Chapter Text
AN: Welcome to the drama arch ;D
Chapter 28 - Imperfections in the Glass
“You could have just asked for more time for this instead of skipping out on sleep,” Kíli remarked as Thorin looked over Fíli’s work.
“Just because I’m not heir doesn’t mean I don’t have a responsibility to our Kingdom.”
That caused both Thorin and Frerin to chuckle.
Thorin handed the necklace back to Fíli, “I’m pleased you learned to work with mithril so quickly. Your One cannot say your offering is poor now. As for this not being a duty of the crown, I promise your grandmother would have strongly disagreed.”
Frerin snorted, “She’s still rolling in her grave with how long Thorin took to find his One.”
“She’s rolling because of your marital status, little brother,” Thorin teased.
Frerin flashed Thorin a wide smile, they so seldom jested about their parents, “I was busy being the favourite uncle.”
Thorin laughed.
Fíli exchanged a smile with Kíli, it was such a relief to have their uncles smiling and joking so freely. Erebor was new to them, far from any home they had known before, but their family’s unburdened happiness made it the home they both wanted to call their own.
“Speaking of approval,” Frerin said. “Kíli and I crafted this box for you.”
Kíli held open the box that fit the necklace perfectly. “Ori knitted the scarf.”
Fíli loved his family as he gently laid his creation down onto the soft fabric.
Kíli shut the box, revealing the Durin family crest etched into a plate of gold.
Fíli ran his fingers over it, and he looked up to find Thorin smiling at him, “We want you happy, dearest Fíli, and we want your One to be happy as well.”
What else could he do but go put his heart on the line again?
Succeed or fail, his family would never desert him.
oOo
Sonna couldn’t deny Fíli when he asked to see her that night after her shift. Not when he asked her on the night before her day off.
She had no excuses to hide behind if Master Oin was sharing her schedule.
They met near the treasure room, where reliefs of the great kings of the past looked down on them.
Sonna reached into her pocket and, for the hundredth time, regretted having lost her aster flower. She couldn’t even remember where she had dropped it.
Fíli sat alone on one of the green stone benches, his hands folded over a box on his lap. His expression was carefully closed off as he watched her approach.
It was her fault that he gazed on her with such reservations, but the young dwarrowdam, newly orphaned, was not the Sonna who approached him tonight.
Tonight, she knew her worth, and she knew she would give this prince a chance for all that she had learned of him since turning him down. Fíli’s reputation for kindness and dedication to those he loved made him the exact sort of dwarf she dreamed of on the rare occasions she allowed herself to dream of a better future for herself.
“Good evening, Prince Fíli, Son of Princess Dís” she greeted.
“Good evening,” he echoed. “Lady Sonna, Apprentice of Master Healer Oin.”
She sat primly next to him, straightening her skirts to give her hands something to do.
“How do you like Erebor so far?” Fíli asked.
She shrugged, “It’s growing on me as the repairs advance. The threat from the south makes it difficult to grow comfortable though.”
He nodded, “I’m not eager for the battles ahead either. It is a relief to me that my Dah and Uncle have made peace with the elves.”
“Certainly better than being at war with them,” she agreed.
Fíli bit his lip before squaring his shoulders. “I know it is not proper to offer another courting gift after you made your feelings clear. But I had hoped the cultural misunderstandings… that is… that I meant you no disrespect. The courting among my father’s people is far less formal yet with many more intermediate steps.”
He held out the box, “In the way of my mother’s blood and my birth father’s, I hope you will find this gift worthy of you.”
Sonna steadied her own breathing as she accepted the box. The wood was finely made, and the crest told her as clearly as any declaration that King Thorin had approved of their courting personally.
Swallowing hard, she opened the box.
She forgot how to breathe.
Inside the box on a Durin blue knit scarf sat a large chain of mithral with golden vines and with flowers set with precious gems.
Yet what was most precious were the organic flowers pressed in glass that hung from the chain. The centre piece was her lost Aster.
