Chapter Text
“The bones in her feet were basically shattered,” Zeller said, gesturing at the now horizontal ballet dancer on the table, “I guess he needed to break the bones in order to achieve that perfect pointe.”
Will stared at the lifeless body, feeling it was a shame for it to be seen this way. She had purpose before, and they had stripped her of it. By taking her down from where she hung, they had made her nothing more than another name on a list. Another statistic. Another grave in a cemetery. Now, she was just an object, when before she had been art.
The shifting form of the Ripper peered over his shoulder, and Will could feel its disappointment mixing with his own. The Ripper was also curious, waiting for Will to speak and reveal his own thoughts of the art piece. Will could feel the darkness from the imagined creature seeping through his skin and into his bones the longer he stood there. It tickled like black feathers against his skin.
“He wanted her to become pliable. She wasn’t teachable before, in life, so he made her more open to suggestion in death. He could have positioned her without breaking her, but he didn’t just want her to obey. He wanted her to learn .”
Will felt the familiar silence fall over them at his words. It tended to happen when he sounded frightening. He was so close to the minds of killers that he sounded like one. That was the excuse everyone gave to his peculiarity. In truth, his understanding came from a more personal interest.
Will wondered, briefly, who would be the one to first break the silence they had cursed themselves with.
If it were Price or Zeller, they would likely say something that would leave both Will and Jack displeased. If it were Beverly, she would say something that eased the tension and momentarily distracted all feelings of discomfort, directing the conversation away from Will. Jack would try to push the team to work harder, or faster. He would only postpone the ire that would later come to hang over Will like a guillotine.
“A man who prides himself in perfect control. He deems his vision for the world to be superior to reality.”
Will turned, not allowing his surprise to show on his face as he set his eyes on Hannibal Lecter. The man was staring right back at Will, and their eyes caught each other with quick intensity. The imago of the Ripper vanished with a speed Will had never experienced from his fantasies of the killers he created.
Alana had said they were alike, and Will was starting to think they were more alike than even she knew. There was something in Hannibal’s eyes that spoke of danger, but more of curiosity. He watched Will, waiting for him to give something away. Will kept steady in his persona, knowing there was nothing the other would be able to tell from his observations. He had tailored his disguise with painstaking precision, and he knew there were no flaws. Not anymore.
Hannibal wanted to see him react to the deaths he witnessed. No reaction was what the team expected, but would be just as telling for the doctor as any reaction would be. Regardless of what the Doctor was thinking about Will’s lack of outward emotion, it was clear he would keep it to himself until the next time Will ended up at his office for a session.
“Everyone has their own vision of how the world should be, and everyone thinks theirs is superior,” Will answered flatly, “He’s not unique in that respect.”
Hannibal tipped his head, keeping steady eye contact, daring Will to look away first. With anyone else, Will wouldn’t have lasted this long, but there was something swirling in the Doctor’s maroon eyes that interested him more than it should have.
“What respect is he unique in?” Hannibal asked in response.
Will studied the man, waiting for any small sign of what he expected to hear. He knew he wouldn’t get anything unless the other man wanted him to, and he wanted to know if he did.
Nothing. The doctor made no move to signal the correct answer, staying perfectly, stoically still.
“His vision.”
There it was. The smallest turn of the man’s lip. The slight softening at the corners of his eyes. A very light puff of air that was less audible than visible. He was pleased with that answer.
Will wanted to know exactly how invested the doctor was in the Ripper case. He had a hunch as to the reasoning, but he needed to research the man a bit more to be sure.
“The lines were inserted through her skin and tied around her bones,” Price continued, apparently unaware of the tense atmosphere building around him.
Will nodded, having expected that to be the case. He had seen it at the scene, and had only had to wait until the others noticed.
“The killer has surgical knowledge, but you already knew that. If he had tied it around her flesh, it would have changed the way she looked. Aesthetics are the primary concern for the Ripper. Can you preserve the knots for me to look at?” he asked, turning and directing the question to Price, who still had his fingers under the skin of the body, “I have a hunch, but I want to verify.”
Price nodded, seeming to expect Will to know more than him in that department. He was right in thinking so, but Will wouldn’t be the one to show it off. Someone else always ended up doing that for him, much to his dismay.
Will glanced over to where Doctor Lecter was watching, and caught his gaze again. His shoulders were tipped just a touch forward, toward Will. His chin was lifted a bit, and his eyes were sharply focused. There was some hint of curiosity in his posture, now, and Will wondered why he would be showing that to him in this moment. To what end?
“Jack, can I get a list of what the Ripper has taken from the victims?” Will asked, turning back to the matter at hand, “Another hunch, but it would only be distracting if I told you and turned out to be wrong.”
