Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

The Winner Takes It All

Summary:

A Mammia Mia AU slammed together with an Erebor never fell AU.

Bilbo Baggins falls in love with a prince who is destined to break his heart. After distracting himself in the beds of others, he ends up pregnant and alone to raise his son.

Frodo happily lives his life as an only child with his single father, but as his wedding with Sam grows near he can't help but be curious as to who his other father could be. When he finds Bilbo’s diary from the year he was born, he impulsively invites the three possible options to his wedding. What he doesn't expect is for them to actually show up and to cause so much chaos and strife for his father before his big day. Did he mention he failed to tell either Bilbo or Sam about his invitations?

Notes:

Heyyyy what is up you guys! Mamma Mia is one of my all time favorite movies/musicals of all time and every Mamma Mia AU fic is always a treat. So how could I avoid the temptation to write my own with my OTP? If you haven't seen the movie/musical, I highly recommend it! I am honestly thrilled to see what people think about this story going in blind! If you have seen it, please keep in mind this is pretty variant from the original. I did my best to keep true to both pieces of art!

No trigger warnings for this fic! There is more angst than my other work, but there will be plenty of fluff and reconciliation to make up for it. Bilbo's pregnancy is not discussed in detail so if that is a squick for you it will hopefully fly under the radar.

Random things to keep in mind: I am fucking with the canon life span of hobbits. I'm extending it quite a bit to give Bilbo plenty of time to live a happy life with Thorin when Frodo is an adult. SUE ME!!! Thorin is younger than he is in the movies. Also, I am shit with Tolkien lore so if you see something wrong about distances between cities or anything like that, pls forgive me and ignore it lol.

A huge thank you to Sunshine for hyping me up on this fic and betaing! And a thank you to everyone in the Acorns and Oak Leaves server who expressed interest/support in this idea! I hope you all enjoy :)

Edit: this fic has been added to the 2025 WIP Round-Up event! I was paired with a fantastic artist to help motivate me finish this bad boy. Any and all art is done by all-things-hobbit!

Chapter 1: Angel Eyes

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Having a prince visit the Shire was inconceivable to the sheltered residents in the peaceful land. Bilbo, of all hobbits, was chosen to host said prince and his small party. The dwarrow of Erebor were hoping to create a lasting allyship with their fellow small folk. Prince Thorin Oakenshield was going to stay in Bag End as Bilbo was not only closely related to the Thain, but was a respectable hobbit with a nearly empty smial. A fact Bilbo was still mourning but his curiosity out won his unsocial habits.

Practically vibrating with excitement, Bilbo prepared his home for the dwarf prince. Out of everything he expected from the stranger from the East, he could have never dreamt that he would have fallen in love- let alone that his feelings would have been returned. Thorin was stubborn, difficult to read, and irritating. But Yavanna above did he have a voice like honey and eyes like forget-me-nots. Bilbo didn’t stand a chance the moment the dwarf was in his doorway. It had started as a harmless crush, one he had no intentions of pursuing. Bilbo was of age and well within his right to begin a courtship but- Thorin was a prince. A hobbit had no place in Erebor, especially seeing as Bilbo was not nearly as brave as his mother when it came to adventures.

Thorin disagreed. The dwarf had stayed up late with him beside the fire, tea and cake sitting untouched by their sides as they spoke. Suddenly, his large, calloused hand enveloped his. Thorin whispered words of adoration despite the nervous furrow in his brow and the quickened pulse Bilbo felt against the thin skin of his wrist. They kissed that night, beside the dim fire that made Thorin look dreadfully handsome.

Bilbo began to properly court him after that, a private affair that only the dwarrow staying in Bag End were aware of. His neighbors undoubtedly caught on over time, and Bilbo was certain Hamfast caught them snogging in his garden one early morning. He felt like a faunt again when the hobbit had cleared his throat, gaze disapproving when they separated with laughter and swollen lips.

It had been over a month when their peace was shattered. Contracts between Erebor and The Shire were moving steadily along in addition to their blooming winter romance. Bilbo and Thorin were shoveling snow out in the garden when a raven, Roac, arrived with a distressed caw. Thorin was on his feet immediately, and Bilbo watched on in confusion and concern as the two conversed in Khuzdul.

