Actions

Work Header

Don't Go Where I Can't Follow

Chapter 19: Angels On The Moon

Notes:

The song that inspired the chapter was "Angels On The Moon" by Thriving Ivory. I recommend you listening to it while reading.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

"Are you well, Your Majesty?"

Fili looked up in the half dazed, half confused way he had been lingering in for longer than he remembered now. His face was stoic, though, just as always, and he looked straight into the eyes of the man sitting on the other side of the table. He was tall and had short beard, but everyone else had long, either grey or dark ones that swept the surface of the table whenever they moved their heads.

Fili blinked and nodded then, clearing his throat quickly.

"Please continue."

He ran his fingers through his own beard. It was extremely short for a dwarf, ragged at the ends and faded. It had once been the colour of honey, softer than his brother's, perfect for braiding. It all felt like a lifetime had passed since then. Maybe even more.

"We do understand you are in a tight corner, Your Majesty," the man spoke as if nothing had happened, and Fili felt himself slowly losing interest again. He tried to hold on, though, and kept his eyes on the moving lips of the man. He didn't even remember his name. "Our king is willing to continue providing help, to keep trading Rohan's livestock for Erebor's valuable gold and gems, but you must see our problem here, Your Majesty. Orcs are trying to occupy the White Mountains on the south, and the King of Rohan is fighting them without ever seeing its end. You have seen the orcs and their destruction yourself as well, King under the Mountain."

Fili's throat tightened and he felt a bitter taste on his tongue. The smell of orc blood and flesh came into his nose in a fraction of a second, the sight of countless men, elves and dwarves who had fallen and were stamped on until they were unrecognizable was lingering in front of his eyes, and he had to swallow to fight down the lump that tried to burst between his tonsils. A headache was gradually growing behind his eyes and he took a deep breath, his eyes falling to the table from the man with pity in his eyes. He felt sick to his stomach simply by looking at him.

"What is it that Rohan needs me to do?" he asked, his voice rough and low, lower than ever before. He lost the thread of the conversation at the beginning, unable to concentrate, and he scolded himself for it. He felt the pointed look of Balin from his side, eyeing him like his teachers used to back in Ered Lúin, but Fili completely ignored him.

The men seemed a bit uncomfortable at the question, but the one who had been speaking so far gathered enough of his composure to answer.

"Rohan had been trading with Erebor for almost a year, but our King had strictly ordered us to tell you, we can find another partner to provide with our help if Erebor keeps falling back on the payments."

Thick silence fell on the hall and everyone remained motionless. The tension was so palpable in the air that one could've sliced it through with a butter knife, and the sound of breathing grew deafening between the walls. Fili inhaled deeply, trying to keep his face as serious as he could as he sat up more comfortably and entwined his fingers on the table.

"Brytta Léofa had aided Erebor greatly in the last few months, which we are eternally grateful for," Fili started as diplomatically as he could, and the men kept eyeing him with forced smiles. "My great-grandfather had gathered wealth great enough so we could aid people in need as well, like the men of Laketown or those who wished to rebuild Dale from its ruins. In spite of all the riches we bestowed upon these men, we still have more to trade with whomever we choose."

The men seemed the slightest bit bewildered at that, but Fili simply showed a similiar false smile to them in return, leaning closer to the table to have his eyes bore into each one of theirs.

"We pay in gold for livestock and farm produce for the Iron Hills, many of the elves, the Shire, and even for Ered Lúin, which is, as I am positive you all know, on the far western shore of Middle-Earth," Fili smiled charmingly, playing with his fingers as the unease of the men only grew and grew with every second. "It is a really, really long way to reach Erebor, especially that orcs are still threatening the safety of the main trading routes, but I am once again positive you all know that, for you just mentioned you have many others to trade with."

A silent, barely audible sound came from the direction of Balin, almost as if the old dwarf was trying to hide a laugh behind a cough. Fili sent him a lopsided smile before he turned back to the men sweating in front of him.

"I do understand your problem, gentlemen," the King under the Mountain said, his voice steady and kind as ever. Except for those who knew him, for they could hear that it was almost dangerously calm, and for his luck, these men already knew him to hear that. It wasn't the first time they came complaining to Erebor, but Fili wanted to make sure it was the last. "Rohan is still recovering from the war with the Dunlendings, then there is the matter of fled orcs on the south of your realm, I completely understand. It must be a burning problem to obtain some gold, believe me I know how stressful that can be. But you must understand something as well."

