Actions

Work Header

Hope, Love, and Glory

Chapter 18: Dwalin's story

Summary:

Ori hates that forest, and thinks again of a conversation with Dwalin.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Ori hated that forest. He had never liked them as a rule, but he hated that one even more than any other before. His recent bad memories involving trees might be to blame for that, of course, though the other had been less close to... immediate peril than he had been when they'd climbed in that tree to escape the orcs, and yet they seemed equally affected by Mirkwood. Something about these woods made them feel watched, and the air felt unmoving. Sometimes Ori feared he might choke.

It would not have been so bad if he had been with Kili. Among other things, the prince made him feel safe, and he always found a way to distract him from whatever bad things were happening around them. It had always been like that, and Ori hope it would never change.

But Kili would not leave his brother's side, not since the whole... incident, a few days earlier. And while Ori rather liked the oldest prince (bit of an ass sometimes, but less than his uncle, and he was clever, and he was kinder than the small scholar had ever expected), he could not be anywhere near him at the moment, or he might... tell him things.

Things he had promised to keep secret.

Dwalin had been quite adamant about it, that day. No one was to know of it. His telling Ori was a proof of his most absolute trust and no one, especially not Fili, was to know of it.


 

Bilbo and him had found the warrior behind Beorn's house, exactly where Fili had said he'd seen him for the last time. Dwalin looked...

broken

Ori could find no other word for it. The only times his friend had looked like that before, it had been when recalling the horrors of Azanulbizar. No matter what Balin and Thorin had told him, their words had to have been designed to hurt and harm.

"I don't want to talk," Dwalin snapped when he saw them approaching. "Go away."

"We're not the sort to leave a friend in pain," Bilbo protested. "And you are our friend. It might not be much, but if there's anything we can do to..."

"Ye can't do a thing, halfling. It doesn't concern ye. Leave me alone."

"Well, if it doesn't concern him, it concerns me," Ori declared firmly. "We are friends, mister Dwalin, and you said yourself you felt for me as a brother. And what sort of brother would I be to see you suffer and be badly treated by anyone, without offering you all the comfort I can give you?"

"Not now, lad."

" Yes, now, mister Dwalin! You can send away mister Baggins if you want, but I'm not going, and that's final. It'd be like leaving Kili alone, only worse because Kili would at least always have Fili, whereas you... Well. I'd never judge mister Balin of course, and he's a very kind dwarf, and I owe him a lot. But what he seems to have done, that doesn't feel very fair or nice."

The warrior gave him a small, sad smile then, as he sometimes did when Ori made such declarations of friendship.

"Fair enough, lad. But ye, halfling..."

"Oh, I think I'll go," Bilbo cut him. "I promised Fili I'd make sure you were well, and you seem to be, that's all I wanted to know. But no matter what's going on, I do hope you'll come back soon. The poor boy is very worried about you. I know it's not my place to say that, but he likes you terribly, and though I don't really know what is going on here, I must say that I'll be terribly cross if you or anyone else hurt him in any way."

“Is that a threat, halfling?”

“Only if you have any intention to harm my friend, dwarf.”

With that, Bilbo gave a firm little nod and left them, looking very decisive as he walked away. Ori would have found it almost funny if the others hadn't told him that Bilbo had killed an orc to protect Thorin, whom everyone knew he was in love with. Hobbits. Cuddly, but dangerous.

“I'll have to be careful around him,” Dwalin said with a half smile, echoing Ori's thoughts. “He'll stab me in my sleep with that toy of his if I'm not careful.”

“Do you plan on hurting Fili, then?”

“I've done it already, lad. Should never had gotten close to him, Balin's right.”

Ori frowned. He knew that Balin, for unknown reason, firmly disapproved of his brother's interest for the prince. He also knew that Thorin too disapproved, for reason equally unknown but probably very similar.

“You love Fili,” the young scholar pointed out. “And there's no doubt that he likes you too. He hasn't really made it secret, has he? So I fail to see why there's a problem.”

“It's more complicated than that, lad.”

“So you've said, mister Dwalin. You've even said it often, actually, but you've never said why.”

“Not my hour of glory,” the warrior sighed, looking away. “It's not that I don't trust ye, lad. It's just... I like ye, and I don't want ye to think ill of me.”

“I won't force you if you don't want to talk of it, mister Dwalin. But if Balin and Thorin know and they're against it, wouldn't you have also someone who knows and is convinced that nothing you can say will make you unfit for Fili? Unless you're secretly his father. That's where I'd draw the line.”

That made Dwalin grin, if nothing else.

“I'm not, lad. And I'll tell ye, but I'll ask ye to not repeat it to a single soul. I'm sure half the company knows or has heard things, but I'd rather not have them sure of things.”

“I won't breathe a word, I promise. On my honour.”

Dwalin nodded, as if to acknowledge Ori's declaration, but he remained silent, fidgeting and refusing to meet the younger one's eyes.

“If you'd rather not talk...” the young one started.

“No, I... I'm just not proud of it all, lad, and the wound isn't as healed as I once thought. But I... when I was young, in Erebor, Thorin and I were involved.”

“When you say involved...”

“I mean lovers, yes,” Dwalin admitted grimly. “My brother was Thorin's advisor and teacher. 'Royal babysitter' he called it, but he was more than glad to do it. Good job. Didn't take long for me to meet Thorin and... you've seen him, lad. You know how he affects people. Imagine him a hundred years younger, and the prettiest damn face a dwarf had ever had. Half the court was in love with him, and out of all that, he picked me. There's nothing I wouldn't have done for him.”

