Actions

Work Header

Truth and Trust

Chapter 6: Endings and Beginnings

Summary:

Thranduil and Bard of Lake Town are sitting outside his gates like expectant dogs or carrion birds, Thorin cannot decide which, each with an army and each with their own demands.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Thranduil and Bard of Lake Town are sitting outside his gates like expectant dogs or carrion birds, Thorin cannot decide which, each with an army and each with their own demands.

“I won’t deny the Men their claims.” He tells Balin, who waits impassively at his side. There is wealth in the Mountain that was not made or collected by Dwarven hands. He’s seen the rough trinkets of beaten metal that Men make in amongst his peoples’ crafts along with Elven goods and more of the Dale’s currency than his grandfather would have kept in the vaults. “…but not while the Elves stand at their side. The men have the Dragonslayer’s traditional reward in the form of Smaug’s breastplate. They are not in such dire straits as they would have us believe. They can afford patience. That they choose not to exercise it does not endear me to them.”

“Aye, my King.” Balin allows with a strangely neutral nod.

“And I will not pay the Elves for the privilege of bread and water in the prison. Ori might have died of their so-called ‘hospitality’.” He goes on.

“Aye.” Balin nods. “That is true.”

“We have food and water for some weeks with care.” Thorin prowls back and forth. He is ready to withstand a siege. That which he values most will not be lost even if he fails to hold Erebor. Briar is small and clever. He trusts her to survive when all the rest of them fall. There is little he believes in these days, but he still believes in that.

He has to.

“Dain will come.” He says. “He will come for the Mountain, if nothing else.”

“That is my worry, my King.” Balin says at last with a pensive look. “I am worried that we trade one siege for another. Perhaps it is better to buy off the Men. They can be bought and I believe Bard will stay that way. Dain is a good man and our kin, but… the Iron Hills is not a wealthy land and his is a pragmatic soul. Moreover we will need Dale before long. Our people are not Hobbits. We do not have the gift of growing things in the good earth nor healing it after so much damage.”

“You would have me bend knee before the Elves?” Thorin snarls.

“No, sire.” Balin holds up his hands. “Only treat with the men. Allow Bard to approach with equal our number or double, if he feels threatened by our walls. Point out we are only twelve and he does not require Thranduil’s blades to take us if he so chooses. He is a good Man, Sire. He tended us when we had nothing. Surely that has not changed.”

“I wish I could agree with you.” Thorin finds a seat and drops into it wearily. “Thranduil’s poison has his ear now. Do you think the elves will go peaceably back into their forest with empty hands? Bard must think to his own folk. They have no walls to stand between them and those blades.”

They would have spoken longer, but Fili interrupts then by dashing in from the balustrades. “Uncle!” He pants. “Uncle, there is trouble. Bard and his men are back… and they have our burglar!”

This is the point where Thorin will remember it all as going wrong for Bard does indeed have a Hobbit who does not belong to him, but neither does she seem to belong to Thorin for all that he would trade his entire portion of gold for her safe return.

She is among the men willingly and she brought with her the Arkenstone.

What passes from that point on is a matter of history and can be found in any book. Thorin will write some of them, although they will be bitter to him and he will not read them again once he has finished.  

Already some accounts will have it that he died of his wounds shortly after the goblins and orcs were defeated, as was almost the case. In these versions of the story he is usually laid to rest with honor in the deep halls of his grandfather with the Arkenstone at his head and Orcrist on his breast as an eternal watchman for his people against the return of the orcs that he hated so in life.

The truth is a little more complicated.

The battle was a bitter one, every bit as harrowing as the one he once fought to reclaim Khazad-dum. He remembers it in bits and snatches, flashes of blades, and the thick scent of Orc blood. He fell, yes, under the onslaught of Azog’s son and a hundred orcs. Fili and Kil were beside him, both wounded, and it seemed for a time that this would be the end of his branch of the family tree.

Then the Eagles came and everything changed.

Dain’s people recovered him and took him into the Mountain. The healers shook their heads and Thorin wandered in and out of a pain-fueled haze. He remembers demanding the return of his Halfling from someone he thought was Bard, but may have been Bombur. Perhaps he dreamed that because she did not come. His people never found her on the field or among the wounded and dying.

Briar Baggins vanished off the battlefield that day and Thorin was glad of it for a time because it meant that she was still among the living.

(In those days he did not allow himself to think of her lying dead somewhere, cloaked by the power of her terrible ring, invisible to all who would bury her with honor.)

It is in those hours, the final ones of his former life, that Gandalf comes to him in his sickroom.

“Greetings, King Under the Mountain.” He says and it is not a kind voice he speaks with. He sits without invitation and dismisses Thorin’s attendants with a voice no one would disobey. “I am told you had two treasures before the Battle began.”

“The battle is over.” Thorin croaks. “And now I have neither.”

“Perhaps.” Gandalf says and from his sleeve he pulls out a gem he thought never to see again outside the grasp of Men. “Bard gave me this to return to you …in trust, of course, for the share of treasure that Briar Baggins promised him.”

“He will have it.” Thorin stares at the stone. Was it always so dull? He remembers it looking brighter, cupped in the hollow of a Hobbit’s belly. He does not reach for it. “I cannot take riches with me where I go and it was her wish that Lake Town be paid from her portion.”