Since Thorin had arrived, his face and body grew more and more relaxed with each day. All of that serenity was gone in an instant. His face was hard as stone and the look he gave Bilbo filled him with dread. “My grandfather- The King has passed…" Thorin searched Bilbo's gaze and he took his hand. His next words shattered the hobbit's heart. "I must leave at once.”

Everything after that felt like a dream. Bilbo floated through Bag End, helping where he could to ensure a swift departure for his love and new dwarrow friends. Except they weren’t truly his. No one extended an invitation to Erebor, and Bilbo wasn't about to invite himself into Thorin's life if he wasn't ready for it. Well, that's what he had told himself. But a deeper part of him was terrified and insecure. He was no future consort, he was but a hobbit just past his majority. He was a fool of a Took to accept Thorin’s advances.

Thorin’s grief mixed with the weight of his future left him helpless. He had expected more time to figure out the best way to ensure a successful future for them both. Now, he was struggling to imagine a grieving nation to accept a hobbit as their future consort. Thorin couldn’t imagine bringing his beloved hobbit to the mountain only to wilt without the sun or his beloved garden. He was foolish to think he could stomach asking Bilbo to bear the weight of being his. To bear the burdens of ruling a kingdom with no family or support outside of Thorin. No, the hobbit deserved a life that was free. Regardless of how happy he made Thorin, regardless of how desperately he wished to have him meet his family.

They laid together one last time on the night before Thorin’s trek back home. Without Bilbo. They were in the hobbit’s bed, burrowed under the blankets as they simply gazed upon each other. Thorin’s fingers gently traced Bilbo’s features, and tears finally spilled over the hobbit’s freckled cheeks. Warm lips kissed away each tear, and when Thorin lifted his head, his own cheeks were damp. They wept, salty lips pressed together as their bodies tangled together. The dwarf committed to memory how perfectly they aligned. How right it felt to be with his One despite the aches in his heart.

The next morning Bilbo woke before Thorin. He took the time to memorize his features, relaxed and soft with the morning sun shining on his pale skin. His hand settled over his chest where Thorin's heart steadily beat below. Perhaps the dwarf would come back, or maybe Bilbo would be brave enough to travel to Erebor to see his beloved. Was he so naive to foolishly hope for their love to somehow reconnect one day?

Sooner than he'd like, Thorin woke up. They kissed and clung onto one another for as long as they could.

Much to Bilbo's dismay they eventually stood in the doorway of his smial. Thorin held his hands and spoke gently. "Ghivashel, it is with shame that I am unable to remain by your side… I'd like to at least gift you this-" He held out a delicate band of gold connected with a small latch. "To promise you that we will meet again." Thorin didn't mention how the gold complimented his curls nor how he wished to shower him in jewelry that marked the hobbit as his. It would be cruel to do so on his depature.

Bilbo couldn't hide the tears that streamed as he accepted the jewelry. His thumb ran across the cool, smooth metal. He noticed on the inside of the metal there was an engraving, amralime. He gave Thorin a wet smile and laughed. "I think it's a tad bit too big for my wrist." He worried his lip before throwing caution to the wind. "Would- Would you mind putting it on my ankle?" A terribly intimate place amongst hobbits. Anklets were quite the statement, but it's not as though the dwarf would know such a fact.

Brushing away Bilbo's tears, Thorin kissed his forehead before kneeling before the hobbit. "It would be my honor." He took the jewelry and gently fastened the piece around Bilbo's steady, well groomed ankle. The hobbit shivered, and Thorin looked up at him with adoration. More cries wracked Bilbo's chest and he shook his head, looking away. Oh how he wished the dwarf was kneeling for a life together instead of apart.

Wiping his eyes, Bilbo stepped away. "O-One moment." The hobbit scurried off to his mother's armoire, his fingers shaking as he found the piece he wished to gift in return. The hobbit was no longer crying when he returned to Thorin's side. Bilbo cleared his throat and smiled as best he could when he offered his gift. "I'd like you to take this. To remember me by." His eyes shone and he nearly plead- Please don't leave me. Take me with you. If you can't at the very least please do not forget me. Bilbo didn't voice his thoughts and instead presented a golden locket. "It was my mother's." He added with a whisper.

Thorin took the gift with awe and grief mixed in his expression. He pulled Bilbo into a passionate kiss. "Nothing could make me forget you, Bilbo Baggins." Nimble fingers got lost in Thorin's hair as he whimpered and kissed his departing dwarf.

