Chapter Text
They stay with Beorn for longer than Thorin is pleased with, but the fault is mainly his own so he has no one to blame but himself.
“These ribs are coming along nicely.” Oin informs him as he helps Thorin wrap his chest with fresh bandages. “We’re fortunate. You could have punctured a lung. Then where would our company be?”
“Under Fili’s command.” Thorin replies and wrestles his shirt on over his head. He’s had to forgo his armor for the time being in deference to his injuries, but at least he’s not bedridden. He’ll take whatever small victories he can get.
“Aye, but he’s as glad as anyone that it hasn’t come to that.” Oin allows. “I have a tea for you, but it’s best you eat something first. The herbs are not kind to an empty stomach.”
“If you must.” Thorin sighs. He’s had about enough of Oin’s restorative teas as any soul should have to withstand. At least here there is plenty of honey to cover the taste of them. That hasn’t always been the case in Ered Luin, where sweets come at a steep price.
“I do.” Oin fixes him with a glare. “Your blood is still thin from your injuries. It needs fortification; food, herbs, and rest. Go, lad. Attend to the first and I’ll see to the second.”
“Aye.” Thorin fixes his belt and escapes into the communal area where Beorn is holding court at the table and wheedling another tale out his guests. Today it seems to be Briar’s turn and she is in the middle of recounting a familiar riddle.
“Thirty white horses standing on a hill. First they champ, then they stamp, then they stand still.” She has a good voice for story telling and speaks now in a low wet tone. “‘Chestnuts, chestnuts’ The creature said. ‘Teeth! Teeth, my precious; but we has only got six.’ It opened its mouth to show me them and so it did; all blackened stumps and broken with great big irregular gaps in-between.”
“What’s this?” Thorin is displeased when his nephews immediately hiss at him to be quiet.
“Not now, Uncle!” Fili says, all desperation. “It’s just getting good. If you ask that, she’ll start over!”
Briar colors prettily and Beorn pokes the young dwarf in the side with one of his great fingers.
“Be generous, young one.” He rumbles. “Tales are meant to be shared in full. Half a story enriches no one.” He pauses. “Unless the Dwarf Lord has heard this one already?” He looks a bit hopeful at that.
“I was telling Beorn and the others what happened in the caves under Goblin Town while we were separated.” She explains. “I met a creature there like I’ve never seen before. It spoke like you or I, but was all-together wretched. There was a goblin who knocked me off the bridge where we were separated and it fell down along with me. The creature…”
“Gollum!” Kili volunteers. “You should name it Gollum. For the noise it made. Monsters need names.” He explains when everyone turns to look at him.
“There, I don’t agree.” Briar sniffs. “Hobbits don’t name dark things if we can help it. Naming something defines it and lends it power. Dark things need no help in either area.” She fixes Kili with a look and he seems suitably abashed so she adds, in a prim tone: “In any event, it called itself ‘My Precious.’ As names go, that will have to do.”
“Perhaps Hobbits are wiser than they’re generally given credit for.” Thorin observes. He takes a seat and helps himself to the bounty of Beorn’s table, since their burglar is paying their keep in stories today. “You made no mention of this on the hill. Why?”
“There was no time.” Briar admits. “And I was still rattled. It would have been a poor story.”
“And one that remains unfinished, Little Bunny.” Beorn hints with minimal subtlety, but it is a gentle hint. Of Thorin’s entire company, he seems to like Briar the best and there is no small concern among the others that when the time comes Beorn will attempt to keep her.
“Forgive me, Master Beorn.” She clears her throat and takes a drink from her mug. “As I was saying, there was a goblin who fell down with me. I was fortunate for the creature found it first because he bludgeoned it to death with a stone while singing and arguing with itself. I crept forward to see it and when the light from my blade died, I knew that so too had the goblin. I was not quiet enough and it heard me, there in the darkness. It found me and would have attacked were I not armed.”
It must have been a wretched creature indeed, Thorin thinks. He’s seen how Briar holds her tiny blade and no experienced warrior would fear her…nor any inexperienced one either.”
“It wasn’t a large creature. Indeed it was smaller than me even.” She continues, ensured of the rapt attention of her audience. His nephews certainly seem enthralled, so perhaps she did not describe the monster in her story very well before. “It was pale like the underbelly of a blind fish with wide, wide eyes that reflected any light that hit them and it rasped ‘gollum, gollum!’ in between breaths.” She mimics a horrible wet cough that sits somewhere between a toad’s croak and the creak some fish make out of the water. “It was spindly and wasted with nothing but a scrap of cloth between its legs for modesty and great big feet that flapped in the water.”
“Perhaps it wasn’t hungry or maybe it was curious, because it did not try very hard to hurt me at first.” Briar shrugs off the vagaries of monsters. “I don’t think it knew what I was and it speculated to itself whether or not I would be good to eat. ‘Bless us and splash us!’ It cried out. ‘I guess it’s a choice feast, at least a tasty morsel it would make us!’”
“Did you not think to kill it, Little bunny?” Beorn asks, speculative. “The dark things in the mountains cannot be trusted and do not understand mercy.”
“Well, you can imagine: I did not want to be eaten, but I did not know the way out either.” Briar explains. “So I had to speak with it, to try and convince it to help me. After all, it already had a meal. It seemed to me that both a goblin and a Hobbit was too much for the creature to eat before we all went bad. The creature was sadly not convinced. It was, however, lonely. So it suggested a contest of riddles.”
Here, she leans forward in her chair and Thorin leans forward with her, snared every bit as tightly as the others.
“‘If It asks Us’It said to me, ‘and We doesn’t answer, then We shows It the way out.’ That seemed reasonable to me, but then it continued to say; ‘...but if We ask and It doesn’t answer, then We eats it, my precious. We eats it whole.’” She pauses and shrugs. “What could I say? I agreed.”
Thorin feels his hands clench around his mug at that, but forces them to relax. What’s done is done and the Halfling is here now, none the worse for her adventure. There will be nastier things in the future than little monsters under mountains and it is good to see she can handle herself better than he ever gave her credit for in the past.
“We exchanged riddles then. Many of which I’ve recounted for Master Beorn and the others, but finally the creature came to its last riddle and I must confess, I almost had no answer.” She smiles. “Would you like to see if anyone here can guess?”
“Tell us your riddle, Little Bunny.” Beorn commands with an indulgent (and somewhat smug) smile.
Briar leans back in her seats. “This thing all things devours; birds, beasts, trees, flowers; gnaws iron, bites steel; grinds hard stone to meal; slays King, ruins town, and beats high mountain down.” She recites it with a queer echo in her voice that chills anyone listening, Thorin included.
“A difficult one.” Beorn allows with a thoughtful frown and sits thinking while Fili and Kili murmur back and forth. Eventually they give up, one by one with Beorn admitting defeat last.
“I’m all agreement with you, Master Beorn.” Briar sighs and looks at her hands. “Because I wasn’t able to guess either. I thought of ogres from stories, even though I knew the answer must be different. Then I became scared and no one thinks well when frightened. It circled me as I thought and watched me with it’s great big eyes. ‘Is it nice?’ It murmured in the darkness. ‘Is it juicy? Is it soft?’ I became so rattled that I tried to cry out, ‘Give me some more time, a little more time!’, but the only thing that came out was ‘Time! Time!’” she smiles. “Maybe I was being guided because ‘time’ was the answer. Oh, how the creature howled! It was not happy and said ‘One more question! Only one more!’ Only I didn’t know anymore riddles.” She opens her hands. “I’d asked all the ones I knew, every single one I ever overheard over the fire in camp, all of them. So I said: what have I got in my pockets?”
“That’s not a riddle!” Fili objects. “Uncle, tell her. That’s not a riddle.”
“Oh, I know it’s not. The creature said just the same things. ‘Not fair!’ It cried out. ‘Not fair to ask Us what it’s got in its nasty little pocketses!’” Briar laughs. “But it just said ‘ask’ and I pointed that out so it had to accept the question, although it bargained for three guesses because I hadn’t asked a riddle. ‘Handses!’ It guessed and fortunately, I had just taken mine out. ‘Knife!’ It tried again, but was wrong. ‘String or nothing!’ was its last guess, which I thought was a bit unfair; guessing two things at once. Fortunately for me, both guesses were wrong.”
Briar shakes her head. “It was very unhappy with me and cried ‘cheater!’ ‘A promise is a promise.’ I told it and it said, ‘Did we promise, precious? To show the nasty Bagginses out? Yes, yes… but we cannot go yet. We must get some things first; things to help us.’”
