Chapter Text
It's late. Later than he usually stays awake unless he has a reason for it. There hasn't been much reason for it, lately, and yet Hannibal rolls in his cot for what must be the dozenth time. He can't seem to sleep. He knows the cause. A dull ache, ever present, made sharper than usual tonight.
'I miss you,' he'd admitted, voice thick and helpless on the other end of the line, and it almost destroyed the both of them.
'I'm not going to miss you,' he'd insisted the last time they'd spoken in person. Two long years that feel like a thousand lifetimes ago. He'd tried to keep that promise, dug a trench between them so deep and wide that Hannibal could no longer see what lived at the bottom. He'd tried so hard for so long. Hannibal lies awake and wonders if the trying hurt more than the failing.
'I miss you. I wonder if you miss me.'
'Of course I miss you, Will,' Hannibal had answered. All in all, it may have been the most honest conversation they'd ever had.
He was glad for the ache, at the end of it all. The pain of hearing Will's voice would always be sweeter than the pain of imagining his voice in the silence. Perhaps the pain would stop entirely if he ceased thinking of Will altogether. He didn't recall feeling any pain before. Before he looked into those stormy blue eyes, heard that beautiful voice. And yet when he thinks back on it now, the ache is there too. Revisionist History, perhaps.
But tonight he's glad that Will had wanted to share such an agony, that hearing Hannibal's voice seemed to cast him to the sea in the same way.
Yes, very glad Will had called.
Lord, but it ached. So much worse than before.
It's always this way with Will. His presence and his absence. His attention and his abandonment. His love and his disdain and the intersections where they meet and cross and blend until Hannibal feels so disoriented that he wishes he had a map of his own heart. It's a frightening thing to lose. Control.
He'd surrendered it, nonetheless. His love nestled at the precise spot where desperation and devotion met, and he gave up everything he had as easily as setting down a freshly finished book. Only for Will. He is only this foolish for him, only this thoughtless for him.
It is always this way with Will.
The door opens, then. It's far too late to be anything routine. He sits up, and sees a mousey young woman place the phone receiver into the slotted drawer in the wall. His heart leaps to his mouth.
She yawns before speaking. "There's a Mister Graham on the line for you, Doctor Lecter."
It takes a moment to make himself breathe. Will. Perfect, marvelous Will, asking after him again while his wife sleeps. It's only been two weeks since their last call, yet the skipping of his pulse suggests it's been much more.
"Thank you," he says as the orderly leaves, staring at the drawer. He takes the receiver with shaking hands, forcing himself to speak.
"Hello, Will," He says, and he knows that the delight is clear in his voice but he can hardly bring himself to care. Not when Will sounds so pleased to hear the familiar greeting.
"Hello, Doctor Lecter."
That voice, like the warm sand after a long, tiring swim.
"Did sleep evade you again, tonight?"
"Yeah. Um, sorry if I woke you."
Like changing into clean dry socks after being caught in a sudden rainstorm.
"Not at all. It seems my subconscious was anticipating your call. I couldn't sleep either."
Will chuckles at that. Like spiced cider on a winter night.
"I wasn't sure when I'd hear from you again," Hannibal says. "This is sooner than I expected."
"It's sooner than I planned," Will returns with a sigh. "Though I'd entertained the idea of never calling a second time."
Hannibal hums. Of course he did. Poor boy, he tries so hard. Always fails, but tries so hard.
"It was difficult, talking to you again." He breathes out a soft laugh. "I'm afraid it's only going to get easier."
He shakes his head. "Why do you do this to yourself, Will?"
"Can I blame it on the whiskey?" he asks, and Hannibal feels like he can smell it on him.
"You've been drinking?"
"Not as much as I did the last time I called you."
Hannibal smirks. "Liquid courage?"
Will snorts. "More like a numbing agent."
"And what are you attempting to numb tonight, Will?"
A short silence. Hannibal hears the sound of ice moving against a glass.
"You're rotten at small talk, you know that?" Will asks, ignoring the question.
Hannibal laughs. He can't remember the last time he laughed. Will joins him and it might as well be Christmas morning for all the joy that bubbles in his chest. "I've never made small talk with you, Will. The first conversation we ever had was about the building of mental walls and you never once said that it was nice to meet me. You can't stand small talk."
"It wasn't nice to meet you," Will fires back. "You made a terrible first impression, and then you kept making terrible impressions for another two years. Your only saving grace was that you were terrible in a way that I found endearing."