Bilbo pulled away and whispered, "I know it's not very royal but-"

Brows furrowed, Thorin cut him off. "Nonsense. I'll wear your gift with pride. Would you do me the honor?" He lifted the piece.

Breathless, Bilbo nodded. Thorin turned around and squatted for the hobbit. Bilbo's fingers grazed his neck as he pulled away raven hair. It took a few tries for his trembling fingers to successfully latch it around Thorin's thick neck. He pressed a chaste kiss to his hot skin before pulling away. Bilbo’s smile wobbled when he saw Thorin properly wearing the golden heart on his chest.

Their last kiss was agony and perfection all at once. Salt lingered on their tongues and their hands clutched onto each other one last time. "I love you." Bilbo whispered against his lips, terrified he'd never have the opportunity to say it again.

The pain and joy mixed in Thorin's shining sapphire eyes made Bilbo smile reassuringly as best he could. The dwarf swallowed hard before rumbling, "And I you, Bilbo Baggins." The hobbit treasured hearing his name from his lips despite the solemn ache in his gut that their love wasn't enough.

Bilbo sat in his garden long after Thorin, Dwalin, and Balin disappeared on the horizon on their ponies. It wasn't until Hamfast was in front of him with a concerned frown that he realized he missed multiple meals. He ate with the Gamgee family and absently listened to their plans on having a fifth child in the next year. Bilbo politely smiled and swallowed the food that tasted like ash as he wondered if hobbits and dwarrow could have children.

~

The fourth morning Bilbo woke up to a cold bed and an empty smial, he realized he had to leave. He couldn’t stay with a family member, no, he couldn’t stomach their pitying, knowing looks. Instead, the hobbit packed for a trip to Bree. A small adventure to clear his mind and make the grief of losing his love to duty a memory- if only for a few moments.

When Bilbo looked past the annoyance of walking amongst men who didn’t mind their shoes, there was as strange comfort in being so small amongst them all. He went to the Prancing Pony, a familiar name thanks to his late mother. The sun was setting by the time he arrived, the pub already beginning to liven up. The hobbit was chilled, but he appreciated feeling something after days of numbness.

Bilbo ate dinner and drank tea alone at a table, the first smile he’s deigned in days thanks to the bard performing. The hobbit eventually warmed up enough to clap and sing along, eventually dragged out of his seat to dance with a group of young women and men. He wasn’t drunk, no, but he felt like it thanks to the dizziness caused by the raucous crowd. Bilbo fell into a chair with a giggle, waving off the paws of his fellow dancers.

Belatedly, Bilbo realized he sat at a taken table. He turned and jolted when he saw an amused elf sitting beside him. “Oh! I’m terribly sorry, I can go-“ And oh- the elf had blue eyes much like Thorin and Bilbo felt his heart feeling heavy once more.

A lithe hand landed over his arm. “Don’t leave on my account. I wouldn’t mind some company.” The elf’s voice was gentle, and Bilbo settled under his touch. The pale fingers were calloused, but cool unlike Thorin’s. He had long, platinum hair decorated with simple plaits.

Bilbo realized he was staring so he looked away, cheeks warm from his rudeness. “Ah- thank you. I-I apologize for staring I simply- I’ve never met an elf.” It was the truth, and the tales of elven ethereal beauty were certainly accurate. Bilbo's curiosity grew tenfold and his mind populated countless questions he wished to ask the stunning elf. Though, those blue eyes didn’t carry the same sensitivity nor richness Thorin’s had. He cleared his throat and offered his hand. “Bilbo Baggins, it’s a pleasure to meet you-“

“Legolas Greenleaf. And please, no apologies needed. Admittedly, I was looking at you long before you joined me- so we can call it equal." The elf quirked his head to the side before asking, "Are all hobbits alluring, or is it just you?” Legolas’ eyes crinkled and Bilbo found his blush only worsening. The elf ordered them a round of ale and the two chatted in the bustling pub. In the end Legolas invited Bilbo up to his room, and the hobbit found himself accepting. Perhaps it was because he didn’t wish to wake up alone again, or maybe it was because Legolas was everything Thorin wasn’t. Regardless, the night he spent in the elf’s arms was a welcome comfort for his aching heart.