She couldn’t speak.
This meant too much to her.
“I was always going to return it to you. When I saw that you kept the purple aster, I hoped that hadn’t fully offended you.”
She cleared her throat, finally braving to meet the young prince’s gaze.
“I was never offended.”
He nodded, “I’m just not who you wanted.”
Her heart constricted, knowing in her bones that this dwarf was her One, her other half, despite how ridiculous her being his One seemed.
She shook her head, “When last we met–”
“I was disrespectful and poor,” he completed, reflecting her callous words back at her.
She flinched, “No, Fíli. I mean, that is to say, I had no one. My survival depended on the kindness of your family. My father had just been executed and I didn't know my own worth. I said what I did to push you away, to make you dislike me. Because I wasn’t ready then.”
“You may take your time, Lady Sonna. I can wait for when you feel comfortable. I would wait forever for you. I would just like you to know my feelings, I believe you are my One. And I would be honoured by your friendship if you wish me to never bring this up again.”
She smiled, running a finger over the familiar glass; there was a tiny crack along the edge where she had dropped it.
She was strangely pleased that Fíli had kept it, the feature that made it imperfect for an otherwise perfect creation of mithral, gold, and glass, so its history would not be lost.
“I'm no longer the same person I was in Ered Luin. I am Healer Oin’s apprentice, and I have earned my position. I have my own coin, I'm valued in our society now. No one can take those truths from me.”
Fíli nodded but disagreed, “You were always valued, Sonna, that is not something you should have felt you had to earn. To seek a contented life while harming none is no shame, but I am glad for the security you've found. Your pride in your craft and position, that, is well earned, and I admire you all the more for it.”
She laughed, “You don't sound like any dwarf I've met before.”
“I'm sorry–”
She reached out to take his hand in hers. “I meant that as a compliment. My father was the worst sort of dwarf, the sort who relies on greed, ambition, and a quick temper. I've seen you Fíli, Son of Dís, Son of Bilbo Baggins from the Kindly West, you are none of those things, and I am honoured by your admiration.”
Fíli seemed to be at a loss for words.
“I accept your courting gift,” she said, squeezing his hand. “And I look forward to being introduced to your family as your One, as I believe you are mine.”
Fíli’s smile was more golden than his hair. He raised her hand gently to his lips, kissing her knuckles with a feather light touch, “It is I who is honoured, Lady Sonna.”
She blushed, her heart fluttering with the idea that her heart had found such a gentle-dwarf to embark on her life’s journey with her.
oOo
Bilbo squawked when Thorin scooped him bodily out of his desk chair.
“You should not be working so much,” his Heartsong chided.
Bilbo huffed at him even as he welcomed Thorin’s embrace.
“I hardly get enough done, if you gave me more-“
“The work you do is more than enough.”
“It’s dwarrow who want everything written down,” Bilbo argued and seeing them take a different tunnel whined. “I don’t need to go to the healers today.”
“It’s not that, we found something else I want to show you.”
Bilbo smiled at the childlike excitement on Thorin’s expression, making him look more like his nephews.
They walked by the healer’s halls to a backroom, through a closet.
And through another secret door, was revealed to an outside pavilion.
It was bare save for a few empty planters and a large stone box.
“It’s an icebox,” Thorin said. He pointed to an overhang, “This place has a bit of a dark history. For those with contagious diseases or if there were those who needed to be treated with fresh air.”
“Not a common treatment for dwarrow,” Bilbo remarked.
“No, it’s not, but even we need fresh air. I know that you would like to keep working, Amrâlimê. And winter comes on swift wings, so no building could begin until the winter thaw. I would rather you begin planning your garden than stressing about politics.”
Bilbo laid a hand over his heart, “My garden?”
“This place is protected and connected to the new royal wing, you could spend as much time here as you like, soak up the sun and feast your toes on soil. I know I promised your people homes on our mountainside; however, I would prefer you and our children closer to me.”