He leaned even closer now, the smile on his face long gone and replaced with such a grim expression that it would've made even the Elvenking tremble on his chair, let alone these men.

"The quantity and quality of your livestock is worse with every month, and we have over a thousand dwarves to feed in this palace," he murmured, his voice so deep that it resonated with every single speck of dust in the room. "Tell your king that until he regains his kingdom's strength, he will have to get used to his problem that he tries so hard to remedy, for cheap threats on abandoning the trade is not the way a good king deals with issues."

The words came out like a hiss, not even loud enough to echo through the hall, and Fili straightened, completely satisfied. The looks on the men's faces were priceless, and he decided he had enough of this company for the rest of the day. He cleared his throat quickly, waving to the guards at the door to come closer.

"My men will show you to your chambers now, gentlemen," Fili said, rubbing his palms together as he stepped back from the table until he was standing by Balin's side. He had a small smile on his face, carefully eyeing the men standing from their chairs. They seemed to tremble the slightest bit, but Fili thought it was only his imagination. "I expect to see you again at dinner."

They kept nodding tentatively, following the guards to the door. Only the silent murmurs of 'your majesty' were left behind, and once the door closed behind them, Fili turned expectantly to Balin.

The last thing he thought he would see was the concern-filled type of smile on his old advisor's face.

"How long do you think you can keep it up, laddie?" Balin asked, earning a confused frown from Fili. The king truly didn't understand, and the long silence drew a sigh from the white haired dwarf. "Brytta needs gold, but he would never ask for it. You have been beating around the bush for months now, and the only thing you will achieve is the termination of trading between Rohan and Erebor. These men told the truth, unlike you."

"Thank you, Balin. It is nice that you praise my abilities as a king like that," Fili pressed his lips together, heading back towards his chair to fall into it unceremoniously. Half of his resentment wasn't even real, but he did feel disappointed at the words of his friend. "If they don't ask, they don't get. I will need to gouge an official plea out of Brytta if I want to keep up the reputation of Erebor."

Even from the corner of his eyes, Fili could see how Balin started slowly shaking his head, approaching the table as well and sitting down on the left of the king. Fili kept staring at an irrelevant point between the gaps of the wooden surface, trying to focus on completely different things that had nothing to do with politics and exhausting men.

"Kings don't beg for help, laddie," Balin sighed, and Fili could feel his eyes on his own face. He didn't look up, though. "We are not trading livestock, nor farm produce with the Iron Hills, and neither with Ered Lúin. And we most certainly don't have more than 800 dwarves living in here. This is not how you deal with problems, Fili."

It was Fili's turn to sigh and he looked at Balin as if the dwarf was about to torture him on the most merciless way possible.

"Have you seen their beards?" he snorted, an incredulous smile spreading on his lips. He knew he was trying to change the topic for a reason, but he kept ignoring it as much as he could. "I felt envy, and it is downright ridiculous."

"You could have such beard if only you hadn't cut it off," Balin shrugged, leaning back on his seat with a satisfied smile and Fili's eyes widened.

"I was drunk!" he exclaimed, his voice an octave higher than usual and he was halfway between a laugh and a yell. It only grew Balin's amusement, and the old dwarf was eyeing the young king with a smile that was particularly rare to see lately. Fili made a mental note about it, but he simply smiled back with exasperation. "Kili almost chopped his ear off!"

He remembered how angry their mother was when they got home, Fili without his beard and Kili with his ear bleeding. They weren't in the right state to start panicking, but it surely changed the next morning when they had to face Dís' fury. She tended to Kili's ear and she tried to cut Fili's beard to look a bit better, but it never grew back the same way. He was glad he kept the braids, though, and he still had them in his chambers until this very day.

Everybody knew it wasn't a kingly deed, to deprive himself of his beard that was probably the most important thing for a dwarf. Then again, it was also known that drinking too much was a way to cope with loss, especially for dwarves, and Fili was not ready to be a king.

He was not ready to sit where his uncle was meant to sit.

Neither of the two dwarves noticed the silence that fell upon them. Seemingly both had been thinking about the same thing, recalling the same sorrowful days, the same grief washing over them over and over again. Their smiles were gone, and they sat in complete quietness.