The morning after he awoke naked, warm, and pressed against a strong body. Bilbo had smiled and hummed out, “Mornin’ Thorin…” His hand moved to nestle into thick curls, only to be met by smooth, thin hair. Bilbo's eyes shot open and his heart dropped. Oh. That's right, he hadn't slept with Thorin, the dwarf was gone. No, he had enjoyed a night with Legolas.

Peering up from under his lashes, he was met with curious eyes. Bilbo winced, "I-I'm so sorry about that Legolas I-"

Legolas shook his head and squeezed Bilbo's hip. "Peace, Bilbo. You were practically still asleep, were you not?"

Bilbo nodded, his brows furrowed. He sat up and hid his face in his hands. Shame overwhelmed him. "Well yes, but I-I- it's awfully rude to call someone by the wrong name after a night of-of passion!" Legolas' hand reached out and gently ran up and down his back. Bilbo's shoulders relaxed and he sighed.

The mattress shifted as Legolas sat up. "I am not offended, Bilbo." He comforted, voice gentle as his hand moved to run through Bilbo's mused curls. "Let us have some breakfast, hm?"

Looking up at the elf, Bilbo was only met with tenderness. He nodded. The two ate breakfast after refreshing themselves. The hobbit lost much of his confidence from the night before, a deep place in his gut screaming he betrayed Thorin. But the dwarf left, and there was no guarantee of any relationship between them. Bilbo stared into space as he ate.

"I hadn't realized the Prince of Erebor was looking for a consort." Legolas commented, tone casual as he observed Bilbo.

Choking on his tea, Bilbo erupted into coughs. "Wh-What?" Legolas grinned and gently kicked him under the table.

"Thorin is a common name for dwarves, but I know of one particular Thorin who is visiting the Shire. Your reaction only confirmed my inkling." Legolas responded before taking another bite.

Bilbo's eyes widened. "H-How could you possibly know-"

A small grin grew on Legolas' lips. "It seems you have an allure for prince's, Bilbo Baggins. I'm aware of Thorin's trade with the Shire because I'm the prince of the neighboring nation." He folded his hands and rested his chin on the back of them. His eyes crinkled as Bilbo's face contorted in shock.

"Oh-Oh absolutely not! No more princes, no more- absolutely not! Thorin wasn't looking for a consort. Which is why- why I threw myself into your bed like a floozy!" Cheeks pink with embarassment and anger, Bilbo stood. "It was a pleasure making your acquantince Legolas, but I best be off."

The elf's pale brows jumped up. He stood and followed the hobbit up the stairs. "I admit, this is the first time someone has been upset by such knowledge. I had no intentions of offending, Bilbo. Please, at least allow me walk you to the edge of Bree."

Bilbo huffed and rolled his eyes. He pursed his lips, guilty for his outburst. "Fine." He spat. Legolas had been a gentleman their entire time together, and Bilbo had genuinely enjoyed his presence. He sighed and stopped when they were outside his room. The hobbit looked up, their height difference nearly comedic when they were both standing together. "I'm not offended I'm just-" His breath hitched. Bilbo shook his head and closed his burning eyes. "He just left a few days ago, that is all. I feel like a fool."

"Oh, Bilbo… You are no fool. And you're not a floozy. It's natural to wish to distract yourself from grief." Legolas smiled. "And I'm honored to know you trusted me with such a task last night. You and I both knew it was a simple daliance. A curiosity to sate. I enjoyed it nonetheless."

Groaning, Bilbo rubbed at his warm face. "Yes- Well. I'm still mortified. Let's just get going, hm?"

The hobbit and elf left together, and Bilbo found it within himself to chat once more. He was smiling by the time they made it to the edge of the city, and Bilbo's heart felt lighter. Legolas was right, there was no shame to be had about how he spent his night. He smiled up at the elf and offered his hand. "It was a pleasure, Legolas! I hope you have safe travels doing whatever it is an elvish prince does."

Chuckling, Legolas shook Bilbo's hand. "Thank you, Bilbo. I'm glad to have met you. Safe travels back home." With that, Bilbo trekked back to the Shire with a tune whistling from his lips.

When Bilbo returned home, he fell asleep burrowed against the pillow Thorin slept on, cradled by his fading scent.

~

It had been a week since his trip to Bree. The house still felt empty and his heart was still heavy, but life went on. Bilbo invited Primula over often, or visited family members he had been avoiding. Sometimes the latter was for the worst, seeing as he was always questioned as to what happened to his dwarf. Bilbo hated having to answer, especially since most hobbits saw the damn dwarf leave.

