Chapter Text
“Will, there’s a new case that Jack wants you on.”
Beverly was forward as ever. She stood in front of Will’s desk, right as he was sitting down to start grading papers. She stood as if she had been there a hundred times before, her weight distributed unevenly on her hips and her arms crossed. Will thought she likely kept her casual stature everywhere she went. It would serve her well, as people would always think she knew what she was talking about. She delivered the news like she already knew how Will would respond.
“Jack agreed that I wouldn’t help him with any more cases unless Doctor Lecter says it’s alright. I have my evaluation set for tomorrow. Can’t he wait that long at least?”
They both knew the answer to that. Jack was anything but patient.
“Yeah, well this one’s a doozy,” Beverly replied, “ever heard of a Glasgow smile?”
Will hesitated for only a moment, but he knew Beverly noticed. Images flashed through his mind again, the blood covering his vision and tainting everything red. The grinning faces of the monsters that reveled in his pain. He heard their cackles over his screams and his tearing flesh.
“Yep. That’s what we’re dealing with,” Beverly continued, thinking he was simply familiar with the method, and not realizing exactly how well acquainted he was with it, “There have been two people killed. Same MO. Ankles tied, each hung from a tree, Glasgow smile from ear to ear.”
Will closed his eyes and swallowed.
“Tell Jack I said no,” he said.
Beverly looked surprised. It seemed not many people dared say no to Jack.
“What? Really?”
Will nodded, putting his papers away and standing up.
“I said no. I am not going to work that case, no matter what Doctor Lecter says. I said no, and there is nothing he can do to change my mind. If he asks again, I will quit and move across the country to get away from him. This is my final decision.”
Beverly’s jaw dropped, but she seemed more impressed than anything else.
Will stood up from his desk and started walking out of the classroom. He didn’t want to be there when Jack was given his response, and he was done with classes anyway. He was going to go home, turn off his phone, and take his dogs on a walk. Jack would have to cool down before he could talk to Will again.
There had been a time when Will wouldn’t have had the guts to do something like that. He had been the police chief’s favorite officer, because he never refused an order, and he was good at his job without creating obstructive connections.
Will knew better now. He knew that if he wanted to protect himself, he had to say no. He had to have the guts to make some people angry. He had to learn to get what he wanted.
It had been a painful lesson.
Will felt a bit bad for making Beverly deliver that message to Jack, but he knew she would be able to deal with it. She didn’t allow Jack’s anger to affect her if it wasn’t directed at her. She would be fine.
Will let the dogs out and walked with them into the field, taking deep breaths of the clean air. The dogs ran ahead of him, milling through the trees and prancing through the tall grass. Their steps made padding sounds on the soft earth, and they would occasionally snap a twig or find a dry leaf that crunched underfoot. Will followed where they led for the most part. He would be able to find his way back no matter what direction they went. He just looked around at the trees and rocks as he walked, keeping an eye on the dogs as he did.
Having seven dogs made his job a bit more exciting when they went out like this. The smaller ones tended to make a break for it if they thought it would be fun. Tracking them down after could stretch into the hours of dark after sunset. Will didn’t even bother carrying a flashlight with him anymore. The fireflies and the moon would light his way well enough for him to make it home if he ended up being out that late.
When he passed by the first body, Will grinned, feeling the pull of the skin from his scars.
Beverly said there had been two people killed , hung from trees with a Glasgow smile. In truth, what she should have said was that two bodies had been found . There were more to be found if the FBI knew where to look. They were far enough into the woods that they might not have to be attributed to Will if they were ever found. They hung from their ankles, bound with perfect and secure knots that Will was actually very proud of. Their cheeks had been cut from the corners of their mouths to their ears, having been torn the last few inches by their own screaming.
No, Will didn’t need to be more sociable . He didn’t need to make friends . He had plenty of friends, though it could be said the people he had chosen were of a lower caliber than he should have. They had all deserved this end, in some way or another. He wasn't a thoughtless killer, like some. These people truly were despicable, and he had done everyone else a favor by stringing them up and giving them a smile.
The ones that had been found were those that Will was very proud of. They had been truly terrible in life, and he wanted to let everyone know they weren’t a concern anymore.