Jack nodded, seeming pleased more every moment he watched Will work. His view of the world would congratulate him on the decision to bring the best available tool to the investigation, and on his ability to convince someone who was notoriously difficult to get. Every time Will did well in Jack’s eyes, it was a stroke to the man’s ego where he certainly did not deserve it.
“So you are wrong sometimes!” Zeller declared triumphantly, as if he had thought it an impossibility before then.
Will caught Hannibal’s eye once more before he answered. He wanted to see how the Doctor reacted to what he would say next.
“Only a fool thinks himself a wise man,” he said, “a wise man knows he is a fool.”
There it was again.
The small hints of a smile in the doctor’s expression. Will was curious despite himself, and wanted to know what the other man was thinking when he allowed himself to show these small bits of emotion. He was certainly unusual, but to what degree had yet to be discovered. Will was determined not to allow the psychiatrist to pose any threat to his life or freedom. If he ever seemed to know more than he should, Will promised himself he would find a way to sever the connection.
That didn’t mean he couldn’t entertain himself by playing a few games in the meantime.
“Dude. Lighten up,” Zeller said, sounding somewhat defeated, “would it kill you to smile every now and then?”
Will turned and fixed the agent with a perfectly blank expression. He knew exactly how disturbing it would be to the man, and he was glad he already had the reputation of being creepy, if for that moment alone.
“No one has seen my smile and lived,” he said, his tone flat and emotionless.
Zeller was frozen in place, his mouth gaping a bit in shock. He was terrified, but also completely confused. He had not expected to ever feel threatened while in this building, and hadn’t considered the other employees of the FBI to be any danger to him. He was under the illusion that he was safe here, and allowed to behave the way he wished. The idea that someone who had been directly requested to be there could in any way harm him or be a danger to him was shattering his perception of how the world worked. He was losing some part of his innocence.
It hadn’t exactly been a lie either. Excluding himself, Will didn’t know of anyone who was alive that had ever seen him actually smile. He didn’t count his small polite smiles, of course, because they were nothing more than a part of his mask. Few people would even call them smiles.
“That was a joke, Agent,” Will stated, huffing a laugh to emphasize his point, “I’m just not very expressive. Focus on your work, and allow me to do mine, thank you.”
Beverly chuckled from where she stood across the lab, and Zeller shot her a venomous glance. Katz remained unfazed by his ire, waving it off as if it were nothing more than a bothersome fly. She reminded Will of a cuttlefish. She was intelligent, curious, adaptable, and had good humor. That would all serve her well, as long as she didn’t become too curious about anything that could put her in danger. There were bigger predators in the water, after all.
“He’s got a point, Z,” she said, “you want him to lighten up, but you can’t even figure out when he’s joking. Maybe you should just mind your own business when it comes to Graham.”
Will studied Beverly again. He had been right in his initial assessment that he would be able to get along with her. She was very likely the only agent on the team who would not become offended by his constant blank expression and monotone voice. She simply added it to her concept of him, and moved on.
---
“How is the Chesapeake Ripper treating you, Will?”
It was an odd way to phrase it, but maybe it was just part of Doctor Lecter’s psychiatrist charm. Will tapped his fingers on the armrest of the chair, sure the small tic would annoy the Doctor, just a bit. It wasn’t that Will wanted to upset Doctor Lecter, but people were typically more likely to slip up and show something they hadn’t meant to when they were distracted by something they were not pleased with.
Will saw the man’s eye flick to the movement, and Will was pleased. It was working, at least a bit. He might just be able to see something in Hannibal’s face as they conversed.
“About as well as any other case,” Will replied, watching for a reaction.
Jack had decided to put Hannibal on the Glasgow Smile case, needing someone to profile the killer in Will’s absence. That made their conversations more interesting. Will knew Lecter was interested in the developments of the Ripper case, so they had fallen into a sort of subtle rhythm. Will would purposefully make Hannibal ask for details if he wanted them, and Will could learn more about what the Doctor thought about his work by discussing that case in return.
They were both very careful never to give away more than was asked for.
Hannibal was resolute in his decision not to react to Will’s reply, apparently. Not a hint of emotion touched his features at Will’s casual disregard of the question.
“And how is the Glasgow Smile case going for you, Doctor?” Will asked.
Reciprocation was a common aspect of their conversations. Neither of them asked a question without being prepared to answer it in return. It was like a macabre dance between them, turning, twisting, spinning, and carefully avoiding the body parts that littered the ballroom floor. It was just a matter of time before one of them tripped over something, or grew tired of the activity. It was a game to see which of them it would be.