Hannibal feels his heart flip. That warmth in Will's voice almost tricks him into thinking they've turned back time, that the two of them are pretending to talk about a case and that Will's body is free of scars.
Will coughs awkwardly. "A-at the time, that is," he mutters.
He opens his mouth to speak. To tell Will how dearly he's been missed. In the end, he settles for "What sort of small talk shall we make, then?"
Will huffs. "Hell, I don't know. Tell me about your day, how about that."
Hannibal smiles to himself. "There isn't much to say, I'm afraid. I finished a novel."
"Another whodunnit?" Will prods. Hannibal hears a bottle opening, but doesn't hear the sound of liquid landing in a glass. Is he drinking from the bottle now?
"Yes. The culprit was a minor, unassuming character who seemingly had nothing to gain from the murder until the very end."
Will chuckles. "It always is, isn't it? Fiction's unrealistic that way."
"And far less exciting than actual crime, for the most part."
"You know what they ought to do? Write a story where everyone knows who the killer is, and he still manages to get away in the end."
"Until he surrenders?" Hannibal asks.
Will sighs. Hannibal can practically see how he scrubs his hand down his face.
"...Yeah. Until he surrenders."
"It sounds more like a myth than a murder mystery."
"People would read it. Come for the Morbid Curiosity, stay for the love story."
Hannibal raises his brows, not bothering to hide his grin. "The love story, you say?"
"Gotta get them to root for the killer somehow. It'll sell."
"What about you?"
Will blows out a long breath. "Same shit, different day."
Hannibal tilts his head. "You've finally found stability, without me. Many people find routine soothing."
"There's a thin, blurry line between routine and monotony, Doctor, and I think we're both on the wrong side of it."
"I'm a prisoner, Will. What's your excuse?"
The answering laugh is sharp, with just a note of bitterness. "I thought it would be better. It's got to be better. Jesus, it's- there's gotta be a middle ground, right? Something between arguing with the guy at the hardware store and having my brain eaten?"
"Maybe for some people. I think you and I are doomed to be creatures of extremes."
"You and I," Will mumbles, and it almost sounds like an afterthought. Something he hadn't fully intended to echo, and certainly not with such softness in his tone. It compels Hannibal to voice his own recent worries.
"Were you happy, before we met?"
Hannibal hears wood creaking through the phone. Will settling further into a rocking chair, most likely. "At some points, I was. Petting my dogs and catching fish and getting my hands dirty- yes, I was definitely happy. Not in a lasting way. Not in the way that makes it easy to get up in the morning. But from time to time, before you, I was happy."
Hannibal nods, turning Will's words over in his mind.
"What about you?"
He furrows his brows. "I thought I was, at the time. Looking back, it seems so glaringly obvious that something was missing. It seems difficult to imagine that I didn't see it, yet I remember feeling perfectly content."
Will doesn't respond, and for a terrible moment, Hannibal fears he's said too much.
"...If you could relive any day of your life, as many times as you wanted, which day would you choose?"
Hannibal hums in thought. He isn't thrown by the sudden subject change, it isn't uncommon for Will to shift gears when he's bored or simply uncomfortable. "Am I allowed to change the course of events?"
"Let's say you couldn't. It has to go the same as it did the first time."
He thinks it over, observing the dark emptiness of his cell. He's spent countless hours at galas, dinner parties, operas. Many days preparing displays and cooking grand feasts, and many nights in the arms of an unlucky stranger.
"The day you killed Garrett Jacob Hobbs, I believe."
Will snorts. "Of course."
Hannibal feels a sense of contentment wash over him as he recalls that day. He hadn't wanted to admit it at the time, but even so early on Hannibal was enamored with Will. He'd written it off as curiosity, but in truth he was hopeless before they'd even finished breakfast.
"We hardly knew one another but our conversations came so easily, like we were old friends."
"You called me a mongoose," Will says, smirk practically audible. "And I let you. I don't know what I was thinking."
"It really was a privilege, seeing you after your first kill. Frightened. Wild. Utterly uncontrollable- though it didn't stop me from trying."
"I must've seemed so...unspoiled, to you. A naive, shivering man, kneeling at your feet and covered in blood. I'm lucky you didn't snatch me for yourself, then and there."
He nods in acquiescence. "There was something quite charming about your purity. I prefer you now, though. You are the version of yourself that I always saw in you, like Michelangelo seeing his David fully realized in the undisturbed stone."