He didn’t need to be thanked, honestly. He had what he wanted simply by seeing the smiles of his friends at times like this. He liked to walk through the trees and be greeted by the grinning faces of those who had wronged others, and had been silenced forever. He didn’t need anything else.
---
“Agent Crawford has informed me that he would be very grateful to me if I allow him to continue having you consult for him.”
Will scoffed. He hadn’t thought Jack would go so far as to ask the shrink for the results he wanted.
Maybe he had underestimated how much Jack wanted his help. There had to be something pushing him to get Will’s insight. There had to be a killer, or a case, that was digging into his flesh and tearing at him. Something that would make him want to stretch the rules to get what he wants.
“I hope you are not a highly suggestible individual, then,” Will replied, relaxing back into the chair opposite Doctor Lecter, “unless of course you are likely to allow me to give you suggestions.”
Doctor Lecter smiled, and he seemed genuinely amused. Maybe he had a similar sense of humor to Will. That would be interesting to see in a psychiatrist.
Doctor Lecter had his legs crossed, and he was wearing a suit that was equally as loud as the one he had worn to introduce himself to Will. His hair was not combed as harshly, letting a small fringe fall over his temple. Will wondered if he was trying to make Will feel comfortable. He certainly should have been, being in his profession, but the ostentatious office, paired with his meticulous appearance would normally have done little to make someone feel at ease. The walls were tall, and stacked to the ceiling with full shelves of books. The office had two levels, and seemed to loom around them with a history of its own. The man sitting across from him seemed to have grown accustomed to the space, filling it with his presence and personality. This was a space one could study to learn about the doctor, but Will wondered if it could be trusted.
“I have never been accused of being suggestible,” Doctor Lecter replied calmly, “but I see it as a bit of a competition, if you will. Whoever makes their case best, with the most evidence to support their side, wins. That doesn’t necessarily determine my decision, but it does entertain me.”
Will covered his mouth again and ducked his head to hide his smile. That was twice in as many meetings. Will wasn’t used to people catching him off guard. It was a dangerous game.
“Then I hope I can entertain you,” Will said, “Is there anything I can say that will ensure you rule in my favor?”
Doctor Lecter smiled. His smile was a small, polite thing that served more the purpose of seeming friendly than it did to actually show happiness. It wasn’t quite a true smile, but Will felt it was better to see that someone was putting in the effort to be nice than to be like him.
“The truth would be preferable,” the doctor answered coolly.
Will scoffed, pressing his fingers against a seam on the armrest of the chair.
“That’s what all psychiatrists say, isn’t it?” he asked.
Will felt the eyes of the doctor searching over him, and he felt exposed. He rarely felt that others could see more of him than he allowed, but Doctor Lecter was pulling at the corners of his outward persona. It was like he could tell what was real, and what was fake, and wanted to peel away the false pieces to reveal everything that Will was.
“The truth is always preferable, Will, though I understand your mistrust for those in my profession. It’s a rather intrusive thing to have thrust upon you unwillingly. I imagine it feels even more so when you are able to understand the motives and thoughts of others so keenly.”
Doctor Lecter laid it all out like it was common knowledge. Will knew it was odd to find someone who knew how it felt to be in his position. It was even more rare to find someone who openly admitted they were a part of that cycle.
The doctor watched Will for his reaction. Will knew that was what he was doing. For someone so aware of his own minute gestures, he must be skilled in the observation and interpretation of others’ as well. He was probably able to read body language as easily as he could read a book, which would have served him well in his profession to this point.
Unfortunately for him, he was working with Will Graham now.
Will wasn’t like Doctor Lecter when it came to body language. He didn’t stop all expression in order to be unreadable. He simply slipped into the mind of who he wanted to be read as. He understood others so intimately that he was able to act exactly as he wanted to be perceived. All the way down to the smallest micro expressions. He could fool anyone. He wasn’t just acting. He was, essentially, becoming. He would even be able to fool a polygraph if it ever came to it.
“The motives of most psychiatrists are to get into my head so they can tell all their psychiatrist friends that they finally got me under their microscope. They all just want to be the authority on Will Graham,” Will answered. He released the pressure he had put on the seam of the chair, and made sure to relax his muscles.
