Actions

Work Header

Easier to Lie

Chapter 19: The Hardest Part

Summary:

bilbo and thorin have a chat, and thorin has to prove his feelings to the hobbit.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Even as they made their way back into the darkness of the reclaimed dwarven city, Bilbo still wasn’t certain what exactly he was doing. He stood by awkwardly as Thorin lit a torch of them, lead the way cautiously as his mind darted back and forth between what had been said, what had yet to be said, and where his feet were leading them. The dust had hardly had time to settle when he was shuffling his way through an open door, the dwarf king not two steps behind him.

He didn’t venture as far as the bedroom. At least, not at first, though he set aside in his mind the possibility of going there later. Instead, he set about to clearing the table in the next room of dust before pulling out a chair and taking a seat on one side, leaving Thorin the space to take another. First Thorin affixed the torch into a fixture in the wall, then he too took his seat, though it was clear that much of what had been so strained between them, so difficult and painful to overcome, was gradually melting away.

“Of what did you wish to speak?” Thorin pressed when the silence had obviously grown too heavy for him, and he reached a hand across the table to the hobbit, his palm upward in invitation to hold the other’s hand. Bilbo hesitated, before letting his smaller hand be enveloped by the dwarf’s much larger one.

There were a few more moments of silence before Bilbo seemed ready to form words, and to let them spill out of his lips.

“Thorin I,” he began, though he had to pause there to keep his emotions in check. If he didn’t consider seriously his words, they might come back to bite him. “I must say…I’m…well, I’m angry. At what you’ve said. What you’ve done. And I need to know…if this is…”

“If I will stay true to my word,” Thorin finished for him, and though there was a hint of understanding in the dwarf’s blue eyes, there was a layer of sadness too. Regret at having failed the other. Recognition that the damage would need to be repaired. “I know that my word must mean very little to you now…but I swear to you that I am in this.”

The hobbit was floundering. His heart was stronger than his head in many respects, and though he knew in the rational part of him that the pain should have outweighed the desire he felt for the other, his heart refused to cooperate. How could he know? “You don’t understand just how much I want to believe that.”

“May I prove it to you? Prove to you my love?”

It was an odd statement, and came so abruptly that the hobbit blinked a few times as he took in the other’s face. The flickering light of the torch on the wall cast eerie shadows on both their faces, though it made Thorin look as though he were aflame himself. The intensity of his gaze was such that the hobbit was afraid to meet it, and he let his own eyes drop down to the hands that were laced together on the table top. His own looked so small. Like a child’s hand. “You think it’s that simple?”

“What would you ask of me?”

Glancing up to look at the other for a split second only, Bilbo could see the need in the other’s face. The determination. “Ask of you?”

“Yes,” Thorin responded quickly, and he gave the hobbit’s hand a firm squeeze. “Anything. Ask of me anything, and I will do so.”

“I can’t.”

“Please, Bilbo.”

The hobbit was beginning to question just whose love was to be proven, but he finally caved and met those piercing eyes with his own firm strength. “You want to prove your love to me?”

Thorin didn’t even hesitate. “Yes.”

“Then show me,” Bilbo answered in a clear and even tone. His words seemed to hit something in Thorin’s mind because the other looked perplexed, but Bilbo refused to go further. “You want me to ask something of you to prove your love. Well…this is…what I’m asking. That…that you show me. Prove your love by showing me.”

For a moment Thorin watched him curiously. Once he almost opened his mouth to say he didn’t understand, but when he thought on it he knew what Bilbo was asking. Bilbo wanted to know just how deep his feelings were, and actions spoke louder than words.

He’d been misusing his actions for so long that it was a wonder Bilbo was giving him this chance at all. Ever since they’d left Rivendell Thorin had given the hobbit mixed signals, and this was just another instance where his actions and words contrasted each other.

Sighing deeply, the dwarf gave the small hand that held to his another squeeze. “The truth is,” he began in a voice that was steady, yet lacked the normal clarity that he so often held. There was frailty there; an admission of weakness. Something that lay just beneath the surface that the dwarf lord had only just begun to admit to within himself. “I do not know how.” Just letting those words slip out was more than Bilbo ever would have expected from the future king. “Love…has never really been my strong suit. Even when it comes to my own kin.”

He turned his gaze downward at that point and Bilbo could feel the dwarf clenching and unclenching his hand around the hobbit’s smaller fingers. Was that shame he detected in the other’s tone? Perhaps. It was difficult to tell.

