Actions

Work Header

Easier to Lie

Chapter 11: Lose It All

Summary:

fili tells bofur that he might want to talk to his brother about something, which forces the young archer to talk about his feelings.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Hey Bofur?”

“Wha’, lad?”

“My khâzash wants t’ talk t’ you.”

The miner glanced up as the young swordsman slipped past him, pausing to glance back at his brother with a playful smile. His younger brother was far from amused; as his dark eyes watched Fíli walk up to the older dwarf and speak to him with that mischievous look in his eyes, even though he had no idea what Fíli was saying, he knew he wanted to smack him. He met his brother’s gaze and when Fíli waved him in the direction of the toymaker, all Kíli could do was stare back at his brother with wide eyes.

“Khâzash!” he called after Fíli with a warning in his voice, but the other dwarf just went to thank the men of Laketown with the members of their company.

The past week spent in Laketown had been one of rest and relaxation for the dwarves, and many of them had needed the time to regain their strength and recover from the painful, jarring journey in the barrels. Yet still, the humans had been more than accommodating, and they had been treated in a kingly fashion, thanks to Thorin and his proclamation that he was the rightful King Under the Mountain who had returned. Most of it was a blur anyway; feasting, sleeping, speaking, caring for the sick and tending to their needs. Hardly enough time to think about trivial dramas like the one that was playing itself out now as they resumed their journey to the mountain.

Kíli wasn’t sure what Fíli was up to, but he didn’t like it, and he started walking with his little pony trailing behind him (among the supplies they’d been given by the humans) when the miner fell into step beside him.

“Your brother said y’ wanted t’ talk t’ me, lad?” Bofur asked in a calmly casual voice. As always, his eyes issued the same kindness that his smile did as he glanced sidelong at the young dwarf.

“Did he?” Kíli replied evasively, looking down at the road but feeling his face grow dark. He wondered how obvious it was in the waning light of day.

“Tha’ he did,” Bofur answered and he pulled out his pipe from among his supplies and pressing a pinch of tobacco in before lighting it. He glanced at the young dwarf, but Kíli hardly responded to the unspoken offer, so he put the tobacco away. Kíli kept himself silent as they walked, and when he didn’t speak for a while, the older dwarf pressed, “Did y’ no’?”

Kíli inhaled and exhaled slowly, looking for his brother among the group. If Fíli had come anywhere near him he would have hit him then and there. As much as he loved his brother – more than anyone else – this was going a step too far. Still, when the silence began to get painful, he finally admitted, “No, he’s righ’. I did.”

“Wha’s on your mind, lad?”

Where to begin? Kíli slowed down as he grasped at things to say to the other. He didn’t want to say anything. There was no point. He’d only be adding more pain to an already painful situation. Why bother?

But Fíli was right. If he never told Bofur, Bofur would never know. And Bofur would never be able to decide if he felt anything in return.

“D’y’ remember when we were in th’ dungeon? The elves?” he started tentatively, and his voice was low. It lacked the usual youthful exuberance that was often so strong in his tone.

“Tha’ I do,” Bofur replied with an understanding tone, though he had to move closer to the young dwarf to hear his words. They were swallowed by his own body as he spoke into his chest, either from discomfort or nerves. The elder couldn’t be entirely sure which. “I told y’ Kíli no’ t’ worry.”

“No, it’s no’ tha’,” the younger interrupted before the elder could get much further in his assumptions. “I know tha’…I know you’ll let ‘im be with my uncle.”

At this point Bofur kept his tongue and let the youth speak, as he couldn’t know what he had to say. First he wondered whether Thorin might have learned of his affections. Would it upset him? He posed no threat. He was no rival to him. Short of the hobbit saying to him directly that he didn’t love Thorin but rather had feelings for him, Bofur could forsee no situation in which he would pose any threat. And even in that scenario, he wouldn’t believe the hobbit. Actions spoke louder than words, and the hobbit was clearly in love with Thorin. Anyone who couldn’t see as much was blind.

Kíli was surprised when the older dwarf said nothing to him in response, but when he glanced back at the older miner, his eyes were locked on the young dwarf’s face, waiting patiently as he thoughtfully smoked his pipe. It made him even more nervous than before and he glanced back down at the ground. “Bofur…” He spoke the name and let it trail off, not sure how to go on.

The silence hung over them, broken only occasionally by a whinny from one of the ponies, and the far off conversations of others in their company. Bofur wasn’t sure if he should say anything, but his senses told him to wait. He was certain that whatever it was the young dwarf had to say, he would say it in his own time and it would come. In that time he finished smoking, and quietly put the pipe back among his things.