“And what would he have done for you?”

“He took me to his bed, that's all I dared to ask at first,” Dwalin sighed. “He didn't love me, not at first anyway, but I was... convenient. During the days we trained together, and at night we'd do whatever he'd want to do. Lasted like that for a couple years, then the dragon came. Thorin changed after that, in good and bad. Treated me as more than a bed warmer, for one thing. I was more in love than ever, and I think he started to actually like me. He trusted me, anyway, and from him, that's even more precious than love I suppose. After Dis married and had Fili, he started talking about taking me as a consort.”

“So he did love you, then?”

“No, probably not. Just needed someone he could count on, someone safe who'd never betray him. I was reliable. I knew I'd never be more than that, more than that person who stood by him and supported him in everything. I was good at taking his side, even when he was a bloody idiot. So many people were doubting him because he was so young, and his grand-father was half mad, everyone knew it, and his father was... fragile. Thorin had to be strong, and he needed someone to never doubt him. I was that someone. Made me so damn happy that of all the dwarves that had fled Erebor, I was the one he trusted. I think it made him happy too. Always hard to say with him.”

Ori listened, trying to imagine a younger Thorin and Dwalin, side by side against the people who doubted the young prince. It was all too easy to picture it, when even now they had sometimes had moments of complicity. They always fought together the way only very old, very close friends did. And Ori had always thought it was just that, that they had been very good friends.

He could see how that might make things more complicated with Fili.

“What happened then?” the young dwarf asked. “You don't seem... quite so close now.”

“Azanulbizar happened. I was... He'd asked me to keep his brother alive, and I failed him. Frerin died, and Gili too. That's... he was Fili and Kili's father. And those two good dwarves died because I wasn't good enough. Thorin never forgave me. Made me come to his tent after the battle, told me everything was over. I'd never be his consort. I wouldn't be his lover any more, or even his friend. Said I could stay if I wanted, but he'd rather have me leave. So I left. Too hard to stay around him like that. I loved him.”

Ori didn't know what to say. Part of him was furious at their king for having been so unfair and having hurt someone who cared so much about him, but mostly he was worried at how much Dwalin still seemed affected by it. He couldn't help but wonder if it was because the warrior still obviously cared a lot for the king that Thorin and Balin disapproved of his interest in Fili.

Not that he suspected Dwalin to be using the young prince as a substitute. Dwalin was a kind, honourable dwarf who would never do something that dreadful, Ori was quite sure of it. But the others might think it possible.

“I'm really sorry for what happened,” he eventually said, having found no better words. “It... you didn't deserve that.”

“Balin thinks I want Fili because he's like Thorin,” Dwalin replied, confirming his friend's suspicions.

“Well, do you?”

The warrior hesitated. “There's a lot of Thorin in him,” he admitted. “He's proud, and he's stubborn, and he wants what's best for those around him. But...”

“But?”

“He's not as proud and stubborn as his uncle, not by far,” Dwalin explained with a sad, fond smile. “And he wouldn't let that hurt those he cares for. Had he been in his uncle's place, we'd all be in Ered Luin still, because he wouldn't want to waste anyone's life on a foolish quest for a kingdom we've learnt to live without. And he's got humour too. Thorin never had much of that, never been very good at just relaxing and having fun while there was time. Fili enjoys life. Still remember when I met him. The lad was in prison for the night, and he flirted with me as if that was the most normal of things. It had been a while since I'd laughed that much.”

“So, they're different enough, right? I wouldn't worry to much if I were you.”

Dwalin gave him a sad smile, and for a few second, Ori felt sure that everything was going to be right.

Until Balin joined them.

It was impressive, in a way.

It only took the older dwarf a few minutes to entirely convince his brother that he would be doing Fili a great disservice if he persisted with their little affair.

“You want to get back at Thorin, and I can understand that, but why should the boy suffer for it? Sooner or later, you'll be forced to admit it's not him you want, but your old lover, and what will you do then? Break his heart and cast him away to go back with Thorin? You're better than that, brother, and the lad deserves better too.”

“But it's not like that!” Ori tried to protest. “He loves Fili, and he doesn't want Thorin back!”

“Well, I'm sad to see my brother has lied to himself so well that he's convinced you too, laddie. But don't you think I know him better than you do? And you, Dwalin, stop acting like an elf in love, and do the right thing. Put an end to your little fling with the prince before anyone gets hurt, it will be best for everyone involved.”

The warrior still appeared to hesitate, and Balin scowled at him.

“Really, brother, do you want to do to him what Thorin did to you?”

And with that, Ori knew that it was lost.

Dwalin lowered his head in defeat.

They went back inside together, and the warrior talked to the prince.

Ori had never felt more angry in his life.


 

And there they were now. Stuck in a forest. Fili pretending he wasn't heart-broken. Dwalin pretending he wasn't fighting every minute of the day to go back to the prince. Balin and Thorin pretending that they didn't see the distress of the other two. And the rest of the company pretending that there was nothing going on.

Ori hated that forest.

And they had only just got there.

Notes:

You know I'm feeling sorry for the characters involved when I can't even try to slip a joke in the middle of all the angst D:
I'll try to have a funnier chapter next time, but it's getting difficult, for obvious reasons.

Anyway, I hope those of you who had grown to hate or dislike Dwalin will forgive him his decision a little? D: