Actions

Work Header

Truth and Trust

Chapter 2: Honor and Pride

Summary:

Rivendell is like most elven settlements; deceptive.

Their hosts are all smiles, agreement, and gracious manners that hide their true motivations. The valley elves are kind enough in their own way, but their leader seems to be under the impression that Thorin’s mission requires his blessing.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

Rivendell is like most elven settlements; deceptive.

Their hosts are all smiles, agreement, and gracious manners that hide their true motivations. The valley elves are kind enough in their own way, but their leader seems to be under the impression that Thorin’s mission requires his blessing.

Elrond translates the map though, which is all Thorin requires of him even if it’s just a delaying tactic.

It becomes clear that the subject of the elves’ interest is their wizard, which is annoying but not the impediment that it could be. They have planned for this and Gandalf knows his role.  In the meantime, Thorin endeavors to keep his people close and ready to move. This is made more difficult by the fact that Elrond’s daughter has adopted his burglar as some kind of exotic pet.

No one has seen Baggins since that first meal. The elven ladies whisked him away and have yet to return him. One by one his men peel away from the open-air chamber they’ve been granted as a campsite and take turns searching their host’s sprawling home. Nori comes closest and locates Lady Arwen’s rooms, which are sequestered from the rest of the house.

“That’s where our hobbit is.” Nori reports. “I heard some of them talking. She may be acting on her father’s orders. The Halfling would make an easy hostage to keep. He’s little, cannot fight, and we can’t replace him at this point.”

Thorin excuses himself when Baggins fails to appear for the evening meal. He has never claimed to know much of Hobbits, but he has learned enough from this one to be instantly wary when they start missing meals.

There’s no one in the women’s quarters when he knocks, which is ominous and he is returning to the feast hall with more concerns than he left it with when someone catches the edge of his coat.

At first he thinks it’s a lost elf child with her long silky skirts and the peaks of her pointed ears emerging from her elaborate coiffure, but he’s never seen an elf without moon-pale skin. This is a healthy nut-brown woman with wide dark eyes and glossy sable curls framing her rosy cheeks.

Then she speaks to him with Briar Baggin’s voice and the world turns over onto its ear.

“Master Baggins?” …he bites his tongue almost immediately when she sighs at it him. It’s a familiar noise and one he’s heard the Halfling make before.

Of course.

“Mistress Baggins.” He corrects himself and it sticks in his throat when she agrees with a smile of relief.

He escorts her back to the others and they speak, but later he won’t be able to remember what they said to one another because he is… he’s angry. It’s a subtle creeping emotion that swells every time he catches the subtle chime of bells or looks to see her seated amongst his company wearing the Elves’ drab gray fabric.

She seems content enough in her ill-fitting and borrowed finery, to be dressed up like a doll or someone’s pet. Did the elves have fun, he wonders? Are they laughing now?

Probably not. Elven malice takes other forms. It’s more likely that Elrond’s daughter is pleased with herself and smug with her perceived charity, which is arguably worse. The Halfling was a diversion for her –a toy at best rather than a woman grown with her own culture and canons of beauty.

She is beautiful, despite the unsuitably dull colors the Elves dressed her in or the one cheap ornament that holds her hair in place. Even the poorest of Dwarfish fathers would dress his wife and daughters in better. Perhaps the insult means little to Hobbits, who cover their cheerful clothing in intricate needlework male and female alike.

Jewelry is a rare thing in the Shire and his people have never been able to sell much of it there. His merchants do a better trade in practical things like plowshares and pitchforks. The weapons other than crossbows and belt knives in their stalls are referred to as ‘mathoms’ by the Halflings, which is a word that Thorin has only ever been able to translate as “interesting to look at, but ultimately useless.” There is little room in the Shire for impractical fripperies.

No, Briar Baggins is clean and warm after weeks of being neither. Her fringe is out of her eyes for once. The only bothersome element in her universe seems to be the way his men keep staring at her exposed shoulders and the gentle swell of her breasts. If the elves intended any insult tonight then it was not aimed at her.

She is young, unmarried, and in Thorin’s employ. By Elven custom he is her legal guardian. It’s not hard to trace the target back from there.

