Actions

Work Header

Abigail Fell’s Master Plan That Most Definitely Will Get Her Dads Together and Won’t Cause Any Chaos at All

Chapter 2: Accidental Lunch Dates Tend to Go Awry

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It was only after about two weeks that the news of the party-gone-wrong seemed to blow over. The society pages had stopped writing about Dr. Fell’s husband that can’t control his anger and the gossipy housewives had stopped their incessant whispering in between overpriced cappuccinos at fancy outdoor cafes. People had moved on and university staff had stopped sending Dr. Fell sideways glances in the hall. Abigail no longer lowered her head in school hallways, and Will, well, he still hadn’t found it in him to leave the house.

Just as Hannibal predicted, Will didn’t himself remember the mess he created and the way he embarrassed himself, but the journalists in attendance at the party made sure he would hear about it, even if it had to be secondhand. He was nowhere to be seen, although he was obviously in the apartment while Hannibal and Abigail were away, evidenced by the organized bookshelves and the polished dishes, which were definitely not done while the rest of the family was home. It was probably some sort of apology for his behavior. 

Will and Hannibal still weren’t speaking, which completely solidified the degree to which Abigail’s plan had failed. But she was known for her resilience, and even if her first attempt failed, she would try, try again. Settling into her desk chair, she started searching through her various papers until she came back across a familiar list. Of course, at the top still sat her first choice, but among the discarded options sat a few more options. Among these options, sat promising the idea of an accidental blind date.

Abigail decided that this would be the next way she would enact her plan. She could ask each one of the men to have a nice lunch with her at the same place and time, proceed to not show up, and watch as they would be forced to spend time together, apologize for their respective shortcomings, and finally address their own emotions. They would then fall madly in love, giving Abigail a break from the stress of walking on the eggshells all day. What a relaxing thought. 

When trying to determine a location, she made sure to steer clear of a restaurant with a bar, even if she knew Hannibal would never allow Will to get as drunk as he was at the party. Instead, she spent a few minutes searching the web on her laptop before opting for a small, outdoor bistro, complete with plants lining the walls, lights hanging over the tables, and a coffee shop across the street, at a perfect distance for Abigail to spy on the two. She decided that Saturday was the perfect opportunity since neither she nor Hannibal would be stuck at work, but Hannibal would most likely be at the university all morning, and therefore wouldn’t see Will getting ready. Abigail could spend the morning out with friends, and promise to meet them each at the restaurant respectively, before taking a detour and leaving them to (hopefully) reconcile with each other. A perfect plan. Abigail mentally applauded herself for thinking of it alone.

It was Friday when she proposed the idea to Will first. He had been hard to track down, but when she took a shorter route back from school, she was able to catch him before he left the apartment. Opening the door, she almost bumped into him, but managed to grab his arm, even if he was still avoiding eye contact.

“Will! It’s good to finally see you,” Abigail said, as cheerily as she could. He would probably be able to see right through it with his fancy profiler skills, but even then, he’d be able to tell she wanted to be positive for him.

“Uhm, Abigail, you- yes, you too,” came Will’s reply, brief and quiet as if his voice was avoiding her.

“I was wondering if you would want to join me for lunch tomorrow. You know, catch up and stuff,” she asked, hope dancing in her voice.

“It’s been what, two weeks since we last saw each other? I doubt that we need to do any catching up,” Will countered.

“Well, you see, I really just want to spend time with you, and I feel like you think it’s your fault for what happened, and it wasn’t and you’ve been avoiding us and I miss you,” she was playing the sympathy card at this point, but it didn’t matter, and she was willing to push it farther. She gave him the most dramatic eyes she could and said quietly, “I miss you being my dad.”

This must have been what sent him over the edge, because he finally managed to look into her eyes and nod, followed by a slow sigh. “Yeah. I’ll-I’ll meet you for lunch. That sounds great.” Instead of continuing to make his way out the door he sat down his keys in the bowl on the table and turned to head back into the kitchen. “Do you, maybe want anything to drink?” he asked furtively, looking at Abigail still standing in the entranceway. She made her way over and said with a smile, “I’ll have a coffee,”

While Will busied himself with french presses, creamers, spices, and milk, Abigail almost felt bad for not planning to show up to their meeting, but having him talk to Hannibal would be good in the long run, and he needed it. Despite this, she could still use this time to talk with him, she thought before striking up a conversation right there in the kitchen, the afternoon sunlight reflecting the golden glow off of the cups on the counter.

They spoke for what seemed like days, but it couldn’t have been more than a couple of hours spent lounging on upholstered chairs and gorging on decadent chocolates found in the back of the pantry. Will glanced at his watch and released a long breath. “As much as I enjoyed this, Hannibal will be home soon, and even if I’ve faced you, I’m not sure I can do the same with him quite yet.” Abigail understood his sentiment and hoped that her plan could help with that issue. She followed suit when he stood up, exchanged a date and time for the lunch date, and watched as he retreated into the comfort and safety of the study.