And all that gave Kíli time to think. He let his eyes scan around him, and was surprised to find once again that the hobbit was watching him, as if his intuition told him what was happening between them. Stranger still, the hobbit gave him a small smile, almost encouragingly so, and it came as a surprise to Kíli that such did more for his courage than his brother forcing him to speak in the first place. Perhaps it was because Bilbo was on the other side of the same coin. They shared something between them.

“Bofur,” he began again, and this time there was a bit more strength in his voice. “Wha’ would y’ say, if I told y’ tha’ there migh’ be someone tha’…want’s y’ t’ be happy, even if it’s no’ with ‘im?”

They were not words that Bofur expected to hear, but as the younger spoke them there was this odd feeling that he already knew in the back of his mind what was being explained. Bofur wasn’t sure how he knew, but something told him that he had known all along, even if he wasn’t aware of it. When Kíli’s voice dropped off, it took Bofur a moment to gather up his own response. “An’…is he happy, lad?” He asked the question openly.

“I don’ know,” the younger replied honestly, and his voice cracked a bit as he said it. “He’s no’ sure.”

“Kíli.” The voice made the young dwarf stop and glance up at the aging miner. When he looked in those eyes, he knew that his affections were known now.

“I don’ know,” he said again, quieter this time.

“C’mere lad,” Bofur instructed gently, and he offered the youth an arm. Kíli didn’t hesitate to slip under the others arm and let his own arm snake around the miner’s waist as they walked together. “How long, Kíli?” he asked once the younger seemed to have calmed a bit.

The youth bit his lip. “Longer th’n y’ migh’ think,” he answered evasively.

“Since before we lef’ th’ Blue Mountains?”

All Kíli could do was nod. Bofur gave him a squeeze as he continued to hold his arm around the younger dwarf. They walked like that for a while, neither saying anything, though they were easily the object of many curious glances and conversations. Still, neither was bothered by the fact. If anything, it made Kíli smile a bit to himself. Just this moment of being seen for who he was and recognized by Bofur was enough for him. And the fact that Bofur had yet to push him away meant more than the other would ever know.

It was finally Bofur who broke the silence between them, though his voice was gentle and had that same layer of kindness that endeared him so much to the younger dwarf.

“You’re so young, Kíli.”

“I’m no’!” Kíli protested with a bit more exuberance than he initially intended, though he spoke before he let himself think about it, and Bofur responded by squeezing his arm once more. “Y’ think I’m too young t’ understand? Well I’m no’!”

“Tha’s no’ wha’ I’m sayin’, lad,” he answered, his voice never rising to overpower, and the youth fell silent. “I jus’ don’ understand why a young dwarf like y’ would waste your time on…well, an ol’ miner like m’self.”

It seems so arbitrary that at first Kíli didn’t think he could respond. But after a moment he glanced up to look directly at the other, his dark, youthful eyes seeming to peer into the mind of the other. “D’ y’ think you’re wasting time with th’ hobbit?”

Bofur was taken off-guard by the question and he met the gaze. It was probably the first time he recognized Kíli as grown – no longer the little dwarfling that he used to make toys for from time to time, but of age. A warrior. With a mind and will of his own. And though he wasn’t the sharpest among them, right now he showed his own inner wisdom. A wisdom that the aging miner had to respect. As they looked at each other, Bofur’s smile spread and Kíli could hardly contain his own smile which sought to mirror him.

“You’re righ’, lad.”

Kíli chuffed and looked around. “I’m righ’, ‘bout wha’?”

“You’re no’ so young,” Bofur concluded, and his arm that had remained on the other’s shoulders came down to clap him on the back. “You’re grown.”

Kíli floundered and glanced down at the ground, surprised at how much it meant to hear the other say such. “Stop tha’,” he replied awkwardly, a playful laugh dancing at the edges of his voice.

“You’re a good lad, Kíli,” the elder continued, only marginally aware of the shyness that overtook the otherwise mischievous youth. It was strange, but something he’d never thought of before was now beginning to seem not so absurd at all. So he ventured a question. “Kíli…would y’ have talked t’ me if your khâzash hadn’ come t’ me firs’?”

The youth didn’t glance but the silence was as good of an answer as any words might have been.

“Then y’ should thank ‘im,” Bofur added after a moment, before patting the youth on the back a second time as he let his arm drop back to his side. “Le’s talk abou’ this when we stop for th’ nigh’, alrigh’ lad?”

Kíli didn’t know what to say. So he simply nodded. As his eyes ventured up to scan the rest of the party, he saw Bilbo far ahead with a knowing smile on his face. They shared a glance, and continued on.

Notes:

i'm a masochist and a sadist. and i feel really bad, knowing where this is going ultimately.

r&r please. and thanks to all my regular readers/commenters. you help me keep this going.