Will made sure his tone was even, rather than upset. He didn’t want to show any prejudice against Doctor Lecter, though he wanted to get his point across. He wanted to see how this one would respond to being called out.
Doctor Lecter tilted his head curiously.
“Are you quite a topic of conversation among psychiatrists?” he asked, “I am surprised that I have not heard of you before now if that is the case.”
Will frowned.
He hadn’t expected that. Alana had never mentioned him to her friends? He didn’t mind that, but he did find it odd. Most psychiatrists would flaunt even having met him once as a sign that they had insight into his inner workings. He supposed he should thank Alana for respecting him more than that. Doctor Lecter really hadn’t heard of him before, though? At all?
“I’m as surprised as you are,” Will admitted, “I would be hard pressed to find a psychiatrist who doesn’t have a preconceived notion of me, yet here you are. Apparently having never even heard my name before Jack Crawford. How odd.”
Doctor Lecter nodded, seeming to completely agree with Will’s observations. He made a note on his pad of paper, and Will wondered what he might be saying to his future self. Perhaps he was making a note to ask Alana later, about why she had never talked about Will. It would have been somewhat humorous if he were considering that Will had some narcissistic thoughts, as Will knew that was not true, or at least not on this particular subject.
“Perhaps the situation is to our advantage, then,” Doctor Lecter decided, “As I have no preconceived notions of you. You are capable of shaping my impression of you in the entirety.”
Will nodded.
It was a pretty good thing to be able to do, if it was the truth. He could hardly imagine any psychiatrist making it to this point without having an idea of what to expect already. It was hard to get a read on the doctor, too. His perfect control over his body language made it hard to know what he was thinking. He might have been lying to Will with every breath, and Will didn’t know if he would be able to tell.
It was fascinating.
“What do you want to know, Doctor?” Will asked, shifting his weight in the chair.
Doctor Lecter studied Will for a moment, as if trying to decide exactly how to dissect him. It wasn’t exactly intrusive, though. Will had seen people so intent to open him up that they had rushed in blind. The way Doctor Lecter was going about it was far more careful and considerate. He wanted to learn, while causing as little damage as possible.
It was refreshing.
“You told me you have nightmares,” Doctor Lecter said calmly, “I think that would be a good place to start today. I would like you to tell me about them. If there is a prominently repeated one, begin there.”
Will nodded. He had been expecting the doctor to come back to those sooner than later. People always wanted to know about the nightmares. It was a novelty, and people always thought they had secret meanings in them. Will thought that was the most ridiculous thing he had ever heard. His dreams didn’t have any secrets. Not from him.
“The one I have the most often is just a replay of the attack,” Will admitted, looking down at his knees and fidgeting, “The one right before I quit being an officer.”
It was true. He spent more nights than not reliving the horror that had driven him away from police work. It was always fresh in his mind, ready for him to access if he wanted it or not. He didn’t even need to sleep to have the full experience again.
Doctor Lecter nodded in understanding. It had been the expected answer. Will knew it would be. Reliving trauma was something most people with PTSD had to deal with. He knew it was true, and the doctor knew it too.
“Do your dreams remain loyal to what happened in reality, or do they warp and become more horrific?” he asked.
That was a new one. Most people didn’t want to make Will uncomfortable by asking more questions about the dreams. They felt uncomfortable themselves, and so they would move on to other topics. Psychiatrists usually asked him to describe what happened in the dreams, rather than ask about specific potential aspects of them.
“Most of the time it’s accurate to reality,” Will replied, “but every now and then I get some monsters. Reality is usually worse than fiction, in my experience.”
Doctor Lecter tilted his head at that, seeming curious. Will wondered exactly how much Lecter would be able to surprise him before he learned the man’s patterns. It had already been more than most people got away with. Will was hard to catch off guard, or throw off balance. He had enough experience with people that he knew the algorithms.
“If your experience was truly that horrific, I wonder why Agent Crawford would want to go against your wishes to put you through it again,” Lecter said.
Will shrugged.
Jack didn’t know the half of what had happened. He just knew that Will had been attacked, and that he didn’t want to do the work. He knew that Will had some ability that could come in handy, and that Will didn’t want to help.
“He isn’t aware of the extent of the damage,” Will said, “and he thinks I can just go to therapy and get fixed.”