It was at dinner that Abigail proposed the idea to Hannibal. It was no doubt more of a strange idea to him, considering that they often ate meals together, just as they were now.

“Would you be interested in trying a new restaurant I found? It's gorgeous and I think you’ll like the food,” she queried.

Over his plate of veal, Hannibal let a wry smile spread along his face. “I don’t see why we can’t eat here. I prefer eating food I cook for myself anyway. Few restaurants live up to my standards.”

This was exactly the situation she was afraid of. “Please? I want to try it and I don’t want to go alone. I think it would be good for you to try,” Instead of playing the sympathy card as she did with Will, she devolved into simple begging, but Hannibal liked to appease her and ended the conversation with a nod of his head and another bite taken of his dinner. Perfect.

Now that all parties were informed of her plan, it was time to set it into motion. On Saturday morning, she went quickly out the door to meet friends for breakfast. She called Hannibal to ensure he was at the university on her walk over. He picked up on the third ring.

“Hello, Abigail. You don’t usually tend to call while I’m at work, may I ask why you chose to this time?”

“I just wanted to remind you about lunch today,” Abigail replied.

Hannibal was skeptical when he said, “I’ve been informed of lunch and I fully intend to be there. But for future reference, you needn’t call,”

His voice was calm and kind, but Abigail knew he was suspicious of her. Hopefully, he wouldn’t flake out and her plan could be realized. After spending the next ten minutes turning over possible scenarios in her head about the date, a friend called her over to their table and she allowed herself not to think of it for a while. 

It was eleven when she broke away from her friends. She took the bus over to her designated coffee shop and ordered a latte and a cannoli, before finding a seat closest to the window with the best view of the outdoor dining patio across the street. She had previously made reservations so she would know where they were sitting, a two-person table with an umbrella and a small red marker, designating it as reserved. It was empty, but she still put on a pair of dark sunglasses to hide her identity, if only for dramatic effect. A real 007. 

Her coffee was nearly gone by the time someone sat down at the table, and of course, it was Hannibal. She should have known Will would show up late, but a part of her wanted him to be there first because she knew he would try to leave as soon as he saw Hannibal. There was no way of knowing when or how he would react, so she elected to slump back in her chair and watch her design play out.

---

Will clambered out the door, jacket hanging half off his shoulders and his shoes beginning to come untied. As always, he was running late, but he was intent on showing up in time for Abigail. Of course, they had to live in a fancy building, courtesy of Hannibal, so Will had to make awkward and short-lived eye contact with the elevator operator on his way to the lobby. He thought of his messy, curly hair, his neglected stubble, and the rumpled flannel he had most likely bought at some Bass Pro Shop or Walmart back in Virginia. He stuck out like a sore thumb here and was afraid that he would disappoint Abigail. He had Googled the address she had given him, and it was a fairly casual establishment, but he was bordering on homeless with his current look. He had never worried about what the public thought of him and never was one for fashion, but he was starting to regret that choice as he stepped onto the city bus and rode downtown. Hannibal must be such a better father to Abigail, with his three-piece suits and stable job. He didn’t like to think of it, but while he was locking himself away in embarrassment, Hannibal was probably sharing lavish dinners and showing Abigail the sights of the city. Maybe today would be an opportunity to earn some of her respect.

When Will reached his stop, his steps were tentative and smooth. If he wanted any dignity, he would have to earn it himself. He smoothed his jacket and combed back his hair with his fingers. After a deep breath, he wrapped his hand around the handle of the door and stepped in with as much self-esteem as he could muster up. The man at the host’s stand pointed him to where he should go, a small table with an umbrella. Underneath that umbrella sat Hannibal Lecter. Of-fucking-course. 

He should have known. It was Abigail’s plan all along. Force them to talk and reconcile. He was about to turn around and leave, but it was just then that Hanibal looked up and caught his eye. Great. 

“Oh, Will, I didn’t expect to see you here. Although I doubt that you’re here of your own accord,” He was loud enough to be heard over the chatter of the restaurant patrons, but his voice was only meant for Will. Will’s feet felt like they were glued to the floor, but he eventually was able to sit down across from Hannibal.

“I was told I would be eating lunch with Abigail,” he said, eyes looking at the patterns of grain on the table rather than Hannibal.

“So was I,” replied Hannibal, a slight chuckle escaping from his lips as he spoke. Will didn’t find it funny.

“So this means she set us up,” Will said dully. “But why?”

“I think she wants us to be better at communication. Both you and I have failed as her guardians,”

“I think you failed her when you cut off her ear and faked her death,”

Hannibal did not take kindly to that statement but still spoke with calm and composure.

“I was thinking more about our mutual lack of cooperation and how that’s affected Abigail’s stress levels,”

That made Will’s face burn in embarrassment. “Yeah, sorry,”

“If you really are sorry, do you promise to do what’s best for Abigail?”

Will nodded slowly.

It was then that the waiter decided to arrive, giving Will a much-needed break from Hannibal’s piercing stare and his lecture.