“Wicked thing.” Beorn says mournfully, shaking his great shaggy head. “They will ever turn traitorous. You did not believe it would honor its word, did you, Little Bunny?”
“Not really.” Briar says. “It left me on the shore and paddled to a little hut it had made on an island in the center of the lake where it lived. It spoke to itself and the cave was shaped so that sound carries a great distance inside of it. I wasn’t intended to hear, but I did. ‘My birthday present.’ It gurgled. ‘That’s what We wants now, yes! We wants it. It came to me on my birthday, my precious.’ I heard it paw around amongst its things and still it whispered. ‘Quite safe, yes. It won’t see us and its nasty little sword will be useless, yes.’”
“So it meant to kill you then.” Fili guesses. He’s making a show of polishing one of his blades now, but it’s an old and familiar task that the boy could do blindfolded. “I might have known.”
“Yes, you’ve the right of it, but whatever it wanted out there on the lake wasn’t there when it went looking.” Briar explains. “It began to thrash about and cried ‘Where is it! Where is it?’ It paddled back to the shore and began to throw bones around, searching and searching and crying out; ‘Lost it! Lost it, my precious! Curse us and crush us, my precious is lost!’ ‘So am I!’ I told it for I was impatient. ‘What have you lost?’ It rolled about and moaned, ‘It musn’t ask us! It isn’t its business!’ We argued that a bit, back and forth. It wanted to stay and search for what it had lost and I wanted to be un-lost, after all, I won the game and it was delaying.” She shakes her head.
“What came next was inevitable, most likely. It looked at me suddenly and began to hiss. ‘We never guessed, did we? What has it got in its pockets? Hmm?’ ‘None of your business. Answers are meant to be guessed, not given.’ I told it, but it was angry by then. ‘What has it got in its pocketses!’ It hissed again and began to chase me. Oh, I ran. I ran in the darkness and it chased me, hissing ‘What has it got in its pocketses?!’ I fell then and it was on me. I thought I was done for and I gripped my blade, hoping to get in a few good whacks...”
“Hah! I knew you killed it.” Kili laughed and holds out a hand to his brother. “Pay up, Fili. Our burglar is blooded now.”
“Don’t pay him, Fili.” Briar advised the elder brother. “I didn’t kill it. It leapt over me and kept going. I don’t think it saw me, it was so blinded by anger. It wasn’t born in those caves, I don’t think, so even if its eyes had adjusted it was never meant to live in such a lightless place. It saw only a little better than I did.” She takes a bite of what appears to be a pickle sandwich as she enjoys the dismay of Thorin’s nephews, who like nothing better than a story with a little gore in it. “It ran ahead, muttering and whispering. ‘Curse it, curse it, curse it! What has it got in its pockets? Oh, we guess, we guess, my precious. It has my birthday present.’ I followed it as chased what it thought was me. ‘It says it doesn’t know the way out.’ It hissed, ‘It said so, yes, but it is tricksy It doesn’t say what it means. It doesn’t say what it’s got in its pockets. It knows. It knows a way in, it must know a way out.’”
“I see.” Beorn laughs his great booming laugh. “Clever bunny! You followed it out!”
“I did and my timing was good. We reached the back door just as the others did, but I couldn’t get past.” She shrugs an apology as Thorin and both his nephews stare at her. “All of you passed within touching distance of the creature. It was hiding behind a stone from you and the goblins chasing you, but it was between me and the exit. Oh, I was so upset. There you were, all my Dwarves and my Wizard, and I could not catch you. It wouldn’t move and I couldn’t move for fear of it seeing me until it turned its back and I …well, I jumped over its back and ran out into the light. It screamed! How it screamed in fury. ‘Baggins! It stole from us! We hates it!’ It shrieked after me. ‘We hates it forever!’” She drops her hands and smiles. “That is how I escaped the caves.”
“A fine story, Little Bunny.” Beorn praises her and rewards her with a honeycake that could feed three of Thorin’s dwarves. “You must be careful in the future. Dark things cling to their hate and they do not forget it.”
“I don’t think it would survive in the daylight world for long, Master Beorn.” Briar looks out one of the great tall windows that line the great hall. “To tell the truth, I very nearly did kill it. I had my blade to its throat and it never saw me. I could have done it, but…” she frowns. “It really was a wretched creature, deprived, and entirely mad. I couldn’t take what little it had left away. Perhaps it’s strange, but for a moment… for a moment in the weak light coming from the back door I looked at it and saw a Hobbit.” She looks up to Beorn. “Is that strange?”
