall next to the royal chambers. I have a confession to make and I want him there." Kili explained and Nori nodded before he placed a hand on the prince's shoulder.

"I'm still angry with you for what was done and my trust in you has vanished but I respect your decision to come clean and support you. If things go badly you have my protection for as much as it's worth." Nori said solemnly and Kili nodded in thanks before the former thief left to bring the others to his rooms. Taking a deep breath, he left his rooms and set about collecting the others, he had a lot of explaining to do and he wanted it over and done with as soon as possible.

…

Bilbo sat at Thorin's side and slid his hand into the King's larger one to offer a bit of comfort. Ever since Fili's condition had worsened the King had been working tirelessly to find a way to save the lad. He'd contact healers from different corners of Middle Earth and had even allowed Legolas and his brother Gilen to come and see if they could help. Unfortunately they all had the same suggestion for curing the Prince and that was to reunite him with his One. The diagnoses had only succeeded in causing the King further pain because even if he were to reverse his decision and allow the thief back in Erebor they had no idea where she was or if she was even alive. None of Nori's spies had news of her or whispers from other lands that pointed to her living still and it brought fear to Thorin's heart and added to the sorrow that weighed on his bones. Not that it was less painful for Bilbo but Bilbo took his role as husband and consort to the King Under the Mountain seriously and did his best to remain strong and steadfast for his love and the family that surrounded them. Which is why when Kili called this meeting he had roused Thorin from Fili's rooms and forced him to sit at his side, knowing it would do the King good to see his nephew and the rest of the family, especially the eldest Brothers 'Ri who had all but stopped speaking to the King in their heartbreak. As he squeezed Thorin's hand he took note of the solemn group and hoped that whatever news Kili had was good, they so needed something good at this time. At that moment Kili walked into the room as if he'd been summoned, followed by Dori who stood proud and straight, the light of confidence and unmasked joy in his eyes and Bilbo suddenly sat straighter as well. If Dori was happy then the news had to be good.

"Hello, everyone, I know you're all busy and that you have a lot that is weighing on your minds but I thank you for coming to this meeting. As you all know I have been tirelessly trying to find a way to save my brother. He is...everything... to me and the thought of him fading... I just couldn't live with the thought of him leaving my side so I decided to find Lor and make things right." Kili spoke confidently and Thorin sat up suddenly while Dis gasped and covered her mouth.

"She is a traitor to the throne. I love Fili, I always have but to bring her back would be an act of treason." Dwalin spoke up and Thorin raised a hand to silence him as he looked at Kili with hopeful eyes.

"Did you find her? Could we bring Fili to her?" Thorin asked, the raw hope in his voice almost painful to hear and Kili nodded.

"Yes, I found her but before we discuss the best way to cure Fili I have something to tell you that will change the entire situation and will change how many of you feel about me but you must know the truth." Kili said in an attempt to calm them down and Thorin motioned for him to continue and Kili did after he took a deep breath to steady himself. "Lor is innocent of the crimes she's been sentenced into exile for. She never stole the chain or any of the items recovered from her room. I was the one who arranged for one of the seamstresses to steal the items and bring them to me in exchange for gold and a night in my bed. As for the chain...I found a thief who was a member of a guild in the Iron Hills, she arrived with a caravan and I caught her lifting a heavy purse from the pocket of a dwarf one day. She had quick fingers and was light on her feet. For a large fee she conducted the theft and framed Lor for the crime. She also stole Bilbo's watch one day upon my orders. All of Lor's protestations of innocence were true, she did no wrong."

Once Kili finished his confession the room was silent, save for Dis who was sobbing openly, hurt deeply from her son's betrayal. Thorin stayed seated but removed his hand from Bilbo's for fear of crushing it and gripped the arms of his seat painfully. Dwalin grew red with rage and more than a bit of shame but he held himself still, knowing that if he moved he would inflict harm upon the Prince and he had sworn an oath to protect the little prick with his life. The rest took deep breaths and attempted to compose themselves but Bilbo suddenly stood up and advanced upon Kili, his anger and disappointment clear in his every step toward the young prince.

"I cannot believe you!" Bilbo shouted in a very un-hobbity voice as he poked Kili in the chest. "You selfish, immature, stupid dwarf. That poor lass trusted you and loved you like a brother and you almost had her sentenced for death because of your selfishness and stupidity. You've also condemned your brother to hopelessness and eventual death and performed treason and for what goal? To keep your brother to yourself? To punish a loving, kind and generous girl for taking your bow? This is beyond foolish and the depth of your betrayal is baffling. You deserve a punishment, something severe for all of the pain you have wrought upon this family but Fili comes first. We heal him, then we see about you."

Kili nodded and bowed his head in shame as Bilbo walked back to his seat beside Thorin and sat, his anger still thrumming through him and Thorin took his hand and held it as he looked at Kili.

"I could not have said it better than my mate has. Kili you are a disappointment and a disgrace, not fit to sit on the throne of Erebor. By all rights we should strip you of your wealth, your title, your hair and perhaps your life and in time we will see you pay for your crimes against Lor and for betraying your brother. For now we will put these punishments on hold until Fili is well because, regardless of your betrayal he still needs you to recover and will remain ignorant of your part in this until we get Lor back and in his arms and he recovers from the pain you brought upon him. Will you bring her to us?" Thorin asked and Kili nodded as tears dripped off the end of his nose and he took a deep breath before he spoke.