Hannibal ordered for both of them, which made Will a bit mad before he realized that he couldn’t pronounce anything on the menu if he was to order for himself. When the waiter left, Will took it upon himself to move the conversation forward.

“What exactly does doing what’s best for Abigail imply?” he asked. 

“Having a normal family structure is important. She deserves to live in an environment where home is a haven, and that is currently not the case,”

“So you want me to be more sociable with you two,”

“Well yes,” Hannibal looked at his hands, “And I need to be home more, I’ve been spending too much time at work,”

Will had a brilliant idea. “I used to be a professor too, you know. I studied more biology than psychiatry, but it’s close enough,”

“What are you asking, Will?”

“I could, um, help you grade papers or make your lesson plans? I’m also pretty good with PowerPoint, but I’m not sure if fancy Italian professors use PowerPoint,”

“I’ve never been able to get it to work, but I’d love to try with some help,”

When a bottle of wine was delivered to the table, the mood was lightened. 

“Day drinking are we?” Will joked as Hannibal poured two glasses.

“I think there’s an opportunity for a good wine at every meal, but don’t expect me to let you have your two fingers of whiskey with breakfast,” he said as a smile spread across his face.

This time, Will responded in kind.

They chatted for about twenty minutes while waiting for their lunch. Eventually, Will asked, “What’ll we do with Abigail when we get home?”

Through a half-smile, Hannibal snickered, “I think we should ignore it and pretend as if we’ve decided to become civil of our own accord,”

As Will grinned in turn with Hannibal, he let his gaze focus on the lines around his eyes, his striking cheekbones, the hair falling into his face, almost-blonde if not for the streaks of grey. His eyes wandered over the dazzling man before him, before finally settling on his lips. He could feel Hannibal’s eyes on him, and for once he didn’t feel ashamed for his staring, but rather confident. He lifted his eyes to meet Hannibal’s, ran his teeth over his bottom lip, and…

CRASH!

Immediately, Will and Hannibal stood from their seats and moved to see where the noise had come from, abandoning their wine and their conversation. Once they were standing on the sidewalk, they could see a wreck in the middle of the street outside the restaurant. A small car had smashed into a public bus, no doubt a product of the winding streets of the city. 

By now, many people were standing on sidewalks, while a few were helping at the wreckage. Everyone seemed to escape the bus fine, but the woman helping whoever was in the car was in a state of panic.

“Doctor!” she called. “Please, is anyone a doctor?”

Hannibal shot a glance at Will and ran to the crash with a raised hand.

“Ma’am, I was a surgeon, can I help?”

Will considered calling an ambulance, but it seemed that multiple people were already doing so. Instead, he just stood and tried to watch Hannibal work, although there wasn’t much to see considering his torso was halfway inside the vehicle. As the ambulance pulled up, Will turned to see none other than Abigail herself, standing with a look of great concern covering her features.

“Abigail?” he asked. 

She turned quickly and immediately turned red. “Oh, hi, fancy seeing you here,”

“Yeah, real coincidence, where were you?”

She made a small nod towards a coffee shop down the road and Will felt like a mother reprimanding a young child. 

“Jesus Christ Abigail, where you watching us?”

It seemed as if she was too embarrassed to speak at this point, only grimacing and looking back at Will.

As the ambulance carried the injured driver away, Will let out a sound that was something of a sigh, laugh, and a sob all in one and put his head in his hands.

---

It was late that night when Hannibal returned home, and Abigail was already asleep in her room, but Will was still teetering on the edge of consciousness, laying across a plush couch, attempting to read one of Hannibal’s giant psychiatry textbooks.

The door opened with a soft click, and Will knew who it was, but he was too tired to get up, so he just waited for Hannibal to find him. It didn’t take long, and soon he was standing above the couch while Will watched him with half-open eyes.

“How is he?” Will asked.

“He’ll live. They said if he hadn’t had immediate care, he could’ve suffered fatal blood loss,” 

Will yawned. “Why were you there all night? Last I checked they don’t just let any doctor into the operating room,”

Hannibal had a kind smile across his face when he responded, “That’s right, but they do let anyone into the waiting room,”

“Ah,” Will nodded. “I didn’t know you cared that much about strangers. Maybe it was the whole cannibalism thing, but you never struck me as a very empathetic guy,”

“You have enough empathy for the both of us, Will,” Hannibal countered. “But that man was never rude, and he didn’t deserve to die,”

Will nodded and let out a small hum of agreement, his eyes closed.

“Are you going to bed?” asked Hannibal.

“No, I think I’ll just stay here,”

Hannibal chucked at this but left Will alone in the sitting room anyway. They didn’t do anything that night, but Will wasn’t upset, considering he probably would’ve fallen asleep halfway through if they had. His biggest grievance with the night was the back pain he had the next morning after a night spent on the couch.

Notes:

Thanks again for reading chapter 2! I just finished the book I was reading for class, so I should have more time to write over winter break. As always, let me know if you liked it, and I'm always open to criticism.