“Yes.” Gandalf agrees. “It was and I am pleased to see you will honor it; pleased enough to offer you a bargain that I thought I would not.”

“I have little time left for games, wizard.” Thorin sighs. “And many goodbyes to make. My heirs lay dying and soon I will join them.”

“Fili and Kili will live.” Gandalf tells him in a more gentle tone. “Thranduil sent healers of his own people, all well-versed in the arts, to see to them in honor of the Hobbit who so impressed him with her selflessness. ‘There is much to be learned’ he said, ‘from little people. We will emulate her behavior.’”

Of course. Thorin would laugh had he the breath. Even now, even in her absence, his burglar is saving that which he values most.

“So now, O King who has lost both his treasures, I offer you a choice.” Gandalf says. “Even though I am still not convinced you deserve it. You will have one of them returned to you, but you must choose which. One of them you may have in life, but the other you may only have in death. Which do you choose?”

“I choose her.” Thorin’s response is instant. There are things he must say, words he must take back, and promises he would fulfill.

“Have a care, King Under the Mountain.” Gandalf cautions him. “I did not say which was which.”

“I care not.” Thorin says. Dying has a way of putting things into perspective and he is shamed by much of his life. “If she is not in this world then I will go to the one where she is.”

“No need.” Gandalf replies and he is smiling at last. “No need, my dear friend. She is still in this one, although where exactly I have not quite discerned. I take the Arkenstone as my price for your life.”

“Take it and have joy of it.” Thorin tells him. “My family has labored under its curse too long. Perhaps a wizard will do better.”

“Perhaps.” Gandalf allows and tucks his sleeves back. “Take a breath now, Thorin, and hold it. What comes will not be pleasant, but it will be worse if you scream.”

It isn’t. He doesn’t. He lives.  

People ask him to this day what the wizard did to cure him and Thorin will not tell them. It is a secret he will take to his grave and beyond, most likely. Some things it is better not to know and this is one of them.

When he can speak again he summons those of Dain’s men who have chosen to stay with him. Balin was incorrect about his cousin. Dain Ironfoot is a good man to whom the Iron Hills are more valuable than all the gold in Erebor. He is glad to return to that ancient stronghold where Dain first settled their people and wishes Thorin every happiness.

Liutenant Freyr is of Firebeard descent and some distant kin of Gloin, thus he is trustworthy. Thorin sends him out with a set of orders that precedes all other priorities.

“Find her.” Thorin tells the grim soldier. “Find her and guard her from harm. Bring her here if she will come or take her to the Shire if she will not.”

“I will obey, my Liege.” Freyr grants him full obeisance and straightens back up with steel in his spine as he starts cracking orders to his men.

It is a full year before he sees any of them again.

Thorin is deep in the mines, inspecting a cave-in when the drums reach his ears. If he could, he would drop everything, but there are miners trapped behind a wall of rubble and no one knows yet if they live so he is forced to trust that his valet remembers the standing orders he has been given in the event that Freyr return is a successful one.

His miners are alive, if annoyed with whoever it was who set the supports in that particular vein. It is more work convincing them to report to the healers instead of starting back to work at once than it was to free them.

His people were ever obstinate.

Freyr is waiting for him at the mouth of the mine shaft and Thorin knows that he fulfilled his mission when the grizzled old veteran breaks into a smile that displays all eleven of his teeth.

“Your valet took charge of her, Majesty.” He reports. “She is resting in the chambers adjacent to yours. Poor mite. It’s been a long journey on the heels of another long journey, but she did Erebor proud.”

“She is incapable of doing less.” Thorin agrees. “You have my gratitude, Captain Freyr.”

The dwarf starts to salute and then falters. “Captain, sire?” He sounds insulted.

“Bear it, soldier.” Thorin advises him. “Or don’t be competent where I can see you. I have need of men like you in positions of greater command.”

“Yer a bastard, Oakenshield.” Freyr declares, chewing on the ends of his moustache. “To think I was starting t’like you!”

“Hah!” Thorin claps his latest senior officer on the shoulder and dispatches him to the armory to get a proper kit. “Take it up with my advisors. They all told me the same.”

She’s asleep when he finds her, curled up on her side and all over damp from a well-deserved bath. He can smell the soap from her skin and it’s the same that he uses. The servants wouldn’t have thought to procure another set of bathing tools on such short notice.

Funny, how something so simple can punch him so hard in the gut with desire.

She is fatter than she was when he last saw her sitting in front of Bard on his horse, but still not as healthy as she was when they first met. She’s let her hair grow long. It spills over her shoulders, down her back, and pools damply on the mattress behind her.

That he doesn’t care is no revelation to him. He’d have been equally glad to see her with the halo of short curls around her head that she had when he stood in her front hall and compared her to a grocer, or the singed and matted lumps she wore fresh out of Smaug’s clutches with the secret of the dragon’s weakness.

The most important this is that she is here, in his rooms or near enough to make no never mind, of her own free will. He has a chance to apologize, to right his wrongs, and beg her to stay the way he should have before.

She stirs in her sleep and he leans forward, waiting for her to wake and for his future to become clear.

-The End

Notes:

Oh snap, is that the end?

Maybe not. Maybe I still have that darned Ring to dispose of... and what of Frodo? And possible Dwobbits?

Guess you're just gonna have to subscribe to the series to find out! 8D