Actions

Work Header

Abigail Fell’s Master Plan That Most Definitely Will Get Her Dads Together and Won’t Cause Any Chaos at All

Summary:

After the Murder Family settles into their new life in Florence, Will and Hannibal are still dancing around each other and their feelings. Sick of dealing with their nonsense, Abigail creates a plan, determined to finally get them together, but some things are easier said than done.

Chapter 1: Fake Marriages Often Yield Unexpected Results

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

According to the most affluent socialites of Florence, the Fells were one of the most charming families in the city. Dr. Hans Fell was an extremely respected psychiatry professor at the local university, happily married to Mr. William Fell, a writer working on a book that never seemed to be published. They had a daughter together, the teenage Abigail. Abigail was well-liked at school, both for her bubbly personality and her propensity for quickly making friends. They were the picture of domesticity, even if they were never seen together. Anyone who was acquainted with Dr. Fell had most likely only heard of William through stories and jokes about the professor’s home life. On the rare occasion they were spotted side by side, it was on a quick walk through the city or a university function at which Mr. Fell could most likely be spotted at the open bar or the buffet table, whiskey in hand. But of course, no one ever mentioned their strange absences from one another’s lives, as that would be rude.

It was at home that they could be themselves, no longer the Fells, but individuals who oftentimes wanted nothing to do with each other, Will and Hannibal specifically. Despite living in the same apartment (it was more of a penthouse than an apartment), they were creative in their ways of ignoring each other. They slept in separate beds, slept at different times of day, worked in different places, and one was almost always out “running errands” that most likely did not need to be run at all. Abigail was tired of it.

After leaving Baltimore, Abigail expected her adoptive fathers to finally address whatever was going on between them (it was obvious that something was). Between the stolen glances and the blunt embarrassment from both parties, some form of mutual attraction was evident. But in true Will and Hannibal fashion, they said almost nothing to each other, leaving between them a stretch of sexual tension thick enough to cut with one of Hannibal’s kitchen knives. Even after moving into their new lives and pseudonyms as the most perfect family in Italy, the two men kept up an air of seclusion from one another, leaving Abigail to moderate. She felt like a messenger penguin when she was forced to carry dinner requests to Hannibal and party invitations to WIll. After some amount of deliberation, she decided that if they weren’t going to get together themselves, she would have to do it for them. Or at least prompt it.

To begin her plan, she pulled a piece of thin paper from her desk (no doubt chosen by Hannibal) and started to write a list. After a few minutes, once she was done erasing, crossing out, and reorganizing, there was one scheme that stuck out at the top of the lineup:

Fake married dinner party?

Abigail concluded that this was the best way to address her predicament. She would invite Hannibal’s snobby friends for a dinner party with the acclaimed chef Dr. Fell. Anyone who’s anyone in Florence would be thrilled to attend, so she could easily amass a large crowd for the night, each one of them counting on an expensive plate of hors d'oeuvres, crafted by Dr. Fell himself. Once every invitation was sent, she would casually mention the topic to Will and Hannibal and that they would need to be hosts. They would most likely be angry with her, but that was a small price to pay to see them stuck to each other’s side at the party, forced to socialize with the crowd before eventually discovering their affinity for life as a married couple, then boom. They would find love and Abigail would find some peace in her own home.

Once she found a list of Hannibal’s colleagues and a nice pen from Hannibal’s desk, she started to work her magic.

Dear esteemed [couple],

It is my pleasure to invite you to my home for a dinner party next Saturday evening, the nineteenth. I plan to serve a plethora of different dishes, all handcrafted by myself. I would be honored if you could find time to attend and enjoy the presence of myself, my husband, and our daughter.

 

- Doctor Hans Fell

It was concise, elegant, and just a little condescending. A perfect replica of something Hannibal could have written. After penning about twenty-five copies, she sent them off to their recipients, packaged in a cream-colored envelope and accented with a wax seal. Just like that, her plan was set into motion.