"I am still not ready for this, Balin," Fili chose to break the silence a few minutes later, his voice small and holding only the slightest bit of despair. Balin didn't speak, he just turned his glance to the younger dwarf and watched him carefully. Fili saw the pain on his face, even behind his massive beard, but he had no one else to share his own with. He only had Balin now, and he thought he could afford a bit of selfishness now, even though it made his insides ache. "I am a warrior, not a king. I can fight, I can save people, but I can never rule Erebor like a true king. It's either I who wasn't supposed to survive that battle, or uncle wasn't supposed to die. It's not the way it was meant to be."

"Things sometimes happen without a reason, laddie," Balin murmured, his voice barely audible in the huge hall and Fili let his head fall forward, a bitter smile tugging at his lips. "Ruling a kingdom is not joyous, and I know you don't feel ready. But we have to make sacrifices."

An incredulous laugh slipped out of Fili's mouth, and he snapped up his head violently. He felt anger building inside his chest, slowly but steadily, and before he could've stopped himself a flood of words escaped his lips.

"You are saying that Dwalin is supposed to be like this?" he asked, and Balin immediately let out a huge breath, shaking his head in silence. He avoided the king's gaze, though, and Fili didn't give him a chance to answer. "That Kili is supposed to spend more time in Mirkwood because he can't bear the sight of Erebor? That Rose was supposed to leave? That... That all those things were supposed to happen to Bilbo? Are you saying that, Balin? Was it all meant to happen?"

"No, laddie. It wasn't."

Fili didn't even realise he was shouting until he heard Balin speaking. The old dwarf seemed so small in that moment, curled up in the chair and staring down with sad eyes that Fili felt a pang of guilt immediately. It tore at his heart, and he had to swallow to keep himself together.

He wanted to be angry at Thorin for so long now that he almost believed he was. The took the easy way out. He died before he could've faced everything that he had done, he left everyone behind to cope with his loss the way they wanted, and he lies under the mountain ever since. They placed Orcrist upon his chest, the only thing he fully trusted and the very thing that took his life in the end. Fili could never forget the last time he saw him, and he could never forgive his uncle for dying. It felt unfair and selfish, and the fact that Fili had to step up in his place and right his wrongs was the worst.

Because, even though he was the rightful heir, Fili couldn't do anything to fix what was broken. He ordered that the Arkenstone must be destroyed, and it was smashed to smithereens in front of his eyes. That was the only thing he knew he had done right, however. Everyone else left him, and the only ones he could lean on were Vanyra and Balin.

Now he managed to hurt Balin, too. He guessed it ran in their family.

"I am sorry," he murmured, his voice sounding way too exhausted all of a sudden, even for his own ears. Balin glanced at him, concern deep in his eyes. "I did not mean to shout at you. It wasn't nice of me."

Or kingly, he added in his mind, but he was glad to see Balin simply shaking his head and waving it off. It didn't erase his guilt, though, but it was nice to have at least one person around him who could act with responsibility and who was wise enough to endure him.

"We all miss Thorin, laddie," Balin said, almost on a fatherly tone that was gentle enough to reach Fili as a caress, yet painful enough to open the wound on his heart even wider. He would have loved to hate him, but he couldn't, and it was only firing his grief more and more with every day. "But he would be proud of you, I am sure about that."

Fili felt a smile tugging at his lips. His cheeks warmed only slightly, for he found Balin's words quite hard to believe.

"Even though I am threatening the well-being of the kingdom with my stupidity?" he asked with a silent laugh in his voice and Balin nodded, winking at him knowingly.

"Even then."

They sat in comfortable silence for a few moments, both smiling about sweet memories that didn't come to poison their soul, only to delight them in times of dire need. Remembering that Thorin wasn't perfect either was a huge help for Fili, and he still believed he could get better with time, even if he didn't feel ready and probably never would. It didn't mean he couldn't try.

The king stood from the table with a huge sigh and a short clear of his throat, nodding towards Balin quickly.

"I promised Vanyra I would pay a visit today, so I better be going," he sidestepped from the chair, setting his clothes straight. He still wasn't used to these scarlet coloured, velvet drapes while his good old pine-green vests were waiting for him on the bottom of his dresser, but he knew they weren't appropriate now, especially while having guests in the palace.

He was already heading towards the door when he heard Balin standing up as well, calling after him. Fili turned swiftly, his composure back in a moment, and raised his eyebrows curiously.

"You can still change your mind about Rohan until tonight's dinner," Balin said knowingly, a cunning smile hiding behind his beard and Fili almost laughed out loud. He knew he wouldn't get away with it so easily, and he trusted his advisor enough to believe that his words held wisdom.