Thorin rubs his temples and kicks Fili under the table. His nephew favors him with a wounded look until he follows the direction of his gaze to Kili, who is attempting to feed their burglar from his own plate. Fili passes the kick onto his brother who manages drop whatever edible bit of greenery it was he was trying to tempt her with.

Dwalin catches Thorin’s look and changes seats with Bifur while Briar’s back is turned. Thus order is maintained for the duration of the meal.

Returning her to the women’s quarters is difficult and made worse by what passes between them in front of the doors there. Thorin is not proud of his actions, but he doesn’t have the words to explain the grave insult that their hosts have offered to his company through her.

Kili is idling about with a bit of copper wire when he returns to their camp. It looks to be the beginnings of an ear cuff with three bands to denote the rank of an honored hireling, someone of value and worth protecting. It is appropriate to Briar’s station within the company and Thorin cannot bear to look at it.

“Halfling do not pierce their ears, nephew.” He tells the boy. “Nor their faces. Their women wear no jewelry. Respect her ways as she has respected ours.”

“But, Uncle,” Kili is a good boy and puts his project away even while he protests. He has the pride and filial piety that suits a prince of Erebor. He, at least, is conducting himself better than his uncle has tonight. “You saw what they did!”

“The Halfing receives the Elves’ attentions in a better spirit than they were intended.” Thorin turns away so his nephews may not see that he likes the situation about as well as they do. “That was kindness in her eyes and not a slight on our company’s ability to support one another. She has suffered no insult and so by extension neither will we.”

“Perhaps one of us should fetch the lass.” Balin offers. “It’s best to have the company together.”

“Let her enjoy the company of other women for now, Balin.” Thorin doubts she is in the mood for his company at the very least. “Tomorrow, Dwalin will direct her to move her belongings to the encampment. It will be well.”

Dwalin comes back the next morning looking hunted. “They giggled at me, Sire.” He grumbles and looks over his shoulders as though Arwen’s attendants are waiting in the hallways to attack him. “And then closed the door in my face.”

Thorin acknowledges his mistake in sending Dwalin, a confirmed bachelor, on this particular mission and dispatches Gloin next, who has a wife and sisters. He fares better and returns with their Hobbit in hand. She’s wearing her own trousers again with a laundered waistcoat and a new shirt on underneath. Her hair she’s tied back with leather, which scalds the dignity of all his dwarves and they scowl at it when her back is turned. It was one thing when she wore it too short for ornaments, but now she looks like a pauper in their midst which is shameful.

The others talk amongst themselves –whispered conversations that go silent when he comes near- and he catches more than one of them lingering near the Elves’ smithy hoping to borrow some time there. It’s a fool’s errand, which he could have told any one of them. Elves forge differently than Dwarves and their tools are alien. Thorin has not missed his forge until now nor his tools. He has been a smith for over a century now while the warrior in him grew sleepy, but he is a Dwarf and the two were always meant to balance inside of him.

Copper is a fine metal, but too ruddy for her skin. Gold would suit their burglar better …with chains of fine steel to mark her bravery in the field of battle and silver charms to symbolize her clever tongue. Were he rich, he would have had a ruby cut in celebration of their defeat over the trolls and she would have worn it over her eyes to honor the entire company.

Were he rich he would have hired an army instead of a burglar.

It is many days before the Elves call for Gandalf, but he is glad when at last they do.

Finally, they can leave this place.  

Notes:

For the record: no, no one was trying to insult anyone. Arwen thinks everyone deserves to wear pretty dresses and is happy to share hers. The rest is mostly culture clash and the fact that Thorin (and company) are kind of looking for excuses to be insulted. (See: 'Are they offering us INSULT?' 'No, Master Gloin, they are offering you *food*')

You guys remember the intro for The Hobbit where we got to see the Dwarf women in Dale? Guys, I have SO MANY HEADCANONS about their awesome complicated jewelry and you're going to have to sit through them. Sorry.

also, please forgive all the 'their Halfling's and 'the Hobbit's. It just occurred to me that I don't ever recall hearing Thorin call Bilbo by name. Like, he'll say 'The Halfling' instead. So I just decided to go with it.