It was the next morning when she informed Will and Hannibal of their obligation. Safe to say, they were not excited. Will was angry at the promise of socializing, Hannibal with the amount of work to be done, especially with such little time for preparations. Abigail made an excuse by saying that they needed to host a party to solidify their place in the high society of the city. Her argument was flimsy, but neither man tried to refute it, which was a win in her book. They never got together as a group to plan the event, which left Abigail to do most of the heavy lifting with Hannibal. If she was being honest, it was probably best if Will didn’t interfere, given his lack of design sense, evidenced by the embarrassment that was his house in Wolf Trap. Together, she and Hannibal constructed a gourmet menu full of exquisite cuisine (no people were on this menu as of yet, considering Hannibal hadn’t had any time to hunt).

When there were only a few days left until the party, Abigail found a box containing a flowy cocktail dress at the front door, accompanied by a suit that no doubt was for Will. Damn Hannibal and his perfectionism. After a bit of debating with herself, she elected to deliver the suit herself. She found Will in the study, clacking away on a laptop, doing God-knows-what. After a few soft steps, she set the box on the desk, watching his face for any change.

“It’s from Hannibal,” she stated.

“What is it?” Will asked.

“I suggest you just open it yourself,” Abigail said quickly, turning to leave the room before Will was able to see the contents of the box.

She was not quick enough, evidenced by the outraged voice behind her back. “What the hell? Does he seriously think I can’t dress myself! What a pompous asshole.” Will was, for lack of a better word, pissed. Not at Abigail of course (she wasn’t sure if he had it in him), but at Hannibal. Abigail was fully aware that Hannibal was more focused on aesthetics than anything else, and she could definitely recognize Will’s shortcomings in that regard. With his old flannel shirts and worn-out chinos, he stuck out like a sore thumb among the chandeliers and gold details that decorated the apartment, let alone the well-to-do society of Florence. She could sympathize with Hannibal wanting to make him look a little nicer for the party. With a short apology to Will, she removed herself from the study and retreated to her room to give him some space.

The night of the party arrived sooner than expected and began with Hannibal and Abigail busying themselves in the kitchen, preparing everything from prosciutto rolls to crème brûlée, which was proving more and more difficult for Abigail as the afternoon wore on. At about five pm, they were finally done, and Will offered to clean the kitchen for them, most likely making up for his dreadful lack of culinary skills. They both obliged, and once changed, Abigail found herself swimming in a gold dress that was adorned with beads, ribbon, and tulle. She wasn’t sure if she wanted to know how much it cost. Hannibal was making space for guests in the main room, wearing a suit that seemed to exactly match Will’s. Will would not be happy when he saw, that was for sure. Hannibal was also wearing the fake wedding ring he wore to work, and Abigail was curious to see if Will even knew where his was, considering his disdain for anything implicating the idea of a relationship between the two men.

It was after about an hour that the kitchen was clean, and that was when Will stepped out into the main room, dressed in his black suit and a gold tie that was so obnoxious it seemed to overshadow the rest of the outfit. It was obvious to who had picked it out. With a glance to the side, Hannibal had blatant hearts in his eyes, even if the man he was gawking at looked as if he would rather step straight out of his skin. With a clap of her hands and a smile that was not returned, Abigail announced, “The party begins!”

It was then that they started ushering guests inside. Attendees included professors, journalists, and even a few politicians. Just the type of people that needed to be impressed. She eyed the crowd as they milled through the apartment, snacking on bits of food and sipping lavish wines. After opening the door far too many times and flashing far too many toothy smiles, she waded off through the dense crowd to find Will and Hannibal. On her way, she was stopped by an older woman who asked where she could find the restroom. Abigail pointed her in the right direction, just when she was intercepted by a man with a notepad, no doubt covering the event, despite his lack of invitation.

“Miss, can you help me find William Fell? I need to speak to him about his book, it’s of utmost importance,”

Abigail mentally rolled her eyes. “I actually saw him walking over that way,” she said, pointing in a direction that she most definitely did not see him walking. The man quickly turned his head to look before scurrying away to get some kind of photo or interview. Abigail kept moving, standing on her toes to look above the crowd and try to find Will or Hannibal, as they would no doubt be apart.