Bilbo was always a curious creature. Maybe that was why he was lured away from hobbits and into the beds of dwarrow and elves. Certainly his mother hadn't had such intentions when she introduced her novels of adventure, or his father's books on history and politics. Alas, it was the truth. Before Thorin, and before Legolas, Bilbo would typically sate his curiosity by simply shopping at the market held by travelling dwarrow.

Most of the vendors were familiar faces, but the person Bilbo gravitated towards to the most was Bofur. He was a toy maker and always helped the hobbit procure the best gifts for his little cousins. He was cheerful, kind, and a rambunctious flirt. Bilbo always left the market with his pockets lighter and his cheeks aching.

Bofur was a good friend to Bilbo after all these years. They never wrote to each other, they simply waited until Bofur returned to the Shire with new goods and new jokes. Immediately, the dwarf saw past Bilbo's polite smile. He didn't ask about it, no, he simply upped his antics to have the hobbit laughing and to bring that twinkle back to his eyes.

Bilbo stuck around much longer than usual that day. He ended up sitting behind Bofur's stand to chat with him and the other hobbits shopping. Prim stopped by, buying a few trinkets before flitting off to see what else she could procure. The sun was beginning to set when Bofur nudged Bilbo. "You know I uh- have a few special toys back in my caravan. Would love to show you tonight, if you're up to it."

Grinning, Bilbo pressed himself closer to Bofur's side. He fluttered his lashes, "Special toys? Like, an articulated dragon?"

Bofur chuckled, his arm wrapping around Bilbo's waist. "No. I mean special toys." His voice dropped, and he glanced at Bilbo's lips.

The hobbit froze, his heart racing when he realized what Bofur was insinuating. One of the reasons the two got along so well was that the dwarf was like him, a bearer. Bilbo blushed, but didn't pull away from Bofur's touch. He licked his lips and hummed. "I-I would like that. But perhaps, dinner first? Wouldn't wish to distract from your… collection."

Smiling wide, Bofur squeezed his side. "Of course! Bombur should be cooking something up right now."

The hobbit remained at his side until the market was closed. He joined Bofur beside of the fire, enjoying the company of his friends and family as he ate. Bilbo felt warm and safe by the time Bofur lead him back to his private caravan. The feeling didn't go away even when he woke up beside his friend.

Bilbo propped his head on Bofur's chest, his brows furrowed and his lips pursed. "Does this uh- make us-" He clicked his tongue. "More? Do you want that?"

Bofur hummed, idly twisting one of Bilbo's curls. "It doesn't have to be more. I'm happy to be your friend who so happens to lay with you when you need some relief." His hand dropped to cup Bilbo's cheek. "I'm also here if you ever wish to talk." The dwarf leveled him a look.

Groaning, Bilbo buried his face in warm, hairy skin. Different from Thorin's, but familiar enough and comforting. "I know. Thank you, Bofur. I will, with time but-" He looked up at him with a small, nervous smile. "Friends then. I like you but I don't think we'd be good husbands together."

Bofur laughed, Bilbo quickly joining in. The rest of the morning went smoothly, and the hobbit went home with a new toy in his bag and a smile on his lips.

~

It wasn't until two months later that Bilbo realized how foolish he had been. He had been feeling ill every day, and it wasn't until Primula stopped by with a healer that he learned the truth. Bilbo was pregnant. And although he hoped for one particular man to be the father, he couldn't be certain seeing as he slept with Thorin and Legolas so close together. He wept so hard until he made himself sick again.

Bilbo would keep the baby, but there was no use reaching out to either potential father. He had no way to reach Legolas, and Thorin likely hadn't even reached Erebor yet. Even if he had, he would be dealing with the affairs of the Kingdom. He wouldn't be able to drop everything to come back to him, to help raise a baby that might not even be his. No, Bilbo would have to raise the child alone. Oh how he wished his parents were still alive. Prim slept with him that night, spooned around him and whispering reassurances.

Notes:

>:3c awful communication in my bagginshield? It’s more likely than you think. I cried so many times writing this tbh

This fic is not complete yet, I'm still chipping away at it so there will not be a reliable update schedule.

Comments and kudos are greatly appreciated and are incredibly motivating! As always, please let me know if you think I need to add any tags or warnings. I hope to see y'all with the next update soon!