"I'll do one better. I'll bring you to her, she's waiting in my rooms." Kili said softly and the rest wasted no time as they stood and walked out of the room, the only two that remained were Kili and his mother. When Dis walked up to him he looked in her eyes and gasped in shock as her hand came in contact with his cheek and she glared angrily.

"Your selfishness and thoughtlessness almost cost your brother his life and have cost you all trust and pride I ever had in you. I have never been so ashamed." With that final admonishment Dis turned and stormed out of the room while remained and Kili sobbed into his hands.

…

Lor sat on a seat in Kili's sitting room feeling nervous but determined. Even if they kicked her out of Erebor or took her head she'd welcome it, as long as they let her see Fili first and give him what he needed to go on. Kir stood at the window of the room, brooding as he looked over the expanse of land before him. He knew one day he'd lose Lor because of the faithless Prince but he had hoped that it would not be for many years and that he could give her a reason to stay with him. Now he was going to lose her but he could console himself with the fact that, though she would be gone from his life, she would live on and be truly happy for all he wanted was her happiness and health. When the door opened Kir moved from the window and stood behind Lor as she rose and placed his hands on her shoulders while Nori stood off to the side but still between Lor and those who entered. When Kir saw the great dwarf king enter he tensed his hands on Lor's shoulders in an attempt to rein in his temper, he would do her no good if he were struck down by the royal guard.

"Miss Firebrand, I cannot tell you how deeply I regret the ill that befell you and mistreatment at my hands. I will spend the rest of my days attempting to make amends for what was done to you." Dwalin spoke with such sorrow and regret that when he knelt before Lor and bowed his head in apology she placed her hand atop his head.

"I understand why you did what you did Mister Dwalin. It is my hope that you learn from this experience and listen more closely when others claim to be innocent. I also hope that, should I stay in Erebor, you will treat me with more respect and trust that I am a changed dwarf. All I want right now is to help Fili, nothing else matters." Lor spoke softly and Dwalin rose with a nod, he would definitely treat her with respect in the future. By taking her punishment without a cry despite her innocence she had earned his respect.

"I hope you decide to stay in Erebor, Miss Firebrand, for we intend to welcome you with open arms." Bilbo spoke from his place beside Thorin and walked up to the young dwarf and took her larger hand in both of his. "I know we have no right to make demands or requests of you but it is my wish that you will remain and help bring Fili back to us. His health in both his mind and body are flagging and you are the only one who can offer him solace and a cure. Please say you will help."

"Why do you think I am here Mister Baggins. Kili sought me out and explained everything, there was no way I could stand by and let Fili die when I could save him. Despite everything I still love him and I would rather die than watch him fade." Lor told him kindly and Bilbo closed his eyes in relief.

"Then let us waste no time in bringing her to him." Thorin finally spoke and Lor nodded as she moved from under Kir's hands and walked up to the King who placed his hand on her head as she lowered her eyes. "I Thorin son of Thrain, son of Thror, rescind your banishment and grant you the status and title of Lady Lor Firebrand of the newly reinstated Clan Firebrand. May Mahal bless you and keep you in his hand."

At Thorin's blessing the tears that had threatened since Dwalin's apology fell and he placed his fingers under her chin and raised her face until her eyes met his. Once they did he brought his forehead to hers and knocked it together lightly and the tenderness in the gesture caused her heart to go to her throat but she simply smiled a watery smile then followed him out of the room when he turned on his heel and remained silent as they continued down the hallways until they reached the familiar rooms. Thorin knocked twice and the door was opened by Oin who took one look at Lor and quickly grabbed her and brought her into the room. The second her eyes adjusted to the darkness of the room she scanned it and gasped as she say Fili on the bed, pale and in obvious pain. With no thought other than stopping his pain Lor wrenched herself out of Oin's grip and ran to the bed where she climbed in gently and ran her fingertips along Fili's jaw and almost jumped out of her skin when the gentle touch startled him awake.

"Lor..." He moaned softly as he opened his eyes and looked at her. "I must be dreaming you're here, or you're a spirit and are here to take me with you."

"I am no spirit my love. It's truly me, in the flesh. Kili found me and cleared my name so I'm free to be here, with you." She said softly and Fili looked at her, his joy warring with disbelief.

"He proved your innocence? Oh thank Mahal for it and for you. I thought I was going to die, being without you tore my soul in two. Now...I think I feel it mending a bit but I'm so tired Lor, so very tired." He said softly and Lor leaned down to kiss him gently.

"Then you must sleep my love, rest and build your strength once more. When you wake again I will be here and we'll find a way to heal your body and soul. Will you rest for me my love, my One?" She asked him and he reached up and took her hand in his before he placed the gentlest of kisses on her palm.

"Do you promise to stay with me? To be by my side?" Fili asked and the fear in his voice tore at her heart but Lor simply nodded and leaned down to kiss him gently.

"I promise you, my Fili, I will never leave you again. Not for all the wide world." He smiled at that and as he allowed his eyes to close he fell into a peaceful slumber and Lor crumpled over him as she sobbed against his neck. She was home and her heart was whole again, now she could finally heal the rift in her heart.