Bilbo raised his hands to Thorin’s cheeks, “A garden, for our children?”
Thorin lowered his head to press their foreheads together, “Unless you think this place–”
“It’s perfect, our children will be born in the Halls of Healing, what greater blessing could we give our Kingdom than that?”
Thorin kissed him, and continued to kiss him as the sun set and they lingered in the chill air.
oOo
Sonna didn’t know why she was so nervous to meet a hobbit.
Her father would have laughed himself sick if he knew how frightened she was.
He would have called her pathetic.
But this was Bilbo Baggins, the hobbit who had helped to slay a dragon and the King Consort to King Oakenshield.
Sonna took a deep breath and knocked.
The door was opened a moment later, and she looked down at the small figure with his pointed ears and bare hairy feet.
He smiled at her, “Lady Sonna, a pleasure to meet you. Bilbo Baggins, at your service, come in, come in. ”
She bowed, “Sonna, Apprentice of Healer Oin, it is my pleasure, King Consort–”
Bilbo waved a hand to beckon her in, “None of that now, Bilbo will do just fine.”
She followed him into his suite, which was cleaner than most other rooms in Erebor outside the healing halls, and there was filtered light coming into the room shining down on a tree whose leaves sparkled as if brushed with gold.
“It was a rare find,” Bilbo said to her. “These rooms, that is. They were closed up before Thorin's grandfather was born, the Raven’s Wing, it's called. No enemy could get into these rooms, not with how many meters thick the sky vents are, but the ravens can. Apparently, the old kings were bothered by the easy access.”
“King Thorin doesn't mind?” she asked, taking the tea gladly for want of something to do with her hands.
These rooms were near enough to where she worked that she wondered if this royal family would remain closer to their people by design.
It would make sense, unlike his grandfather, King Thorin had led his people shoulder to shoulder in the trenches of toil.
They sat for tea beneath the tree, a silver tea set painted with blue lacquer flowers waited for them along with a number of sweets.
Bilbo's expression softened fondly as he spoke of the King, “He picked this room for me. This region of Erebor is close enough to the old royal wing to not be a hindrance to governance and large enough that the company and their extended families can grow into them. He also tells me that outside this part of the mountain is where the great hobbit smials will begin to be built, there's a protected plateau that seems well suited to future cultivation.”
She shook her head, “I'm still awed that your people would be so willing to move.”
Bilbo shrugged, “I think strongly adverse to war is a more accurate thing to say than willingly . Mind you, if we had nowhere safe left to go, I would imagine we would fight until we were forced out. Alas, that is no longer a choice we must make thanks to the dwarrow of Ered Luin and Erebor.”
Sonna blinked, “That’s still more grace than I would have expected.”
Bilbo laughed, “Grace is not what you’ll call it if you ever meet my cousin Lobelia, I assure you. I am perhaps more glib than most as I’ve already said my goodbyes to Bag End. I’ve considered my family to be my home for quite some time now.”
Sonna smiled behind a sip of tea, “Glad I am to find my One who has even a fraction of your kindness, King Consort.”
Bilbo laughed, “Ah, a sweet talker, I believe you and I will get along quite well. Now, tell me of your adventures since leaving Ered Luin. Oin has spoken very fondly of you as the sharpest apprentice he's ever had.”
She flushed, “Your son's trade is surely more exciting.”
Bilbo clucked his tongue, “What nonsense, Fíli takes after his mother and uncle, but healing was my mother's trade and my stepson's trade. I myself am considered somewhat a healer, or a chemist, though it's more true to say I'm a specialised gardener in herbs and roots.”
Sonna touched her necklace, “Your son took after you more than you think.”
Bilbo's eyes brightened as he leaned closer to look. “Quite a beautiful piece, and a lovely marriage between our two cultures. H3 picked those along the road, and I'm so glad they weren't lost inside my journal. I've always been fond of pressed flowers, but don't be discouraged when they fade. Pressed flowers are memories that age with us and remind us that the present, the love we hold before us, is more beautiful than the past.”