Doctor Lecter seemed to understand that. He looked up to the top of the wall behind Will and seemed to be remembering something of his own. Will hadn’t even realized how searing his gaze had been until it was no longer directed at him. He felt like he could relax more now that the doctor wasn’t looking directly at him.
“Therapy is beneficial to anyone who will allow it to help. Even those who do not have intense trauma find it can help with what ails them. Do you think you are an exception?”
Will grimaced. He had heard this before. People thought he was arrogant for not wanting to talk to a stranger about what kicked around in his head. He was too proud to let himself be helped, they all thought. Will had heard it all, having found himself with plenty of insulted therapists and acquaintances in the past because of how they saw it.
“I’ve tried before,” Will said defensively, “but I know all the tricks you guys use. I can see what you are doing, and forgive me for not wanting to have someone dig around in my mind until they find the little trinket of information they can write an article about and be known for. I’m really not that sorry that I don’t go around telling everyone about my feelings. I’ve let the wounds heal. Opening them up again might make the scars smaller in the long run, but I’ve gotten used to it and want to be able to function in the meantime.”
The doctor’s eyes snapped back down and fixed on Will.
“I am not upset with you for your words, Will,” he said, “and I admire your ability to understand where you stand. Most patients I see come with the hope that I can tell them.”
Will was taken aback.
Doctor Lecter really was making a habit of surprising him. He hadn’t ever had anyone hear all that and say they weren’t upset with him for it. It wasn’t as if he really expected the doctor to be upset, but he hadn’t expected to hear him say it.
And on top of that, Lecter had just told Will he admired something about him. Something that had to do with his mental health .
It was how sure Will was. He hadn’t come into Lecter’s office, lost and confused, hoping to have someone map out where he stood. Will knew what he struggled with. He knew what his problem was. He knew what was wrong with him. For some reason, Doctor Lecter thought that was admirable.
“You have found a balance within yourself, Will, where you are able to function in your life, so long as no one upsets it. While it is an impressive feat for someone who has been put through so much as you have, it is not a healthy balance. You must fortify yourself against the changes that may come. I am going to recommend that you begin to have regular sessions with me. I will not open your wounds, but rather help you to understand how to work the damaged parts of yourself until they become healthy again. I will tell Agent Crawford that you may work with him, but I will be monitoring your mental state and can take you off a case if I see fit. I do apologize that this is not what you wished, but Jack will not be pleased with me either.”
Will scowled.
That was not what he had wanted to have happen.
Doctor Lecter was supposed to take a side, not make some convoluted compromise that served himself in the long run. He was supposed to make either Will or Jack happy, not make them both angry.
Will rolled up the sleeve of his flannel, not really thinking beforehand. He was just upset.
“You see these, Doctor Lecter?” he demanded, showing the scars that littered his arm, “This is what happens when I work in the field. This is what I want to avoid. The next scar I get is on your conscience if you do that.”
Will hadn’t meant to sound so childish and upset. He had just wanted to make the man understand what he was dealing with. It wasn’t just psychological pain that he had been through. It wasn’t just a single injury that had made him leave. He wanted Lecter to understand what he would have to face if he went out again.
Doctor Lecter frowned, seeming genuinely sad about it all, but he sighed. His eyes were fixed on the scars covering Will’s arms, and Will felt suddenly extremely aware of them. He kept them hidden most of the time because they made people ask questions.
“I am sorry, Will. You should never have gone through that. I believe Jack will be able to protect you from the physical dangers, and I will do my best to protect you from the mental. I have made my decision.”
Will huffed unhappily.
The image of Hannibal Lecter, with his face cut, faded into existence before Will’s eyes. He saw the gashes on the man’s cheeks, and the wide grin as the blood poured down his face. Will felt the knife in his hand, and felt the resistance as he pressed it into the doctor’s flesh.
Maybe the doctor would show more emotion when his face tore apart from his screams. Maybe Will would be able to know what he was thinking in truth, when Lecter was hanging by his ankles from a tree out behind Will’s house.
Will would be caught if he killed Lecter after this. It would be too obvious. He would be a suspect, and they would search the woods. The others would be found, and Will would be arrested.
No. He couldn’t kill Lecter. At least not yet.
But he had earned a place on the list of future grinning friends.