Fili nodded with a grin, his hand on the handle of the door as he spoke.

"I already did."

***

It was a warm afternoon when Vanyra laid a single flower next to so many others at the bottom of the Lonely Mountain. The winds, given it was late summer again, for a year had passed already, were pleasant on her skin, blowing her long locks over her shoulder as she straightened. She brought a rose, dark crimson with huge petals, a flower that was fit for a king.

A former king, she corrected herself in her mind, a sad smile tugging at her lips and tears brimming in her eyes.

It had been a long year, and it felt even longer without Thorin Oakenshield being around. Vanyra came to the grave twice in every month, collecting the dry flowers and bringing new ones instead. The tomb was secluded by a several feet high stone, an abundance of runes carved into its surface listing Thorin's real khuzdul name and the cause of his death. She knew every word by heart, and she often ran her fingers over the carvings, imagining she was touching Thorin's face.

She missed him way too much to describe. Thorin wasn't simply her king, but something way more important than that. Her best friend, her brother, her confidant. They grew up together, they often fought together, and losing him was like a piece or her heart being torn from her chest.

It hurt. And the pain of grief wasn't to vanish so easily.

"I thought I might find you here."

Vanyra wasn't frightened to hear the soft words right from behind her, and even if she had decided not to turn around, she would have recognised the owner of this voice. It reminded her way too much of her best friend's voice, and it made her smile without sadness now. She locked eyes with Fili, following the movements of the king as he approached her, stopping beside her.

"He would be happy to see all this green grass around the mountain," Vanyra took a deep breath, entwining her fingers in front of her thighs. She wore a light red dress, the same one she wore on the day she came back to Erebor. That was a day she wouldn't forget, ever. "Maybe even the trees will return one day."

The desolation was gone indeed, a clearing of sweet grass taking its place. There were no black spots anymore, nor wasteland. The ground swallowed every ounce of water during the long winter and the rainy spring, becoming more beautiful by August than ever before. Vanyra felt an aching in her heart that Thorin could not see how his kingdom recovered from the reign of the dragon, but she hoped he somehow had seen it anyway from the halls of Mahal, standing by the side of his father and grandfather.

"He would be so proud of you, Fili," she turned to the king with a watery smile, raising a hand to touch the dwarf's forearm gently. His laughter was almost lost in the winds, barely audible and weak, deep sadness glimmering in his eyes as well. He eyed the runes without a blink, reading them again and again until they were burnt into his memory.

"Why?" he asked silently, bitter exasperation ringing from his voice. "I have done nothing to earn his acknowledgement. I couldn't keep Kili by my side, and now the only heir of Erebor lives in Mirkwood. I couldn't protect Bilbo, and I had to watch as Rose left with him. Dwalin hadn't spoken a word for a year now, and I don't know how to fix him. I can't say anything that I've done well, Vanyra."

He fell silent for a few seconds, trying to collect himself quietly. Vanyra felt her tears rolling down on her cheeks, but she quickly wiped them away with the sleeve of her dress. She wasn't supposed to cry now. Not in front of Fili who had seemed like a child again, lost and insecure. She had to stay strong for his sake.

"I am a failure," he added, his voice barely a whisper as he uttered the words. He sounded so heartbroken that Vanyra felt a wave of protectiveness rush over her, and she caught herself raising her chin fiercely, turning Fili by his shoulder so he would face her. She swallowed her last tears, taking a deep breath before she spoke.

"Do not ever say that, Fili," Vanyra said firmly, grabbing the dwarf's other shoulder as well. She held him in one place, never letting his gaze go. "Kili had a choice and he is loved where he is now. He has yet to grow up, and he is looked after. What had happened to Bilbo is not your fault, and you could've never prevented it. Rose made her choice as well, and I know it hurts, but I still think it is not the end for you. She still loves you, and if you do not wish to marry only to produce an heir then you won't. You can keep her close, even if she is in the Shire."

Fili stayed quiet, eyeing Vanyra vaguely before he slowly opened his mouth.

"And Dwalin?"

Vanyra felt her heart twisting painfully in her chest, her throat feeling too tight all of a sudden. Thinking about Dwalin was filling her with sadness and worry, neverending concern that she would never feel anything else had it come to him again.