“I believed I had lost such feeling long ago…that it was swallowed in the fires that destroy my home and displaced my people. And…perhaps that is why I cloud my feelings with anger. Anger is something I understand. I know it much better.”

It was strange, hearing such vulnerability from the other, such exposed truth. Bilbo felt blessed just to hear it, though he didn’t allow himself any words to interrupt the other. Truly he already felt like Thorin had won him over, but there was something beautiful about hearing the other, and knowing him like this, the only sounds his deep baritone and the sharp crackle of the torch.

Again Thorin sighed, a deep, profound thing that seemed to fill the whole room with its heaviness. This time it was Bilbo who gave the other’s hand a reassuring squeeze. It seemed to have an effect on the other because Thorin glanced up to meet the hobbit’s gaze and when their eyes locked, he smiled. It was the same smile he’d had on the eyrie when the eagles had left them safely. The same smile he’d sported when he embraced Bilbo in recognition of what the hobbit had done. This smile was Thorin at his best, and though it didn’t show very often, it was, at least in Bilbo’s mind, the purest form of Thorin that he had yet seen. It was Thorin. The Thorin that was not battling with the weight of his people, the pain of his past, and the anger of betrayal.

“But that’s not what you asked,” he concluded finally. “You asked me to show you.” And without saying another word, Thorin took the hand that still held to his own and brought it to his mouth. First, gently, he kissed Bilbo’s knuckles. Then, releasing the hand, he took it in both hands so that he could brush the palm with his lips and there he kissed him as well before he closed his eyes and pressed his forehead into the other’s hand.

Bilbo was at a loss for words.

They sat like that for a while, Bilbo letting the king press his small hand to his forehead, and Thorin seemingly slipping into the other through that simple form of physical contact. When he finally pulled back and let his hands take the hobbit’s small hand in his own again, there was a lingering sadness that was felt – as if Bilbo wasn’t quite ready to let the touch cut off quite then.

“You’ll forgive me for not showing you enough,” he admitted quietly, and it was the cue Bilbo needed to jump back in, though he did with a bit more enthusiasm than was entirely necessary.

“Then keep going.” His words came out so fast that they brought a low chuckle to the other, who brought himself to his feet and continued to hold the other’s hand, forcing Bilbo to stand as well.

“Shall I?”

There was something in Thorin’s expression that made Bilbo’s voice vanish into his throat again, so the hobbit simply nodded. Pulling the hobbit close to him, Thorin continued to hold the hand within his own while his free hand wrapped around the hobbit’s back, pressing them close together in an embrace that was both tender and yet reserved. An attempt to show what was difficult to express, what had until then never been fully expressed before. The sheer fact that Thorin was trying had made a deep enough impression on the hobbit and he let his arm slip around the other, his hand resting in the middle of Thorin’s back.

He felt small pressed against him, but perfectly warm and strangely comfortable. Like he belonged there. Like they fit.

Then, softly, as if it might ruin the perfection that was the moment, Thorin spoke; “I’m sorry.”

Bilbo didn’t want to pull back from the other and instead pressed his head into the dwarf’s chest. Just being wrapped in the other’s arms had done wonders to his own body temperature. It was like wearing the other as a cloak, and he was enveloped in the heat of Thorin’s furs and leathers. “Yes, alright,” he mumbled into the other’s chest, though it was more of a vibration than anything else, as his words were swallowed up into the other.

“I may not know how,” Thorin continued in that same tone, and he pressed the hobbit closer to him so he could rest his chin atop his head. “But I will try to continue to show you.”

A small chuckle sounded from the face pressed into his chest, and the vibration carried through into his own body. It made the dwarf lord smile.

“Practice makes perfect,” was all that Bilbo said.

Notes:

i know i said that there was looking to be smut, but it appears neither of them are ready for sex yet. because bilbo needs more confirmation from thorin and thorin doesn't know how to show love properly ergo he needs to learn a bit. so anyway. but. never fear, smut will be here! if i don't write thilbo smut there is one more chapter of kifur smut on the horizon where kili gets to be dom. ah yis.

i only have like 10 pages to write of one paper, and the other paper is a creative project that i can do whatever i want so i think i will write a play. anyway. had to pop in and reward myself for all my hard work.

i'm graduating with a master's degree in 37 days EEK!