After scanning the opulent apartment, she caught a glance of what could only be Will, with the same suit and his signature unkempt mop of curly hair. Pushing through the group, she made her way over to him, only to see him nursing a glass of whiskey, accompanied by several empty glasses of God-knows-what on the counter in front of him. “Oh no,” Abigail whispered to herself, although it must have been loud enough for Will to turn his head to look at her. “Abigail!” he called, ignoring the fact that they were close enough to the point where he didn’t need to yell. “Uhm, Will, hi, may I ask how many drinks you’ve had?” she inquired. “Not that many, don’t worry about it,” Will replied, and Abigail could make out the way his words were slightly slurred above the noise of the crowd. Lovely.  

She attempted to take the glass from his hand, but midway through her effort, he pulled his hand away, spilling most of his drink and toppling a plate of caviar-topped crackers onto the marble flooring. He made a low whistling noise under his breath at the same time Abigail released a tired sigh. She bent down to collect the mess, a string of increasingly rude curses flowing from under her breath. “Cleaning up after you is like cleaning up after a child,” she muttered. “Technically, you’re the child,” Will offered in response, which had Abigail suddenly bristling in anger. She wasn’t quite sure why she blew up, but she did.  “Goddamnit Will! I plan one night where you can finally socialize and try to spend some time with your family, and all you do is show up, complain, get drunk, and cause chaos! I doubt you even spent time with your husband!” Will, still fairly nonchalant about the ordeal, quipped, “My ‘husband’?” (He was very intense with his air quotes.) “Let’s call over my husband shall we?” At this point, he was loud enough to command the room, guests across the floor turning to look at the conversation over their champagne flutes.

“Hey,” Will called across the room. “Hannibal!” Abigail was considering chastising him for using Hannibal’s real name, but at this point, she really couldn’t be bothered. A line of partygoers separated, forming a path leading straight to an unbothered Hannibal. Will stood from his chair and walked over, Abigail hot on the trail behind him. He pointed a finger straight at Hannibal’s chest and asked, “You were having a fine night without me, weren’t you? Talking with all your fancy friends and leaving me to have my peace?” After a beat, Hannibal, calm as ever, responded, “It would have been nice to spend the evening with my dear husband, but you can do as you please,” “Jesus Christ, can you stop with the ‘my husband’ bullshit?” came Will’s slow and slurred speech.

“I’m not sure what you mean, and using such language won’t improve your persuasion skills,”

“You know exactly what I mean, you just don’t want to say anything!”

Hannibal made no move to reply, which seemed to be the final straw for Will, as he landed a push straight to Hannibal’s chest, however weak and impaired by alcohol it may have been. To the entire crowd, Hannibal called with a smile, “I think it is time for my dear William to go to bed, and time for this party to be over. Sorry to send everyone home on such short notice.” Apparently, they didn’t need to be told twice and started to file out the door without Abigail to open it. Will was still gesticulating wildly and talking mostly to himself.

By the time the attendees were gone, Hannibal made to move Will to his room, despite the amount the man was flailing about. Once they were out of sight down the hall, Abigail flopped down onto a couch in the sitting room, a long sigh escaping her lips. She wasn’t sure how long she lay there, eyes closed and arms limp, but it was long enough for Hannibal to come back, with no Will to be seen. “I highly doubt he’ll remember that by morning,” he admitted in an almost-whisper as if there was a sleeping baby in the other room, which Abigail supposed there was. “I sure hope he doesn’t”, she said. “It would be better if he didn’t remember the entire party concept as a whole.”

“You had good intentions,” Hannibal explained. “It wasn’t your fault it ended this way, it was mostly mine if I am to be completely honest.” Abigail doubted this but didn’t ask him to clarify, as she figured it was probably one of his psychiatrist tactics. 

With a long breath through her nose, she got up from her chair, accepted a long hug from Hannibal, and went straight to her bedroom. She was too tired for much of anything and went to bed feeling sorry.

 

Notes:

Thank you for reading the start of my fic! As mentioned in the summary, updates will be coming soon. I'm sorry if my writing skills are sub-par, as I'm relatively new to writing fiction as a whole. Please let me know if you enjoyed it, and constructive criticism is welcome and necessary.