“Developments are slow and uncommon,” Hannibal replied coolly, “The killer is very aware of their actions, and is careful to leave little trace of themselves behind.”
That meant they didn’t have any physical evidence. Hannibal was probably being pressed for insight at every turn. Will would have paid money to see Jack pester him the same way he did Will, though Will had the sneaking suspicion he wasn’t quite as discourteous to the Doctor.
“Has your Viking angel maker been caught?”
Will snorted. That killer was many things, but Will did not in any way want to claim them as his . They were a minnow where he was fishing for a shark.
“Probably,” he answered, “I can’t imagine it has taken them this long to figure it out. I’m not technically on that case, though, Doctor.”
Lecter nodded in deference.
Will was still trying to figure out what it would take to make the man drop his perfect control. Even for a moment. So far, small annoyances had not worked, and he knew outright rudeness would only make the man close off even more. He needed to find a way to get more out of Lecter than he gave.
“Jack has given me the impression that you were quite adamant you not be put on the Glasgow Smile case, which is why I have been,” Hannibal noted aloud.
Will shrugged, also refusing to give anything away. It was almost stunning how little they managed to say to each other over the course of an hour every week where they did nothing but talk.
“Sometimes a case just hits a bit too hard,” he said, “and he tried to ask before I got my eval, which was a broach of our agreement.”
“Your verbal agreement.”
Will raised an eyebrow.
“Yes. I didn’t sign anything, but that also means I can quit working for him the moment I see fit, as I have not legally bound myself into servitude on his behalf. I prefer it that way, despite the fact that I am usually the only one who remembers the precise details of the agreements.”
Hannibal inclined his head, just a touch. He was curious. Will needed to use that. He had to keep the man curious, but not hide so much that it seemed Lecter wouldn’t be able to find out what he wanted.
“Do you have a very remarkable memory, Will?” he asked.
“Eidetic,” Will replied flatly, “always have. Sometimes it’s helpful, but most of the time it’s just another one of the things echoing through my head when it’s least convenient. What about you? Do you have a very good memory, Doctor?”
Hannibal smiled. It was just another one of his simple, single movements that gave away nothing.
“I was taught at a young age how to best utilize the spaces in my mind,” he replied.
Will nodded, relaxing back into his chair.
“You’ve built yourself a memory palace, then,” he concluded, “that’s the way most people do it. Theoretically, you won’t forget anything ever again. Of course, unless you make it to old age and your neurons start to decay, I suppose.”
Oh. Now that got a reaction out of the man. Just a moment of surprise, and his distaste at the idea of growing old and forgetful, flashed over his features. He thought that would be boring and he, for some reason, did not plan to have that happen.
Will was fascinated. It looked like the best way to learn about the man was to surprise him, but he was not surprised by the same things most people would be. Will’s dark humor and intelligence didn’t earn any reaction. Will would have to work hard to find out what would best catch the man off guard.
A man who was in perfect control of his mannerisms, who was intrigued by the minds of killers, who seemed to share Will’s mentality to a point where Alana had noticed. He despised the idea of growing old and seeing his body and mind decay before his eyes.
“That is the theory,” The man agreed, pulling himself together with admirable efficiency, “have you used any sort of method to improve your memory, or at least your ability to organize information within?”
Will studied the man across from him. He sat with his long legs elegantly crossed, and his fingers interlocked on his knee. He was much like a golden orb weaver. A beautiful spider with aesthetics that other spiders would envy, and delicately created traps that would prove fatal to any prey that wandered too near.
“I’ve never felt any strong connection with any man made structures,” Will offered truthfully, “so my mind contains no palace.”
Will could see the psychiatrist growing more interested, and the slight tilt of his head was as good as the man sitting on the edge of his seat.
“Then you must have captured areas from the outdoors in which to store information,” Lecter said, probably sounding more curious than he had intended to.
Will shrugged.
“I don’t store information in places , Doctor,” he replied, “I store them in moments. With everything that entails. With sights, sounds, feelings, every sensation. I remember every part, even if I didn’t notice it consciously at the time. It’s like having snow globes on shelves, each one holding a moment frozen in time. I just have to pick it up and shake it in order to relive it entirely.”
If Hannibal hadn’t been curious enough before, he really was now. He had actually moved forward in his seat, just a tiny amount that most people wouldn’t notice. Will had plucked on a few of the fibers of the web, and Lecter was coming to investigate if he was predator or prey.
“Are all the memories yours?” the man asked.
Will tipped his head, but otherwise didn’t react to the question. He wanted to show Doctor Lecter that he was not so easily read as most people. He would not be able to pull Will apart without having Will pull back. Will didn’t give up anything without a fight.