“No, Little One.” Beorn replies sadly. “Even dark things came from somewhere and they all belong to someone. Even Orcs are born of their mothers. It is a difficult thing to remember that they are creatures of rational minds and beating hearts just as you and I are. Perhaps it was a Hobbit once, but I doubt it. It did not recognize you as one of its own.”
“True.” Briar allows and smooths a hand down the front of her clean mended waistcoat. Thorin’s eyes are drawn to the little wooden buttons that have replaced the little twigs and sticks that she has been using for toggles in place of the buttons she lost before. They seem to be a good fit and Thorin is pleased.
“Is that where you lost your buttons?” He asks, unable to resist and is rewarded by an embarrassed blush.
“Yes.” She toys with one of her replacements, the third one from the bottom that has a slight irregularity to its shape where Thorin encountered a tiny knot in the wood as he carved. “I fled through a crevice that was almost too tight for me to squeeze through. I might have done it better had I time, but the creature was chasing me and so I pushed so hard my jacket tore.” She turns a speculative look on him. “No one else has asked me about my lost buttons.”
Thorin goes still. He had assumed she knew who’d left that gift on her pillow. It was meant to be an offering of reconciliation, but it’s… it’s good seeing her wear the work from his hands. He likes it too well and often catches himself designing little trinkets throughout the day; things a Hobbit would value like a traveler’s spoon or a fish hook.
“Perhaps you know who this belongs to then?” She asks as she tugs the handkerchief he wrapped his handiwork in. It’s a fancy thing that Dis insisted he carry with him even though he has never used it for its intended purpose. It seemed fitting to pass it along to someone else who has been in need of one.
“I’m sure its owner intended for you to keep it.” Thorin says. “If it was left for you.”
“Hmmm, I wonder.” She turns the cloth over in her hands. “It’s a shame that they would give away such fine needlework.”
“Give us a gander.” Fili says and looks over her shoulder. “Hmmm, that’s the crest of Durin’s line. See? That’s the King’s crown there. Here now, Kili, is this yours?”
“Not mine.” Fili holds up his hands. “You know I can never keep those, no matter how many Ma gives us. I lost all mine before we ever reached the Shire and they were never so clean.”
“I see.” She looks at the square in her hand and tucks it back into her pocket. “Well then, I guess I’d better hold onto it. Perhaps its owner will want it back someday.”
“Doubtful.” Thorin mutters and would say more, only Oin comes into view then with an entire pot of his noxious tea and it is time to make a strategic withdrawal –for all the good it does. The old bastard finds him within half an hour and makes him drink the entire pot. The leaves make him tired, which is probably the point, and so he retreats to his own bed.
Perhaps he should have expected that the Halfling wouldn’t let the issue of the buttons or the blasted handkerchief slide because there’s a small square of linen folded up on his pillow when he goes to lay down.
At first he thinks it’s the one he gave to her being returned in the most final way possible, but the color is wrong when he picks it up. The texture too. Dis favors stiffer fabric that holds a crease well, but this is soft like a worn shirt.
It is from a worn out shirt, he realizes after a moment having suddenly recognized the scrap as all that remains of the fine shirt their little burglar received from her Elven benefactors. It’s been laundered and hemmed around the edges with neat orderly little stitches. There is no embroidery, no frippery about it, just plain workman-like sewing.
He shouldn’t be pleased with this. There is clearly something wrong with him that he instantly likes it better than a gift his sister undoubtedly spent hours working on, but this… it suits him. It’s functional.
He likes it.
Thorin lays it down on top of his coat as he stretches out on his pallet and it’s probably just his imagination, but the faint echo of spice follows him into his rest and soothes his dreams with the sound of soft laughter in a snug little house full of warmth and good cheer.
...and perhaps it's only a dream, but he thinks he hears voices later outside of his cubby. One belongs to his Wizard and the other his Burglar.
"Out of curiosity, my dear Briar," Gandalf asks. "What did you have in your pockets?"
"A secret." She replies all cheek and amusement. "It was a secret."
"I see." Gandalf hums and it is not entirely a sound of contentment. "I see. Then you had best be careful of it." He says at last. "I've noticed that those tend to bite."