She remembered the moment she left their chamber only half an hour ago, the once so fierce and valiant warrior now sitting motionlessly in front of the fireplace where he had been usually staying for a year now. He was staring ahead of him, right at the stone wall like waiting for something to show up there but naught ever appeared. He hadn't spoken, he hadn't given any sign of understanding what anyone was telling him, and he barely accepted food. He slept at night but he always awakened with nightmares, his warrior instinct telling him to grab his sword and protect himself. After a few incidents where Dwalin almost killed her at night, Vanyra had to put away the sword and get used to the restless nights.

It was a heavy burden to bear, but she never complained. She stayed by Dwalin's side ever since, waiting for a moment when he would wake from his lingering and realise that life had moved on.

Thorin was dead. And there was no going back.

Vanyra realised that she forgot to answer once she felt Fili's hand cupping her cheek gently. It shook her out of her thoughts, and she laid her own hand on the top of Fili's with a sad smile, squeezing it softly.

"Dwalin is broken," she finally answered, staring at Fili's chest. She was close to tears again, and she didn't want to see the pity in Fili's eyes. She would've started crying only. "I don't think it is your duty to fix him. It is only his. I know he hears me when I am talking to him, it is only that his grief and guilt is too high for him to see through it."

"Guilt?" Fili furrowed his brows ever so slightly, and Vanyra nodded.

"Guilt that he couldn't protect Thorin. Guilt that he let him go down on that road until he destroyed himself," she looked up into the king's eyes. They were filled with surprise, but it only made Vanyra smile again. She could feel how weak it seemed. "The same guilt you feel for everything you think was your duty but you couldn't fulfill. You too are broken, my boy, but you are a Durin, and you are strong. And you better remain strong, for our people have great hope in you, and everything you do is appreciated."

It was the first time that a genuine smile appeared on Fili's face, and he pulled Vanyra closer to hug her tightly. Vanyra often spoke to Dís, but she saw how the mother of the lads had changed after Thorin's death. She was either way too loving towards her sons or way too distant, she couldn't decide which would be the better way to cope with their and her own pain. It seemed the king was too young for ruling a kingdom sometimes, and he needed love that he could get from Vanyra whenever he needed. The girl hugged him back with need, pulling his head close until his face was buried in her neck.

Vanyra was glad she herself could keep her sanity, and even though she often felt way too fragile to carry this weight on her shoulders that was grief and worry, she could always pay her attention to Fili and Kili. Whenever the younger came home to see his brother and his mother, he always found peace with Vanyra, talking about Mirkwood, the elves and their strange customs. Fili shared his problems on politics and asked for her advice many times, and she gave it gladly. She had always been there for them, ever since they were born, and she knew Thorin wouldn't have wanted it any other way even now.

"The only thing I've done well was the destruction of the Arkenstone," Fili muttered into her neck, breathing in deeply, and Vanyra could feel how his body started trembling. He was close to tears, and she started stroking his back to soothe him, her other hand in his locks, her fingertips rubbing against his head gently. Mothers comforted their children this way, and Vanyra often felt like she was their mother on a certain level. "It can cause no harm now. It can't poison our bloodline. It is gone for good."

Vanyra pressed a kiss against Fili's shoulder, nodding slightly and waiting for Fili to calm down.

"You are your mother's boy," she smiled softly, thinking about how bravely Dís could reason with her sons, with her brothers, with her husband. She was a real dwarven woman. It came from their mother, Rís, and Fili wasn't any different. Kili was more like his grandfather, though, often acting on sudden impulses instead of thinking. Thorin had that in himself as well. "Fierce. Insightful. And that's something your uncle had most certainly been missing."

Fili laughed at that, pulling back so he could wipe the tears from his eyes swiftly, but still holding onto Vanyra's shoulder with one hand. The girl smiled, caressing his hand gently and taking a deep breath.

"I should go back and check up on Dwalin," she sighed, pulling away her hand and stepping back ever so slightly. She turned her gaze back to the tomb for one last time, the massive stone locked with a magic-spell shining in the sunset. She ran her palm over the runes again, smiling sadly as her arm fell back next to her side. "Until next time, Thorin."

Vanyra saw Fili nodding his head ever so slightly, as if he was saying his farewells that way, then he held out a hand for Vanyra. She grinned, snaking her arm around Fili's as they started walking back to the palace, leaving the former King under the Mountain to rest.

***

Time in the land of Aman passed differently than in Middle-Earth. Days felt longer and nights felt warmer. The birds sang in the light and in the dark, stars shone brighter and it sounded like as if they had had their own voices. Minutes were longer, hours felt like days, and it was completely different from everything anyone had ever experienced.