“I know that some of them are, I know that some of them aren't, but there are a few that land in the grey area,” Will admitted, “that just comes with the territory.”
Hannibal nodded, relaxing back in his chair as if he realized he had moved forward and was trying to cover up the fact that he had been so interested. He was waiting for Will to get caught in the web, so he would not have as much of a fight when he went in for the kill. Little did he know, Will was not prey in this scenario. Perhaps neither of them were. Only time would tell.
“Our memories are what build our personalities,” Doctor Lecter said, “we draw from our experiences whenever we are faced with a new scenario, in order to make a decision on how to act. Do you feel you have taken parts of your personality from those whose memories you now possess?”
Will laced his fingers together and crossed his legs so he was mirroring Lecter’s posture perfectly.
“My mind is full of mirrors, Doctor,” Will replied calmly, “and only some of them show my true reflection. It takes time to learn which of them can be trusted, and every now and then I run into a new one and have to learn what it shows.”
There was a lull in the conversation as Lecter considered what had just been said, and Will watched for signs of what the man was thinking. He was getting better at seeing the small things in the other man, but they were still hidden and vague. It took a lot of concentration to be sure what he was thinking.
“What about you, Doctor?” Will asked after a moment, “are there dangers in your mind palace? Places you dare not go? Shadows you pretend not to see?”
Lecter seemed to be pulled forcefully out of whatever thought he had been entertaining, and he blinked. Will had caught him off guard once again, and he watched intently.
Hannibal pressed his lips together, just a bit. His shoulders tensed almost invisibly. He pressed the pads of his fingers harder into the backs of his hands. His gaze was distant, but sharp and dark.
“My mind palace is not without its dangers,” he answered, “and one must tread carefully within their own mind no matter what their past contains. I am no different.”
Oh, now that wasn’t fair. Hannibal was purposefully downplaying the horrors his past held. Will could see he had true tragedy somewhere in there, but the man was good at hiding it. Will wondered what he would have to do to dredge it up. He knew a few party tricks, so to speak, that might be able to get him there.
In reality, they had gotten him kicked out of every party he had used them at, but they had been requested first. He wondered if Hannibal would be the type of person to reject him once Will started digging, or if he would grow more curious. From what he had seen so far, Lecter was more curious than judgmental when it came to his abilities, but he knew better than anyone that was no promise for the future.
“I think you have some real dangers in your mind palace,” Will said, staring Hannibal down, “Right at the center, at the beginning of construction. There are some deaths there. Significant people.”
Will hummed in thought, watching as the other man slowly retreated inside himself, leaving his expression just a shell of a human. A puppet without a master for a moment.
“Close family. Both your parents, I think. And someone else . Even more important to you. Someone you thought was everything. Someone you would have given the sun and moon to. You were young, but they must have been younger than you. Maybe a sister. A little sister who was taken from you. You still think of her, and you still have nightmares when something reminds you of her. You’ll probably have a nightmare tonight because of me.”
Hannibal stood up abruptly and turned, walking quickly over to his desk.
Will tipped his chin up as he watched. It was the most extreme reaction he had ever gotten out of the doctor, and he was interested. He wanted to see what the man would say in response to everything that had just been said.
“That was incredibly intrusive and personal, Will,” Hannibal said, his tone dark and dangerous.
Will didn’t reply. He watched as Hannibal braced himself against the desk. His shoulders were tense, and he was breathing slowly. After a moment of silence, Hannibal turned back around and looked at him.
“I believe I would be justified in some level of anger towards you.”
Will nodded.
“That’s how most people react,” he agreed, “but you’re more interesting than most people. I was curious to see what you would do. It’s not as if you have avoided asking me intrusive questions. I didn’t ask a single question, and you are free to deny anything I have just said. The reason you won’t, is that I’m right. It’s not everyday someone looks you in the eye and tells you about yourself. Feel free to do the same to me.”
Hannibal sighed, and he looked tired. It made him look older.
“You are aware I do not have the same ability as you,” Hannibal said, leaning back so he was sitting on the edge of his desk.
Will stood to walk over near the doctor. He felt powerful, seeing the man withdrawing inside himself just from the effect of Will’s words. Words were the weapons that dealt the most damage to Hannibal Lecter, Will had discovered. He intended to use them with as much precision and efficiency as possible.
“But you have some insights into how you think my mind works. I know you do. So tell me what you think you’ve figured out.”
Doctor Lecter looked up at where Will stood, his expression wary when he met Will’s gaze. Perhaps he knew what Will intended to do with his new found power. Perhaps he only had a sense of the venom in Will’s fangs.