Sonna felt her heart skip a beat.
The flowers would fade?
She had noticed that the flowers weren’t as bright as the day she got them but surely…
“My dear?” Bilbo asked.
Sonna blinked back tears, “I’m sorry, I just hadn’t realised… I should have, of course, they are still flowers even pressed beneath glass. Dwarrow, we make a thing last. What good is it if it can’t last?”
She winced when she realised she had said the last part aloud.
But Bilbo only huffed, “Ah, but that is like asking what good is a meal after it is eaten, or a life once it is lived. A memory cannot be shared in its wholality, but an experience may be, a story can be shared. Is a book not worth its writing if fire claims it one day? All things age, Lady Sonna, all things meet their end one day, yet the journey remains worth taking.”
She nodded, a bit overwhelmed. She reached up to unclasp the necklace. “Would you tell me what the flowers mean please?”
Bilbo nodded, holding out his hand, his fingers tracing over the glass of the purple aster, “Purple is often a mark of royalty or nobility, as well as a mark of wisdom. This was the first flower he gave you, no?”
She nodded, “Yes, but how did you know?”
“The arrangement can be as meaningful as the bloom. He knew you were a healer's apprentice, did he not?”
“That's how we met.”
Bilbo smiled fondly. “Then this message is very plain. Hobbits, we have our lines of succession, our own pride and classes. In station, as a prince of the line of Durin, had you given him this bloom it would have been very unromantic indeed.
“It's something you might give your landlord who was kind to you during a poor harvest or brought you a meal after a new faunt was born. But for him to give it to you is to renounce his rank. A way of saying you have permission to address him without a title if you accepted his courtship. It was also a sign of his respect and admiration for your craft. He wouldn't have given a purple aster to a gardener because that career is seen as a passion of birth, not always a choice. Whereas being a healer is seen as a huge commitment and responsibility to others. The purple aster is a statement to all that you are deserving of admiration beyond romantic interest.”
Sonna’s heart thundered, “Relinquished his title as prince, for me?”
Bilbo smiled, “He didn't forswear his family and birthplace, no, he merely stated that between you and him there is no inequality, that he would be honoured by your use of his given name. To see him first as a dwarf before his rank or concern for your own.”
Sonna felt almost sick, because even in not knowing her well, his first gift to her would have been a balm to her fears.
“And if I had used his title?”
“To not accept a flower is to spit in a hobbit's face. I’ve never even done that to my cousin. But if you immediately used his title, it would have been a rejection of his suit. The first courting gift among hobbits is always something that can be easily rejected without shaming either party, most believe that admiration can bloom into either friendship or romantic intentions. Typically, the first courting gesture with any declaration is to be done before the other’s family. Until then, affections are passed between young ones until they get to know one another.”
Sonna was definitely going to be sick, “I thought— I thought hobbits were like dwarrow, I thought your Ones were called Heartsongs, destined. How can courting be… a pursuit of romance or friendship?”
Bilbo hummed, “My Heartsong was a dwarf, it may be that we were already destined. By the time I heard him sing, I was already quite befuddled. But my father had heard my mother sing throughout their childhoods and at parties, but it wasn’t until my mother opened her heart to him that their songs changed to fit one another. Everyone we meet changes us to some degree, as every experience shapes us. Not every hobbit meets their Heartsong, and I know some hobbits who were married for twenty years before their songs matched each other’s hearts.”
“They married without knowing they were each other’s Ones?”
“I’ve heard dwarves have been known to do the same, mostly for the desire for children, if I understand correctly. Hobbits are much the same, but a Heartsong is less rigid. If you love your partner, even if you were perhaps meant for another, your love for your spouse would prevent you from becoming the person who would have shared a heart with that other. Again, Ones and Heartsongs are not interchangeable.”