Thorin did not know how long he had walked the eternal halls of Mandos. He knew his soul was peaceful, his mind quiet and his face soft. He did not feel the urge to rush, and the marble stones under his feet were cool against his skin. The long, dark blue robes he wore caressed his skin gently with every step, comforting his body ever so slightly. He loved walking these halls, even though he saw no end of them. It was a quiet place, the echo of a song filling the air as if it came from the far end of Aman. Every statue, every column held beauty, and even those he met during his walk but never spoke to were souls of peace, never of resentment. They were dead, but so was Thorin.

He wasn't alone at least.

Most of them walked through the halls only once, then Thorin had never seen them again. Strange it was, for the once majestic king seemed to be the only one who couldn't find his place. It didn't fill him with worry, though, nor fluster. This calmness never left him, easing his soul with every step. He waited for his fate in silence, endlessly walking and walking every day.

Thorin often saw Mandos sitting on his throne, long beard and grim expression always the same. He never spoke, but the aura of power and wisdom lingered around him at all times and he often eyed Thorin knowingly. The dwarf knew exactly who he faced, therefore he found it impolite to hold his gaze for too long. Instead, he turned around to make another round in the halls, the place bathing in dim light, yet endlessly sublime never ceasing to amaze him completely. Sometimes he would find Mandos gone from his throne, and it filled him with wonder, a thirst that he could not ease. It was wonderful to feel something at times, after all that peace and contentment. Not seeing Mandos was strange, but luckily rare. Thorin felt safer with him around, for without Mandos the halls felt way too spacious as if they were about to swallow him whole. It didn't make him frightened, though, simply uneasy. But Mandos always came back, and continued watching him just as before.

And Thorin continued walking. Right until the day he heard the first proper voice speaking behind him. For then, he stopped for the first time and turned, a warmth spreading inside his chest.

"How long, brother?" the man with blonde locks and honest smile asked him, and Thorin's lips parted in awe. His heart felt like a huge butterfly, fluttering and singing a whole different song from what he kept listening to ever since the first moment he had awaken in these halls. The long forgotten feeling of happiness washed over him, and he stepped closer, extending a hand and placing it on the man's shoulder. He was the same height as him, and he was a dwarf. Thorin's palm touched solid surface, and his fingers dug into the flesh ever so slightly.

He laughed, and it rang incredulously. He was so happy he could not believe it.

"Frerin," he breathed, and the dwarf's smile widened, pulling him in for a hug. And there, in the middle of the halls of Mandos, Doomsman of the Valar, they embraced.

The walk of the dead stopped and they stood, watching the reunion of brothers for long moments. They felt joyous, and the halls of Mandos hadn't seen such happiness between those walls for thousands of years. Thorin laughed into Frerin's shoulder, and the younger let him, holding him closely in his arms.

Thorin was the first to pull away, palming Frerin's face with one hand and holding another on his shoulder still. He feared once he had let him go, he would disappear. And he would not let that happen, not just yet.

"I could not help wondering where you have been," Frerin said, relief and the joy of seeing Thorin once again almost palpable in his voice. He smiled brightly. "This is no place for a dwarf, brother. Elves and men dwell here only, you do not belong here."

Thorin looked around, the walk of dead already moving again. They only glanced at them as they passed, understanding glimmering in their eyes. Thorin had not seen even the tiniest bits of emotions on their faces so far, let alone such generous gifts as sympathy, and his smile grew at the sight.

"I figured that much," Thorin said, turning back to Frerin to meet those grey eyes once again. His brother had the features of their mother, and it rekindled hope in Thorin's heart. "Who else is here, Frerin?"

"Everyone," the younger grabbed his shoulder, pulling him in a direction Thorin had never walked in so far.

He saw the high gate only now, his eyes widening at the sight. Beautifully carved door it was, black as night and huge as a dragon himself, closed tightly. There was light seeping at the bottom, though, and Thorin kept his eyes on it intently. He marched the walk of the dead for a thousand times now, yet he never once saw the door. He wondered for a moment if it was allowed for him to take this path, but Mandos never stopped him.

Thorin let himself be dragged to the door, then looked at Frerin with wonder.

"Is there more to this land?" he asked as if he was at the age of a child and not his brother. Frerin laughed, touching the door gently. It obeyed as a good servant, opening up slowly and letting the light fill the halls in a fraction of a second. Thorin gaped, his eyes welling up with tears at the sight.