“You are asking me to reveal my hand, when you have only revealed a card,” he said.
Will shrugged.
“I’m not a fan of card games, Doctor. I consider this chess, in which case I am just asking you to make your move.”
Doctor Lecter nodded slowly. He seemed unsure, and Will knew that was not something he was used to feeling. A man like Doctor Lecter was confident and self-assured at all times, in order to have the upper hand even when he would otherwise be at a disadvantage. Will had managed to outplay him at a game he had thought was his own, and he was coming to terms with that.
They were both spiders, but Hannibal was only used to playing with small insects. Will had spent his entire life playing with the other spiders. Doctor Lecter was going to have to get used to playing with opponents on his level if he wanted to have any chance against Will.
“You hide your trauma, though you pretend to be upfront with your past. The scars you have shown me are the least of what has happened to you, and they are the most you are willing to show anyone. In truth, you have been changed by your past in a way you choose to hide from others. Perhaps you worry you will be rejected by others if they discover what ways you have been changed.”
Will hummed thoughtfully as he leaned against the desk in the same way Hannibal was. He stared across the room to the large windows and let his entire posture relax. He knew Lecter was still watching him carefully, and he wanted to show the man that he was not intimidated. Will wanted Hannibal to know they were on an even playing field, but he refused to give anything away outright. He wouldn’t confess to anything, even if Lecter decided to confess something to him .
“What if I told you I wasn’t changed by my trauma?” Will asked softly, still not looking to the other man, “that what happened to me was not a diversion of my path, but an acceleration of it.”
Hannibal watched Will carefully as he spoke, and Will wondered what he was thinking. If he had suspicions towards Will, which he almost certainly did, then he might be starting to understand exactly what kind of monster he was. Will wanted to know exactly what kind of monster Lecter was.
“I would admire your ability to evolve through pain,” Hannibal replied, turning to stare across the room where Will was looking, “and I would marvel at the beauty of what you must have become, that you would keep to yourself. I wonder if you will ever find anyone you think is worthy of seeing you in all your glory.”
They both let the words hang in the air between them for a few minutes. Will didn’t feel any need to answer his wondering. There was nothing pushing him to satisfy Hannibal’s curiosity about him. There was no reason to give him what he wanted when Will still hadn’t found what he wanted himself.
“You are convinced that, whatever I have become, it must be beautiful,” Will noted, his voice soft.
Hannibal nodded.
“I can catch glimpses of it in your eyes sometimes,” he replied, “when you are surprised, or pleased. You may not seem expressive to most people, but your eyes truly are the windows to your soul. They speak louder than your voice at times. I would even hazard a guess that this is the reason you avoid eye contact when you can.”
Will took a deep breath and closed his eyes. Another signal to the other man that he did not feel threatened. No matter how dangerous Hannibal might be, Will showed confidence that he was more so.
He wondered what the other man would make of his obvious gestures. What he would think about someone who clearly did not fear the lion in the room. It could either be taken as foolishness, or rightly as a challenge.
“Eyes have always either said too little or too much, in my experience,” Will answered, “even as a child, I avoided the eyes of others in any way I could.”
Hannibal sighed softly. Will couldn’t tell if he was resigned to being understood, or frustrated at his own lack of understanding, or perhaps something else. Even with the insight into Lecter’s past, Will could not entirely predict what the man was thinking. He was an interesting person, and Will was enjoying the little game they were playing.
“Was it my eyes that betrayed the horror of my past?” Hannibal wondered aloud.
He did not seem to expect an answer, but Will knew he would not begrudge one either.
“More or less,” Will confirmed, “You are much too careful with your actions to give anything away unless you intend to. That is, apart from the moments you are surprised. I have managed to surprise you a few times, and each time I gathered another piece of the puzzle. When I put them together, I realized the tragedies your past must contain.”
They were both silent for a moment. There was nothing they needed to say. Will knew Hannibal would be studying his own actions, looking for times when he gave away bits of information. The man was not used to having anyone read his actions, or know about his past. He was accustomed to being mysterious and well-liked. Will took no small amount of enjoyment from being the first, and most likely only, person to catch him in this way.
Will still had a few tests he would need to put to the man before he could decide what was to be done about him.
Jack had inadvertently given Will an easy path to kill the Doctor if he ended up finding it necessary. The man was now investigating him, without anyone knowing it. If Hannibal ever came too close to identifying Will as the Glasgow Smile killer, Will would be able to take him out and display him for all to see. It would be a shame he could not join Will’s friends in the forest, as he was one of the most interesting people Will had met. Regardless, Will did not yet intend to kill the man. He only wanted to learn about him for now.