“By dwarf standards, giving me flowers as a courting gift like these means I’m worth only as much as weeds, that my beauty is fleeting. A joke, a denial of fate.”
Bilbo smiled at her, “Yet you knew that was not his intention, even if you didn’t understand the message.”
“I kept the flowers, but I used his titles.”
Bilbo nodded, “But you accepted his second courting gift.” Then he continued to translate Fíli’s gift, “Lavender, strength and healing, a representation of you, your beauty, your strength, and your gift for healing others. Potentilla, courage and endurance, yours. Snowdrops, hope and new beginnings.
“Translated into the Common Speech, it means that you are a soul whose generosity and wisdom far supersede your noble beauty, that he sees and respects your strength and the trials you’ve overcome. That even unrequited, his love for you is eternal, and its purity of feeling enriches his life whether or not you ever accept him.”
Sonna blinked back tears and immediately failed, feeling in her heart that the flowers spoke more eloquently than any other language and that hobbit traditions were the gentlest of all the free races of Middle Earth.
And twice as devastating for the same reason.
Bilbo offered her a clean handkerchief.
“I’m told gems and jewels can deliver similar messages, the elves certainly have the words to speak their meaning; men live too immediately to be overly bogged down by sentiment. But for my own, even more loving than the Green Speech is the language of flowers, an art much more than mere symbolism.”
Sonna could only nod in agreement as she dapped at her tears.
She would never value a material gift more than this one even when it came time to be passed down to her children or grandchildren and the flowers had all greyed and browned, it would forever be the most precious thing she owned.
Not for the mithral or the gold or the finest of precious gems chosen meticulously from the treasury of Erebor, but for the love and compassion of the blooms her One had chosen for her as he crossed Middle Earth.
oOo
Bilbo had relented as Thorin had requested in letting others do the work that the Consort was supposed to do.
He was somewhat comfortable in this, knowing that as Glorifindal was King Thranduil’s current ambassador, that his Adar would give the dwarrow more than fair deals.
What was he doing instead? Planning his garden. He was not an architect, but he had been shown where the light would fall depending on the season and he knew what his plants needed. It was no guarantee that they would grow well so far from the Yavannah’s blessed lands of the Shire, but Bilbo would do his best as one of her children to provide for these future gardens.
Going over his lists of plants and the blueprint he had been given, he was interrupted by a knock on his door.
Looking up, Bilbo called, “Come in.”
The door opened to reveal a dwarf he had never met before, who bowed immediately upon making eye contact, “King Consort, Lord Bilbo Baggins, Son of Glorfindel.”
“Can I help you–” Bilbo asked, pausing for an introduction.
The stranger did not give his name, just his purpose, “Lord Balin sent me with a document, my Lord.” The dwarf gave another bow.
“Well, let’s see it then,” Bilbo said with a sigh, surprised Balin wouldn’t stop by himself.
When the document was opened, breaking Thorin's own seal, Bilbo was a bit mortified it wasn’t Thorin presenting this to him.
Dwarrow and their contracts.
“Is this really necessary?” Bilbo sighed as he flipped through it, slowing as certain terminology stood out to him. “Did the King write this?”
“It was written with you in mind, my Lord. The language needed to be changed because of your background,” the dwarf explained.
Bilbo was about to chastise the tone when his eyes stumbled over a phrase.
“Get out,” he demanded.
“You need to sign with a witness, my Lord,” the dwarf argued.
“I said, get out . That was an order.”
The dwarf scurried out and Bilbo started reading the contract from the beginning, hoping that he had misunderstood.
Of course, he hadn’t.
Unadulterated rage burned in Bilbo’s gut as the legalities tore apart all that Thorin and he had dreamed about their futures.
It was one thing to ask that their hobbit fauntlings be removed from the line of succession; a part of Bilbo would be relieved if they were. After all, dwarven kings were expected to lead their people in war.
But this contract removed not just Bilbo’s blood kin, but Fíli from the line of succession.