Pines stretching as high as the sky, crystal clear blue water that turned into white vapour and the thousand colours of a rainbow at a waterfall with bright unclouded sky awaited him on the other side of the door. The air was fresh and birds sang in the distance - it was Arda showing its most beautiful side, and Thorin wished he could have woken up to this sight every day in his mortal life.

Frerin saw his bewilderment and smiled softly, still holding his hand on Thorin's shoulder and squeezing it ever so slightly. Valinor was a beauty no one should've died to see, but they were here and it was all that mattered in that moment.

"Come," he murmured close to Thorin's ear and pulled him to the left, the older dwarf following him without a word. His eyes still feasted on the sight, seemingly never getting satisfied, but Frerin gave him time to memorize everything. There was so much to remember, and Thorin wanted all of it.

They walked for a while, exchanging words in silence about all the beauty Thorin could lay his eyes on. Frerin then brought him into a garden and showed him the people who spent their time there. There were mostly elves, but Frerin could name every one of the Maiar who happened to show up in the greenery. No higher power than them could be seen there, though, and Frerin decided to sit them down on the soft, sweet grass and let Thorin rest for a while.

Thorin wasn't wearied from the long walks he had taken, for he hadn't even noticed how long he endured without a moment of rest. But Frerin knew, for he was looking for his brother for almost a year now, searching the halls of Aulë again and again. To find him in the halls of Mandos was a surprise, but he understood its meaning swiftly and it made him happy. It meant it wasn't the end for Thorin just yet, that the Valar hadn't decided on his fate. Thorin did not seem to know, though, which was all well.

He would realise later, when his time came.

"So, how you died, brother?" he asked, leaning against a tree with his back. Thorin was running his fingers through the grass, smiling absentmindedly at the feeling. He felt like a child again, reuniting with nature after a long time.

"It was a battle," Thorin looked up, the smile still on his face. He did not feel agitated, and he remembered the last moments with peace in his heart. "A battle against orcs and goblins."

"Nasty death," Frerin frowned, but the knowing look in his eyes stayed. Thorin nodded in silence, turning back to the grass. "What happened?"

Thorin stayed silent for a few moments, the movements of his hand slowing down slightly. He seemed to linger in his memories while Frerin waited for the answer, but the younger was patient. He had known many things on the fate of his brother after his own death, but he wanted to hear certain things from Thorin.

"I was facing the Pale Orc, Azog," Thorin started, his voice silent but never once breaking with aching. There was no pain for the dead, Frerin knew that already. "I made a mistake and let grandfather's sickness take over me as well. By the time I realised it was the Arkenstone, it poisoned my mind and I wasn't myself. I grew reckless in the battle, and Azog pushed my own sword through me."

Frerin gave a sound that made Thorin snap his head immediately, a questioning grin forming on his lips. The younger looked completely shocked, his mouth hanging open with bewilderment.

"Your own sword?" he repeated on a voice at least one octave higher, and Thorin chuckled. He would've found the situation weird on any other day, laughing about his own death with his dead brother, but it was Frerin and, well, he was dead too. There was nothing to feel ashamed for now.

"Its name was Orcrist. It glowed in blue whenever orcs and goblins were close," Thorin explained, shifting closer to the tree as well. The tree-trunk was wide enough for the both of them to comfortably lean against it right next to each other, and as Thorin nestled himself in the grass, his arm was touching Frerin's.

They were both eyeing the distant mountains and hills where the sunlight seemed to turn into gold and melt on the side of the grassy rises. It looked like the endless piles of coins that both Frerin and Thorin admired so while they were little, when Thrór would pull them into the treasure room and tell tales of how he put his hands on such riches. They didn't need words to know that they were thinking of the same memories, recalling the same stories, and they both smiled at the breathtaking scenery in front of them.

The silence between them was comfortable and lasted for minutes before Thorin spoke, his voice low and calm.

"I am sorry I couldn't be there with you," the dwarf murmured. Frerin turned his head, confusion creasing his brows as he looked at his brother.

"When?"

"When you died."

It would've hurt on any other day, but not then and not there. Frerin smiled and it occured to him for the first time that forgiveness must have been strange and new for Thorin. Valinor gave a new beginning to everyone, even if they were dead or alive. Elves and Men rarely left the halls of Mandos, for they went on different ways than Dwarves. Dwarves were waiting for the Last Battle, though, and their former lives were all but forgotten.

And forgiven.

So Thorin really gets a second chance, then, he thought to himself as the warmth of joy washed over him. Thorin looked at him and did not understand, the mistakes of his life still burning him from the inside. He would have a chance to atone for them.

