Chapter Text
Pete stepped into the familiar warmth of the café, the doorbell jingling above his head as he entered. The small, cozy space hadn’t changed a bit since he’d last been here—mismatched tables, chipped mugs, the ever-present hum of the espresso machine in the back.
There was something oddly comforting about it, but it also made his stomach tighten. It was all too familiar, too... nostalgic. And that wasn’t necessarily a good thing.
Max was already sitting at their usual table, the one by the big window that overlooked the street. As soon as he spotted Pete, he stood up with a grin that made Pete’s chest tighten in a way he hadn’t expected.
Max still had that effect on him—an effortless, magnetic charm that hadn’t dulled in the years since they’d broken up.
“Pete,” Max greeted, his voice smooth as velvet, as he reached out to pull him into a hug.
Pete froze for a moment, surprised by the warmth of Max’s embrace.
It was more intimate than he had expected.
Longer, too.
“Hey, Max,” Pete said, forcing himself to relax as he pulled away.
He smiled, though the words felt stuck in his throat. He wasn’t sure why it felt strange now—seeing Max again, feeling the way his presence still seemed to echo in Pete’s body.
They sat down, and for the first few minutes, the conversation was light. They talked about mutual friends, jobs, the usual catch-up stuff. Pete found himself easing into the rhythm of it—there was a comfort in the familiarity of Max’s voice, the way their jokes still landed in that old, effortless way.
It almost felt like time hadn’t passed.
Almost.
But then Max’s gaze shifted, becoming more intense, more focused.
It wasn’t subtle, the way he started looking at Pete like he was the only person in the room.
Pete shifted uncomfortably in his seat, not used to being the centre of Max’s attention after all this time.
The small talk started to fade, and the air between them thickened.
“You know,” Max said casually, leaning forward with his elbows on the table, his fingers steepled in front of him, “I’ve thought about you a lot over the years. We always had such good chemistry, don’t you think?”
Pete felt his throat tighten. Chemistry?
It had been a long time since he’d thought about their relationship in those terms. They had shared something—something deep, but that was years ago.
He had moved on.
He was with Vegas now and Vegas was everything.
“I don’t know,” Pete said, his voice coming out quieter than he’d intended. “That was a long time ago, Max. We were young.”
Max’s eyes glinted as he leaned even closer, his voice dropping lower, more intimate.
“Yeah, but the spark... you can’t tell me you don’t feel it, Pete. We always had it. No one else could ever make you feel the way I did, could they?”
Pete froze, his heart suddenly pounding in his chest.
Max wasn’t just reminiscing anymore; he was pushing, flirting in that old, irresistible way that used to make Pete feel wanted, important, like he was the entirety of Max’s world.
It unsettled him now.
It felt like a violation of the boundaries he’d worked so hard to establish, both with himself and with Vegas.
“I’m with Vegas now,” Pete said, trying to keep his voice steady, but it came out a little rougher than he meant. He could feel a flush creeping up his neck. “I’ve been with him for years.”
Max didn’t back off.
Instead, he smiled—slow, calculating, the kind of smile that always made Pete’s heart race, even when he didn’t want it to.
“Yeah, I’ve heard about Vegas. He’s...handsome, I guess.”
Max paused, his eyes narrowing slightly as he took in Pete’s reaction.
“But let’s be honest, Pete. You’ve always been the kind of guy who wants someone safe, someone who won’t stir things up, someone who won’t challenge you.”
Pete’s stomach churned at the implication.
He wanted to brush it off, wanted to ignore it, but something about Max’s tone—laced with condescension and old familiarity—made Pete bristle.
He clenched his hands under the table, trying to keep his cool.
“I don’t know what you’re trying to say, Max,” Pete said, his voice quiet but hard. “Vegas isn’t just safe. He’s everything I need. And we’re good together.”
Max leaned back in his chair, folding his arms across his chest as he studied Pete, his gaze darkening.
“Really? Everything? I find that hard to believe. Vegas can’t give you what you need, Pete. He’s just the kind of guy who’ll never push you, never challenge you to be more. He’s—well, let’s be real here—he’s just easy. You’ve always been good at picking the easy ones, haven’t you?”
Pete’s heart skipped a beat, and for a second, he wasn’t sure what to say.
He felt something hot and sharp rise in his chest—a mix of anger, frustration, and the sudden urge to defend the man he loved.
Vegas wasn’t just easy. Vegas wasn’t anything like that. Pete had never felt more at home, more right, than he did with Vegas. And to have Max dismiss that, to insinuate that Vegas was somehow less than he deserved... Pete felt a surge of protectiveness.
“Don’t talk about him like that,” Pete said, his voice finally breaking through the fog of uncertainty.
It came out more forcefully than he had intended, but he didn’t care. The words needed to be said.
“Vegas is the most real thing I’ve ever had. He gets me, Max. Something you never did.”
Max’s smirk faltered for a moment, but it was quickly replaced with something sharper, more biting.
“Oh, so that’s how it is now? You’re just going to settle, huh? With someone who doesn’t even challenge you? Who doesn’t even make you feel alive?”
Pete’s pulse quickened, and he leaned forward, his hands gripping the edge of the table. “I’m not settling, Max,” he said through clenched teeth.
“Vegas makes me feel more than I ever felt with you. He respects me. He doesn’t try to manipulate me into thinking I’m someone I’m not. You don’t get to insult him like that.”
Max’s eyes flickered with something that Pete couldn’t quite place—anger, maybe?
Jealousy?
It didn’t matter.
Pete wasn’t going to back down.
Not this time.
“You know,” Max said, his voice turning cold, his smile no longer playful, “It’s pathetic, really. Watching you throw away everything we had for someone who can’t even handle the real you. He’s just a fucking rebound, Pete. You’ll figure it out sooner or later. But by then, it’ll be too late.”
The words hit Pete like a punch to the gut. He felt his whole body stiffen, the heat of his anger boiling over.
This wasn’t about Max, about the past—they weren’t the same people anymore.
But the nerve, the audacity for Max to insult Vegas like that—it cut deeper than Pete had anticipated.
It made his blood run cold. And in that moment, Pete knew there was no point in continuing this conversation.
No point in trying to salvage a friendship that had already been buried under layers of hurt and manipulation.
Pete stood up abruptly, knocking his chair back in the process. He wasn’t going to let Max—anyone—disrespect what he had with Vegas.
“You’re done here, Max,” Pete said, his voice low and controlled, but carrying the weight of finality. “I’m done with this conversation. Done with you.”
Max’s lips parted in surprise, but Pete didn’t give him a chance to say anything else. He turned and walked out of the café, the door swinging shut behind him with a quiet thud.
Outside, the cool air hit him like a breath of fresh air, clearing the heat from his chest.
His mind raced as he pulled out his phone, fingers quickly typing a message to Vegas.
Pete: “Hey, I’m on my way home. Let’s talk when I get there. We’re good, I promise.”
He hit send and tucked the phone into his pocket, taking a deep breath.
He wasn’t going to let Max’s words—Max’s bullshit—get to him.
Not now, not ever.
He had something real with Vegas, something worth fighting for. He wasn’t about to let anyone, especially not Max, tear that down.
The past was over.
Vegas was his future.
And that was the only thing that mattered.