How could Thorin do this? How could Balin?
The parts of the contract that stripped Bilbo of any authority were secondary to that, but no less offensive, as it broke all the promises that Thorin had made him.
The hobbits will own no part of the treasury nor property in any dwarven kingdom in his own name.
Bilbo reread the contract until he could recite it.
Then he crumpled the entirely unacceptable ‘marriage contract’ and shoved it into the bottom of his desk before he marched back to their rooms to wait for his ‘dear husband.’
oOo
Thorin was late getting home. He seldom missed supper, but he was being stretched thin as fixing Erebor became less practical and more intricate now that most obvious damage was being dealt with.
He was prepared to apologise to Bilbo but he paused when he found his supper beneath a lone serving tray on their large dining room table.
Normally, if he was late, Bilbo would clean up and make Thorin something small or reheat it himself when Thorin returned.
He was a bit embarrassed by his own disappointment at the meal left out to cool.
When he had grown so spoiled despite his One only being a few weeks out of bedrest?
Thorin sat down to eat his cold meal without complaint and was sure to clean up and scrub the dishes himself afterwards despite the exhaustion pulling on him.
When he entered the bedroom, the air felt cold despite the roaring fireplace.
Bilbo was sitting up, reading a book about dwarven law that Ori had found in the library that was written in Common.
He looked up at Thorin with an unreadable expression, with no word of greeting.
Thorin fought the urge to fidget and apologised, “I’m sorry I was late tonight. I’ll try to remember to send word if I get that late again.”
“I’m sure you’re very busy.”
Thorin winced as he began to strip down to get into bed, “It’s nothing to worry about, just more voices trying to be heard.”
“I’m glad you were spared the annoyance of mine, then.”
Thorin froze, turning to his One, “No, Ghivashel. That’s not at all what I meant. Your rest is more important than–”
“Is that what you want to talk about tonight?” Bilbo asked as he sharply interrupted.
“Um, I suppose not. I’m sorry, love. Is there something you would like to discuss?”
“Like to? No, but is there something you need to discuss with me?”
Thorin’s mind whirled, when he came up blank, he questioned, “No?”
Bilbo’s entire expression closed down, “Fine, then.”
“Bilbo, what’s wrong?” Thorin asked, reaching out to him over the bed.
But Bilbo flinched back from him, “Nothing. Nothing is wrong. I want to go to sleep.”
Thorin retreated, “Of course, I’m–”
He bit his tongue as he watched Bilbo turn off his side-table lamp and set aside his book.
Thorin hurried to get turned in as well. His heart sank when he reached out to Bilbo, and his hobbit turned his back on him, away from his touch.
It was the first night they had shared a bed or a bedroll that Bilbo pulled away.
The first night Thorin felt lonely this close to his Heartsong.
He didn’t know what was wrong but he vowed he would discover the cause and mend this rift between them.
He bore down on the pain in his heart, knowing that he must have done something wrong to deserve it.
oOo
Bilbo felt as if Thorin had plunged a dagger through his heart.
Not only did Thorin not deign to discuss the marriage contract with him before writing up a draft but he thought it was such a standard thing that they had no cause to discuss it before or after his signing of it.
To not even question if he would sign it.
But Bilbo was a Baggins and would not sign a contract that waved his rights, the rights of Thorin's children, nor Fíli’s rights away.
Surely when Dís arrived she would take Bilbo's side in this, even if Thorin and Balin had betrayed him like this.
It was a good thing Bilbo had long ago learned to cry quietly.
Thorin didn't deserve to see the pain he caused, Bilbo would not allow him to change the contract merely because of his tears.
No, Thorin would rewrite the damn contract himself and propose a formal dwarven marriage, romantically, because it was what they both deserved.
His Heartsong had made him promises, Bilbo would ensure the King of Erebor would stay true to them, or he would find himself without a Consort and barren garden.
oOo
AN: Thoughts, Mama Llamas, or requests, pretty please?