"It was swift and you felt enough pain about it afterwards, so forget about it," Frerin grinned, wrapping his arm around Thorin's shoulder and pulling him closer. The older dwarf didn't seem less confused, but Frerin didn't give him the chance to ask for explanation. "But you, you had someone by your side, didn't you? Tell me about him."

Not like he did not know every single detail about Bilbo Baggins from the Shire, but it was something else that he would've also preferred to hear from Thorin. He knew of the spell of Estë and Irmo, and he knew how many of the Valar were piqued for it. But Estë was wise and her husband willing to see the halfling happy - a halfling who happened to come across the greatest evil of Arda and still being able to keep his sanity. He deserved happiness, and Irmo had it in his power to give it to him.

And what caused happiness to Bilbo, even if it demanded great sacrifices along the way, caused happiness to Thorin, and Frerin was endlessly grateful for everything the Valar had done.

The smile on Thorin's face at the mention of the hobbit was brighter than the sun, and Frerin needed to restrain himself from giggling like a child. He had never seen his brother in love, and it lifted his soul to unimaginable heights to see that joy in the otherwise worried lines of his face.

"He is a hobbit," Thorin murmured, his eyes staring at a point somewhere in the distance. He smiled gently, imagining every single detail of the burglar's face in front of his eyes. From the honey coloured hair until those perfect lips, the kind eyes and round cheeks, the small hands and short legs, and what was the most beautiful about him, his soul. He adored everything about Bilbo Baggins, and the love washed through him in waves without him even noticing. "He is the best thing that ever happened to me, Frerin. And he was there, right until the end."

"You are a real softie, Thorin," Frerin grinned, not being able to hold back the comment for any longer, and Thorin punched him on the shoulder gently. They laughed for a while, none of them really knowing the reason, but they soon regained their calmness and the dreamy expression returned to Thorin's face.

"Remember how father always wanted me to court Vanyra?" he mused, staring up at the bright blue sky above them. Frerin nodded, watching Thorin's face carefully with a small smile. "I could never find it in myself to fall in love, but then Bilbo came and everything changed. Had I not gotten under the spell of that cursed piece of stone, I would have married him, Frerin. I have made mistakes instead that I would never be able to forgive myself for. He would never forgive me either. It was for the better that I died, probably."

Frerin almost started laughing again. Thorin did love to be dramatic at times, but Frerin thought he would grow it out. Now, though, as he listened to his brother's words, he caught himself shaking his head ever so slightly.

"You are so wrong, brother," he said, earning a curious look from Thorin. Frerin stood then, pulling up the older dwarf with him and grabbing his shoulders. "You jumped between a wolf and your brother to save him and took the wound for him. You fought wars you weren't meant to fight, you made sacrifices you weren't meant to make. You were brave where everyone else was afraid and you gave hope to your people. You learned to love, and you were a fair and just king. The sickness took you, but your friends don't remember you that way. You will see that soon, brother. You will be forgiven, trust me."

Thorin's face was downright confused now, not understanding anything of what Frerin just said, but he let himself nevertheless when the younger dwarf pulled him into a hug again. His words held a finality that Thorin tried to ignore but couldn't, and, for the first moment since he walked Aman he felt a small knot of fear spreading on the bottom of his stomach. He hugged back with fierce arms, holding Frerin in one place with closed eyes.

"Why did you say those things, Frerin?" he muttered into his shoulder, his voice suddenly smaller than before and Frerin smiled.

"Because they are true."

When they let go, Thorin already knew that it was the end of something. The birds grew silent, and he could only hear the sound of his own heartbeat in his ear, throbbing harder and harder with every breath he took. Frerin kept his gaze, his hand slowly slipping from Thorin's shoulder as he stepped back.

"This is not the last time we meet," he promised, his face full of light and joy. "And it is most certainly not your last time in Valinor, Thorin."

Thorin wanted to ask questions, but he had not the chance.

The greenery disappeared from around him, and so did Frerin.

Notes:

So, here we go. Two chapters left and we are here, at the doorstep of the end. I was so emotional while writing this, and I just couldn't resist bringing Frerin in. He is too precious for my heart.

I might be able to bring the last two chapters only on Sunday, for I'm going on a vacation to visit my gorgeous Ivana tomorrow and I won't be at home until the end of the week. Nevertheless, I will bring the last two chapters on the same day, so watch out for both! : )