"I was half expecting you to answer with the night you finally got my blood on your hands," Will says, slurring a little.
Hannibal shuts his eyes. It stings- not just being reminded of that awful night, but the idea that Will thought Hannibal enjoyed it. "No. I would never wish that upon either of us."
"Hannibal..." he whispers, in reply. He sounds striken, far away.
"And what is your answer, Will?"
"I..."
A sad smile rises to his lips. "You must've given it some thought. You wouldn't have asked otherwise. Which day would you relive?"
"I-" He coughs takes a slow breath. "I find myself trying to stich pieces of different days together. Making Frankenstein's Monster from scraps of the past. A morning in the stream, fishing in silence, alone with my thoughts. An afternoon in the Uffizi Gallery, finally seeing you again after so long. Dinner after I killed Randall Tier, you looking so proud and my knuckles throbbing where I grip my wine glass. A night in Abigail's hospital room, watching her sleep and trying to trick myself into thinking I was a good man."
Hannibal shakes his head. "I believe that defeats the purpose of the exercise, no? You must choose a full day, dawn til dusk. If you revisit that afternoon in the Gallery, then you owe it to both of us to also revisit what happened when we walked out."
There's a brief moment of deliberation before Will says "Then I would choose a day that I don't remember."
Hannibal tilts his head, waiting for more and knowing that it's forthcoming.
"Just a normal Friday. Something before the Encephalitis got too severe, I think. Morning with the dogs. Classes. Talk to Jack about whatever case he's got me investigating. A session with you, talking for an hour in your office. Maybe we have a quick drink after. Nothing spectacular or course-altering. Just a day that doesn't feel quite so...misplaced."
"You'd relive a routine."
"Guess I like it after all, under the right circumstances."
Hannibal looks sidelong, and sees Will leaning on his front porch. It's not the same house he lives in now, it's the old one. The one Hannibal knows. Near the threshold Hannibal carried Will over. Will takes a swig from the whiskey bottle in his hands, holds it out to Hannibal in a wordless offer. Hannibal takes it, searches for the taste of Will's lips on the glass.
"What if you could change it?" Will asks softly, frowning out at the darkness.
Hannibal swirls the amber liquid, watching how it catches the porch light. "I've always done what I felt was best. Some of my choices are regrettable, but I believe they were necessary in the end." He glances up at the other man, smiling softly. "I wouldn't change a thing, Will."
Will sniffs. His grip on the railing tightens. He lowers his head, features crumbling.
"I don't think there's a single day I wouldn't change," Will whispers, and when he looks back out at the yard, there are tears rolling down his face.
"And how would you change it? What would you do?" Hannibal asks, stepping closer.
Will looks up at him, blue eyes glistening with tears. His gaze flicks down to Hannibal's lips for just a moment, before settling back on his own. Hannibal leans in.
Will clears his throat. The sound rattles a bit in the receiver and it shocks Hannibal back to earth. Back to the empty darkness of his cell and the dryness of his mouth and the miles and endless miles between Will and himself. "It doesn't matter," Will says. "I have to own up to the Here and Now, right? We're both here. We both put ourselves here. Wishing that things had gone differently isn't helping anyone."
Hannibal fights the impulse to object, to urge Will onwards.
"Will you be calling me again?" he asks instead.
Will huffs. "I'd like to say no. I'd hoped the answer would be no."
Hannibal smiles despite himself. "It will be easier for you, next time. It will only become easier."
"Yeah, I know. That's what I'm afraid of."
Hannibal licks his lips. He'd like this to last a small eternity, but if Will falls asleep outside and half-drunk again, his wife may become suspicious. "You should get some rest. I'd hate for you to fall asleep on the porch again, that must've been hell on your muscles the day after."
Will chuckles dryly. "Yeah, you're right. Have a good night-"
"And Will?"
"Yeah?"
He braces himself, steels his nerves.
"I miss you, mylimasis."
Will is quiet for a moment before he sighs softly, so sweet that Hannibal tastes it on the stale air.
"...I miss you too, Hannibal. I'll um, I'll talk to you soon, okay? Good night."
When the line goes dead, Hannibal mourns the loss. He feels a bittersweet sort of longing coursing through his veins, but he also feels deeply soothed. Just hearing his voice, knowing that he is alive and near and thinking of him- it's a balm to his nerves.
He lies in his cot, prepared to sleep more easily than he has in weeks. He looks to the ceiling of his cell, thinks of Will-
And the ache begins again.
